http://ramshorn.

ca/blog-1 Go SEP AUG SEP

👤 ⍰❎
9 captures 13 f 🐦
9 Sep 2015 - 13 Aug 2018 2017 2018 2019 ▾ About this capture

Login Contact Search this site:

HOME ABOUT US CURRENT ISSUE BOOKS DOCUMENTS GRAPHICS SUBSCRIBE ARCHIVES

Blog #1 The Rams Horn Archives

2013
Submitted by Cathleen Kneen on June 17, 2015
Lead Article:  Can salmon aquaculture be certified organic? 2012
2011
  2010
2009
As I mentioned at the meeting, I have a number of concerns which relate to the 2008
possibility of a genuine Organic aquaculture standard (whether or not it is 2007
integrated with the Canada Organic Standard).  I noted that your proposals are 2006
very much focused on maintaining the health and integrity of the organic products 2005
and processes, and it seems that much less, if any, attention has been paid so far 2004
to the broader Organic Principles which begin the document: 2003
2002
 Principle of Health – Organic production should sustain and enhance the health of 2001
soil, plant, animal, human and planet as one and indivisible. 2000
1999
 Principle of Ecology – Organic production should be based on living ecological 2014
systems and cycles, work with them, emulate them and help sustain them. 2015
Blog #1
 Principle of Fairness – Organic production should build on relationships that
ensure fairness with regard to the common environment and life opportunities.
 Principle of Care – Organic production should be managed in a precautionary and
responsible manner to protect the health and well-being of current and future
generations and the environment.
All of these indicate that organic production must be integrated with the
environment in which it is practised, and be practised in such a way as to “sustain
and enhance” that environment. Bluntly, if you indeed want to follow these
principles, I can see no way to practise ocean-located net pens. They are an
environment which cannot be isolated from its surroundings and the fish and other
aquatic life there. There are inevitably escapes and inter-breeding with wild
stocks, not to mention the outbreak of disease which can spread readily to wild
populations. Even for a well-managed ‘organic’ enterprise with lower stocking
densities, these are real issues. Together, the cumulative risks of disease from
proximity to caged salmon, and the fact that the salmon’s amazing genetic imprint

Create PDF in your applications with the Pdfcrowd HTML to PDF API PDFCROWD
 does not contain coding for this kind of lifestyle which makes them more
susceptible to disease, puts into serious question the whole system of ocean-
located net pens.
There is an ethical as well as a practical problem here. The Organic Standard
reflects a vision which is couched in language of respecting integrity and natural
systems. I think that many practitioners of organic farming might use the term
‘reverence’ in this context. The life- cycle of the Pacific Salmon is one of these
systems which many revere, and the Adams River, which hosts the largest and best
known migration, has been nominated as a World Heritage Site. The Sockeye
salmon migrate for hundreds if not thousands of kilometres from their natal
stream high in the interior, through river systems to far out in the open ocean, and
then back again four years later, with striking changes in their bodies as they
battle their way upstream until they spawn and die. The fish are in a web of
interdependence with the wildlife (bears, eagles) that feed on their dead bodies,
the high mountains whose snow-melt provides the cold water in the rivers that
they need, and the majestic trees that both cool the water and are nourished by
the remains of their carcases and the droppings of their scavengers. It is not
surprising that the Secwepemc (Shuswap) and other peoples in the region describe
the salmon as sacred, reflecting the interweaving of relationships that is basic to
Indigenous thinking.
How can the principles of ecology and fairness be applied to the confinement
rearing of a migratory species?

In fact, the question must be raised about the suitability of what are in effect
“factory farms” for an organic designation, even if they are located on land, and
especially if they are not part of an integrated system where the leavings of one
species provides the feed for another in an elegant closed loop. (Please note, I am
simply suggesting that the question needs to be discussed.)

One of the most important concerns of the Technical Committee was, of course,
just this question of feed and its provenance. This includes concern about the
balance of pelagic fish and other protein sources in the feed for farmed fish; some
scepticism of the label “sustainable fishery” for the pelagic fisheries on the basis
of a state sign-on, without third-party verification; and the fact that it takes 1½ 
pounds of [wild] fish to grow one pound of salmon. Again, these are concerns
which require more discussion of the evidence available to show that the proposed
aquaculture is indeed sustainable and adheres to the Organic Principles in that
regard.
In the interests of full disclosure, I need to note that this is an issue about which I
have been passionate for a long time. I am a Newfoundlander, and you can still
reduce me to tears just by mentioning the demise of the Northern Cod. I also lived
for nearly ten years in Secwepemc territory, close to the Adams River and Lake
Shuswap, and the experience of paddling my canoe in the midst of swarming,

Create PDF in your applications with the Pdfcrowd HTML to PDF API PDFCROWD
 bright-red fish powerfully reminded me of the early explorers to the Grand Banks,
who reported that the cod were so plentiful you could catch them in a basket.
These are not, to my mind, minor matters, and they need careful and respectful
consideration if we are to contemplate a certified Organic Standard for
Aquaculture in Canada.
Thank you for listening.
Cathleen Kneen
June 10, 2015
 

‹ 2015 up
Printer-friendly version Login or register to post comments

Home About Us Current Issue Books Documents Graphics Subscribe Archives

Copyright: All material published in Canada is automatically copyright. However, we decline this privilege and place all the material in The Ram's Horn in the public
domain, to be freely used and built upon. We would appreciate acknowledgement of the contribution of The Ram's Horn to your work.

Create PDF in your applications with the Pdfcrowd HTML to PDF API PDFCROWD