Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A. Meaning of MNC
A large commercial organization with affiliates operating companies in a number of different
countries. A typically one normally functions with a headquarters that is based in one country,
while other facilities are based in locations in other countries. In some circles, this type of
corporation is referred to as a multinational enterprise (MNE) or a transnational corporation
(TNC).
Many authorities, scholars, and authors have variously defined multinational companies from
different perspectives. Some of these definitions are meticulously written below:
“A multinational enterprise (MNE) is a company that is headquartered in one country but has
operations in one or more other countries.” - Alan M. Rugman, Simon Collinson
According to Fred Luthans and Jonathan P. Doh “A firm having operations in more than one
country, international sales, and a nationality mix among managers and owners”.
According Drucker (1974), The multinational company grew from the emergence of a genuine
world market demand transcending national, cultural and ideological boundaries, due to the
information explosion.
In the words of Hodgetts and Luthans (1997), multinational companies are firms having
operations in more than one country, international sales, and nationality mix of managers and
owners.
Going by all these definitions highlighted above, it could be asserted that they all took a
multinational company and defined it from structural, functional and geographical perspectives
and from the point of scope covered geographically.
Page 1 of 14
Chapter 1
however, these same environmental factors can be very different on each of the markets in which
the firm operates.
A second characteristic of an MNE is that it draws on a common pool of resources, including
assets, patents, trademarks, information, and human resources. Because the affiliates are all part
of the same company; they have access to assets that are often not available to outsiders. For
example, both Ford and General Motors compete vigorously in Europe and many of the design
and styling changes developed for their European cars have now been introduced in US models.
The flow of information and technology between European and US affiliates has led to success
in the worldwide market for many MNEs. Similarly, if an affiliate needs expansion funds, an MNE
will often help out by working with the affiliate to raise the money. If a loan is needed, the affiliate
is likely to find many financial institutions that are willing to provide the money because the MNE
will back the loan.
A third characteristic of an MNE is that it links together the affiliates and business partners with
a common strategic vision. Simply put, all of the firms with whom the MNE works fit into the
company’s overall plan of what it wants to do and how it intends to go about implementing this
strategy. General Motors (GM) is a good example. The auto giant has announced that it is now
going to rely heavily on partnerships to help it grow.4 GM realizes that no auto maker has all of
the resources for achieving leadership in every region of the world or in every product segment.
As a result, the company has formed a manufacturing partnership with Toyota to conduct research
and development on fuel cell and gas-electric hybrid vehicles. GM also has created an alliance with
Fuji Heavy Industries and its Subaru brand that allows GM to benefit from Fuji’s strengths in
small sport utility vehicles, continuously variable transmissions, and all-wheel-drive systems and,
in turn, gives Fuji access to GM’s vehicle platforms and other important manufacturing
technologies. These types of arrangements are part of GM’s new strategic vision—one that is not
limited just to building cars. Today the company is looking into ways of providing customers with
other auto-related services as seen by its Onstar communications program with wireless phone
service that allows drivers to be in constant contact with someone who can give them information
and assistance.
There are some major characteristics of Multinational Corporations-
Create maximum operation: The multinational companies are extended to many countries.
People can grasp the opportunity. People can join the multinational companies according to their
capabilities. Manpower can be well utilized in the multinational companies.
Very high assets and turnover: To become a multinational corporation, the business must be
large and must own a huge amount of assets, both physical and financial. The company’s targets
are so high that they are also able to make substantial profits.
Transfer of technology: these multinational companies are establishing with hug capital and
advanced technology. It also transfers the technology in the host countries that can be used for
production.
Page 2 of 14
Chapter 1
Marketing superiority: it is large organization which has international name and fame. It has
good network world wide for distribution of goods.
High efficiency: these organizations operate their business with efficiency. They use advanced
technology. They also involve keenly in research works. They used many trained people that helps
in the production of quality goods.
Multiple currencies: Multinational companies deal in currencies of several countries. The risk is
high because of changing values of currencies in host countries.
Centralized Control: MNCs have their branches in different countries. These branches are
monitored, controlled and managed by centralized offices or the headquarters usually located in
the home countries.
