Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract— Biodiesel as a renewable and sustainable dependence on fossil fuels and also has significant
alternative fuel has gained importance in recent environmental benefits [2].
times. Use of biodiesel has shown reduced power, Different additives are used along with diesel and
increased BSEC and increase in NOx emission. biodiesel. The purposes of these additives are to
Different additives are used along with diesel and improve the cold flow properties of the fuel and
biodiesel for improving fuel properties, combustion engine performance and emission characteristics. In
characteristics, engine performance and emission this paper detailed review of effect of additives on
characteristics. This article describes about the use fuel properties, combustion characteristics engine
of additives for above mentioned purposes. It is performance and emission from the engine is done.
found that use of additives improved the
biodiesel/diesel properties like viscosity, flash and A.Types of additives
fire points and pour points etc. Use of additives Additives can be broadly classified as organic
reported no much improvement in engine additives and metal based additives. It can be further
performance except few cases who reported to the classified as additives to improve the properties of
contrary. Combustion characteristics found to be base fuel, additives used to improve the engine
improved with use of additives. HC and PM performance, additives used to improve the emission
emissions reported to be reduced and NOX emission characteristics. Additives to improve the engine
was found to increase in some cases. Special NOx performance can be further classified as pre-flame
inhibitor additives found to be more effective in additives, flame additives and post-flame additives.
reducing the NOx emission. A special class of additives which improve the
oxidation stability of biodiesel are under study.
Keywords — Biodiesel, organic, metallic, additives, NPAA (4-Nonyl phenoxy acetic acid), NPPD
performance, combustion, emission. (N-phenyl-1, 4-phenylene diamine), DPPD (N, N‟-
diphenyl-1, 4-phenylenediamine), Synthetic fatty
acids, Oxygenated diglyme are the examples for
I. INTRODUCTION organic additives. Nio, mno2,Fecl3,Mn,Mo,
O,Mg,SCD5,Magnallium(Al-Mg),CD3O4,ceo,Cu are
As a renewable, sustainable and alternative fuel
the examples for metal based additives. Gossypol,
for compression ignition engines, biodiesel instead
pyrogallol (1-2, 3 trihydroxy benzene), Propyl
of diesel has been increasingly fuelled to study its
gallate (3,4,5-trihydroxy benzoic acid),
effects on engine performance and emissions in the
butylatedhydroxyanisole BHA(2-tert butyl 4-
recent years. Available literature reviews show that
methoxy phenol) are the examples for additives for
use of bio diesel lead to reduced engine power,
improving oxidation stability of biodiesel.
increased BSEC because of reduction in heating
values of biodiesel. But use of biodiesel has shown
reduction in PM, HC and CO but increase of NOx B. Effect of Additives on fuel properties
The additives are added to improve the
emission. Biodiesel favours to reduce carbon deposit
properties of base fuel. Gossypol was found to be
wear of key engine parts. [1]
exogenous antioxidant for FAME‟s [3].Pyrogallol,
Biodiesel fuel is an oxygenated fuel and sulfur
Propyl gallate, butylatedhydroxyanisole was found
free fuel. These factors lead to complete combustion
decreasingly effective i.e. (Py>PG>BHA) in
and less exhaust emissions than diesel fuel.
improving oxidation stability of Magalocarpous oil
Furthermore biodiesel has higher viscosity, density,
biodiesel [4].
pour point, flash point and cetane number than diesel
Metin Guru et al [5] studied the effect of
fuel. Using biodiesel can help reduce the world‟s
organic compounds of Mn, Mg, Cu and Ca metals as
additives for improving the diesel fuel properties. It A few more research work is needed in the area
was found that organic based Manganese gave of effect of additives improving the properties of
greatest decrease in freezing point. This additive diesel/biodiesel.
