Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Figure 1: Device for stabilization of upper limb and Figure 2: Child in position for passive stiffness measures,
positioning of dynamometer during isometric strength with forearm and hand stabilized and electrodes in place
tests of wrist flexors and extensors. for electromyographic monitoring.
Muscle Characteristics and Hand Function in Children with CP Daniela Virgínia Vaz et al. 729
until three successful repetitions had been performed. (diameter 4.8cm, height 10.6cm). Children were instructed
Resistance torques registered by the dynamometer were to complete the tasks as fast as possible and were allowed a
treated with a fourth-order Butterworth filter with a low cut-off maximum time of 40 seconds to complete each task.18 The
(1.25Hz). A biomechanical model, considering body mass, age, total time spent in the three tasks was registered in seconds
and hand length, was used to estimate the torques generated and used as the hand function score (ICC=0.98).
by the weight of the hand.15 The estimated hand torques and
the torques generated by the metal plate were subtracted from STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
the torques registered by the dynamometer, allowing the mea- Mixed analyses of variance (ANOVAs), with two repeated mea-
surement of the remaining torque produced by the soft tis- sures and one independent factor, were used to compare wrist
sues. Simple regression analyses between resulting resistance extensor and flexor strength between groups and between
torque values and joint angles were performed for each of the the three test positions. Independent t-tests and Mann–Whitney
three successful trials. The mean of the three regression slopes U tests were used to compare anthropometrical characteris-
was used as the value of passive muscle stiffness, expressed in tics and passive stiffness of flexors between groups.
Joules per radian (ICCs: CP=0.96, TD=0.85). Pearson’s product moment correlation coefficients and
Manual dexterity of the CP group was assessed with three Spearman’s rank correlations were performed to test associ-
tasks based on the Jebsen–Taylor Hand Function Test,17 which ations between variables related to strength and stiffness of
included: (1) picking up two pencils, two correction fluid bot- wrist muscles and hand function in the CP group. A stepwise
tles, and two erasers and putting them in a can; (2) stacking multiple regression was performed with the independent
four wooden discs; and (3) picking up five round containers variables that correlated significantly with hand function.
Table I: Group estimates and comparisons between children with cerebral palsy (CP) and typically developing (TD) children
Body mass (kg) 28.70 (7.30) 23.80 to 33.60 30.26 (9.79) 23.68 to 36.81 1.56 (–6.12 to 9.23) 0.677a
Hand length (m) 0.10 (0.01) 0.07 to 0.11 0.11 (0.01) 0.10 to 0.11 0.07 (–3.24 to 0.02) 0.059a
Flexor strength (N) 48.69 (16.47) 43.08 to 54.31 118.44 (32.50) 107.35 to 9.53 69.75 (57.08 to 82.42) 0.001a
Extensor strength (N) 17.93 (10.61) 14.31 to 21.55 60.64 (22.65) 52.91 to 68.37 42.71 (34.02 to 51.41) 0.001a
Median, IQR (95% CI) Median, IQR (95% CI) Dif. between medians (95% CI)
Flexor stiffness (J/rad) 0.192, 0.195 (0.17 to 0.52) 0.145, 0.076 (0.09 to 0.26) 0.076 (0.01 to 0.21) 0.02b
aDifference tested with independent t-test; bdifference tested with Mann–Whitney U test. IQR, interquartile range; CI, confidence interval.
Table II: Estimates for joint positions and comparisons between positions for wrist flexors and extensors strength values in
children with cerebral palsy and typically developing children
a b
Wrist physiological range Wrist physiological range
Length Length
Figure 3: Consequences of shifts in length–tension curves of wrist flexors and extensors. (a) Flexor curve shifted to left owing
to tissue remodelling caused by maintenance of muscle in a shortened position. Tension decreases with wrist in extension
when flexors are excessively elongated. (b) Extensor curve shifted to right owing to tissue remodelling caused by
maintenance of muscle in an elongated position. Tension decreases with wrist in extension when flexors are excessively
shortened. , normal length–tension curves; , shifted length–tension curves.
Muscle Characteristics and Hand Function in Children with CP Daniela Virgínia Vaz et al. 731
the wrist was extended. Nevertheless, because spasticity is with the wrist in flexion could be attributed to an insufficient
characterized by muscle reflex activity that occurs during pas- number of test positions. Another explanation would be that
sive movement and ceases after movement is terminated,21 this the plateau of extensors could have been displaced to new
factor could not have influenced results of isometric strength wrist amplitudes which include neutral and 30˚ of flexion. A
tests. Strength results could also have been influenced by dif- strong trend towards significantly greater flexors strength
ferences between groups in the moment arms of wrist muscles. values at 30˚ of flexion was found; the 95% confidence inter-
However, no moment arm alterations were observed in chil- val for the difference between 30˚ of flexion and extension
dren with CP undergoing surgery for wrist flexion contrac- demonstrates the possibility of a true and clinically meaning-
tures.22 As no child of the CP group had contractures, moment ful difference between these joint positions.
