Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Be Learned?
Samir Abuznaid
Executive Summary
Religion has a major impact on human behavior, social interactions, and social rela-
tions. This research article discusses the impact of Islam on managers’ behavior. The
impact is exerted from the five pillars of Islam: faith, prayer, alms, fasting, and pil-
grimage. From the article, it is evident that such pillars have a direct effect on Moslems’
behavior. Besides that, the article shows the significant impact of Allah supreme names
on managers’ behavior and style. Allah names have a direct interrelationship with
management functions like planning, organizing, and directing. A Moslem manager,
in fact, can use Allah supreme names as a guide to his management style and action.
Finally, the article sheds light on major Islamic management principles and their
effect on managers’ behavior and perception. © 2006 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
INTRODUCTION
Religion has a great and direct impact on human behavior, social interactions,
and social relations. In fact, religion might influence the political and educational
system of any society. Concerning this, Weber (1964) pointed out that “the reli-
gious determination of life conduct, however, is also one, not the only one of the
determinants of the economic ethic. Of course, the religiously determined way
of life is itself profoundly influenced by economic and political factors operating
within given geographical political, social and national boundaries” (p. 268).
Dr. Samir Abuznaid, associate professor of management and organization at Hebron University,
West Bank, where he established the School of Finance and Management in 1994, and has taught
business at An-najah University Nablus, West Bank for eleven years. He has given lectures in Pales-
tine, United States, United Kingdom, France, Spain, Italy, Jordan and Germany, and is the recipi-
ent of several rewards and honors . Most recently he was selected as a Fulbright scholar where
he had to teach cross-cultural management courses at Portland Community College, Portland, Ore-
gon, USA (sameerz@hebron.edu).
This article is divided into four major sections. The first section
attempts to give a thorough description of the major pillars of Islam.
The second section deals with economic prosperity, as well as the
main practices of managers as their way of belief. The third section
discusses the main managerial themes in Islam. The final section
examines the impact of Allah Almighty names on management
behavior and actions.
MEANING OF ISLAM
Every religion of the world has been named either after the name of its
founder or after the community and nation in which that religion took
its birth. For instance, Christianity takes its appellation from the name
of its prophet, Jesus Christ, and Judaism, from the name of the tribe
Judah, where it was born. This is also true of other religions. But not
so with Islam (Maududi, 1980, p. 9), which has been described by
Weber as the religion of world-conquering warriors, a knight order of
disciplined crusaders (Weber, 1964, p. 279). Islam is not associated
with any particular person or group. It does not convey any such rela-
tionship, for it does not belong to any particular person, people, or
country. Neither it is the product of any human mind or confined to Islam is an Ara-
any particular community. Islam, as a matter of fact, is an attributive bic word connot-
title. Whosoever possesses this attribute, may he or she belong to any ing submission,
race, community, country, or clan, is a Moslem (Maududi, 1980, p. 9). surrender, and
obedience.
WHO IS A MOSLEM?
Islam is built on five pillars. They are the testimony of faith, prayer, alms,
fasting, and pilgrimage to the city of Makkah. These pillars of Islam will
be treated in some detail due to their importance, as they are practiced
daily by Moslems and therefore affect Moslems’ daily behavior.
Faith (Al-Shahadatan)
Faith is summarized in the two confessions: “There is no God but
Allah, Mohammed is His messenger.” It is belief in one God, the cre-
ator. Mohammed is the last of all prophets and has brought to man
the final revelation that God has for them (Tritton, 1966, p. 23). It
is believed that faith makes the believer dedicate his life to one God,
Allah, and pleasing others, such as the boss, becomes secondary.
Prayer (Salah)
Moslems pray five times a day; at dawn, at noon, in the afternoon,
after sunset, and after dark. It seems that this timing is intended to
avoid any suggestion of worshipping the sun. The prayers differ in
their length and section. The Morning Prayer has two sections, the
noon four, the afternoon four, the sunset three, and the night four.
Moslems pray
five times a day; On the festivals the feast of sacrifice (Eid al-Adha) and the ending of
at dawn, at the fast (Eid al-Fitr), the sermon follows the prayer, in contrast to
noon, in the Friday prayer, in which the two sections are preceded by the sermon
afternoon, after (Qutb, 1982, p. 85). It is believed that prayer affects managers in sev-
sunset, and after eral ways:
dark.
1. Prayer makes managers better at time management and being
organized. From prayer, managers learn to become better and
more prompt.
2. Prayer makes practitioners look nice and in good uniform with
good smell.
3. The prayer element has forced businesses to allocate mosques
in their facilities for worship; in addition, it allows workers to
halt production for the sake of making prayer.
Alms (Az-zakat)
Legal alms or obligatory charity would be better names for this insti-
tution. Clear distinction should be made between Az-zakat and alms.
