You are on page 1of 5

ARTICLES

West Nile encephalitis epidemic in southeastern Romania

T F Tsai, F Popovici, C Cernescu, G L Campbell, N I Nedelcu, for the Investigative Team*

Summary Introduction
Mosquito-borne West Nile fever (WNF) is an endemic
Background West Nile fever (WNF) is a mosquito-borne
febrile illness in Africa, the Middle East, and
flavivirus infection endemic in Africa and Asia. In 1996, the southwestern Asia. The flavivirus has also been isolated in
first major WNF epidemic in Europe occurred in Romania, Australia and sporadically in Europe but fewer cases in
with a high rate of neurological infections. We investigated human beings have been recognised. Clinical features are
the epidemic to characterise transmission patterns in this acute fever with severe myalgia, arthralgia, and headache,
novel setting and to determine its origin. conjunctivitis, prominent lymphadenopathy, and a
Methods Hospital-based surveillance identified patients roseolar rash, complicated, occasionally, by meningitis or
admitted with acute aseptic meningitis and encephalitis in
encephalitis.1–5 Outbreaks with hundreds of cases were
reported from Israel in 1950–57. In 1974, an epidemic in
40 Romanian districts, including Bucharest. Infection was
a 2500 km2 area of central South Africa produced tens of
confirmed with IgM capture and indirect IgG ELISAs. In
thousands of infections.6,7 Except for a small outbreak in
October, 1996, we surveyed outpatients in Bucharest and
southern France in 1962, WNF has not been a public-
seven other districts to estimate seroprevalence and to health threat in Europe.8 Between July and October,
detect infected patients not admitted to hospital. We also 1996, an epidemic of WNF with mainly neurological
measured the rates of infection and seropositivity in infections occurred in Bucharest and the lower Danube
mosquitoes and birds, respectively. valley of southeastern Europe. We described after a field
Results Between July 15 and Oct 12, we identified 393 investigation from Sept 28 to Oct 11, 1996, the epidemic,
patients with serologically confirmed or probable WNF its transmission patterns, and its likely source.
infection, of whom 352 had acute central-nervous-system
infections. 17 patients older than 50 years died. Methods
Fatality/case ratio and disease incidence increased Romania is divided by the Carpathian range into a region of
mountains and high plains to the northwest and a large plain to
with age. The outbreak was confined to 14 districts in the the south, with the Danube river forming most of the southern
lower Danube valley and Bucharest (attack rate border with Bulgaria. Bucharest, the capital city, consists of six
12·4/100 000 people) with a seroprevalence of 4·1%. The administrative sectors and is surrounded by the Ilfov District
number of mild cases could not be estimated. WN virus (figure 1). The national and Bucharest municipal populations
was recovered from Culex pipiens mosquitoes, the most were about 23 million and 2·3 million, respectively, in 1996.
likely vector, and antibodies to WN virus were found in 41% In mid-August, 1996, unusually high numbers of acute
central-nervous-system infections were reported by clinicians
of domestic fowl.
from the two infectious-disease hospitals in Bucharest. In early
Interpretation The epidemic in Bucharest reflected September, the Centre for Medico-Military Scientific Research,
Bucharest, found WN virus haemagglutination-inhibition
increased regional WNF transmission in 1996. Epidemics
antibodies in the blood of several patients, and the diagnosis was
of Cx pipiens-borne WNF could occur in other European confirmed by the WHO Collaborating Centre for Haemorrhagic
cities with conditions conducive to transmission. Fevers and Arboviruses, Pasteur Institute, Paris, France.
On Aug 20, the Ministry of Health started active surveillance
Lancet 1998; 352: 767–71
in Bucharest. Suspected cases of WNF were defined as patients
See Commentary page xxx admitted to hospital with acute aseptic meningitis,
meningoencephalitis, or encephalitis with pleiocytosis. Clinical
and epidemiological data were collected and serum and
cerebrospinal-fluid samples were obtained. Active hospital-based
surveillance was expanded nationwide on Sept 10.
Serosurveys were done between Oct 2 and Oct 4 in Bucharest
and on Oct 28 and Oct 29 in seven other affected districts to
estimate the incidence of acute symptomless and mild WN viral
infection. Samples were obtained from blood taken for other
medical purposes in general clinics. The numbers of samples
were proportional to the sizes of clinic catchment areas and the
age distributions in each of the Bucharest clinics, or to the
catchment areas of the non-Bucharest clinics. In the Bucharest
serosurvey, histories were taken of recent illnesses, including
fever, myalgia, headache, rash, joint pain, lymphadenopathy,
jaundice, respiratory, gastrointestinal, and central-nervous-
system symptoms and signs. Symptoms among recently infected
Division of Vectorborne Infectious Diseases, Centers for Disease IgM-positive respondents were compared with those of
Control and Prevention, Fort Collins, CO 80522, USA (T F Tsai MD, seronegative controls matched for age and sex.
G L Campbell MD); Bucharest Preventive Medicine Centre, To ascertain whether there had been previous WN viral
Bucharest, Romania (F Popovici MD); Institute of Virology, transmission in the region, serum samples collected in
Bucharest (Prof C Cernescu MD); and Ministry of Health, Bucharest Bucharest, Tulcea, and Dolj for influenza serology during
(N I Nedelcu MD) 1993–96, before the WNF epidemic began, were tested for WN
Correspondence to: Dr T F Tsai viral antibodies.

