Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1998 PES-TR7
Formerly TP133
TRANSIENTS
Prepared By IEEE Working Group 15.08.09
Tutorial On
Modeling And Analysis or System Transients Using Digital Programs
Abstracting is permitted with credit to the source. For other copying, reprint, or republication permission, write to the IEEE
Copyright Manager, IEEE Service Center, 445 Hoes Lane, Piscataway, NJ 08855-1331. All rights reserved. Copyright © 1998
by The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.
Introduction i
1. Background 1-1
This documentis written in order to provideguide- The range of frequencies of primary interest in a
lines for the modeling of power system apparatus for use in switching transients study vary from the fundamental power
time - domain solutionof electromagnetic transientphenom- frequency up to 10kHz. Switching surge modeling guide-
enon. This publication has been arranged in the following lines are presentedincluding modeling of the various power
eight (8) parts. systemcomponents such as transmission lines, cables, trans-
formers, source equivalents, loads and circuit breakers. In
Part 1 :Background addition, typicalcase studies are also presented.
Part 2 :PowerElectronics
Part 3:Slow Transients 1.5 FAST FRONT TRANSIENTS
Part 4 :Switching Transients
Part 5 :Fast Front Transients Modeling guidelines are presented for fast front
Part 6 :Very Fast Front Transients transients (i.e., frequency range from 10 kHz up to 1 MHz),
Part 7 :Protection And Control with particularemphasison lightningsurge analysis of over-
Part 8 :Bibliography head lines and substation. Modeling philosophies, simpli-
fied mathematical relationships, typical data, and examples
A general statementof each area is as follows. are given for various power system components. A case
study is presented in order to illustrate the overall modeling
1.1 BACKGROUND procedure.
This section presents a comprehensive summary of 1.6 VERY FAST FRONT TRANSIENTS
the background and state of the art for the transientsolutions,
representation of control systems, and modeling of power The objective of this section is to provide an expla-
systemcomponents. nation of the phenomena of very fast transients, in the fre-
quencyrange of 100 kHz to 50 MHz. This type of transients
1.2 POWERELECTRONICS typically occur in the gas insulated substations (GIS).
Effects and modeling guidelines for GIS are presented. An
The guideline presentsthe basic issuesthat are criti- example of a GIS calculationwith detailed input data is pro-
cal for successfully modeling of power electronics devices vided. A simulation accuracyis verifiedwith field measure-
and the interfacebetweenpower electronics and the utility or ments.
industrial system. Modeling aspects are presentedfor simu-
lation of the semiconductor switching devices, power elec- 1.7 PROTECTIONAND CONTROL
tronics system, snubber treatment, and simulation errors and
control. A number of simulation examples, including General guidelines for modeling of protection sys-
FACTS modeling, are presented. tems is presented. Because digital modeling of protection
systemsin the electromagnetic transients programs is a rela-
1.3 SLOW TRANSIENTS tively new procedure, this section describes the advantages
and limitations of the protection system modeling. Model-
Modeling guidelines are presented for investiga- ing of instrument transformers, relays - electromechanical,
tions of small signal torsional oscillations, large -signalshaft static and microprocessor based are summarizedand models
transient stresses, turbine -blade vibrations, fast bus transfer, are presented.
controller interactions, harmonics interaction, and resonance
phenomena. Sample test systems and simulationresults are 1.8 BIBLIOGRAPHY
provided.
A comprehensive list of references on the subject-
are provided.
i-I
Digital Computation of Eelectromagnetic
Transients in Power Systems: Current Status
Juan A. Martinez-Velasco
Departament d'Enginyeria Electrica
Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya, Spain
Abstract- This documentpresentsan introductionto time-domain techniques. The subject of this document is the digital
solution of electromagnetic transients in power systems using a simulation ofelectromagnetic transients in power systems, using
digitalcomputer•Currently, the mostwidely usedsimulation tools time-domain techniques. Presently, the most widely used
tosolve electromagnetic transientsare basedonthetrapezoidalrule solution method is based on the application of the trapezoidal
andthe methodofcharacteristics(Bergeron'smethod). Onlyworks
rule and the Bergeron's method, also known as method of
related to this solutionalgorithm are considered in this document
whichcoverstwo maintopics: solution techniques and modeling of characteristics [1] - [6].
powercomponents.
This document has been arranged as follows. Section 2 deals
Keywords : Electromagnetic Transients, Time-domain with the basic solution techniques either already implemented
Simulation, Trapezoidal Rule, Numerical Oscillations, Control or proposed for implementation in electromagnetic transients
Systems, Modeling. programs (emtps). It covers not only the algorithms aimed at
solving the transient solution, but procedures to reduce
numerical oscillations produced by the trapezoidal rule,
1. INTRODUCTION initialization methods, and procedures to solve the interface
between power networks and control systems.
Transient phenomena in power systems are caused by
switching operations, faults, and other disturbances, such as Section 3 presents a summary of modeling works related to the
lightning strokes. They involve a frequency range from DC to most important power components taking into account their
several MHz. A rough distinction is usually made between frequency-dependent behaviour.
electromechanical transients, traditionally covered by transient
stability studies, and electromagnetic transients. The latter type Due to difficulties for developing power component models
of transients can occur on a time scale that goes from accurate enough for a wide frequency range, much work has
microseconds to several cycles; they are a combination of been done to provide modeling guidelines for digital simulation
travelling waves on lines, cables and buses, and of oscillations of every type of transient phenomenon. Section 4 summarizes
in lumped-element circuits ofgenerators, transformers and other the work done in this area and reports about works still in
devices. Some electromechanical transients, such as progress.
subsynchronous resonance, for which detailed machine models
are needed, are usually included in this class of transients. Some topics, such as parallel computation or real-time emtp-
based simulation of electromagnetic transients, which are
Several tools have been used over the years to analyze closely related to the main subjects of this document are not
electromagnetic transients. At early stages, miniature power covered here.
system models, known as Transient Network Analyzers (INA),
were used. At present, the digital computer is the most popular A selected bibliography related to topics of each part has been
tool, although INAs are still used; in addition, the new included at the end of this document.
generation of real-time digital systems are probably the most
adequate tool in some applications for which either a very
high-speed or a real-time simulation is required. 2. SOLUTION METHODS
Many techniques have been developed to solve electromagnetic 2.1 TRANSIENT SOLUTION
transients using a digital computer. They can be classified into
two main groups : frequency-domain and time-domain The studies to solve travelling wave problems by means of a
1-1
digital computer were started in the early 1960's using two proposed to cope with nonlinear and time-varying elements
different techniques, the Bewley's lattice diagram [7] and the [11]. These modifications were based on a current source
Bergeron's method [8]. Thesetechniqueswereapplied to solve representation, a piecewise-linear representation or the
smallnetworks, withlinearandnonlinear lumped- parameter, as compensation method. Someof the advantages and drawbacks
well as distributed-parameter elements. The extension to shownby these approaches were discussed in [5] and [11].
multinode networks was made by H.W. Dommel [1]. The
Dommel's scheme combined the Bergeron's method and the Using compensation, nonlinear elements are represented as
trapezoidal rule into an algorithm capable of solving transients currentinjections whicharesuperimposed to the solution of the
insingle- andmulti-phasenetworks withlumped anddistributed linearnetwork after this solution has been computed. Figure 1
parameters. This solution method was the origin of the shows the scheme of the compensation method for a single
ElectroMagnetic Transients Program (EMTP), whose nonlinear element.
development was supported by Bonneville Power Nonlinear
Administration (BPA). ® lklll Vk m equatio r.~··
I --+ /~
/'
I II
r
Linear, "- »<
Thetrapezoidal ruleis usedto convertthedifferential equations + ! ~----<:
tim e -
<,.....
voltages, currents andpastvalues. Thesealgebraic equations are invariant Vk m ,IT '0 '-.
/ i~ Netw~~k'
assembled using a nodal approach Netwo rk -
I
/ :o' e q u a ti on
/ ' ::l
[ G] [ v ( t)] = [i ( t)] - [ I] I
(I) @
where [G] is the nodal conductance matrix
[vet)] is the vectorof node voltages Figure 1. Principles of the compensation method.
[i(t)] is the vectorof currentsources
[I] is the vectorof "history" terms. Oncethe solution of the network withoutthe nonlinearelement
has been computed, its contribution is computed from the
Veryoftenthenetwork contains voltage sources toground, then following equation
the equation is split up into part A with unknown voltages and
part B with knownvoltages (3)
and the characteristic of the nonlinear element
(2) v km = f(ikm' dikm/dt, t, ... ) (4)
The resulting conductance matrix is symmetrical and remains vkm(O) in (3) indicates the voltage solution acrossthe nodes "k"
unchanged astheintegration isperformed witha fixed time-step and "m'' without the nonlinear element, while rthev is the
size.Thesolution ofthetransient processis thenobtained using Thevenin equivalent resistance.
triangular factorization. One of the main advantages of this
procedure is that it can be applied to networks of arbitrary size Iterative solution methods, such as the Newton's method, are
in a very simple fashion. usedto solvethis step.
Bergeron's method can be efficiently used with lossless and The compensation method can be generalized to networks with
distortionless lines. However, parameters of actual transmission several nonlinear components [12]. However, its application is
systems are frequency-dependent. The first works on limited to only one nonlinear elementper node.
frequency-dependent models were performed for telephone
circuits in the 1920's [9]. The first frequency-dependent Other solution methods has been proposed to solve this
transmission line modeldeveloped for EMTP simulations was limitation. A very simple procedure based on a predictor-
implemented in 1973 [10]. Much effort has been made since corrector method has been recently presented [13].
then, and some other frequency-dependent line models have
been developed and implemented, see Section 3.2. An interface for simulation ofHVDC linksand machines, also
basedon the Dommel's algorithm, was presented in [14].
The original Dommel's scheme could be used to solve linear
networks. However, many power components - transformers, The computation of electromagnetic transients with the
reactors, surge arresters, circuit breakers - presenta nonlinear trapezoidal rule is performed in the time-domain. Some other
behaviour. Several modifications to the basic method were techniques have been developed to solve network equations
1-2
using a time-domain solution (z-transform methods [15], wave ----~------]
digital filters [16]) or a frequency-domain solution [17]. Some
alternative methodologies taking advantage of the Dommel's
scheme have been recently proposed, they use a hybrid ~ R
frequency- and time-domain approach [18], or a state equation
~ L
modeling [19].
