Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
CONTENTS
About: Brent Baxter
About: Man vs. Row
Select Cuts
Intro
Outro
Are You Ready To Make Your Songs Cut/able?
manvsrow.com
About: Brent Baxter
My first cut came in early 2004, when “Monday Morning Church” was recorded by Alan
Jackson. This was my dream come true! The song went on to become a top five hit,
honored as one of NSAI’s “Songs I Wish I’d Written.” In early 2005, I signed my first
publishing deal, becoming a staff songwriter for Major Bob Music. Bob Doyle (“Major
Bob”) is Garth Brooks‘ manager, so signing a publishing deal with him was another too-
good-to-be-true moment. That deal has yielded cuts by artists including Lady
Antebellum, Randy Travis, and Lonestar.
In 2009 and 2010, I wrote for a joint venture of Peer Music and RPM Music. That deal
has yielded cuts by Joe Nichols, Ray Stevens, Charles Billingsley, Randy Kohrs, and
others.
From 2010 through 2012, I was the flagship writer for Infinity Music Group. This deal
yielded a #1 and CCMA Single Of The Year by Canadian star Gord Bamford, as well as
cuts by comedy legend Ray Stevens, guitar legend Steve Cropper, Andy Griggs, Buddy
Jewell, Ruthie Collins, and James Dupre’, among others.
manvsrow.com
I currently write for my own publishing company, Cowboy Chords Music, and I’m actively
writing and pitching my songs.
I live outside of Nashville with my wife, Emily, and my kids, Ozark “Ozzy” and Ruby
Jean.
manvsrow.com
About: Man vs. Row
It’s my hope that Man vs. Row will be helpful to everyone from the songwriting novice to
the seasoned pro. Topics range far and wide- business, craft, inspiration, writing
prompts, and whatever else catches my interest. You can check it out at:
www.manvsrow.com
manvsrow.com
Select Cuts
“Crickets”
Writers: Brent Baxter, Lisa Shaffer, Bill Whyte
Artist: Joe Nichols
Album: “Crickets” Red Bow
“A Woman Scorned”
Writers: Brent Baxter, Hillary Scott, Casey Koesel, Jon Armstrong
Artist: Lady Antebellum
Album: “Lady Antebellum” Capitol Nashville
Note: The song was a digital bonus track.
manvsrow.com
“Last Night Last”
Writers: Brent Baxter, Hillary Scott, Charles Kelley, Dave Haywood
Artist: Lady Antebellum
Album: “Need You Now” Capitol Nashville
Note: The song is an exclusive bonus track for iTunes Europe.
“Tough”
Writers: Brent Baxter, Brent Anderson, Joel Shewmake
Artist: Lonestar
Album: “Party Heard Around The World” Saguaro Road Records
Note: The song is an exclusive bonus track for Wal-Mart.
manvsrow.com
“Right Reverend Roadhog McGraw”
Writers: Brent Baxter, Matt Cline, Anthony Orio
Artist: Ray Stevens
Album: “One For The Road” Clyde Records
Album: “A Funny Thing Happened In Church Today” Clyde
Records
“Caribou Barbie”
Writers: Brent Baxter, Matt Cline, Max T. Barnes
“Fly Over Country”
Writers: Brent Baxter, Tim Meitzen
Artist: Ray Stevens
Album: “We The People” Clyde Records
“Vintage”
Writers: Brent Baxter, Ruthie Collins, Jessica Roadcap
Artist: Ruthie Collins
Album: “Ruthie Collins” Curb Records
manvsrow.com
INTRO
manvsrow.com
Here you go!
Here’s your copy of “Think Like A Pro Songwriter!” I appreciate that you’ve trusted me
and Man vs. Row with some of your valuable time. If you’re like me, more things are
competing for your attention than ever before. So it means a lot to me that you’re here
right now, reading this. I’ll do my best to not waste a single minute of your time.
The goal of this book is to give you valuable insights into the mind of a pro songwriter.
It’s my hope that you’ll adopt many, if not all, of these mindsets. Why? Because if you
want to BE a pro songwriter, you have to THINK like a pro songwriter.
Can I guarantee you a cut or a career as a pro? No. Nobody can guarantee anything in
this business. But I believe the information and mindsets in this book (and on my blog
at www.manvsrow.com) will help you act like a pro and increase your chances of
success.
I’d write a longer intro for you, but... hey... I’m a songwriter. I’m used to saying things in
as few words as possible.
God Bless,
Brent
manvsrow.com
“The Pro” Knows
So, how does “The Pro” think, and why should that matter to you? Simply put, if you
want to BE a pro, you need to think like The Pro. “The Pro” is a songwriter who gets
cuts, is respected in the industry, and maintains long-term success in the business.
“The Pro” is a composite figure made from professional songwriters I’ve written with
over the years, successful writers I’ve studied from a distance, and lessons I’ve learned
from personal experience. I hope you find it helpful.
" Eventually, those rejections start turning into more open doors. In a weird way,
" you have to see it as a certain kind of success when your songs start getting
" rejected by people further and further up the ladder. [I remember in my first
! month in Nashville that I’d gotten to know a songplugger named Tracy.
! One day she told me that she played one of my songs for Tim McGraw,
! but he passed. I was thrilled! Tim McGraw had heard my song!!!
! That was farther than any of my songs had ever gotten before, so that
! rejection was actually a victory.]
" Eventually, if you’re one of the fortunate few, “no” will turn to “yes” every now and
" then. But even a “yes” is often disappointing. “Yes, they cut it, but it’s on a
" no-name artist.” “Yes, they cut it, but the record never came out.” “Yes, but it’s
" a bonus track that’s almost impossible to find.” [I’ve had all those happen to
! me a !few times each.]
" The Pro knows that you have to be patient. You have to endure. Sure, you’re
" going to get frustrated. You’re going to get disappointed again and again. But
" you have to keep getting back up. You have to keep all of that stuff outside the
" writing room. You have to keep your head down and keep working. You have to
" keep believing.
manvsrow.com
2. The Pro knows... it’s a relationship business.
" Story of a cut is, in many ways, the story of relationships. “I knew this guy who
" knew the producer...” Songs travel through relationships. (Sure, there might be
" an oddball story here and there like Blake Shelton cutting “God Gave Me You”
" after he heard Dave Barnes’ version on the radio- but those are rare.)
