Professional Documents
Culture Documents
••••
THE TOTAL NITROGEN, PHOSPHORUS AND
CALCIUM CONTENT OF COMMON WEEDS
AND NATIVE GRASSES IN OKLAHOMA·
By H. J. Harper. H. A. Daniel. and H. F. 'Murphy"
Oklahoma A. and M. College
Information concerning the chemical composition of natural vege-
tation 1a very llmited as compared with the total number of plants which
have been studied. and the major pOrtton of the investigations which have
been conducted have been confined to weeds and grasses which grow in
competition with cUltivated crops.
IDee (6) determined the amount of nitrogen in thirteen common
weeda which occurred in the cUltivated fields of North Dakota and found
~ twenty-four out of the twenty-seven weeds which were analyzed con-
tained larpr amounts of n1tl'Olen and phosphorus than wheat. oats. barley.
and flax. The averaae nitrogen content of these weeds was 2.53 per cent
and the pboepborus content was .29 per cent.
8D1der (11) analyzed fifteen different weeds for nitrogen and found
tbM on the avenae they contained 3.01 per cent of this element. Portu-
laca c1eraceae contained the J&raest amount of nitl'Olen. which was 4.40
per cent. ~der suaests that weeds are not deUca.te feeders because of
tile la.rae amount of mineral matter which they contain and when they
are bUrned a heavy 1088 of nitrogen occurs.
PlcItel1 (10) determined the protein content of nine Florida. weeds and
'OUlad &bat mM of the plants were relatively low in nltropn as compared
• ODnVlbuUon tram the Oklaboma Asr1cultural Bzperlment Statton•
•• on.e auUlon wIIb to tbaDk Robert 8va\ton and B. I. Peatherly. of the Bot-
ACADBMY OF SCIBNCE FOR. 1933 aT
. &IQ' Department of the Oklaboma A. and K. 00l1ep. for ....tance in the 1dentUl-
catton Of Ute plants studied.
with the results secured by the two previous inveatigators; although Portu-
laca cleraceae contained •.05 per cent nitrogen, which 18 s1m1lar to the
result secured by Snyder (11). .
campbell (2) studied the nitrogen content in the tops of eleven winter
annuals which were secured in the fan and again in the spring. He found
that the spring growth contained on t·he average 3.53 per cent nitrogen as
compared with 2.63 per cent which occurred in the leaves and stems which
grew in the fall. A comparison of 'the nitrogen content of nine annual
plants at different stages of growth indicated that a rapid decrease in
nitrogen content occurs between the blooming period and maturity. Just
what effect the loss of leaves had on these results was not discussed. Six
weeds growing in rye contained about the same amount ot nitrogen as the
rye plants when harvested at different periods during the growing season.
The roots of certain weeds contained smaller amounts of nitrogen than
the leaves, and' the stems were usually higher in plant food than the roots.
M'illspaugh (8) analyzed forty-nine different plants for total nitrogen,
phosphorus, and potassium, and his results indicate that the composition
of weeds and grass are very similar to that of CUltivated crops although
a marked variation occurs in certain species.
Cooper (3) found that the nitrogen, phosphorus, and calcium contents
of Poa praetensis, Danthonia spicata, and Andropogon virgintcus were all
low when these plants were in full bloom. Cruickshank (4) and others have
shown that the nitrogen and phosphorus content of grass decreases as the
season advances and that young grass is high in nitrogen.
Stutzer and Seidler (12) analyzed seven important weeds for nitrogen,
phosphorus, potassium. sodium, and calcium. These weeds contained larger
amounts of plant food than ordinary field crops, and in some instances '
plants which contained large amounts ot calcium were low in potassium.
Kling (6) has made a survey of the German literature on the chem-
ical composition of weeds and reported the analyses at six common weeds,
all of which were very high in plant food. The average nitrogen content
was 3.64 per cent; phosphorus, .52 per cent; calcium, 2.35 per cent; and
potassium, 6.20 per cent. These analyses were much higher than thOlSe
secured by Stutzer and Seidler (12) on the same kind of plants.