One of these techniques uses additional damping to force c) Simulation result with the snubbercircuit
oscillations to decay [22]. This damping can be provided by the
integration rule itself or externally, by adding fictitious Fig. 2. Numerical oscillations and their solution.
resistances in parallel with inductances and in series with
capacitors. This method can have an important effect on the Some of the most efficient techniques developed to avoid
accuracy of the solution. numerical oscillations are based on the temporary modification
of the solution method, only when numerical oscillations can
Another technique is based on the use of snubber (RC) circuits occur, without affecting the rest of the simulation. One ofthese
in parallel with switches. This option is particularly interesting techniques is based on the CDA (Critical Damping Adjustment)
in power electronics applications as snubber circuits are very procedure [23], [24]. During a switching operation, CDA uses
often placed in parallel with semiconductors to limit a backward Euler rule and two half-size integration steps. This
overvoltages across them. Figure 2 shows a very simple case of method does not require recalculation of the admittance matrix.
a half-wave single-phase rectifier. Plots without and with
snubber circuit in parallel with the diode illustrate this drawback Another technique is based on interpolation [25]. Several
of the trapezoidal rule, and one possible solution. approaches have been developed. The procedure presented in
[26] uses two time step sizes and represents switching devices
(power electronics components) by means of characteristic
curves . A modified linear interpolation to solve problems
manifested not only in the network solution, but in the control
1-3
system too, has been presented in [27]. A significant effort has been made during the last years to
develop efficient procedures for implementation in emtps and
aimed at calculating ac steady-state initial conditions with the
2.3 INITIALIZATION presence of nonlinear components. The techniques can be
divided into three groups: frequency-domain, time-domain, and
The solution of a transient phenomenon is dependent on the hybrid methods.
initial conditions with which the transient is started. Although
some simulations can be performed with zero initial conditions, One of the first methods, known as Initialization with
for instance some lightning surge studies, there are many Harmonics (IwH), was presented in [28]. This procedure uses
instances for which the simulation must be started from power- an iterative solution based on the superposition of the steady-
frequency steady-state conditions. Capabilities to obtain the state phasor solutions at the fundamental frequency and at the
initial steady-state solution are of great importance in emtps. In most important harmonic frequencies, with a representation of
addition, an initialization procedure can be a useful tool on its nonlinear inductances as harmonic current sources.
own, for instance to calculate resonant voltages due to coupling
effects between parallel transmission lines. An improved version ofthe IwH method was presented in [29].
This procedure uses a harmonic Norton modeling of nonlinear
The steady-state solution of linear networks at a single branches and a quasi-Newton type method.
frequency is a rather simple task, and can be obtained using
nodal admittance equations [5] Several procedures have been proposed to calculate initial
[Y] [V] = [I] conditions using time-domain techniques. The search of the
(5) periodic steady-state solution is presented as a two-point
where [V] is the nodal complex admittance matrix boundary value optimization problem. Techniques developed
[V] is the vector of node voltages during the last years are based on an iterative Newton method.
[I] is the vector of current sources. More recent procedures use a shooting method [30], or a
waveform relaxation technique [31]. The latter paper presents
Elements of both [V] and [I] are complex phasor values. a procedure with a fast and efficient convergence in networks
with nonlinear power elements and ideal diode-type devices.
As for the transient solution, this equation is partitioned when
the network contains voltage sources to ground Hybrid approaches to calculate initial conditions in nonlinear
[YAA ] [VA] = [I A] - [YAB] [VB] networks using both frequency- and time-domain techniques
(6) have also been developed [32].
However, this task can be very complex in the presence of
nonlinearities. Saturation effects in transformers and shunt A different solution method to obtain steady-state solution is
reactors, rectifier loads and HVDC converter stations can needed when initial operating conditions are specified as power
produce steady-state harmonics. constraints. An initialization procedure, kown as Multiphase
Harmonic Load Flow (MHLF), was presented in [33] and [34].
The initial solution with harmonics can be obtained using some In this method, static compensators and other nonlinear
simple approaches. The simplest one is known as "brute force" elements, under balanced or unbalanced conditions, are
approach : the simulation is started without performing any represented by harmonic Norton equivalent circuits. Further
initial calculation and carried out long enough to let the improvements incorporated a synchronous machine model into
transients settle down to steady-state conditions. This approach the initialization procedure [35]. A simpler multiphase power
can have a reasonable accuracy, but its convergence will be very flow solution based on the MHLF procedure was presented in
slow ifthe network has components with light damping. A more [36]. If this approach is used for emtp initialization, sources
efficient method is to perform an approximate linear ac need to be defmed to drive the transient solution at those nodes
steady-state solution with nonlinear branches disconnected or for which load flow models were specified.
represented by linearized models. Some emtps have either a
"snapshot" or a "start again" feature. The state of the system is 2.4 CONTROL SYSTEMS
saved after a run, so later runs can be started at this point. Using
a "brute force" initialization, the system is started from The development of a section for representation of control
standstill, once it reaches the steady-state, a snapshot is taken systems in transients programs was initially motivated by
and saved. studies of HVDC links. The Transient Analysis of Control
Systems (TACS) option was implemented in the BPA EMTP in
1-4
1976 [37]. Although the main goal was the simulation ofHVDC Components other than transfer functions can be included in a
converters, it soon became obvious that TACS had many other TACS section, but they are seen as nonlinear blocks and not
applications, such as the representation of excitation of directly added into the simultaneous solution of transfer
synchronous generators, dynamic arcs in circuit breakers, or functions.
protective relays .
When a nonlinear block is inside a closed-loop configuration,
Control systems are represented in TACS by block diagrams a true simultaneous solution is not possible. The procedure
with interconnection between system elements. Control implemented in the TACS solution is simultaneous only for
elements can be transfer functions, FORTRAN algebraic linear blocks, that is s-transfer functions, and sequential for
functions, logical expressions and some special devices. The nonlinear blocks. When these blocks are present, the loop is
solution method used by TACS is also based on the trapezoidal broken and the system is solved by inserting a time delay. These
rule. A control block in the s-domain can be described by the delays inside control loops, as well as the delay between the
following relationship network and the control system, are the sources of different
X(s) = G(s) U(s) effects. Instabilities, inaccuracies and numerical oscillations
(7) produced by delays have been reported.
where U(s) and X(s) are respectively the input and the output in
the Laplace domain, and G(s) a rational transfer function Although the first release ofTACS was a powerful and flexible
tool, new applications have been demanding other capabilities
N +Ns+ • • • +Ns m than those implemented in the original version. One example are
G ( s) =K 0 1 m msn
Do + D1 S + ••• + Dns n (8) the new digital controls used in static compensators, HVDC
converters and other FACTS devices. The execution of tasks
Transfer functions are converted into algebraic equations in the only when needed, the simulation of conditional branching
time-domain (IF-THEN-ELSE) or the manipulation of vector arrays are
' x ( t ) =Kdu(t) +hist(t-~t)
capabilities not available in the first TACS releases.
(9)
where K is the gain, while c and d are obtained from the Several works have been performed to overcome main
coefficient of the rational transfer function G(s) [5], [37]. limitations and minimize problems originated by TACS :
* Improvements to solve internal time delays, initialization
A control system with many linear blocks results in a system of problems and some FORTRAN code limitations, were
equations with the following general form implemented and presented in [38].
[Ax) [x] + [Ax) [u] = [hist] (10)
* Limitations in FORTRAN code capabilities were solved by
The resulting algebraic equations of a control system are by developing an interface between TACS and FORTRAN
nature unsymmetrical. Due to this fact, the electric network and subroutines. The interface presented in [39] maintains full
the control system were solved separately in the original TACS TACS capabilities and takes advantage of the FORTRAN
release. The network solution is first advanced, network flexibility to represent digital controls.
variables are next passed to the control section, and then control * Another approach to overcome these limitations was provided
equations are solved. Finally, the network receives control by MODELS [40]. Initially known as "New TACS" , the
commands. The whole procedure introduces a time-step delay , MODELS program was developed to substitute the TACS
see Figure 3. program. However, it became obvious that both options
provided alternate approaches, and therefore TACS was
NETWORK preserved in those emtps in which MODELS was imbedded.
solution from - -----____. node volt a ge s. branch
t-tIt to t --........... currents, etc., between * Several techniques can be used to solve simultaneously power
'-""Z
<,<, i-At. end t used us input
network and control system equations and avoid problems
TACS
"'-" related to the interface delay . Two procedures using
voltage and
V;ifJe
( de_l~Y • compensation have been recently developed [41], [42] .
c u r r en t. sources, " U TACS
* A different and simple solution using filter interposition to
...'<, '
1 -5
3. MODELING OF COMPONENTS A significant number of papers dedicated to analyze the
frequency-dependence behaviour of overhead lines and
3.1 INTRODUCTION insulated cables for digital simulation has been presented during
the last 30 years. And although some efficient models are
An accurate simulation ofevery transient phenomenon requires presently implemented in the most widely used emtps, new
a representation of network components valid for a frequency efforts are being now devoted to the development of more
range that varies from DC to several MHz. An acceptable efficient models.
representation of each component throughout this frequency
range is very difficult, and for most components is not Some of the first papers presenting frequency-dependent line
practically possible. models for digital simulation were published during the late
1960's and early 1970's [44], [45]. Most models were aimed at
Modeling of power components taking into account the solving transmission-line equations using a time-domain
frequency-dependence ofparameters can be practically made by solution. Those models were based on the modal theory :
developing mathematical models which are accurate enough for multiphase line equations are decoupled through modal
a specific range of frequencies. Each range of frequencies transformation matrices, so that each mode can be separately
usually corresponds to some particular transient phenomena. studied as a single-phase line. For unbalanced and untransposed
One of the most accepted classification of frequency ranges is lines, transformation matrices are frequency dependent.
that proposed by the CIGRE WG 33-02 [184]. According to the However, it is possible to obtain a good accuracy using constant
CIGRE document, frequency ranges can be classified as four transformation matrices [46], [47].
groups with some overlapping
Several approaches using modal theory have been proposed:
* low-frequency oscillations, from 0.1 Hz to 3 kHz weighting functions [10], recursive convolutions [48] - [50],
* slow-front surges, from 50/60 Hz to 20 kHz state-space formulation [51]. One of the most popular models
was presented in [52]; the paper proposed the solution of a
* fast-front surges, from 10 kHz to 3 MHz transmission line model using a modified recursive convolution
* very-fast-front surges, from 100 kHz to 50 MHz. and assuming frequency-independent transformation matrices.
