Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
Why Connection Failure Should be Avoided?
2
BEHAVIOR OF JOINTS ARE COMPLEX
• Geometric imperfections.
• Lack of Fit.
• Residual stresses.
• Connection flexibility.
• Geometric complexity.
• Slipping.
• Non linear load deformation.
3
Classification of Connections
4
Classification of Connections
Connection geometry: Single web angle, single
plate, double web angle, top and seat angles
(with and without stiffeners), end plates, or
header plate, welded connections using plates
and angles, etc.
Type of force transferred across the structural
connection: Shear connections, shear and
moment connection or simply moment
connection, tension or compression, tension or
compression with shear.
5
Classification Based on
Joint Rigidity
Rigid: That develop the full moment capacity of
connecting members and retain the original angle
between the members under any joint rotation.
Rotational movement of the joint will be very small
Simple: No moment transfer is assumed between the
connected parts and hence assumed as hinged (pinned).
Rotational movement of the joint will be large.
Semi-Rigid: May not have sufficient rigidity to hold the
original angles between the members and develop less
than the full moment capacity of the connected
members.
In reality all the connections will be semi-rigid only.
6
Examples of Rigid Connections
7
Examples of Pinned Connections
8
RIVETS AND RIVETED CONNECTIONS
10
Black or Ordinary Bolt and Nut
Source: AISC
11
Black or Ordinary Bolt and Nut
• ASTM-A307-Least expensive bolts-light
structures.
• Temporary fasteners-HSFG Bolts.
• Not recommended for connections subjected
to impact-fatigue or dynamic loads.
• Mild steel rods- square or hexagonal head &
nut.
12
Hexagonal Head
Black Bolt and Nut
For grade 4.6 bolts, nuts of grade 4 are used and for grade 8.8, nuts of grade 8 or 10 are used.
15
RIBBED BOLTS
• Round head –ribs paralleled to shank .
• Actual diameter of shank > bolt hole.
• Driving bolt into the hole-cuts the edges
around the hole- relatively tight fit.
• Used – bearing type connection- stress
reversals.
16
HIGH STRENGTH BOLTS
• HSB-Medium Carbon
• 1956- factored delayed – immediate acceptance- high
cost.
• High strength- quenching & tempering process.
• Washer at both side purpose-to distribute the clamping
pressure to a large area of the softer metal, to prevent
the nut or bolt head from damaging the member.
• To prevent the threaded portion of the bolt from
bearing on the connected members.
17
High-Strength Bolts
18
HIGH-STRENGTH BOLTS
The material of the bolts do not have a well defined
yield point.
Instead of using yield stress, a so-called proof load is
used.
The proof load is the load obtained by multiplying
the tensile stress area (approximately equal to 0.8
times the shank area of bolt) by the proof stress.
the proof stress is taken as 0.7 times the ultimate
tensile stress of the bolt.
19
HIGH-STRENGTH BOLTS
• They are identified by
manufacturer’s
identification symbol and
property class identification
symbol 8 S or 8.8 S or 10 S
or 10.9 S which will be
embossed on the heads of
Source:
www.nichiasteel.co.jp
these bolts.
20
High-Strength Friction Grip (HSFG) Bolts
21
Advantages of Bolted connections
Bolted connections offer the following advantages over
riveted or welded connections:
Use of unskilled labour and simple tools
Noiseless and quick fabrication
No special equipment/process needed for installation
Fast progress of work
Accommodates minor discrepancies in dimensions
The connection supports loads as soon as the bolts are
tightened (in welds and rivets, cooling period is
involved).
Main drawback of black bolt is the slip of the joint when
subjected to loading
22
ADVANTAGES OF HSFG BOLTS
• HSFG bolts do not allow any slip between the elements
connected, especially in close tolerance holes, Thus they
provide rigid connections.
• Because of the clamping action, load is transmitted by
friction only and the bolts are not subjected to shear and
bearing.
• Due to the smaller number of bolts, the gusset plate sizes
are reduced.
• Deformation is minimized.
• Holes larger than usual can be provided to ease erection and
take care of lack-of-fit. However note that the type of hole
will govern the strength of the connection.
• Noiseless fabrication, since the bolts are tightened with 23
wrenches.
