Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FINANCIAL CRIME
COMPLIANCE STUDY
Global Report
March 2020
PAGE 1
OVERVIEW
PAGE 2
OVERVIEW
METHODOLOGY
A Comprehensive Survey was Conducted Among 898 Financial Crime Compliance
Decision Makers Across the Markets and Types of Organizations Shown Below.
Respondents included decision makers Organizations represented: Where organizations are referred to
within the financial crime compliance in terms of asset size**, they are defined as:
function who oversee: Banks
Small <$10B total assets
Know Your Customer (KYC) remediation,
Sanctions monitoring, Anti-Money Investment Firms
Mid/large: $10B + total assets
Laundering (AML) transaction monitoring,
and/or compliance operations Asset Management Firms
Insurance firms
* For the purpose of this study, Mexico is included with LATAM instead of North America.
** All currency references in this report are based on USD.
PAGE 3
OVERVIEW
MACRO
TOTAL
MARKET VIEW
PAGE 4
OVERVIEW
The largest regional markets for financial crime compliance are in There are specific countries outside of Europe and the LATAM
1 3
Europe and the U.S. There are significantly more financial institutions regions which also experience heightened challenges more so than
in these markets, with substantially higher average spend on financial others. These include Singapore, Indonesia, and Canada. Singapore still
crime compliance, compared to other regions. reverberates from the 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) scandal
involving a number of its financial institutions, with increased pressure
At a regional level, Europe and LATAM experience the most
2 challenges with financial crime. There is a tremendous level of
and oversight by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) as a result.2
Indonesia is a key market for terrorist financing3; de-risking is rated as
regulatory activity that continues to be brought into force in Europe. a top financial crime compliance driver there as much as it is by LATAM
The LATAM region is very active with predicate offenses (e.g., underlying financial institutions. This, along with a sizeable level of Indonesian
money laundering activities), particularly with porous borders that deposits in Singaporean banks, has earned extra attention by the U.S.
enable narcotics trafficking.1 Treasury Department.4 In North America, Canada is cited as “one of
the world’s major money-laundering jurisdictions” by the U.S. State
Department.5
1 1 knowyourcountry.com/brazil1111;
Mutual Evaluation Report of Mexico 2018,
Financial Action Task Force (FATF); fatf-
gafi.org/countries/#Mexico; Argentina:
North America* Europe Financial Information Unit’s New AML
Regulations for Financial Institutions,
United States UK DLA Piper, July 12, 2017; latamlawblog.
3
com/2017/07/argentina-financial-
Canada Germany information-units-new-aml-regulations-
2
France for-financial-institutions/
2 sbr.com.sg/source/zuu-online/heres-
Italy how-singapore-banks-are-involved-in-
Netherlands 1mdb-scandal
3 Asia/Pacific Group on Money Laundering
APAC
LATAM* (APG) Mutual Evaluation Report,
September 2018
Malaysia 4 flexicompliancenews.com/us-treasury-
Brazil
Philippines department-targets-singapore-for-
Mexico money-laundering
Argentina Singapore 5 theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-
canada-needs-to-do-more-to-curb-
Chile Indonesia money-laundering-us-report-says/
Colombia
*For the purpose of this study,
Mexico is included with LATAM
instead of North America.
South Africa PAGE 5
OVERVIEW
PAGE 6
Macro
PAGE 7
Macro
KEY FINDING 01
TOTAL PROJECTED COST BY REGION
$31.5B
North America**
United States, Canada $136.5B
Europe
UK, Germany,
France, Italy, Netherlands
$6.1B
APAC
Indonesia, Malaysia,
Philippines, Singapore
German and UK banks, in
particular, are at the epicenter
of compliance activity; both are
significant financial centers faced
with ever-increasing compliance $2.3B
regulations and are expending $4.5B South Africa
capital on human resources LATAM**
in order to manage these Brazil, Mexico, Argentina,
requirements and workloads. Chile, Colombia
* Representing the following markets: UK, Germany, France, Netherlands, Italy, U.S., Canada, Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, Chile, Colombia, South Africa, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, and the Philippines.
** For the purpose of this study, Mexico is included with LATAM instead of North America.
PAGE 8
Macro
KEY FINDING 01
TOTAL PROJECTED COST BY REGION
NORTH AMERICA* Across the five LATAM study markets, the number of financial institutions is just under the
United States $26.4B $31.5B
number for Germany alone (roughly 1,300), with the significant majority being smaller asset-sized
Canada $5.1B
firms with lower average annual compliance spend. Brazil is the biggest market, with nearly 2.5
times the number of firms compared to Argentina and Mexico and 3–5 times more than in Chile
and Colombia.
