FRAMING SYSTEM

CONSTRUCTABILITY DAYS % Subordinate Rank

CONCENTRICALLY 150.00 10.00
ECCENTRICALLY 200.00 2.50 7.50
SINGLE SPAN RIGID STEEL 400.00 6.25 3.75

ECONOMIC COSTS % Subordinate Rank

CONCENTRICALLY 10000000.00 10.00
ECCENTRICALLY 15000000.00 3.33 6.67
SINGLE SPAN RIGID STEEL 40000000.00 7.50 2.50

STRUCTURAL SAFETY COSTS % Subordinate Rank

CONCENTRICALLY 1.02 10.00
ECCENTRICALLY 2.50 5.92 4.08
SINGLE SPAN RIGID STEEL 3.57 3.00 7.00

COLUMNS
CONSTRUCTABILITY DAYS % Subordinate Rank
S-SHAPE 14.00 10.00
WIDE FLANGE 17.00 1.76 8.24

ECONOMIC PHP/TON % Subordinate Rank

S-SHAPE 31000.00 10.00
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 0.46 9.54

STRUCTURAL SAFETY mm % Subordinate Rank

S-SHAPE 19.10 2.88 7.12
WIDE FLANGE 13.60 10.00

BEAMS
CONSTRUCTABILITY DAYS % Subordinate Rank
I-SHAPE 21.00 10.00
WIDE FLANGE 22.00 0.45 9.55

ECONOMIC PHP/TON % Subordinate Rank

I-SHAPE 30000.00 10.00
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 0.77 9.23
STRUCTURAL SAFETY mm % Subordinate Rank
I-SHAPE 17.30 2.02 7.98
WIDE FLANGE 13.80 10.00

BRACES
CONSTRUCTABILITY DAYS % Subordinate Rank
HORIZONTAL 6.00 10.00
VERTICAL 7.00 1.43 8.57

ECONOMIC PHP/TON % Subordinate Rank

HORIZONTAL 200000.00 10.00
VERTICAL 275000.00 2.73 7.27

STRUCTURAL SAFETY mm % Subordinate Rank

HORIZONTAL 37.01 1.88 8.12
VERTICAL 30.03 10.00

CONNECTIONS
CONSTRUCTABILITY DAYS % Subordinate Rank
BOLTED 4.00 10.00
WELDED 5.00 2.00 8.00

ECONOMIC PHP/TON % Subordinate Rank

BOLTED 100000.00 2.50 7.50
WELDED 75000.00 10.00

STRUCTURAL SAFETY mm % Subordinate Rank

BOLTED 33.00 10.00
WELDED 39.20 1.58 8.42
 10

IMPORTANCE SINGLE SPAN RIGID

FRAMING SYSTEM TRADEOFFS CONCENTRICALLY ECCENTRICALLY
FACTOR STEEL

CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 10 90 7.5 67.5 3.75

ECONOMIC 10 10 100 6.67 66.7 2.5
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 10 90 4.08 36.72 7
280 170.92

IMPORTANCE
COLUMNS TRADEOFFS S-SHAPE WIDE FLANGE
FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 10 90 8.24 74.16
ECONOMIC 10 10 100 9.54 95.4
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 7.12 64.08 10 90
254.08 259.56

BEAMS TRADEOFFS IMPORTANCE I-SHAPE WIDE FLANGE

FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 10 90 9.55 85.95
ECONOMIC 10 10 100 9.23 92.3
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 7.98 71.82 10 90
261.82 268.25

IMPORTANCE
BRACES TRADEOFFS HORIZONTAL VERTICAL
FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 10 90 8.57 77.13
ECONOMIC 10 10 100 7.27 72.7
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 8.12 73.08 10 90
263.08 239.83

IMPORTANCE
CONNECTIONS TRADEOFFS BOLTED WELDED
FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 10 90 8 72
ECONOMIC 10 7.5 75 10 100
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 10 90 8.42 75.78
255 247.78
SINGLE SPAN RIGID
STEEL COMBINATION 1 : SKELETON, S-SHAPE, I-SHAPE, HORIZONTAL AND BOLTED
ECONOMIC: 10361000
33.75 CONSTRUCTABILITY 195.00
25 STRUCTURAL SAFETY 107.43
63
121.75 COMBINATION 2 : WALL BEARING, S-SHAPE, I-SHAPE, HORIZONTAL AND BOLTED
ECONOMIC: 15361000
CONSTRUCTABILITY 245.00
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 108.91

COMBINATION 3 : SINGLE SPAN, S-SHAPE, I-SHAPE, HORIZONTAL AND BOLTED

ECONOMIC: 40361000
CONSTRUCTABILITY 445.00
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 109.98

COMBINATION 4 : SKELETON, WIDE FLANGE, WIDE FLANGE, VERTICAL AND WELDED

ECONOMIC: 10415000
CONSTRUCTABILITY 201.00
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 97.65

COMBINATION 5 : WALL BEARING, WIDE FLANGE, WIDE FLANGE, VERTICAL AND WELDED
ECONOMIC 15415000
CONSTRUCTABILITY 251.00
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 99.13

COMBINATION 6 : SINGLE SPAN, WIDE FLANGE, WIDE FLANGE, VERTICAL AND WELDED
ECONOMIC: 40415000
CONSTRUCTABILITY 451.00
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 100.20

