Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Background The work required to assist individuals in improving their mental health is stressful and known to be
associated with burnout. In Japanese companies, non-medical occupational health (OH) staff often
take the role of maintaining and improving workers’ mental health. However, few studies have exam-
ined burnout in this population.
Aims To assess the relationship between burnout and occupational stressors among non-medical OH
staff.
Methods We conducted a cross-sectional study of OH staff who had participated in mental health seminars
between 2016 and 2018. Occupational stressors were assessed using the Japanese version of the Job
Content Questionnaire. Burnout was assessed using the Japanese version of the Maslach Burnout
Inventory.
Results We administered the survey to 230 non-medical OH staff, of which 188 completed the question-
naire. According to a hierarchical multiple linear regression analysis, high job demands were asso-
ciated with greater emotional exhaustion, depersonalization and personal accomplishment. Greater
job control was associated only with higher personal accomplishment. Lower job support was asso-
ciated with greater emotional exhaustion and depersonalization.
Conclusions The present study found relationships between occupational stressors and burnout dimensions
among OH staff. To avoid burnout among non-medical OH staff, it is important to take measures
against occupational stressors, especially job demands and low levels of job support.
Key words Burnout; occupational health staff; occupational stressors.
© The Author(s) 2019. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Society of Occupational Medicine.
All rights reserved. For Permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oup.com
46 OCCUPATIONAL MEDICINE
who belong to the personnel departments and have no We distributed a self-report questionnaire to 263 OH
healthcare training and are not qualified as health staff. staff members whose work primarily involved mental
Non-medical OH staff are charged with maintaining and health and who were participating in mental health
improving the mental health of workers in a given organ- seminars between 2016 and 2018. These seminars are
ization, which they often must perform alongside other conducted in accordance with the curriculum pub-
types of work (e.g. choosing people for jobs, dealing with lished by the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare,
employees’ complaints or problems and so on). In many and include mental health issues such as formulation of
cases, the scope of their work is too broad and the work- mental health plans, response to mental illness, support
load too high. Among their duties are: health promotion, for returning to the workplace and improvement of the
providing employees education on mental health, stress workplace environment. Participants in these seminars
awareness and coping methods; management of stress; applied through a voluntary online application. They in-
establishing consultation systems to connect with spe- clude both non-medical OH staff and medical OH staff
cialists; and supporting workers in being reinstated. (including nurses, such as mental health nurses or public
Given the scope of their duties, non-medical OH staff health nurses) belonging to the company. A total of eight
must often engage in emotional labour, much like med- such seminars were held during this period. Data from
ical mental health staff. However, compared with medical 33 medical OH staff were excluded from the analysis be-
staff, non-medical OH staff tend to have less knowledge cause we wanted to focus on non-medical OH staff in
of mental health and have poorer coping methods, and this study. After participants with incomplete responses
also have greater stigma regarding mental illness [9]. As were excluded (valid response rate 82%), 188 staff were
a result, they may be exposed to numerous occupational included in the analysis.
stressors but lack the ability to adequately cope with All participants gave informed consent to participate
these stressors. Therefore, it is reasonable to assume that as volunteers and understood that there was no penalty
they may have a higher risk of burnout. for choosing not to participate. The study design was ap-
The relationship between occupational stressors and proved by the Human Subjects Review Committee of
burnout has been extensively studied among medical Osaka City University (authorization number: 1409). All
staff. However, this relationship has rarely been explored data were stored only in our database. Participants’ em-
among non-medical OH staff. Moreover, there is little in- ployers did not have access to the data and did not know
formation on the levels of the burnout dimensions in this who participated in the study.
group. We, therefore, investigated levels of burnout (and The demographic variables measured were age, gender
its dimensions) among non-medical OH staff and clari- and marital status (single or married). Work-related vari-
fied their relationship with occupational stressors. Based ables included months of experience and occupation.
on prior studies among mental health professionals, we The Job Content Questionnaire (JCQ) was designed
hypothesized that high levels of occupational stressors to measure work environment characteristics based on
would be associated with more severe burnout among the demand–control–support model [10,11]. In this
non-medical OH staff. Furthermore, we studied each di- study, we used the Japanese version of the JCQ (JCQ-
mension of burnout in relation to occupational stressors. J) to assess occupational stressors. The reliability and
validity of the JCQ-J for assessing job stressors among
Methods Japanese employees are excellent [12]. The questionnaire
comprises four scales: job demand (5 items), job control
We used a cross-sectional design to examine the rela- (9 items), supervisory support (4 items) and co-worker
tionship between occupational stressors and burnout. support (4 items). The job demand items relate to the
Y. OKUDA ET AL.: BURNOUT AND OCCUPATIONAL STRESSORS 47
speed of completing work, the degree of difficulty of the of work experience were entered in step 1, and JCQ-J
work, the amount of work, the time given to complete the scales were entered in step 2, with controls for the vari-
work and the presence of conflicting demands. The job ables from step 1. The regression analysis was conducted
control scale measures decision-making authority, task in line with the National Institute for Occupational
variety and personal freedom on the job. The support Safety and Health stress model [16]. Differences were
scales contain items evaluating support from supervisors considered significant at P < 0.05. All statistical analyses
and co-workers. The items are rated on a four-point were conducted using SPSS Statistics v24.0 software
Likert-type scale ranging from 1 (‘strongly disagree’) to (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA).
