Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ergonomics
To cite this article: Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, Charles Ikechukwu Ezema & Chinenye
Kosisochukwu Nwosu (2016): Job Stress Dimension and Work-related Musculoskeletal
Disorders among Southeast Nigeria Physiotherapists, International Journal of Occupational
Safety and Ergonomics, DOI: 10.1080/10803548.2016.1219476
Download by: [Stephen F Austin State University] Date: 04 August 2016, At: 06:04
Page 1 of 9
Publisher: Taylor & Francis & Central Institute for Labour Protection – National Research Institute
(CIOP-PIB)
Journal: International Journal of Occupational Safety and Ergnomics
DOI: 10.1080/10803548.2016.1219476
Title: Job Stress Dimension and Work-related Musculoskeletal Disorders among Southeast Nigeria
Physiotherapists
Authors: Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu,* Charles Ikechukwu Ezema, Chinenye Kosisochukwu
Nwosu.
Affiliation (all authors): Department of Medical Rehabilitation, University of Nigeria, Enugu Campus,
Nigeria
* Corresponding author
Correspondence: Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, Department of Medical Rehabilitation University of
Downloaded by [Stephen F Austin State University] at 06:04 04 August 2016
studies have also shown that physiotherapists are more susceptible than other health care providers to
these conditions because of their labor-intensive tasks.[8] The practice of physiotherapy is physically
demanding because it requires the therapist to perform repetitive tasks and use high force manual
techniques on patients. Such techniques exert direct pressure on specific joints of the physiotherapist,
require awkward positioning of the therapist’s joints during certain maneuvers, and demand prolonged,
constrained postures [9].
This study investigated aspects of job stress and their relationship to musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) in
southeast Nigerian physiotherapists because the very high prevalence of MSDs in this population has
implications for the healthcare system in southeast Nigeria. The purpose of the study was to examine the
relationship between WMSDs and psychological job demands (or work-related stress) in southeast
Nigeria physiotherapists. Findings could guide the characterization of different dimensions of job stress
southeast physiotherapists experience and enabling tailored macro-ergonomic interventions to reduce
WMSDs in the physiotherapists.
Downloaded by [Stephen F Austin State University] at 06:04 04 August 2016
2. Methods
This was a cross-sectional survey conducted in hospitals (teaching, general, private, and government)
across the 5 states of southeast Nigeria. All licensed physiotherapists currently practicing physiotherapy
in southeast geo-political zone of Nigeria were invited to participate. A purposive sampling technique was
used so as to recruit only fully licensed physiotherapists, whether full or part time, working in both the
private and government sectors in southeast Nigeria.
This study used two questionnaires that investigated demographics, job content, and MSDs. The first
questionnaire was the Job Content Questionnaire (JCQ),[10] which was used to measure the dimensions
of job stress. This has been widely used to measure the social and psychological structure of the work
situation, with the reliability index of 0.63–0.86. [11,12] As the questionnaire was intended to be used
among clinical health professionals, 30 relevant items, covering the core set of items, from the full
version of the JCQ [10] were included following example from a previously publish research among
Iranian nurses.[13] The items are grouped into nine scales as follow: decision latitude (9 items),
psychological job demands (5 items), social support (8 items), physical job demands (5 items) and finally
job insecurity (3 items). Each item was scored based on a 4-point scale ranging from 1 = strongly
disagree or never to 4 = strongly agree or often. The scale calculations were performed in accordance to
the JCQ User’s Guide .[12] The second questionnaire was the Nordic questionnaire, designed by
Kuorinka et al., [14] which was used to examine reported cases of WMSDs among the study population.
Ethical approval was obtained from the Ethics and Research Committee of University of Nigeria
Teaching Hospital, Enugu. All participants signed the informed consent form applicable to the research
before being enrolled in the study and receiving the questionnaires.
completed. After a maximum of 4 weeks, the second authors or the research assistants personally
collected the completed questionnaires.
2.2. Data Analysis
The results were analyzed using SPSS version 20. The prevalence of MSDs was reported in frequency
and in percentages, while the mean and standard deviation of job stress dimensions were reported
according to criteria in the JCQ.[10] The Mann–Whitney U test was used to assess association between
job stress dimensions and reported MSD symptoms. In all tests, p ≤ 0.05 was considered significant at a
95% confidence interval.
3. Results
The records of the five eastern Nigerian state chapters of the Nigeria Society of Physiotherapy indicated
that at the time of the study, 176 fully registered physiotherapists were working in the five southeastern
states. 59 physiotherapists did not participate due to reasons ranging from less than 12 months of work
experience as fully registered physiotherapists (n = 36), on annual leave (14), away from work for a
Downloaded by [Stephen F Austin State University] at 06:04 04 August 2016
4. Discussion
The results showed that southeast Nigeria physical therapists experience high levels of physical demand
of job stress and moderate levels of psychological stress. The 82.1% prevalence of MSD symptoms
reported in this study indicates high prevalence of MSD symptoms. A similar prevalence has been
reported by Adegoke et al. [15] in Nigeria (91.3%), Cromie et al. [16] in Australia (91%), Glover et al. [5]
in the UK (68%), Salik&Ozcan [17] in Turkey (85%), suggesting that physiotherapists in general have a
high risk of MDS.
