Professional Documents
Culture Documents
brief report
summary
We report the survival of a 15-year-old girl in whom clinical rabies developed one
month after she was bitten by a bat. Treatment included induction of coma while a na-
tive immune response matured; rabies vaccine was not administered. The patient was
treated with ketamine, midazolam, ribavirin, and amantadine. Probable drug-related
toxic effects included hemolysis, pancreatitis, acidosis, and hepatotoxicity. Lumbar
puncture after eight days showed an increased level of rabies antibody, and sedation
was tapered. Paresis and sensory denervation then resolved. The patient was removed
from isolation after 31 days and discharged to her home after 76 days. At nearly five
months after her initial hospitalization, she was alert and communicative, but with
choreoathetosis, dysarthria, and an unsteady gait.
On the first hospital day, the patient was febrile vous system, and it has had little effect in animal
(temperature, 38.2°C) and semiobtunded but an- models, but we administered the drug with the ra-
swered simple questions and complied with simple tionale that elevated protein levels in the cerebro-
commands during diagnostic maneuvers. She had spinal fluid indicated permeability of the blood–
scanning speech, bilateral sixth-nerve palsies, de- brain barrier (Table 1) and that ribavirin might
creased upward gaze, dysarthria, myoclonus, inten- protect against rabies myocarditis.3 Ribavirin was
tion tremor of the left arm, and ataxia. Samples of administered on the third hospital day, with a load-
serum, cerebrospinal fluid, nuchal skin, and saliva ing dose of 33 mg per kilogram followed by a main-
were submitted to the Centers for Disease Control tenance dose of 16 mg per kilogram every six hours.
and Prevention (CDC) for the diagnosis of rabies. Interferon alfa was not used because of its neuro-
Repeated brain magnetic resonance imaging and toxicity. Neither rabies vaccine nor rabies immune
angiography showed no abnormalities. The patient globulin was administered because of the patient’s
began salivating, with uncoordinated swallowing, demonstrated immune response and the potential
and was intubated for airway protection. On the sec- for harm from a potentiated immune response.8
ond hospital day, the presence of rabies virus–spe- Amantadine (200 mg per day, administered enter-
cific antibody in her cerebrospinal fluid and serum ally) was added on the fourth hospital day because
was confirmed by the CDC. Attempts to isolate ra- of its in vitro activity against rabies virus, as well as
bies virus, detect viral antigen, and amplify viral its antiexcitotoxic activity, which is distributed more
nucleic acid from two skin biopsies and nine saliva rostrally in the brain than is that of ketamine.9,10
samples were unsuccessful. High doses of benzodiazepines with supplemen-
The patient’s parents were counseled about her tal barbiturates were necessary to maintain burst
diagnosis and prognosis. We offered both hospice suppression. Limited availability of preservative-free
care and an aggressive approach on the basis of an midazolam necessitated the use of midazolam con-
untested strategy that combined antiexcitatory and taining 1 percent benzyl alcohol. Biochemical evi-
antiviral drugs with supportive intensive care. We dence of hemolysis and acidosis was detected by
provided information about the probable failure of the fifth hospital day. The hemoglobin level declined
antiviral therapy and the unknown effect of the pro- from 13.7 to 10.9 g per deciliter, whereas the lac-
posed therapy, as well as the possibility of severe tate dehydrogenase level rose from 420 to 1020 U
disability if the patient were to survive. The pa- per liter over seven days, a finding that was consis-
tient’s parents requested that we institute aggres- tent with hemolysis, probably after a cumulative
sive care on the basis of the principles we had dis- total of 276 mg per kilogram of ribavirin had been
cussed. administered. An arterial base excess of 2.7 mmol
We administered ketamine at 2 mg per kilogram per liter declined to –3.8 mmol per liter over five
of body weight per hour with midazolam at 1 to days, which was consistent with metabolic acidosis,
3.5 mg per kilogram of body weight per hour to without a change in the blood lactate level, proba-
suppress background activity on electroencepha- bly reflecting the cumulative total of 362 mg per ki-
lography so that only one to two seconds of cere- logram of benzyl alcohol. Ribavirin was reduced
bral activity were interspersed (Fig. 1). Oxygen de- to 8 mg per kilogram for nine doses, and midazo-
livery was optimized without inotropic agents by lam was tapered to 1.5 mg per kilogram per hour,
red-cell transfusion to maintain the hemoglobin with phenobarbital supplementation to maintain
level at more than 10 g per deciliter, appropriate burst suppression.