LATAM*
$4.5B The UK has the second highest number of financial institutions behind the U.S. (over 2,200);
(Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, Chile, Colombia)
there are many smaller asset management firms and banks, with a more limited number of
mid/large firms; however, average annual compliance spend is higher for both small and mid/large
firms compared to other markets.
EUROPE Germany has the third highest number of financial institutions (just over 1,600); but many are
$136.5B mid/large with a significantly higher average annual compliance spend compared to other regions,
UK $49.5B Italy $15.8B
Germany $47.5B Netherlands $2.7B including the U.S.
France $21.0B
France and Italy have a similar number of financial institutions (just under half as many as
Germany); a number are mid/large with a significantly higher average annual compliance spend
SOUTH AFRICA $2.3B compared to other regions, including the U.S.
South Africa has slightly fewer financial institutions compared to France and Italy (roughly
500), split by small and mid/large but with lower average annual compliance spend per institution.
As with LATAM, the number of financial institutions across the four APAC study markets is just
APAC under the number for Germany alone (roughly 1,400), with nearly three-fourths being smaller
(Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore)
$6.1B
asset-sized firms and lower average annual compliance spend. Singapore is the largest market
and represents half of the total projected spend.
*For the purpose of this study, Mexico is included with LATAM instead of North America. PAGE 9
Micro
PAGE 10
Micro
KEY FINDING 02
AVERAGE COST OF COMPLIANCE
7X
Up to 7 times the spend in LATAM Various factors explain the significant cost Average financial crime compliance spend
This is roughly 3–4 times higher than larger difference between larger European firms is not insignificant for firms in other global
North American firms and even more so and those in other regions; these will be regions, with similarly high levels among
compared to those in LATAM, APAC, and explored on subsequent slides. mid/large North American, Singaporean,
South Africa. Indonesian, and Filipino firms.
PAGE 11
Micro
KEY FINDING 02
AVERAGE COST OF COMPLIANCE
$42.0
$24.7
$14.2
$11.4
$7.7
$4.2 $7.0
$1.9 $2.4 $1.5
PAGE 12
Micro
KEY FINDING 02
AVERAGE COST OF COMPLIANCE
40% 57% 42% 54% 37% 62% 44% 47% 47% GDPR challenges
53%
Singapore 52% 45% UK 64% 36% Brazil 49% 42% U.S. 54% 46% Increased volume/hours associated
with completing due diligence
Indonesia 55% 41% Germany 64% 36% Mexico 48% 43% Canada 52% 48%
Compliance teams are larger and
Malaysia 55% 42% France 58% 42% Argentina 43% 50% require more skilled and higher-
salaried professionals
Philippines 58% 41% Italy 61% 39% Chile 44% 49%
PAGE 13
KEY FINDING 02
AVERAGE COST OF COMPLIANCE
GDPR creates headaches for European financial crime Leading European financial
financial crime compliance regulations are putting more firms have particularly felt
processes. pressure on due diligence and the pain of hefty fines by
onboarding efforts, including: U.S. regulators.
GENERAL DATA PROTECTION • More required documentation • Stricter ultimate beneficial • Sanctions violations/concerns
REGULATION (GDPR) ownership requirements as per
CHALLENGES • Firms need to obtain consent • Increased correspondent banking
the Fifth Money Laundering
from individuals before using their risks where loans or transactions
Directive (5AMLD)
INCREASINGLY COMPLEX personal data, thus lengthening have been processed in
REGULATION due diligence times • Limitations on using simplified U.S. denominations
due diligence across pooled client
• Limitations on the use of
accounts
personal data
• Deeper checks on payment
companies, verifiable accounts,
and cryptocurrency
PAGE 14
KEY FINDING 02
AVERAGE COST OF COMPLIANCE
The time required to complete business account due diligence by European firms has increased
significantly since 2017. Further, European firms took longer to do this compared to other regions in 2019.
Drivers Of Larger European Financial Crime Compliance Costs
Small, Medium-Sized Enterprises (SME) Domestic Midmarket Corporate Domestic Large Corporate
47
41
LABOR – INCREASED 36 37
34
CDD VOLUME / HOURS 30 30
22 24 25
19 21
17 19 17
17
14
11 10 11
8 9 8 8
7
2017
PAGE 15
KEY FINDING 02
AVERAGE COST OF COMPLIANCE
GDPR CHALLENGES There is a reported need for more specialized professionals among European financial firms.
