UNIVERSITY OF NUEVA CACERES-

COLLEGE OF LAW

CASE DIGEST in Criminal Law 1

Professor: Dean/ Atty. Antonio Rivero

Submitted by: Mr. Johnson A. Yaplin- LW1943675

1|Page
 List of Case Digest
I. PRELIMINARY TITLE AND TITLE I
1. U.S. vs. TAYLOR 28 PHIL 599
2. PEOPLE vs. SANTIAGO 43 PHIL 120
3. U.S. vs PABLO, 35 PHIL 94
4. U.S. vs. LOOK CHAW, 18 PHIL 573
5. NAVALES vs. ABAYA, G.R.162318-341, Oct.25, 2004
6. U.S. vs. FOWLER 1 PHIL 614
7. U.S. vs BULL 15 PHIL 7
8. PP vs WONG CHENG 46 PHIL 729

II. UTILITARIAN THEORY

9. MAGNO VS.COURT OF APPEALS-210 SCRA 471 –June 26,1992

III. POSITIVIST THEORY/CONSTRUCTION OF PENAL LAWS

10. DE JOYA vs. THE JAIL WARDEN,ETC.,G.R.No.159418-19, Dec.10,2003
11. INTESTATE STATE OF GONZALES vs.PEOPLE.,G.R.No.181409, Feb.11,2010

IV. CHARACTERISTIC OF CRIMINAL LAW

12. PEOPLE vs. TULIN, G.R.No.111709, Feb.11,2010

V. EX POST FACTO LAW Rule

13. BENEDICTO vs. COURT OF APPEALS,G.R.No.125359,Sept.4,2001
14. LACSON vs. EXECUTIVE SECRETARY, G.R.No.128096, Jan.20,1999

VI. DOCTRINE OF PRO REO/EQUIPOISE RULE

15. PP.vs PABIONA – 433 SCRA 301 - June 30,2004
16. PP.vs.DIMALANTA-440 SCRA 55 - Oct.1,2004
17. AMANGUITAN vs. PEOPLE- 596 SCRA 366 – Aug.14,2009

VII. INTENT/MOTIVE
18. PP.vs.DELIM – 396 SCRA 386 - Jan.28,2003
19. MANUEL vs. PEOPLE – 476 SCRA 461 – Nov.29,2005
20. PEOPLE vs.ESPONILLA – 404 SCRA 421 – June 20,2003
21. PP vs. TANEO, 58 PHIL 255
22. PP vs. BERONILLA, 96 PHIL 566

VIII. MISTAKE OF FACT

23. U.S. vs. AH CHONG – 15 PHIL 488
24. PP vs. OANIS 74 PHIL 257

IX. MALA IN SE/ MALA PROHIBITA

25. LONEY vs.PEOPLE- 482 SCRA 195 – Feb.10,2006
26. GARCIA vs. C.A. – 484 SCRA 617 – Mar.14,2006
27. PP vs.BAYONA - 61 PHIL 181

X . PROXIMATE CAUSE/IMPOSSIBLE CRIMES Doctrines

28. URBANO vs.IAC- 157 SCRA 1 - Jan.7,1988

2|Page
29. GARCIA vs. PEOPLE, 597 SCRA 392 – Aug.28,2009
30. INTOD vs.C.A. – 215 SCRA 52 – Oct.12,1992
31. JACINTO vs. PEOPLE – 592 SCRA 426 – July 13,2009

XI. CONSUMMATED/FRUSTRATED/ATTEMPTED
32. PEOPLE vs. LIZADA – 396 SCRA 62 - Jan.24,2003
33. BALEROS VS.PEOPLE – 483 SCRA 10 – FEB.22,2006
34. VALENZUELA vs.PEOPLE – G.R.NO.160188 –JUNE 21,2007
35. PEOPLE VS.ORANDE – 415 SCRA 699 – NOV.12,2003

XII. CONSPIRACY
36. PEOPLE VS.PAGALASAN – 404 SCRA 275 – JUNE 18,2003
37.PEOPLE VS. CASTILLO – 425 SCRA 136 – MARCH 10,2004
38. PEOPLE VS. LARRANAGA- 421 SCRA 530 – FEB.3,2004
39. FERNAN ET AL.,vs.PEOPLE- G.R. NO.145927- AUG.24,2007
40. PEOPLE VS.GARCHITORENA – 597 SCRA 420 – AUG.28,2009
41. PEOPLE vs. BINGKY CAMPOS- G.R.176061, July 4, 2011

XIII. JUSTIFYING
42. PEOPLE VS.CRISOSTOMO – GR L-38180 - Oct.23,1981
43. PEOPLE VS.SABIO – GR L-23734 - Apr.27,1967
44. PEOPLE VS.CAJURAO – GR L-122767 –Jan.20,2004
45. PEOPLE VS.GENOSA – GR L-135981 – Jan.15,2004
46. PEOPLE VS.EDUARTE – GR L-72976 -July 9,1990
47. PEOPLE VS.AGRAPINAY – GR L-77776 -June 27,1990
48. PEOPLE VS.MORAL – GR L-31139 - October 12,1984
49. PEOPLE VS.NORMA HERNANDEZ – C.A.55 O.G. 8465
50. PEOPLE VS.DE JESUS – GR L-58506 - Nov.19,1982
51. PEOPLE VS.CABRERA – GR L-31178 -Oct.28,1980
52. SYCIP vs COURT OF APPEALS – GR L-125059 March 17,2000
53. PEOPLE VS.WILSON and DOLORES – 52 PHIL 919
54. SPO2 CABANLIG vs. SANDIGANBAYAN- GR 148341-July 28 2005
55. MAYOR AMBIL vs SANDIGANBAYAN – GR No.175457-July 6,2011
56. TY vs. PEOPLE _ GR No.149275 – Sept.27,2004