volume loading, and mechanical ventilation target- There were minimal systemic effects of brain-
ing arterial normoxia and mild hypercapnia.5 Ade- stem and peripheral neuropathy. The patient had
quacy of oxygen delivery to organs was monitored transient evidence of both deficiency and excess of
by intermittent assessment of venous saturation, antidiuretic hormone on the fifth through seventh
and brain and somatic oxygenation by near-infra- hospital days. Clinical autonomic denervation de-
red spectroscopy.6 Heparin (10 U per kilogram per veloped on the fifth hospital day, with reduced car-
hour) was administered prophylactically.7 diac variability (Fig. 1) and higher central venous
After the induction of coma and on the basis of pressure.1,11-13 Salivation decreased on the eighth
discussions with scientists at the CDC, we institut- hospital day. The patient’s skin became flushed,
ed antiviral therapy. Studies in animals have shown and ileus developed. Increased levels of liver amino-
little penetration of ribavirin into the central ner- transferase (52 IU per liter), lipase (1193 U per milli-
A
41 10,000
Temperature
(reciprocal dilution)
Temperature (°C)
1000
39 Rabies virus–specific antibody
38 100
37
36 Neutralizing antibody
35 10
1 8 15 22 29
B
6 100
Amantadine Amantadine
5
Ketamine (mg/kg/hr) and Benzodiazepines
Ribavirin 80
(midazolam equivalents [mg/kg/hr])
Burst
Phenobarbital (mg/kg/day)
Benzodiazepines
4 suppression
60
3 Phenobarbital
40
2
20
1
Ketamine
0 0
1 8 15 22 29
C
180 8
Pulse (beats/min) and Respiratory Rate (breaths/min)
160
140
100 Pulse
80
4
60 Denervation and
reactivity score
40
20 Respiratory rate
2
0
0
1 8 15 22 29
Hospital Day
termittent dystonia and ballismus, which produced with benzodiazepines and barbiturates, along with
a lurching gait and fine-motor difficulties (Video NMDA-receptor antagonism with ketamine and
Clip 2 in the Supplementary Appendix). She was amantadine, to reduce excitotoxicity, brain metab-
able to write legibly but slowly and to type with her olism, and autonomic reactivity.21-23
index fingers. She had normal extremity tone, bi- This improvised approach was a logical exten-
lateral upward-going toes, and no clonus. She had sion of previous efforts to prevent complications
decreased dorsiflexion in the left ankle and de- through aggressive critical care.5,7,18 The induction
creased grip in the left hand. She had intact sense of coma was associated with a remarkably unevent-
of position and light touch. ful course in the intensive care unit, suggesting that
much of the dysautonomia characteristic of rabies
discussion can be avoided with therapeutic sedation anesthe-
sia. An alternative hypothesis is that this patient
At the time of the patient’s transfer to our facility, would not have developed substantial dysautono-
a search of the recent literature had confirmed the mia. Autonomic hyperreflexia emerged while the
futility of antiviral therapy and immune modulation drugs were being tapered, which suggests a paral-
in the treatment of clinical rabies. This finding was lel to the hypersensitivity to environmental stimuli
confirmed by experience at the CDC. We noted that seen in tetanus, with a general preservation of high-
the pathology of the human brain in cases of rabies er cortical function.7,24 Induction of coma through
reflected secondary complications rather than any GABA agonism with NMDA antagonism may have
clear primary process and that a normal immune conferred specific benefit. Although similar strate-
system cleared the virus.2,7,15,16 Clinical reports in- gies have not shown consistent clinical efficacy for
cluded the hypothesis that death resulted from “neu- protection against excitotoxicity, our high-dose,
rotransmitter imbalance” and autonomic failure; multimodal regimen was more aggressive and the
supportive care was predicted to succeed.5,7,15,17,18 insult less cytopathic.
A search of the literature regarding neurotransmit- The patient survived, but with neurologic im-
ters in rabies identified ketamine as an N-methyl-d- pairment. Although her improvement continued
aspartate (NMDA)–receptor antagonist with specif- five months after her initial hospitalization, we can-
ic activity against rabies in animal models.19 We not predict the long-term outcome. In addition to
conceived a strategy to try to protect the brain from this girl, there are five well-documented survivors
injury while enabling the immune system to mount of rabies. All of the patients had received either oc-
a natural response and clear the virus. Hypothermia cupationally related preexposure rabies vaccination
was ruled out because of its effects on immune func- or postexposure prophylaxis.4 Our patient survived
tion.20 We elected to induce therapeutic coma us- with only naturally acquired immunity, although
ing g-aminobutyric acid (GABA)–receptor agonism her exposure to rabies virus consisted of minimal
Table 1. Evolution of Inflammation and Levels of Rabies Virus–Specific Antibody in Cerebrospinal Fluid, According to
Hospital Day.*
* CSF denotes cerebrospinal fluid, IFA indirect immunofluorescence antibody titer, and RFFIT rapid fluorescence focus in-
hibition test. Antibody values are expressed as the reciprocal dilution. The bat exposure occurred on September 12, 2004.
