You are on page 1of 8

RARE METALS Available online at www.sciencedirect.

com
Vol. 26, No. 1, Feb 2007, p . 89
E-mail: rm@ustb.edu.cn AT ScienceDirect

Influences of solid particles on the formation of


the third phase crud during solvent extraction

ZHENG Qi, RUAN Renman, WEN Jiunkang, SONG Yongsheng, DONG Qinghai, WU Minglin,
and Y40 Guocheng
General Research hrtitute fot Nonferrous Metals, Belling 1ooOX8, China
(Received 2005 11-18)

Abstract: The influences of solid particles in leach solution on the formation of the third phase crud during solvent extrac-
tion of :upper were studied. Analyzed fiom the point of view of pH value and surface tension, the study results showed that
the soli 1particle is one of the most important contributors for the formation of the third phase crud. During solvent extrac-
tion, if he pH value was greater than 2.30, the number of solid particles in the mother solution increased, in which case the
possibility of forming the third phase crud could also increase, and the interface tension value might grow in pace with the
quantit: of the third phase crud.
Key wc,rds: solvent extraction; solid particle; the third phase crud; surface tcnsion

wpptrrred by the “973”National Basic Research of China (No. 2004CB619206).]


[This tr~idji~jinunciull~

tion, and influence the balance of copper ion be-


1. Introduction
tween both the phases, that is, the solvent extraction
During solvent extraction, the solvent extraction rate of copper, but also has adverse effects on the
rate depends on the chemical reaction rate and mass phase splitting speed and even impede the normal
transfer speed on phase interface. To improve the production progress. Moreover, because of the en-
area of contact interface, both phases must be ade- trainment of the third phase, a loss of the organic ex-
quately mixed to form an emulsion, that is, one tracting agent may accompany it. And the formation
phase uniformly disperses into another phase in the of large quantity of crud is very unfavorable to nor-
form of micro drops with the diameter usually more mal production. Thus, how to effectively reduce or
than 0.1 p n . However, this emulsion could be un- prevent the generation of the third phase becomes an
stable, when the mixing ceases. The dispersed phase important study topic during solvent extraction of
(i.e.. micro drop) must be aggregated and both copper.
phases stratified rapidly. If the dispersed phase is not In the solvent extraction circuit, the causes of
aggregated and stratified for a long period (for ex- forming the third phase crud are complex, such as
ample, of the order of several ten minutes). this the solids in leach solution, composition of solvent
phennmcnnn is callcd criiuldication, and its product (cxtractmg agent a d diluting agent etc.), and ex-
is the third phnre crud; in cothar W O I ~ ~klhuillly
, tllc pci-iiirciit opcraiiun CIC. may present adverxe effects
third phase may be formed between the organic on chemical and physical behaviors during solvent
phase and the aqueous phase. Its generation may not extraction and lead to the formation of the third
only impede the interaction between the organic phase crud. Assuming that the interface reaction of a
phase and the aqueous phase during solvent extrac- solid particle occurs between the aqueous phase and

Correqponding author: 7HFYG Q1 E-mail: qir65@’aind L o r n


90 RARE METALS, Vol. 26, No. 1, Feh 2007

organic phase to stabilize the emulsion and form the facial chemistry (such as surfacehnterface tension),
crud [I], the third phase crud is defined as a solid especially the influences of solid particle. in the
stable emulsion resulting from mixing an aqueous leach solution (solvent extraction mother solution)
phase containing some fine suspended solids such as on the third phase crud, analyzed the components of
a pregnant leach solution with an organic extractant the third phase crud and the influences of surface
phase; in other words, the formation of crud is tension on the formation of the third phase mid, and
caused by the affinity of some solid particles in a finally found a means to control or reduce the for-
leach solution to some components in the organic mation of the third phase crud.

