Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MarketView
CEE Big Box Logistics
www.cbre.eu/research May 2011
OVERVIEW
• Economic fundamentals stronger; future prospects remain uncertain
External demand has remained the key driver of economic growth in CEE. A strong link
Quick Stats with German manufacturers has kept industrial output in Central and Eastern Europe
(CEE) above the level in the Eurozone. Due to the strong basis achieved in 2010, export
Change from growth
th is
i likely
lik l to
t slow
l somewhat
h t in
i the
th second
d half
h lf (H2) off 2011.
2011 The
Th revival
i l off domestic
d ti
Q1 10 Q4 10 demand remains subject to consumer confidence which is strongly linked to
unemployment. A strong upturn in employment is not expected in 2011 outside of Eastern
Total Leasing Activity Ï Ï Europe. As a consequence consumer demand is likely to grow at a moderate level during
Completions Ð Ð 2011 in most markets in the region. GDP growth in South Eastern Europe (SEE) has also
recently turned positive in most countries.
Vacancy Rate Ð Ð
• Development picking up in larger markets; focus shifts from capital to regional cities
Rents Ð Î After the logistics development market almost came to a halt during the economic
downturn, the market has recently seen development activity picking up again. The year
Investment Turnover Ï Ï 2011 is likely to see an increase in project deliveries, mainly based on development activity
in Poland and Russia. Most other markets, however, are expected to see another year-on-
year (y-o-y) drop in deliveries. Increased productivity at manufacturers and their link with
Hot Topics regional CEE markets has caused development activity to move from capital cities towards
regional cities. This is especially the case in the Czech Republic and Poland but also to
• Economic fundamentals stronger; some extent in Hungary and Slovakia. In most markets developers can only develop based
f
future prospects remain uncertain on a built-to-suit
built to suit (BTS) agreement or when a significant pre-lease
pre lease is signed.
signed
• Development picking up in larger • Vacancy continues downward trend; arising opportunities not always anticipated
markets; focus shifts from capital to Average vacancy in CEE declined further to 16% at the end of Q1 2011. Considerable
regional cities differences exist around the region. The Bratislava region in particular and regional
markets such as Brno have seen vacancy dropping below 3% and 5% respectively.
• Vacancy continues downward trend; Especially for Bratislava the development market is not yet anticipating this low level of
arising opportunities not always supply and rents may selectively start trending upwards there. Most other larger markets
anticipated are still facing considerable vacancy (10 (10-15%
15% and higher) clearly indicating why
• Prime rents bottoming; prime yields development has generally remained at a relatively low level in most markets.
have compressed and investment on • Prime rents bottoming; prime yields have compressed and investment is on the rise
the rise Prime rents have changed little across the region over the last six months. In Central
Europe (CE) higher take-up levels combined with low levels of completion have helped
rental levels in bottoming. On the other hand in regional cities the pipeline under
construction (U/C) is increasing pressure on rents. Rental increases were registered in
Moscow on the back of a high g level of absorption
p achieved in 2010. Prime yyields have
compressed further, however, to a more limited extent than during the first half of 2010.
Besides the acquired logistics assets in the Europolis portfolio, a large portfolio sale in
Czech Republic also triggered the investment volume this year. After a year-on-year (y-o-y)
increase of 40% in investment turnover in the CEE industrial segment in 2010, year-to-
date volume in 2011 amounts to around €550 million and is already surpassing the 2010
level by 30%.
600
100%
400
90%
Total Leasing
4 2007=100%)
200
a 0
2007
Q4
2008
Q1
2008
Q2
2008
Q3
2008
Q4
2009
Q1
2009
Q2
2009
Q3
2009
Q4
* Total for Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Slovakia.
2010
Q1
2010
Q2
2010
Q3
2010
Q4
2011
Q1
80%
Source: Oxford Economics, CB Richard Ellis (May 2011) ©2011, CB Richard Ellis, Inc.