Az-zakat is an ordinance prescribed by the laws. Charity, on the other
hand, is voluntary. It cannot be imposed by the law or by order of
rulers (Tritton, 1966, pp. 15–26). Az-zakat is a tax collected and dis-
tributed among the poor by the state and not by the rich people, so
that a poor man can maintain his dignity by not taking Az-zakat from
other people. Almsgiving is thought to be the religious and social
responsibility of managers.
Fasting (Siyam)
Fasting begins during the daytime, starting from the time it is possi-
ble to distinguish a white thread from a black one until the sunset.
The believer must abstain from food, drink, carnal intercourse, smok-
ing, and even chewing gum. Children, pregnant women, the sick,
aged, and travelers are excused (Tritton, 1966, p. 26). Fasting lasts
for a whole month (Ramadan).
These are the five pillars of Islam. From this, it is becoming clear that
religious convictions influence practically every act during each
moment in life.
The issue of Islam and economic prosperity has been the subject of
discussion by many writers. It has caught the attention of Moslems
and non-Moslems, the economists and the historians, the sociologists
and the anthropologists. The literature reveals that some of these
scholars are sympathetic toward Islam by arguing that nothing in
Islamic teaching and traditions is opposed to the adoption of modern
and progressive economic methods (Adams, 1976, p. 29). Others, on
the contrary, have endeavored to show that Islam forbids those who
hold it to engage in any fruitful economic endeavors, thus dooming
them to stagnation (Rodinson, 1974, p. 2). Indeed, since the publi-
cation of Weber’s “The Protestant Sects and the Spirit of Capitalism,”
many writers and academicians have agreed that Islam is in fact the
main impediment to economic and industrial development in the
…many writers Arab world (Bendix, 1960, pp. 103–116).
and academi-
cians have Others went even further to blame all economic backwardness in the
agreed that Arab world on Islam and its teaching. Contrary to these claims is that
Islam is in fact of Rodinson, who argues that Islamic teaching and Koranic values are
the main impedi- not antiethical either to capitalism or to socialism (Rodinson, 1974,
ment to eco- p. 13). Another scholar, Robert, confirmed that trade and business
nomic and activities have always had a significant place in the minds of Moslems
industrial devel- (Robert, 1982, pp. 145–152).
opment in the
Arab world. However, it is beyond the scope of this article to indulge in the sub-
ject of Islam and capitalism or Islam and socialism. Rather, it aims to
present a general overview of the various business practices that are
allowed or prohibited in Islam. It is believed that such discussion will
help clarify some of the misconceptions about Islam and its responsi-
bilities either for economic prosperity or backwardness in the Arab
and Moslem world.
fact, in the Moslem world, the code of conduct is absent in many orga-
nizations. As a result, managers and laborers believe that the ethical
part of their lives comes from the inside and is something more per-
sonal. In the Arab world, it is believed that employees, not manage-
ment, can force self-discipline, or what is called holy work.
Global financial
institutions are MANAGERIAL THEMES IN ISLAM
starting to adopt
some Islamic While nobody can claim that Islam provides a comprehensive theory
themes in their in management, nevertheless one cannot ignore a set of general
dealings in order guidelines that could be applied to management. These guidelines
to meet the can be easily detected in the Koran and the sayings and deeds of the
needs of their prophet Mohammed. Since the Koran is a comprehensive book that
Moslem clients. is concerned with all aspects of human life, the existence of such
guidelines is inevitable and natural. Chiefly concerned with the orga-
nization of human activities and the regulation of individual and
group responsibilities, these guidelines are aimed at the realization of
individual and group interest, without prejudicing the other. Need-
less to say, Islam provides a very delicate balance between the rights
and duties of both individuals and groups (e.g., the state). According
to the Islamic doctrine, the individual has certain rights and freedoms
that are God-given and cannot be denied or violated. Such rights
include the right to live, the right to have the basic amenities of life,
and the right to be safe and secure. However, the rights of individu-
als and their duties and responsibilities toward themselves and their
immediate and forward society at large are inextricably entwined.
The individual’s rights should not be at the expense of society’s rights
and vice versa.
It is an established fact, however, that Islam is, at the same time, reli-
gion and state, right and might, mosque and school; in brief, it is a
comprehensive system that regularizes all walks of life and good to
each time and place.
Consultation (Al-Shura)
Consultation is an immensely important Islamic principle governing
the administration and management of public interest. The prophet
Mohammed himself was instructed by God to consult with his com-
panions about various matters affecting the group. The following
132 Thunderbird International Business Review • DOI: 10.1002/tie • January–February 2006
Islam and Management: What Can Be Learned?