THE LANCET • Vol 352 • September 5, 1998 1


ARTICLES

Ukraine
Incidence/100 000
0
0·1–1·0
Hungary 1·1–10·0
Bucharest 12·4

Moldavia

Galati Ukraine

Arges Buzau

Prahova Braila
Tulcea

Dimbovita Ialomita
Bucuresti
Olt Calarasj Black Sea
Dolj Giurgi Constanta
Teleorman r
ve
Ri
Danube Bulgaria

Figure 1: WN encephalitis incidence by district, 1996


Viral isolation in cell cultures, suckling mice, or both was on to Vero cells for viral isolation by standard methods.10
attempted with 106 serum, cerebrospinal fluid, or necropsy Because WNF virus is transmitted in a mosquito-avian cycle,
samples from patients with acute infection; in addition, six blood samples from wild and domestic birds were tested for the
serum and 22 cerebrospinal fluid samples were assessed by PCR presence of neutralising antibody to WN virus by plaque-
for WN virus genome. Extracted RNA was reverse transcribed reduction assay.10 The Ministry of Agriculture was asked for
and cDNA was amplified with primers directed against a notifications of equine encephalitis cases.
conserved flaviviral envelope sequence; PCR products were
identified by hybridisation with a probe specific for WN virus.9
Viral isolates were identified by PCR, and for a cerebrospinal
Results
fluid isolate (96-1030) antigenically, by comparison of its Of 835 patients admitted to hospital with suspected
reactivity with that of prototype WN virus (B956) in plaque- central-nervous-system infection and reported under the
reduction neutralisation tests against reactivity with reference surveillance system, 767 (92%) met the definition of
polyclonal antibodies (dengue 1–4, WN, yellow fever, and WNF cases. Appropriate blood, cerebrospinal fluid, and
Russian spring-summer encephalitis viruses), monoclonal necropsy samples were available from 441 patients,
antibodies (central European and Russian encephalitis viruses), among whom WN encephalitis was serologically
and 11 serum samples taken during convalescence after WNF.10
confirmed in 352 (80%). In addition, among 68 patients
Serum and cerebrospinal fluid samples were tested for IgM
and IgG antibodies to WN virus by capture and indirect EIAs, who did not meet the case definition, 41 (60%) had
respectively.10 IgM in clinical samples was captured with an laboratory-confirmed or probable infection. A total of
antibody to µ-chain, WN virus and control antigens were added, 393 patients had laboratory-diagnosed WNF.
and bound antigen was detected with a peroxidase-labelled Among these 393 patients, the neurological diagnoses
antiflavivirus antibody. IgG was measured by the addition of were meningitis (40%), meningoencephalitis (44%), and
samples to plates coated with WN virus and control antigens in encephalitis (16%). The onset of illness was typically
alternate wells, and bound IgG was detected with a peroxidase- abrupt, with fever (91% of patients), acute headache
labelled antibody to human IgG. Acute WN virus infection was
(77%), neck stiffness (57%), vomiting (53%), chills
confirmed if IgM, IgG, or both classes of antibody to WN virus
were present in cerebrospinal fluid, or if there was a conversion (45%), and confusion (34%). Disorientation, disturbed
in paired serum samples from negative to positive in IgM or IgG consciousness, and generalised weakness were the
EIA. Patients with specific IgM in a single serum sample were predominant signs in patients with encephalitis; some
classified as having a probable recent infection, and patients with patients had decreased motor power with hypotonia, and
(specific) IgG only in a single serum sample as having had a past others had increased tone, hyper-reflexia, and abnormal
infection. Because tick-borne encephalitis is the principal reflexes. Ataxia and extrapyramidal signs were recorded
flavivirus infection transmitted in Europe, a subgroup of patients in 17% of patients, and cranial-nerve palsies or seizures in
was tested for cross-reactive antibodies to central European
smaller proportions. The illness progressed to coma in
encephalitis virus.
Mosquito and avian surveys were done between Oct 1 and 13% of cases, and among patients with confirmed or
Oct 9 at 13 sites in Bucharest and the Ilfov District. Adult probable infection there were 17 deaths (fatality/case ratio
mosquitoes, collected by aspiration from resting sites, were 4·3%), all in patients older than 50 years. Age-specific
identified and pooled, and ground suspensions were inoculated fatality/case ratios increased substantially with age, from