surface behaviors of solid particles may be divided e > 900


- __ O = 90" f3< 90"
into hydrophilic, hydrophobic, or both at the same Fig. 1.. Three forms of the distribution of solid parti-
time. cles at the interface of organic-aqueousphase.
Factors responsible for the stability of the third
phase crud are surfacerinterface tension, interface
charge, and strength of the interfacial film. Similar to
2. Experimental
the surface-active agent, the solid particles are dis- 2.1. Materials and reagents
tributed at the interface of the solution to stabilize Tlie experimental materials were obtained from
the third phase and mainly increase the strength of the copper leach solution in the leach expansion ex-
the interfacial film. periment. Part of the third phase crud was also taken
The behavior of a solid particle at the interface from the solvent extraction loop in the laboratory.
depends on its wettability to water and the organic Reagent: the extracting agent was Lix983N pro-
phase, that is, depends on three interface tensions: duced by Cognis Corporation, German; and the di-
interface tension c&,bd.w&r between solid-water, in- luting agent was commercial sulfonated kerosene;
terface tension c&,Mq,",c phase between solid-organic all other reagents such as sulfuric acid, sodium hy-
phase, interface tension o,,~, phase-water between or- droxide, copper sulfate, sodium silicate, aluminum
ganic phase-water. The interface tension of solid sulfate, ferric sulfate, etc. were technically pure or
particles at interface may be calculated according to chemically pure.
the formula below:
qohd-orgamc phase - qsohd-water = oxgmc phase-~ate&~s@ 2.2. Methods
where Bis the contact angle, used for measuring the The extractant (organic phase) and leach solution
wettability of solid to water or to the organic phase. (aqueous phase) were filled into a separating funnel
Fig. I shows the distribution of solid particles be- according to the specified proportion. After being
tween the interface of the organic phase-aqueous vibrated and mixed with a vibrator for 3 nun, it was
phase. allowed to rest, to stratify. The extracted residual
Although some researchers have given their in- solution (aqueous phase) was taken for anal! zing the
terpretation on the causes of forming the third phase. concentration of metallic ion.
their opinions are quite different. The authors studied Eimulsion separation: emulsion samples were
the formation of the h r d phase crud during solvent loaded into 50 mL centrifuge tubes and then centri-
extraction of copper from the point of view of inter- fug;ihzed at about 9000 r/min for 1 h at 26 'C.
Zheng Q., et al., Influences of solid particles on the formation of the third phase crud during.. . 91

2.3. Analysis and test ous phase is easier to dye, but the organic phase is
The main testing instruments included a F’roces- difficult to dye. The wholly-dyed crud is the wa-
sor Tensiometer KlOO full-auto surface tensiometer ter-in-oil type; on the contrary, only the drop dyed is
produced by Germany KRUSS Company, U.S. the oil-in-water type. Using this method it was found
Thermo Orion MODEL868 acidometer, Hitachi that the third phafe crud formed by solid particles
GGX-9 atomic absorption spectral photometer, 722 exists either in the oil-in-water type or in the wa-
visible raster spectrophotometer, Philips PW2400 ter-in-oil type.
XRPX fluorescence spectrometer, Germany OP- The component analysis was carried out for the
TON polarization microscope, and JSM-840 scan- third phase crud sampled from the laboratory, and
ning electron microscope. The content of metallic the results are shown in Tables 1 and 2.
ion was measured using the atomic absorption Table 1. Component analysis for the third phase crud
method and Gravimetric method. The pH value of %
the aqueous phase or acid strength was measured
Organic phase Aqueous phase
-___ Solid -
phase
with the acidometer using the acid-base titration ~ ~~ ~ -

method, and the surface tensiodinterface tension 65.7 25.8 8.5


was measured with a tensiometer. The shape, granu-
Table 2. Composition of the solid phase in the crud
larity, and component were detected using scanning
%
electron microscopy with an energy spectrometer.
SiO? Fe A1203 Cu ~~~
CaO ~~
MgO-
45.84 30.36 14.78 1.38 0.98 0.60
3. Results and discussion
3.1. Analysis on the component of the third phase Tables 1 and 2 show that the main components of
crud the crud include organic solvent, relatively small
The third phase crud is a mixture of organic sol- quantity of solid phase, and solid phase mainly con-
vent, aqueous solution, and solid substances formed sists of SiOz and Fe, secondly of A1203, Cu, CaO,
during the mixing of solvent extraction, which is a MgO, etc. Thus it is deemed that the solid particles
physical and not a chemical process [6]. When the in the mother solution are one of the main causes in
third phase forms, its stratification is relatively slow, the formation of the third phase crud.
with the upper layer black and the lower layer yel- The shape and gain size of solid particles sus-
low, and a large quantity of white floccus between pended in the mother solution were observed using
the upper and lower layers, mixed with emulsion. the scanning electron microscope and the results are
Although the crud is a relatively stable multi- shown in Fig. 2. As seen in Fig. 2, the solid particles
ple-phase system, after deposition for a long period, are irregular, with the grain size less than 1 pm.
some organic phase or aqueous phase may slowly
separate. The third phase crud during solvent extrac- 3.2. Sources of solid particles and influences on
tion has water-in-oil (wh) type or oil-in-water (o/w) the formation of third phase crud
type. The type of the third phase crud depends on the The surface tension or specific surface energy of
causes of crud formation. Both types of crud may be solid particles is very high, hence easier to absorb
present during the production of copper extraction. the organic solvent which reduces its surface energy
To determine the type of crud, apart fi-om direct ob- so as to form the stable third phase crud. In the leach
servation, it may also be observed through the dye- solution, the solid particles usually exist in solid
ing method; that is, after it is dyed with wa- suspensions and charged colloidal particles (buch as
ter-soluble methylene blue, the third phase crud is colloidal silicon settlement). Certainly both have no
observed with a microscope. Under the microscope, clear dividing line, and for the purpose of conven-
it may be clearly distinguishable, because the aque- ience, the effects of both types of solid particles on
92 RARE METALS, Vol. 26, No. 1, Feh 2007