Professional management: MNCs hire qualified, professional, and skilled people. They make all
possible efforts to keep their employees updated by ensuring proper training on a regular basis.
International operation: MNCs establish their branches, plants, and offices in more than one
country. They operate through a network of branches, subsidiaries and affiliates in host countries.
For example, Coca Cola, Apple, etc.
Sophisticated Technology: MNCs adapt to the latest trends and follow advanced technology to
supply world class products. They use capital-intensive technology and innovative techniques of
production.
Forceful marketing and advertising: One of the most effective survival strategies of
multinational corporations is spending a huge amount of money on marketing and advertising. It
is how they are able to sell every product or brand they make.
Page 3 of 14
Chapter 1
attractive to multinationals. In 2001, China entered the World Trade Organization, and this
acceptance of international rules made China more attractive for MNEs.
Firms also become MNEs in response to increased foreign competition and a desire to
protect their home market share. Using a “follow the competitor” strategy, a growing number
of MNEs now set up operations in the home countries of their major competitors.
This approach serves a dual purpose: (1) it takes away business from their competitors by offering
customers other choices, and (2) it lets competitors know that, if they attack the MNE’s home
market, they will face a similar response. This strategy of staking out global market shares is
particularly important when MNEs want to communicate the conditions under which they will
retaliate.
A fourth reason why companies become an MNE is to reduce costs. By setting up operations
close to the foreign customer, these firms can eliminate transportation expenses, avoid the
overhead associated with having intermediaries handle the product, respond more accurately and
rapidly to customer needs, and take advantage of local resources. This process, known as
“internalization” of control within the MNE, can help to reduce overall costs.
A fifth reason is to overcome protective devices such as tariff and non-tariff barriers by
serving a foreign market from within. The EU provides an excellent example. Firms outside
the EU are subject to tariffs on goods exported to EU countries. Firms producing the goods
within the EU, however, can transport them to any other country in the bloc without paying
tariffs. The same is now occurring in North America, thanks to the North American Free Trade
Agreement (NAFTA), which has eliminated tariffs among Canada, the United States, and Mexico.
A sixth reason for becoming an MNE is to take advantage of technological expertise by
manufacturing goods directly (by FDI) rather than allowing others to do it under a license.
Although the benefits of a licensing agreement are obvious, in recent years some MNEs have
concluded that it is unwise to give another firm access to proprietary information such as patents,
trademarks, or technological expertise, and they have allowed current licensing agreements to
lapse. This has allowed them to reclaim their exclusive rights and then to manufacture and directly
sell the products in overseas markets.
D. The Advantages of Multinational Organizations
Multinational businesses and non-profit organizations have numerous advantages. In some
instances, the advantages are excellent for the business and the regions in which they operate. In
others, the multinational arguably has an unfair advantage and over local businesses and have a
net negative impact. The business model is controversial, and is subject to scrutiny on a global
scale.
Cheap Labor Force
Multinational organizations have the ability to source labor cheaply. The ability to operate in
multiple different companies builds in the ability to capitalize on cheap labor markets. The
Page 4 of 14
Chapter 1
multinational footprint is clear in countries with abundant labor forces willing to operate at a lower
cost. This maximizes profit margins and can also deliver goods to markets at a lower cost. For the
local economy, the arrival of a multinational signals a supply of jobs to depressed areas, potentially
stimulating the local economies. The downside to the labor advantage is the potential for abusive
labor practices. Regions with cheap, abundant labor are also often poorly regulated and the
multinational can execute abusive labor practices.
Access to Lower Tax Rates
The multinational business model has a central brand/corporate office but each arm of the
business has some autonomy and independence as well. This makes it possible to run independent
arms of the business in areas with lower tax rates and tax shelters. Intentionally locating
manufacturing facilities in countries with cheap labor and low import/export costs gives the
multinational a major advantage.
Page 5 of 14
Chapter 1
Page 6 of 14
Chapter 1
Page 7 of 14
Chapter 1
Smaller, less developed governments often trade an increase in revenues for access to their natural
resources. The lower standards create better pricing structures for each customer, but it also
creates environmental damage that could have future generations paying the price for today’s
decisions. Some nations even trade in recycled materials and trash, which can place even more
stress on local resources.