4 (‘strongly agree’). The item scores were weighted and
summed to create scale scores. The weights were set ac-
cording to the JCQ user’s guide [12]. A high job demand Results
score and low scores for the other three subscales were Table 1 shows the participants’ characteristics and de-
considered to indicate more stressors. The Cronbach’s scriptive results of the JCQ-J and MBI. The average age
Table 1. Demographic variables, Job Content Questionnaire (JCQ) scores and Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI) scores by gender
Mean ± SD
*P < 0.05, **P < 0.01.
Table 2. Spearman correlations between Job Content Questionnaire (JCQ) scores and Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI) scores
1 2 3 4 5 6
1. Job demand –
2. Job control 0.09 –
3. Supervisory support −0.09 0.30*** –
4. Co-worker support −0.23** 0.24** 0.62** –
5. Emotional exhaustion 0.36*** −0.15* −0.44*** −0.43** –
6. Depersonalization 0.27*** −0.18* −0.48** −0.45** 0.68** –
7. Reduced personal accomplishment −0.15* −0.39*** −0.17* −0.18* 0.16* 0.16*
depersonalization and increased personal accomplish- mental health seminars might have higher awareness of
ment scores on the MBI. Higher job control scores were mental health than the general population of OH staff.
associated with increased personal accomplishment and Furthermore, the causal relationship between occupa-
higher supervisory and co-worker supports were associ- tional stressors and burnout could not be determined
ated with lower emotional exhaustion and depersonaliza- because of the cross-sectional nature of the study design.
tion. Although we hypothesized that higher occupational Longitudinal studies with a larger sample and the use of
stressors (i.e. high job demands, low job control and low diagnostic interviews for burnout should be conducted
social support) would be associated with more severe to confirm our conclusions.
burnout, the results of this study showed that occupa- Regarding the risk of burnout, a study with Japanese
tional stressors were associated with each burnout di- consultation support specialists showed the prevalence
mension independently and with different patterns. of high-risk burnout. Tao and Kubo, who created the
The strengths and limitations of this study are dis- Japanese version of the MBI used in this study, defined
cussed below. This study is among the first to explore the the criteria for a high-risk group on each dimension [17].
association between occupational stressors and burnout Using these criteria, consultation support specialists had
among non-medical OH staff in Japan. Therefore, our a risk of 2% on emotional exhaustion, 0% on deperson-
findings can provide suggestions for reducing risk of alization and 3% on reduced personal accomplishment
burnout among non-medical OH staff. However, use of [18]. When these criteria were applied to the prevalence
self-report questionnaires and selection bias limits the of high-risk burnout in our study (data not shown),
generalizability of the findings. The selection bias derives prevalence rates were 2% on emotional exhaustion,
from the fact that OH staff who voluntarily participate in 7% on depersonalization and 8% on reduced personal
Y. OKUDA ET AL.: BURNOUT AND OCCUPATIONAL STRESSORS 49
Table 3. Hierarchical multiple linear regression analysis of Job Content Questionnaire (JCQ) scores and Maslach Burnout Inventory
(MBI) scores
β β β β β β
Step 1: adjusted for gender, age, marital status (reference category: single) and months of work experience.
Step 2: adjusted for occupational stressors and job strain ratio.
*P < 0.05, **P < 0.01.
accomplishment, which were higher than those reported individually, which makes comparison difficult. However,
by Hatano [18]. when high job control occurs in conjunction with high
Higher JCQ-J job demands scores were associated job demands, it is hypothesized that if employees are able
with higher emotional exhaustion and depersonaliza- to deal with these demands, they receive protection from
tion scores on the MBI. Emotional exhaustion and de- excessive stressors, which fosters feelings of learning and
personalization are considered the core dimensions of mastery, and leads to positive states, such as personal ac-
burnout [19]; there is a general consensus that both of complishment [25]. Therefore, job control might buffer
these dimensions must be included in the measurement against burnout among non-medical OH staff.