COMBINATION 7: SKELETON,S SHAPE,I SHAPE ,HOR ,BOLTED

ECONOMIC: 4
CONSTRUCTABILITY 40000000.00
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 51.00
 ECONOMIC CONSTRUCTABILITY S SAFETY

SK 70000000.00 500.00
WB 60000000.00 550.00
SP 40000000.00 400.00
S SHAPE 31000.00 14.00
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 17.00
I SHAPE 30000.00 21.00
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 22.00
HORIZONTAL 200000.00 6.00
VERTICAL 275000.00 7.00
BOLTED 100000.00 4.00
WELDED 75000.00 5.00

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
ECONOMIC CONSTRUCTABILITY S SAFETY 1
SK 70000000.00 2
WB 60000000.00 3
SP 40000000.00 4
S SHAPE 31000.00 5
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 6
I SHAPE 30000.00 7
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 8
HORIZONTAL 200000.00 9
VERTICAL 275000.00 10
BOLTED 100000.00 11
WELDED 75000.00 12
13
14
15
16
ECONOMIC
TRADE-OFFS UNITS INITIAL ESTIMATE SUBORDINATE RANK
%
COMBINATION 1 PHP 70361000 5.7327 4.2673
COMBINATION 2 PHP 70336000.00 5.7348 4.2652
COMBINATION 3 PHP 70361000.00 5.7327 4.2673
COMBINATION 4 PHP 70411000.00 5.7287 4.2713
COMBINATION 5 PHP 70363500.00 5.7325 4.2675
COMBINATION 6 PHP 70338500 5.7346 4.2654
COMBINATION 7 PHP 70438500.00 5.7264 4.2736
COMBINATION 8 PHP 70413500.00 5.7284 4.2716
COMBINATION 9 PHP 70362500.00 5.7326 4.2674
COMBINATION 10 PHP 70337500.00 5.7346 4.2654
COMBINATION 11 PHP 70437500.00 5.7265 4.2735
COMBINATION 12 PHP 70412500.00 5.7285 4.2715
COMBINATION 13 PHP 70365000.00 5.7324 4.2676
COMBINATION 14 PHP 70365000.00 5.7324 4.2676
COMBINATION 15 PHP 70440000.00 5.7263 4.2737
COMBINATION 16 PHP 70446000.00 5.7258 4.2742
COMBINATION 17 PHP 60361000 6.6825 3.3175
COMBINATION 18 PHP 60336000.00 6.6852 3.3148
COMBINATION 19 PHP 60436000.00 6.6742 3.3258
COMBINATION 20 PHP 60411000.00 6.6769 3.3231
COMBINATION 21 PHP 60363500.00 6.6822 3.3178
COMBINATION 22 PHP 60338500.00 6.6850 3.3150
COMBINATION 23 PHP 60413500.00 6.6767 3.3233
COMBINATION 24 PHP 60413500.00 6.6767 3.3233
COMBINATION 25 PHP 60362500.00 6.6823 3.3177
COMBINATION 26 PHP 60337500.00 6.6851 3.3149
COMBINATION 27 PHP 60412500.00 6.6768 3.3232
COMBINATION 28 PHP 60062500.00 6.7157 3.2843
COMBINATION 29 PHP 60365000.00 6.6820 3.3180
COMBINATION 30 PHP 60340000.00 6.6848 3.3152
COMBINATION 31 PHP 60440000.00 6.6737 3.3263
COMBINATION 32 PHP 60446000.00 6.6731 3.3269
COMBINATION 33 PHP 40361000.00 9.9938 0.0062
COMBINATION 34 PHP 40336000.00 10.0000
COMBINATION 35 PHP 40436000.00 9.9753 0.0247
COMBINATION 36 PHP 40411000.00 9.9814 0.0186
COMBINATION 37 PHP 40363500.00 9.9932 0.0068
COMBINATION 38 PHP 40338500.00 9.9994 0.0006
COMBINATION 39 PHP 40438500.00 9.9747 0.0253
COMBINATION 40 PHP 40413500.00 9.9808 0.0192
COMBINATION 41 PHP 40362500.00 9.9934 0.0066
COMBINATION 42 PHP 40337500.00 9.9996 0.0004
COMBINATION 43 PHP 40362500.00 9.9934 0.0066
COMBINATION 44 PHP 40412500.00 9.9811 0.0189
COMBINATION 45 PHP 40365000.00 9.9928 0.0072
COMBINATION 46 PHP 40340000.00 9.9990 0.0010
COMBINATION 47 PHP 40715000.00 9.9069 0.0931
COMBINATION 48 PHP 40446000.00 9.9728 0.0272
 CONSTRUCTABILITY
CONSTRUCTABI SUBORDINA
TRADE-OFFS UNITS INITIAL ESTIMATE
LITY TE RANK
SK 500.00 COMBINATION 1 DAYS 70361000 28.7074
WB 550.00 COMBINATION 2 DAYS 351961500.00 5.7389
SP 400.00 COMBINATION 3 DAYS 351861500.00 5.7406
S SHAPE 14.00 COMBINATION 4 DAYS 351910500.00 5.7398
WIDE FLANGE 17.00 COMBINATION 5 DAYS 351961500.00 5.7389
I SHAPE 21.00 COMBINATION 6 DAYS 352061500 5.7373
WIDE FLANGE 22.00 COMBINATION 7 DAYS 351910500.00 5.7398
HORIZONTAL 6.00 COMBINATION 8 DAYS 352010500.00 5.7381
VERTICAL 7.00 COMBINATION 9 DAYS 351814000.00 5.7413
BOLTED 4.00 COMBINATION 10 DAYS 351914000.00 5.7397
WELDED 5.00 COMBINATION 11 DAYS 351763000.00 5.7422
COMBINATION 12 DAYS 351863000.00 5.7405
COMBINATION 13 DAYS 351914000.00 5.7397
COMBINATION 14 DAYS 351914000.00 5.7397
COMBINATION 15 DAYS 351863000.00 5.7405
COMBINATION 16 DAYS 422374000.00 4.7822
1 COMBINATION 17 DAYS 60361000 33.4633
2 COMBINATION 18 DAYS 351936500.00 5.7393
3 COMBINATION 19 DAYS 351785500.00 5.7418
4 COMBINATION 20 DAYS 351885500.00 5.7402
5 COMBINATION 21 DAYS 351936500.00 5.7393
6 COMBINATION 22 DAYS 352036500.00 5.7377
7 COMBINATION 23 DAYS 351985500.00 5.7385
8 COMBINATION 24 DAYS 351910500.00 5.7398
9 COMBINATION 25 DAYS 351789000.00 5.7417
10 COMBINATION 26 DAYS 351889000.00 5.7401
11 COMBINATION 27 DAYS 351838000.00 5.7409
12 COMBINATION 28 DAYS 211038000.00 9.5712
13 COMBINATION 29 DAYS 351889000.00 5.7401
14 COMBINATION 30 DAYS 351989000.00 5.7385
15 COMBINATION 31 DAYS 351838000.00 5.7409
16 COMBINATION 32 DAYS 422349000.00 4.7825
1 COMBINATION 33 DAYS 201938000.00 10.0025
2 COMBINATION 34 DAYS 201988000.00 10.0000
3 COMBINATION 35 DAYS 201913000.00 10.0037
4 COMBINATION 36 DAYS 201963000.00 10.0012
5 COMBINATION 37 DAYS 201913000.00 10.0037
 6 COMBINATION 38 DAYS 201963000.00 10.0012
7 COMBINATION 39 DAYS 201888000.00 10.0050
8 COMBINATION 40 DAYS 201938000.00 10.0025
9 COMBINATION 41 DAYS 201913000.00 10.0037
10 COMBINATION 42 DAYS 201963000.00 10.0012
11 COMBINATION 43 DAYS 201913000.00 10.0037
12 COMBINATION 44 DAYS 201938000.00 10.0025
13 COMBINATION 45 DAYS 201888000.00 10.0050
14 COMBINATION 46 DAYS 201938000.00 10.0025
15 COMBINATION 47 DAYS 242200500.00 8.3397
16 COMBINATION 48 DAYS 242276500.00 8.3371
 %
-18.7074
4.2611
4.2594
4.2602
4.2611
4.2627
4.2602
4.2619
4.2587
4.2603
4.2578
4.2595
4.2603
4.2603
4.2595
5.2178
-23.4633
4.2607
4.2582
4.2598
4.2607
4.2623
4.2615
4.2602
4.2583
4.2599
4.2591
0.4288
4.2599
4.2615
4.2591
5.2175
-0.0025