Some larger banks have more recently hired additional staff – particularly experienced and specialized – given
INCREASINGLY COMPLEX
Drivers Of Larger European Financial Crime Compliance Costs
REGULATION increased Ultimate Beneficial Owner (UBO) regulations and more scrutiny from recent high profile money
laundering and sanctions-related scandals in Europe.6
Mid/large German, French and Italian firms reported larger teams compared to those in
the Netherlands.
LABOR: LARGER,
MORE SKILLED TEAMS
113
89 96
76
61
38 37 38 31 35
PAGE 16
KEY FINDING 02
AVERAGE COST OF COMPLIANCE
GDPR • GDPR creates headaches • European financial crime • Leading European financial firms
CHALLENGES for financial crime regulations are putting more have particularly felt the pain of
Drivers Of Larger European Financial Crime Compliance Costs
COMPLEX compliance processes pressure on due diligence and hefty fines by U.S. regulators
REGULATION onboarding efforts
INCREASED CDD
VOLUME/HOURS • Larger compliance teams • Longer due diligence times • Need for more
specialized professionals
LARGER, MORE
SKILLED TEAMS
HIGHER Entry (1-3 years) 31% $47,226 50% $31,326 15% $38,035 43% $37,620 38% $59,000
LABOR COSTS 41% $73,961 29% $50,652 49% $66,646 41% $75,200 36% $84,050
Mid (3-9 years)
High (10+ years) 29% $122,479 21% $77,983 35% $111,168 16% $89,500 26% $144,400
* Reported salary levels do not include benefits Denotes being significantly higher for all or most account types compared to other regions
PAGE 17
KEY FINDING 03 Regulatory compliance and
minimizing reputational risk are
common financial crime compliance
drivers across regions.
Each global region has its own unique risks
and challenges with money laundering and
financial crime compliance. These relate to common challenges
with regulatory reporting, customer
risk profiling, and sanctions screening.
PAGE 18
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
PAGE 19
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
Canada has been cited as “one of the world’s major money- There appears to be more aggressive regulatory monitoring
laundering jurisdictions” by the U.S. State Department.7 This of North American wealth management/investment firm
coincides with weaknesses cited about Canada’s AML/Counter compliance activities.9 Some of this may relate to reported
Terrorism Financing (CTF) regime in Financial Action Task Force’s weaknesses in alert reviews and monitoring of deposits for
(FATF) 2016 Mutual Evaluation report, including the need for better suspicious activities, including from penny stock transactions.10
and more timely abilities of Canadian law enforcement to fight 7 theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-canada-needs-to-do-more-to-curb-money-laundering-us-report-says/
money laundering and terrorist financing.8 8 reuters.com/article/bc-finreg-canada-aml-iduskcn1md240
9 insurancenewsnet.com/innarticle/2018-finra-fines-increase-cases-down
10 Ibid
*For purposes of this study, Mexico is included in LATAM and not in North America.
PAGE 20
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
The TriBorder Area (TBA) between Argentina, Brazil and Paraguay Mexico is concerned with crime and money laundering methods that
presents high risk for narcotics trafficking, and therefore, to hide beneficial ownership and cash smuggling across the
financial firms that may have accounts linked to illicit funds and U.S.-Mexican border.11 The Odebrecht and Lava Jato scandals also
money laundering. continue to cause concern.
Trans-national criminal organizations operate throughout Brazil 11 Mutual Evaluation Report of Mexico 2018, Financial Action Task Force (FATF); fatf-gafi.org/countries/#Mexico
and launder proceeds from drug trafficking operations and
human smuggling.
*For purposes of this study, Mexico is included in LATAM and not in North America.
PAGE 21
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
PAGE 22
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
PAGE 23
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
Tighter regulatory oversight and requirements put into effect as Other challenges include proximity to international trafficking
a result of the 1MDB scandal originating in Malaysia and involving a routes, presence of active terrorist organizations and smuggling
number of Singaporean banks. U.S. and Singaporean regulators are activities.
actively watching as a result.