reduced the freezing point to 12.40C at the rate of
dosage of 54.2µmol Mn/L diesel fuel. It was C. Effect of additives on biodiesel engine
established that the cetane number of diesel fuel performance
without additive was 46.22 whereas the cetane Most of the researches on the performance
number 48.24 for diesel fuel with optimum amount characteristics of diesel engine when additive was
of dosage. It was observed that the organic based used along with biodiesel report that effect of
Manganese reduces the viscosity and flash point. An additive on the performance of diesel engine fuelled
Organic based Manganese additive was found to with biodiesel was not much significant. In a study
improve the properties of pomace oil methyl ester conducted by Kalam. M.A. et al [10] on effect of
biodiesel [6].Doping the fuel at a ratio of 12µmol/l adding NPAA additive in B20 palm biodiesel to the
oil methyl ester led to a 20.37% decrease in viscosity, extent of 1% additive showed better performance
70C fall in flash point and reduced the pour point such as improved brake power, lower SFC.
from 00C to -150C. A bio solution made of natural organics was used as
Chicken fat methyl ester has the advantage of an additive in a research [11]. Experimental results
having a high cetane number, being non-corrosive, in this work demonstrate that emulsified bio-
clean and renewable, while having certain solution/palm biodiesel/diesel blends have the
disadvantages such as a high freezing point, high advantage of saving energy upto the extent of 16%
viscosity and high flash point. In a study Magnesium reduced fuel consumption.
based additive was synthesized stoichiometricaly at Ali Keskin et al [12] studied the effect of
2250C for 1 hour in a 1 litre glass reactor. Effects of synthesized Mn and Ni based additive in biodiesel
[7] the additive on pour point, viscosity and flash produced out of tall oil. Fatty acids and resinic acids
point of raw chicken fat methyl ester were were obtained from crude tall oil by distillation
investigated by dosing additives upto 16µmol/l. method. Tall oil methyl ester was produced from
Increase in additive concentration from 0 to fatty acids. Resinic acids were reacted with NiO and
16µmol/l resulted in lower freezing point, viscosity mno2 stoichiometrically for the production of
and flash point. A dosage of 16µmol Mg into the metallic fuel additives. Each metallic fuel additive
chicken fat methyl ester a causes a 70C pour point was added at the rate of 8µmol/l and12µmol/l to
decrease. Viscosity and flash point tests were carried make mixture of 60%tall oil methyl ester/40% diesel
out with and without the Mg additive. The increase fuel (TE60) for preparing test fuels. Biodiesel fuels
from in magnesium concentration from 0 to were tested in an unmodified direct injection diesel
16µmol/l lead to decrease from 5.184 to 4.812 in engine at full load condition. Specific fuel
viscosity. With the same Magnesium additive consumption of diesel fuel increased by 6%.
concentrations flash point was decreased from 129 0C However in comparison with TE60 it showed trend
to 1220C. The additive causes reductions in the flash of decreasing with adding additives. A different
point, viscosity and pour point compared to fuel study conducted by Ali Keskin et al [13] on the
without additives. The synthesized additives such as influence on tall oil biodiesel of Mg and Mo
polyisobutylene (PIB)-succinimides showed same or additives based fuel additives. The engine torque and
better detergent-dispersant properties compared to power output values did not change much in
the conventional diesel and biodiesel blends. They comparison with fuel without additives. A study was
also provided corrosion inhibiting and lubricity conducted by G.R.Kannan et al [14] on the effect of
improving effects when applied in diesel fuel, 5% ferric chloride (fecl3) additive with waste cooking
biodiesel containing diesel fuel and 100% biodiesel palm oil based biodiesel. The metal based additive
[8]. was added to biodiesel at a dosage of 20µmol/l. The
M De Torres et al [9] studied the effect of CFPP study revealed that fecl3 added biodiesel resulted in a
(cold filter pour point) additives on biodiesel fuel decrease of brake specific fuel consumption (BSFC)
and improvement in bad behaviour at low of 8.6% while the brake thermal efficiency was
temperatures. In this study, it has been shown that increased by 6.3% for constant speed test at
how the presence of free fatty acids in the starting 1500rpm.