tion may present 171. There are some large porous


surface-active agents such as minerals and clay in
the leach solution, some of them are hydrcyhilic,
and the others hydrophobic. These solid particles
help t;o stabilize the emulsion to form the crud.
Moreover, the solid particle in the leach solution
may not only accelerate the formation of cnd, once
absorbed in the crud, it may also become a srabiliz-
ing agent to stabilize the emulsification structure of
the crud. The types of third phase cruds formed de-
pend on the hydrophobic and hydrophilic h:haviors
of solid particles. If the solid particles art hydro-
philic, the oil-in-water type may appear; if they are
Fig. 2. SEM of solid particles in mother solution. hydrophobic, the water-in-oil type crud forms.
The following data may explain the influences of
the formation of the third phase crud are elucidated solid suspensions on the formation of crud. In the
a5 shown below. column leach expansion experiment solution with
(1) Functions of solid suspensions in the leach the solid suspensions of 85 mgL, filtered after clari-
solution. fication for 24 h, the content of solid suspensions in
The undecomposed ores in the leach solution, the leached solution is reduced to 18 mg/L. T&e the
some insoluble fine solid particles such as hydrate leached solution before and after filtering respec-
from metallic ion hydrolysis, salt based sulfates of tively, and carry out the solvent extraction test under
Fe and Cu, aluminum sulfate, calcium sulfate (gyp- the Sine test conditions. Before filtering, the quan-
sum), soluble silicon, aluminum, suspensions of tity of crud is 3-4 times more than that after filtering
mud, and dust etc. usually easily form the diffi- (see Table 3 for details). Observations ti-on I the test
cult-to-stratified emulsion with organic phase and show that for an organic solvent, before purification,
lead to the formation of the third phase crud. Espe- there are large quantities of netted bubbles ;it the in-
cially from the devotion of Si02 in solution: from terface during the solvent extraction. and after puri-
the common practices, it is known that the content of fication, the interface of the organic solverit is very
SiOz in the aqueous phase will be less than 0.1 g L . clear during the solvent extraction. The duration of
If it is greater, for the stabilization of S O 2 to phase separating is only 32 s.
oil-in-water type emulsion, usually the emulsifica-