Korsmo (7) pUblished a table in his book on the tood value contentt
of ftfty-three different weeds. The average nitrogen content was 2.47
per cent; phosphorus, .33 per cent; pOtassium, 3.29 per cent; and calcium,
1.79 per cent. A greater variation occurred in the potassium content of
the different plants than in case of calcium. These analyses point out
very clearly that many weeds remove large amounts of plant tood from
the soil.
Nielson (9) and Brenchley (1) have classified a large number of weeds
on the basts of their development on soils ot varying degree of acidity and
texture but did not study the etfect ot so11 conditions on the composition
of different plants.
White (13) studied the growth of Rumex acetosella on limed and un-
limed soils and found that this plant responded to an application of lime-
stone; however, the stimulating effect ot lime on the growth of red clover
resulted in the choking out of the red sorrel due to plant competition.
EXPERIMENTAL
Erosion of cultivated soils combined with a shallow zone of organic
IDatter accumulation in the sol1 profile under virgin conditions has re-
SUlted in the production of large areas of marginal land in Oklahoma. The
ftrat type of vegetation which develops on abandoned areas are annual
weeda and Il'&SSe8 typical of those plants which were most abundant in
-- PROCEEDINGS OF THE OKLAHOIIA
tile fteIdI or along tile borders or in fence rows whUe the land was in
crops.
In many areas the change from the annual weed stage to the peren.
Dial weed stage and from the perennial weed stage to the mixed weeds and
IP'US stale OCCUJ'I very 8lowly. The fertility 'of the soU Is one Important
factor whieb Umlts the rapid development of climax grasses in many areas
and the ablence of seed in the soli retards the appearance of those grasses
wbere condltlons are favorable for their development.
Due to dlfferences in cllmatic and soU condltions, many weeds which
appear in one part of Oklahoma are not abundant in other areas. Bome
species, bowever, are adapted to a wide range of condltions and may be
found in both dry and molat climates. During the season of 1927 a few
of the common weeds which appear on abandoned land. in waste places,
and following the harvest of small grain were collected and analyzed. The
results of these analyses are given in Table I.
In all cues the plants had reached the blooming stage and do not
represent an Immature condition. Many of the plants contained more
than 2 per cent of nitrogen, which 18 similar to the amount of this par-
ticular element which occurs in cultivated legumes. The phosphorus con-
tent of these plants was exceptionally high on the average even in case
of plants which were growing on relatively poor soil, such as Erigeron
canaclens1a, which is a weed commonly found on sandy land. The cal-
cium content of all the weeds was high as compared with the calcium
content of native grasses.
SOU condltions and the ratio of stems to leaves in the different species
of plants are important factors in affecting the nitrogen content of the
plants. Coreopsis tinctoria has a small proportion of leaves as compared
with the stems and 18 low in nitrogen. The effect of soil on the nitrogen
content of weeds is shown in case of Ambrosia artemlsUfol1a (Sample No.2,
Table I) and ErIgeron canadensis (Sample No. 14, Table I> which grew
on a very poor sandy sol1, and the plants were much lower in nitrogen
than I1m1lar species grown on different 8011.
In order to obtain further information on this particular subject, R.
large number of plants were collected in December, 1932. Most of the
leaves had dropped before the plants were collected; consequently the
analyses represent chiefiy the plant food content of the stems. These
anab8e8 are given in Table n. In most cases the phosphorus content of
the Items was very much lower than that which occurred in the first
group of plants which were analyzed. Also there was a marked decrease
In the nttropn and calcium content which did not occur due to leach-
In&' or maturity but is due to the fact that the nitrogen and calcium con-
tent of the leaves is much higher than in the stems.
The lowest results occurred in case of Aristida oligantha., which 18
one of the ftrst plants to appear on poor eroded land. This particular
plant is exceed1nlly low in nitrogen, phosphorus, and calcium .during all
of Ita I1'Owth stages; however on good soil it wUl absorb considerably larger
amounts of plant food than will be found in the plants produced under
unfavorable .condltions. This plant is easUy carried by the wind and
In the ablence of competition from other plants it can secure a foothold
In waste areas and survive under very unfavorable conditions.