2 THE LANCET • Vol 352 • September 5, 1998


ARTICLES

50 Clinical incidence 100

40 80
Incidence per 100 000

30 60

Cases
20 40

10 20

0 0
8 5 2 9 5 2 9 6 2 9 6 3 0 7 4
Seroprevalence ly 1 2 2 g 1 1 2 t t 1 2 3 t 1
Ju July July July Au Aug Aug Aug Sep Sep ept ept ept Oc Oct
S S S
Seroprevalence (%)

10 Week of onset
Figure 3: WN encephalitis cases by week of onset, Romania
5 laboratory-confirmed infections lived in urban areas. In
Bucharest, however, the rate was significantly higher in
0 the rural Ilfov District (28/100 000) than in urban areas
of the region (ten/100 000). In other districts more
9 9 9 9 9 9 9 70 patients who lived in rural areas were infected, but rates
0– –1 –2 –3 –4 –5 –6 ⭓
10 20 30 40 50 60 could not be calculated.
Age-group (years) WN virus genomic sequences were not detected in any
serum or cerebrospinal-fluid samples. A cerebrospinal-
Figure 2: Age-specific incidence and viral-specific IgM fluid viral isolate (96-1030) recovered in cell cultures was
seroprevalence of WN encephalitis, Bucharest, 1996
identified as WN virus by PCR. The virus was
zero in patients younger than 50 years, to 3·4% in those antigenically indistinguishable from prototype WN virus
aged 50–59 years, 4·3% in those aged 60–69 years, and in plaque-reduction neutralisation-test assays with
14·7% in those older than 70 years, without significant reference polyclonal and monoclonal flavivirus
differences between men and women. Age-specific attack antibodies. In 11 human serum samples taken during
rates also increased with age (figure 2). convalescence, however, neutralisation antibody titres
Among the 41 patients with WN-virus infections who were consistently higher for the local WN viral isolate,
did not meet the case definition, the diagnoses were acute with a geometric mean ratio of 3·1; therefore, the isolate
respiratory infection (11), acute febrile illness (three), could be considered a variety of WN virus.
monoparesis (one), cerebrovascular disease (one), No serological cross-reactivities were detected against
urinary-tract infection (one), various chronic illnesses central European encephalitis virus in 11 serum samples
(four), and no diagnosis (20). The 326 patients who met with IgM antibodies to WN virus (geometric mean titre
the case definition but lacked appropriate samples for 10 500) or in eight serum samples with titres of IgG
testing differed significantly from patients with antibody to WN virus of 1:400.
appropriate samples in age, clinical diagnosis, residence, Serosurveys showed higher proportions of outpatients
onset dates, and fatality/case ratio (11%), which was with IgG antibodies in Bucharest (39 [4·1%] of 959) than
consistent with logistical difficulties in obtaining in the other seven districts (eight [0·9%] of 868). In
appropriate samples from patients who died soon after Bucharest, the proportions of outpatients with IgG and
admission to hospital. These differences suggest that IgM antibodies were similar in both sexes in all age-
untested cases were heterogeneous, and analysed only the groups and regions of the city (data not shown). This
393 patients with laboratory-confirmed infection. finding suggests a uniform risk of infection among city
The onset of illness in the earliest confirmed case was residents (figure 2). At the time of the serosurvey, 2
July 15, 1996. The epidemic peaked in the first week of months after the epidemic peak, only 18 of the 39
September and the last confirmed case had onset on Bucharest residents with IgG antibodies also had
Oct 12 (figure 3). The first confirmed cases were reported detectable IgM (1·9% of the sample). By extrapolation of
from Bucharest, and in other districts 3 weeks later. IgM and IgG prevalence rates to the general population,
The incidence of cases in the 15 districts in the we calculated that 43 000–96 000 people were infected
epidemic area was four per 100 000 people in the general during the epidemic in Bucharest and 31 000 in the other
population, without significant differences between the surveyed districts. The estimated clinical-to-subclinical
sexes. The epidemic was confined to the Danube plain, infection ratio was one to 140–320 (Bucharest data). In
southeast of the Carpathian range and, excluding the Bucharest survey, 31 recently infected people and 37
Bucharest, the rate of infection was highest in districts seronegative controls reported similar frequencies of
bordering the Danube River (figure 1). The attack rate minor illness symptoms.
for Bucharest, 12·4 per 100 000, was higher than that for Among serum samples collected before the epidemic
all other districts, in which the mean rate of infection was (151 from Bucharest, 31 from Tulcea, 40 from Dolj), IgG
1·5 per 100 000. 240 (61%) of 393 patients with antibodies to WN virus were found in four Dolj samples.