The transient solution of this model is based on the rational
This part discusses modeling works for some of the most function approximation of the propagation and characteristic
important network components - overhead lines, insulated admittance functions. The order of the rational functions will
cables, transformers, arresters, network equivalents, rotating depend on the line geometry, the frequency range and the
machines, circuit breakers - taking into account their desired accuracy. A high accuracy can only be obtained with a
frequency-dependent behaviour. large number of real poles. This can slow down the simulation
of large networks. Low-order fittings have been proposed as a
3.2 OVERHEAD LINES compromise between the solution accuracy and the model
simplicity [53], [54]. The validity and limitations of constant
Two types of time-domain models have been developed for transformation matrices, as well as guidelines on how to choose
overhead lines and insulated cables : these matrices, were discussed in [55].
a) Lumped-parameter models, that represent transmission
A procedure for representing dissipative multiconductor
systems by lumped elements whose values are calculated
transmission lines with frequency-dependent parameters in a
at a single frequency
wide frequency range has been recently proposed [56]. The
b) Distributed-parameter models, for which two categories procedure is aimed at evaluating the correcting terms to be
can be distinguished, constant parameter and frequency- added to the propagation and characteristic admittance functions
dependent parameter models. calculated according to the solution presented in [52].
The first type of models is adequate for steady-state New methods using frequency-dependent transformation
calculations, although they can also be used for transient matrices have been recently proposed. They are based on a
simulations in the neighbourhood of the frequency at which Newton-Raphson iteration technique [57], vector fitting and
parameters were evaluated. The most accurate models for modal decomposition [58], or polar decomposition [59].
transient calculations are those which take into account the
distributed nature of parameters and consider their A different solution method based on the superposition
frequency-dependence. principle and the Hartley transform was presented in [60].
1-6
Some recent works have shown that the solution of line Additional works related to cable modeling and some case
equations can be efficiently performed using a phase-domain studies are presented in [91] - [93].
formulation, instead of modal-domain [61] - [68]. Reference
[68] uses a second method which combines modal and phase As mentioned above, a new trend in the solution of cable
domain solutions. equations taking into account frequency-dependence of
parameters is to carry out calculations in the phase-domain [62],
All the previous papers consider transmission line [63], [64], [67].
representations taking into account only conductor geometry.
Some other parts ofa transmission line, such as the towers, have A method for simulating electromagnetic wave propagation in
an important influence on its performance in lightning studies. coaxial cables represented by finite sections, taking into account
The concept of nonuniform transmission lines includes the the frequency dependence of cable parameters, was presented
effect of towers and grounding resistances, as well as corona in [94].
effect [69], [70]. In lightning studies, towers are represented by
a surge impedance with an associated travel time. Literature 3.4 POWER TRANSFORMERS
related to tower modeling can be found in [71] - [74].
An accurate representation of a power transformer over a wide
A source of attenuation and distortion of surges and frequency range is very difficult, despite of its relatively simple
overvoltages in overhead lines is corona. An important effort design. In addition, two alternative transformer models can be
has been made during the last 20 years to understand this effect used whether surge transfer from one winding to another is not
and for its representation in transient studies [75] - [79]. Many of concern, or surge transfer has to be computed.
interesting papers dealing with corona representation in digital Representations for both situations were proposed in the
simulations have also been published [80] - [86]. document written by the CIGRE WG 33.02 [184].
3.3 INSULATED CABLES A significant effort on transformer modeling has been made
during the last twenty years. Some modeling approaches for use
The formulation of insulated cable equations and their solution in transient programs follow:
are similar to those used with overhead lines. However, the
1) The representation of single- and three-phase n-winding
large variety of cable designs makes very difficult the
transformers is made in the form of a branch impedance
development of a single model for representation of every type
or admittance matrix [95]. This approach is generally used
of cable.
to derive models for low-frequency and slow-front
transients. Transformer parameters are both nonlinear and
One of the first works dealing with a general formulation of
frequency-dependent. Major causes of iron core
impedances and admittances of single-core coaxial and
nonlinearities are saturation and hysteresis; one of the
pipe-type cables was presented in [87]. The cable models could
main causes of frequency-dependence are eddy currents.
be used to evaluate matrices and equivalent pi-circuits ofcables
This approach cannot include nonlinear effects of iron
and to obtain steady-state initialization at a single frequency, but
cores. They are incorporated by connecting nonlinear
they should be used to perform accurate transient calculations.
inductances at winding terminals, Many built-in models
The validity of this formulation is restricted, as mentioned
currently available in several emtps use this type of
above, to transient calculations in the neighbourhood of the
representation; their derivation is made from nameplate
frequency at which parameters are evaluated. The derivation of
data.
cable impedances and admittances was the subject of some
previous works, see [88] for coaxial cables and [89] for Iron core nonlinearities have been the subjects of many
pipe-type cables. interesting papers [96] - [102]. The representation of eddy
current effects has been analyzed in [103] - [106].
Reference [90] presented a method to solve cable equations
2) Detailed models incorporating core nonlinearities can also
considering the frequency-dependence ofcable parameters. The
be derived by using the principle of duality from a
solution of the cable equations is performed in the modal
topology based magnetic model [107] - [110]. This
domain and assumes frequency-dependence of modal
approach is very useful to create models accurate enough
transformation matrices. The model is valid for transient
for low-frequency and slow-front transients.
simulations over a wide frequency range. Recent works have
presented new approaches based on vector fitting and modal A different approach to obtain the equivalent circuit of a
decomposition [58], or polar decomposition [59]. three-phase five-legged transformer, valid also for
1-7
low-frequency and slow-front transients, was proposed in related to modeling of surge arresters can be found in [130],
[111]. A hybrid model based on core topology, and [131], [132].
consisting of electric and magnetic circuits was presented
in [112]. MOSAs present a frequency-dependent nonlinear characteris-
tic: the voltage across the arrester is a function ofboth the rate
3) Previous approaches do not consider frequency-dependent
of rise and th~ magnitude of the current conducted by the
parameters, they are not useful to represent a transformer
arrester.ModelmgofMOSAs was the subject ofa paper written
at high frequencies, although they can be improved if
by the IEEEWG on Surge Arrester Modeling [133]. The paper
lumped capacitances are connected across transformer
proposes a procedureto obtain the parametersof the equivalent
terminals. Models taking into account frequency-dependent
model from manufacturer's data.
parameters can be divided into two groups : models with
a detailed description of internal windings [113] and
A different model that represents the frequency-dependence
terminal models, based on the fitting of the elements of a
behaviour by means of a nonlinear inductance in series with a
circuit that represents the transformer as seen from its
nonlinear resistance was proposed in [134]. An algorithm to
terminals [114] - [118].
derive parametersof the arrester model from test data was also
included.
Reference [119] presents a simplified model based on the
classical T-fonn model; this model is extended to high
Modeling guidelines of gapped silicon-carbide surge arresters
freque~cie~ by adding winding capacitances and representing
~or digital simulationsof slow-front transients were presented
short-circuit branches by RL frequency-dependent equivalent
In [135]. The proposed model is based on current-limiting
networks.
arrester design. Recommendations to adapt the model for
lightning studies were also included.
A hybrid model for internal resonance studies, and valid for a
wide frequency range - from a few kHz to a few Mhz -, was
~etal-~xide v~stors (MOV) models suitable for digital
presentedin [120].Themodelis based on a coil-by-coil detailed
simulation ofsenes compensatedlines have been the subject of
model plus intercoil black box models.
some recent works [136], [137].
Detailed models are needed to obtain internal transient voltage
3.6 NETWORK EQUIVALENTS
distribution. These models are reasonably accurate for
insulation design, and generally consist of large networks.
The simulation of transient phenomena in power systems very
However,theymakesystemmodelsunnecessarylargewhenthe
often requires a detailed modeling of just a small part of the
concern is the response at the transformer terminals, Some
system to be studied. Network equivalents can be used to
effortshavebeen devotedto obtainreduced transformer models
represent those parts of the system for which a detailed
using eitherlinear or nonlinear techniques [121] - [124]. '
modeling is not needed. The goal is to reduce the complexity
and the computation time, while the simulation accuracy is
Other models, including saturation, hysteresis, as well as
preserved. Several procedures have been proposed since early
eddy-currentlosses, have been proposed in [125] - [127]. The
1970's to obtain single- and multi-port network equivalents
performance of different transformer models, most of them
[138] - [142].
currentlyimplemented in manyemtps,for the simulationof fast
switchingtransients was analyzed in [128].
Most of these procedures are based on the frequency response
of the network to be represented by the equivalent and on the
Usually models are derived considering the behaviour of the
application of a fitting technique to synthesize either a single-
transformer from its terminals, a method for simulation of
or a multi-port circuit which matches the response of the
internalfaultsinpowertransformers usingcapabilitiesavailable
network over a wide range of frequencies.
in some emtps was presented and validated in [129].
3.7 ROTATING MACHINES
3.5 SURGE ARRESTERS
The need for detailed synchronous generator models in
~~o basic ~es of surge arresters are now in use : gapped
transients programs was motivated by some serious
silicon-carbidearrestersand gaplessmetal-oxide surgearresters
su~~~chronous resonance (SSR) incidents in the early 1970's.
(MOSA). Although many of the arresters still in use are the
~tIhtIe~ were concerned about some problems involving
?lder type gapped silicon-carbide, the majority of the new
interactions between synchronous generators and power
mstalled arresters are the gapless metal-oxide type. Literature
1-8
systems. Different techniques to solve machine-power system interface
have also been developed and implemented in other transients
The simulation oftorsional interactions between the mechanical programs [149].
turbine-generator system and the power system needs a very
detailed representation of the generator and the power system. Models currently implemented in all emtps are adequate for
Several dynamic three-phase synchronous generator models simulation of low frequency transients. They are sufficiently
were developed and implemented in the BPA EMTP at mid accurate to analyze the interaction between the machine and the
1970's [143], [144]. All those models were based on the Park's power system, as well as torsional oscillations in the mechanical
transformation for solving the electrical equations. They part. However, these models are not adequate for simulation of
incorporated a detailed representation of mechanical and fast-front transients. Some switching motor operations can
electrical parts, used a sophisticated solution method to solve originatesteep-front surges and cause large turn-to-turn winding
machine-power system interface, and included interface to stresses. Lightning surges transferred through transformers are
control systems. also a source of high stresses and dielectric failures. Recent
works have proposed computer models for analyzing machine
Although its development was raised by SSR problems, those behaviour in fast-front transients and predicting distribution of
models could also be used for other studies, such as loss of interturn voltages caused by steep-fronted surges [150], [151],
synchronism, load rejection or transmission line reclosure. [152]. Some of these models have been represented and
Magnetic saturation effects were not included at early stages. A simulated using emtp capabilities [150], [152].
simple and efficient representation of magnetic saturation was
added to one model in the late 1970's [145]. Techniques to develop machine models based on their
frequency response have also been proposed [118], [153].
