Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Conducted by:
Icha Balqis Iswanto and Huda Maulida
Advisor:
Tarich Yuandana, S. Pd., M. Pd
ABSTRACT
Language generally is defined as a means of communication in social
life. Language is not only used an instrument of communication but also as a
means of individual society language is not instinctive. Along with research,
the writer arises these questions as research problems: 1. Is there are any
differences in how Javanese ethnic people use Surabaya dialect to the
younger, same age and older person in Surabaya? 2. Is there are any
differences in how Javanese ethnic people use Tuban dialect to the younger,
same age and older person in Tuban? 3. How do Javanese ethnic people use
Surabaya dialect and Tuban dialect Spoken to Younger, Same Age and Older
Addressee in Indonesia? This research used the descriptive qualitative method
with four steps; they were recording the data, transcribing the data, organizing
the data, and summarizing or interpreting the findings. The result of the
research showed that a difference between Surabaya dialect and Tuban dialect
is spoken to younger, same age and older addressee in Indonesia is very
visible. A level of status level from Surabaya cannot be equated with the
status of the Tuban level.
Keyword: Surabaya Dialect, Tuban Dialect, Addressee in Indonesia
INTRODUCTION
Indonesia is an archipelago that consists of many islands, and on each island, it
certainly has a culture such as Batak culture, Balinese culture, Madura culture, Javanese
culture, etc. In each culture must have their respective language. Each island in
Indonesia certainly has a different culture and language, and that depends on the
geography of each region. Such as cited in article (Durahman et al., 2019) Indonesia has
560 local languages along with their own dialects, one of them is Javanese language.
Dialect is known as the varieties of how local people use their language for
formal or informal speech. According to (Chaer, 2010) dialect is a language variation of
certain speakers that different from one area to another. In Javanese, it is known as
krama inggil and krama (formal) and ngoko (informal). Meanwhile, language is known
to be the superordinate category and the standard variety of a language, or the main
language known in every single person in one place (Wardhaugh & Fuller, 2015). For
example, the Surabaya dialect and the Tuban dialect have different languages, even
though it is a province of East Java.
In our conversations we have some problems because of language, the language
in general, is determined as a communication tool in social life. Language is not only
used as a communication tool but also as a means of individual society. Language is not
instinctive. All humans use language to be used with others in society. Language
variation has more than one variation, especially in the way of speaking. This means
that various regions, social classes, and educational backgrounds can cause a variety of
languages. Therefore, Indonesia has many different regional languages, such as
Javanese, Batak, Papuan, etc.
The most famous regional language is Javanese. Javanese language is famous
for Java island which is the largest island that has many island communities, it is not
surprising that many people we meet come from Java, because of the wide spread of
Javanese communities who migrate to meet various reasons. Javanese also has different
dialects in each province and each province. For example, in the area of East Java
Province, the language used by Surabaya and Tuban people has a very big difference.
Surabaya is the capital of the East Java Province, Indonesia, as well as the
largest metropolitan city in the province. Surabaya has its own language, Javanese
Suroboyoan or better known as Suroboyoan (Javanese language Suroboyoan) and the
Arekan language is a Javanese dialect spoken in Surabaya and its surroundings. The
dialect that is developed and used by some of the people of Surabaya and surrounding
areas. Structurally, Suroboyoan can be said as the harshest Javanese language.
While Tuban is one of the districts in East Java, located on the North Coast of
East Java. Tuban has used Javanese with various levels such as the language of krama
inggil and krama (formal) and ngoko (informal). The language used by the Surabaya
language is very far away, where the language used by Tuban people is much more
subtle than the Surabaya language. When Surabaya people meet with Tuban people will
definitely have difficulty in communicating, because Surabaya people will feel the
language used by Tuban people is too smooth, and Surabaya people prefer to use
national language when talking to Tuban people because they want to respect in
communication because they cannot understand Tuban language well.
(Fadillah, 2018) Knowing that Surabaya is in east java, people in Surabaya also
known as Javanese people who are unique because they are barely use the Javanese
language in three level of politeness. The language in Javanese which is called ngoko
are the best-known language in Surabaya because it is the easiest to be understood and
has a closer meaning o the Indonesia language. Surabaya language with a finer level is
still used by some Surabaya people, as a form of respect for others. However, the use of
Javanese refined (Krama) among the Surabaya people is mostly not as smooth as in
Tuban.