Table 3. Influences of solid suspensions on the formation of crud

~~~~~~~
State Clarified time / h ~
Solid suspensions / (mg.L-’)
~ ~ ~ ~~~~
Quantity of crud / mL Phase separatiori time
-~
/s
Before clarifying 0 85 1.o I97
After clarifying 24 18 3.2 32

(2) Influences of colloidal particles on the forma- by acid may be turned into silicic acid (,Si(OH)j),
tion of the third phase crud. and silica gel finally.
The colloidal materials in the leach solution are Dui-ing the physical mixing in two mutual insolu-
inainly caused by improper control of the pH value ble liquids systems, it is inevitable that there is “fric-
of the leach solution. If the pH value is very high, tion” between both phaqes. This “friction” may gen-
the colloids such as Fe(OH)3, AI(OH)?, and H2Si03 erate a static charge on the surface of drop.;. When
may be formed. For example, the silicate dissolved the liurface of the dispersed drops is charged, these
Zheng Q.. et af., Influences of solid particles on the formation of the third phase crud during ... Y3

chargcd drops may repel mutually and they will be when the pH value of this leach solution was ad-
unable to aggregate to keep at suspension state. This justed to 1.7-2.5 with sulfuric acid and the extraction
is one of the main causes in the formation of an test was carried out under the same test conditions,
emulsion. One case is that the drop is composed of its results showed that the colloid would be damaged
an uncharged nucleating center (micro particles such effectively by adjusting the pH value of the leach
as SKI2) for absorption effect. The negative charge solution below 2.3 and allowing the Fe, Al, Si, etc.
on its drop surface is mainly caused by ”friction”. present in the ionic states. Thus, the control of the
Another case is that the nucleating center of the drop pH value in the leach solution to reduce the genera-
is composed of a charged ionic colloidal group (such tion of colloidal materials is crucial to prevent the
as multinuclear hydrocarbon complex ion of Fe) or formation of the third phase crud.
solid particles. Under the effect of its charges, the
polar 2nd of the organic phase or aqueous phase 3.3. Influences of pH value on the formation of
molec dar is absorbed on its surface, and the surface the third phase crud
of the drops form the whole potential to let the drops Observing from everything mentioned above,
repel r iutually. during the solvent extraction, if the pH value is too
During the solvent extraction, if the surface film high, especially over that of hydrolysis of Fe. A1 etc.,
absorbed a solid particle. especially the charged par- sediments such as Fe(OH)3 and AI(OH)3 etc. may be
ticle , ind a new-formed colloidal particle, the formed. Under these conditions, the formation of the
strengl h and tightness of the film may be improved third phase crud is easier.
considxably. The colloid charged and let the drops The mother solution for the experiment is taken
repel ( ne another and therefore it was uneasy to ag- from the column leach expansion test. Dilute sulfu-
pegatt:. thus the emulsification phenomenon oc- ric acid or sodium hydroxide solution may be re-
curred [6]. spectively used for adjusting the pH value of the
During the solvent extraction experiment, it was mother solution to 1.52, 1.97, 2.30, 3.14, and 3.91.
found hat when the pH value of leach solution was The other conditions are identical. Table 4 shows the
more han 3.0, the third phase crud formed, but test results.

Table 4. Intluences of pH value on the formation of the third phase crud

~
Mother solution
~
Solvent extraction
~ ~ ~ Quantity of Recovery of
Content 01 solid Intcrfacid Phase scparating crud I mL copper I %
pH ohenomenon time I s
I .52 0 L.ittle foam 40 0 x0.05
1.97 0 Little foam 35 1 8 I .57
7.30 20 Interface clear 35 1 95.10
-3. I4 85 Much foam I97 3.2 90.36
3.91
-~ 100 Much foam 150 3.8 75.56

As shown in Table 4, with the pH value increas- tion, and the crnulsification is presented easily and
ing in tilt mother solution. the copper extraction rate forms the third phase. Reducing the pH value dam-
also increases when the pH value is lower, However. ages the colloid and postpones the formiltion of thr
when the pH value reaches up to 7.30. the quantity third phiixe crud. The text has proven that controlling
1 1 1 IIii- f l t l i C l Idlii>c ciud iiicicasrs gicatly. ‘ r h i h is die pH valuc oi rhc morhcr soiurion ~ C I O W~ . .i
iiisy
caused by a high content of foreign materials such as reduce 2/3 of the total formation of the third phase.
Fe. Al. Si etc. in the mother solution. If the pH value Because the contents of Ca and Mg are higher in the
is highcr than that for hydrolysis purpose. the col- mother solution, if the pH value is too low, during
loidal substance is generated during solvent extrac- the solvent extraction, calcium and magnesium may
94 RARE METALS, Vol. 26, No. 1, Feb 2007

be separated out in the sulfate, to increase the quan- substances are absorbed on the surface of drops, its
tity of interface floccus and cause the third phase to surface free energy may be reduced considerably,
increase. Table 4 shows that decrease in the pH because the molecular of surface active substances is
value of the mother solution may increase the ex- an organic compound composed of a hydrophilic
traction rate of copper (pH > 2.3). If the pH value is polar group (such as OH group) and hydrmophobic
too low, however, the extraction rate of copper may non-polar group (such as alkyl group). Its polar
be decreased again. Thus the pH value shall be con- group faces the water and its non-polar group faces
trolled at about 2.3. the organic phase. This regular orientation mange-
ment lets the unsaturated force field on the iurface
3.4. Influences of surface tension on the forma- balance, and thus reduce the surface tension. There-
tion of the third phase crud fore, the surface tension may be reduced ~.mlyif
General speaking, the formation of the third there are surface-active substances which allow the
phase crud mainly depends on the surface tension of emulsion to stabilize. Certainly, if the solvent extrac-
the drop and the strength and tightness of the surface tion :system is entrained with surface-acti\.e sub-
film. During generation of the third phase crud or stancm such as solid particles, the surface tension
emulsion, the influence of surface tension is signifi- will be lowered and will form the stable emulsion,
cant; both the water-in-oil or oil-in-water types have that is, the third phase crud.
interface reaction. Apart from the behavior of the The surfacehnterface tension may be nicasured
drop itself (such as medium properties and concen- through the platinum plate methodplatin urn ring
tration). the surface tension also depends on whether method, respectively. The mother solution. extract-
there are surface-active substances in the solvent ex- ing agent, extracted residual solution, and loaded
traction system. Usually the existence of sur- organic phase are taken for measuring. Table 5
face-active substances may cause the formation of shows the results and phenomenon of the surface
stable emulsion. According to the surface chemical tension test. Table 6 shows the influences of the pH
principle, the higher the surface energy of molecular, value of solvent extraction on the surface tension.
the less the surface area of drop, which shrinks Se:en from the rest results in Tables 5 and 6, it was
automatically; that is, the drops may aggregate. found that the surface tensions of extracted residual
However, if the molecular of some surface active so1ut:ion and loaded organic phase are considerably

Table 5. Test result of surface tension and experiment phenomenon


~ ~

Sudace tension / ( m m-')


~
Phase Quantity
Mother Extracted residual Loaded organic Interface tension ~eparat,on ot crud
Extractant
solution
~ ~~ ~~
solution
~~ ~~
phase ~
of water-organic
~ ~ ~~ __
69.87 52.75 48.67 25.62 13.45 Rapid hl iriim
72.35 52.75 5 1.87 26.04 15.96 Quicker I 1rtle
70.85 52.75 52.24 26.71 15.74 Slower Ab~rnil:tnce
72.21 52.75 49.70 25.83 14.08 Mcdium Abundance

Table 6. Influences of pH on surface tension


Surface tension / (rnn~m-') ~

pH Mother solution Extracting agent Extracted residual solution Loaded organic phase
~~~ ~~~ ~ ~~ -~~ . -~
I .97 69.95 52.75 53.12 26.84
2.30 70.48 52.75 52.33 26.84
3.14 70.85 52.75 52.24 26.7 1
3.91 71.32 52.75 :51.58 26.96 _~
Zheng Q., et al., Influences of solid particles on the formation of the third phase crud during ... 95

