Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Applied Linguistics
LANE 423
Introduction
While we all exhibit inherently human traits of learning, every
individual approaches a problem or learns a set of facts or
organizes a combination of feelings from a unique
Styles and Strategies
perspective
1 in particular contexts.
3 4
Process:
Process, Styles, and Strategy
All human beings engage in certain universal processes.
Just as we all need air, water, and food for our survival, so do
In SLA, what do we mean by the terms: all humans of normal intelligence engage in certain levels or
types of learning.
Process?
Human beings universally engage in association, transfer,
Style?
and generalization.
Strategy? We all make stimulus-response connections and are driven
by reinforcement.
5 6
Style: Style:
It is a term that refers to consistent tendencies or preferences For example:
within an individual. you might be:
Styles are those general characteristics of intellectual more visually oriented,
functioning (and personality type, as well) that
more tolerant of ambiguity,
are directly related to a person as an individual,
more reflective than someone else
differentiate him/her from someone else.
1
7 8
9 10
With a style that tends to be generally tolerant of ambiguity, I first told myself Your solution will be based to a great extent on the styles you
not to get flustered, and to remain calm in spite of my fatigue and frustration. happen to have(e.g. tolerant of ambiguity, reflective, field
My left-brain style told me to take practical, logical steps and to focus only independent, etc.)
on the important details of the moment. If you are tolerant of ambiguity, you will not easily get flustered or
Simultaneously, my sometimes equally strong natural tendency to use a right-
nervous by your unfortunate circumstances.
brain approach allowed me to empathize with airport personnel and to use
If you are reflective, you will exercise patience and not jump quickly
numerous alternative communicative strategies to get messages across.
to a conclusion about how to approach the situation.
I was reflective enough to be patient with miscommunications and my
inability to communicate well, If you are field independent, you will focus on the necessary and
yet impulsive to the extent that I needed to insist on some action as soon as relevant details and not be distracted by surrounding but irrelevant
possible. details.
11 12
The way we learn things in general and the way we attack a So, what are learning styles?
problem seem to depend on a rather vague link between According to Keefe (1979):
personality and cognition.
They are the ―cognitive, affective, and physiological traits
This link is refereed to as Cognitive style that are relatively stable indicators of how learners perceive,
When cognitive styles are specifically related to an interact with, and respond to the learning environment.‖
educational context, where affective and physiological According to Skehan (199):
factors are mixed, they are usually more generally referred to A learning style is "a general predisposition, voluntary or not,
as learning styles. toward processing information in a particular way."
2
13 14
15 16
Ehrman and Leaver (2003) listed the following Learning styles to SLA:
Are styles stable traits in adults?
1. Field independence-dependence
It would appear that:
2. Random (non-linear) vs. sequential (linear)
3. Global vs. particular
Individuals show general tendencies toward one style or
4. Inductive vs. deductive
another
5. Synthetic vs. analytic
6. Analogue vs. digital
However, differing contexts will evoke differing styles in the 7. Concrete vs. abstract
8. Leveling vs. sharpening
same individual.
9. Impulsive vs. reflective
17 18
3
19 20
21 22
you see only the parts and not their relationship to the
you perceive the whole picture, the larger view,
whole.
the general configuration of a problem or idea or
―You can't see the forest for the trees" .
event.
23 24
FI/FD Styles
FI/FD Styles
FI/D literature has shown:
4
25 26
FI/FD Styles
FI/FD Styles
A democratic, industrialized, competitive society with
Cross-culturally, the extent of the development of a
27 28
Persons who are FI tend to be generally more Persons who are FD tend to be:
more socialized
29 30
5
31 32
analysis,
Two conflicting hypotheses emerged.
attention to details,
33 34
Naiman et al. (1978) found in a study of English-speaking 8th, The 2nd Hypothesis:
10th , and 12th graders who were learning French in Toronto
that FI correlated positively and significantly with language
success in the classroom. FD persons will, by virtue of their empathy, social
Other studies (Hansen 1984, Hansen & Stansfield 1983, Hansen outreach, and perception of other people, be
& Stansfield 1981) found relatively strong evidence of a successful in learning the communicative aspects
relationship between FI and cloze test performance, which
of a second language.
requires analytical abilities.