Profits often go back to the multinational company instead of staying in the local market
Multinational corporations might provide job opportunities in each local market, but they also
funnel out many of the profits back to their centralized office. Some might see this as a return on
their infrastructure and educational investments, but it can also be a decision that further weakens
an already underperforming government or economy. When you compare how much goes into
foreign markets with what comes out of them, the difference is usually minimal and can sometimes
be a negative return.
Nothing stops a multinational company from importing their skilled labor
There are even times when a multinational corporation will not hire local workers, opting instead
to import positions from the centralized office to get things up and running. This process will still
provide contributions to the local economy and provide a handful of jobs that fall outside of this
disadvantage, but it tends to benefit the company and the workers more than the local community.
The best jobs, especially the ones which become available in a developing country, are therefore
given to someone who may not even live in the local community. That means their wages will not
have the same economic impact that they would have if a local employee was in that position.
Multinational corporations remove raw materials from the local economy
Although infrastructure benefits do occur when a multinational corporation moves into a
developing country, the construction efforts are usually meant to benefit the business and not the
local market. Roads and bridges are built to access raw materials, distribute goods, and manage
processes more than they are to improve the livelihood of those living in the region. Once all of
the goods are removed, then the agency might decide to abandon the project, leaving the
government with no way to manage the situation.
“Multinational corporations and a market economy have transformed human beings into
instruments of making money,” said Satish Kumar. “Human beings should be the end, and money
should be the means to the end.”
It creates a dependency on the business that can be unhealthy for an economy.
Because a multinational corporation can control a majority of the decisions that people make
thanks to the size and scope of their structure, their presence can create dependencies that are
unhealthy for the local marketplace. Consumers might think that they have choices when
shopping, but the reality of their situation is that one company is pulling all of the strings of their
transaction. That’s why Zbigniew Brzezinski said that the people, governments, and economies
of each country must serve the needs of this entity.
Page 8 of 14
Chapter 1
Unilever sells everything from soap to olive oil and has products selling in over 190 countries.
Coca-Cola and PepsiCo sell a combination of beverages and snacks that encompass hundreds of
different brands – sometimes competing with each other for the same shelf space. Anheuser-
Busch InBev controls a lineup of more than 200 different beer brands. Over 2 billion people use
the products from these companies on any given day.
F. Types of MNC
A multinational corporation (MNC) or multinational enterprise (MNE) or transnational
corporation (TNC) or multinational organization (MNO) is a corporation /enterprise that
manages production establishments or delivers services in at least two countries. Multinational
corporations (MNC) are often divided into three broad groups:
Horizontally integrated multinational corporations manage production establishments
located in different countries to produce the same or similar products.
Vertically integrated multinational corporations manage production establishment in certain
country/countries to produce products that serve as input to its production establishments in
other country/countries.
Diversified multinational corporations manage production establishments located in different
countries that are neither horizontally nor vertically integrated.
Very large multinationals have budgets that exceed those of many countries. Of the 100 largest
economies in the world, 51 are multinational corporations. They can have a powerful influence in
international relations, given their large economic influence in politicians ‘representative districts,
as well as their extensive financial resources available for public relations and political lobbying.
Multinationals have played an important role in globalization. Given their international reach and
mobility, prospective countries, and sometimes regions within countries, must compete with each
other to have MNCs locate their facilities (and subsequent tax revenue, employment, and
economic activity) within. To compete, countries and regional political districts offer incentives
to MNCs such as tax breaks, pledges of governmental assistance or improved infrastructure, or
lax environmental and labour standards. This process of becoming more attractive to foreign
investment can be characterized as a race to the bottom. There is a dispute as to which was the
first MNC.
MNCs make decisions about market-entry strategy; ownership of foreign operations; and
production, marketing, and financial activities with an eye to what is best for the corporation as a
whole. The true multinational corporation emphasizes group performance rather than the
performance of its individual parts. There are different types of multinational companies, such as;
Raw-Material Seekers: Raw-material seekers were the earliest multinationals and their aim was
to exploit the raw materials that could be found overseas. The modern-day counterparts of these
firms, the multinational oil and mining companies such as British Petroleum, Exxon Mobil,
International Nickel, etc.,
Market Seekers: The market seeker is the arche type of the modern multinational firm that goes
overseas to produce and sell in foreign markets. Examples include IBM, Toyota, Unilever, Coca-
Cola.