ADVANTAGES OF HSFG BOLTS
• The possibility of failure at the net section under the working
loads is eliminated.
• Since the loads causing fatigue will be within proof load, the nuts
are prevented from loosening and the fatigue strength of the
joint will be greater than in welded/connections.
• Since the load is transferred by friction, there is no stress
concentration in the holes.
• Unlike riveted joints, few persons are required for making the
connections.
• No heating is required and no danger of tossing of bolt. Thus
safety of the workers is enhanced.
• Alterations, if any (e.g. replacement of defective bolt) is done
easily than in welded connections.
24
DRAWBACKS OF HSFG BOLTS
25
EBCS 3 Is Subdivided In Various Parts
EBCS EN 1993:2013
26
EBCS EN 1993-1:2013 “General rules and rules for buildings” comprises:
EBCS EN 1993-1-1:2013 Design of Steel Structures: General rules and rules for buildings.
EN 1993-1-7 Design of steel structures: Strength and stability of planar plated structures
transversely loaded.
EN 1993-1-10 Design of steel structures: Selection of steel for fracture toughness and through-
thickness properties.
27
Design assumptions
28
PARTIAL SAFETY FACTOR
As per EBCS EN 1993-1-8:2013
Table 2.1
29
JOINTS LOADED IN SHEAR SUBJECT TO IMPACT,
VIBRATION AND/OR LOAD REVERSAL
Where a joint loaded in shear is subject to impact or significant
vibration one of the following
jointing methods should be used:
− welding
− bolts with locking devices
− preloaded bolts
− other types of bolt which effectively prevent movement of the
connected parts
− rivets.
The yield strength fyb and the ultimate tensile strength fub
for bolt classes 4.6, 4.8, 5.6, 5.8, 6.8, 8.8 and 10.9 are given in
Table 3.1
31
Categories of bolted connections
Shear connections
Bolted connections loaded in shear should be designed as one of the
following:
• a) Category A: Bearing type
In this category bolts from class 4.6 up to and including class 10.9
should be used. No preloading and special provisions for contact surfaces
are required. The design ultimate shear load should not exceed the design
shear resistance.
32
• Category B: Slip-resistant at serviceability limit state
In this category preloaded bolts shall be used. Slip should not
occur at the serviceability limit state. The design serviceability
shear load should not exceed the design slip resistance.
• Category C: Slip-resistant at ultimate limit state
In this category preloaded bolts shall be used . Slip should not
occur at the ultimate limit state. The design ultimate shear load
should not exceed the design slip resistance.
Tension connections
Bolted connection loaded in tension should be designed as
one of the following:
a) Category D: non-preloaded
In this category bolts from class 4.6 up to and including class 10.9
should be used. No preloading is required. This category should not
be used where the connections are frequently subjected to
variations of tensile loading. However, they may be used in
connections designed to resist normal wind loads.
b) Category E: preloaded
In this category preloaded 8.8 and 10.9 bolts with controlled
tightening .
34
35
Dimension of Holes
36
BOLT HOLES
Bolt holes are usually drilled.
punched holes only in materials whose yield
stress (fy) does not exceed 360 MPa and where
thickness does not exceed (5600/fy) mm.
Bolt holes are made larger than the bolt
diameter to facilitate erection.
Oversize holes should not exceed 1.25d or (d+8)
mm in diameter, where d is the nominal bolt
diameter in mm.
Slotted hole [provided to accommodate
movements) should not exceed 1.33d in length
(for short slotted hole) and 2.5 d in length (for
long slotted hole).
37
38
39
40
Typical Bolted Connections
41
Behavior of Bolted Joints
As soon as the load is applied, there is a very small friction at the
interface; slip occurs and the force is transferred from bolts to other
elements through bearing of bolts.
Once the bolts are in bearing, the connection will behave linearly,
until yielding takes place at the following:
1. At the net section of the plate(s) under combined tension and
flexure.
2. On the bolt shear plane(s)
3. In bearing between the bolt and the side of the hole.
43
Behaviour of HSFG Bolted Connection
44
Force Transmission Through Bolts
(Trahair et al, 2001)
45
POSSIBLE FAILURE MODES
47
Bearing Failure of Bolt
48
Tension failure of bolts
The image part with relationship ID rId3 was not found in the file.