35 36
Very little empirical evidence has been gathered to Which one is important? FD? FI?
support it.
Why?
Both
There are no standardized means of measuring FD.
6
37 38
within the constraints of the classroom (FI). (tendency to one of the two styles),
The 2nd kind of learning implies natural, face-to-face but, given certain contexts, can exercise a sufficient degree
39 40
41 42
Left- and Right- Brain Dominance Left- and Right- Brain Dominance
As the child's brain matures, various functions The left hemisphere is associated with logical, analytical thought,
with mathematical and linear processing of information.
become lateralized to the left or right hemisphere
of the brain. The right hemisphere perceives and remembers visual, tactile, and
auditory images; it is more efficient in processing holistic,
integrative, and emotional information.
7
43 44
Left- and Right- Brain Dominance Left- and Right- Brain Dominance
Although there are many differences between left- The left-/right-brain construct helps to define
and right-brain characteristics, it is important to another useful learning style continuum, with
remember that the left and right hemispheres implications for second language learning and
operate together as a ―team‖. teaching.
45 46
Left- and Right- Brain Dominance Left- and Right- Brain Dominance
Stevick (1982) concluded that:
Studies in 2nd Language Acquisition:
hypothesis that : language, carrying out sequences of operations, and dealing with
abstraction, classification, labeling, and reorganization.
left-brain-dominant second language learners preferred a
right-brain-dominant learners
deductive style of teaching
appear to deal better with whole images , with generalizations, with
right-brain-dominant learners appeared to be more
metaphors, and with emotional reactions and artistic expressions.
successful in an inductive classroom environment
47 48
Left- and Right- Brain Dominance Left- and Right- Brain Dominance
It can be suggested that there could be a greater need to So how do left- and right-brain functioning differs
perceive the whole meaning in the early stages of learning
from FI and FD?
the second language, and to analyze and monitor oneself
more in the later stages.
8
49 50
51 52
53 54
9
55 56
57 58
59 60
They found that learners with a high tolerance for ambiguity were
slightly more successful in certain language tasks.
10
61 62
63 64
David Ewing (1977) refers to two styles that are Systematic Style: Systematic thinkers tend to weigh all the
considerations in a problem, work out all the loopholes, and
closely related to the reflectivity/impulsivity (R/I)
then, after extensive reflection, venture a solution.
dimension:
65 66
Studies:
It has been found that children who are conceptually
The implications for language acquisition are reflective tend to make fewer errors in reading than
impulsive children (Kagan, 1965).
numerous.
Impulsive persons are usually faster readers, and
eventually master the "psycholinguistic guessing game"
(Goodman, 1970) of reading so that their impulsive style of
reading may not necessarily deter comprehension.
11
67 68
Studies:
In another study (Kagan, Pearson & Welch, 1966),
inductive reasoning was found to be more effective with Most of the research to date on this cognitive
reflective persons, suggesting that generally reflective
style has looked at American, monolingual,
persons could benefit more from inductive learning
English-speaking children.
situations.
69 70
performance on a proofreading task. impulsivity always implies accuracy. Some of her subjects
were fast and inaccurate.
71 72
teaching.
On the other hand, a reflective person may require
patience from the teacher, who must allow more time for
the student to struggle with responses.
12
73 74
It is also conceivable that those with impulsive styles may Visual learners tend to prefer reading and studying
go through a number of rapid transitions of charts, drawings, and other graphic information.
semigrammatical stages of SLA.