Cost Minimizers: Cost minimizers are a fairly recent category of firms doing business
internationally. These firms seek out and invest in lower-cost production sites overseas (for
example, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Taiwan, and India) to remain cost competitive both at home and
abroad.
MNCs have to follow the changes in macroeconomic factors, environmental and social issues,
and business and industry developments. These factors will all profoundly shape the corporate
landscape in the coming years. The following section deals with these trends.
Page 10 of 14
Chapter 1
Page 11 of 14
Chapter 1
Page 12 of 14
Chapter 1
Market potential
Sixth, there are MNCs who always have an eye on foreign markets. IBM, Valvo, Unilever etc.
come in this category. Originally American firms bought plant and equipment in Western Europe.
Later, Western Europe firms opened shops in USA. In the last part of the 20 th Century, Japanese
acquired firms in Europe and America. Now, there is camping of MNCs in the emerging world
markets like India, China, Mexico etc. Perceived restrictions on imports led to MNCs opening up
factories in foreign lands.
India and China are a great attraction as market for most MNCs at present. There is a classic
difference between US and Japanese MNCs in market capturing. US MNCs look at the up-end of
the market, while Japanese MNCs look at the unattended low-end. Low-end market has lot of
growth potential and this gives scale economies. With accumulated resource, wide mark et, and
proven process technology, Japanese MNCs are a threat to the US MNCs.
Raw Material availability
Seventh, initially most MNCs were spreading their wings globally just to tap raw-materials
available elsewhere for supporting production at the patent plant. British, French and Dutch East
India Companies are classic examples of MNCs of the raw-material seeking type. Now instead of
tapping raw-materials, the MNCs set up plants where factor markets are favorable. Because their
search for growth never is inward but always outwards. That is their culture.
Low Cost Production Possibilities
Eighth, MNCs are now driven by cost-minimization drives. They set up plants at places where
low-cost production possibilities are great. Taiwan, Hongkong and Finland are preferred by
MNCs for setting up electronic industrial units for there is cost efficiency. India, being a cheap
labour country, MNCs have started flooding into India. IBM, Ford outsource production of parts
to low-wage countries such as Mexico and by establishing assembly plants and R&D Centers in
Europe and Japan.
Risk-minimizing
Ninth, MNCs have long back realized the need for risk-minimizing. Threats from their
oligopolistic competitors are always there. Further, country-risk is always there. Meeting both the
risks is facilitated by geographical spread. By being close to market, better orientation to market
is possible and that monopolistic product differentiation is easily facilitated. Geographical spread
is risk-minimizing strategy and there is growth. Japanese Competition affects the American Auto
Industry. So, American Auto firms go out to the third world in search of strategic alliance
partnership.
Page 13 of 14
Chapter 1
Profit Orientation
Tenth, MNCs are interested in profits. And MNCs are generally highly profitable. Profit booking
facilitates growth, diversification, modernization and R&D competitiveness. Actually, MNCs
book profits by being flexible, adaptable and quick. In today s head-on competition, the most
important factor for growth is speed. Ability to design, develop and distribute products / services
in short span of time holds the key to success.
Management culture
Eleventh, growth of MNCs is very much influenced by their management culture. MNCs generally
adopt to local conditions and the relationship between parent and subsidiaries is that of
coordinated federation. Decisions on investment financing and market are localized. But Japanese
MNCs do centralize decisions. The East-West difference is thus found. But the underlying
similarity is the basis for action. Corporate strategic planning is an essential package of MNCs
management practice whereby the MNCs scan and plan for enhanced integration and co-
ordination of their global activities.
Microsoft Corporation allows its European subsidiaries to develop local strategies to meet local
market needs. This type of autonomous adoption to fast changing local business environment has
been the main reason for the spread of MNCs. The autonomy enjoyed by subsidiaries is not to
turn into dysfunctional anarchy, for the behavior of individual managers is well shaped through
shared vision of identification with and binding commitment to the global strategy of the MNCs.
Hence the growth of MNCs.
Page 14 of 14