more r-duced than those of the mother solution and (2) During copper solvent extraction, the solid
extracting agent, and the sum of both kept at a stable particles in the mother solution are the main causes
value. The interface tension value has the tendency to form the third phase crud. The solid particle sus-
of keeping step with the variation of the third phase pensions are usually easier to form in a diffi-
crud; the higher the pH value, the higher the surface cult-to-stratify emulsion with organic phase and
tension of mother solution. but the less the surface cause the formation of the third phase crud. These
tension of extracted residual solution. The variation solid particles may not only accelerate the formation
of loadzd organic phase is not considerable. of crud, once absorbed on the crud, they may also
become stabilizing agents to stabilize the emulsifica-
tion structure of the crud. Hence, the leach solution
4. Measures to prevent and control the
with solid suspensions should be filtered to greatly
formation of the third phase crud
reduce the quantity of the third phase crud. From all
Becwse the solid particles are the cause of form- the above mentioned, it is clear that the suspended
ing the third phase crud, some measures may be solid particles in the mother solution present great
adopted for controlling the aqueous phase to prevent effects to the formation of crud.
the formation of the third phase crud. (1) Naturally (3) During the solvent extraction, if the surface
clarifj )r filter etc. to eliminate those insoluble solid film is absorbed with some solid particles, especially
particles in the extraction solution, strictly control charged particles and new-formed colloidal particles,
the con :ent of solid particles in the aqueous phase. (2) the strength and tightness of the film may be im-
E l i m k t e those colloids or suspensions such as sili- proved considerably. Because the colloid is charged
con oxide, alumina. and ferric hydroxide etc. in ex- and the drops repel mutually, it is difficult to aggre-
traction solutions. (3) Keep the extraction solution at gate. Thus, the third phase crud presented.
the speified pH value to prevent the existence of (4) During the solvent extraction, if the pH value
colloid1 particles in leach solution, for example, is too high, especially above that needed for hy-
when e.;tracted in acid solution, its pH value must be drolysis of Fe and A1 etc, the sediments such as
lower ti) avoid the formation of the third phase for Fe(OH)? and Al(OHh may be accompanied. Under
some metallic ion sediment, and to reduce the nucle- these conditions, the formation of third phase crud
ating ctmter for the formation of the third phase; becomes easier.
Adjust the pH value of leach solution by adding (5) After extraction, the surface tensions of the
sulfuric acid (strong electrolyte), which may effec- extracted residual solution and loaded organic phase
tively dJmage the colloid, and let the Fe, Al, and Si are considerably reduced and the sum of both kept at
present in the ion state. (4) Add the flocculating a stable value. The interface tension value has the
agent and then filter. The formation of the third tendency of keeping step with the variation of the
phase or crud during solvent extraction may be re- third phase crud; that is, the higher the value of in-
duced e3ectively. terface tension, the more the quantity of crud; and
the higher the pH value, the higher the surface ten-
sion of the mother solution, but the less the surface
5. Conclusions
tension of the extracted residual solution.
(1) During copper solvent extraction, the compo-
nents of the measured third phase crud show that the References
main ccmponents of solid phase are SiOz and Fe,
111 Bumiston T., Greenshieds J.N., and Tetlow RE.. A
followed by A1 and Ca, Mg, Cu, etc. Thus the solid
review of solids handling and crud control in operat-
particles in the mother solution are one of the most ing copper solvent extraction plants, [in] SME Annual
importarit contributor5 for the formation of the thlrd Meeting, Denver, Colorado, USA, 1991.
phase crJd. [ 2 ] Clariant I?, Choice of extractant-optional extractants
96 RARE METALS, Vol. 26, N I L1, Feb 2007