"
" The seasoned pro knows that to have the best chance of success, he needs to
" have as many good relationships in the biz as possible. He wants to have a
" good songplugger pitching his songs. He wants to know as many producers and
" A&R people as possible. He wants to know the managers. He wants to know -
" and write with - the artist’s cowriting buddies. And, ultimately, he wants to know
" and be cowriting buddies with the artists themselves. [I wrote “When Your
! Lips Are So Close” with the producer and the artist. It became a #1
! hit in Canada. I never would’ve had a shot at getting on that project if I
! hadn’t known Byron Hill, the producer.]
" Good relationships provide two invaluable assets: information and access. [A
! cowriting buddy of mine has a record deal on a major label in town.
! He’s working and writing toward his first record. Since I know him and
! I’ve spent a lot of time in the writer’s room with him, I know that the
! label’s official “we’re looking for ___ kind of song” for him is not very
! accurate. So everyone who is just going by the official blurb is barking
! up the wrong tree. Also, because we’re friends, I have a good idea
! about what he will and won’t sing about. So I’m able to write songs
! WITH him that are aimed right AT him. Plus, if I write a song that I
! think is good for him, I can email it to him or play it for him at our
! next cowrite.]
" Having more relationships in the biz gives a writer more advantages. Therefore,
" The Pro takes time - and considers it a part of doing business - to develop
" relationships with others in the music biz.
manvsrow.com
" ALMOST right, but you can’t put your finger on what is wrong. The last bit of
" polish on your diamond might be the most difficult, but The Pro knows that’s
" where you get the best shine. Or maybe you really like your song, but your
" publisher thinks you need to take another look at it. [It’s not fun when that
! happens. But I’ve also seen a lot of my songs get better because I
! went back in.] The Pro will do the work.
" Not every songwriter loves going out to writers nights to network. And I’m sure
" there’s not a writer out there who loves to sit across from a producer or A&R rep
" and have them turn off their “best” song halfway through the first chorus. But The
" Pro does those things anyway. He knows he has to be disciplined to have
" sustained success.
" Being disciplined also means taking the time to take a step back from the fun and
" busyness of writing, cowriting, and demoing to do an honest evaluation of your
" songwriting business. There’s a difference between working IN your business
" and working ON your business. Working in your business includes writing and
" demoing. Working on your business might include replacing certain cowriters
" with new cowriters or deciding to write more uptempo positive love songs. Both
" are vital. The Pro seeks out the BEST thing to do, not just the NEXT thing to do.
" Well, it isn’t the 90’s anymore. It’s almost impossible to find a new 3-act play on
" country radio. It’s equally difficult to find a singer being goofy or a male singer
" being very sensitive. Right now, almost everything is about young boys and girls
" in trucks on dirt roads. And that will change in time, too.
" The Pro knows it isn’t wise to only write one type of song in one certain way.
" That’s putting all your eggs in one basket- and Nashville is ALWAYS knocking
" baskets around. It’s good to be musically curious- to listen to things outside of
" country. See what’s going on in other genres, see if there’s something cool you
" can incorporate into a song. It’s important to keep things fresh.
manvsrow.com
" For example, Bobby Braddock is a Hall of Fame songwriter. He wrote arguably
" the greatest country song ever, “He Stopped Loving Her Today.” But Bobby
" hasn’t spent the last few decades trying to write another version of that song. In
" fact, he wrote “I Wanna Talk About Me” for Toby Keith. It’s hard to imagine those
" songs coming from the same planet, much less from the same mind. But he did
" it. Another good example is “Whisperin’” Bill Anderson. He started out as an
" artist, but he’s transitioned into a Hall of Fame songwriter. He’s written several
" #1 singles over several decades. You don’t achieve that level of success by
" getting stuck in your ways.
5. The Pro knows... it’s not your job to write songs- it’s
your job to write songs that monetize.
" A songwriter can write all the songs in the world, but if those songs don’t make
" enough money, that writer will soon be back waiting tables or selling cars. To
" be a pro, your songs HAVE to make money. It’s a subtle but profound difference
" in mindset. “It’s my job to write songs” and “It’s my job to write money-making
" songs” will each lead you to make different choices on a daily basis.
" There’s a big difference between a quarterback who steps onto the field and
" says, “My job is to throw passes” and a quarterback who says, “My job is to throw
" passes that move us down the field and get us into the end zone.” If he thinks
" his job is just to throw passes, he is measuring success too early. After all, his
" pass could be incomplete or even intercepted. If that happens enough, he’s
" going to end up sitting by himself on the far end of the bench.
" No, The Pro knows his job is to write songs that turn into points on the
" scoreboard. This is going to affect which song ideas he writes, who he writes
" with, and the creative choices he makes while writing. It also affects what he
" does AFTER he writes a song, which brings me to the next thing The Pro knows.
manvsrow.com
" Also, the relationships created and strengthened through pitch meetings are
" extremely valuable. They can lead to cowrites with the producer or artist as well
" as more access in general to the artist’s network. The Pro knows that getting his
" face and his songs in front of an A&R rep or producer helps create “brand
" awareness” of him as a writer. No producer is ever going to say, “We really need
" a Joe Hitsmaker song to round out this album” if he doesn’t have any idea who
" Joe Hitsmaker is and what kind of songs he writes.
" This is the same reason Papa John’s works so hard to put their name and pizzas
" in your mind through advertising. When you’re hungry, they want you hungry for
" pizza - and specifically for Papa John’s Pizza. Likewise, when an artist or
" producer is hungry for hits, you want them hungry for YOUR hits.
" The Pro also knows that unless he’s writing with the artist, he’s fighting for one
" (or more) of only a couple slots on the album- and he’s competing against the
" best songwriters in the world. And even if he IS writing with the artist, he knows
" he’s STILL competing against the best songwriters in the world- at least the ones
" who are also writing with the artist. The Pro knows he better bring his best.
" [I admit to being guilty of this one. There were too many times I
! almost coasted when writing with a young artist- as if they weren’t
! writing with really good writers in their other cowrites. Maybe this
! came from years of writing with indie artists who cut a bunch of my
! songs and WEREN’T writing with a lot of other people. Maybe I got
! spoiled and I didn’t know it. Either way, none of those songs got cut.