of burnout [20]. An increase in job demands was sig- When the associations between these occupational
nificantly related to both greater emotional exhaustion stressors and the three dimensions of burnout are taken
and depersonalization among care providers in oncology together, results of this study showed that higher job de-
wards [21], in a study of nurses [22] and in volunteer mand is associated with more severe scores on the core
ambulance officers [23]. Findings were the same in our dimensions of burnout (emotional exhaustion and de-
study. It is therefore assumed that the relationship be- personalization), and higher social support (supervisory
tween job demands and the two core burnout dimen- and co-worker support) has an opposite association with
sions is strong regardless of occupation. these core dimensions and thus might serve as a buffer
Non-medical OH staff who received more support effect on the severity of burnout. Further, higher job de-
from co-workers and supervisors experienced less emo- mand and higher job control were associated with in-
tional exhaustion and depersonalization. One study in- creased personal accomplishment. A state of having high
dicated that support from a supervisor buffered against job demand and high job control simultaneously is called
emotional exhaustion and depersonalization, which an active job state in Karasek’s job demand–control
were both aggravated by organizational change-related model. This state is hypothesized to lead employees to
stressors among Canadian healthcare staff [24]. Thus, to positive states, such as motivation and personal accom-
prevent burnout among non-medical OH staff, we need plishment [25]. This combination may increase personal
to focus on reducing job demands and increasing sup- accomplishment in non-medical OH staff.
port from co-workers and supervisors, which in turn may The current findings provide suggestions for inter-
improve the two core dimensions of burnout. ventions. Interventions targeting burnout can be cat-
Non-medical OH staff who reported higher job con- egorized into person-directed and organization-directed.
trol scores tended to have greater personal accomplish- Person-directed interventions include participating in
ment scores as well. However, few previous studies have psychological workshops such as mindfulness [26] and
explored job control and personal accomplishment stress management training [27]. Attending seminars or
50 OCCUPATIONAL MEDICINE
training regarding mental health designed to develop an 6. Sullivan PJ. Occupational stress in psychiatric nursing. J
understanding of mental health might assist in preventing Adv Nurs 1993;18:591–601.
burnout. The majority of organization-directed interven- 7. Melchior ME, Bours GJ, Schmitz P, Wittich Y. Burnout in
tions involve workload or schedule changes designed psychiatric nursing: a meta-analysis of related variables. J
Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs 1997;4:193–201.
to prevent burnout. In 2019, the Japanese parliament
8. Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare. Workplace Safety
enacted a Work Style Reform law aimed at drastically
[Internet]. Tokyo: Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare.
changing the way people work [28]. This law includes http://anzeninfo.mhlw.go.jp/yougo/yougo87_1.html (14
implementing a cap on overtime work to redress long February 2019, date last accessed).
working hours. This will help to prevent work-related 9. Kingdon D, Sharma T, Hart D et al. What attitudes do psy-
illnesses including burnout. The effectiveness of com- chiatrists hold towards people with mental illness? Psychiatr
bining several interventions such as fostering communi- Bull 2004;28:401–406.
cation aimed at increasing social support or cultivating 10. Karasek R, Brisson C, Kawakami N, Houtman I, Bongers P,
a sense of teamwork and job control was also reported Amick B. The Job Content Questionnaire (JCQ): an in-
24. Day A, Crown SN, Ivany M. Organisational change and 28. Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare. Outline of the Act on
employee burnout: the moderating effects of support and the Arrangement of Related Acts to Promote Work Style Reform
job control. Saf Sci 2017;100:4–12. (Act No. 71 of 2018). https://www.mhlw.go.jp/english/policy/
25. Karasek R, Robert A, Theorell T. Healthy Work: Stress, employ-labour/labour-standards/dl/201904kizyun.pdf (19
Productivity, and the Reconstruction of Working Life. New September 2019, date last accessed).
York, NY: Basic Books, 1990. 29. Linzer M, Poplau S, Grossman E et al. A cluster randomized
26. Guidetti G, Viotti S, Badagliacca R, Colombo L,
trial of interventions to improve work conditions and clin-
Converso D. Can mindfulness mitigate the energy- ician burnout in primary care: results from the Healthy Work
depleting process and increase job resources to prevent Place (HWP) Study. J Gen Intern Med 2015;30:1105–1111.
burnout? A study on the mindfulness trait in the school 30. Imamura K, Kawakami N, Tsuno K et al. Effects of
context. PLoS One 2019;14:e0214935. web-based stress and depression literacy intervention on
27. West CP, Dyrbye LN, Erwin PJ, Shanafelt TD. Interventions improving work engagement among workers with low work
to prevent and reduce physician burnout: a systematic re- engagement: an analysis of secondary outcome of a ran-
view and meta-analysis. Lancet 2016;388:2272–2281. domized controlled trial. J Occup Health 2017;59:46–54.