Republic of the Philippines
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
MINES AND GEOSCIENCES BUREAU
Cordillera Administrative Region
80 Diego Silang St., Baguio City 2600
Tel. No. 63 74 442 6392; Fax No. 63 74 304 2596; Website: yn car.mgb.gov.ph
E-mail: car@mgb.gov.ph; car_mgb@yahoo.com; mgb.cordillera@gmail.com
November 21, 2019
HON. BENSMAR B. LIGWANG
Municipal Mayor
Kabugao, Apayao
Sir:
As per your request, attached herewith is the report entitled “Ocular Geologic
Investigation Conducted on an Area Affected by Typhoon Quiel and Monsoon Rains
at Poblacion, Kabugao, Apayao" by Jelson Fitzgerald D. Edduba, Geologist
We hope that the result of the investigation would satisfy the purpose of your request
and we appreciate the opportunity to be of service to you.
Very truly yours,
OIC, Regional Director $4¥*
cy = reese res
Sanaa
AVN HA tt
MGB-CAR-FO-FAD-DCC-001 0 (08.24.18)
“MINING SHALL BE PRO-PEOPLE AND PRO-ENVIRONMENT
IN SUSTAINING WEALTH CREATION AND IMPROVED QUALITY OF LIFE.”
Office of the Regional Director/Finance and Administrative Division - 63 74 442 6392; ICT - 63 74 661 7685; Geosciences
Dhvsion/Laboratory Section 63 74 304 2500; Mine Management Division - 63 74 304 3068 (Monitoring and Technical Services
Section/Mining Tenement Evaluation/Mineral Lands Survey Section); Mine Safety Environment and Social Development Section - 63,
74304 2595; Social Development Section/Environment Section 63 74 304 2530Republic of the Philippines
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
MINES AND GEOSCIENCES BUREAU
Cordillera Administrative Region
80 Diego Siang St., Baguio City 2600
Tel. No, 63 74 442 6392; Fax No. 63 74 304 2596; Website: wnw.car.mgb gov ph
E-mail: car@mgb.gov.ph; car_meb@ yahoo.com; mgb.cordillera@gmail.com
November 18, 2019 name inant ft Fees
2 ee
MEMORANDUM ato
al Au UN
FOR ray w. apie TY ee
OIC, Regional Director sos
ars
THRU | BENIGNO CESAR L. ESPEJO
OIC, Geosciences Division
FROM JELSON FITZGERALD D, EDDUBA
Geologist
SUBJECT: Ocular Geologic Investigation Conducted on an area affected by Typhoon
Quiel and Monsoon Rains at Poblacion, Kabugao, Apayao
In connection with the verbal request of Hon. Bensmar B. Ligwang, Municipal Mayor, Kabugao,
Apayao addressed to Fay W. Apil, OIC, Regional Director, Mines and Geosciences Bureau,
Cordillera Administrative Region, Department of Environment and Natural Resources (MGB-
CAR, DENR), a Geohazard Investigation was undertaken by the undersigned geologist at the
above-mentioned location. The purpose of the investigation is to assess the geological stability of
the proposed project and to come up with the appropriate recommendation
“MINING SHALL BE PRO-PEOPLE AND PRO-ENVIRONMENT
IN SUSTAINING WEALTH CREATION AND IMPROVED QUALITY OF LIFE.”
Office of the Regional Director/Finance and Administrative Division ~ 63 74 442 6392; ICT ~ 63 74 661 7685; Geosciences
Division/Laboratory Section 63 74 304 2500; Mine Management Division ~ 63 74 304 3068 (Monitoring and Technical Services
Section/Mining Tenement Evaluation Mineral Lands Survey Section); Mine Safety Environment and Social Development Section - 63
74308 2585; Social Development Section/Environment Section 63 74 304 2530,Findings and Observations
1. The site is situated at Poblacion, Kabugao, Apayao and is approximately located at
geographical coordinates 18°1' 17.3" North latitude and 121° 10' 55.7" Bast longitude using
Geographical Positioning System (GPS) instrument, It can be reached from Santa Marcela
Municipal Hall thru Santa Marcela Municipal Road then thru San Juan Barangay Road
The site is situated adjacent to San Juan Elementary School Compound
2, It is situated on a levelled ground characterized by highly sloping topography towards
northwest. No slope stabilization structure was noted on the area during the investigation
In addition, a damaged residential building and tension cracks with vertical and horizontal
displacement were noted,
Figure 1 aerial photo of Barangey Poblacion, Kebugao, Apayao
3. The area is affected by surface run-off which tends to flow on a generally northwest
direction towards Apayao River traversing a general northeast direction, No drainage canal
was noted within the site during the time of inspectionigure 2 photo showing tension cracks with vertical and horizontal displacements observed on the area
4, Numerous existing residential buildings were observed within the affected area during the
time of investigation®Figure 4 photo showing the downslope portion of the area sloping towards Apayeao River, In ation, thsi photo aso shows
benttilted trees along the sloping portion ofthe are5. The area is underlain by sedimentary rocks composed of conglomerate, sandstone and
siltsone, In addition, thick soil cover was noted that is believed to be derived from the in-
situ weathering of the underlying rocks.
6. No surface manifestation of faults and lineaments were observed within the area and its
vicinities during the field ocular inspection. However, the site is affected by an active mass
movement in the form of creeping as manifested by the presence of tilted trees. The
creeping was aggravated by saturation due to the continuous and heavy downpour of
typhoon of Typhoon Quiel which then resulted to the downward movement of the area.
Moreover, presence of approximately 20 centimeter vertical and horizontal displacements
were observed during the time of inspection.
Conclusions and Recommendations
Based from the above cited findings and observations, the site is experiencing instabilities in the
form of creeping. The unstable area has low stability since the shear stress has been reduced,
Furthermore, it will continue move downslope over a long period of time or can be easily
remobilized, Additional factor considered is that the subject area is situated on a steep slope.
Based from the discussions previously mentioned, all the basic factors considered for the
progression of the landslide are still present, thus its progression/remobilization should be
expected. To avoid possible loss of lives as well as properties the following recommendation
should be taken into consideration. However, these are mitigation in nature and not a guarantee
for the total stability of the progressive landslide.
1
‘A systematic drainage system should be introduced in the area and should be
concreted and interconnected with the main drainage system. All surface water
should be diverted away from the site, Furthermore, appropriate embankment and
concrete lining along the River should be considered to prevent
scouring/instabilities along the riverbank.
Reduction of slope angle by systematic terracing/benching and the consequent
introduction of retaining walls along the slopes to be cut/benched.
As a long-term solution, residents affected by the ground instabilities should be
relocated to a more stable area4. The area should be declared as “Danger Zone”, therefore, construction of new
building structures should be prevented.
5. Proper monitoring of the area should be implemented including the residential areas
for possible development of ground stabilities as manifested by tension cracks,
tilted/bent trees and/or ground displacements.
6. The residents of the area should be properly informed of the geohazard condition
of the area and that they should be vigilant especially during prolonged/heavy
precipitation.
7. Consult a Structural Engineer for a detailed assessment of the structural integrity
of the affected buildings
Any damages due to non-implementation of these recommendations shall be the sole responsibility
of the proponents.
SON FITZGERALD D. EDDUBA
Geologist
PRC # 0002941AGS
iD
“pov.
SS
Vi
7