-0.0037 TRADE-OFFS
-0.0012 COMBINATION 1
-0.0037 COMBINATION 2
-0.0012 COMBINATION 3
-0.0050 COMBINATION 4
-0.0025 COMBINATION 5
-0.0037 COMBINATION 6
-0.0012
-0.0037
-0.0025 TRADE-OFFS
-0.0050 COMBINATION 1
-0.0025 COMBINATION 2
1.6603 COMBINATION 3
1.6629 COMBINATION 4
COMBINATION 5
COMBINATION 6
 CONSTRUCTABILITY SUBORDI
TRADE-OFFS UNITSINITIAL ESTIMATENATE %
COMBINATION 1DAYS 545 RANK
8.17 1.83
COMBINATION 2DAYS 595 7.48 2.52
COMBINATION 3DAYS 445 10.00
COMBINATION 4DAYS 551 8.08 1.92
COMBINATION 5DAYS 601 7.40 2.60
COMBINATION 6DAYS 451 9.87 0.13

STRUCTURAL SAFETY SUBORDI

TRADE-OFFS UNITSINITIAL ESTIMATENATE %
COMBINATION 1 MM 128.61 RANK
7.79 2.21
COMBINATION 2 MM 136.44 7.34 2.66
COMBINATION 3 MM 109.98 9.11 0.89
COMBINATION 4 MM 118.63 8.45 1.55
COMBINATION 5 MM 126.67 7.91 2.09
COMBINATION 6 MM 100.20 10.00
 IMPORTA
CONSTRAINTS NCE COMBINATION 1
FACTOR
CONSTRUCT 9 8.17
ECONOMIC 10 5.74
STRUCTURA 9 7.79
COMBINATION 1 COMBINATION 2 COMBINATION 3 COMBINATION 4 COMBINATION 5 COMBINATION 6