Most researchers analyze tentang dialect such as (Durahman et al., 2019)
Javanese Lexical Variation of Cirebon Dialect in Pabuaran and Ciperna Region; and
(Sibarani et al., 2016) Dialect Geography of Batak Toba Language Variation; (Ansar,
2016) Affix In Sentence Pattern of Indonesia-Makassarese Dialect; (Kartikasari et al.,
2018) A Study of Dialectology on Javanese “Ngoko” in Banyuwangi, Surabaya,
Magetan, and Solo; (Andika & Abdullah, 2019) Phonological Interference in Javanese
Language of Banyumas Dialect in Family Domain in Purwokerto; (Siregar, 2017) The
Influence of Dialect on The Student’s Pronunciation in Speaking Ability; (Malihah,
2017) The Applicative Constructions in Javanese Dialect of Kudus; (Setiawan, 2015)
International Journal of Linguistics, Literature and Culture; and (Aini, 2015)
Linguistic Analysis on Javanese Language Selogudig-An Dialect in Selogudig,
Pajarakan, Probolinggo.
However, there are several articles and dissertation that related to this topic from
(Fadillah, 2018) Cina-Surabaya Dialect Spoken to Younger, Same Age, and Older
Addressee in Surabaya which discusses the way ethnic Chinese use Chinese-Surabaya
as a dialect produced by them to talk to younger, the same age, and older recipients.
Looking at the differences in how Chinese-Surabaya dialects are used for age
differences, the research problem is the difference in how ethnic Chinese people use
Chinese-Surabaya dialects and how Chinese-Chinese dialects use Chinese-Surabaya
dialects to speak for age differences. In this case, the writer is interested to conduct an
analysis, the writer wants to know “The differences between Surabaya Dialect and
Tuban Dialect Spoken to Younger, Same Age and Older Adrresse in Indonesia.”
Where these two regions are in one province but this area has a dialect difference, when
speaking and gives a greeting to someone who is easier, the same age and older.
RESEARCH QUESTION
Along with research, the writer arises these questions as research problems:
1. Is there are any differences in how Javanese ethnic people use Surabaya dialect to the
younger, same age and older person in Surabaya?
2. Is there are any differences in how Javanese ethnic people use Tuban dialect to the
younger, same age and older person in Tuban?
3. How do Javanese ethnic people use Surabaya dialect and Tuban dialect Spoken to
Younger, Same Age and Older Addressee in Indonesia?
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Language
Language generally is defined as a means of communication in social life. (Aini,
2015) stated that language is not only used an instrument of communication but also as
a means of individual society language is not instinctive. All human being use
languages to interact with other person in the society. As a form of language variation,
each language has more than one variety, especially in the way in which it is spoken. It
means that the various regions, social class, and educational background may cause a
variety of a language. It also influenced someone when used addressee terms to speak
with younger, same age, and older people (Fadillah, 2018).
Dialect
Dialect is known as the varieties of how local people use their language for
formal or informal speech. According to (Chaer, 2010) dialect is a language variation of
certain speakers that different from one area to another. In Javanese, it is known as
krama inggil and krama (formal) and ngoko (informal). Meanwhile, language is known
to be the superordinate category and the standard variety of a language, or the main
language known in every single person in one place (Wardhaugh & Fuller, 2015).
Wardaugh (Wardhaugh & Fuller, 2015) also classifies dialect into two types;
regional dialect and social dialect. Regional dialect is a dialect based on geographical
location while social dialect is a dialect related to some factors such as social class,
religion, or ethnicity. However, this study limited only to differences between Surabaya
dialect and Tuban dialect when spoken to younger, same age, and older addressee.
Previous Study
Related to differences between dialects spoken by people in the Javanese
language, there are several types of research that also define about that phenomenon.
The first research is by Khalis Fadillah (2018) entitled Cina-Surabaya Dialect Spoken
to Younger, Same Age, and Older Addressee in Surabaya. This research focused on the
way Tionghoa ethnic people used Cina-Surabaya as the dialect produced by them to
speak to a younger, same age, and older addressee using the descriptive qualitative
method to identify its linguistic features. The result of the research is that there are
differences of how Tionghoa ethnicity people in Surabaya uses Cina-Surabaya dialect
on how they say something to someone younger, same age, and older. The distinctive
features also show on how they differentiate the title in calling the same ethnicity and
different ethnicity person they are talking. The differences between this research and
Khalis’ research is that this article not only identifies about one dialect variety in talking
with the same ethnicity or different etnicity with the, but also two different dialect in
different ethnicitity, which are Surabaya and Tuban.