PAGE 24
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
These factors are even more De-risking is more of a driver, Improving business results EMEA firms are more
important for LATAM firms particularly in emerging (62%) is ranked higher concerned with supporting
(71%-85%), perhaps because markets of LATAM and APAC, by North American firms, correspondent banking (47%)
drug trafficking and corruption with the 1MDB scandal playing suggesting that these financial than others are, suggesting
proceeds are key concerns in a role with the latter, as well as institutions recognize ways that the inherent challenge
the region, including the risky the sizeable terrorist financing in which increased customer of “knowing your customers’
TriBorder Area. risk from the Indonesian market. knowledge benefits the broader customers” has made these
organization, including the relationships more risky in
business development and the stricter KYC environment.
marketing functions.
PAGE 25
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
11% 10%
PAGE 26
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
16 16
11 11
12
14
11
12%
10
9 Expected average increase in
8 8 7
7 6 6 6
5 6 alert volumes by end of 2019
4
3
11% 14% 8% 11%
APAC EMEA LATAM NORTH
AMERICA
Germany 12 20 21 17
France 12 17 16 10
Italy 13 13 15 15
Netherlands 11 12 11 17
Denotes being significantly higher for all or most
account types compared to other regions South Africa 9 8 11 12
PAGE 27
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
PAGE 28
KEY FINDING 03
REGIONAL ISSUES IMPACTING FCC
72%
64% 65%
56% 55% 56% 54% 56% 56%
53% 53% 52%
48% 49%
44% 43% 46%
39% 39% 40% 42% 40% 41% 42%
36% 38%
33%
28%
21% 21%
Singapore Germany
(63%) (67%)
France South Africa Chile U.S.
(69%) (64%) Brazil (82%) (54%)
Malaysia Italy
(43%) Canada
(48%) (51%)
Netherlands Mexico (34%)
(52%) (41%)
South Africa
(55%)
Netherlands
Denotes being significantly higher for all or most (58%)
account types compared to other regions
PAGE 29
KEY FINDING 04 LATAM AND
CANADIAN
financial firms have been
affected most.
PAGE 30
KEY FINDING 04
NON-BANK PAYMENT PROVIDER IMPACT
Degree Non-Bank Payment Providers Have Created Challenges for Financial Crime Compliance
During the Past Year (% moderate/large degree)
PAGE 31
KEY FINDING 04
NON-BANK PAYMENT PROVIDER IMPACT
Larger financial regions of EMEA, APAC, APAC firms are somewhat more likely LATAM financial services firms are more
and North America commonly feel an than others to feel the negative effects of likely than others to mention increased
increased risk to their correspondent increased alert volumes (61%), cost of risk of compliance violations. This
banking relationships. resources (57%), and stress on compliance could relate to more of them mentioning
teams (54%). payment chain complexity/lack of
transparency as a screening challenge
with non-bank payment providers, in a
region that is already high risk for money
laundering through narcotics and
unregulated long borders.
PAGE 32
KEY FINDING 04
NON-BANK PAYMENT PROVIDER IMPACT
Increased Alert Volumes Increased Correspondent Banking Risk Increased Cost of Tech Investments
Increased Risk of Compliance Violations Increased Cost of Resources Increase Compliance Team Stress
61%
55% 57% 54% 55%
53% 49% 51% 49% 51% 52% 52% 53% 50%
43% 42% 42% 46% 47%
42%
37% 40% 38% 41%
33% 33% 35%
30% 31%
21%
Indonesia
(42%) Malaysia France Brazil Colombia Canada
(67%) (59%) (56%) (35%) (77%)
PAGE 33
KEY FINDING 04
NON-BANK PAYMENT PROVIDER IMPACT
Actions Financial Crime Compliance Organizations Have Already Taken to Address Non-Bank Provider Challenges
Expanded Screening Operations Hours (Not 24 x7) Expanded Screening Operations Hours to 24x7
54% 53%
46% 45%
45% 45% 42%
43% 45% 42% 41% 41% 41%
36% 38% 38% 37% 39% 39% 37%
33% 34% 35% 35% 33% 35% 37% 34%
30% 27% 29% 30% 30% 30% 31%
25%
20% 20%
12% 10%
PAGE 34
KEY FINDING 04
NON-BANK PAYMENT PROVIDER IMPACT
69%
Singapore 51% 53% Germany 49% 58% Brazil 55% 29% U.S. 42% 62%
Indonesia 58% 61% France 35% 56% Mexico 61% 24% Canada 46% 87%
Denotes being significantly
higher for all or most Malaysia 35% 51% Italy 48% 51% Argentina 69% 72%
account types compared to
other regions Philippines 53% 60% Netherlands 47% 53% Chile 36% 14%
PAGE 35
KEY FINDING 04
NON-BANK PAYMENT PROVIDER IMPACT
PAGE 36
KEY FINDING 05 Financial crime compliance
costs have risen by double-digit
percentages during the past
two years.