Hospital days are numbered from October 18, 2004.
trauma at a distal body site, probably with a limited Further review of the literature indicates that rabies
quantity of inoculum. She was young and athletic. virus infection of the heart is infrequent and limit-
The bat that bit her was not recovered, and we were ed in extent.12,13
unable to isolate or detect rabies virus from saliva, Ribavirin is variably toxic to mitochondria, and
cerebrospinal fluid, or nuchal-biopsy specimens. we measured profoundly depleted serum levels of
We therefore cannot rule out the possibility that coenzyme Q10 (0.30 µg per milliliter; range, 0.57
her survival was due to an unusual, more temperate to 3.03) during the second month of her convales-
or attenuated variant of the virus or a rare host poly- cence in association with persistently depressed
morphism. Therapy may have been more effective myocardial contractility.25 Rabies virus is largely
than in past cases because of the inferred limited restricted to the nervous system, so depletion of
exposure to rabies virus, early recognition of the coenzyme Q10 was probably associated with her
disease, and aggressive management. critical illness or administered drugs. For patients
Clearly, our experience with this patient requires whose disease is diagnosed before their immune
replication in other patients and proof-of-concept response to rabies virus can be detected, we sug-
experiments in animal models. Although our pri- gest considering the use of ribavirin, but at a more
mary therapeutic intent was to provide protection limited dose or with concurrent supplementation
against excitotoxic neuronal injury, the patient may with coenzyme Q10. Given that manifestations of
have benefited from the dual action of ketamine dysautonomia were easily managed, we recom-
and amantadine, drugs with activity against rabies mend a longer-acting benzodiazepine with less pre-
virus. She incurred possible toxic effects associated servative for future patients.
with ribavirin (hemolysis, pancreatitis, and mito- Survival of this single patient does not change
chondrial toxicity) and benzyl alcohol (acidosis). the overwhelming statistics on rabies, which has
6
Ventilator
Hospitalization
5
Ketamine (mg/kg/hr) and Benzodiazepines
Burst suppression
(midazolam equivalents [mg/kg/hr])
Incubation
4 > 38.9°C
SIADH or
diabetes insipidus Sit > 10 min
3
Stand with assistance
Write name
–36 1 9 32 76 131
Hospital Day
Figure 2. Timeline by Hospital Day from the Time of Inoculation with Rabies Virus until Two Months after Discharge
from the Hospital.
The incubation period extends from the day on which the patient was bitten by a bat until her first symptoms appeared.
Hospitalization includes both the referral and accepting hospitals. The therapeutic coma induced by ketamine and
midazolam and the period of burst suppression are shown for reference. Disorders of temperature (more than 38.9°C)
and the syndrome of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone (SIADH) or diabetes insipidus are indicated. The patient was
transferred from intensive care on the 32nd hospital day. A selected list of rehabilitation milestones is shown.
the highest case fatality ratio of any infectious dis- We are indebted to the following people for their advice, excellent
clinical care, laboratory diagnosis, or chart abstraction: S. Connolly,
ease. Any regimen may be ineffective in cases as- R.N.; A. Church, R.N.; L. Grade, R.N.; C. Hanlon, V.M.D.; J. Kane,
sociated with extremes of age, massive traumatic M.D.; A. Joseph, M.D.; I. Kuzmin, Ph.D.; K. Larsen, R.N.; B. Ludwig,
inoculation, or delayed diagnosis and must be cou- R.N.; P. Morrill; K. Murkowski, R.R.T.; M. Niezgoda, M.S.; N. Norins,
M.D.; L. Orciari, M.S.; L. Quarterman, R.N.; J. Surgis; J. Twanow,
pled with strategies to reduce the risk of complica- M.D.; and P. Yager.
tions from long-term treatment in the intensive
care unit.
refer enc es
1. Gode GR, Raju AV, Jayalakshmi TS, Kaul fect of amantadine on rhabdovirus infection. PK, Bhide NK. Treatment of 54 clinically di-
HL, Bhide NK. Intensive care in rabies ther- Drugs Exp Clin Res 1985;11:69-74. agnosed rabies patients with two survivals.
apy: clinical observations. Lancet 1976;2: 10. Porter RH, Greenamyre JT. Regional Indian J Med Res 1988;88:564-6.