and their operation outline in copper solvent extrac- Phoenix Arizona, 1999: 29 I .
tion plants, [in] 2012 Copper Solvent Extruction 15I Chen Z.Q. and Dai M.G, Colloid Ch>misrry(in Chi-
Technology Exchun :e ConJ;rence (in Chinese), nese), Higher Educatic)n Publishing i louse, Beijing,
Kunrning, 2002: 3 I . 1984: 323.
131 Ritcey GM., Crud in solvent extraction p r i c e s s i n e 161 Xian L., The causes analyse of foiming the third
a review of causes :jnd treatment, Hyfrotnetullurgy, phase crud In the solvent extraction circuit, Hydro-
1980,s: 97. metullucsp (in Chinese), 1998,68 (4): 29.
141 Vimig M.J., Olafson S.M., Kordosky GA.. and Wolfe [71 Ma R.J., The emulsification and thiid phase in the
GA., Crud formatioil: field studies and fundamental solvent extraction, NotlfZ.rrous Met. (Extrc~ctiveMet-
studies, [in] Four Ittternational Conference Copper allurgy) ( i n Chinese), 1996.48 (3): 4:.
99-Cohre 99 W u m e I V Hvdrometdlurgy of Copper,

[Continuedfrom page 781

[ I l l Makyta M.. Mechenisrn of the cathode process in Bcijing, 1983: 60.


the electrochemical svnthesis of TiBz in molten salts-I. [ IS] Jiang H.Y., Metullur,yical Electrochrjmistry(in Chi-
The synthesis in an all-fluoride electrolyte, Electro- nese), Metallurgical Indwtry Press, Beiiing, 1983:
chim. Actu, 1989,34 861. 110.
[12] Taranenko V.I., Mechanism of the cathode process [I61 Duan S.L., Kang Y., Gu X.F., and [liao Z.Y., Basic
in the electrochemical synthesis of TiBz in molten research xbout titanium deposition i i ' the KCI-NaCI
salts-11. Chloride-fluoride electrolytes, Elrrlrochim. molten salt, Chin. J. Rlire Met. (in Chinese), 1993, 17
Actu, 1992,37: 263. ( 5 ) :348.
[I31 Shi Q.R., Durn S.2 , and Wu S.M., Elecirochemical 1171 Tsuda 7 ., Nohira T., and Ito Y., Nu( leation and sur-
reduction of B(II1) i n molten fluorides, J Univ. Sci. face morphology of aluminum-lanthanum alloy elec-
Techno/.Beijing (in Chinese), 1994,16 (6):599. trodeposited in a LaC13-saturated A IC13-EtMeIMCI
[I41 He C.X. and Ma (;,C., Phuse Diugrum.vfor Noble room temperature molten salt, Elr .trochim. Actu,
Metal Alloys (in Chi iese). Metallurgy Industry Press, 2002,47: 28 17.

You might also like