55
Bearing resistance
56
The bearing resistance Fb,Rd for bolts
– in oversized holes is 0.8 times the bearing resistance for
bolts in normal holes.
– in slotted holes, where the longitudinal axis of the slotted
hole is perpendicular to the direction of the force transfer, is
0.6 times the bearing resistance for bolts in round, normal
holes.
57
Tension resistance
58
Prying Forces in Beam-Column
Connection
59
Failure Modes Due to
Prying Forces
60
Additional Force in Bolt
due to Prying
The additional force Q in the
bolt due to prying action:
lv βγf obet 4 βf o
Q = [ ][Te − 2
] le = 1.1t
2le 27lelv fy
• γ = 1.5
61
Bolts With Shear and Tension
• A circular
2
interaction
2
curve
V Te
+ ≤ 1.0
Vsd Tnd
V = Applied factored shear
Vsd = Design shear strength
Te = Externally applied
factored tension
Tnd = Design tension strength
62
Block shear Failure
Block tearing consists of failure in shear at the row of
bolts along the shear face of the hole group accompanied by
tensile rupture along the line of bolt holes on the tension face
of the bolt group.
63
Typical Block Shear Failure
64
Block Shear Strength
65
Case Study: Kemper Arena collapse
On June 4, 1979
severe wind
(110 km/h) and rain
storm (108 mm)
caused a portion (61
by 66 m )of Kemper
Arena's roof to
collapse
source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kemper_Arena
The secondary steel plane trusses were supported by the
space frame by pipe hangers at 42 different panel points.
Each of these hangers carried 622 kN in tension. the roof was
designed to hold water as a temporary reservoir.
66
Details of the Kemper Arena Hanger Assembly
68
Lap Joints
69
Butt Joints
70
Typical Truss Connections
Block shear model may
be used to predict the
ultimate capacity of
gusset plate
connections in tension.
Local buckling may be
prevented , by
restricting the
unsupported edge of a
gusset plate to 42ε
times the thickness,
where ε= (250 / fy)0.5.
71
Case Study:
Mississippi River Bridge
Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I-35W_Mississippi_River_bridge
72
73
74
75
Clip and Seating Angle Connections
(Angle seat Connection )
Cleat angle –lateral / torsion restraint
– lateral stability.
Beam reaction- bearing, shear, and
bending of horizontal leg – seat angle.
Horizontal force – Connection
between the vertical leg and column.
Beam is designed for simply support
and column is designed for eccentric
beam reaction.
Clearance – 2mm to 5 mm between-
Maximum Bearing .
Clip and Seating Angle Connections
(Angle seat Connection )
Minimum length of bearing at edge
of root radius = Reaction / (web
thickness x design strength of web) .
Seat angle – unstiffened-shear force
–Column bolts.
Outstanding leg – stiffened- beam
reaction is too large & no enough
bearing is provided.
Beam web – stiffened to resist
shear and bearing .
Stiffened Seat Angle
89
Eccentrically loaded connections
M* = Pe
Tensile force in
extreme critical bolt Direct
Assume NA below Shear
the last bolt
Eccentric load causing bending moments
(Bracket-Type II Connection)
Column may need additional stiffeners. Such as web stiffners, diagonal stiffners , web
plate .
Deep beams to slender columns – haunced connections provided .
Bending of end plate – Prying action-increases bolt load upto 30% .
Flange-Angle Connection
98
T-stub connection
I section – used to clip the flange of the I Section.- connection
bolts will be in tension.
Prying action- bolts connecting T with the column flange .
Only two bolts can be provided in one gauge length – if more
than one- non-uniform forces – transfer only limited moments .
Bracket connection
More rigid – fabrication cost is high
101
Beam-to-Beam Connections
102
Moment Resistant
Beam-to-Beam Connections
103
BEAM AND COLUMN SPLICES
Rolled beams, plate girder and columns are spliced due to several
reasons,
Full length may not be available form the mill
105
Types of Beam-Splices
COLUMN SPLICING
108
Bolted Column Splice
109
Column Splices
Using End-Plates
110