Interests in the analysis and simulation of renewable energy
sources motivated the demand for other machine models. A very Most emtp studies are dealing with large three-phase
powerful and flexible module, known as Universal Machine synchronous and induction machines. The analysis and
(UM), was implemented in the BPA EMTP in 1980 [146]. The simulation of small and special machines were presented in
UM module allowed the representation ofup to twelve different [154], [155].
machine models and expanded the applications ofthe program,
for instance to the simulation of adjustable speed drives. The The simulation of an induction machine using the existing
first UM release had several limitations that were solved in synchronous machine models available in some emtps was
subsequent versions [147]. Two interface methods, detailed in [156].
compensation and prediction, are currently used with this
module. 3.8 CIRCUIT BREAKERS
All the machine models above mentioned are based on the A circuit breaker opens its contacts when a tripping signal is
transformation of phase-quantities into dqo-quantities. The sent to it. The separation of the contacts causes the generation
matrix of self and mutual inductances becomes then constant. of an electric arc. The phenomenon by which the arc is actually
With models based on compensation methods no more than one extinguished is very complicated. Although a large number of
machine connected to the same nodes can be simulated. This arc models have been proposed, there is no general acceptance
limitation is avoided with a prediction-based interface. for any of them.
However, with this solution method, the prediction of several
electrical variables is needed. This can originate numerical Several approaches can be used to reproduce the arc
instability. interruption phenomenon; the most suitable representations in
a transients program are the so called black-box models [157],
The development of a synchronous generator model using [158]. The aim of a black-box arc model is to describe the
phase-domain equations instead of Park's transformation to interaction of an arc and a electrical circuit during an
solve the electrical equations has been recently presented [148]. interruption process. They consider the arc as a two-pole, and
This solution is numerically stable, as no prediction of any determine the transfer function using a chosen mathematical
electrical variable is made, and simplifies the inclusion of form and fitting free parameters to measured voltage and current
saturation effects. With this approach, the matrix of self and traces. Rather than internal processes, it is the electrical
mutual inductances changes with the rotor position, then the behaviour of the arc which is of importance. Several levels of
admittance matrix of the network has to be recalculated at each complexity are possible [159], [160] :
time step, which generally increases the simulation time. 1) The breaker is represented as an ideal switch that opens at
1-9
first zero current crossing, after the tripping signal is Several models can also be used to represent a circuit breaker in
given. This model can be used to obtain the voltage across closing operations [5] :
the breaker, which is to be compared with a pre-specified
1) The simplest model assumes that the breaker behaves as
transient recovery voltage (TRY) withstand capability for
an ideal switch whose impedance passes instantaneously
the breaker. This model cannot reproduce any interaction
from an infmite value, when open, to a zero value at the
between the arc and the system.
closing time. This performance can be represented at any
2) The arc is represented as a time-varying resistance, whose part of a power cycle.
variation is determined ahead of time based on the breaker
A closing operation can produce transient overvoltages
characteristic. This model can represent the effect of the
whose maximum peaks depend on several factors, for
arc on the system, but requires advanced knowledge of the
instance the network representation on the source side of
effect of the system on the arc.
the breaker, or the charge trapped on transmission lines in
3) The most advanced models represent the breaker as a a reclosing operation. One of the factor which has more
dynamically varying resistance or conductance. They can influence on the maximum peak is the instant of closing,
represent both the effect of the arc on the system and the which can be different for every pole of a three-phase
effect of the system on the arc. No precomputed TRY breaker.
curves are required. Most of these models rely on a first
Most transient programs allow users to analyze the
influence of this factor and obtain a statistical distribution
1 dg _ ( 1 vi ) of switching overvoltages, usually provided in the form of
g dt - "1[1 i I I g] P [j i I I g] - 1 (11) an accumulative frequency distribution. Two types of
switches can be represented:
order differential equation a - The closing time of a switch is systematically varied
where g is the arc conductance from a minimum to a maximum instant in equal
v is the arc voltage increments of time; this type is known as systematic switch.
i is the arc current
b - The closing time is randomly varied according to
't ,P are black-box model parameters.
either a normal (Gaussian) or an uniform distribution; this
These models are generally developed to determine initial type is known as statistical switch. Data required to
arc quenching, that is to study the thermal period only, represent these switches are the mean closing time, the
although some can also be used to determine arc reignition standard deviation and the number of switching operations.
due to insufficient voltage withstand capability of the When a pre-insertion resistor is used to mitigate switching
dielectric between breaker contacts. Their most important overvoltages, the closing time of both main and auxiliary
application cases are short line fault interruption and contacts are statistically determined.
switching of small inductive currents.
2) The breaker model assumes that there is a closing time
from the moment at which the contacts start to close to the
Many models for circuit breakers, represented as a dynamic
moment that they finally make. The withstand voltage
resistance/conductance, have been proposed. A survey on
decreases as the separation distance between contacts
black-box modeling of gas (air, SF6) circuit breakers was
decreases, an arc will strike before the contacts have
presented in [158]. The emtp implementation of three dynamic
completely closed if the voltage across them exceeds the
arc models, adequate for gas and oil circuit breakers, was
withstand voltage of the dielectric medium. Modeling of
presented in [161]. All those models are useful to represent a
the pre-strike effect and its influence on the switching
circuit breaker during the thermal period, models for
overvoltages produced during line energization has been
representation of SF6 breakers during thermal and dielectric
analyzed in [168].
periods were discussed and used [162], [163]. The development
of a user-defined model based on the Newton's method was
Similar models can be used with other switching devices, for
proposed in [164]. A new model also based on the Newton's
which a representation for both opening and closing operations
method and a predictor for calculation ofthe arc resistance was
can be needed.
recently presented [165].
3.9 OTHER COMPONENTS
A vacuum circuit breaker has a different performance, its
representation has to consider its statistical properties. Models
Capabilities currently available in most emtps make practically
for this type of breaker were presented in [166] and [167].
1-10
possibleuser-developed modelsof thosecomponents for which the probability of insufficient or wrong modeling. In
a built-in model has not been implemented. In fact, this is the addition, a very detailed representation of a system will
case for some componentmodels discussedabove require very long simulation time. Some experience will
* a transformermodel for low-frequency transientsbased on be therefore needed to decide how detailed the system
should be and choose the model for the most important
the principle of duality has not been implemented in any
components.
emtp, the capabilities needed to develope such a model
have been used in some papers [107]
Presently there are several sources where it is possible to
* there is no built-in model for circuit breakers in most consult modeling guidelines of power components for time-
emtps, but its representation can be made using branches domaindigital simulations :
and control features, available in all emtps [160], [164]
1) One of the first document published on this subject was
* althoughthere is a built-in surge arrestermodel that produced by the CIGRE WG 33-02 [184]; it covers
implemented in all emtps, it is not adequate for lightning the most important power components and proposes the
studies; users have to improve this model by taking representation of each component taking into account the
advantageof other capabilities. frequency range of the transient phenomena to be
simulated.
Semiconductors are usuallyrepresentedas ideal switchesin all
2) Modeling guidelines can also be found in the documents
switchingoperations,althoughsometransientsprogramsallow
produced by the IEEE Working Group on Modeling and
usersto considerignitionvoltagesandholdingcurrents. As with
Analysis of System Transients Using Digital Programs.
other components, capabilities available in some transient
The group was created in 1991 and later split up into 6
programscan be used to developmore accuraterepresentations
Task Forces. Followinga different approach to that of the
[169], [170].
CIGREWG, each TF was created to produce
documentation on a particulartype of studies : Low Ftapn:y
The list of components for which a built-in model is not
Transients, SwitchingTransients, Fast Front
available might also include instrument transformers [171] -
Transients, Very Fast Transients, Power Electronics,
[175], protective relays [176] - [181], fuses [182], [183]. The
Protection and Control. Up to date, several papers have
implementation ofmodelsfor instrumenttransformers andsome
been presented [185] - [190].
types of relays in one emtp was presented in [178].
3) Currently, the IEC Working Group 28-04 is dealing with
the same subject. This WG started its tasks in 1996. The
4. MODELINGGUIDELINES aim is to produce a document on modeling guidelines for
digital calculation of overvoltages.
The followingaspectsareto be consideredin digitalsimulations
of electromagnetic transients [184] :
5. CONCLUSIONS
a) Very often only approximated or estimated values are used
for some parameterswhose influenceon the representation
Time-domain simulations of electromagnetic transients using
of a component can be important or very important. In
digitalcomputers were started in early 1960's.Currently, most
general, this happens with some basic parameters and
transientsprograms are based on the Dommel'sscheme which
frequency-dependent parametersin simulations of fast and
combines the trapezoidalrule and the Bergeron'smethod.
very fast front transients. In addition, it is important to
take into account that some parameters may change due to
Muchworkhas been doneto solvesomeofthe main drawbacks
climatic conditions or be dependenton maintenance.
and limitations of the originalscheme,i.e solution of nonlinear
b) In many overvoltages studies it is the maximum peak networks, elimination of numerical oscillations. In addition, a
which is of interest. This maximum usually occurs during significanteffort has been dedicatedto the developmentof new
the first oscillation after the transient phenomenon starts. models, specially frequency-dependent models for the most
Large differences in peak values are mainly due to a poor importantpower components.
representationof losses, while deviations in inductances or
capacitances will lead to time shifting of the peak but not The development of the first tools was mainlymotivatedby the
to importantdifferences betweenthe maximumvalues. calculation of overvoltages. Presently most emtps can be used
for simulating a broad spectrum of transient phenomena in
c) The more components the system in study has, the higher
power systems : subsynchronous resonance, power quality
1-11
analysis, AC-DC links, FACTS and Custom Power 90, no. 6, pp. 2561-2567, November/December 1971.
technologies, electronically-controlled drives. [12] H.W. Dommel, "Usefulness and limitations of multi-
terminal reduced circuits", Proceedings of11th PSCC,
Due to the wide range oftransient phenomena in power systems pp. 1155-1160, August 30 - September 3, 1993,
and the complexity of many studies, modeling guidelines are Avignon (France).
needed to choose a correct representation of the most critical [13] T. Noda, K. Yamamoto, N. Nagaoka and A. Ametani,
components of the system to be simulated. Several works have "A predictor-corrector scheme for solving a nonlinear
been published during the last decade aimed at providing these circuit", Proceedings of IPST'97, pp. 5-10, June 22-
guidelines. However, some work is still needed to solve 26, 1997, Seattle.
important limitations, i.e. the representation of some [14] D.A. Woodford, A.M. Oole and R.Z. Menzies,
components is very complex, reliable data are not always "Digital simulation of de links and ac machines", IEEE
available. Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 102, no.
6, pp. 1616-1623, June 1983.
[15] W. Derek Humpage, Z-transform Electromagnetic
6. REFERENCES Transient Analysis in High-Voltage Networks, Peter
Peregrinus Ltd., London, 1982.
