You are on page 1of 10

Proceedings of Indian Geotechnical Conference

December 22-24, 2013, Roorkee

USE OF CONTOUR MAPS FOR PRELIMINARY ASSESMENT OF SUBSOIL OF


GUWAHATI CITY

Binu Sharma, Prof., Deptt. of Civil Engineering, Assam Engg. College,binusharma78@gmail.com


S. K. Rahman, Deptt. of Civil Engineering, M.E. student, Assam Engg. College , rahmanshafi6@gmail.com
B.D. Saikia, Retired Prof., Deptt. Of Civil Engineering, Assam Engg. College, Assam, bibha_saikia@yahoo.com

ABSTRACT: Guwahati, the major city in the north eastern region of India is growing rapidly in every aspect with
major infrastructures like sports complex, educational institutions, hospitals, flyovers, multiplex halls, etc.
Determination of the subsurface soil condition is necessary to ensure the structural safety and serviceability of the
above mentioned structures before any construction. Therefore contour maps of standard penetration test N value,
ground water table and shear wave velocity will be of great help to the foundation designers at the initial stage for
site selection and preliminary foundation design under static and seismic condition. Attempt has been made in this
work to prepare contour maps of SPT N value, ground water table and shear wave velocities of Guwahati city.
Standard Penetration Test (SPT) N values and depth of water table were taken from a data base of 200 boreholes
upto 30 meter depth to prepare N-value and ground water table contour map of Guwahati city. SPT values correlate
empirically with the foundation design parameters such as soil relative density, friction angles, settlement of
shallow and deep foundations, bearing capacity values, etc. The shear wave velocity profile is usually obtained by
carrying out wave propagation tests in the field. But it is often not economically feasible to conduct these tests at all
the sites. Therefore, a reliable empirical correlation between V and SPT-N would be of considerable advantage.
s
This work has developed a regression equation between Vs and SPT-N value based on twenty seven previous
similar correlations. From the regression equation, the shear wave velocities are calculated based on the N values
and contour map of the shear wave velocity of Guwahati city is prepared.

INTRODUCTION
For the analysis of geotechnical earthquake This shear wave velocity was compared with the
engineering problems like site specific shear wave velocity as determined according to the
amplification factor and ground response study, method suggested by Rao (2012) [1]. Using
standard penetration test N value and shear wave Geographical Information System (GIS),
velocity are important input parameters. Borehole geospatial contour maps of shear wave velocity
logging is generally considered the standard profile for Guwahati city are prepared. Geospatial
method for obtaining shear wave velocity (Vs) contour maps of standard penetration test N value,
data, but drilling and logging to the depths contour map of ground water table are also
generally required for earthquake ground motion prepared in this study.
investigations is very expensive, and it is A soil database from 200 boreholes of Guwahati
problematic in heavily built up areas. In view of city was used for this purpose. The soil database
this several researchers have developed was from a project funded by the Directorate of
correlations between the SPT ‘N’ value and shear Science and Technology, India for microzonation
wave velocity ‘Vs’, which are useful for of Guwahati City.
determining the dynamic soil properties. In this Phukan et al. (2004) [2] studied the Guwahati city
work a regression equation between Vs and SPT-N areas for multi criteria evaluation in GIS
value based on previous similar correlations had environment for ground water resource mapping in
been developed. This regression equation was used Guwahati city areas. Ribeiro et. al. (2007) [3]
to determine shear wave velocity of Guwahati city. studied the soil of Brazilian port site for

Page 1 of 10
Binu Sharma, S.K Rahman. & B.D Saiki,.