Avika Dwi Cahyaningsih and Erlita Rusnaningtias (2015) also also write an
article about dialect variations entiled The Lexical Differences in the Javanese Varieties
Spoken by People in the Western and Eastern parts of Blitar Regency. This research
focuses on the lexical differences found in the Javanese varieties spoken by people in
the western and eastern parts of Blitar Regency and to determine the status of the lexical
differences using qualitative and quantitative method. The findings of this study show
that therea are some glosses and lexical differences which mostly occur due to the
different geographical conditions of the observation points. Also, some of the
observation points compared have the status of different subdialects; while some others
have the status of different dialects. Briefly, the Javanese varieties spoken by people in
the western and eastern parts of Blitar Regency are different dialects. The differences
between this research and Avika and Erlita’s is that this article not only focuses about
dialect varieties spoken in two different areas, but also identifies the differences
between two different dialect when spoken to a younger, same age, and older addressee.
Another research is written by Daniel Craube (2017) entitled The Javanese
Language of Surabaya among Young Speakers: A Sociolinguistic Case Study. This
research focuses on a variety of dialect spoken by younger in Surabaya. The result of
this study show that originally only a limited number of polite words found its way into
Surabayan Javanese. Besides, in recent time, even less polite words have been used
young speakers are often not aware of the correct usage of polite vocabulary. This
research also revealed that most young Surabayan Javanese speakers hardly understand
more than 100 polite words. The differences between this article and Daniel’s is that
this article identifies the differences between two different dialet when spoken to a
younger, same age, and older addressee while Daniel’s is identifies only the variations
among dialect among young speakers.
In addition to the phenomena happened from Surabaya dialect and Tuban
dialect, this research may be able to show differences on how people in Surabaya and
Tuban use the dialect from their each region for younger, same age, and older
addressee. The result of this research may help sociolinguistics studies on Surabayan
and Tubanese to elaborate the way Surabaya and Tuban dialect expressed as their
unvarying and beliefs. This research is not only identified linguistics patterns produced
by people in their area which had been investigated on the previous research, but also
the formality and differences of Surabaya dialect and Tuban dialect concerning the use
of it for different age of the addressee.
REFERENCES
Aini, L. N. (2015). Linguistic Analysis on Javanese Language Selogudig-An Dialect in
Selogudig, Pajarakan, Probolinggo. Jurnal Ilmiah Bahasa Dan Sastra, 2(2).
https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107415324.004
Andika, Y., & Abdullah, W. (2019). PHONOLOGICAL INTERFERENCE IN
JAVANESE LANGUAGE OF BANYUMAS DIALECT IN FAMILY DOMAIN. 4,
219–227.
Ansar, F. A. (2016). Affix In Sentence Pattern of Indonesia-Makassarese Dialect.
English Education: Jurnal Tadris Bahasa Inggris IAIN Raden Intan, 9(2), 308–326.
https://doi.org/10.24042/ee-jtbi.v9i2.378
Durahman, E. utami, Sofiyani, D., Pratiwi, Y. A., & Setiani, F. (2019). Javanese Lexical
Variation of Cirebon Dialect in Pabuaran and Ciperna Region. Teknosastik, 17(2),
32. https://doi.org/10.33365/ts.v17i2.303
Fadillah, K. (2018). Cina-Surabaya Dialect Spoken to Younger, Same Age, and Older
Addressees in Surabaya. Lingua Cultura, 12(3), 273.
https://doi.org/10.21512/lc.v12i3.4072
Kartikasari, E., Laksono, K., Savitri, A. D., & Suryarini, D. Y. (2018). A Study of
Dialectology on Javanese “Ngoko” in Banyuwangi, Surabaya, Magetan, and Solo.
Jurnal Humaniora, 30(2), 128. https://doi.org/10.22146/jh.v30i2.29131
Malihah, N. (2017). The Applicative Constructions in Javanese Dialect of Kudus.
Parole - Journal of Linguistics and Education, 6(1), 18–27.
https://doi.org/10.14710/parole.v6i1.12537
Setiawan, I. (2015). Social Dialect Variations in Sasak Monolingual Society: A Lingual
Critical Study. International Journal of Linguistics, Literature and Culture, 1(1), 1.
https://doi.org/10.21744/ijllc.v1i1.101
Sibarani, T., Sibarani, R., Sembiring, M. C. A., & Hasibuan, N. H. (2016). Dialect
geography of batak toba language variation. Quest Journal: Journal of Research in
Humanities and Social Science, 4(12), 94–98.
Siregar, S. (2017). The Influence Of Dialect on The Student’s Pronunciation in
Speaking Ability. 5(1), 27–36.