Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A
pproximately 70 percent of
incarcerated women in America
How dog-assisted therapy can are responsible for a minor
child.1 This means 1.3 million children
improve inmates as mothers nationwide have a mother in jail or prison.
An at-risk population, female inmates
All content and images are copyrighted by ACA, 2018, and may not be reprinted,
24 — May/June 2018 Corrections Today
altered, copied, transmitted or used in any way without written permission.
The innovative use of therapy dogs has succeeded in are often innocent victims in a revolving criminal-justice
reducing trauma-induced feelings when one has difficulty door. Innovative programs are necessary to provide
trusting others because of dysfunctional, damaged or these inmates with emotionally supportive, jail-based
nonexistent early childhood attachments. This is particu- parenting skills that can be tested for their ability to help
larly important for female inmates who often have long restore damaged mother-child bonds, enhance family
histories of abuse/trauma. reunification, decrease recidivism and possibly reduce
intergenerational offending patterns.
What’s the solution?
Restoring mother-child bonds can result in behav- Therapy dogs
ioral and emotional benefits for both mothers and their Jail-based parenting programs can help mothers devel-
children. Hence, classes that target parenting skills are
4
op healthy bonds with their children by empowering them
essential, especially for jailed women, who traditionally to feel more confident about parenting, by increasing their
receive fewer programs than their counterparts in prison knowledge of effective parenting techniques and by pro-
and generally fewer programs than male inmates overall. moting a healthy parent-child relationship. These programs
Interventions for these women can be tremendously useful offer support and attempt to lessen the emotional effects
in helping to enhance their parenting skills and improve surrounding the mothers’ separation from their children.
their relationships with their children and/or children’s Significant data exist to demonstrate the psychologi-
caregivers. Unlike women in prison, jailed women’s cal benefits of utilizing dog-assisted support. Dogs can
separation from their children doesn’t last as long. The av- help mediate the relationship between adults that en-
erage state prison stay for American inmates is 4.5 years, ables more open and useful communication. In addition,
compared to a national average jail stay of six months.5 animal-assisted therapy (AAT) has numerous benefits
This is a great opportunity to provide a desperately needed by reducing stress; lessening anxiety; improving emo-
intervention for those who have shorter periods of absence tional well-being and behavior; decreasing depression;
from their children and from
the community.
Because jailed women’s
physical separation from their
children doesn’t last as long,
they can bring the skills they
learn to their home environment
sooner. Their stays are often so
brief, it is difficult to find women
who are there long enough to
complete an entire program,
but this does not mean suc-
cessful interventions cannot be
accomplished. It does require in-
novation with time management,
Photo courtesy Federal Bureau of Prisons
lowering blood pressure, heart rate and perceived feelings (AATL), and female inmates at both facilities who com-
of loneliness; and enhancing communication and reading plete the same evidence-based parenting program without
skills, all while raising the perceived quality of overall AATL. Staging the study in this way (control groups first)
health.6 Correctional departments have been using some enabled a more sensitive and knowing process for devel-
form of animal-based programming with varying degrees opment of the AATL version of the parenting curriculum
of success for years.7 Preliminary results for inmates are and for preparing the therapy dog teams. This process
encouraging; they are correlated with increasing self- takes into account — in a lesson-by-lesson manner —
worth and confidence,8 increasing social skills, decreasing the hurdles inmates face as they strive to overcome issues
infractions,9 and increasing engagement, specifically to of trust, emotional integrity and learning challenges.
help female inmates become more open to therapeutic It also delineates specific protocols during each class
participation.10 lesson for utilizing human and canine members of the
therapy-dog teams to support the inmates in overcoming
those hurdles.
The partnership The partnership modeled its pilot program after the
With a two-year development, implementation and evidence-based Parenting Inside Out (PIO) curriculum,
approval phase, Pace University partnered with the Met- which dramatically decreased depression, lowered sub-
ropolitan Correctional Center (MCC); the Westchester stance abuse, increased parental participation, enhanced
County Department of Correction (WCDOC); and The parenting skills, reduced parental stress and reduced re-
Good Dog Foundation, a nationally recognized, nonprofit cidivism (study participants were less likely to have been
leader in therapy-dog team training and deployment (all rearrested, with a rearrest rate of 27 percent compared to
are located in New York). The Parenting, Prison, & Pups a rate of 48 percent for nonparticipants).11 The first two
program weaves together a best-practice, jail-based par- control groups (parenting without AATL), concluded
enting curriculum with the activities of specially trained at MCC in spring 2017 and WCDOC in fall 2017 with
therapy dogs and their handlers, who are licensed men- promising results, which are discussed below.