Bermuda I1'88S was much higher in nitrogen. phosphorus, and cal-
cium during the dlfferent growth stages than most of the other grasses
atucUec:l. '1bI8 Ja an important factor in localities where a mineral deficiency
In the foraae may affect the Irowtb of livestock.
; III order to 88Cure more complete information on the composition of
the ~ different tlnds of weeds which make up the major portion of
tbe Datift veaetatton In meadows, along roe.dsldes and in cultivated 1leldl
TABLE I.
-= '!be Nitrogen. Calcium. and Phosphorus Content of Mature Weeds and Grass Collected in Oklahoma in 192'l.
No. SClentUlc Name COmmon Name Location PJlROBNT
Nltl'ogen PhC)8. calCIum
1 Acn1da tamar1lclDa Water hemp 8 m1. E. of Enid 1.517 .426 1.7M
2 Ambrosfa artem18t1tol1& Annual Ragweed 11 m1. S. E. of Glencoe .'198 .IM 1.518
,.
8 Ambroet.a a:rtemJa1Uolla
AmbJ'Olda pel10stachya
Annual Ragweed
Perennial ragweed
Exp. Sta. Parm. St11lwater
A. <& M. Campus. Stlllwater
1.802
2.222
.288
.286
2.8eO
l.eal
6 Ambrosla psUost&chya Perennial ragweed 11 m1. S. W. of StUlwater 1.139 .218 I._
e Applopappus clltatua Rosin weed East of Buffalo 1.13' .180 1.151
1 Applopappus clltatua Rosin weed 1 mi. N. of Okeene 1.888 .282 2.881
8 Applopappua cll1atua Rosin weed 1 m1. N. of carrier 1.320 .150 1._
0 Applopappus clltatus Rosin weed. 5 m1. S. of St11lwater 1.785 .15& 1.&80
10 Buch10e dactyloldee Buffalo grass A. & M. Campus. Stillwater 2.000 .130 .338
11 Coreopala tlnctorla Wild Flax U m1. N. E. of Carrier 0.913 .2M .801
12 Coreopsls t1netorta WUd Flax 8 mi. E. of Enid. 1.071 .301 .691
tl') 18 Cynodon dactylon Bermuda gra.ss, Exp. St&. Farm.. St1llwater 2.085 .381 3.022
tl') (seed stage)
....
0.-
a=
I" ErIgeron canadena1s
1& Erigeron canadens18
Muletall
MUletall
11 m1. S. E. of Glencoe
4 m1. W. of Quinlan
1.188
1.&38 ••
.228
.775
1.101
~ 18 Brtgeron canadensls Muletall East of Buttalo 2.023 .258 .975
IliQ
17 Ertgeron can.adenall
18 Erigeron canadena1s
Muletall
Muletall
S. E. of Chandler
1 m1. N. of Carrier
1.393
1.882
.322
.301 ••
1.060
~ 19 Brlgeron canadena1s Muletall 5 m1. S. of St11lwater 2.225 .258 .SMS
~ 20 Bngeron canadensll Muletall Exp. St&. Farm. Stlllwater 2.M5 .219 1.080
~ 21 Heltanthus annuua
22 Laetuea ecartola
Wild sunflower
Wild lettuce
5 mi. S. E. of St1l1water
East of Buffalo
2.310
1.133
.180
.307
1.700
1.1150
~ 28 Lactuca acar10la
:lot Mel110tua alba
Wild lettuce
Sweet clover
Near Goodwell
Exp. St&. Farm. St1l1water
2.112
1.880
.3oiS
.1M
2.881
:180
~ 25 Rudbeot1a hJrta Blaekeyed SUsan S. E. of Chandler .932 .300 2.280
~ 28 Syntherlsma sangulna118
2'1 Syntber1sma aangulnalll
Crabgrass
Crabgrass
501 Monroe St.• St11lwater
Exp. St&. Parm. Stillwater
1.878
2.189
.ssa
.2H
.SA
.dB
~"ill 28 Xantblum commune Cocklebur 11 m1. S. W. of St11lwater 2.300 .211 2.120
- TABLB II.
lfttroIen, PboIpborus, aDd caJclum Content of Stems of Mature 1'taDta CoUected In DeceDiber 21, 1832. ~al1
•
of the Leaves Bad Pallen.