! Nowadays I always do my very best, never taking a cut for granted. I
! work harder, and I get better results.]
manvsrow.com
" have a steep drop. Otherwise, it’s a low road the whole way. And it is for most
" writers.
" However, in either situation it’s important to watch your money closely. The more
" toys you put on a credit card, the more cuts you have to get to pay for them. The
" bigger the car payment, the less money you’re putting back for a rainy day. And
" even if a hit happens, The Pro knows it might be his only one, so he doesn’t blow
" it.
" The Pro doesn’t let himself get in such bad shape financially that he has to sign
" over his share of a particular song’s copyright to his cowriter’s publisher just to
" cover a $300 demo bill. (If the song becomes a hit, his publisher’s share alone
" could be worth over $100,000.) The Pro will build a lifestyle that doesn’t require
" a hit every other year to cover his bills. [I’m a fan of Dave Ramsey. If
! you’re interested in watching your money like The Pro, I suggest you
! check out www.daveramsey.com.]
" Cowriters are very important. The right cowriter can be a huge asset by being a
" talented writer, a great songplugger and a networking powerhouse. Or he could
" be a lazy writer and so toxic that nobody wants to have anything to do with him,
" including his songs. Publishers are very important, too. Does The Pro go with
" the first publisher that offers decent money, or does he hold out for the best mix
" of draw, songplugging, and support? Or does The Pro want to hire an
" independent songplugger and keep his publishing? These can be tough
" decisions with no clear answer, but The Pro knows to be patient and discerning.
" Each person on your team, each cowriter, songplugger, etc., is like an individual
" stock in your portfolio. Each is an investment in terms of your time, creativity,
" energy, and opportunity. Invest in a bunch of bum stocks and you’ll go broke.
" Invest in the right stocks and the value of your portfolio might go through the roof.
manvsrow.com
10. The Pro knows... they really DO want positive-
uptempo-love songs!
" The Pro knows that to maintain success over the long haul, he has to
" consistently provide artists / labels / radio with what they want, which is usually
" positive-uptempo-love. It’s really as simple as that. The Pro looks at
" industry tip sheets and sees that pretty much every artist on there is either
" looking for “uptempo positive” or “hits.” And, of course, most hits are “uptempo
" positive.”
" The Pro doesn’t spend all his time trying to push songs that the industry and
" the listener don’t want. The Pro knows he must balance his uniqueness as an
" individual and creative person with the wants and needs of a mass market. The
" Pro isn’t afraid to be outside the box, but The Pro respects the box.
" Yes, the writer must bring something unique that gives the artist’s team a reason
" to pick his songs, but The Pro remembers that his songs are written for an
" audience of millions, not just written for himself. The artist knows he doesn’t
" ALWAYS have to write positive-uptempo-love, but he knows that’s where most of
" the money is.
In Conclusion...
I hope this insight into The Pro’s mind has been helpful. True, not every professional
songwriter thinks the way I’ve described. Some might even advocate thinking the
opposite on a point or two. But on the whole, on average, I think this is pretty accurate.
Now go, write great songs, and enjoy your songwriting journey!
God Bless,
Brent
manvsrow.com
A HIT SONGWRITER’S ADVICE TO
ASPIRING WRITERS
Now, I certainly don’t know everything about songwriting and how to get cuts- if I did, I’d
be writing a song on a beach somewhere today. But I have been blessed with enough
success and educated by enough failures to learn a few things. So here’s some free
advice to help you gain some of the same successes and avoid some of the same
failures.
5. Be intentional.
" If you enjoy songwriting, it’s easy to get caught up in playing- writing with
" whoever comes along, demoing whatever song tickles your fancy, pitching
" sporadically. You need to be intentional. You need to have a purpose to your
" actions. Otherwise, you could end up being like an octopus on roller skates-
" there’s a lot of activity, but you’re not getting anywhere.
manvsrow.com
6. Choose your song ideas carefully.
" Don’t just write the first idea that pops into your head or the first one your cowriter
" throws out. Without having analysis paralysis, try to write the best idea you can
" find- the idea best suited to help you achieve your goals.
manvsrow.com
THE BAND IS A BRAND.
ARE YOU BRAND CONSCIOUS?
This is the part of songwriting I didn’t know I was signing up for- the business, strategic
side of things. Sure, I have my MBA, but I really just wanted to write my songs and
have them pitched by somebody to somebody and- whammo! Cuts. But the world is
how it is, not how I wish it were. So now I think about artists as brands and try to act
accordingly.
An artist is a brand, and they and their team (label, promotion, management) work really
hard to position their brand (artist) into a certain place in the market. In business terms,
they want to increase their market share- on radio and in our wallets. Everything
supports the brand image: album artwork and photos, songs, videos, etc.
If you can write a song that really fits an artist’s brand, you have a great opportunity.
Think about “Real Good Man” for Tim McGraw. What a great song for him. Musically, it
fits him well. Great feel, and Tim can sing it. Lyrically, that’s totally his persona- a real
bad boy, but a real good man.
The artist is Coke. Their songs are Coke Classic, Cherry Coke, Coke Zero, Diet Coke,
etc. They want songs that both reinforce and expand their brand. They may want
Cherry Vanilla Coke or Raspberry Coke or something. Your song needs to fit on the
same shelf. Your song may be the best $200 bottle of wine to be found, but it doesn’t
matter. That artist is Coke.
Luke Bryan is married with children. (So was Al Bundy, but that’s a different topic
altogether.) Anyway, Luke has a family, but you wouldn’t know it from listening to his
manvsrow.com
music. His music presents him as Spring Breakin’ tailgatin’ good ‘ol party-boy who loves
the ladies. I believe there’s only one song in which he has a wife and kids. But that
was on his first album before he really found his image/voice/brand. And it wasn’t a
single. Since he found his image, he has really stuck to it. And who can blame him?
It’s working great.
It’s not about what you think they should sing or who they
should be
... or where you think they should go as an artist. Unless you’re in their circle of
influence, it doesn’t really matter what you want. Sorry.
I’ve mainly focused on lyrical content, but the music has to fit the artist’s brand, too.
Miranda Lambert isn’t likely to cut a song that sounds like Shania Twain no matter how
well the lyric fits her. Ask yourself: is this song the right kind of pop? The right shade of
country?