XIV. EXEMPTING
57. PEOPLE VS.BONOAN – GR L-45130 - Feb. 17,1937
58. PEOPLE VS.AQUINO – GR L-87084 - June 27,1990
59. PEOPLE VS.FALLORINA – GR L-137347- Mar.4,2004
60. PEOPLE VS.LORENO – GR L-54414 -July 9,1984
61. PEOPLE VS.SARIP – GR L-31481-83 - Feb.28,1979
62. PEOPLE VS.PETERINA – GR L-51256 - Aug.12,1986
63. PEOPLE VS.BORJA – GR L-22947 - July 12,1979

XV. MITIGATING.
64. PEOPLE VS.DE JESUS – GR L-58506 - Nov.19,1982
65. PEOPLE VS.URAL – GR L-30801 - Mar.27,1974
66. PEOPLE VS.Amit – GR L-29066 - Mar.25,1970
67. PEREZ vs. PEOPLE – GR L-164763 –Feb.12,2008
68. ROMERA vs.PEOPLE - GR L-151978- July 14,2004

3|Page
69. PEOPLE VS.C.A. – GR L-103613 – Feb.23,2001
70. PEOPLE VS.LOPEZ – GR L-136861 - Nov.15,2000
71. ESTACIO vs.SANDIGANBAYAN – GR L-75362 - Mar.6,1990
72. RIVERA VS.C.A. – GR L-125867 - May 31,2000
73. DEVERA vs. DEVERA - GR L-172832 – April 7, 2009
74. PEOPLE VS.GUMIMBA – GR L-174056 - Feb.27,2007
75. PEOPLE VS.ANTONIO,JR.,– GR L-144266 - Nov.27,2002

XVI. AGGRAVATING
76. PEOPLE VS.REGALARIO – 582 SCRA 738 - MARCH 31,2009
77. TOLEDO VS.PEOPLE - 439 SCRA 94 – SEPTEMBER 24,2004
78. PEOPLE VS.SARCIA,RICHARD-599 SCRA 20 – SEPT.10,2009
79. MADALI vs. PEOPLE – 595 SCRA 274 – AUG.4,2009
80. PEOPLE VS.BALDOGO – 396 SCRA 31 – JAN.24,2003
81. TY VS. PEOPLE – 439 SCRA 220 – SEPT.27,2004
82. PEOPLE VS. ANOD – 597 SCRA 205 – AUG.25,2009
83. PEOPLE VS.IGNAS – 412 SCRA 311 – SEPT.30,2003
84. PEOPLE VS. MANGUERA – 398 SCRA 618 – MARCH 5,2003 (GR139906)
85. PEOPLE VS.ALFON - 399 SCRA -64 – MARCH 14,2003 (GR 126028)
86. PEOPLE vs. MANINGDING, G.R. No.195665, Sept.14, 2011
87. PEOPLE vs. AGCANAS, G.R.No.174476, Oct.11,2011
88. VALENZUELA vs. PEOPLE, G.R.No.149988,Aug.14, 2009

XVII. INSTIGATION/ENTRAPMENT
89. PEOPLE VS.NAELGA – 599 SCRA 477 - SEPT.11,2009
90. PEOPLE VS.MARCOS – GR L-83325 -May 8,1990

XVIII. PRINCIPAL/ ACCOMPLICE /ACCESSORIES

91. PEOPLE VS.OCO - 412 SCRA 190 - SEPT.29,2003
92. PCGG VS. DESIERTO - 397 SCRA 171 - FEB.10,2003
93. PEOPLE vs. TAMPUS G.R.No.181084, June 16,2009
94. PEOPLE vs. MALIAO, G.R.No.178058, July 31,2009
95. PEOPLE vs. DELA TORRE, G.R.No.121213, Jan.13,2004

XIX. DEATH PENALTY, SUSPENSION

96. MATEO vs. PEOPLE -

XX. COMPLEX CRIME

97. ENRILE vs. JUDGE AMIN -
98. ENRILE vs SALAZAR -

XXI. PENALTIES
99. PEOPLE VS.SILONGAN - 401 SCRA 459 - APRIL 24,2003
100. PEOPLE VS.MEDINA,SR.,- 404 SCRA 248 – JUNE 18,2003

XXII. EXTINCTION OF CRIMINAL LIABILITY

101. PEOPLE VS. BAUTISTA - GR.NO.168641 – APRIL 27,2007
102. BRILLANTE VS.C.A. – 440 SCRA 541 – OCT.19,2004
103. PANGAN VS. GALBALITE - 449 SCRA 145 - JAN.21,2005

4|Page