Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Received 18 November 1999; Revisions requested 30 November 1999; Revisions received 27 March 2000; Accepted 28 March 2000
Abstract
Three bacterial strains, two identified as Pseudomonas stutzeri and one as a strain of cucurbit yellow vine disease
bacterium, isolated from a foundry soil and a tannery, respectively, in Pakistan, were resistant to up to 1 mM
chromate and anaerobically reduced Cr(VI) up to 100 µM. The highest removal was by P. stutzeri CMG463:
88 µmol l−1 (88% of that supplied; specific rate was 3.0 nmol mg−1 protein h−1 ), while 58 and 76 µmol l−1 (58%
and 76%) were removed by P. stutzeri CMG462 and cucurbit yellow vine disease bacterium CMG480, respectively.
These isolates were compared to strains isolated from an uncontaminated coastal site in the UK and designated as
K2 (Pseudomonas synxantha) K3 (Bacillus sp.), and J3 (unidentified Gram-positive strain). Strain K3 was Cr-
sensitive, partially lysed by Cr(VI), but had the highest removal of chromate anaerobically: 92 µmol l−1 (92% of
that supplied) at a specific rate of 71 nmol mg−1 protein h−1 . Analysis of cell sections using transmission electron
microscopy with energy dispersive X-ray analysis showed intracellular chromium in P. stutzeri but the cucurbit
yellow vine disease bacterium and the Bacillus sp. precipitated chromium extracellularly. The isolates from the Cr-
contaminated sites did not remove more Cr(VI), overall, than Cr-unstressed bacteria, but their tolerance to Cr(VI)
is potentially useful for bioremediation, particularly since other studies have shown that the two P. stutzeri strains
can bioaccumulate Cu2+ .
transmission electron microscopy. For energy disper- UK coastal samples were not above normal environ-
sive X-ray analysis (EDAX) thicker sections (200– mental levels (Tolley 1993); therefore strains isolated
300 nm) were cut and examined by scanning transmis- from these had not suffered Cr-stress. The metals-
sion electron microscopy (JEOL JEM-100CXII) using burden of the foundry and tannery environments was
a LINK ISIS X-ray analyser to determine elemental not measured, but both are known to be heavily con-
distribution in/on and around the cells. taminated. For example a survey of tannery effluents
showed chromium and copper contents ranging from
Identification of isolates 0.06–7.9 mg l−1 and from 2.8–7.2 mg l−1 respectively
(N. Ahmed, unpublished). Strains CMG462, CMG463
Gram staining was carried out using established meth- and CMG480 were resistant to 1 mM sodium chro-
ods (Collins & Patricia 1984). The isolates were iden- mate (growth on plates supplemented with 1 mM
tified using partial 16S rRNA gene analysis. A small CrO2−
4 ), but K2 and J3 grew only with 100 µM Cr(VI)
colony of each was resuspended in 0.1 ml of sterile, and K3 was sensitive to that concentration. It was con-
de-ionised water (SDW), mixed and heated at 70 ◦ C cluded that the polluted site isolates were Cr-resistant;
(10 min) for cell lysis. Crude lysate (0.2 µl) was the mechanism(s) was not elucidated further.
added to SDW (0.0198 ml) and used as a template
in a polymerase chain reaction using the eubacterial Identification of isolates
16S targeted PCR primers (pA and pH0 ) as designed
by Edwards et al. (1989). These are known to am- Three isolates were homologous to strains of
plify a 1536 base pair (approx. 1.5 kbp) length of Pseudomonas (Table 1), with the highest homology to
16S rDNA. The reaction mixture for amplification P. stutzeri (Pakistan foundry isolates) and P. synxantha
was as published by Bruce et al. (1992). Cycling (UK coastal site isolate). The tannery isolate gave a
used a MJ thermal cycler (MJ Research Inc., USA) high homology to an isolate identified only as ‘cucur-
under tube temperature control and using 30 cycles bit yellow vine disease bacterium’, an enterobacterial
of the following program: 94 ◦ C for 40 s, 55 ◦ C plant pathogen (Avila et al. 1998). Strain K3 was a
for 1 min, 72 ◦ C for 2 min and a final 10 min ex- Gram-positive aerobic sporeformer and was assigned
tension at 72 ◦ C. PCR products were cleaned using to the genus Bacillus while J3, also Gram-positive,
Sephacryl S400 columns (Pharmacia, Sweden), and was not identified further. All isolates were ∼97%
partially sequenced using 16S sequencing primer 943 similar to reference sequences on the EMBL database.
reverse (Lane et al. 1985) by Alta Biosciences (Uni- The Pseudomonas spp. were 99% similar to matching
versity of Birmingham, UK). Sequences (up to 650 bp) sequences.
were analysed using ADVANCED BLAST software
to access the EMBL database, Heidelberg, Germany Chromate reduction by isolated strains
(Web ref: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/Blast).