73.53 7.48 67.32 10 90 8.08 72.72 7.4 66.6 9.87

57.4 6.69 66.9 10 100 5.73 57.3 6.68 66.8 9.99
70.11 7.34 66.06 9.11 81.99 8.45 76.05 7.91 71.19 10
201.04 200.28 271.99 206.07 204.59
COMBINATION 6

88.83
99.9
90
278.73
 ECONOMIC

CONSTRU
ECONOMIC S SAFETY TRADE-OFFS
CTABILITY

SK 70000000.00 500.00 COMBINATION 1

WB 60000000.00 550.00 COMBINATION 2
SP 40000000.00 400.00 COMBINATION 3
S SHAPE 31000.00 14.00 COMBINATION 4
WIDE FLAN 32500.00 17.00 COMBINATION 5
I SHAPE 30000.00 21.00 COMBINATION 6
WIDE FLAN 32500.00 22.00 COMBINATION 7
HORIZONT 200000.00 6.00 COMBINATION 8
VERTICAL 275000.00 7.00 COMBINATION 9
BOLTED 100000.00 4.00 COMBINATION 10
WELDED 75000.00 5.00 COMBINATION 11
COMBINATION 12
COMBINATION 13
COMBINATION 14
COMBINATION 15
COMBINATION 16
1 COMBINATION 17
2 COMBINATION 18
3 COMBINATION 19
4 COMBINATION 20
5 COMBINATION 21
6 COMBINATION 22
7 COMBINATION 23
8 COMBINATION 24
9 COMBINATION 25
10 COMBINATION 26
11 COMBINATION 27
12 COMBINATION 28
13 COMBINATION 29
14 COMBINATION 30
15 COMBINATION 31
16 COMBINATION 32

CONSTRU
ECONOMIC CTABILITY S SAFETY COMBINATION 33
1
SK 70000000.00 2 COMBINATION 34
WB 60000000.00 3 COMBINATION 35
SP 40000000.00 4 COMBINATION 36
S SHAPE 31000.00 5 COMBINATION 37
WIDE FLAN 32500.00 6 COMBINATION 38
I SHAPE 30000.00 7 COMBINATION 39
WIDE FLAN 32500.00 8 COMBINATION 40
HORIZONT 200000.00 9 COMBINATION 41
VERTICAL 275000.00 10 COMBINATION 42
BOLTED 100000.00 11 COMBINATION 43
WELDED 75000.00 12 COMBINATION 44
13 COMBINATION 45
14 COMBINATION 46
15 COMBINATION 47
16 COMBINATION 48
 SUBORDINATE
UNITS INITIAL ESTIMATE
RANK
%
PHP 70361000 5.7327 4.2673
PHP 70336000.00 5.7348 4.2652
PHP 70361000.00 5.7327 4.2673
PHP 70411000.00 5.7287 4.2713
PHP 70363500.00 5.7325 4.2675
PHP 70338500 5.7346 4.2654
PHP 70438500.00 5.7264 4.2736
PHP 70413500.00 5.7284 4.2716
PHP 70362500.00 5.7326 4.2674
PHP 70337500.00 5.7346 4.2654
PHP 70437500.00 5.7265 4.2735
PHP 70412500.00 5.7285 4.2715
PHP 70365000.00 5.7324 4.2676
PHP 70365000.00 5.7324 4.2676
PHP 70440000.00 5.7263 4.2737
PHP 70446000.00 5.7258 4.2742
PHP 60361000 6.6825 3.3175
PHP 60336000.00 6.6852 3.3148
PHP 60436000.00 6.6742 3.3258
PHP 60411000.00 6.6769 3.3231
PHP 60363500.00 6.6822 3.3178
PHP 60338500.00 6.6850 3.3150
PHP 60413500.00 6.6767 3.3233
PHP 60413500.00 6.6767 3.3233
PHP 60362500.00 6.6823 3.3177
PHP 60337500.00 6.6851 3.3149
PHP 60412500.00 6.6768 3.3232
PHP 60062500.00 6.7157 3.2843
PHP 60365000.00 6.6820 3.3180
PHP 60340000.00 6.6848 3.3152
PHP 60440000.00 6.6737 3.3263
PHP 60446000.00 6.6731 3.3269

PHP 40361000.00 9.9938

0.0062
PHP 40336000.00 10.0000
PHP 40436000.00 9.9753 0.0247
PHP 40411000.00 9.9814 0.0186
PHP 40363500.00 9.9932 0.0068
PHP 40338500.00 9.9994 0.0006
PHP 40438500.00 9.9747 0.0253
PHP 40413500.00 9.9808 0.0192
PHP 40362500.00 9.9934 0.0066
PHP 40337500.00 9.9996 0.0004
PHP 40362500.00 9.9934 0.0066
PHP 40412500.00 9.9811 0.0189
PHP 40365000.00 9.9928 0.0072
PHP 40340000.00 9.9990 0.0010
PHP 40715000.00 9.9069 0.0931
PHP 40446000.00 9.9728 0.0272
 CONSTRU
ECONOMIC S SAFETY
CTABILITY

