6/24/2020 Why an Arc Flash Study is Necessary

Why an Arc Flash Study is Necessary for Your Facility

Author: Doug Black

Arc Flash & Electrical Safety Learning Center / Risk Assessment / Why an Arc Flash Study is Necessary for Your Facility

An Arc Flash Assessment / Analysis is a study of the facility's power system to determine the
incident energy available at speci c electrical devices that employees would be exposed to while
“interacting with” the electrical equipment at the facility. The output of the Assessment/ Analysis
is a determination and labeling of the PPE required of the electrical devices, suitability of the
devices for service as installed and if there are any miss- coordination issues involved as the
system is currently installed.

A short circuit current available analysis and the clearing times of the overcurrent devices
involved is required to determine the incident energy at the various points in the system.

OSHA 1910.132 requires that employers identify and protect their workers from workplace
hazards. Every industrial / commercial power system includes inherent risks – speci cally
electrical shock and arc ash, anytime employees are “interacting with” electrical equipment
while energized. Interacting with electrical equipment includes operation of fully enclosed
switches and power circuit breakers as well as any exposure to energized equipment or circuit
parts, including all energized testing or troubleshooting activities.

NFPA 70E – Standard for Electrical Safety in the Workplace, Section 110.1 - requires “The
employer shall implement and document an overall electrical safety program that directs activity
appropriate to the risk of electrical hazards. The electrical safety program shall be implemented
as part of the employer’s overall occupational health and safety management system, when one
exists.” Section speci cally includes identifying and quantifying the risks of both shock and arc
ash hazards, before work begins.

NFPA 70E, Section 130.5 Arc Flash Analysis – requires an arc ash risk assessment shall be
performed to determine the risk, safety related work practices required, the arc ash boundary,
the incident energy at the working distance, and the PPE that people within the arc ash
boundary shall use. This assessment shall be reviewed at intervals not to exceed 5 years.

NFPA 70E Section 130.5 (H) Labeling - requires all equipment “likely to require examination,
adjustment, servicing, or maintenance while energized shall be eld marked” … with a label
containing arc ash risk identi cation, severity of the risk, arc ash boundary and required PPE
level among other things. This includes any energized testing or troubleshooting activity..

NFPA 70E, Section 110.3 (A) Host Employer Responsibilities - requires that host employers of
contractor or outside service personnel are responsible for notifying the contractor of the
hazards they may encounter in the performance of their work. This holds the host employer /
facility owner responsible for identifying the hazards a contractor may encounter on the site.
Therefore, using contract maintenance and electrical workers does not reduce the need for arc
ash analysis.

https://www.e-hazard.com/learn/risk-assessment/why-an-arc-flash-study-is-necessary.php 1/4
6/24/2020 Why an Arc Flash Study is Necessary

It is impossible to know what level of arc ash hazard risk is inherent in your power system
without assessment by knowledgeable technical resources. However, it is a true statement that
every industrial / commercial electrical system has some level of inherent arc ash hazard. In
order to protect the safety of your employees or contract employees working on or operating
your electrical equipment an arc ash assessment must be completed and the equipment
appropriately labeled.

Arc Flash Analysis Methodologies

Standard Bracketing Method
This is the most common and cost-effective method as it identi es the Arc Flash PPE
requirements at the last electrical device to be interacted with by bracketing the PPE level
changeover points at the last device by ampacity size based upon the fault current and device
type at the Power Distribution Panel, MCC or Bus Duct and accounts for the connected
horsepower at each of these distribution centers. With this method it will be known and
identi ed on the model drawings that for instance up to a 200-amp overcurrent device will result
in a PPE level 0 exposure and any device larger than the 200-amp overcurrent device will result
in a PPE level 1 exposure at the nal device to be interacted with.

Detailed ONE LINE Method

This method identi es and shows on the drawings all eld devices connected and provides what
is typically known as a power distribution one-line drawing. This method is labor intensive and
thus is typically many times more expensive than the most common standard bracketing method.
The end result of the exposures at the last device is identical to the standard bracketing method.
This method is typically not used due to the much higher cost. Some clients want a complete one
line of their power distribution system to the last device.