6-8. variations in the pharmacology of NMDA re- 19. Lockhart BP, Tordo N, Tsiang H. Inhibi-
2. Emmons RW, Leonard LL, DeGenaro F ceptor channel blockers: implications for tion of rabies virus transcription in rat corti-
Jr, et al. A case of human rabies with pro- therapeutic potential. J Neurochem 1995; cal neurons with the dissociative anesthetic
longed survival. Intervirology 1973;1:60-72. 64:614-23. ketamine. Antimicrob Agents Chemother
3. Jackson AC, Warrell MJ, Rupprecht CE, 11. Maton PN, Pollard JD, Davis JN. Human 1992;36:1750-5.
et al. Management of rabies in humans. Clin rabies encephalomyelitis. Br Med J 1976;1: 20. Beilin B, Shavit Y, Razumovsky J, Wol-
Infect Dis 2003;36:60-3. 1038-40. loch Y, Zeidel A, Bessler H. Effects of mild
4. Willoughby RE, Rotar MM, Dohnau HL, 12. Jogai S, Radotra BD, Banerjee AK. Rabies perioperative hypothermia on cellular im-
et al. Recovery of a patient from clinical ra- viral antigen in extracranial organs: a post- mune responses. Anesthesiology 1998;89:
bies — Wisconsin, 2004. MMWR Morb mortem study. Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol 1133-40.
Mortal Wkly Rep 2005;53:1171-3. 2002;28:334-8. 21. Reich DL, Silvay G. Ketamine: an update
5. Hattwick MA, Weis TT, Stechschulte CJ, 13. Jackson AC, Ye H, Phelan CC, et al. Ex- on the first twenty-five years of clinical expe-
Baer GM, Gregg MB. Recovery from rabies: traneural organ involvement in human ra- rience. Can J Anaesth 1989;36:186-97.
a case report. Ann Intern Med 1972;76:931- bies. Lab Invest 1999;79:945-51. 22. Wang X, Shimizu-Sasamata M, Mos-
42. 14. Bell JF, Moore GJ. Effects of high ambi- kowitz MA, Newcomb R, Lo EH. Profiles of
6. Hoffman GM, Stuth EA, Jaquiss RD, et ent temperature on various stages of rabies glutamate and GABA efflux in core versus
al. Changes in cerebral and somatic oxygen- virus infection in mice. Infect Immun 1974; peripheral zones of focal cerebral ischemia
ation during stage 1 palliation of hypoplas- 10:510-5. in mice. Neurosci Lett 2001;313:121-4.
tic left heart syndrome using continuous 15. Rubin RH, Sullivan L, Summers R, 23. Nargi-Aizenman JL, Havert MB, Zhang
regional cerebral perfusion. J Thorac Car- Gregg MB, Sikes RK. A case of human ra- M, Irani DN, Rothstein JD, Griffin DE.
diovasc Surg 2004;127:223-33. bies in Kansas: epidemiologic, clinical, and Glutamate receptor antagonists protect
7. Bhatt DR, Hattwick MA, Gerdsen R, laboratory considerations. J Infect Dis 1970; from virus-induced neural degeneration.
Emmons RW, Johnson HN. Human rabies: 122:318-22. Ann Neurol 2004;55:541-9.
diagnosis, complications, and management. 16. Lodmell DL, Bell JF, Moore GJ, Ray- 24. Warrell DA, Davidson NM, Pope HM, et
Am J Dis Child 1974;127:862-9. mond GH. Comparative study of abortive al. Pathophysiologic studies in human ra-
8. Mrak RE, Young L. Rabies encephalitis and nonabortive rabies in mice. J Infect Dis bies. Am J Med 1976;60:180-90.
in humans: pathology, pathogenesis and 1969;119:569-80. 25. Fleischer R, Boxwell D, Sherman KE.
pathophysiology. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 17. Jackson AC. Rabies virus infection: an Nucleoside analogues and mitochondrial
1994;53:1-10. update. J Neurovirol 2003;9:253-8. toxicity. Clin Infect Dis 2004;38:e79-e80.
9. Superti F, Seganti L, Pana A, Orsi N. Ef- 18. Gode GR, Saksena R, Batra RK, Kalia Copyright © 2005 Massachusetts Medical Society.