The lyric and melody BOTH have to work for the artist.
And it’s important to remember that these brands change over time. They aren’t locked
in forever. Lonestar was one thing before “Amazed,” and another thing after. Toby
Keith was one thing before “How Do You Like Me Now” and another thing after. Kenny
Chesney had a slower, but no less important transition to beaches and nostalgia. So
don’t lock a brand in your mind with super glue. Make sure to look for the shifts that are
inevitable.
manvsrow.com
6 THINGS TO ASK YOURSELF BEFORE
PITCHING A SONG
Let’s say you have the opportunity to pitch to an artist. Maybe Aunt Agnes knows a guy
that mows the lawn of the guy that cuts Blake Shelton’s hair. Or maybe you’re a staff
writer who knows you shouldn’t leave all the pitching to your plugger. Either way, you
want to make the most of your pitches. Here are some questions to ask as you’re going
through your songs.
4. Is it a quality recording?
" I’ve gotten cuts from demos. I’ve gotten cuts from good guitar/vocals. But
" unless it’s something I wrote with the artist, I’ve never gotten a cut off a worktape.
" There are writers that can pitch a worktape, but they’ve had enough success that
" the listener expects to hear a great song because of who wrote it. Also, they can
" probably play it directly for the artist or producer. Depending on how close you
" are to the project, your song may have to get past an A&R intern, a production
" assistant, and who knows who else before it can get to someone who can give
" you the “Big Yes.” I personally don’t count on every person in that chain to be
" able to hear through a worktape- especially when it’s sandwiched between
" great-sounding demos.
manvsrow.com
5. Is this song a step into the artist’s future?
" Right after Brad Paisley hit with “The Fishing Song,” he got blasted with fishing
" songs from everywhere. Notice how he STILL hasn’t put another one out as a
" single? I’m sure he didn’t want to get pigeonholed as the fishing guy (although
" that was an important part of his brand at the time). Besides, he can write a
" great fishing song on his own- he doesn’t need to pay me for mine when he can
" make money on his. Successful artists evolve over time. Plenty of writers will be
" pitching them their LAST hit. You need to pitch them their NEXT hit.
I hope this list is helpful for you. It’s not an exhaustive list- each pitch opportunity
comes with it’s own particulars. But I think you’ll be well served to keep these questions
in mind. Happy hunting!
manvsrow.com
10 WAYS TO GET TO A PUBLISHER
It’s hard to get to get a music publisher’s time and attention. There are many reasons
for this, some of which I have discussed elsewhere on the MvR blog. But for now, I
want to share some pathways to a publisher.
manvsrow.com
www.nashvillesongwriters.com www.globalsongwriters.com
I know at this point, you might be more frustrated than you were five minutes ago. Hey,
nobody said this was easy. I just don’t know of any path to a publisher that is quick and
easy (outside of dumb luck). And luck is not a strategy. However, like they say, “The
harder I work, the luckier I get.”
manvsrow.com
8 QUESTIONS TO ASK BEFORE YOU
DEMO THAT SONG
So, you’ve written a stack of songs, and you’ve mowed a bunch of yards to get demo
money. The big question right now is not when to demo, where to demo, or how to
demo. The big question to ask is SHOULD you demo this song? If you thoughtfully and
honestly answer the following questions, you will spend your money more efficiently and
effectively.
2. Is it a wide pitch?
" A wide pitch is a song that fits a large number of artists. A narrow pitch is one
" that only a very limited number of artists could record. For example, if you say, “If
" Dierks Bentley doesn’t cut this, I don’t know who will,” that’s a narrow pitch. As a
" general rule, I’m gonna demo the wide pitches, because there are more pitch
" possibilities.
3. Is it commercially relevant?
" Is this a song that a big audience will want to hear? Will it make the listener
" laugh, cry, dance, or think? It’s not about you- it’s about the audience.
manvsrow.com
6. Will I pitch it... really?
" If you already have ten songs just like this one demoed (and they’re not getting
" cut), and this one isn’t any better... what’s the point? Will you really pitch it?
" Maybe you should spend your time writing a song that you will pitch instead of
" demoing a song you won’t.
8. Is it great?
" I’ve never had a so-so song get pitched to and cut by a major artist. I just
" haven’t. The songs are each different- fast, slow, funny, sad - but, to me, each
" one has something great about it.
Asking these questions before you demo can save you a lot of time and money in the
long run. It’s not easy to be honest with yourself, but it’s the best thing you can do for
your career.
manvsrow.com
10 REASONS SONGWRITERS SHOULD
PITCH THEIR OWN SONGS
When I signed my first publishing deal with Major Bob Music, I thought, “This is great! I
can just sit in my writer’s room, write every day, and let our three songpluggers pitch my
songs and get ‘em cut.” This was a mistake. Not that Scot, Mike, and Jesse weren’t
smart, hardworking guys who wanted me to succeed. No, those guys worked hard for
all of their writers. It was a mistake because I spent the first couple years of that deal
missing out on the benefits of pitching my own songs. Here are ten benefits.
1. My odds improve.
" It’s HARD to get cuts, so I want all hands on deck. Simply put, the more songs of
" mine that are getting pitched, the better the chance of the right song hitting the
" right ears at the right time.
manvsrow.com
6. It builds my personal brand.
" An A&R rep may hear five of my songs in a day from five different sources.
" That’s great, but they might never know those are my songs. They might
" associate the songs with my cowriters or the publishers who brought them. If it’s
" ME in the room, though, the rep hears several of my songs in a row and gets to
" put my face with the name on the CD. And I get to do the same, which is handy
" if I see them out at an industry function. Oh, and I hopefully get them to like me
" as a person, which never hurts.
So, there you go. My top ten reasons songwriters should pitch their own songs. Now,
please forget everything you just read- I don’t need the extra competition!
manvsrow.com
6 SIMPLE WAYS TO MAKE YOUR
SONGS MORE COMMERCIAL
If your goals are like mine- getting cuts, hits, etc., then your best bet is by writing well-
crafted COMMERCIAL songs. Here are six simple (though not always easy) ways to
make your songs more commercial.
1. Write uptempo.
" Learn to write tempo! If you don’t believe how important this is, count the ballads
" on the radio for an hour. Or listen to a few of the current top albums and count
" the ballads. Knock, knock. Who’s there? Math. Math, who? Math says they cut
" a lot more uptempo and midtempo that ballads.