Lower back pain was the most common MSDs reported, followed neck pain. These findings accord with
the results described by Adegoke et al. in Nigeria.[15] Also, several researchers in the UK, [5] Kuwait,
[18] the USA, [19] Canada [20] also show a higher prevalence of MSDs in the lower back
inphysiotherapists. Based on these findings, one may infer that physiotherapists are exposed to risk
factors more associated with WMSDs affecting the lower back and neck.
Page 4 of 9
This study, the first study in Nigeria that examines different psychosocial job dimensions associated with
WMSDs among physiotherapists, showed that although job demand, particularly physical job demand, is
high among the physiotherapists, psychological stress is moderate. The southeast Nigeria physiotherapists
felt they had the control over their job, enjoyed good social support, and therefore had low levels of job
insecurity. Because no national data concerning psychosocial job dimensions among occupational groups
in Nigeria exists, it is not possible to compare the results from this study to a national average. That
notwithstanding, Ibikunle et al.[21] reported that about 40% of Nigerian physiotherapists see their jobs as
stressful but did not provide dimensions for stress factors. Okwaraji and Aguwa[22] reported a high level
of burnout and psychological stress among Nigerian nurses, but this is not a fair comparison with our
research due to the dissimilarity of studies in tool and design used as well as population studies. However,
the results of this study show that compared with their counterparts in the USA, physiotherapists in
southeast Nigeria had higher physical demands but similar job control.[23] Similar to the physiotherapists
we studied, Iranian nurses reported high levels of physical and psychological demands; however they had
Downloaded by [Stephen F Austin State University] at 06:04 04 August 2016
low job security, job control and social support [13] unlike our respondents. The high level of physical
job demand in these workers is a concern because of its established relationship to poor health and work
outcomes. [3,4] Interestingly, the southeast Nigeria physiotherapists studied had good job control and
security as well as social support. The implication is that job control and security as well as the social
support enjoyed by the physiotherapists compensates for the physical stress associated with the
profession. Therefore, the results suggest that job stress in southeast Nigeria physiotherapists is related
more to physical than psychological factors.
In this study, a high level of physical demand was not associated with WMSDs. This is a rather surprising
finding because physical demand has been well documented as responsible for WMSDs in many
occupational groups, [24,25] including physiotherapists .[23] We had expected this association in the
light of the high prevalence of WMSDs in the physiotherapists. Perhaps another factor, not considered in
this study, is confounding the expected association between physical demand and WMSDs. Regardless,
the inability to compare our group of physiotherapists with a group of healthcare providers whose job
entails high physical load (such as nurses) who did not have WMSDs or reported low physical demand
makes it difficult to draw conclusions from these data.
The results showed no association in physiotherapists between psychological demand and WMSDs in any
of the body regions. This is also surprising because psychological job demands have been found to be
significantly associated with WMSDs among many occupational groups. [13, 24,26] This finding may
suggest higher than usual tolerance to psychological stress in physiotherapists in southeast Nigeria who
constantly face harsh psychological situations, as shown by their psychological stress score. It could also
mean that because WMSDs are very prevalent among this group, the possible association may have been
obscured.
Jones and Bright [27] described job control as employees' control over their tasks and how those tasks are
executed. High levels of decision latitude (job control) had no association with MSDs among the
physiotherapists. This contrasts with the results of Bugajska et al. [26] in which increased control showed
a statistically significant decrease in the risk of carpal tunnel syndrome ((p = 0.037). Campo et al.,[23]
Brazideh et al.,[13] and Skov et al.,[28] also reported that among physical therapists in America, nurses in
Iran, and sales people in Denmark respectively low levels of decision latitude (job control) were related to
WMSDs. The high decision latitude (job control) reported among physiotherapists in our study indicates
that southeast Nigeria physiotherapists have excellent control in execution of work related tasks.
Levels of job insecurity had no association with WMSDs among the physiotherapists, a finding which
disagrees with the reports of Lee et al.[24] among long-haul international female flight attendants, in
which showed an association between high levels of job insecurity and lower-back WMSDs. The low
level of job insecurity reported among southeast Nigeria physiotherapists may suggest a decreased burden
among this group and the may explain the dissociation between WMSDs and job insecurity.
5. Limitation
The particular limitation of the present study is the same size in light that no scientific derivation was
employed in determining the minimum sample. This was not possible in light of the not too large
Page 5 of 9
population of the physiotherapists studied. Therefore a total sampling was deemed a best fit for a better
representation. Secondly, our design being cross-sectional could not establish causality between job stress
dimensions and WMSDs. Future studies should explore prospective design in studying this relationship in
this population.