materials for producing biodiesels can be used for Pomace oil methyl ester blended with diesel fuel
synthesizing additives able to improve cold flow can be used as an alternative fuel in the conventional
properties of biodiesel from reused oils. The study of diesel engine without any major modification. An
crystallization patterns of pure derivatives by DSC organic based Manganese (Mn) additive improved
and optical microscopy revealed the improvement of engine performance along with the base fuel
cold properties of biodiesel. Blends of biodiesel with properties [6]. Metin Guru et al [7] studied the
upto 5% of some of these compounds allowed a chicken fat biodiesel with synthetic Mg additive in a
decrease of CFPP. single cylinder DI diesel engine for its effects on
engine performance. Organic based synthetic
Magnesium additive was doped into biodiesel blends has been observed that the improvement in the
by 12µmols of Mg. Engine tests were run with diesel efficiency generally increases with dosing levels of
fuel (EN590) and a blend of 10% chicken fat nanoparticles.
biodiesel and diesel fuel (B10) at full load operating
conditions and different engine speeds from D. Effect of additive on biodiesel combustion
1800rpm to 3000rpm. The results showed that the characteristics
engine torque was not changed significantly with Researches are carried out on the effect of
addition of 10% chicken fat biodiesel, while specific additive on biodiesel combustion characteristics in a
fuel consumption increased by 5.2% due to lower diesel engine. Ferrocene was used as additive in a
heating value of biodiesel. A.S. Ramadhas et al [15] study conducted by C.J.Du et al [20]. Two engine
experimentally proved that the3 diethyl ether could configurations were tested, standard aluminium
be used as an additive with biodiesel to improve piston with normal engine deposits and engine
performance characteristics. cleaned to “new engine condition”, with piston
An experimental investigation has been carried replaced with a thermal barrier coated piston. It is
out on the effects of „injection pressure‟ on found that 30 and 40% burn angles were advanced
performance and emission characteristics of CI while 5 and 60% burn angles remained unchanged.
engine using Jatropha Curcus As biodiesel with Eji Kinoshita et al [21] experimentally found that the
SCD5 additive. Tests were conducted on single ignition delay of biodiesel became longer by adding
cylinder four stroke water cooled compression crude glycerine to biodiesel.
ignition engine to evaluate the feasibility of blends Hu Li et al [22] investigated the effect of a
of JME with SCD5 additive. The performance of J20 multifunctional diesel fuel additive package used
with SCD5 additive shows less specific energy with rapseed oil (RSO) as a fuel in DI heavy duty
consumption and highest brake thermal efficiency diesel engine. The results showed that use of
[16]. multifunctional fuel additive package reduced the
IRGANOR NPA was added to POME-Diesel ignition delay, increased the premixed combustion
blended fuels especially for B20+1% combination in duration (PCD), improved the combustion stability,
a study conducted by M.Shahabuddin et al [17]. reduced deposit build up on fuel injectors and
Along with B20+1% several form of biodiesel is prevented the deterioration of engine.
used in this experiment namely B100 (pure bio G.R.Kannan et al [12] investigated the effect of
lubricant), B20, B20+2% and compared with FeCl3 as a fuel borne catalyst (FBC) for waste
ordinary diesel. It is found that B20+1% produces cooking palm oil based biodiesel for combustion
1.73% and 9% higher brake power compared to fuel characteristics. FBC added biodiesel showed higher
B20 and ordinary diesel respectively. Also it is cylinder gas pressure, heat release rate and shorter
found that B20+1 consumes 26% and 6% lower SFC ignition delay at optimized operating conditions.
compared with fuels B20 and ordinary diesel. A three phase biodiesel emulsion of oil in water
Ali Keskin et al [18] studied the influence of drops- in oil (O/W/O) and O/W/O biodiesel
metallic based fuel additives such as synthesized Mn emulsion containing aqueous ammonia were
and Mg based additives on engine performance. The prepared and tested for burning quality in a study
metallic based additives were produced by conducted by Cheng-Yuan Lin and Hsia-An Lin [23].
synthesizing of resinic acids (abeetic acid) with The experimental results showed that the burning of
mno2 and mgo. These additives were doped into O/W/O biodiesel emulsion and the O/W/O emulsion
diesel fuel at the rate of 8µmol/l and 16µmol/l for containing aqueous ammonia had larger fraction of
preparing test fuels. The fuels with and without fuel burnt and thus larger heat release rate than neat
additives were tested in a direct injection diesel biodiesel if water content is not considered for
engine at full load condition. Maximum reduction in calculations of heating value.