ECONOMIC BACKGROUND
View CEE Big Boxx Logistics
-12.5%
Away from manufacturing, consumer spending has 2008 2008 2008 2008 2009 2009 2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011 2011
Q1 Q
Q Q2 Q3 Q Q4 Q1Q Q2 Q3 Q
Q Q4 Q1Q Q2 Q3 Q
Q Q4 Q1e
Q e Q Q2f Q3f
Q3 Q Q4f
MarketV
not really picked up in most markets yet. Poland and Source: Oxford Economics (May 2011)
Russia are the exception to this. High unemployment
rates and fragile consumer confidence indicate that a Components of GDP in CE Economies*
rebound of domestic demand should not be expected Domestic consumption Export
in most other markets before 2012. The economies in 6.0% 20.0%
0.0% 0.0%
-1.5% -5.0%
MODERN LOGISTICS STOCK
-3.0% -10.0%
and St. Petersburg) amounts to 16 million sq m. 2008 2008 2008 2008 2009 2009 2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011 2011
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1e Q2f Q3f Q4f
Another 5 million sq m of modern logistics space is * Weighted average of data for Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Slovakia.
located in regional cities, mostly in Poland and the Source: Oxford Economics (May 2011)
60%.
Industrial production change (yy-o-y)
5.0%
experience only limited new developments taking 2008 2008 2008 2008 2009 2009 2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011 2011
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1e Q2f Q3f Q4f
place.
l B d on developments
Based d l U/C across the
h
region, 2011 is likely to see a similar level of Source: Oxford Economics (May 2011)
3.0
25%
Apart from Moscow and St. Petersburg, other major 25
2.5
CEE cities are still waiting for the development market 20%
Stock (million sq m)
15%
visible in the regional markets recently. Based on 1.5
0.0 0%
Moscow
arsaw
Kyiv
grade
SSofia
apest
St Peterssburg
Bucharest
Bratisslava
PL, Siilesia
oclaw
ague
PL, Ceentral
oznan
CZ, Brno
Plzen
Pra
CZ, P
Buda
Wa
PL, Wro
Belg
PL, Po
a
Page 2
©2011, CB Richard Ellis, Inc.
CEE Logistics Completions and Pipeline (U/C) Looking at country-wide vacancy rates, the increased
MarketV
400
Completions 2009 Completions 2010 Expected completions 2011* pipeline U/C in Poland may initially seem a bit surprising.
Vacancy, however, is generally lower in regional cities
300
than in Warsaw and the majority of new projects start
200
also witnessing increasing interest for regional locations.
100
Developers, however, have remained cautious with
speculative projects, especially in regional markets.
0
Trading of development land has picked up as well.
Bucharest
Moscow
Warsaw
Kyiv
Belgrade
PL, Central
Sofia
Budapest
Petersburg
Bratislava
PL, Silesia
Prague
PL,, Wroclaw
CZ, Plzen
PL, Poznan
CZ, Brno
Infrastructure developments are an important driver in
d idi
deciding on locations.
l i N
New transactions
i can be
b found
f d in
i
St P
P
* Deliveries in Q1 also included. P
Source: CB Richard Ellis (May 2011) Romania, for example, where along planned motorway
connections land transactions are taking place again after
Industrial Demand in CEE Capitals and Regional Cities* a long period of illiquid market conditions.
Regional Cities Capital City
Take-up trend in Capital Cities Take-up trend in Regional Cities DEMAND
800 140%
500
80%
400 seen in 2007-2008.
60%
300
300 12%
2007 2007 2007 2007 2008 2008 2008 2008 2009 2009 2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2011
compared to capital cities in 2010. While renewals
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 formed an increasing share in TLA at the cost of new take-
take
* Data for Bratislava, Bucharest, Budapest, Prague and Warsaw.
Net absorption in Q1 2010 was negative. up in capital cities, demand in regional cities consists of
Source: CB Richard Ellis (May 2011) new BTS-solutions and pre-leases for new schemes.
Net Effective Logistics Rents in CEE
VACANCY
Range (MAX-MIN)
8.0
5.0
percentage point compared to the peak measured a year
ago. Some markets – like Bratislava, Kyiv and Prague –
4.0
have vacancy rates at considerably lower levels than a
May 2011
Prague
ucharest
Belgrade
St Petersburg
Brratislava
Moscow
Kyiv
PL,, Poznan
CZ, Brno
Sofia
Budapest
PLL, Silesia
PL, Central
1
Bu
C
B
Source: CB Richard Ellis (May 2011) (above 20%), however, the vacancy is significantly lower
within Warsaw boundaries (10% in Sector I). The lowest
a
rate is currently registered in Bratislava with only 3%.