[1] H.W. Dommel, "Digital computer solution of [16] M. Roitman and P.S.R. Diniz, "Power system
electromagnetic transients in single- and multi-phase simulation based on wave digital filters", IEEE Trans.
networks", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and on Power Delivery, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 1098-1104,
Systems, vol. 88, no. 2, pp. 734-741, April 1969. April 1996.
[2] H.W. Dommel and W. Scott Meyer, "Computation of [17] J.P. Bickford, N. Mullineux and J.R. Reed,
Electromagnetic Transients", Proc. of IEEE, vol. 62, Computation of Power System Transients, Peter
no. 7, pp. 983-993, July 1974. Peregrinus Ltd., London, 1976.
[3] H.W. Dommel, "Techniques for analyzing electromag- [18] M. D'Amore and M.S. Sarto, "A new efficient
netic transients", IEEE Computer Applications in procedure for the transient analysis of dissipative
Power, vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 18-21, July 1997. power networks with nonlinear loads", IEEE Trans. on
[4] "Digital Simulation of Electrical Transient Power Delivery, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 533-539, January
Phenomena", A. Phadke (ed.), IEEE Tutorial Course, 1996.
Course Text 81 EHOI73-5-PWR. [19] Y. Kang and J.D. Lavers, "Transient analysis of
[5] H.W. Dommel, Electromagnetic Transients Program. electric power systems : Reformulation and theoretical
Reference Manual (EMTP Theory Book), Bonneville basis", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 11, no. 2,
Power Administration, Portland, 1986. pp. 754-760, May 1996.
[6] J.A. Martinez-Velasco (Ed.), Computer Analysis of [20] S.C. Tripathy, N.D. Rao and S. Elangovan,
Electric Power System Transients, IEEE Press, 1997. "Comparison of stability properties of numerical
[7] L.O. Barthold and O.K. Carter, "Digital traveling- integration methods for switching surges", IEEE Trans.
wave solutions. 1 - Single-phase equivalents", AlEE on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 97, no. 6, pp.
Trans., vol. 80, pte III, pp. 812-820, December 1961. 2318-2326, November/December 1978.
[8] W. Frey and P. Althammmer, "The calculation of [21] A. Semlyen and F. de Leon, "Computation of electro-
transients on lines by means of a digital computer", magnetic transients using dual or multiple time steps",
Brown Boveri Rev., vol. 48, pp. 334-355, May/June IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 8, no. 3, pp.
1961. 1274-1281, August 1993.
[9] J.R. Carson, "Wave propagation in overhead wires [22] F.L. Alvarado, R.H. Lasseter and J.J. Sanchez,
with ground return", Bell Syst. Tech. J., vol. 5, pp. "Testing of trapezoidal integration with damping for
539-554, 1926. the solution of power transient studies", IEEE Trans.
[10] W. Scott Meyer and H.W. Dommel, "Numerical on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 102, no. 12,
modeling of frequency dependent transmission-line pp. 3783-3790, December 1983.
parameters in an electromagnetic transients program", [23] J.R. Marti and J. Lin, "Suppression of numerical
IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. oscillations in the EMTP", IEEE Trans. on Power
93, no. 5, pp. 1401-1409, September/October 1974. Systems, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 739-747, May 1989.
[11] H.W. DommeI, "Nonlinear and time-varying elements [24] J. Lin and J.R. Marti, "Implementation of the CDA
in digital simulation of electromagnetic transients", procedure in the EMTP", IEEE Trans. on Power
IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. Systems, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 394-402, May 1990.
1-12
[25] B. Kulicke, "Simulation program NETOMAC : systems in an electromagnetic transients program with
Difference conductance method for continuous and TACS", Proc. ofIEEE PICA, pp. 266-271,1977.
discontinuous systems", Siemens Research and [38] R. Lasseter and J. Zhou, "TACS enhancements for the
Development Reports, vol. 10, no. 5, pp. 299-302, Electromagnetic Transient Program", IEEE Trans. on
1981. Power Systems, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 736-742, May 1994.
[26] T.L. Maguire and A.M. Gole, "Digital simulation of [39] L.X. Bui, S. Casoria, G. Morin and J. Reeve, "EMTP
flexible topology power electronic apparatus in power TACS-FORTRAN interface development for digital
systems", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol 6, no. controls modeling", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems,
4, pp. 1831-1840, October 1991. vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 314-319, February 1992.
[27] P. Kuffel, K. Kent and G. Irwin, "The implementation [40] L. Dube and I. Bonfanti, "MODELS : A new
and effectiveness of linear interpolation within digital simulation tool in the EMTP", European Transactions
simulation", Electrical Power and Energy Systems, vol. on Electrical Power Engineering, vol. 2, no. 1, pp.
19, no. 4, pp. 221-228, May 1997. 45-50, January/February 1992.
[28] H.W. Dommel, A. Van and S. Wei, "Harmonics from [41] A.E.A. Araujo, H.W. Dommel and J.R. Marti,
transformer saturation", IEEE Trans. on Power "Simultaneous solution of power and control
Systems, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 209-215, April 1986. equations", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 8, no.
[29] X. Lombard, J. Masheredjian, S. Lefebvre and C. 4, pp. 1483-1489, November 1993.
Kieny, "Implementation of a new harmonic [42] S. Lefebvre and J. Mahseredjian, "Improved control
initialization method in EMTP", IEEE Trans. on systems simulation in the EMTP through
Power Delivery, vol. 10, no. 3, pp.1343-1352, July compensation", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol.
1995. 10, no. 4, pp. 1654-1662, April 1995.
[30] B.K. Perkins, J.R. Marti and H.W. Dommel, [43] X. Cao et al., "Suppression of numerical oscillation
"Nonlinear elements in the EMTP : Steady-state caused by the EMTP-TACS interface using filter
initialization", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 10, interposition", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol.
no. 2, pp. 593-601, May 1995. 11, no. 4, pp. 2049-2055, October 1996.
[31] Q.Wang and J.R. Marti, "A waveform relaxation [44] A. Budner, "Introduction of frequency-dependent line
technique for steady state initialization of circuits with parameters into an electromagnetic transients
nonlinear elements and ideal diodes", IEEE Trans. on program", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and
Power Delivery, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 1437-1443, July Systems, vol. 89, no. 1, pp. 88-97, January 1970.
1996. [45] J.K. Snelson, "Propagation of travelling waves on
[32] G. Murere, S. Lefebvre and X.D. Do, "A generalized transmission lines - Frequency dependent parameters",
harmonic balance method for EMTP initialization", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol.
IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 91, no. 1, pp. 85-91, January/February 1972.
1353-1359, July 1995. [46] P.C. Magnusson, "Traveling waves on multi-
[33] W. Xu, J.R. Marti and H.W. Dommel, "A multiphase conductor open-wire lines. A numerical survey of the
harmonic load flow solution technique", IEEE Trans. effects of frequency dependence of modal
on Power Systems, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 174-182, composition", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and
February 1991. Systems, vol. 92, no. 3, pp. 999-1008, May/June
[34] W. Xu, J.R. Marti and H.W. DommeI, "Harmonic 1973.
analysis of systems with static compensators", IEEE [47] R.G. Wesley and S. Selvavinayagamoorthy,
Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 183-190, "Approximate frequency-response values for
February 1991. transmission line transient analysis", Proc. lEE, vol.
[35] W. Xu, J.R. Marti and H.W. Dommel, "A 121, no. 4, pp. 281-286, April 1974.
synchronous machine model for three-phase harmonic [48] A. Semlyen and A. Dabuleanu, "Fast and accurate
analysis and EMTP initialization", IEEE Trans. on switching transient calculations on transmission lines
Power Systems, vol. 6, no. 4, pp. 1530-1538, with ground return using recursive convolutions",
November 1991. IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol.
[36] J.J. Allemong, R.J. Bennon and P.W. Selent, 94, no. 2, pp. 561-571, MarchlApri I 1975.
"Multiphase power flow solutions using EMTP and [49] A. Ametani, "A highly efficient method for calculating
Newtons method", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, transmission line transients", IEEE Trans. on Power
vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 1455-1462, November 1993. Apparatus and Systems, vol. 95, no. 5, pp. 1545-1551,
[37] L. Dube and H.W. Dommel, "Simulation of control September/October 1976.
1-13
[50] A. Semlyen, "Contributions to the theory of calculation approximation of transfer matrices and its application
of electromagnetic transients on transmission lines with to the phase domain calculation of electromagnetic
frequency dependent parameters", IEEE Trans. on transients", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 9, no.
Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 100, no. 2, pp. 1, pp. 420-428, February 1994.
848-856, February 1981. [62] B. Gustavsen, J. Sletbak and T. Henriksen,
[51] J.F. Hauer, "State-space modeling of transmission line "Calculation of electromagnetic transients in
dynamics via nonlinear optimization", IEEE Trans. on transmission cables and lines taking frequency
Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 100, no. 12, pp. dependent effects accurately into account", IEEE
4918-4924, December 1981. Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 10, no. 2, pp.
[52] J.R. Marti, "Accurate modeling of frequency- 1076-1084, April 1995.
dependent transmission lines in electromagnetic [63] T. Noda, N. Nagaoka and A. Ametani, "Phase domain
transient simulations", IEEE Trans. on Power modeling of frequency-dependent transmission lines by
Apparatus and Systems, vol. 101, no. 1, pp. 147-155, means of an ARMA model", IEEE Trans. on Power
January 1982. Delivery, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 401-411, January 1996.
[53] L. Marti, "Low-order approximation of transmission [64] T. Noda, N. Nagaoka and A. Ametani, "Further
line parameters for frequency-dependent models" , improvements to a phase-domain ARMA line model in
IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. terms of convolution, steady-state initialization, and
102, no. 11, pp. 3582-3589, November 1983. stability", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 12,
[54] A. Oguz Soysal and A. Semlyen, "Reduced order no. 3,1327-1334, July 1997.
transmission line modeling for improved efficiency in [65] F. Castellanos and J.R. Marti, "Full frequency-
the calculation of electromagnetic transients", IEEE dependent phase-domain transmission line model",
Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 1494- IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 12, no. 3, pp.
1498, August 1994. 1331-1339, August 1997.
[55] J.R. Marti, H.W. Dommel, L. Marti and V. [66] H.V. Nguyen, H.W. Dommel and J.R. Marti, "Direct
Brandwajn, "Approximate transformation matrices for phase-domain modeling of frequency-dependent
unbalanced transmission lines", Proc. ofthe 9th Power overhead transmission lines", IEEE Trans. on Power
Systems Computer Conference, Cascais (Portugal), Delivery, vol. 12, no. 3, 1335-1342, July 1997.