75 76
Most successful learners utilize both visual and auditory input, The students rated statements like:
but slight preferences one way or the other may distinguish "When I read instructions, I learn them better"
one learner from another "I learn more when I make drawings as I study"
77 78
13
79 80
Strategies Strategies
81 82
Strategies Strategies
83 84
Strategies Strategies
Rubin (Rubin & Thompson, 1982) later summarized fourteen Good language learners:
6. Use mnemonics and other memory strategies to recall what has
such characteristics. been learned
Good language learners: 7. Make errors work for them and not against them
1. find their own way, taking charge of their learning. 8. Use linguistic knowledge, including knowledge of their first
language, in learning a second language
2. organize information about language. 9. Use contextual cues to help them in comprehension
10. Learn to make intelligent guesses
3. are creative, developing a "feel" for the language by experimenting
11. Learn chunks of language as wholes and formalized routines to
with its grammar and words. help them perform "beyond their competence"
4. Make their own opportunities for practice in using the language 12. Learn certain tricks that help to keep conversations going
13. Learn certain production strategies to fill in gaps in their own
inside and outside the classroom
competence
5. Learn to live with uncertainty by not getting flustered and by 14. Learn different styles of speech and writing and learn to vary their
language according to the formality of the situation
continuing to talk or listen without understanding every word.
14
85 86
Cognitive
87 88
Selective attention
thinking about the learning process as it is taking place,
Self-management
monitoring of one's production or comprehension,
Functional planning
and evaluating learning after an activity is completed
Self-monitoring
Delayed production
Self evaluation
89 90
Translation
learning tasks and involve more direct
Grouping
manipulation of the learning material itself.
Note taking
Deduction
Imagery
Keyword
15
91 92
93 94
While learning strategies deal with the receptive domain of Research of the last decade focused largely on the
communication strategies pertain to the employment of More recent approaches seem to take a more positive view
verbal or nonverbal mechanisms for the productive of communication strategies as elements of an overall
communication of information. strategic competence in which learners bring to bear all the
possible facets of their growing competence in order to send
clear messages in the second language.
95 96
Phonological avoidance
Topic avoidance
16
97 98
99 100
101 102
Circumlocution: Describing or exemplifying the target object Literal translation: Translating literally a lexical item, idiom,
of action (e.g., the thing you open bottles with = corkscrew) compound word, or structure from L1 to L2 (e.g. open doors
the meaning of the target lexical item as closely as possible Stalling or time-gaining strategies: Using fillers or hesitation
(e.g., monkey for chimpanzee, gorilla, etc) devices to fill pauses and to gain time to think (e.g., well,
Use of all-purpose words: Extending a general, empty lexical now let's see, uh, as a matter of fact)
17
103 104
Using memorized stock phrases or chunks of language, Asking for aid from the interlocutor
which are often found in pocket bilingual phrase books,
either directly (e.g. what do you call …?)
without internalized knowledge of their components.
or indirectly (e.g. rising intonation, pause, eye contact,
Such phrases are memorized by rote to fit their appropriate
puzzled expression).
context
Using this strategy, learners may also venture a possible
Examples: ―how much does this cost‖ ―where is the toilet‖ ―I
guess and then ask for verification from the native speaker
don’t speak English‖
of the correctness of the attempt or appeal to a bilingual
dictionary for help.
105 106
Communication Strategies
Strategies-Based Instruction
Code-switching:
Often code-switching subconsciously occurs between two
Much of the work of researchers and teachers on
advanced learners with a common first language, but in such a
case, usually not a compensatory strategy. the application of both learning and
Learners in the early stages of acquisition, however, might code- communication strategies to classroom learning
switch to- use their native language to fill in missing knowledge.
has come to be known as :
When it all else fails, when strategies are all incapable of producing
a meaningful utterance – a learner may resort to language switch.
Strategies-based instruction (SBI)
That is, he may simply use his native language whether the hearer
knows the native language or not.
Sometimes just a word or two are slipped in, in the hope that the
hearer will get the gist of what is being communicated.
107 108
18
109 110
certain preconceived notions of what "ought" to 3. do not consider its implementation to be overly
go on in the classroom. difficult
111 112
113
Thank You
19