Page 3
©2011, CB Richard Ellis, Inc.
ox Logistics
600 25%
Million EUR
development activity in many of the major markets. For 400
15%
some of the markets this cautiousness is remarkable in
300
light of the low levels of vacancy reached in some cities
10%
in CEE. Based on today’s pipelines U/C, vacancy rates 200
perty investment
5%
region. 100
0 0%
PRICING
2006 H1 2006 H2 2007 H1 2007 H2 2008 H1 2008 H2 2009 H1 2009 H2 2010 H1 2010 H2 *2011 Q1
* Q1 2011 volume is influenced by Europolis portfolio acquisition by CA Immo.
Net effective rental levels for logistics properties in CEE Source: CB Richard Ellis (May 2011)
have remained mostly unchanged compared to CEE Weighted Average Prime Logistics Yields
November 2010, and vary by sub-region to a great CE Logistics Yield Premium
CE Logistics Yield
CE Office Yield
SEE Logistics Yield
extent.
t t For
F the th capital
it l city
it markets
k t in
i CE nett effective
ff ti 20
EE LLogistics
i i Yi Yield
ld
Q2 2005
Q3 2005
Q4 2005
Q1 2006
Q2 2006
Q3 2006
Q4 2006
Q1 2007
Q2 2007
Q3 2007
Q4 2007
Q1 2008
Q2 2008
Q3 2008
Q4 2008
Q1 2009
Q2 2009
Q3 2009
Q4 2009
Q1 2010
Q2 2010
Q3 2010
Q4 2010
Q1 2011
SEE markets have not seen significant leasing activity in
recent quarters. As a result rents have remained under Source: CB Richard Ellis (May 2011)
pressure and more hypothetical.
CEE Logistics Prime Yields and Prime Rental Changes
During the last two quarters the prime yield gap between
Change in Change in
Warsaw and other CE capitals closed slightly on the back Market
Prime yield prime yield prime rent
of further compression in Budapest and Prague. The (%)
y-o-y (bps) y-o-y (%)
current weighted average prime yield for CE stands at
Belgrade 12.00% -100 0%
8.2% which represents a 10 bps compression compared
to Q3 2010. The same indicator for CEE stands at Bratislava 8.75% 0 13%
11.2% reflecting a 20 bps compression compared to the Bucharest 10.25% -25 -1%
end of Q3 2010. The industrial prime yield in CEE has
Budapest 9.00% -50 0%
remained around 150 bps above prime office yields.
Kyiv 15.00% -100 0%
INVESTMENT MARKET Moscow 13.50% -50 20%
volume has shown continuous growth since the bottom St Petersburg 15.00% -100 0%
of the cycle was reached in early 2009. 2009 Industrial
Zagreb 9.50% 0 -3%
property investment in 2010 reached €420 million and
increased by 40% y-o-y. Industrial property investment Warsaw 7.75% -100 0%
made up for 10% of the total property investment volume
Source: CB Richard Ellis (May 2011)
reached in CEE in 2010. In 2011 this positive trend has
continued. Year-to-date investment volume in 2011
amounts to €550 million. This volume is, however,
positively impacted by the acquisition of the Europolis
portfolio
tf li by
b CA Immo.
I A th
Another significant
i ifi t sale
l took
t k
May 2011
1
a
schemes for around €300 million.
Page 4
©2011, CB Richard Ellis, Inc.
CEE MARKET ANALYSES
MarketV
The industrial market in Bulgaria is highly affected by the In Romania during recent years major international
low consumer spending and the weak construction automotive companies have developed their production
business. Development activity is still declining. New facilities, mostly in the western part of the country. In cities
Despite the positive change in fundamentals, the The Slovakian industrial market has seen low levels of
Hungarian industrial market is recovering only slowly. Due development activity, with only one new scheme delivered
to the fact that some large warehouses became vacant in in Central Slovakia in Q1 2011. Another 21,000 sq m of
Q1 2011, vacancy has remained at around 22% in the BTS space is currently under construction in Kosice but no
Greater Budapest area despite stronger demand. The scheme has been launched in Bratislava since Q3 2010.
take-up has been gradually increasing since the bottom in The amount of vacant space has reached a historical low
2009. New supply, however, is at a historic low with only level with vacancy falling below 3% in the capital city area.
a fully let scheme delivered in Q4 2010. 2010 Rents have D it the
Despite th high
hi h absorption
b ti i recentt quarters
in t and
d hence
h
remained stable for the last two quarters. the low level of current availability, speculative
development may be undertaken only as adjacent space
In Poland demand remains strong with new deals to BTS projects.