SK 70000000.00 500.00
WB 60000000.00 550.00
SP 40000000.00 400.00
S SHAPE 31000.00 14.00
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 17.00
I SHAPE 30000.00 21.00
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 22.00
HORIZONTAL 200000.00 6.00
VERTICAL 275000.00 7.00
BOLTED 100000.00 4.00
WELDED 75000.00 5.00

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

CONSTRU
ECONOMIC CTABILITY S SAFETY
1
SK 70000000.00 500.00 2
WB 60000000.00 550.00 3
SP 40000000.00 400.00 4
S SHAPE 31000.00 14.00 5
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 17.00 6
I SHAPE 30000.00 21.00 7
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 22.00 8
HORIZONTAL 200000.00 6.00 9
VERTICAL 275000.00 7.00 10
BOLTED 100000.00 4.00 11
WELDED 75000.00 5.00 12
13
14
15
16
ECONOMIC

SUBORDINATE
TRADE-OFFS UNITS INITIAL ESTIMATE
RANK
%
COMBINATION 1 DAYS 545 8.1651 1.8349
COMBINATION 2 DAYS 546.00 8.1502 1.8498
COMBINATION 3 DAYS 545.00 8.1651 1.8349
COMBINATION 4 DAYS 547.00 8.1353 1.8647
COMBINATION 5 DAYS 546.00 8.1502 1.8498
COMBINATION 6 DAYS 547 8.1353 1.8647
COMBINATION 7 DAYS 543.00 8.1952 1.8048
COMBINATION 8 DAYS 548.00 8.1204 1.8796
COMBINATION 9 DAYS 548.00 8.1204 1.8796
COMBINATION 10 DAYS 549.00 8.1056 1.8944
COMBINATION 11 DAYS 549.00 8.1056 1.8944
COMBINATION 12 DAYS 550.00 8.0909 1.9091
COMBINATION 13 DAYS 549.00 8.1056 1.8944
COMBINATION 14 DAYS 549.00 8.1056 1.8944
COMBINATION 15 DAYS 550.00 8.0909 1.9091
COMBINATION 16 DAYS 565.00 7.8761 2.1239
COMBINATION 17 DAYS 595.00 7.4790 2.5210
COMBINATION 18 DAYS 596.00 7.4664 2.5336
COMBINATION 19 DAYS 596.00 7.4664 2.5336
COMBINATION 20 DAYS 597.00 7.4539 2.5461
COMBINATION 21 DAYS 596.00 7.4664 2.5336
COMBINATION 22 DAYS 597.00 7.4539 2.5461
COMBINATION 23 DAYS 598.00 7.4415 2.5585
COMBINATION 24 DAYS 593.00 7.5042 2.4958
COMBINATION 25 DAYS 598.00 7.4415 2.5585
COMBINATION 26 DAYS 599.00 7.4290 2.5710
COMBINATION 27 DAYS 600.00 7.4167 2.5833
COMBINATION 28 DAYS 588.00 7.5680 2.4320
COMBINATION 29 DAYS 599.00 7.4290 2.5710
COMBINATION 30 DAYS 600.00 7.4167 2.5833
COMBINATION 31 DAYS 600.00 7.4167 2.5833
COMBINATION 32 DAYS 615.00 7.2358 2.7642

COMBINATION 33 DAYS 445.00 10.0000

COMBINATION 34 DAYS 446.00 9.9776 0.0224

COMBINATION 35 DAYS 446.00 9.9776 0.0224
COMBINATION 36 DAYS 447.00 9.9553 0.0447
COMBINATION 37 DAYS 446.00 9.9776 0.0224
COMBINATION 38 DAYS 447.00 9.9553 0.0447
COMBINATION 39 DAYS 447.00 9.9553 0.0447
COMBINATION 40 DAYS 448.00 9.9330 0.0670
COMBINATION 41 DAYS 448.00 9.9330 0.0670
COMBINATION 42 DAYS 449.00 9.9109 0.0891
COMBINATION 43 DAYS 448.00 9.9330 0.0670
COMBINATION 44 DAYS 450.00 9.8889 0.1111
COMBINATION 45 DAYS 449.00 9.9109 0.0891
COMBINATION 46 DAYS 450.00 9.8889 0.1111
COMBINATION 47 DAYS 457.00 9.7374 0.2626
COMBINATION 48 DAYS 465.00 9.5699 0.4301
 ECONOMIC CONSTRUCTABILITY

SK 70000000.00 22.20
WB 60000000.00 30.03
SP 40000000.00 3.57
S SHAPE 31000.00 19.10
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 13.60
I SHAPE 30000.00 17.30
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 13.80
HORIZONTAL 200000.00 37.01
VERTICAL 275000.00 30.03
BOLTED 100000.00 33.00
WELDED 75000.00 39.20