2. Write positive.
" If you’re like me, your natural inclination is to write sad/negative. When I come
" up with a hook, my first instinct is something sad. Maybe for some reason pain is
" just more interesting that happiness. But not for radio. Radio likes happy.
" Knock, knock...
5. Write in-the-moment.
" The present tense- right now- has more power than the past or the future.
" “You’re killing me in that sundress” usually beats “you were killing me in that
" sundress.” There’s power in the present.
There are obviously many hits that weren’t written in the way I’ve described. But, from
both my experience and observations, writing songs with these six qualities as your
default setting will increase the commercial appeal of your songs.
manvsrow.com
BE HELPFUL
Zig Zigler is known for saying, “You can have anything you want out of life as long as
you help enough people get what they want out of life.” Sounds a little counter-intuitive,
right? But it’s true- all of a songwriter’s success is based on helping others get what
they want. Here are a few examples of what people want:
It’s not about getting an artist to help YOU by recording YOUR song that YOU like. It’s
about writing and pitching a song that THE ARTIST has been looking for, that THE
ARTIST wants to sing and will help THE ARTIST take their career a step forward.
I don’t think anyone has ever asked me to write or cut one of my songs only to help ME
out. People write with me and cut my songs to help THEMSELVES out. And, hey, if the
result of them getting what they want is that I also get good cowrites and cuts, I’m fine
with that.
Songwriting is a service business. Improve your service, and you improve your odds of
success.
manvsrow.com
HOW DO YOU KNOW WHO IS LOOKING
FOR SONGS?
After I posted “10 Reasons Songwriters Should Pitch Their Own Songs,” on the MvR
blog, I got a few questions about how to pitch and how to know who’s looking for songs.
Let’s dive into the 2nd part- how to know who’s looking and listening for songs.
1. Personal relationships.
" If you personally know an artist, producer or label A&R, they can tell you if they’re
" actively listening for a project. And they MIGHT even know what they need and
" when they need it. But remember, any info is always subject to change at a
" moment’s notice.
2. Industry chatter.
" If you can’t get the scoop directly from the horse’s mouth, publishers and other
" songwriters are always talking. Keep your ear to the ground, and don’t be afraid
" to ask questions.
4. Liner notes.
" If an artist is doing well, you know they’re gonna make another album. And
" they’ll probably be looking real hard when they’re on the second or third single
" from their current album. Check the album’s liner notes for the name of their
" label and producer, then do some research for how to find them. Of course, the
" artist may be changing producers for the next album, so you never know for sure.
I hope that helps. I know there’s no magic bullet, but that’s just the way it is. That’s one
reason why writers that have success can keep it going more easily- they have more
accurate information. Good luck out there.
manvsrow.com
THE 4 CORNERSTONES OF
SONGWRITING SUCCESS: W.R.A.P.
I believe there are four cornerstones to professional songwriting success. You can
remember them by the acronym, “W.R.A.P.” They are:
W. Writing
" This one’s pretty obvious. We’re songwriters, after all, aren’t we? If you’re a
" writer... write. If you don’t write, there’s nothing to get recorded. And it’s not
" enough to just write every once in a while. Write hard, write consistently.
R. Recording
" It’s not enough to have scratchy worktapes if you want someone else to cut and
" release your song. You have to get a good recording of your song- one that
" presents it in a good light. This could be a guitar/vocal, a full demo, or something
" in between.
A. Accessing
" A great demo does you no good if you can’t get it into the hands of someone who
" can do something with it. Accessing is building relationships and otherwise
" gaining access to singers, publishers, labels, producers, etc.
P. Pitching
" You have to ask for the cut, as simple as that. You have to give publishers,
" artists, etc. the opportunity to say “yes” to your song.
Note that each of these are cornerstones - you won’t have a stable, well-functioning
career if you neglect one or more of them. I’m not saying you should spend equal hours
on each of these areas, but you should give them the proper amount of time based on
your particular situation.
WRAP is also good for helping you focus on what’s important. If an opportunity comes
up, compare it to WRAP. If that activity doesn’t fall into one of those categories, it might
not be a wise use of your time.
manvsrow.com
5 THINGS SONGWRITERS SHOULD
QUIT
It’s hard to quit. Society says, “never quit.” Or maybe you’ve invested so much in
whatever it is that you feel it’s too late to quit. Pride doesn’t want you to move on. But
sometimes, the only way to win is to quit. Here are 5 things songwriters should quit
doing.
1. Toxic relationships.
" If you have “friends” or cowriters who habitually belittle your dreams or always
" point out why something won’t work, it might be time to find new friends and
" cowriters. Yes, we need people that love us enough to be honest with us even
" when it’s unpleasant. But some people are energy vampires who will only drag
" you down. Figure out who’s who, and act accordingly.
2. Whining.
" Don’t be somebody else’s toxic relationship. A negative attitude not only drives
" away positive people, it blinds you to opportunity. If you always focus on the
" closed door, you might miss the open window.
3. Misaligned cowrites.
" You want to write hit country songs, but she wants to write niche novelty songs.
" Or you both want to write hits, but his songs sound like 1952 and he refuses to
" update his sound, meet with publishers, or pitch his songs. These types of
" cowrites are most likely not going to get you to your goals. They conflict will drain
" your energy and enthusiasm. Do you want to bring your best, most commercial
" ideas to these cowriters? Probably not. So if you can’t bring 100% to the
" cowrite, maybe you should find new cowriters.
4. Lazy artists.
" An aspiring artist may have a great voice and be a good writer, but if they don’t
" want it badly enough, it doesn’t matter. If they don’t take their career seriously,
" you can’t take their career seriously, either.
manvsrow.com
Part of the advantage of quitting is that it makes room in your life for better things.
Negative relationships can be replaced with inspiring relationships. Misaligned cowrites
can be replaced with properly-aligned cowrites. Lazy artists can be replaced with
serious artists. The time and money you spend on mediocre songs can be spent
finding, writing, and demoing better songs.
Win by quitting.
manvsrow.com
INSIDE VS OUTSIDE SONGS -
AND WHY IT MATTERS
When an artist is working on a project (album), there are two types of songs which will
(or will not) be considered: inside songs and outside songs. So what are these?