All strains grew aerobically in 100 µM Cr(VI)-
Netscape browser interface was used.
supplemented minimal medium (doubling time was
generally 4–6 h) but reduced little Cr(VI) (Table 2a).
Treatment of data
Anaerobic growth at the expense of Cr(VI) as the elec-
All experiments were done on at least three separate tron acceptor was negligible but Cr(VI) was reduced
occasions except anaerobic tests with strain J3 which and removed (Table 2b). These cultures were essen-
were done twice. Data for each time point are pooled tially resting cell suspensions, permitting determina-
and the mean is given ± standard error of the mean tion of specific rates of Cr(VI) reduction (Table 2).
(SEM). This was observed only after a lag of 31 h (follow-
ing growth in the aerobic cutures); the rates were
determined from 31–192 h.
Results and discussion Cr(VI) reduction aerobically was low in ac-
cordance with the provision of O2 as the pri-
Resistance of the polluted site isolates to Cr(VI) mary (competing) electron acceptor (Table 2a). The
Pseudomonas spp. CMG462, CMG463 and K3
Analysis using atomic absorption spectroscopy and showed a comparable loss of Cr(VI) after 192 h. With
X-ray fluorescence following acid digestion showed CMG480 this was small. Strain J3 removed the most
that the concentrations of metals (Cr, Cu, Pb) in the chromate after 192 h aerobically but this was still
832
Table 1. Bacterial strains used in this study.
Strain Residual Cr(VI) (µM) Loss of Cr(VI) (µM) Rate (nmol mg−1 protein per h)
CMG462 87 ± 1 14 0.1
CMG463 85 ± 1 15 0.4
CMG480 91 ± 5 9 0.1
K2 93 ± 2 8 0.4
K3 87 ± 1 12 0.1
J3 79 ± 2 23 0.4
The protein content was that following growth, which was complete after 24 h. The high protein con-
tent due to bacterial growth aerobically resulted in a low specific rate of Cr(VI) reduction following
growth.
Strain Residual Cr(VI) (µM) Loss of Cr(VI) (µM) Rate (nmol mg−1 protein per h)
CMG462 42 ± 3 58 3.0
CMG463 12 ± 3 88 2.6
CMG480 24 ± 7 76 4.3
K2 21 ± 2 79 5.6
K3a 8±7 92 71.5
J3 28 73 3.2
Negligible growth occurred anaerobically in the absence of added electron acceptor (other than that
present in the yeast extract).
a Strain K3 gave very poor growth anaerobically before Cr(VI) addition. The protein content was low,
hence the specific rate of Cr(VI) reduction was high.
less than 25% of that provided (Table 2a). In contrast tha) removed Cr(VI) comparably to the two P. stutzeri
Cr(VI) reduction was apparent in all strains anaero- strains. Comparison of strains of the same genus
bically; the best strains were Pseudomonas stutzeri (Pseudomonas spp.) suggested that pre-exposure to
CMG 463 and Bacillus sp. K3 in terms of total Cr(VI) metal contamination and enrichment for resistance
removed (88% and 92%, respectively). K3 gave the to Cr(VI) did not promote reduction of Cr(VI), in
best overall rate, largely attributable to a low pro- accordance with other studies in the literature.
tein content associated with very poor growth in the
3 h prior to Cr(VI) addition. Strain K2 (P. synxan-
833
Fig. 1. Transmission electron microscopy of sections of Cr(VI) challenged cells withdrawn after 48 h and prepared as described in Materials
and methods. (a, c, e, g): Controls (No Cr(VI)). (b, d, f, h): Cr(VI)-challenged cells. (a, b): Pseudomonas stutzeri GMG462. (c, d): Pseudomonas
stutzeri CMG463. Pseudomonas synxantha K2 is not shown but was similar to (a, b). (e, f): Cucurbit yellow vine disease bacterium, CMG480.
(g, h): Bacillus sp. K3. Bars are 500 nm.
834
Fig. 2. EDAX analysis of electron opaque areas. (a, c): P. stutzeri CMG463, (b, d, f): Cucurbit yellow vine disease bacterium. (e): resin matrix
around the cells (blank). (a, b): Cell edge regions. (c, d): regions inside cells. In (c) this corresponds to an electron opaque inclusion body as
visible in Figure 1d. In (f) this corresponds to the electron opaque extracellular particles as shown in Figure 1f.