~
PDoamn'
Ifo. 8cleDutic Rame Common Name Location
Nltr'p PhOll. Oalolum.
2.110
1.100
ur,o
1.810
6 Ambrosia artemJa11folla Common ragweed Exp. 8ta. Farm. StUlwater 2.261 .1M 2.501
7 Ambrosla ~08tachya PerennJal ragweed Exp. 8ta. Farm, St1Uwater 2.060 .216 3.3&0
8 Ambrosia Ida Horseweed 8i mi. 8. B. of Stlllwater 1.804 .252 :UOO
I Andropogon sorghum Johnson grass Exp. 8ta. Farm. SUllwater .910 .127 .380
10 Apocynum hyperlc1follum Dogbane 3 m1. 8. E. of 8tWwater 1.280 .105 .90&
11 ApPIO~ c1llatus Rosin weed Exp. 8ta. Farm. St1Uwater 2.120 .169 1.820
12 Bapt18la cteata False Indigo 3 mt. So B. of St1llwater 2.020 .089 1.250
18 Chenopocl1um album Lamb's quarter Exp. Sta. Farm. St1Uwater 2.040 .U9 1.ll&-
14 Chenopodium leptophyllum Plr;:eed Exp. 8ta. Farm. St1Uwater 2.240 .093 1.1~
15 C1rc1um cana.scene 81 ver thlatle Exp. 8ta. Farm. 8tillwater 2.826 •US5 2.291 .
16 ConvolvuJua arveD818 Bindweed Exp. 8ta. Farm. St1Uwater 1.804 .262 lUOO'"
17 Deamodlum aeaa1llfolium ......................... 3 mi. 8. E. of 8tWwater 1.400 .065 1.550'
18 Deenonthua illlnoewse ............................. 3 mi. 8. E. of StWwater 1.900 .101 1.610·
19 D10dla teres Button weed Exp. 8ta. Farm. 8t1llwater 2.690 .200 1.885-
20 Dlodla teres Button weed 86 mL 8. of 8tUlwater 1.950 .146 1.27&
...'"
~
0. 21
22
23
Erigeron canadena1a
Buflhorb1a ffexagona
He lanthus annuus
MuletaU
Hexagonal spurge
WUd sunflower
Exp. 8ta. Farm. Stillwater
86 mt. S. of Stillwater
Exp. 8ta. Farm. St1llwater
2.165
2.605
2.858
.212
.212
.274
.925
1.090"
2.370'
~ H Hel1anth~tlolar1s Wild sunflower 81 m1. S. E. of StUlwater 1.800 .190 1,'790>
0 25 Ipomea p urata Wlld ~tato vine Exp. Sta. Farm. 8tUlwater 2.766 .180 1.286·
lilt 26 Iiectuca ecartola Wl1d ettuce Exp. Sta. Farm. StUlwater 1.850 .190 1.460"
27 Leepedeza v1rglnlca ............................. 3 mi. S. E. ot St1llwater 1.640 .098
~
_ .'720'
28 Oenothera lactnlata Evening rcrimrose Exp. Sta. Farm. Stillwater 1.150 .185 2.420'
29 Petalostemum purpuerewn Prairie cover 3 mi. S. E. of StUlwater 1.280 .075 1.548
fIQ 30 Plantago PurBhll Plantain 81 m1. S. E. of 8t1llwater 1.045 .1M .970
t3
fIJ
31 Polygonum hydropiperoldes
32 Polygonum penney'lvaD4cum
Bmartweed
Smartweecl
Exp. Sta. Farm. StUlwater
Exp. 8ta. Farm. Sttllwater
1.585
2.640
.091
.147
.985
1.560
8S Polygonum ramoe1M1mum Knotweed S mi. 8. E. of 8t1llwater .890 .075 .370
~ 34
86
Portulaca oleraceae
Psoralea pedunculata
Purslane
Wlld alfalfa
Exp. 8ta. Farm. Stillwater
2 mt. W. of StUlwater
3.795
2.300
.625
.182
.840
1.500
~
36 Peoralea peduncu1ata Wlld alfalfa 3 mi. 8. of Claremore 2.010 .138 1.725
87 Peoralea pedunculata Wlld alfalfa 4 mi. 8. E. of Stillwater 2.010 .128 1.400'
~ 38
81
Rumex crlapua
Solanum carol1neD8e
Curled dock
Horse nettle
Exp. Sta. Farm. Stulwater
Exp. 8ta. Farm. Sttllwater
1.740
3.280
.185
.200
.878'·
1.880'
~
40 Solanum roetTatum Buffalo bur Exp. 8ta. Parm. 8t1llwater 3.410 .210 1.880'
'1 Vernonia. ........._...... Iron weed S m1. S. E. of 8tUlwater 1.105 .085 1.:180
42 Jtanthlum commune Cockle bur «I m1. S. E. ot StUlwater UNS .280 2.440'
~
PROCEEDINGS 0' THB OKLAHOMA
e
.,
8
Andropocon torreanua
Buchloe dactJ'loldea
Boutebua gracUla
Cynodon dactylon
2
14
8
1.