6. Conclusions
The prevalence of work related MSDs among physiotherapists in southeast Nigeria is high. Physical and
psychological job demands are prevalent among these physiotherapists, but job stress is related more to
physical than psychological factors. In any case, the job stress dimensions are not associated with MSDs
among the physiotherapists. Interventional programs should be organized to prevent MSD symptoms in
the study population, and efforts made to reduce psychological and physical job demands at the
workplace. Importantly, there is a need for ergonomic guidelines for the clinical practice of physiotherapy
in Nigeria. Such guidelines can contribute to a reduction to of risk factors for MSDs and reduce the
prevalence of this condition. Further studies with a larger sample size, and more encompassing variables
Downloaded by [Stephen F Austin State University] at 06:04 04 August 2016
assessment including analysis of specific task variables are recommended. Although our respondents are
representative of Nigeria in terms of gender distribution of physiotherapists,[29] future studies should
include the entire country so that wider age and years of practice distribution could give a more inclusive
evidence regarding all physiotherapists in Nigeria.
References
1. De Souza Magnago TS, Lisbou MTL, Griep RH, et al. Psychosocial aspects of work and
musculoskeletal disorders in nursing workers: Rev Latino Am Enfermagem. 2010;18(3):429-35.
2. Park J.R, Coombs C, Wilkinson J, et al. Attractiveness of physical therapy in the National
Health Service as a career choice: qualitative study. Physiotherapy. 2003;89:575-583.
3. Krause N, Ragland DR, Fisher JM, Syne SL. Psychosocial job factors, physical workload and
incidence of work-related spinal injury: a 5-year prospective study of urban transit operators.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 1998;23 (23):2507-2516.
4. Head J, Kivimäki M, Martikainen P, et al.Influence of change in psychosocial work
characteristics on sickness absence: the Whitehall II study: J Epidemiol Community Health.
2006;60(1):55-61.
5. Glover W, McGregor A, Sullivan C, Hague J. Work-related musculoskeletal disorders affecting
members of the Chartered Society of Physiotherapy. Physiotherapy. 2005;91(3):38-147.
6. National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion Division of Population Health:
Glossary Terms. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/workplacehealthpromotion/tools-
resources/glossary/glossary.html#W4. Updated on December 5, 2015. Accessed on 20th February
2016.
7. Al-Eisa E, Buragadda S, Shaheen AAM, et al. WSDs: causes, prevalence and response among
Egyptian and Saudi Arabian physiotherapists: Middle East J Sci Res. 2012;12(4):523-529.
8. Cromie JE, Robertson VJ, Best MO. Occupational health and safety in physiotherapy:
guidelines for practice. Aust J Physiother. 2001; 47(1):43-51.
9. Kogi K, Kawakami T, Itani T, Batino JM. Low-cost work improvement that can reduce the risk
of musculoskeletal disorders.Int J Ind Ergon. 2003;31:179-184.
10. Karasek RA. Job Content Questionnaire and user’s guide. Lowell (MA): University of
Massachusetts; 1985.
11. Karasek R, Brisson C, Kawakami N, Houtman I, Bongers P, Amick B. The Job Content
Questionnaire (JCQ): An instrument for internationally comparative assessments of
psychosocial job characteristics. J Occup Health Psychol.1998;3(4):322-355.
Page 6 of 9
12. Karasek R, Choi BK, Ostegren PO, Ferrario M, De Smet P. Testing two methods to create
comparable scale scores between the job content questionnaire (JCQ) and JCQ-like
questionnaires in the European JACE study. Int J Behav Med. 2007;14(4):189-201.
13. Brazideh M, Choobineh AR, Tabatabee HR. Job stress dimensions and their relationship to
musculoskeletal disorders in Iranian nurses. Work. 2014; 47(4)423-429.
14. Kuorinka I, Jonsson B, Kibom A, et al. Standardised Nordic questionnaires for the analysis of
musculoskeletal symptoms. Appl Ergon. 1987;18(3): 233-237.
15. Adegoke B, Akodu AK, Oyeyemi AL. Work-related musculoskeletal disorders among
Nigerian physiotherapists: BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2008; 9:112.
16. Cromie JE, Robertson VJ, Best MO.Work-related musculoskeletal disorders in physical
therapists: prevalence, severity, risks, and responses. Phys Ther. 2000;80(4):336-351.
17. Salik Y, Ozcan A.Work-related musculoskeletal disorders: a survey of physical therapists in
Downloaded by [Stephen F Austin State University] at 06:04 04 August 2016
Table 3: Mean scores of the prevalent job stress dimensions among the physiotherapists(n = 126)
Job stress dimension M (SD) Range Range attainable
Physical demand 3.63 (0.55) 1–4 1–4
Decision latitude 74.18(11.53) 28–92 24–96
Skill discretion 37.16(5.91) 16–48 12–48
Table 4: Association between job stress dimensions and musculoskeletal disorders in at least one body
region.
12-month prevalence 7-day prevalence
Yes No (n = 22) p ≤ 0.05 Yes (n = 28) No p
(n = 101) (n = 95)
Job stress dimension Mean rank scores Mean rank scores
Physical demands 60.83 59.05 0.791 64.44 59.35 0.414
Downloaded by [Stephen F Austin State University] at 06:04 04 August 2016
Note: Missing values are evident as physiotherapists did not respond to certain items.
p ≤ 0.05 was considered significant