1987. [67] A. Morched, B. Gustavsen and M. Tartibi, "A
[56] M. D'Amore and M.S. Sarto, "Modelling of lossy universal model for accurate calculation of
ground parameters in the EMTP for very-fast transient electromagnetic transients on overhead lines and
analysis", Proceedings ofIPST'97, pp. 49-54, June 22- underground cables", Paper presented at the 1997
26, 1997, Seattle. IEEE PES Summer Meeting, July 20-24, 1997, Berlin.
[57] L.M. Wedepohl, H.V. Nguyen and G.D. Irwin, [68] B. Gustavsen and A. Semlyen, "Combined phase and
"Frequency-dependent transformation matrices for modal domain calculation of transmission line
untransposed transmission lines using Newton-Raphson transients based on vector fitting", IEEE Trans. on
method", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 11, no. Power Delivery, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 596-604, April
3, pp. 1538-1546, August 1996. 1998.
[58] B. Gustavsen and A. Semlyen, "Simulation of [69] M.T. Correia de Barros and M.E. Almeida,
transmission line transients using vector fitting and "Computation of electromagnetic transients on
modal decomposition", IEEE Trans. on Power nonuniform transmission lines", IEEE Trans. on Power
Delivery, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 605-614, April 1998. Delivery, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 1082- 1091, April 1996.
[59] B. Gustavsen and A. Semlyen, "Calculation of [70] H.V. Nguyen, H.W. Dommel and J.R. Marti,
transmission line transients using polar decomposition", "Modeling of single-phase nonuniform transmission
IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 13, no. 3, pp. lines in electromagnetic transient simulations", IEEE
855-862, July 1998. Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 12, no. 2, 916-921,
[60] R. Mahmutcehajic, S. Babic, R. Gacanovic and S. April 1997.
Carsimamovic, "Digital simulation of electromagnetic [71] W.A. Chisholm, Y.L. Chow and K.D. Srivastava,
wave propagation in a multiconductor transmission "Lightning surge response of transmission towers",
system using the superposition principle and Hartley IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol.
transform", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 8, 102, no. 9, pp. 3232- 3242, September 1983.
no. 3, pp. 1377-1385, July 1993. [72] W.A. Chisholm and Y.L. Chow, "Travel time of
[61] A. Oguz Soysal and A. Semlyen, "State equation transmission towers", IEEE Trans. on Power
1-14
Apparatus and Systems, vol. 104, no. 10, pp. 2922 [85] J.R. Marti, F. Castellanos and N. Santiago, "Wide
-2928, October 1985. -band corona circuit model for transient simulations",
[73] M. Ishii et aI., "Multistory transmission tower model IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 4, no. 2, pp.
for lightning surge analysis", IEEE Trans. on Power 1003-1013, May 1995.
Delivery, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 1327-1335, July 1991. [86] H.M. Barros, S. Carneiro Jr. and R.M. Azevedo, "An
[74] T. Yamada et aI., "Experimental evaluation of a DHV efficient recursive scheme for the simulation of
tower model for lightning surge analysis", IEEE Trans. overvoltages on multiphase systems under corona",
on Power Delivery, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 393-402, IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 10, no. 3, pp.
January 1995. 1443-1452, July 1995.
[75] M.Mihailescu-Suliciu and 1. Suliciu, "A rate type [87] A. Ametani, "A general formulation of impedance and
constitutive equation for the description of the corona admittance of cables", IEEE Trans. on Power
effect", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, Apparatus and Systems, vol. 99, no. 3, pp. 902-910,
vol. 100, no. 8, pp. 3681-3685, August 1981. May/June 1980.
[76] X.-R. Li, O.P. Malik and Z.-D. Zhao, "A practical [88] L.A. Wedepohl and D.J. Wilcox, "Transient analysis
mathematical model of corona for calculation of of underground power-transmission systems", Proc.
transients on transmission lines", IEEE Trans. on lEE, vol. 120, no. 2, pp. 253-260, February 1973.
Power Delivery, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 1145-1152, April [89] G.W. Brown and R.G. Rocamora, "Surge propagation
1989. in three-phase pipe type cables. Part I - Unsaturated
[77] M.A. AI-Tai et aI., "The simulation of surge corona pipe", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems,
on transmission lines", IEEE Trans. on Power vol. 95, no. 1, pp. 88-95, January/February 1976.
Delivery, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 1360-1368, April 1989. [90] L. Marti, "Simulation of transients in underground
[78] X.-R. Li, O.P. Malik and Z.-D. Zhao, "Computation cables with frequency-dependent modal transformation
of transmission lines transients including corona matrices", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 3, no.
effects", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 1099-1110, July 1988.
3, pp. 1816-1821, July 1989. [91] A. Ametani, "Wave propagation characteristics of
[79] C. de Jesus and M.T. Correia de Barros, "Modelling cables", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and
of corona dynamics for surge propagation studies", Systems, vol. 99, no. 2, pp. 499-505, April 1980.
IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. [92] N. Nagaoka and A. Ametani, "Transient calculations
1564-1569, July 1994. on crossbonded cables", IEEE Trans. on Power
[80] K.C. Lee, "Non-linear corona models in an Apparatus and Systems, vol. 102, no. 4, pp. 779-787,
electromagnetic transients program (EMTP) ", IEEE April 1983.
Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 102, no. [93] B. Gustavsen and J. Sletbak, "Transient sheath
9, pp. 2936-2942, September 1983. overvoltages in armoured power cables", IEEE Trans.
[81] W.-G. Huang and A. Semlyen, "Computation of on Power Delivery, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 1594-1600,
electro- magnetic transients on three-phase transmission July 1996.
lines with corona and frequency dependent [94] R.J. Meredith, "EMTP modeling of electromagnetic
parameters", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 2, transients in multi-mode coaxial cables by fmite
no. 3, pp. 887-898, July 1987. sections", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 12,
[82] P. Sanna Maruvada, D.H. Nguyen and H. no. 1, pp. 489-496, January 1997.
Hamadani-Zadeh, "Studies on modeling corona [95] V. Brandwajn, H.W. Dommel and 1.1. Dommel,
attenuation of dynamic overvoltages", IEEE Trans. on "Matrix representation of three-phase n-winding
Power Delivery, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 1441-1449, April transformers for steady-state and transient studies",
1989. IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol.
[83] S. Carneiro Jr. and J.R. Marti, "Evaluation of corona 101, no. 6, pp. 1369-1378, June 1982.
and line models in electromagnetic transient [96] W.L.A. Neves and H.W. Dommel, "On modeling iron
simulations", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 6, core nonlinearities", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems,
no. 1, pp. 334-342, January 1991. vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 417-425, May 1993.
[84] S. Carneiro Jr., H.W. Dommel, J.R. Marti and H.M. [97] W.L.A. Neves and H.W. Dommel, "Saturation curves
Barros, "An efficient procedure for the implementation of delta-connected transformers from measurements",
of corona models in electromagnetic transients IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 10, no. 3, pp.
programs", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 9, 1432-1437, July 1995.
no. 2, pp. 849-855, April 1994. [98] M. Vakilian and R.C. Degeneff, "A method for
1-15
modeling nonlinear core characteristics of transformer presented at the 1998 IEEE PES Winter Meeting,
during transients", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, February 1-5, 1998, Tampa.
vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 1916-1925, October 1994. [111] D.L. Stuehm, B.A. Mork and D.D. Mairs, "Five-
[99] S.N. Talukdar and J.R. Bailey, "Hysteresis models for legged core transformer equivalent circuit", IEEE
system studies", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 4, no. 3, pp.
Systems, vol. 95, no. 4, pp. 1429-1434, July/August 1786-1793, July 1989.
1976. [112] X. Chen, "A three-phase multi-legged transformer
[100] E.P. Dick and W.Watson, "Transformer models for model in ATP using the directly-formed inverse
transient studies based on field measurement", IEEE inductance matrix", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery,
Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 100, no. vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 1554-1562, July 1996.
1, pp. 401-419, January 1981. [113] R.C. Degeneff "A general method for determining
[101] J.G. Frame, N. Mohan and T.H. Liu, "Hysteresis resonances in transformer windings", IEEE Trans. on
modeling in an electro-magnetic transients program", Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 96, no. 2,
IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. MarchiApril 1977.
101, no. 9, pp. 3403-3412, September 1982. [114] R.C. Degeneff, "A method for constructing terminal
[102] F. de Leon and A. Semlyen, "Simple representation of models for single-phase n-winding transformers",
dynamic hysteresis losses in power transformers", Paper No. A 78 539-9, 1978 IEEE PES Summer
IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. Meeting, July 16-21, Los Angeles.
315-321, January 1995. [115] A. Morched, L. Marti and J. Ottevangers, "A high
[103] J. Avila-Rosales and F.L. Alvarado, "Nonlinear frequency transformer model for the EMTP", IEEE
frequency dependent transformer model for Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 1615-
electromagnetic transient studies in power systems", 1626, July 1993.
IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. [116] P.T.M. Vaessen, "Transformer model for high
101, no. 11, pp. 4281-4288, November 1982. frequencies", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 3,
[104] J. Avila-Rosales and A. Semlyen, "Iron core modeling no. 4, pp. 1761-1768, October 1988.
for electrical transients", IEEE Trans. on Power [117] V. Woivre, J.P. Artaud, A Ahmad and N. Burais,
Apparatus and Systems, vol. 104, no. 11, pp. 3189- "Transient overvoltage study and model for shell-type
3194, November 1985. power transformers", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery,
[105] E.J. Tarasiewicz, A.S. Morched, A. Narang and E.P. vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 212-222, January 1993.
Dick, "Frequency dependent eddy current models for [118] A. Oguz Soysal, "A method for wide frequency range
nonlinear iron cores", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, modeling of power transformers and rotating
vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 588-597, May 1993. machines", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 8,
[106] F. de Leon and A. Semlyen, "Detailed modeling of no. 4, pp. 1802-1810, October 1993.
eddy current effects for transformer transients", IEEE [119] S. Chimklai and J.R. Marti, "Simplified three-phase
Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 1143- transformer model for electromagnetic transient
1150, April 1994. studies", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 10, no.
[107] C.M. Arturi, "Transient simulation and analysis of a 3, pp. 1316-1324, July 1995.
three-phase five-limb step-up transformer following an [120] G.B. Gharehpetian, H. Mohseni and K. Moller,
out-of-phase synchronization", IEEE Trans. on Power "Hybrid modelling of inhomogeneus transformer
Delivery, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 196-207, January 1991. windings for very fast transient overvoltage studies",
[108] A. Narang and R. H. Brierley, "Topology based IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 13, no. 1, pp.
magnetic model for steady-state and transient studies 157-163, January 1998.
for three-phase core type transformers", IEEE Trans. [121] R.C. Degeneff, M.R. Gutierrez and P.J. McKenny,
on Power Systems, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 1337-1349, "A method for constructing reduced order transformer
August 1994. models for system studies from detailed lumped
[109] X. Chen and S.S. Venkata, "A three-phase three- parameter models", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery,
winding core-type transformer model for low-frequency vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 649-655, April 1992.
transient studies", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, [122] M. Gutierrez, R.C. Degeneff P.J. McKennny and
vol. 12, no. 3, 775-782, April 1997. J.M. Schneider, "Linear, lumped parameter
[110] B.A. Mork, "Five-legged wound-core transformer transformer model reduction technique", IEEE Trans.
model: Derivation, parameters, implementation, and on Power Delivery, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 853-861, April
evaluation", Paper PE-414-PWRD-0-12-1997, 1995.