THE LANCET • Vol 352 • September 5, 1998 3


ARTICLES

Sylvatic cycle Urban cycle and seronegative respondents. Furthermore, even if mild
?Cx Cx Human illnesses had been ten times more frequent than
modestus pipiens beings neurological cases (for an extrapolated incidence of
Africa
124/100 000 people in the city), even with 959
Middle Birds respondents, we lacked sufficient statistical power to
Birds Birds
East exclude a much larger epidemic of mild illness over and
above the outbreak of neurological infections.
?Cx Cx The Bucharest serosurvey found nearly identically low
modestus pipiens infection rates in every age-group, whereas rates of
neurological disease increased substantially with age
(figure 2). The clinical/subclinical infection ratio
(1:140–320) showed that higher rates of central-nervous-
Figure 4: Sylvatic and urban transmission cycles in lower
Danube valley and model by which epidemic occurred
system infection in the elderly were due to host
susceptibility rather than exposure. Closely related
Culex pipiens was the predominant mosquito species in neurotropic flavivirus infections, such as St Louis
Bucharest. All investigated sites were heavily infested, encephalitis and Japanese encephalitis, have similar
including houses, poultry sheds in the rural Ilfov District, patterns, but the pathogenesis of age-related susceptibility
and especially apartment complexes, many of which had has not been elucidated.17
leaking pipes and standing water in basements. 3689 The uniform seroprevalence rates in all age-groups also
adult mosquitoes of seven taxa were collected, 94% of suggest that the virus had not been present previously in
which were Cx pipiens. A virus recovered from a pool of this population or, if infections had occurred before, that
Cx pipiens collected in central Bucharest was identified they were rare. In the seven non-Bucharest districts
antigenically as WN virus (H Savage, N Karabatsos, surveyed, low seroprevalence rates suggested the absence
unpublished observation), which resulted in a minimum of widespread endemic transmission. The absence of
infection rate of 0·3/1000. antibodies to WN virus among Bucharest residents
Chickens and other domestic fowl were commonly kept sampled before the outbreak was further evidence of a
at private residences in Bucharest. Neutralising new epidemic in the city. In this susceptible population,
antibodies to WN virus were detected in 30 (41%) of 73 the epidemic affected an extensive area of southeastern
domestic fowl and in one (8%) of 12 wild birds. No Romania and, from anecdotally reported cases in
increase in equine encephalitis cases was reported. Bulgaria, an even larger area of the Danube delta. Better
case-finding probably contributed to the reported high
Discussion attack rate in Bucharest, but viral transmission may also
Although WNF is recognised in Africa, Asia, and Europe, have been more intense in the urban and periurban Cx
encephalitis cases have been reported previously only pipiens-borne cycles. The absence of cases of WNF north
from Israel, India, and Pakistan.1–7,11,12 Transmission of of the Carpathian range suggests that these mountains
WN virus in at least 11 European countries (France, were a barrier against further spread and transmission.