Electron microscopy and analysis by EDAX CrO2−4 can enter the cell but for a waste remediation
process a cell surface-localized deposit is preferable
A study of the three Pseudomonas strains (CMG462 because it may be possible to remove this and conserve
and 463, and K2) suggested two mechanisms of chro- the biomass for re-use. Two strains showed extracellu-
mate resistance and accumulation. P. stutzeri CMG462 lar electron opaque deposits. In accordance with the
and P. synxantha K2 showed some electron opaque toxicity tests (above) Bacillus sp. K3 showed lysis
material at the outer cell surface (Figure 1b) but the lo- of some cells (Figure 1h). The observation that the
calised concentration of this was below the sensitivity inhibited culture reduced Cr(VI) similarly to the Cr-
of the EDAX technique. P. stutzeri CMG 463 showed tolerant cultures (Table 2) suggested that dead cells or
occasional intracellular deposits of electron opaque cell-lysates probably retained Cr(VI)-reductive ability.
material (Figure 1d) which gave a positive result for A similar phenomenon was seen with strain CMG480
Cr and also for P by EDAX (Figure 2c). Analysis (Figure 1f). Analysis of the extracellular material of
of the cell surface (Figure 2a) and background resin CMG480 by EDAX clearly showed co-deposition of
around the cells (Figure 2e) gave no detectable Cr. Cr and P (Figure 2f) which were not visible inside
Detection of intracellular Cr suggests that the anionic the cells (Figure 2d), at the cell surface (Figure 2b)
835
or in the extracellular resin matrix (Figure 2e). Ca and cation; such an approach has been used previously in
Fe were co-deposited with Cr and P (Figure 2f); the the identification of pathogenic isolates (Beswick et al.
precipitate was probably a mixed metal phosphate. A 1999).
similar result was obtained by analysis of extracellular The potential phytopathogenicity of the strain may
precipitate of strain K3 (not shown). Strain J3 ap- preclude its widespread industrial use. The reason for
peared to remove Cr(VI) aerobically as well as anaer- its occurrence in a tannery environment is conjectural.
obically (Table 2) but was no better than P. stutzeri However as tannins and similar polyphenolic com-
CMG463, overall, in terms of total Cr removal, and pounds are important secondary metabolites of many
was not considered further. plants, a tolerance to relatively high concentrations
of such compounds would be a likely prerequisite for
a phytopathogenic bacterium; high concentrations of
Conclusions and wider implications such compounds building up from bark used in tradi-
tional tanning processes could impose a selection on
Substantial reduction of Cr(VI) occurred only anaer- the environmental microflora towards species tolerant
obically but growth at the expense of Cr(VI) as the of these plant products. It seems possible that this
electron acceptor was not observed. Many bacterial putative plant pathogenic strain has evolved a mech-
strains reduce chromate anaerobically or aerobically anism(s) of resistance to free radical toxicity which, in
but not both (Germain & Patterson 1974). Strain J3 the present case, may be associated with the oxidative
could be an exception but the total Cr(VI) reduced was effects of Cr(VI).
low aerobically, and anaerobically this strain was not Industrial workplaces in Pakistan provide novel
exceptional. Strain K3 showed cellular damage and enrichment environments for the natural selection of
sensitivity to 100 µM Cr(VI) and would probably be novel strains of metal resistant bacteria because there
insufficiently robust for industrial use. is little regulatory control over industrial emissions
The strains isolated from the metal contaminated and environmental burdens can be severe. The strains
sites were the most tolerant to Cr(VI) and the P. described in this study, in addition to being capa-
stutzeri removed Cr(VI) comparably to P. synxantha ble of Cr(VI) reduction to an extent comparable to
(strain K2), which had not been previously metal- good isolates from a natural environment, have other
stressed. The high Cr(VI) resistance of these isolates potentially useful properties and numerous plasmids
makes them attractive for Cr-waste remediation, no- (U. Badar & N. Ahmed, unpublished) that will be
taby because reduced Cr(VI) uptake was reported pre- reported elsewhere. The conclusion from this study
viously in a Cr-resistant strain of P. fluorescens (Bopp is that while the new strains may not have the high-
& Ehrlich 1988). est rates of Cr(VI) reduction as compared to the best
Strain CMG480 is noteworthy. Analysis of the ex- strains reported in the literature, they combine Cr(VI)
tracellular precipitate identified by EDAX suggests resistance with its reduction and also have the potential
a method of Cr deposition via reduction of Cr(VI) for removal of metal cations.
to Cr(III) followed by precipitation of CrPO4 at the
expense of phosphate provided in the medium. It is
possible that CrO2−4 is taken up, reduced and effluxed Acknowledgements
for precipitation exocellularly. Extracellular precipi-
tate was seen in all Cr(VI)-cultures of CMG 480 (3 The authors acknowledge, with thanks, the support of
experiments). the British Council in support of U.B. P.P. was sup-
Strain CMG480 was virtually identical to cucur- ported by the Government of Thailand and A.B. was
bit yellow vine disease bacterium over 308 bp of the supported by grants to Prof N.L. Brown (University of
16S rRNA gene including variable regions. It could Birmingham, from BBSRC, EU and PHLS). They also
be argued that this provides insufficient data for a acknowledge, with gratitude, useful discussions with
definitive identification. However the 308 bp frag- the late Dr R.B. Pearce in aspects of plant pathology.
ment was from the middle region of the 16S rRNA
gene which contains a key hypervariable region which
provides a substantial amount of discriminatory infor-
mation about the bacterium. In addition there are less
variable regions which also contribute to the identifi-
836