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
ECONOMIC CONSTRUCTABILITY 1
SK 70000000.00 22.20 2
WB 60000000.00 30.03 3
SP 40000000.00 3.57 4
S SHAPE 31000.00 19.10 5
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 13.60 6
I SHAPE 30000.00 17.30 7
WIDE FLANGE 32500.00 13.80 8
HORIZONTAL 200000.00 37.01 9
VERTICAL 275000.00 30.03 10
BOLTED 100000.00 33.00 11
WELDED 75000.00 39.20 12
13
14
15
16
ECONOMIC
TRADE-OFFS UNITS INITIAL ESTIMATE SUBORDINATE
RANK %
COMBINATION 1 MM 129 6.6197 3.3803
COMBINATION 2 MM 134.81 6.3153 3.6847
COMBINATION 3 MM 128.61 6.6197 3.3803
COMBINATION 4 MM 127.83 6.6597 3.3403
COMBINATION 5 MM 125.11 6.8049 3.1951
COMBINATION 6 MM 131 6.4836 3.5164
COMBINATION 7 MM 85.13 10.0000 0.0000
COMBINATION 8 MM 124.33 6.8472 3.1528
COMBINATION 9 MM 123.11 6.9155 3.0845
COMBINATION 10 MM 129.31 6.5839 3.4161
COMBINATION 11 MM 116.13 7.3306 2.6694
COMBINATION 12 MM 122.33 6.9591 3.0409
COMBINATION 13 MM 119.61 7.1178 2.8822
COMBINATION 14 MM 119.61 7.1178 2.8822
COMBINATION 15 MM 112.63 7.5584 2.4416
COMBINATION 16 MM 137.93 6.1721 3.8279
COMBINATION 17 MM 136.44 6.2397 3.7603
COMBINATION 18 MM 142.64 5.9685 4.0315
COMBINATION 19 MM 129.47 6.5757 3.4243
COMBINATION 20 MM 135.67 6.2752 3.7248
COMBINATION 21 MM 132.94 6.4040 3.5960
COMBINATION 22 MM 139.14 6.1186 3.8814
COMBINATION 23 MM 132.17 6.4414 3.5586
COMBINATION 24 MM 131.97 6.4511 3.5489
COMBINATION 25 MM 130.94 6.5018 3.4982
COMBINATION 26 MM 137.14 6.2078 3.7922
COMBINATION 27 MM 130.17 6.5403 3.4597
COMBINATION 28 MM 130.17 6.5403 3.4597
COMBINATION 29 MM 127.44 6.6803 3.3197
COMBINATION 30 MM 133.64 6.3704 3.6296
COMBINATION 31 MM 120.47 7.0670 2.9330
COMBINATION 32 MM 145.77 5.8404 4.1596
COMBINATION 33 MM 109.98 7.7411 2.2589
COMBINATION 34 MM 116.18 7.3280 2.6720
COMBINATION 35 MM 103.00 8.2651 1.7349
COMBINATION 36 MM 109.20 7.7958 2.2042
COMBINATION 37 MM 106.48 7.9956 2.0044
COMBINATION 38 MM 112.68 7.5556 2.4444
COMBINATION 39 MM 99.50 8.5558 1.4442
COMBINATION 40 MM 105.70 8.0540 1.9460
COMBINATION 41 MM 104.48 8.1486 1.8514
COMBINATION 42 MM 110.68 7.6922 2.3078
COMBINATION 43 MM 104.48 8.1486 1.8514
COMBINATION 44 MM 103.70 8.2093 1.7907
COMBINATION 45 MM 100.98 8.4311 1.5689
COMBINATION 46 MM 107.18 7.9434 2.0566
COMBINATION 47 MM 124.04 6.8636 3.1364
COMBINATION 48 MM 119.30 7.1359 2.8641
 CONSTRAINTS IMPORTANCE COMBINATION 1 COMBINATION 2 COMBINATION 3
FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 8.165138 73.48624 8.150183 73.35165 8.165138
ECONOMIC 10 5.732721 57.32721 5.734759 57.34759 5.732721
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 6.619727 59.57754 6.31527 56.83743 6.619727
190.391 187.5367

CONSTRAINTS IMPORTANCE COMBINATION 7 COMBINATION 8 COMBINATION 9

FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 8.195212 73.75691 8.120438 73.08394 8.120438
ECONOMIC 10 5.726414 57.26414 5.728447 57.28447 5.732599
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 10 90 6.847177 61.62459 6.915479
221.021 191.993

IMPORTANCE
CONSTRAINTS COMBINATION 13 COMBINATION 14 COMBINATION 15
FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 8.105647 8.105647 8.090909 72.81818 8.090909
ECONOMIC 10 5.732395 57.32395 5.732395 57.32395 5.726292
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 7.117846 64.06062 7.117846 64.06062 7.558442
129.4902 194.2028

IMPORTANCE
CONSTRAINTS COMBINATION 19 COMBINATION 20 COMBINATION 21
FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 7.466443 67.19799 7.453936 67.08543 7.466443
ECONOMIC 10 6.674168 66.74168 6.67693 66.7693 6.682184
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 6.575703 59.18133 6.275191 56.47671 6.403963
193.121 190.3314

CONSTRAINTS IMPORTANCE COMBINATION 25 COMBINATION 26 COMBINATION 27

FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 7.441472 66.97324 7.429048 66.86144 7.416667
ECONOMIC 10 6.682294 66.82294 6.685063 66.85063 6.676764
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 6.501779 58.51602 6.207834 55.87051 6.540341
192.3122 189.5826