geotechnical mapping and reports about N-value Intensified anthropogenic activities particularly in
contour mapping at Brazilian port. Humyra et al. and around the hills has led to high rate of
(2012) [4] studied the soil of Rajshahi for the aggradations in the low lying areas clogging the
preparation of SPT contour map of Rajshahi city city drainage system. Alluvial soil is found in the
area. In the study they used 21 soil reports of valleys and low lying areas of the city. They are
Rajshahi city prepared by civil engineering typically brown and grey coloured silty clays or
department of Rajshahi University of engineering clayey silts. At present most of the ancient alluvial
and Technology. Ayothiraman et al (2012) [5] also soils are overlain by artificially transported soil and
developed average N-value (15m) contour map of overburden material brought about by
Guwahati city. Rao (2012) studied and estimated anthropogenic activities. They are visible only in
Shear Wave Velocity from Soil Indices. In that excavations and borings. The hills surrounding
study, in situ Vs measured by cross-hole technique Guwahati city are primarily composed of
at six sites have been compared with those Porphyritic Granites and Quartzo Feldspathic
evaluated using an existing empirical relation Gneiss which are cross-cut by amphibolite
between N value, soil indices and shear wave intrusives and quartz veins. Sandy soil which are
velocities. A new, modified empirical relation for produced by weathering of porphyritic granites are
predicting Vs from N-Values and other soil indices found in many areas of the city. The sandy soils are
has been proposed. Sykora and Koester (1988) [6] rich in unsorted coarse fragments of quartz
found strong statistical correlations between together with associated clay and minor amounts of
dynamic shear resistance and standard penetration mica flakes. These soils are pale brown in colour
resistance in soils. Other research workers in this and have a low degree of cohesion. Localities
direction are Imai and Yoshimura (1975) [7], underlain by Quartzo-feldspathic Gneisses are
Sykora and Stokoe (1983) [8], Jafari et al (2002) covered by red coloured soils rich in clay minerals.
[9], Trivedi, Rao and Gupta (2009) [10] and In order to study the engineering soil properties of
Maheshwari, Boominathan and Dodagoudar (2008) Guwahati City, bore holes of 30m depth were
[11] to name a few. made in 200 locations covering an area of 262
sqkm. The bore hole location map along with the
SOIL STUDY OF GUWAHATI CITY river Brahmaputra in Guwahati city is shown in
The Guwahati city area, measuring about 229.94 Fig. 1. Soils in Guwahati city mostly consists of
sq. km., encompasses southern part of Kamrup alternating layers of both fined grained and coarse
(Urban) district of Assam. The mighty river grained soils. There is a great deal of variation in
Brahmaputra flows to the north of Guwahati city, the thickness of these layers. The fine grained
the south and the eastern sides are surrounded by fraction mostly consists of soils of classification
two rows of semi-circular hillocks. The city is CL, CI and CH according to the Indian standard
extended more in an E-W trend occupying the soil classification. In a few locations inorganic silt
position between the Brahmaputra River towards of classification ML and CL-ML and non plastic
north and Precambrian hills of Shillong Plateau inorganic silts were also encountered. The coarse
towards south. It has a population of over 8, 14,575 grained fraction is mostly of classification SP, SW,
(Census 2001) occupying mostly the narrow tracts SC, SM, SP-SC. Gravel deposits were also
of alluvium and sediment filled low lands encountered in certain bore holes.
interspersed with Precambrian residual hills.

Page 2 of 10
Use of contour maps for preliminary assesment of subsoil of Guwahati city

Fig.1 Locations of bore holes in Guwahati city.

N-value contour maps


Standard penetration test was done at every 1.5m from SPT are corrected for overburden pressure
interval to determine the N value of the soil with and dilatancy (IS: 2131-1981) for the development
depth. At some locations, SPT has been done to of SPT N -value contour maps. The N-value
depths less than 30m due to refusal been contour maps for 3m, 6m and 10.5m from the
encountered. Uncorrected N- value of the soils ground surface are shown in Figure 2, 3 and 4
varied from 4 to > 50 (refusal). The data available respectively.

Fig. 2. Contour map of corrected N- value at 3m depth.

Page 3 of 10
Use of contour maps for preliminary assesment of subsoil of Guwahati city

Fig.3. Contour map of corrected N- value at 6 m depth.

Fig. 4. Contour map of corrected N- value at 10.5m depth

Page 4 of 10
Binu Sharma, S.K Rahman. & B.D Saiki,.

The average standard penetration resistance at all where d i = thickness of each layer.
the bore holes can be computed by the following Ni= SPT N- value at ith layer.
expression as suggested by International Building n = total no layers.
Code [IBC, 2003]. The spatial distribution of average N- value upto
di
Navg = ∑ni=1 di / ∑ni=1(Ni) (1) 30m depth is shown in Figure 5.