.718
.087
.933
1"-
.100
.128
.108
.1'1a
.s.
.aaa·
.81.:
••8,
~ 10 Paapalum dUatatum Da111s grass 1.109 .187 .1ee'
11 Sorghutrum nutana Indian gr&I8 "
6 .827 .086 .201
=
U
fI.»
12 SyDther1.ama aangulna1la Crab grus 6 1."80 .100 .sa9
~
AVERAOE •...••...80a .118 .818
~--
~
~
PROCEEDINGS OF THE OICLAHOI!:s.
Young plants are btgher In mtneral nutrients and nitrogen than older
plants. The stems are lower In nitrogen, phosphorus, and calcium than
the leaves.
Arlstida ollgantba, which is commonly found on very poor soU, con-
tained very low amounts ot mineral plant tood. Diodia teres also grows
on land whfeh will not support many other kinds of native plants but was
b1gh in nitrogen. phosphorus, and calcium. '!be feeding power of the
plant 18 the probable explanation ot this difference.
'!be eftect ot weeds on the preservation of plant foods and the possible
stimulation ot nitrogen fixation has meen emphasized.
REPBRENCES
1. Brench1ey. W. E. 1911. The weeds of arable land in relation to the 8011s on
wbich they Il'Ow. Ann. Bot. (London) 26 :166-166.
2. Oampoell. B. G. 1924. Nitrogen content ot weeds. Bot. Gazette 78:103-115.
8. Cooper. H. P. 1930. Ash conatituenta ot pasture grasses, their standard elec-
trode potentia1a and ecological significance. Plant PhysIology 2 :193-214.
-t. Cruickshank, Ethel M. 1026. Report on the seasonal variations in the m.1ner-
al content of pastures. Jour. Agr1. 8c1. 16:89-97.
6. Inee. J. W. 1916. FertlUty and weeds. North Dakota Agri. Exp. 8ta. Bui. 112.
6. KUng. M. 1914 Uber die chemJeche zummenset'.zung einlger Unkrauter 80wie
deren Wert als Putter and Dugemlttel Landw. Vera. Stat. 85 :433-470.
7. Koramo, E. 1930. Unkrauter tm Aokerbau de Neuzeit. Julius 8pringer. Ber-
lin. '"8-'"9.
8. Mmspaugh, C'. F. 1891. Weeds as fertlUzers. West Va. Agr1. Exp. ata. Bui. 19.
9. Nleuen, N C 1926 Ukrudsvegetatlonen 80m Vejlednlng ved Undersogelser over
MineralJorders Kalktrang Nord. Jordbrugsforak. (Kongres 1. Oslo): 421-433.
10. Pickell, J. M. 1890. Analysis of some Florida weeds and grasses. Fla. Agrl.
Bxp. Stat Bul. 11.
11. Snyder. Harry. 1907. Porage crops of high, medium and low protein con-
tent. Minn. Agr!. Exp. Sta. Bul. 101.
12. Stutzer. A. and Seidler. L. 1908. The content of tmportant plant food Ingre-
c11ente in aome common weeds. Puhl1ng's Landw. Ztg. 57:429-430. 8ee Exp. Bta.
Record 20:760 (1909).
• •••