IMPORTANCE
CONSTRAINTS COMBINATION 31 COMBINATION 32 COMBINATION 33
FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 7.416667 66.75 7.235772 65.12195 10
ECONOMIC 10 6.673726 66.73726 6.673064 66.73064 9.993806
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 7.066973 63.60276 5.840388 52.56349 7.741123
197.09 184.4161

IMPORTANCE
CONSTRAINTS COMBINATION 37 COMBINATION 38 COMBINATION 39
FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 9.977578 89.79821 9.955257 89.59732 9.955257
ECONOMIC 10 9.993187 99.93187 9.99938 99.9938 9.974653
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 7.995586 71.96027 7.555625 68.00062 8.555822
261.6903 257.5917

IMPORTANCE
CONSTRAINTS COMBINATION 43 COMBINATION 44 COMBINATION 45
FACTOR
CONSTRUCTABILITY 9 9.933036 89.39732 9.888889 89 9.910913
ECONOMIC 10 9.993434 99.93434 9.98107 99.8107 9.992816
STRUCTURAL SAFETY 9 8.148648 73.33783 8.209309 73.88378 8.431097
262.6695 262.6945
COMBINATION 3 COMBINATION 4 COMBINATION 5 COMBINATION 6

73.48624 8.135283 73.21755 8.150183 73.35165 8.135283 73.21755

57.32721 5.72865 57.2865 5.732518 57.32518 5.734555 57.34555
59.57754 6.659704 59.93734 6.804924 61.24431 6.483607 58.35246
190.391 190.4414 191.9211 188.9156

1 8.165138 5.732721
COMBINATION 9 COMBINATION 10 COMBINATION 11 COMBINATION 12
2 8.150183 5.734759
73.08394 8.105647 72.95082 8.105647 72.95082 8.090909 72.81818 3 8.165138 5.732721
57.32599 5.734637 57.34637 5.726495 57.26495 5.728528 57.28528 4 8.135283 5.72865
62.23931 6.583891 59.25502 7.330647 65.97582 6.95912 62.63208 5 8.150183 5.732518
192.6492 189.5522 196.1916 192.7355 6 8.135283 5.734555
7 8.195212 5.726414
8 8.120438 5.728447
COMBINATION 15 COMBINATION 16 COMBINATION 17 COMBINATION 18
9 8.120438 5.732599
72.81818 7.876106 70.88496 7.478992 67.31092 7.466443 67.19799 10 8.105647 5.734637
57.26292 5.725804 57.25804 6.682461 66.82461 6.685229 66.85229 11 8.105647 5.726495
68.02598 6.172055 55.54849 6.239684 56.15716 5.968466 53.71619 12 8.090909 5.728528
198.1071 183.6915 190.2927 187.7665 13 8.105647 5.732395
14 8.105647 5.732395
15 8.090909 5.726292
COMBINATION 21 COMBINATION 22 COMBINATION 23 COMBINATION 24
16 7.876106 5.725804
67.19799 7.453936 67.08543 7.441472 66.97324 7.504216 67.53794 17 7.478992 6.682461
66.82184 6.684952 66.84952 6.676653 66.76653 6.676653 66.76653 18 7.466443 6.685229
57.63566 6.118602 55.06742 6.441369 57.97232 6.451131 58.06018 19 7.466443 6.674168
191.6555 189.0024 191.7121 192.3647 20 7.453936 6.67693
21 7.466443 6.682184
22 7.453936 6.684952
COMBINATION 27 COMBINATION 28 COMBINATION 29 COMBINATION 30
23 7.441472 6.676653
66.75 7.568027 68.11224 7.429048 66.86144 7.416667 66.75 24 7.504216 6.676653
66.76764 6.715671 67.15671 6.682018 66.82018 6.684786 66.84786 25 7.441472 6.682294
58.86307 6.540341 58.86307 6.680347 60.12312 6.370419 57.33377 26 7.429048 6.685063
192.3807 194.132 193.8047 190.9316 27 7.416667 6.676764
28 7.568027 6.715671
29 7.429048 6.682018
COMBINATION 33 COMBINATION 34 COMBINATION 35 COMBINATION 36
30 7.416667 6.684786
90 9.977578 89.79821 9.977578 89.79821 9.955257 89.59732 31 7.416667 6.673726
99.93806 10 100 9.97527 99.7527 9.981441 99.81441 32 7.235772 6.673064
69.67011 7.327997 65.95197 8.265099 74.38589 7.795848 70.16263 33 10 9.993806
259.6082 255.7502 263.9368 259.5744 34 9.977578 10
35 9.977578 9.97527
36 9.955257 9.981441
COMBINATION 39 COMBINATION 40 COMBINATION 41 COMBINATION 42
37 9.977578 9.993187
 89.59732 9.933036 89.39732 9.933036 89.39732 9.910913 89.19822 38 9.955257 9.99938
99.74653 9.980823 99.80823 9.993434 99.93434 9.999628 99.99628 39 9.955257 9.974653
77.0024 8.053981 72.48583 8.148648 73.33783 7.692162 69.22946 40 9.933036 9.980823
266.3462 261.6914 262.6695 258.424 41 9.933036 9.993434
42 9.910913 9.999628
43 9.933036 9.993434
COMBINATION 45 COMBINATION 46 COMBINATION 47 COMBINATION 48
44 9.888889 9.98107
89.19822 9.888889 89 9.737418 87.63676 9.569892 86.12903 45 9.910913 9.992816
99.92816 9.999008 99.99008 9.906914 99.06914 9.972803 99.72803 46 9.888889 9.999008
75.87987 7.943364 71.49027 6.863572 61.77215 7.135864 64.22278 47 9.737418 9.906914
265.0062 260.4804 248.478 250.0798 48 9.569892 9.972803
6.619727
6.31527
6.619727
6.659704
6.804924
6.483607
10
6.847177
6.915479
6.583891
7.330647
6.95912
7.117846
7.117846
7.558442
6.172055
6.239684
5.968466
6.575703
6.275191
6.403963
6.118602
6.441369
6.451131
6.501779
6.207834
6.540341
6.540341
6.680347
6.370419
7.066973
5.840388
7.741123
7.327997
8.265099
7.795848
7.995586
7.555625
8.555822
8.053981
8.148648
7.692162
8.148648
8.209309
8.431097
7.943364
6.863572
7.135864
SUMMARY OF RESULTS OF COMBINATIONS