Fig. 5. Spatial distribution of average N- value at 30 m depth

Many building codes use Nave for classifying a site Where Navg= average SPT N- value
for purposes of incorporating local site conditions
in estimation of design ground motion. In UBC According to the above classification out of 200
(2000) the site classification based on average N bore holes of Guwahati city 89 boreholes are
value is given and is presented in Table 1. As per classified as E type and rest of 111 boreholes
UBC (2000), E-type sites with low Nave are belong to class D.
susceptible to liquefaction
Contour map of water table
Table1:Soil site classification based on N avg The contour map of depth to ground water level in
Range of N avg Site class Guwahati city is shown in Fig. 6. The map in Fig.6
Navg<15 E indicates that in most of the locations in Guwahati
15< Navg<50 D city the water table is at a shallow depth. Depth to
Navg>50 C the water table in the 200 bore logs was found to
be within 0m to 6m meter of the ground surface.

Page 5 of 10
Binu Sharma, S.K Rahman. & B.D Saiki,.

Fig. 6. Contour map of depth to ground water table in Guwahati city

Contour map of Shear wave velocity (Vs) Table 2. Correlations of SPT N- value and shear
Shear wave velocity can be measured either by wave velocity
invasive or non-invasive methods. Invasive Researcher correlation
methods mainly include down hole, up hole and Kanai (1966) Vs = 19N0.6
cross Hole method. Non-invasive method includes Ohba and Toriumi Vs = 84N0.31
seismic refraction, Multichannel Analysis of (1970)
Surface Waves (MASW) and Spectral Analysis of Imai and Yahimura Vs = 76N0.33
Surface Waves (SASW). However both these (1970)
methods are very expensive and require expert Fujimara (1972) Vs = 92.1N0.337
supervision. Many empirical relations now exists Ohsaki and Iwasaki Vs = 81.4N0.39
connecting Vs and soil indices. Most of these (1973)
equations are based on the relation between Vs and Imai and Yoshimura Vs = 92N0.329
N-value. Table 2 shows 27 such empirical (1975)
correlations. These empirical relations are used Imai et al. (1975) Vs = 89.9N0.341
mainly for convenience, efficiency and cost saving. Imai (1977) Vs = 91N0.337
Ohta and Goto Vs = 85.35N0.348
(1978)

Page 6 of 10
Use of contour maps for preliminary assesment of subsoil of Guwahati city

Seed and Idriss Vs = 61.4N0.5


(1981) Table 3: Coefficient of soil type
0.314
Imai and Tonouchi Vs = 97N
(1982) Type of soil Coefficient for soil type.
Imai and Yoshimura Vs = 76N0.33
(1990) clay 1.0
Yokota et al. (1991) Vs = 121N0.27 Fine sand 1.086
Kalteziotis et al. Vs = 76.2N0.24 Medium sand 1.066
(1992) Coarse sand 1.135
Athanasopoulos Vs = 107.6N0.36 Sand and Gravel 1.153
(1995) Gravel 1.448
Sisman (1995) Vs = 32.8N0.51
Iyisan (1996) Vs = 51.5N0.516 In this study, shear wave velocity is determined
Jafari et al. (1997) Vs = 22N0.85 from equation (2) and equation (3) from the
Kiku et al. (2001) Vs = 68.3N0.292 uncorrected N- values obtained from the 200 bore
Hasancebi and Vs = 90N0.309 holes. Shear wave velocity is also computed from
Ulusay (2007) the uncorrected N-values using equation (3)
Hanumantharao and Vs = 82.6N0.43 because this equation incorporates thickness of the
Ramana (2008) soil strata and also type of soil. Most of the
Lee and Tsai (2008) Vs = 137.153N0.229 researchers utilized uncorrected SPT-N in
Dikmen (2009) Vs = 58N0.39 establishing relationship with shear wave velocity
values. Uma Maheswari et al. (2010) [11] reported
Uma Maheswari et Vs = 95.64N0.301
that the corrected and uncorrected N values
al. (2010)
predicted Vs with equal accuracy. Mhaske and
Tsiambaos and Vs = 105.7N0.327
Choudhury (2011) [12] also concluded that
Sabatakakis (2011)
0.51 correlation of uncorrected SPT N- value and shear
Anbazhagan et al. Vs = 68.96N
wave velocity Vs can give reasonably good
(2012)
estimate of value of shear wave velocity for typical
soil of Mumbai city. In view of this shear wave
By using the above 26 correlations, simple linear
velocity is determined from the uncorrected N-
power regression analysis was done by averaging
values.
shear wave velocities at different N- values. The
The shear wave velocity averaged over the
resulting equation from above analysis is given as
top 30 m of soil is referred to as VS30 and is
computed by dividing 30 m with the shear wave
Vs = 74.639xN0.3876 (2) velocity from the surface to 30 m as given in
2
for which R = 0.9996 following equation.
Rao (2012) has given a relation between shear
wave velocity and N-value in the form ∑n
i=1 di
Vs = 68.79 x N0.171 x H 0.199 x Vavg = di (4)
∑n
i=1� �
Vi
(1.0 for Alluvium or1.303 For Diluvium)x where ∑di =cumulative depth in m.
Coef�icient for soil type (3) Vi = Shear wave velocity at ith layer
where, H = thickness of soil strata. Modern seismic codes like NEHRP, UBC97,
The coefficient for soil type according to Rao IBC2000 and Eurocode8 use VS30 for doing the site
is given in Table 3. characterization. Contour map of VS30 by equation
(2) is shown in Figure 6 and contour map by
equation (3) of Rao (2012) is shown Figure 7.