I had two songs cut on Ray Stevens’ “We The People” album. One song was a true
inside song. “Caribou Barbie” was written at Ray’s request with two of his staff writers.
The other song, “Fly Over Country” was an outside pitch. However, since Ray didn’t
advertise that he was doing a record, I never would’ve known to pitch a song (much less
that song in particular) without some inside information. I’ve also had two Lady
Antebellum cuts (bonus tracks, sadly). “A Woman Scorned” was written with Hillary
Scott, and “Last Night Last” was written with all three members of Lady A. Almost every
song on that first album was written or cowritten by the band, so it definitely put those
songs in a better competitive position.
manvsrow.com
This is not to say that ONLY inside songs get cut. I’ve had some outside songs get cut,
too. “Monday Morning Church” was written before either my cowriter, Erin Enderlin, or I
had ever had a cut, and only Erin was working with a publisher at the time. Erin’s
publisher played the song for Alan Jackson’s producer, who played it for Alan. Same
thing for my Joe Nichols cut- I sent “Crickets” to the head of Joe’s record label (whom
I’ve never even met). He loved it and sent it to Joe. The song became an outside cut.
So, yes, both inside and outside songs still get cut. But inside songs have the inside
track- pun intended.
manvsrow.com
THE ARTIST’S CAMP
You may hear about songwriters trying to get into an artist’s “camp.” What does that
mean? Well, it’s not a place to unroll a sleeping bag and sing your songs around a
campfire.
Each artist has their own camp, and it’s often hard to know who really has the artist’s
ear. For example, the A&R person for Artist A may be a big influence on what gets cut,
but Artist B may not care at all what his A&R person thinks.
Think of it like a dart board. The artist is the bullseye (usually- though sometimes the
producer or label head REALLY makes the final decision on what gets cut). The
members of the artist’s camp occupy the various concentric circles around the bullseye.
The closer to the bullseye, the more influence that person has over the project.
If you’re looking to get into an artist’s camp, it’s good to figure out the layout of their
dartboard if possible. And remember, nothing gets you in a camp like GENUINE
friendship. If you’re just using the artist, it’ll be really hard to get past the outer edges of
the dartboard.
Good luck!
manvsrow.com
THE ARTIST’S CAMP:
MULTIPLE POINTS OF CONTACT
Gaining access (and keeping access) to an artist is kind of like rock climbing- you
always want to have more than one point of contact with the mountain. It’s a dangerous
thing to be hanging by one hand- if that one rock gives way or that hand slips... bye,
bye.
Likewise, if your only point of contact with an artist is her producer, what happens if she
switches producers? What happens if you have a light point of contact with the artist
herself, but she starts letting her A&R person or publisher book all her cowrites because
she’s too busy out on the road? Bye, bye. You might’ve just fallen off the mountain.
This kind of stuff has happened to me, so I’ve learned the hard way not to rely on only
one point of contact with the artist. Nowadays, if I’m targeting an artist or a project, I try
to secure multiple points of contact. If I know the A&R person, I try to develop a contact
with the producer as well. If I’m writing with an artist, I’ll suggest a 3-way cowrite with
one of their other regular cowriters. Basically, I want to surround the artist. I want to dig
in deeper than a tick in a dog’s ear so there’s no way they can scratch or shake me off!
Of course, you want to balance the time you spend surrounding one artist with taking
time to develop other points of contact in other artists’ camps. Just like you want to
have more than one point of contact with an artist, you want to be in more than one
artist’s camp. Think of it as diversifying your portfolio. After all, most new artists aren’t
very successful. What happens if the one artist you’ve invested all your time in fails?
Bye, bye.
manvsrow.com
YOU MUST HAVE INVISIBLE TALENT
The music business is frustrating. Why aren’t the best singers always the biggest
stars? Why aren’t the best songs always the biggest hits?
Same goes for songwriting. Maybe you have a high level of craft, but your songs are
oranges when most folks only want apples. Or maybe you’re unreliable and difficult so
pros don’t let you into their inner circles.
Or maybe you’re good and getting better but just haven’t connected with the right
people yet.
What I’m saying is, it takes more than visible talent. By “visible talent,” I mean the part
that the outsider can easily see. You sing great or put on a great live show or write
great songs. Don’t get me wrong- visible talent is a must if you’re going to get to the
top. But you also need the invisible talent. Talent like people skills, drive,
determination, grit, good business sense, good commercial sense, etc.
Think of a house. It might look big and beautiful from the outside (visible talent). But if
it sits on a foundation made of sand or it’s eaten up with termites (invisible talent), it’s
just a matter of time until a storm blows it down.
So, yes- work to improve your visible talent. But also work on your invisible talent. You
need both.
manvsrow.com
WHAT IS YOUR ENDPOINT?
At different times in my songwriting history (and I guess I’ve been doing this long
enough to officially consider it “history”) I’ve had various “endpoints.”
What is an endpoint?
The endpoint is the basic target your efforts try to hit. It’s
where you focus your effort and where most of your effort
ends. It’s the horizon you don’t often look past.
When I first started out, my endpoint was a finished song and a worktape. It felt great,
and I had a sense of accomplishment and something to listen to. I dreamed of hearing
one of those songs on the radio. But pretty much all I did about that part was dream.
Years later, after I had moved to Nashville, my endpoint was to impress a publisher so
they’d start pitching my songs. Sure, I dreamed of getting songs on the radio, but on a
day-to-day basis, I didn’t work at anything beyond landing a good publisher relationship.
Later still, I had a publishing deal and my endpoint was often getting my publisher to
demo songs so THEY could pitch them. I’d even had a hit on the radio by this time, but
I couldn’t really see beyond the demo.
These days, my endpoint is the farthest it’s ever been. The endpoint now is getting cuts
and singles. I’m writing with just a few artists and the conversation and work centers on
getting songs on their records and on the radio. Demos, if they’re discussed at all, are
recorded to pitch to the artist’s label for their own record. (If it doesn’t make their record,
then we’ll pitch it around. But that’s Plan B.)
Sure, I’ve worked for years to get to the point where it’s realistic to talk about cuts and
singles. But how much further would I be in my career if hits had ALWAYS been the
endpoint?