Calculate to the NFPA 70E Tables Method

This method calculates to the equipment types listed in the NFPA 70E HRC tables and when the
equipment type meets the requirements of the tables, the calculations stop and the equipment is
labeled to the table requirements. The NFPA 70E tables are conservative and will result in many
exposures that are in reality a PPE Level 0 or 1 exposure but the tables will require a PPE Level 2
protective system. This change to a PPE Level 2 system results in the Balaclava requirement
under the arc rated face shield to be utilized. This is generally only used in much smaller facilities,
usually 500 Kva of capacity and one service. This method does save upfront analysis costs over
the Standard Bracketing Method but usually incurs more PPE required for the majority of the
standard maintenance tasks at the last device interacted with by the electrical worker.

How Can My Facility Ensure Proper Protection for Electrical

Workers and Be Compliant with NFPA 70E?
1. Electrical safety and arc ash training of electrical workers
2. Arc Flash Assessment of electrical equipment
3. Labeling of equipment with
1. Nominal system voltage
2. Arc ash boundary
3. And at least one of the following:
a. Available incident energy at working distance, or required PPE Level
b. Minimum arc rating of clothing
c. Site-speci c level of PPE (must be equal to or greater than incident
energy)
4. Use of proper arc ash PPE (arc rated clothing as daily wear and higher levels available
where needed) and shock protection PPE (insulated tools and rubber insulating gloves
with leather protectors for all energized contacts over 50V AC or DC)
5. Written Electrical Safety Program for the site, as described in Section 110.1, including
auditing and reporting processes to show compliance, identify gaps and keep the

https://www.e-hazard.com/learn/risk-assessment/why-an-arc-flash-study-is-necessary.php 2/4
6/24/2020 Why an Arc Flash Study is Necessary

program on track.

Important Facts:
Annually in the US about 2000 people go to burns centers as the result of arc ash injuries. 80%
of these are due to clothing res. The other 20% are mostly burns to bare skin which should have
been covered with arc rated clothing. If every electrical worker would wear the proper arc rated
PPE, this would become a very small number.

Industrial electrocutions (deaths) occur every other day (about 170 in 2013) in the US. If
electrical workers would use appropriate insulated tools and rubber insulating gloves every time
they are within the restricted approach boundary, this would also become a very small number.

The Three Key Factors in Making Electrical Safety a Success

Are:
Understanding the energy available in your power system for both shock and arc ash.
Having the proper PPE available and making its use a standard practice / requirement.
Once hazards are identi ed, use engineering controls and work practice modi cations to
reduce personnel exposure. Remote controls, modi ed switching or LO/TO/V procedures,
etc.

At e-Hazard our goal is to educate electrical workers to understand the shock and arc ash
hazards associated with the electrical equipment they work on daily and the appropriate
methods used to perform that work safely. Each of us has many years of industrial electrical
power system experience in engineering, maintenance, safety and arc ash analysis as well as
mitigation / reduction of arc ash energy levels and exposure to personnel.

Ready to Get Started?

Join thousands of happy customers who have used our services.

Contact Us Today

e-Hazard is Proud to Have

Employee Members of the Following Organizations

Contact e-Hazard Electrical Safety Training Electrical Safety Services

 3018 Eastpoint Parkway, Louisville, KY 40223 NFPA 70E Training Arc Flash Studies
 Of ce: +1 (502) 716-7073
Arc Flash Training Arc Flash Audits
 Fax: +1 (502) 371-6300
Train the Trainer Electrical Compliance Inspections
 Contact Us
1910.269 Utilities Written ESP Development
 Hours: 8 AM to 5 PM, EST - Weekdays
Training Schedule Written ESP Review

https://www.e-hazard.com/learn/risk-assessment/why-an-arc-flash-study-is-necessary.php 3/4
6/24/2020 Why an Arc Flash Study is Necessary

 Electrical Safety Schedule

Low Voltage
High Voltage

About e-Hazard
e-Hazard is dedicated to building an
electrical safety culture with you.
Through our training and services, we
equip you and your coworkers to work
safely.

Learn More About Us

© 2004 - 2020 e-Hazard Management, LLC. All rights reserved. Home | Blog | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

https://www.e-hazard.com/learn/risk-assessment/why-an-arc-flash-study-is-necessary.php 4/4