Page 7 of 10
Binu Sharma, S.K Rahman. & B.D Saiki,.

Fig. 7. Contour map of VS30 by equation (2)

Fig. 8: Contour map of VS30 at 30 m depth using equation of Rao (2012).

Page 8 of 10
Binu Sharma, S.K Rahman. & B.D Saiki,.

According to NEHRP (National Earthquake static and seismic condition. Further it can be used
Hazard Reduction Programme) site classes of soil for low cost housing construction where generally
profile based on VS30 are shown in Table 4. subsurface investigations are not done. Shear wave
velocity by equation (3) of Rao (2012) has given
Table 4: Site classification of soil based on VS30 higher values than shear wave velocities obtained
Site class VS30 (m/s) Soil profile by equation (2) indicating further study is needed
range name in this direction.
A >1500 Hard rock
B 760-1500 Rock REFERENCES:
C 360-760 Very dense soil 1. Rao, S. Ch. (2012), Estimation of Shear wave
& soft rock velocity from soil indices, Indian Geotechnical
D 180-360 Stiff soil Journal, March 28, DOI 10.1007/s40098-013-
E <180. Soft soil 0049-3.
2. Phukon, P., Phukan, S., Das, P. and Sarma,
It is seen that the shear wave velocity as calculated B.(2004), Multicriteria Evaluation in GIS
by equation (2) comes out to less than that Environment for Groundwater Resource
calculated by Rao (2012) equation. When average Mapping in Guwahati City Areas, Assam, Map
shear wave velocities of Guwahati city are India Conference .
calculated by equation (2) then out of 200 3. Riberio, E. P., Dyminski, A. S. and Kormann,
boreholes in Guwahati city 6 sites belongs to class M. (2007), Evaluation of local and global
E and 194 borehole sites comes under class D. interpolation using neural networks for
According to Rao (2012), out of 200 boreholes 11 geotechnical mapping of Brazilian port site,
site belongs to class D, 183 sites belongs to class C APMTAC, Portugal, 1-9.
and 6 site comes under class B. On going through 4. Humyra, T., Awall, Md. R., Mofiz, S. A. and
the bore logs of the 200 bore holes it is seen that Sobhan, Md. A. (2012), Preparation of SPT
Guwahati soil consists of alternating layers of both Contour Map of Rajshahi City Area and its
fined grained and coarsed grained soils with N- Application to Foundation Design.
value ranging from 4 to > 50 (refusal). Ninety International Journal of Civil & Environmental
seven number of bore holes showed existence of Engineering, Vol: 12 No: 02, 11-17.
very dense strata from depth ranging from 12m to 5. Ayothiraman, R., Raghukanth, S. T. G. and
22.5m upto 30m showing N- value as refusal. Sreelatha, S. (2012) Evaluation of liquefaction
Again seven number of bore holes have gravel potential of Guwahati: Gateway city to
deposits from depth ranging from Northeastern India, Springer; 21 April, Nat
17m to 22m upto 30m. Bed rock was not Hazards (2012) 63: 449-460.
encountered in any of the 200 borings in Guwahati 6. Sykora, D. W. and Koester, P. J. (1988),
city. This gives the impression that equation (3) Correlations between dynamic shear resistance
according to Rao (2012) is overestimating the and standard penetration resistance in soils,
shear wave velocity and equation (2) is Earthq. Eng. Soil Dyn., 2, 389–404.
underestimating the shear wave velocity of 7. Imai, T. And Yoshimura, Y. (1970), Elastic
wave velocity and soil properties in soft soil (in
CONCLUSIONS: Japanese). Tsuchito- Kiso 18(1):17–22.
This study was done in order to generate contour 8. Sykora, D. E. and Stokoe, K. H. (1983).
maps of N- value, average N-value, depths to “Correlations of in-situ measurements in sands
ground water table and average shear wave of shear wave velocity,” Soil Dyn. Earthq.
velocity VS30 to characterise subsurface conditions Eng., 20, 125–36
in Guwahati city. These maps will be of use to the 9. Jafari, M.K., Shafiee, A. and Razmkhah, A.
foundation designers at the initial stage for site (2002), Dynamic Properties of Fine Grained
selection and preliminary foundation design under Soils in South of Tehran, Journal of