Cyprus, former Czechoslovakia, Greece, Italy, Portugal, Sporadic cases of encephalitis, serologically diagnosed
Romania, Spain, Turkey, former Yugoslavia, and Russia) as WN virus infection, have been suspected previously in
has been surmised from animal and human serosurveys Romania.18–20 In addition, surveys in the lower Danube
and by the occasional isolation of the virus from human, valley have shown haemagglutination-inhibition antibody
horse, wild bird, mosquito (Aedes cantans, Anopheles rates to be as high as 18% among certain human
maculipennis, and Cx modestus), and tick (Hyalomma populations and 53% among migratory birds, although
plumbeum and H asiaticum) sources.1–3 With the exception WN virus was never isolated.21–23
of a small outbreak in the Rhone delta (La Camargue), Field studies have not differentiated between the
France, however, cases of WNF have not been recognised existence of a local WN virus transmission cycle,
in Europe.8 Cases may have escaped detection because of although this may be plausible, and repeated viral
the mild and non-specific symptoms. WN is only rarely introductions by migratory birds, especially from Africa.
complicated by hepatitis, pancreatitis, or encephalitis.11–14 Reference hyperimmune antibodies did not distinguish
The epidemic in Romania in 1996 was the first the locally recovered (human) WN virus isolate from
important outbreak of WNF recorded in Europe. The prototype WN virus, although a slight but consistent
true number of cases and deaths may have been higher antigenic difference was seen in serum samples from
than recorded because national surveillance was delayed, recovering patients, which shows that the local strain
and because appropriate clinical samples were available could be a distinct variety of WN virus.
from few patients. The paucity of acute-phase samples Genetic analysis of WN viral strains recovered from
probably contributed to the poor yield of viral recoveries. France showed their relation to a viral lineage also
The predominance of neurological cases reflected including certain strains from Africa and Kunjin virus, a
hospital-based surveillance and the lack of case-finding flavivirus transmitted mainly in Australia and Asia, which
efforts in outpatient clinics. Confirmed infections in also produces a febrile exanthem and encephalitis.24
patients not meeting the case definition probably Introduction of a virus from Africa to Europe by
represented a mixture of coincidental WN virus infection migratory birds has precedence in the transfer of Sindbis
and other manifestations of the illness, such as myelitis virus from South Africa to northern Europe and the
and respiratory infection.15,16 We attempted to identify emergence of Sindbis fever epidemics in Scandinavia in
milder infections retrospectively in the Bucharest survey. 1982.25–26 By analogy, sporadic isolations of WN virus
With a 6-week delay after the epidemic peak and the non- from migratory birds and their ticks in Europe show that
specific nature of symptoms, however, we found no this virus could also be transferred in spring
difference in minor symptoms between recently infected migrations.1–3,8