SFC was recorded as 4.16%. Power and Torque An experimental investigation was conducted
values of engine were increased slightly by Mn by D.H.Qi et al [24] to evaluate the effects of using
based additive at some engine speeds. diethyl ether and ethanol as additive to
V Sajith et al [19] conducted experimental biodiesel/diesel blends on the combustion
investigation on effects of Cerium oxide nano characteristics of a direct injection diesel engine.
particle fuel additives on biodiesel derived from Test fuels were denoted as B30 (30% biodiesel and
jatrophacurcus. Engine performance tests were 70% diesel in volume), BE-1(5% diethyl ether, 25%
conducted on the diesel engine with standard biodiesel and 70%diesel in volume) and BE-2 (5%
biodiesel oil and modified fuel. The results show ethanol, 25% biodiesel and 70% diesel in volume)
that the brake thermal efficiency of diesel engine respectively. At Lower engine loads, the peak
improved by addition of Cerium oxide in the fuel. pressure rise rate and peak heat release rate of BE-1
The Cerium oxide nano particles present in the fuel were almost similar to those of B30 and higher than
promote longer and more complete combustion those of BE-2. At higher engine loads the peak
compared to the base fuel as Cerium oxide acts as an pressure rise rate and peak heat release rate of BE-1
oxygen buffer thus increases the efficiency. It also were highest and those of B30 were lowest. Here
appreciably reduced with the addition of Cerium smoke opacity are keenly observed and
oxide nanoparticle. In an investigation done by additives found to improve these characteristics.
D.Ganesh et al[32] on the effect of Nano fuel
additive {Magnalium(Al-Mg) and cobalt oxide REFERENCES
(CO3O4)} on emission reduction in a [1] Jin Lin Xue, Tome E Grift, Alan C Hansen. Effect of
biodiesel(Jatropha) fuelled CI engine, it is found that biodiesel on engine performances and emissions.
nono fuel additive resulted in maximum reduction Renewable and Sustainable energy reviews. 15(2011) pp
about 60% in UBHC and 50% reduction in CO at 1098-1116
[2] Syed A B, Rajagopal K. A review of the effects of catalyst
full load and 75% load respectively. Yanangan et al and additive on biodiesel
[33] investigated the burning characteristics of fuel production,performance,combustion and emission
droplets of JME containing nano and micron sized characteristics. Renewable and Sustainable energy reviews.
Al particles by varying its size. Al particle 16(2012) pp 711-717
[3] Bryan R Moser. Efficacy of gossypol as an antioxidant
significantly reduces the emission of CO2, NOx. additive in biodiesel. Renewable Energy 40 (2012) pp 65-
Husnawan et al [34] showed that using post 70
flame MgO additive successfully diminished [4] Kivevele T T, Mbrava M M, Bereczky A, Laza T,
poisonous exhaust gasses from diesel and vegetable Madarasz J. Impact of antioxidant additive on the oxidation
stability of biodiesel produced from Croton Megalocarpus
oil based biodiesel blends. These gasses are HC, oil.Fuel Processing Technology 92 (2011) pp 1244-1248
NOx and CO. Use of metal based additive such as [5] Guru M, Ugur K, Duram A, Ahmet A. Improvement of
MgO combined with oxygenated additive (palm- diesel fuel properties by using additives. Energy
polyol) found reducing NOx from biodiesel-diesel Conversion and Management 43 (2002) pp 1021-1025.