Page 9 of 10
Binu Sharma, S.K Rahman. & B.D Saiki,.

Seismological Earthquake Engineering, 4, 25– Master of Science in Civil and Environmental


35. Engineering, Los Angeles, 2009.
10. Trivedi S.S., Rao S. K., Gupta K.K., Rathod 19. Sharma, B., Saikia, B. D. And Hazarika P.J.
G.W. (2009), Mapping average shear wave (2012), Assesment of liquefaction potential of
velocity for ahmedabad soil sites: a case study, Guwahati city, IGC, Decembar 13-15, Vol. 1,
IGC, Guntur, India, 545-547. New delhi, India pp 1077-1079.
11. Maheswari, U. R., Boominathan, A. and 20. Marto, A., Soon, T. C. and Kasim, F.(2013), A
Dodagoudar, G.R. (2010), Use of Surface correlation of shear wave velocity and standard
Waves in Statistical Correlations of Shear penetration resistance, EJGE, Vol 18, 463-471.
Wave Velocity and Penetration Resistance of
Chennai soils, Geotechnical and Geology
Engineering, 28(2), 119-137.
12. Mahaske, S.Y. and Choudhury, D. (2011),
Geospatial contour mapping of shear wave
velocity for Mumbai City, Springer, 12 March,
Nat Hazards (2011) 59:317–327.
13. Dunlap, W., Holcombe, L. and Holcomb, T.
(2004), Shear Strength Maps of Shallow
Sediments in the Gulf of Mexico, Final Project
Report Prepared for the Minerals Management
Service Under the MMS/OTRC Cooperative
Research Agreement, Texas, 1-9.
14. Matsuoka, M., Wakamatsu, K., Fujimoto, K.
and Midorikawa, S. (2006), Average shear-
wave velocity mapping using Japan
engineering geomorphologic classification
map, Structural Eng./Earthquake Eng., JSCE,
April, Vol.23, No.1, 57s-68s.
15. Ismet, K. A., Tildy, P., Pronay, Z., Pinar, A.
and Hermann, L. (2006), VS 30 mapping and
soil classification for seismic site effect
evaluation in Dinar region, SW Turkey,
Geophys. J. Int., 223–235.
16. Raghukant, S.T.G. and Dash, S. K. (2008),
Stochastic modelling of SPT N value and
evaluation of probability of liquefaction at
Guwahati city, Journal of Earthquake
engineering and Tsunami, Vol. 2 No. 3,175-
19610
17. Anbazhagan, P. and Sitharam, T.G. (2008),
Site characterization studies of Bangalore using
geophysical method, Geotechnical and
geophysical site characterisation, 793-798.
18. Bellana, N. (2009), Shear Wave Velocity as
Function of SPT Penetration Resistance
and Vertical Effective Stress at California
Bridge Sites, A thesis submitted in partial
satisfaction of the requirements for the degree

Page 10 of 10

You might also like