4 THE LANCET • Vol 352 • September 5, 1998


ARTICLES

In Africa, WN virus is principally transmitted in an involvement in arbovirus cycles in the Mediterranean Basin. J Vector
Ecol 1995; 20: 44–58.
enzootic cycle among Cx univittatus and birds.6 Many
3 Taylor RM, Work TH, Hurlbutt HS, Rizk F. A study of the ecology of
northward migratory routes follow a flyway across the West Nile virus in Egypt. Am J Trop Med Hyg 1956; 5: 579–620.
Middle East, Turkey, and the Black Sea, along which the 4 Marberg K, Goldblum N, Stork V, Jasinska-Klingberg W, Klingberg
Danube delta is a main avian refuge.27 Frequent M. The natural history of WNF, I: clinical observations during an
epidemic in Israel. Am J Hyg 1956; 64: 259–69.
introductions of WN virus, with establishment of a local
5 George S, Prasad SR, Rao JA, Yergolkar PN, Sreenivasaiah Setty CV.
enzootic transmission in the Danube basin seem possible. Isolation of Japanese encephalitis and West Nile viruses from fatal
Cx modestus, identified as an enzootic WN virus vector in cases of encephalitis in Kolar district of Karnataka. Indian J Med Res
southern France, is present in the Danube delta and 1987; 86: 131–34.
6 McIntosh BM, Jupp PG, Dos Santos I, Meenehan GM. Epidemics of
could mediate local sylvatic transmissions, from which West Nile and Sindbis viruses in South Africa with Culex (Culex)
the virus could be transferred to an urban cycle or could univittatus Theobald as a vector. S Afr J Sci 1976; 72: 295–300.
infect humans directly (figure 4). Such interactions of 7 Klingberg MA, Jasinska-Klingberg W, Goldblum N. Certain aspects of
sylvatic and urban transmission cycles have been reported the epidemiology and distribution of immunity of West Nile virus in
Israel. Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Tropical
previously in the USA for St Louis encephalitis virus.17 Medicine and Malaria,. 1959; 5:132–40.
Few mosquitoes were collected because of the lateness 8 Panthier R, Hannoun C, Beytout D, Mouchet J. Epidemiologie du
of the season and only one viral isolate was recovered virus West Nile: (etude d’un foyer en Camargue, 3—Les maladies
humaines. Ann Instit Pasteur 1968; 115: 435–45.
from mosquitoes. Although the minimum infection rate
9 Puri B, Henchal EA, Burans J, et al. A rapid method for detection and
in Cx pipiens was only 0·3 per 1000, this species was identification of flaviviruses by polymerase chain reaction and nucleic
probably the epidemic vector in Bucharest at least. acid hybridization. Arch Virol 1994; 134: 29–37.
Cx pipiens is the predominant mosquito species in the 10 Tsai TF. Arboviruses. In: Murray PR, Baron EJ, Pfaller MA, Tenover
FC, Yolken RH, eds. Manual of clinical microbiology, 6th edn.
city; apartment blocks and houses were heavily infested, Washington, DC: ASM Press, 1995: 980–96.
as well as domestic environments in rural locations where 11 Varsano M, Basat MB, Rannon L. West Nile virus infection in recent
apparently the mosquitoes feed readily on human beings years in Israel. Israel J Med Sci 1982; 19: 11.
and birds. WN virus has been isolated previously from 12 Flatau E, Kohn D, Daher O, Varsano N. WNF encephalitis. Israel J
Med Sci 1981; 17: 1057–59.
the species and its capacity to transmit the virus has been 13 Perelman A, Stern J. Acute pancreatitis in WNF. Am J Trop Med Hyg
shown.1–3 The mosquito potentially could have 1974; 23: 1150–52.
transmitted WN virus from person to person within 14 George AJ, Lesbordes JL, Georges-Courbot MC, Meuniér DMY,
apartment buildings where flooded basements provide Gonzalez JP. Fatal hepatitis from West Nile virus. Ann Inst Pasteur
1987; 138: 237–44.
favourable breeding conditions for Cx pipiens.3,28 To 15 Darwish MA, Feinsod FM, Scott RM, et al. Arboviral causes of non-
prevent future outbreaks we recommended actions to specific fever and myalgia in a fever hospital patient population in
control Cx pipiens in Bucharest. Cairo, Egypt. Trans Royal Soc Trop Med Hyg 1987; 81: 1001–03.
The other circumstances that favoured an epidemic of 16 Gadoth N, Weitzman S, Lehmann EE. Acute anterior myelitis
complicating WNF. Arch Neurol 1979; 36: 172–73.
WNF in Romania in 1996 are unknown. WNF outbreaks 17 Monath TP, Tsai TF. Flaviviruses. In: Richman DD, Whitley RJ,