Koranic verse describes how the relation between the leader and the
subordinates should be: “It is part of the mercy of God that thou
dost deal gently with them: wert thou severe or harsh-hearted, they
would have broken away from about thee. So pass over their faults,
and ask for God’s forgiveness for them, and consult them in affairs
(of moment). Then when thou has taken a decision, put trust in God,
for God loves those who put their trust in him” (Holy Koran, 3:159). Islam urges
Al-Gufeili (1983) has described Islamic management as consultative Moslems to be
management. constantly mind-
ful and aware of
The merit of consultation in management, as well as in other God’s observa-
spheres of collective activities, cannot be overestimated. Consulta- tion of them.
tion enhances the spirit of solidarity between employees and their
managers.
Honesty (Sidk)
Honesty is the soul of every endeavor. Islam urges Moslems to be
constantly mindful and aware of God’s observation of them. In his
approach to the study of Islamic management, Al-Gufeili (1983) has
characterized Islamic management as management of one’s self and
ethic.
Employees in all spheres and all people at large ought to do the right
thing, not simply because it is expedient for them but because doing
otherwise would be a disobedience to God. The Koran describes
those who forget God as transgressors and warns them against the
hellfire.
Firmness (Al-Hazm)
Firmness is necessary if one is to carry out responsibilities and execute
instruction efficiently and effectively. Islam considers any slackness or
negligence in carrying out one’s tasks and responsibilities, especially
public trust, a great sin against God and His Messenger. The Koran
admonishes believers not to be treacherous by not keeping their
One of the trusts. However, firmness should not be at the expense of fairness.
names of Allah is
the merciful, the Mercy (Al-Rahmah)
compassionate. One of the names of Allah is the merciful, the compassionate.
Moslems ought to be merciful and beneficent, too. Mercy, however,
cannot be treated in isolation, but should rather be considered in the
context of other principles of work. Excess leniency could be as harm-
ful as excessive injustice. In Islam, management pays attention to the
psychological needs, soul needs, and material needs of mankind.
ever may have to be done”, and he went out and collected the fire
wood from the jungle.
Setting an Example
As an Islamic leader, one should be pragmatic. He should think of
himself as a model. In the field, he should be the first to take up
responsibilities. Being an example should be manifested in the
leader’s behavior in his dealing with others. A good example of this
is the role of the prophet Mohammed in collecting the wood and his
role in digging up a trench and in fighting in the battlefield. A leader
in Islam should set an example to those under his supervision practi-
cally and theoretically (Dohohayan, 1991, pp. 151–158).
Thunderbird International Business Review • DOI: 10.1002/tie • January–February 2006 135
Samir Abuznaid
Planning
God the Almighty has the best, greatest, highest, and most honorable
names, which he gave to himself and ordered. He should not be
called and named by other names that are not mentioned in the
sharia to avoid attributing to him meanings unfitting for his highness
and greatness.
Motivator
Allah is called the provider (Al-Razzaq) (e.g., “For Allah is He who
gives [all] sustenance, Lord of power, steadfast for ever [Holy Koran,
51:58] and “Allah doth enlarge, or grant by strict measure the suste-
nance” [Holy Koran, 13:26]).
CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES
Abusin, A. (1984). Management in Islam. Sudan House for Books: Al-Khartoum, Sudan
(Arabic).
Adams, C. J. (Ed.). (1976). Islamic religious traditions. In L. Binder (Ed.), The study of the
Middle East: Research and scholarship in the humanities and social sciences (pp. 29–95). New
York: Wiley.
Al-Gufeili, I. (1983). An Islamic approach to the study of management. Al Mansura Univer-
sity: Cairo, Egypt.
Ata, I. (1984). The impact of Westernizing and other factors on the changing status of Moslem
women. Eastern Anthropologist, 37(2), 95–126.
Bendix, R. (1960). Max Weber: An intellectual portrait. New York: Doubleday.
Dohohayan, A. R. (1991). Islamic administration and government: Thought and practice.
Saudi Arabia.
ITN News. (1987). November 1987.
Maududi, A. A. (1980). Towards understanding Islam. Nottingham, UK: Islamic Mission.
Prothro, E. T., & Melikian. (1952, September). Social distance and social change in the Near
East. Sociology and Social Research, 37, 10.
Qutb, M. (1982). Islam: The misunderstood religion. Lahore: Islamic Publications Ltd.
Rand, E. J. (1967, February). Learning to do business in the Middle East. The Conference
Board Records, Vol. 13.
Robert, D. S. (1982). Islam: A Westerner’s guide. Middlesex, UK: Hamlyn Publishing.
Rodinson, M. (1974). Islam and capitalism. Suffolk, UK: Chaucer Press.
Sharabi, H. (1979). In the path of God. In D. Pipes (Ed.), Islam and political power. New
York: Basic Books.
Tritton, A. S. (1966). Islam: Beliefs and practices. London: Hutchinson.
Weber, M. (1961). The social psychology of the world religions. In H. H. Gerth & C. W. Mills
(Eds. and trans.), From Max Weber: Essays in sociology (pp. 267–301). London: Routledge
and Kegan Paul.