arms probably did not influence results. Muscle alterations observed in children with CP appear to
A shift in the length–tension curves of wrist flexors and exten- reflect adaptations to the pattern of wrist flexion observed
sors in the CP group is probably the best explanation for the during manual activities. The excessive flexor stiffness and
decrease in strength in the extended wrist position. In adults, the decreased strength with the wrist in extension could make
both extensor and flexor peak strength occur with the wrist in the use of the wrist in extended amplitudes difficult and con-
extension.23 Such peaks were not observed in TD children, tribute to functional deficits. Results revealed associations
probably because of the few positions tested. Nevertheless, between hand function and variables related to muscle char-
results for children with CP were contrary to what is expect- acteristics in the CP group, suggesting that muscle properties
ed for TD children. that may impose limitations to wrist extension are associated
Within physiological range limits, wrist flexors work in the with poorer performance. The greater the difference in exten-
ascending portion of their length–tension curves23, as illus- sor strength between 30˚ of wrist flexion and extension (this
trated in Figure 3. A shift of the flexors curve to the left caused variable would reflect the shift in the extensors length–
by tissue remodelling in the shortened position,14 as proba- tension curve) the greater the time to complete manual tasks.
bly occurs in children with CP, would lead to an excessive Additionally, lower extensor strength in relation to flexor stiff-
sarcomere elongation at wrist extension and a consequent ness was associated with poorer hand function and explained
decrease in strength. On the other hand, extensors work in 46.2% of the total variation in hand functional scores. This
the descending portion of their curves, with tension increas- interpretation would be further confirmed by associations
ing as the wrist is extended.23 In children with CP, because between variables related to extensors strength at 30˚ of
extensors are maintained in lengthened positions, there would extension with better hand function (Table I), which could
be a shift of the curve to the right.14 Thus, with the wrist in have reached significance with a larger sample size.
extension, sarcomeres would still be in a less than ideal length It is not possible to determine if alterations in muscle char-
for tension development, and would only achieve adequate acteristics would cause functional difficulties, or if observed
lengths with wrist flexion (Fig. 3). movement patterns, adopted as adaptations to other deficits,
The fact that greater extensor strength was not produced would result in altered tissue demands and muscle remodel-
ling, as suggested by results. Both alternatives are possible
and may happen simultaneously in children with CP. Movement
and posture patterns depend on resources available to the
Table III: Correlations between hand function score and organism, and at the same time have an impact on these
variables related to strength and stiffness of wrist flexors and resources, establishing a cycle.24,25 It is possible that primary
extensors in children with cerebral palsy deficits such as weakness may lead the child to adopt com-
pensatory movement patterns to achieve functional goals.25
Variable r 95% CI p The weakness of wrist extensors would limit extension against
FSta 0.493 (–0.15 to 0.84) 0.118
gravity during manual activities. The maintenance of the wrist
FS 30˚ extensionb –0.017 (–0.61 to 0.58) 0.961 in flexion and the relative limb immobility would result in mus-
FS 0˚b –0.229 (–0.73 to 0.4) 0.498 cle tissue remodelling, with shifts in the length–tension curves
FS 30˚ flexionb –0.168 (–0.69 to 0.46) 0.621 of wrist muscles and increases in stiffness of wrist flexors.
ES 30˚ extensionb –0.564 (–0.76 to 0.05) 0.070 These alterations, in their turn, would contribute to the main-
ES 0˚b –0.306 (–0.76 to 0.35) 0.359 tenance of the wrist in flexion.
ES 30˚ flexionb 0.210 (–0.44 to 0.72) 0.534 A better understanding of the interaction between muscle
Mean ESb 0.128 (–0.51 to 0.67) 0.708 properties and motor dysfunction is necessary to meet the chal-
Mean FSa –0.073 (–0.64 to 0.55) 0.818 lenge of developing efficient intervention strategies to promote
Mean ES/Mean FSb 0.064 (–0.51 to 0.67) 0.852
functional improvements in children with CP. Interventions
ES/FS 30˚ extensiona –0.509 (–0.85 to 0.12) 0.109
ES/FS 0˚b –0.106 (–0.66 to 0.52) 0.756
aimed at the modification of muscle characteristics associated
ES/FS 30˚ flexionb 0.371 (–0.29 to 0.79) 0.261 with hand dysfunction could promote improvements in motor
Dif ESb 0.612 (0.03 to 0.89) 0.045 abilities for children with CP. Strengthening exercises for wrist
Dif FSb –0.155 (–0.69 to 0.49) 0.649 flexors and extensors in extended wrist amplitudes could
ES 30˚ extension/FStb –0.679 (–0.91 to –0.14) 0.021 promote improvements in strength through muscle tissue
Ageb –0.330 (–0.76 to 0.33) 0.310 remodelling and neural adaptation, as well as decreases in pas-
aCorrelation tested with Spearman’s rank correlation; bcorrelation
sive flexor stiffness. Future investigations should evaluate the
effects of such interventions in this population.
tested with Pearson’s product moment correlation. CI, confidence
intervals; FSt, flexor stiffness; FS, flexor strength; ES, extensor
strength; Dif, difference between strength values at 30˚ of wrist
flexion and 30˚ of wrist extension. DOI: 10.1017/S0012162206001563
Muscle Characteristics and Hand Function in Children with CP Daniela Virgínia Vaz et al. 733