[6] Sinem C, Metin G, Ahmet B, Ali K, Yakup I. Biodiesel
blended fuel combination. production from pomace oil and improvements of its
A study was conducted by Mahesh C.V et al [16] properties with synthetic manganese additive. Fuel
on emission characteristics of CI engine using 88(2009) pp 534-538.
JatrophaCurcus as biodiesel with SCD5 additive. [7] Guru Metin, KocaAtilla, Can Ozer, Cinar Can, SahinFatih.
Biodiesel production from waste chicken fat based sources
They found that as the amount of SCD5 additive and evaluation with Mg based additive in a diesel engine.
with JME increases the HC, CO, and smoke density Renewable Energy 35(2010) pp 637-643.
in exhaust decreases. [8] Jeno H, Mark B, Adam B, Jeno B. Development of
multifunctional additives based on Vegetable oils for high
quality diesel and biodiesel. Chemical Engineering
Research and Design 86 (2008) pp 793-799.
II. CONCLUSIONS [9] De Toress M, Jime‟nez-Ose‟s, Mayoral J A, Pires E. Fatty
From the literature available following acid derivatives and their use as CFPP additives in
biodiesel. Bioresourece Technology 102 (2011) pp 2590-
conclusions can be drawn. 2594.
1. Adding different types of additives found that [10] Kalam M A and Masjuki H H. Testing Palm biodiesel and
increased oxidation stability of base fuel, NPAA additives to control NOx and CO while improving
efficiency in diesel engines. Biomass and Bio energy 32
decrease the freezing point, reduce the viscosity, (2008) pp 1116-1122.
decrease the flash point and reduce the pour [11] Kang-Shin Chen, Yuan-Chung Lin, Lien-Te Hsieh, Chia-
Chieh Wu. Saving energy and reducing pollution by use of
point of base fuel. Additives improved the emulsified palm- biodiesel blends with biosolution additive.
detergent-dispersant properties of Energy 35 (2010) pp 2043-2048.
diesel/biodiesel blends [12] Ali K, Guru M, Duram A. Biodiesel production from tall
oil with synthesized Mn and Ni based additives: Effects of
2. Performance of diesel/biodiesel blended engines additives on fuel consumption and emissions. Fuel 86
grossly have not shown much improvement. But (2007) pp 1139-1143.
[13] Ali K, Guru M, Duram A. Influence of tall oil biodiesel
in some cases it was reported that there were with Mg and Mo based additives on diesel engine
marginal decrease in SFC and little increase in performance and emissions. Biosource Technology 99
(2008) pp 6434-6438.
brake thermal efficiency [14] Kannan G R, Karvembu R, Anand R. Effect of metal based
3. Additives in diesel/biodiesel blends are found to additive on performance emission and combustion
improve the combustion characteristics. charecteristics of diesel engine fuelled with biodiesel.
Applied Energy 88 (2011) pp 3694-3703.
Improved combustion stability, reduced deposit [15] Ramadhas A S, Jayaraj S, Muraleedharan C. Experimental
buildup, shorter ignition delay, better heat investigations on diethyl ether as fuel additive in biodiesel
engine. International Journal of Global Energy 29 (2008)
release rate are observed with the additives. But pp 329-336.
in some researches increased delay period and [16] Mahesh C V, Puttaiah E T and Swetha S. Effect of
Injection pressure on the performance and emission
reduced heat release rate were reported. charecteristics of C.I.engine using jathrophacurcusas
4. Additives in general improved the emission biodiesel with SCD5 additive. International Journal of
Engineering research and applications. Vol2, Issue3,May-
characteristics of diesel/biodiesel fuelled June 2012 pp 2282-2287.
engines. The addition of antioxidant additives [17] Shahabuddin M, Masjuki H H, Kalam M A,Mofijur M,
reduced NOx emission. Emission characteristics Hazrat M A. Effect of additive on performance of CI
engine fuelled with biodiesel. Energy Procedia 14(2012) pp
like CO, HC, NOx, PM, PAH and soot and 1624-1629.