Instead of aiming at just writing songs, what if the endpoint had been writing songs that
an artist would want to sing? (And not just writing what I wanted to say?)
Instead of effectively washing my hands and walking away when a song got demoed,
what if I kept going, getting my demos in the hands of decision-makers myself?
Instead of playing that demo for an A&R rep and then letting off the gas, what if I kept
working to get the song to the people who made the final decision?
manvsrow.com
Instead of being happy to just write with a baby artist, what if I had really focused on
writing that deal-getter with that artist?
Most of the endpoints I’ve ever had have not been set consciously. There were just set
at the next song or the next step in my career.
And those steps (write, publisher, demo, etc.) are each good steps. But they are each
just steps on a staircase. If those steps are your focus, where your attention and
energy is focused... you might just miss an elevator with its doors wide open.
I encourage you to take a look at your goals for your writing- then take an honest
assessment of where your attention and energy is focused. Have you set your endpoint
where only a milemarker should be? Milemarkers are great- they mark progress and
keep you feeling motivated.
manvsrow.com
6 SONGWRITING TIEBREAKERS
Let’s say you’ve written a very, very good song and it’s on hold for an artist named Luke
Paisley. It’s down to your song and one other as to what they’re gonna cut. The artist
likes both songs, so it’s basically a tie going in. That’s when the tiebreakers might kick
in. These tiebreakers may include...
1. Personal relationships.
" Is one of the songs written or published by a friend of the artist? It’s more fun to
" call your buddy and say you just cut his song than it is to explain that you didn’t.
2. Business interests.
" Would a publisher, manager, or someone else owe the artist or feel thankful if the
" artist cut one song over the other? Is there some hidden long-term advantage to
" be gained? Or would the artist or producer be returning a favor by cutting a
" particular song?
3. Financial interests.
" If the artist is a writer or publisher on one of the songs, he makes more money by
" recording that one.
4. Safer bets.
" If one song is written by a proven hit songwriter and the other isn’t, the artist (and
" his team) may lean towards the hit writer’s song. Since it’s always a little bit of a
" guessing game as to which songs are hits, a song written by a hit writer feels like
" a safer bet.
5. Branding.
" Does one song fit the artist and his brand a little better? Will it speak to his
" audience in a way that’s a little more “on point?” That can make the difference.
" Or is one song too much like what he’s already recorded, and it doesn’t take him
" anywhere new?
6. Singability.
" Is one song more easy or fun to sing?
manvsrow.com
Now, you obviously can’t control which songs are your competition. You just have to do
what you can to give your songs the best chance to win.
Write the very best song you can. Always. But also spend time thinking about the
tiebreakers and how you can turn them in your favor. It’s not easy, and it won’t happen
overnight. But as you are mindful of this stuff as you build your career, it’ll pay off big
time down the road.
manvsrow.com
ARE YOU TAKING OWNERSHIP OF
YOUR SONGWRITING SUCCESS?
Are you just hoping for success? Waiting on the universe to give you what it’ll give you?
Or are you taking responsibility (ownership) for it?
It’s easy and tempting to wait and hope for your cowriters, publishers, or manager (or
ASCAP or NSAI...) to make something happen on your behalf. And while these people
can be a valuable part of your team, they will never have as much riding on your
success as you do. They have their own families to feed.
I know there’s a lot of uncertainty surrounding the music biz. There’s not a simple 1-2-3
process for earning success. And since it’s often unclear how to make success, it’s
easy to become passive.
manvsrow.com
SHOW ME YOUR SONGWRITING
FRIENDS, AND I’LL SHOW YOU YOUR
FUTURE
Yes, I know that probably sounds like something your mother would say. But I think it’s
true. And, if it IS true, it really matters who you let into your inner circle.
Now consider YOUR inner circle- your closest friends, family, cowriters and music
business connections. If the above statements are true, then it really matters what type
of people these folks are.
" If your friends are lazy songwriters, you’re more likely to be a lazy
! songwriter.
! If your inner circle is full of negative complainers, you’ll end up being one,
! too.
! However...
! If your inner circle is full of positive, motivated people, you’ll stay more
! positive and motivated, too.
! If your close friends are pitching songs and networking, you’ll probably do
! more of that, too.
manvsrow.com
In light of this, are there changes you need to make? Obviously, you shouldn’t leave
your family. Nor am I saying that you should never talk to your “happy-with-mediocrity”
friends again. But I am encouraging you to seek out and start spending time with the
go-getters, the achievers, the folks with positive, can-do attitudes.
After all, the people closest to you are the ones who rub
off on you the most.
manvsrow.com
THE UPWARD SPIRAL OF THE
SONGWRITING BIZ
Here’s the upward spiral of songwriting:
Because writers and publishers have a problem. They need hits- either to write them or
to publish them. The better you write, the more potential you have to solve their
problems. People like people who can solve their problems. And they will give you the
opportunity to provide them with hits by writing with them or with someone on their
team. Their problem is your opportunity.
Publishers are more likely to invest in you in two ways: 1) giving you deeper feedback,
speeding up your learning curve and 2) setting you up to write with better writers, which
leads to more learning and better songs. And even without a publisher, you can hook
up with better writers on your own (or through your existing cowriters).
These newer, better songs lead to even better and stronger relationships, which lead to
better songs, which lead to more relationships... you get the idea. It takes time. You
have to be patient, but that’ll be the general trend of your songwriting if you consistently
work to get better and network in a professional manner. It doesn’t just happen, though.
But beware. You can short circuit the upward spiral if you get lazy or don’t treat people
well. Word will get around, and your career will suffer for it. Enjoy the journey!
manvsrow.com
THE VALUE OF A SONGWRITER /
PRODUCER RELATIONSHIP
Everyone tells you about the value of writing with a writer/artist. And, true enough,
those can be very valuable relationships. Write a great song with a writer/artist, and you
have a direct path to a cut.
There’s also another type of “slash” that has a lot of value, too. That’s the writer/
producer. Whereas a writer/artist gives you direct access to that particular artist, a
writer/producer can give you direct access to several artists.
Byron Hill is a hit songwriter with multiple #1s and a ton of cuts. He’s also produced
Gord Bamford’s first several albums. Gord’s a big star in Canada, and he and Byron
cowrite a lot of his songs. Because of my cowriting relationship with Byron, I was able
to write with both of them, leading to 3 cuts and a #1 hit / Single Of The Year.