FRAMING COLUMN BEAM BRACING

280 254.08 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
280 254.08 261.82 Vertical 255.00
S-Shape I-Shape
280 254.08 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
280 254.08 261.82 Vertical 255.00
280 259.56 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
280 Wide 259.56 Wide 268.25 Vertical 255.00
Concen-trically 280 Flange 259.56 Flange 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
Braced 280 259.56 268.25 Vertical 255.00
Framing 280 254.08 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
System 280 254.08 Wide 268.25 Vertical 255.00
S-Shape
280 254.08 Flange 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
280 254.08 268.25 Vertical 255.00
280 259.56 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
280 Wide 259.56 261.82 Vertical 255.00
I-Shape
280 Flange 259.56 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
280 259.56 261.82 Vertical 255.00
170.92 254.08 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
170.92 254.08 261.82 Vertical 255.00
S-Shape I-Shape
170.92 254.08 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
170.92 254.08 261.82 Vertical 255.00
170.92 259.56 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
170.92 Wide 259.56 Wide 268.25 Vertical 255.00
Eccentrically 170.92 Flange 259.56 Flange 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
Braced 170.92 259.56 268.25 Vertical 255.00
Framing 170.92 254.08 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
System 170.92 254.08 Wide 268.25 Vertical 255.00
S-Shape
170.92 254.08 Flange 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
170.92 254.08 268.25 Vertical 255.00
170.92 259.56 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
170.92 Wide 259.56 261.82 Vertical 255.00
I-Shape
170.92 Flange 259.56 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
170.92 259.56 261.82 Vertical 255.00
121.75 254.08 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
121.75 254.08 261.82 Vertical 255.00
S-Shape I-Shape
121.75 254.08 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
121.75 254.08 261.82 Vertical 255.00
121.75 259.56 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
121.75 Wide 259.56 Wide 268.25 Vertical 255.00
Single Span 121.75 Flange 259.56 Flange 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
Rigid Steel
Framing
System
 Wide Wide
Single Span Flange Flange
Rigid Steel 121.75 259.56 268.25 Vertical 255.00
Framing 121.75 254.08 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
System 121.75 254.08 Wide 268.25 Vertical 255.00
S-Shape
121.75 254.08 Flange 268.25 Horizontal 263.08
121.75 254.08 268.25 Vertical 255.00
121.75 259.56 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
121.75 Wide 259.56 261.82 Vertical 255.00
I-Shape
121.75 Flange 259.56 261.82 Horizontal 263.08
121.75 259.56 261.82 Vertical 255.00
 CONNECTIONS TOTAL
Simple 255.00 1313.98
Simple 255.00 1305.90
Moment 247.78 1306.76
Moment 247.78 1298.68
Simple 255.00 1325.89
Simple 255.00 1317.81
Moment 247.78 1318.67
Moment 247.78 1310.59
Simple 255.00 1320.41
Simple 255.00 1312.33
Moment 247.78 1313.19
Moment 247.78 1305.11
Simple 255.00 1319.46
Simple 255.00 1311.38
Moment 247.78 1312.24
Moment 247.78 1304.16
Simple 255.00 1204.90
Simple 255.00 1196.82
Moment 247.78 1197.68
Moment 247.78 1189.60
Simple 255.00 1216.81
Simple 255.00 1208.73
Moment 247.78 1209.59
Moment 247.78 1201.51
Simple 255.00 1211.33
Simple 255.00 1203.25
Moment 247.78 1204.11
Moment 247.78 1196.03
Simple 255.00 1210.38
Simple 255.00 1202.30
Moment 247.78 1203.16
Moment 247.78 1195.08
Simple 255.00 1155.73
Simple 255.00 1147.65
Moment 247.78 1148.51
Moment 247.78 1140.43
Simple 255.00 1167.64
Simple 255.00 1159.56
Moment 247.78 1160.42
Moment 247.78 1152.34
Simple 255.00 1162.16
Simple 255.00 1154.08
Moment 247.78 1154.94
Moment 247.78 1146.86
Simple 255.00 1161.21
Simple 255.00 1153.13
Moment 247.78 1153.99
Moment 247.78 1145.91