1-16
[123] R.C. Degeneff, M.R. Gutierrez and M. Vakilian, Systems, vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 953-958, November 1987.
"Nonlinear, lumped parameter transformer model [137] J.R. Lucas and P.G. McLaren, "A computationally
reduction technique", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, efficient MOV model for series compensation studies",
vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 862-868, April 1995. IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 6, no. 4, pp.
[124] R.I. Galarza, J.H. Chow and R.C. Degeneff, 1491-1497, October 1991.
"Transformer model reduction using time and [138] A.S. Morched and V. Brandwajn, "Transmission
frequency domain sensitivity techniques", IEEE Trans. network equivalents for electromagnetic transients
on Power Delivery, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 1052-1059, studies", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and
April 1995. Systems, vol. 102, no. 9, pp. 2984- 2994, September
[125] D.N. Ewart, "Digital computer simulation model of a 1983.
steel-core transformer", IEEE Trans. on Power [139] M. Kizilcay, "Low-order network equivalents for
Delivery, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 174-183, July 1986. electromagnetic transients studies", European
[126] D. Dolinar, J. Pihler and B. Grear, "Dynamic model Transactions on Electrical Power Engineering, vol. 3,
of a three-phase power transformer", IEEE Trans. on no. 2, pp. 123-129, March/April 1993.
Power Delivery, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 1811-1819, October [140] A. Abur and H. Singh, "Time domain of external
1993. systems for electromagnetic transients programs",
[127] F. de Leon and A. Semlyen, "Complete transformer IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 8, no. 2, pp.
model for electromagnetic transients", IEEE Trans. on 671-679, May 1993.
Power Delivery, vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 231-239, January [141] A.S. Morched, J.H. Ottevangers and L. Marti,
1994. "Multi-port frequency dependent network equivalents
[128] B.C. Papadias et aI., "Three phase transformer for the EMTP", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol.
modelling for fast electromagnetic transient studies", 8, no. 3, pp. 1402-1412, July 1993.
IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. [142] H. Singh and A. Abur, "Multiport equivalencing of
1151-1159, April 1994. external systems for simulation of switching
[129] P. Bastard, P. Bertrand and M. Meunier, "A transients", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 10,
transformer model for winding fault studies", IEEE no. 1, pp. 374-382, January 1995.
Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 690-699, [143] V. Brandwajn and H.W. Dommel, "A new method for
April 1994. interfacing generator models with an electromagnetic
[130] D.P. Carroll et aI., "A dynamic surge arrester model transients program", Proc. of IEEE PICA, pp.
for use in power system transient studies", IEEE 260-265, 1977.
Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 91, no. [144] G. Gross and M.C. Hall, "Synchronous machine and
3, pp. 1057-1066, May/June 1972. torsional dynamics simulation in the computation of
[131] C. Dang, T.M. Parnell and P.J. Price, "The response electromagnetic transients", IEEE Trans. on Power
of metal oxide surge arresters to steep fronted current Apparatus and Systems, vol. 97, no. 4, pp. 1074-1086,
impulses", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 1, no. July/August 1978.
1, pp. 157-163, January 1986. [145] V. Brandwajn, "Representation of magnetic saturation
[132] W. Schmidt et aI., "Behaviour of MO-surge-arrester in the synchronous machine model in an
blocks to fast transients", IEEE Trans. on Power electromagnetic transients program", IEEE Trans. on
Delivery, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 292-300, January 1989. Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 99, no. 5, pp.
[133] IEEE Working Group on Surge Arrester Modeling, 1996-2002, September/October 1980.
"Modeling of metal oxide surge arresters", IEEE [146] H.K. Lauw and W. Scott Meyer, "Universal machine
Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 302-309, modeling for the representation of rotating machinery
January 1992. in an electromagnetic transients program", IEEE Trans.
[134] I. Kim et al., "Study of ZnO arrester model for steep on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 101, no. 6, pp.
front wave", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 11, 1342-1352, June 1982.
no.2,pp.834-841,ApriI1996. [147] H.K. Lauw, "Interfacing for universal multi-machine
[135] IEEE Working Group of Surge Protective Devices system modeling in an electromagnetic transients
Committee, "Modeling of current-limiting surge program", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and
arresters", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 104, no. 9, pp. 2367-2373, September
Systems, vol. 100, no. 8, pp. 4033-4040, August 1981. 1985.
[136] D. L. Goldsworthy, "A linearized model for MOV- [148] J.R. Marti and K.W. Louie, "A phase-domain
protected series capacitors", IEEE Trans. on Power synchronous generator model including saturation
1-17
effects", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 12, no. 799-805, May 1988.
1, pp. 222-229, February 1997. [162] L. van der Sluis, W.R. Rutgers and C.G.A. Koreman,
[149] A.M. Gole, R.W. Menzies, H.M. Turanli and D.A. "A physical arc model for the simulation of current
Woodford, "Improved interfacing of electrical machine zero behaviour of high-voltage circuit breakers", IEEE
models to electromagnetic transients programs", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 7, no. 2, pp.
Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 103, no. 1016-1022, April 1992.
9,pp. 2446-2451, September 1984. [163] Z. Ma et aI., "An investigation of transient overvoltage
[150] P.G. McLaren and M.H. Abdel-Rahman, "Modeling generation when switching high voltage shunt reactors
of large AC motor coils for steep-fronted surge by SF6 circuit breaker", IEEE Trans. on Power
studies", IEEE Trans. on Industry Applications, vol. Delivery, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 472-479, April 1998.
24, no. 3, pp. 422-426, May/June 1988. [164] J.A. Martinez-Velasco, "Modelling of circuit breaker
[151] J.L. Guardado and K.J. Cornick, "A computer model using the type-94 component", EEUG Meeting 1995,
for calculating steep-fronted surge distribution in Hannover, November 13-15, 1995.
machine windings", IEEE Trans. on Energy [165] J. Mahseredjian, M. Landry and B. Khodabakhchian,
Conversion, vol. 4, no. 1,95-101, March 1989. "The new EMTP breaker arc model", Proceedings of
[152] A. Narang, B.K. Gupta, E.P. Dick and D.K. Sharma, IPST'97, pp. 245-249, June 22-26, 1997, Seattle.
"Measurement and analysis of surge distribution in [166] J. Kosmac and P. Zunko, "A statistical vacuum circuit
motor stator windings", IEEE Trans. on Energy breaker model for simulation of transients
Conversion, vol. 4, no. 1, 126-134, March 1989. overvoltages", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol.
[153] N.J. Bacalao, P. de Arizon and R.O. Sanchez, "A 10, no. 1, pp. 294-300, January 1995.
model for the synchronous machine using frequency [167] M.T. Glinkowski, M.R. Gutierrez and D. Braun,
response measurements", IEEE Trans. on Power "Voltage escalation and reignition behavior of vacuum
Systems, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 457-464, February 1995. circuit breakers during load shedding", IEEE Trans. on
[154] A. Domijan and Y. Yin, "Single-phase induction Power Delivery, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 219-226, January
machine simulation using the Electromagnetic 1997.
Transients Program: Theory and test cases", IEEE [168] D.A. Woodford and L.M. Wedepohl, "Impact of
Trans. on Energy Conversion, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. circuit breaker pre-strike on transmission line
535-542, September 1994. energization transients", Proceedings of IPST'97, pp.
[155] H. Knudsen, "Extended Park's transformation for 250-253, June 22-26, 1997, Seattle.
2x3-phase synchronous machine and converter phasor [169] J.A. Martinez-Velasco, R. Abdo and G. Capolino,
model with representation of harmonics", IEEE Trans. "Advanced representation of power semiconductors
on Energy Conversion, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 126-132, using the EMTP", Proceedings of IPST'95, pp. 505-
March 1995. 510, September 3-7, 1995, Lisbon.
[156] R. Hung and H.W. Dommel, "Synchronous machine [170] C. Wong, "EMTP modeling of IGBT dynamic
models for simulation of induction motor transients", performance for power dissipation estimation", IEEE
IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. Trans. on Industry Applications, vol. 33, no. 1, pp.
833-838, May 1996. 64-71, January/February 1997. .
[157] ClORE Working Group 13.01, "Practical application [171] J. Lucas et al., "Improved simulation models for
of arc physics in circuit breakers. Survey of calculation current and voltage transformers in relay studies",
methods and application guide", Electra, no. 118, pp. IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 7, no. 1, pp.
64-79,1988. 152-159, January 1992.
[158] CIGRE Working Group 13.01, "Applications of black [172] M. Kezunovic et al., "Digital models of coupling
box modelling to circuit breakers", Electra, no. 149, capacitor voltage transformers for protective relay
pp. 40-71, August 1993. transient studies", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery,
[159] EPRI Report EL-4651, "Electromagnetic Transients vol. 7, no. 4, pp. 1927-1935, October 1992.
Program (EMTP) Workbook II", 1989. [173] M. Kezunovic et al., "Experimental evaluations of
[160] J.A. Martinez-Velasco, "Circuit breaker representation EMTP-based current transformer models for protective
for TRV calculations", EEUG Meeting 1995, relay transient study", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery,
Hannover, November 13-15, 1995. vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 405-413, January 1994.
[161] V. Phaniraj and A.G. Phadke, "Modeling of circuit [174] M. Kezunovic et aI., "A new method for the CCVT
breakers in the electromagnetic transients program", performance analysis using field measurements, signal
IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. processing and EMTP modeling", IEEE Trans. on
1-18
Power Delivery, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 1907-1915, October limiting fuses in distribution systems for improved
1994. power quality and protection", IEEE Trans. on Power
[175] M.R. Iravani et aI., "Digital time-domain investigation Delivery, vol. 12, no. 2, 791-800, 1\pril1997.
of transient behaviour of coupling capacitor voltage [184] CIGRE Working Group 02 (SC 33), "Guidelines for
transformer", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 13, Representation of Network Elements when Calculating
no. 2,pp. 622-629,1\pril 1998. Transients", 1990.