We wrote a song called, “Five String.” Drew actually didn’t cut that song, but it WAS cut
by another artist, Tristan Horncastle, that Aaron was producing for Sony Canada. Drew
ended up cutting a different song of mine, “Farm Hands,” which he heard through
Aaron. Like I said, one writer/producer can link you to several artists.
Another buddy of mine is Brian Hitt. I’ve written songs with him that have landed on
some of his projects including a Canadian Christmas single for an artist he was
producing and 3 songs on a children’s album that he produced for Brentwood Benson, a
major player in the Christian music world.
And here’s another advantage of writing with a writer/producer: if they have a home
studio, you can get great, cheap demos of your cowrites. Bonus!
manvsrow.com
OUTRO
manvsrow.com
Hey, alright! You did it! I know this wasn’t exactly “War And Peace,” but you finished
(unless you’re a skimmer or a skip-to-the-ender. If that’s you, just go back to the
beginning, and I’ll see you back here in a little bit.)
Are you REALLY going to ask yourself the 8 questions before your next demo, or are
you going to let the excitement of a new song dictate how you spend your money?
Are you going to REALLY consider if the “6 Simple Ways To Make Your Song More
Commercial” fit your idea, or are you just going to write it how it first hits you - how you
always write?
Are you READY to see if you calendar and daily activities fit into W.R.A.P.? Or are you
just going to go where the day and the week takes you?
This is where the hard part starts. This is where you decide whether or not to keep
investing in your career.
Today is when you can decide to begin thinking... and acting... like a pro songwriter.
God Bless,
Brent
manvsrow.com
For more songwriting tips
and info about songwriting
and the music business,
subscribe to my blog at:
www.manvsrow.com
manvsrow.com
READY TO MAKE YOUR SONGS “CUT/ABLE?”
"Cut/Able: Lessons In Market-Smart Songwriting" is four powerful lessons for
songwriters who want cuts & hits, who want to learn how to write commercially
marketable songs, and who want their songs to connect powerfully with both
fans and Music Row pros.
Are you frustrated that your audience isn’t responding to your songs the way you want
them to? Do publishers or song evaluators keep saying your songs aren’t commercial
or that they don’t “fit the market” or they don’t “fit on radio?”
Have you ever asked yourself, “What IS the market? What’s marketable, and how do I
write more marketable songs?”
That’s a frustrating place to be. I know- I’ve been there. I know how it feels to wonder if
there is some secret code written into the songs on the radio- a code nobody has
shared with you. I also realized that it was going to take a lot longer to crack that code
without some guidance, without some help from someone inside the music biz.
Thankfully, I was able to make contacts in the music business, and with a lot of hard
work and trial and error, I’ve been able to write songs that have been recorded by Alan
Jackson (the top 5 hit “Monday Morning Church”), Lady Antebellum, Randy Travis, Joe
Nichols, Lonestar, comedy legend Ray Stevens, guitar legend Steve Cropper, Andy
Griggs, Canadian country star Gord Bamford (the #1 single and 2014 Single Of The
Year “When Your Lips Are So Close”), Curb artist Ruthie Collins and more. And now I
want to share some of what I’ve learned in my 10+ years in the music business.
Cut/able: Lessons In Market-Smart Songwriting exists to help you write songs that fit
the commercial market- songs that are “market-smart.” Each of these four powerful
lessons challenge you to take an in-depth look at current and recent country hits and
compare them to YOUR best songs.
Cut/able isn’t just about “___, ___ and ___ is popular right now, so write that.” No, it’s
much more than that. It’s about teaching you how to study the charts and radio so you
can identify what kind of songs are market-smart at any time.
Cut/able isn't just a book, either. It's a WORKBOOK. It combines sections where I
provide insight and information, but it also has exercises for you to do on your own. In
manvsrow.com
my experience, information is much more valuable when you apply it and learn in a
hands-on way.
This workbook allows you to really dig in and add the characteristics of market-smart
songs to YOUR songs.
Connect on a deeper level with the artist and listener through effective use of
imagery. (Lesson #1: W.I.L.L.power: Proving Personality & Emotions Through
Your Lyrics)
Give the artists what they need, give radio what it wants, and give the fans what
they like by learning the importance of writing positive, uptempo, love/depth
songs. (Lesson #2: P.U.L.’D To Success: The Value of Positive, Uptempo, Love/
Depth Songs)
Develop skills to identify an artist’s “brand” so you can write songs that fit that
brand and speak to the artist’s core audience. (Lesson #3: Neighborhoods: Where
Will You Build A Home For Your Song?)
Pinpoint areas of opportunity within an artist’s catalog- slots you can fill with
your songs, songs that fit the artist’s brand without being just like what they’ve
already done. (Lesson #4: Fill The G.A.P.S.: Growth, Achievement, Preaching/
Positioning, Songwriting)
Start investing in your songwriting career TODAY. The sooner you do, the sooner you’ll
increase the commercial marketability of your songs.
God Bless,
Brent
www.manvsrow.com/store
manvsrow.com
PRAISE FOR "CUT/ABLE"
Wow! What a great, practical book about songwriting for the real world. Read it and,
most importantly, work your way through the exercises and you will learn invaluable
lessons about your own writing and what you need to do to take it to the next level.
Highly recommended.
-- Kate Schutt, singer-songwriter, Grand Prize Winner in the Jazz Category of the John
Lennon Songwriting Competition (2007) and ASCAP Plus Awards for Jazz (2006
through 2009) www.kateschutt.com
Loved Cut/able Brent. This is essential material for the aspiring commercial
songwriters. Fantastic work.
-- Doug Folkins, Songwriter, Courtenay, British Columbia
Cut/able is filled with real insights into the songs being cut today by someone who is
actively getting those cuts himself. It goes beyond broad advice into very specific,
actionable detail on how to write songs that are far more likely to get cut in today's
market and how to find the artists most likely to cut them.
Brent reveals some really common mistakes songwriters make that kill your chances of
getting a cut and processes you can use that multiply your chances that your songs will
find a home.
Cut/able is a must-read for songwriters who are serious about getting cut.
-- Andrew Cavanagh
manvsrow.com
“Think Like A Pro Songwriter”
manvsrow.com