tal health professionals. Utilizing a pretest and posttest, Normally, inmates have very constricted access to
quasi-experimental design, the partnership also evaluates their children while in prison. Thus, in the test groups
the differences between female inmates housed at MCC (those with the dog-therapy teams), interaction with the
and WCDOC who complete an evidence-based parent- dogs will provide a more real-world, high-impact learn-
ing program with animal-assisted therapy and learning ing practice (HILP), which will not be available to control
known to facilitate
rehabilitative outcomes,
even in prison
The second control group was held at WCDOC in measures (i.e., anxiety, stress, parental stress and self-
fall 2017. Most measures did not prove to be statistically esteem), they were not statistically significant. Many of
significant; however, the women at WCDOC presented these women were not in contact with their children, with
with many more issues and problems, such as lengthier some prevented from having contact via child protective
criminal histories, when compared to the federally orders. As a point of comparison, only one woman at the
incarcerated women. Thirteen women began the parent- federal facility was prevented from having contact with
ing class at WCDOC and 10 completed. The majority her son through a child protective order.
of participants were women of color, with 40 percent
identifying as African American (n=4), 10 percent as La-
tina (n=1), and one woman (10 percent) who identified as
biracial. Approximately 80 percent had a family history of Because jailed women’s
incarceration, and while 30 percent were incarcerated for
a specific drug charge, the remainder of the women were physical separation from
incarcerated for a charge related to their drug use (i.e., their children doesn’t last
fraud, grand larceny, petty larceny or DUI). Participants,
on average, had three children, and none of the women as long, they can bring
were married. In comparison to the federal women, who
had an average of four arrests during their lifetime (half
the skills they learn to their
of them were arrested for the first time on their current home environment sooner
charge), the county women had an average of 24 arrests,
with the majority reporting over ten arrests during their
lifetime; six women reported more than 20 arrests. Ad-
ditionally, where the majority of the federal women were In general, 64 percent of the women from WCDOC
the primary caregivers of their children prior to arrest, felt the class provided them with enhanced parenting
the majority of the county women were not the primary skills. Many of these women commented that since they
caregivers of their children prior to arrest. Data from this were not responsible for raising their own children, they
group demonstrated a statistically significant decrease in found this information very useful, particularly since they
depression, and although there were changes in the other all planned to try to reconnect with one or more of their
children upon release.
Six women reported that
communication was the
most effective skill that
they learned, with eight
women reporting that
these skills helped to im-
prove their relationship
with family members
and nine women said
it helped to improve
Photo courtesy Federal Bureau of Prisons
following parenting class lessons, the classes set aside listen. What are the best ways to handle a
10 to 15 minutes before and after their time frame for non-cooperative partner during the communica-
unstructured human-animal interaction. → tion process?
Class 4: Effective Problem-Solving Skills Class 6: The Child’s Job and the Parent’s Job
This class focuses on the steps needed to effectively This class examines the developmental stages of
solve a problem. Although problems will not always be childhood. Students will also examine the developmental
solved, utilizing these steps improves one’s chances for stages of a dog and how to have appropriate expectations
solving them. Real-life situations with dogs will serve as for behavior based on the age of the dog. For example,
an example of how to solve problems systematically: do you have patience to allow your dog to explore with
–– You are going on vacation; who will take care its nose? Do you have patience to allow your toddler to
of your dog? explore with his/her hands and mouths? How do we allow
–– Your dog is ill or eats a bad substance; what them both to explore safely? Dogs, like children, experi-
do you do? ence the world in a way that adults do not; they are low to
–– Your child keeps missing curfew; how do you the ground and see things differently. They are individual,
deal with it? sentient beings but rely on adults to take care of them.
–– The women in your unit are always fighting; Can we see/understand from their perspective?
how do you handle it?
Regardless of the problem, one can always utilize the Class 7: Directions and Encouragement
same steps in their process of problem-solving. This class focuses on how to provide effective di-
rections and encouragement. Training dogs to behave
Class 5: Bonding Through Play and Reading: requires giving effective directions consistently and
Child-Centered Play providing encouragement through rewards. It will ask the
This class examines the differences between child- questions: Why do we need guidance and structure with
centered play and adult-directed play. How does one dogs, and why do we need it with children?
play with their dog? What does the dog want to do? How
can we respect and understand that it is important to take Class 8: Rules, Rewards and Consequences
the dog’s needs, as well as our children’s needs, into This class focuses on logical and natural consequences
consideration, even during play activity? If literacy skills and rewards. It will explore how to use natural and logical
are an issue, inmates may increase their confidence for consequences for children by first using dogs as a model.
reading to their children by practicing reading to one of For example, if the dog runs away, it could get lost or hurt
the dogs — a successful method of assisting people with (a natural consequence). After this, it may always be on a
reading difficulties. leash when outside from then on (a logical consequence).
Pace students also took part in some of the fun of Evidence of the deliciousness of the cake made especially
Reunification Day. for the class graduates.