amounting to 80 % of total leasing activity. In the regions
the industrial market is improving mostly on the back of The slow recovery of the Kyiv industrial market has
built-to-suit projects and pre-leases being signed. The continued. Demand for modern warehouse space
vacancy rate has been decreasing much faster here than in increased and in combination with a virtual absence of
th Warsaw
the W region.
i A a resultlt off limited
As li it d construction
t ti new supply l this
h causedd the
h vacancy rate to decrease
d to
activity, availability is expected to decrease further, 17%. In Q1 2011, the largest lease since the beginning of
although a few speculative projects have been launched the recession was completed on 20,000 sq m. Effective
recently in Silesia and Wroclaw areas. The market in rental levels have remained stable compared to Q3 2010.
May 2011
greater Warsaw should see further improvements in 2011 The pipeline U/C has grown with currently over 100,000
in terms of take-up, however, the existing vacant space sq m being actively under construction.
needs to be absorbed before new projects will be
considered. Downward pressure on effective rents around
Warsaw is stillll registered,
d although
lh h it is diminishing
d h in
other popular regions of Poland.
a Page 5
©2011, CB Richard Ellis, Inc.
View CEE Big Boxx Logistics
A
Associate
i t Director,
Di t H d off IIndustrial
Head d t i l and
d Logistics
L i ti CEE
CEE Capital Markets CEE Industrial and Logistics
t: +44 207 182 2723 t: +48 22 544 8049
e: patrick.ogorman@cbre.com e: tom.listowski@cbre.com
Central and Eastern Europe (CEE), includes the following countries: Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Hungary,
P l d Romania,
Poland, R i Russia,
R i Serbia,
S bi Slovakia
Sl ki and d Ukraine.
Uk i C t l Europe
Central E (CE) includes
i l d Czech
C h Republic,
R bli Hungary,
H
Poland and Slovakia. South Eastern Europe (SEE) includes Bulgaria, Croatia, Romania and Serbia. Eastern Europe
(EE) includes Russia and Ukraine.
Currency effects, the rents and capital values in Russia and Ukraine are based on indices denominated in US
Dollars (USD) and are therefore influenced by exchange rate effects.
Net Absorption, represents the change in occupied stock within a market during the survey period.
Net Effective Rent, as presented in this report, represents a range of rental levels for a requirement of around 5,000
sq m in a modern logistics facility according to international standards. Net effective rents reflect payable rental
levels already corrected for a total package of incentives applicable to the state of the market at that given time.
Prime Rent, represents the top open-market tier of rent that could be expected for a unit of standard size
commensurate with demand in each location, of the highest quality and specification and in the best location in a
market at the surveyy date. In the case of industrial p properties,
p , p
prime rent is achievable for smaller unit sizes in
centrally (or strategically) located warehouses and not necessarily in logistics sheds.
Prime Yield, represents the yield that an investor would receive when acquiring a grade/class A building in a prime
location which is fully let at current market value rents. Prime Yield should reflect the level at which relevant
transactions are being completed in the market at the time but need not be exactly identical to any of them,
particularly if deal flow is very limited or made up of unusual one-off deals. If there are no relevant transactions
during the survey period, a hypothetical yield should be quoted, and is not a calculation based on particular
transactions, but it is an expert opinion formed in the light of market conditions, but the same criteria on building
location and specification still apply.
Total Leasing Activity, represents the total gross floor space known to have been let or pre-let, sold or pre-sold to
tenants or owner-occupiers during the survey period, and also contract renewals are included.
Total Stock, represents the total space completed (occupied and vacant) at the survey date, recorded as the gross
rentable area. Pipeline, or Space under Construction, represents the total amount of gross rentable area of
properties where construction has commenced on a new development or in existing properties and is ongoing at the
survey date.
Weighted averages, (Economy) are calculated based on a country’s 2010 nominal GDP published by Oxford
Economics.
example only and do not represent the current or future performance of the market. This information is designed
exclusively for use by CB Richard Ellis clients, and cannot be reproduced without prior written permission of CB Richard
Ellis.© Copyright 2011 CB Richard Ellis
Page 6
©2011, CB Richard Ellis, Inc. a