Professional Documents
Culture Documents
and Strategy
Charles J. Fombrun
LEVELS OF CULTURE
Human Resource Management, Spring/Summer 1983, Vol. 22, Numbers 1/2, P 139-152
*' > 1983 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 0090-4848/83/010139-14$04.00
A good deal of academic research and descriptive analysis has addressed
the nature of "culture" at various levels of analysis. Understanding the
interplay between them is crucial if we are to properly position the concept
of a "corporate" culture as a unique and worthwhile level of analysis.
From a system perspective three levels can be distinguished from the
start: (1) the societal level, (2) the industry level, and (3) the organizational
level.
We will discuss these in turn. As we point out, there are some built-
in contradictions and tensions between these levels which may help ex-
plain the difficulties inherent in "managing" a corporate culture.
Societal Culture
Organizational Culture
Single Plant
Departmental Organization
As the small scale activity of the initial plant grows through market
expansion, the culture of the organization tends to champion cost-efficient
techniques for production that maximize competitiveness. A larger scale
of operations decreases the average costs of production, thereby opening
up demand. With growth in output comes growth in labor input, the
need for delegation through structure, and the beginnings of systematic
personnel management techniques.
For each type of departmental organization, the central value orientation
will of course vary. In manufacturing, for instance, mechanization and
technical control of the workforce tend to prevail. Pay systems and ap-
praisal systems are piece-rate, and the necessary skills are simple indeed.
In a marketing organization, on the other hand, the sales function probably
dominates, with pay and appraisal based on quantitative measurement.
Table II attempts to specify the different cultures and human resource
systems consistent with the three principal departmental organizations.
The unity of the corporate culture as a whole depends on the systematic
support of the dominant value orientation across the four human resource
systems of the departmental organization.
Functional Organization
i
Department Organization Cost-Control
Market Expansion
Vertical Integration
i
Multi-Functional Market-Share
Organization Growth
Diversification Competitiveness
Bureaucratic Controls
i
Multi-Divisional Portfolio
Organization Management
Bottom-Line Impacts
Corporate/Business
Dichotomy
Multidivisional Organization
SS
I
HI •43'
o
01
I 13 2
X
01 01 C
Ou
U a<5 O J3
-a
ID 01
.S O
3" bO
(/5 01
I CSS
2£
O T3
2 CT)
(• a
U
O»
»-
to
3
O
.2i -^
c -r re
a,
2 .S
§1 X) C
^ O
2 'I' 5;^ 2
C
3
C
4 c
2 o
01 cn
o
o
u
u
Ol
1 0)
C CiS UH
O
"«
N
'H 2 c
0
bO
o 8 O
6^ c
c O (0
O c
01 U
D>
B
t:
j
1
Ml
01
N
^1 5 2i
•a u
it C
C .M S
(A
ga (A
8 IS 1
6.^
n^ oo
1
CO
3
4.
CA
o
U
C CA
CA
n> O
O)
(A 0)
CA O) 6
o o;
Ss l •s
-I eg
l <S ^
C C
CA
r^
I
•c
01
3'So
5 S
55 J§;s 6 2
ll l £X
U
11 0)
Vt3
cn
01 0) c £ c c
W i3 2 d
'(A
(A CA
3
.£
(A
(U
I C
2 j2 Q" CL,
CQ
u
PQ CO o» o 3
*£ 0) P
u^.a 22
1.1
U CA
CA S ^ tA CA
Ol
01
CA
•Ji .Si
C
3
,2 3 cr
«^ c
I
0) cu
1^
CA O
3 2i S c ^ "is« ^5 O)
Oj S )_ >• t
.2 ^ v2 «
CO
•H (A
2 3 13 w .. SJ
CD pa 0) ft>
C/3 ac
s|
ca
0)
I- s
o 1 CA
73
I
a
>
•"• §0
i o
CONCLUSION
References
Anthony, Robert. Planning and Control Systems. Cambridge, MA: Graduate School
of Business, Harvard University, 1965.
Chandler, Alfred. Strategy and Structure. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University
Press, 1977
Deal, Terrence E., and Kennedy, Allan A. Corporate Cultures. Reading,
MA:Addison-Wesley, 1982.
Doeringer, P., and Piore, Michael. Internal Labor Markets and Manpower Analysis.
Boston, MA: D.C. Heath, 1971.
Edwards, Richard. Contested Terrain. New York: Basic Books, 1979.
Galbraith, lay, and Nathanson, Dan. Strategy Formulation: Analytical Concepts.
New York: West Publishing Co., 1978.
Lorange, Peter. Corporate Planning: An Executive Viewpoint. Englewood-Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall, 1980.
Ouchi, William. Theory Z: Meeting the Japanese Challenge. Reading, MA: Addison-
Wesley, 1980.
Pascale, Richard, and Athos, Anthony. The Art of Japanese Management. New
York: Warner Books, 1981.
Peters, Thomas J., and Waterman, Robert H., Jr. In Search of Excellence. New
York: Harper & Row, 1982.
Porter, Michael. Competitive Strategy. New York: Free Press, 1981.
Rumelt, Richard P Strategy, Structure, and Economic Performance. Boston, MA:
Harvard University Press, 1974.