in North Africa in 1994 and 1996 suggest a regional Hayden FG, eds. Clinical virology. New York: Churchill-Livingstone,
increase in enzootic viral transmission.29,30 In some areas 1997: 1133–86.
of Europe, urban conditions are suitable for the 18 Miskolczy D, Csiki C, Vendeg V, et al. Epidemic of late summer-
autumn virus encephalitis in 1955 in Tirgu Mures: so-called mosquito
introduction and amplification of WN virus, with the risk encephalitis. Neurologia Psihiatria Neurochirurgia. 1958; 2: 139–47.
of future epidemics that follow the pattern of infrequent 19 Duca E, Duca M, Strat E, et al. Investigations on cases of encephalitis
but recurrent Cx pipiens-borne St Louis encephalitis transmitted by arthropods in Moldavia. Rev Med Chir Soc Med Nat
Iasi. 1963; 67: 399–404.
epidemics in cities of the eastern USA.17,31
20 Topciu V, Rosiu N, Son G, et al. Consideritions sur quelques cas
Members of the Investigative Team d’encephalite virotique primaire apparus dans le sud-ouest de la
Romania—V Laurentia, L Spantulescu, Bucharest Preventive Medicine Roumanie (région du Banat). Arch Roum Path Exp Microbiol 1968; 27:
Center, Bucharest; V Chitu, S Ruta, G Tardei, Institute of Virology, 531–38.
Bucharest; D Crăciun, D Nicolaiciuc, D Pit‚igoi, Ministry of Health, 21 Drăgănescu N, Girjabu E, Iftimovici R, Klebleer Études èrolgiques sur
Bucharest; C Ceianu, G Nicolescu, A Ungureanu, L A Vladimirescu, la présence de quelques arbovirus dans la région de sylvo-steppe de
Cantacuzino Institute, Bucharest. Tulcea. Rev Roum Virol 1991; 42: 47–51.
France—V Deubel, B LeGuenno, Centre National de Reference pour les 22 Drăgănescu N, Girjabu E, Iftimovici R. Investigations s èrologiques
fievres Hemorragiques et les Arbovirus, Paris, France. chez l’homme et chez differentes espéces d’animaux domestiques de la
USA—L Han, H Savage, L Tengelsen, Centers for Disease Control and région de sylvo-steppe de Roumanie, pour le d’pistage de quelques
Prevention, Fort Collins; EA Henchal, F Knauert, JA Mangiafico, Togaviridae et Bunyaviridae. Rev Roum Virol 1993; 44: 207–10.
C Rossi, United States Army Medical Reasearch Institute of Infectious 23 Drăgănescu, N. Recherches sur les infections à arbovirus. Rev Roum
Diseases, Fort Detrick. Méd Virol 1989, 40: 257–69.
Contributors 24 Berthet FX, Zeller HG, Drouet MT, et al. Extensive nucleotide
T F Tsai was responsible for guiding the epidemic investigation, data changes and deletions within the envelope glycoprotein gene of Euro-
analysis, and preparation of the paper. Florin Popovici managed the African West Nile viruses. J Gen Virol 1997, 78: 2293–97.
databases and data analysis. Costin Cernescu supervised the laboratory 25 Espmark A, Niklasson B. Ockelbo disease in Sweden: epidemiological,
investigation. Grant Campbell supervised the field team and assisted in clinical and virological data from the 1982 outbreak. Am J Trop Med
data analysis. Sergio Nedelcu coordinated surveillance and administered Hyg 1984; 33: 1203–11.
overall operations. 26 Yukio S, Niklasson B, Dalrymple JM, Strauss EG, Strauss JH.
Structure of the Ockelbo virus genome and its relationship to other
Acknowledgments Sindbis viruses. Virology 1991; 182: 753–64.
We thank Terry Gay, Office of International and Refugee Health,
27 Curry-Lindahl K. Bird migration in Africa: movements between six
Department of Health and Human Services, USA Public Health Service continents, Vol 1. London: Academic Press, 1981.
for administrative assistance, and Peter LaPera, Randall Thompson, and
28 Anonymous. Update: St. Louis encephalitis outbreak, 1994. Louisiana
Mary Ann Micka of US Agency for International Development for
Morbidity Report 1995; 5: 3.
support.
29 Le Guenno B, Bougermouh A, Azzam T, et al. West Nile: a deadly
virus? Lancet 1996; 348: 1315.
References 30 El Harrack M, Le Guenno B, Gounon P Isolement du virus West Nile
1 Peiris JSM, Amerasinghe FP. WNF. In: Beran GW, ed. Handbook of au Maroc. Virologie 1997; 1: 248–49.
zoonoses, 2nd edn, section B: Viral. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 31 Lundström JO. Vector competence of Western European mosquitoes
1994: 139–48. for arboviruses: a review of field and experimental studies. Bull Soc
2 Mitchell CJ. Geographic spread of Aedes albopictus and potential for Vector Ecol 1994; 19: 23–36.

THE LANCET • Vol 352 • September 5, 1998 5

You might also like