Financial crime compliance challenges
and issues are having a negative impact on
financial institutions, particularly in EMEA, Financial crime compliance
PAGE 37
KEY FINDING 05
NEGATIVE IMPACTS OF COMPLIANCE
PAGE 38
KEY FINDING 05
NEGATIVE IMPACTS OF COMPLIANCE
33% 36%
31%
Singapore 42% 40% Germany 66% 51% Brazil 73% 74% U.S. 32% 59%
Indonesia 33% 33% France 76% 55% Mexico 76% 70% Canada 26% 56%
Denotes being
significantly higher for
all or most account types
compared to other regions
67% Concerned with job satisfaction in compliance department 63 Average hours of annual lost productivity per FTE
compliance analyst due to job dissatisfaction
PAGE 39
KEY FINDING 05
NEGATIVE IMPACTS OF COMPLIANCE
17%
12%
9% 8.5% 9% 9%
7% 8%
4.5% 5%
Singapore 5.0% 10.0% Germany 8.5% 19.0% Brazil 8.5% 9.0% U.S. 8.0% 14.0%
Indonesia 4.5% 9.0% France 8.0% 14.0% Mexico 7.5% 8.0% Canada 3.0% 6.0%
Denotes being Malaysia 4.5% 9.0% Italy 8.5% 17.0% Argentina 7.0% 8.0%
significantly higher for
all or most account types Philippines 9.0% 7.0% Netherlands 8.0% 20.0% Chile 7.5% 10.0%
compared to other regions
South Africa 7.5% 15.0% Colombia 9.0% 9.0%
Denotes a significant or
directional difference
compared to some or all
countries within category
PAGE 40
KEY FINDING 06 Financial crime compliance
investments can benefit
other functional units where
the organization has a fuller
A layered approach to financial crime understanding of customer
risks and preferences.
compliance technology is crucial to
facilitating a more cost-effective, efficient
compliance approach, as well as one that There can be a direct cost benefit
PAGE 41
KEY FINDING 06
BENEFITS OF COMPLIANCE
Improved Data for Financial Risk Improved Data for Customer Improved Understanding of
Management Relationship Management Customer Risk Tolerance
78%
PAGE 42
KEY FINDING 06
MULTI-LAYERED SOLUTION APPROACH
Fake, synthetic identities developed from Investigate both the physical (name, address,
breached data Sanctions screening documents) and digital identity attributes
(the digital footprint, devices, and behavior of
Mobile and online channel transactions, and the entity)
digital onboarding that provide anonymity for Efficient alerts resolution
synthetic identities Assess both the individual (Is this the right
person?) and the transaction (Are there
Non-bank payment providers/systems Complex payment chains anomalies with the transaction?)
that make transaction and customer transparency
difficult, and pose risk of being non-compliant Incorporate both KYC (individual) and KYB
themselves Positive ID of PEPs (business) processes
Cryptocurrencies that enable criminals to move Leverage data analytics to assess risks and
illicit funds, especially across borders behaviors in real-time
PAGE 43
KEY FINDING 06
MULTI-LAYERED SOLUTION APPROACH
Average Hours Required for Completing Customer Due Diligence (Business Accounts)
DOMESTIC DOMESTIC
MIDMARKET LARGE FOREIGN
SME CORPORATE CORPORATE FOREIGN SME CORPORATE
27
24
15
10 12
Overall: Across All
Firms and Regions
PAGE 44
Micro
KEY FINDING 06
MULTI-LAYERED SOLUTION APPROACH
$141
Average Cost of Compliance Per FTE $85
(Annual Cost USD in Thousands)
PAGE 45
FOR MORE INFORMATION
risk.lexisnexis.com/FCC
All currency references in this report are based on USD. For the purpose of this study, Mexico is included with LATAM instead
of North America. This document is for educational purposes only and does not guarantee the functionality or features of
LexisNexis products identified. LexisNexis does not warrant this document is complete or error-free. LexisNexis and the
Knowledge Burst logo are registered trademarks of RELX Inc. Other products and services may be registered trademarks of their
respective companies.
PAGE 46