[176] 1\. Domijan and M.V. Emami, "State space relay [185] IEEE Task Force on Slow Transients (M.R. Iravani,
modeling and simulation using the Electromagnetic Chairman), "Modeling and .Analysis Guidelines for
Transients Program and its Transient Analysis of slow transients. Part I : Torsional Oscillations;
Control Systems capability", IEEE Trans. on Energy Transient Torques; Turbine blade vibrations; Fast bus
Conversion, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 697-702, December transfer", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 10,
1990. no. 4, pp. 1950-1955, October 1995.
[177] R.E. Wilson and J.M. Nordstrom, "EMTP transient [186] IEEE Task Force on Slow Transients (M.R. Iravani,
modeling of a distance relay and a comparison with Chairman), "Modeling and Analysis Guidelines for
EMTP laboratory testing", IEEE Trans. on Power slow transients. Part II : Controller Interactions;
Delivery, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 984-992, July 1993. Harmonic Interactions", IEEE Trans. on Power
[178] 1\.K.S. Chaudhary, K.S. Tam and A.G. Phadke, Delivery, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 1672-1677, July 1995.
"Protection system representation in the [187] IEEE Task Force on Slow Transients (M.R. Iravani,
electromagnetic transients program", IEEE Trans. on Chairman), "Modeling And Anlysis Guidelines for
Power Delivery, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 700-711, April slow transients - Part III : The study of ferroreso-
1994. nance" , 1998 IEEE Summer Power Meeting, July 12-
[179] M.T. Glinkowski and J. Esztergalyos, "Transient 16, San Diego.
modeling of electromechanical relays. Part I : [188] IEEE TF on Fast Front Transients (A.Imece,
A.rmature type overcurrent relays", IEEE Trans. on Chairman), "Modeling guidelines for fast transients",
Power Delivery, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 763-770, April IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 11, no. 1,
1996. January 1996.
[180] M.T. Glinkowski and J. Esztergalyos, "Transient [189] IEEE TF on Very Fast Transients (D. Povh,
modeling of electromechanical relays. Part II : Plunger Chairman), "Modeling and analysis guidelines for very
Type 50 relays", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. fast transients", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol.
11, no. 2, pp. 771-782, April 1996. 11, no. 4, October 1996.
[181] J.1\. Martinez-Velasco and L. Kojovic, "1\TP modeling [190] IEEE Task Force on Power Electronics (L. Tang,
of electromechanical relays", Proceedings ofIPST'97, Chairman), "Guidelines for modeling power electronics
pp. 446-451, June 22-26, 1997, Seattle. in electric power engineering applications", IEEE
[182] 1\. Petit, G. St-Jean and G. Fecteau, "Empirical model Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 12, no. 1, pp.
of a current-limiting fuse using EMTP", IEEE Trans. 505-514, January 1997.
on Power Delivery, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 335-341,
January 1989.
[183] L. Kojovic and S. Hassler, "Application of current
1-19
Modeling Guidelines for Power Electronics in Electric Power
Engineering Applications
Report Prepared by the Power Electronics Task Force
of the IEEE Modeling and Analysis of System Transients Working Group
Contributing Members: K. K. Sen (Co-Chair), L. Tang (Co-Chair), H. W. Do~mel, K. G. ~ehrle, A. M.
Gole, E.W. Gunther, I. Hassan, R. Iravani, A. J. F. Keri R. Lasseter, J. R. Marti, J. A. Martinez, M. F.
McGranaghan, O. B. Nayak, C. Nwankpa, P. F. Ribeiro
ABSTRACT -This paper presents a summary of of the interaction between the power electronic subsystem
guidelines for modeling power electronics in various power and the connected power system. Thus, a model for a power
engineering applications. This document is designed for use by electronic switching device can be greatly simplified.
power engineers who need to simulate power electronic devices
Detailed descriptions about the device representation are
and subsystems with digital computer programs. The guideline
presented in the later section of this paper. In the last section
emphasizes the basic issues that are critical for successful mod-
eling of power electronics devices and the interface between of the paper, the references related to various power elec-
power electronics and the utility or industrial system. The mod- tronics simulations are listed.
eling considerations addressed in this guideline are generic for
all power electronics modeling independent of the computa- 2. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS OF POWER
tional tool. However, for the purposes of illustration, the simu- ELECTRONICS MODELING
lation examples presented are based on the EMTP or EMTP
type of programs. The procedures used to implement power 2.1. Types ofProblems
electronics models in these examples are valuable for using
other digital simulation tools. Power electronics modeling can be divided into
two basic categories, depending on study objectives. The
1. INTRODUCTION first category covers all steady state evaluations. The focus
is from the power system response to the harmonics injected
As a consequence of the advances in power elec- from a power electronics subsystem. Examples of this type
tronics technologies over the last two decades, power elec- include a study of the steadystate harmonic propagation in a
tronics applications have quickly spread to all voltage levels, transmission and distribution system, harmonic frequency
from EHV transmission to low voltage circuits in end user resonance, system voltage and current distortion, filtering
facilities. Commonly observed power electronics applica- design calculation and performance evaluation, telephone
tions include HVDC terminals, various static var compensa- interference analysis and system losses associated with har-
tion (SVC) systems, high power AC to DC converter for DC monics. In this type of study, the harmonic current injection
arc furnaces, static phase shifter, isolation switch, load trans- can often be assumed independent of the voltage variations
fer switch, converter/inverter based drive technologies, at a point of common coupling (PCC) which is an electri-
active line conditioning, energy storage and instantaneous
cally dividing point between the utility system and the cus-
backup power systems, renewable energy integration, and
tomer circuit. Therefore, the power electronics subsystem
numerous others covered under subjects of Flexible AC can greatly be reduced to a shunt circuit equivalent.
Transmission Systems (FACTS) and Custom Power Systems
(CPS). The need for power electronics modeling and simu-
The second type of power electronics modeling
lation is driven by both existing and new applications.
covers a much more extensive and complex range of practi-
cal problems. In many applications, operation of a power
Objectives of the simulation include: electronics subsystem depends closely upon the operation
verification of an application design
state of the connected system. To evaluate the dynamic and
prediction the performance of a system
transient performance of a system with power electronics
identification of potential problems
interfaces, the monitoring and control loops of the system,
evaluation of possible problem solutions.
including detailed signal processing and power electronics
device firing need to be modeled. Examples of this type of
The simulation is specially important for a concept validation
applications can be a SVC system, a Superconducting Mag-
and design iteration during new product development.
netic Energy Storage (SMES), active power conditioning
system and various adjustable speed drives applications.
Power electronics applications are relatively new to
When modeling these applications, variations of system
many power system engineers. This guideline provides gen-
parameters need to be used to derive the power electronic
eral procedures to help these engineers to make their own
simulation cases as needed. The theories of power electron- controls so the output of the power electronics subsystem
ics are not discussed. Attention is focused on the simulation changes accordingly as demanded. Since a power electron-
2-1
ics subsystem directly affects overall system operation, a type programs may be less efficient for detailed power elec-
comprehensive treatment of the supply system and the power tronics modeling. However, these programs are very attrac-
electronics subsystem should be performed. tive for an application oriented power electronics simulation
because these programs offer tremendous capability and flex-
2.2. Frequency Domain and TIme Domain Simulation ibility in characterizing various types of power system com-
ponents , inc lu d in g power electronics switches with
The solution methods are considered from two basic ap- reasonably simplified characteristics. As graphic interfacing
proaches: features are gradually incorporated in these programs, a level
of difficulty in using these tools will decrease.
1. frequency domain solution
2. time domain solution. 3. MODELING GUIDELINES
Digital computers can only simulate circuit phe- 3.1. Representation ofPower Electronics Switching Devices
nomena at discrete frequencies or at discrete intervals of time
(step size M or ~t). This leads to discretization errors. Com- For a power level application, the commonly used
pared with the time domain calculation, a frequency domain switching devices are power diode , Silicon Controlled Recti-
simulation is more robust because a circuit solution is found fier (SCR), Gate Turn-Off thyristor (GTO) and Insulated
at each individual frequency and these errors are not accumu- Gate Bipolar Transistor (IGBT). The diode is a two-termi-
lated. The programs using this solution method often treat nal, uncontrollable device and the rest are three terminal con-
the nonlinearity of a system as known current sources. For a trollable devices.
harmonic evaluation, the frequency domain solution usually
requires less computation time compared with a time domain Representing the reverse recovery characteristic,
solution. However, most available frequency domain solu- leakage current, and forward voltage drop of a diode is often
tion programs have difficulties in handling the system not necessary for an application study. For an application
dynamics, control interfaces and fast transients. The time simulation, some details of a device characteristic can be
domain solution is based on the integration over a discrete reduced. In many cases, a simplified device model is accept-
time interval. The numerical methods applied in different able. For example, instead of trying to represent a power
programs can use either iterative techniques or direct solu - electronic diode device using its switching characteristic as
tion methods. The solution stability and accuracy achieved shown on the left in Fig. 1, a simplified or an idealized char-
are closely related to the time step size selection. Because acteristic, shown by solid and dotted lines respectively on the
discretization errors can accumulate , the solution may right , can be used. In commonly used simulation programs,
diverge from the true solution if an improper time step is the simplified diode model may be available as a built-in
selected. The time domain simulation has great advantages device or it can be realized with a voltage controlled switch.
over a frequency domain simulation in handling the system
dynamics, power electronic models , non-linearities and tran-
sients . Real Device Simulated Device
Characteristic Characteristic
2.3. Toolsfor Power Electronics Application Simulation
-==---t"- - - v
According to their main functions, commonly used
tools for power electronics related simulations can be classi-
fied into three groups:
1. Power electronics simulation tools
2. General transients simulation tools or EMTP type of
Cathode --t<:J- Anode
2-2
..
For numerical simulations, if the gating circuit power require-
v ment is excludedfrom the study, there is very little difference
between modelinga GTO, IGBT or any other three-terminal,
controllable, unidirectional current flowing device. The de-
vice can all be represented by an simplified switch with gate
tum-on and tum-off controls. The different switchingcharac-
teristics can be realized by applying different firing controls.
Conducting when v>VS In the simulation, additional errorscan accrue becausethe gat-
ing pulses can only be applied at integral time-step multiples,
Fig. 2. An IdealizedPower DiodeRealization which may not be the case in reality.The impactof this can be
minimized if the program allows a variable time-step or uses
Since an existing diode model does not allow to interpolation [60].
specify on-state and off-state resistances, the device can be
realized using two above described switches connected in In an actualpower electronicsapplication, in order to provide
parallel (Fig. 3) with the opposite polarities and different a continuous current flowing path for an inductive load, a re-
conducting voltage thresholds when loss calculation is of versal diode (free wheeling diode) is used in parallel with a
interest. To include losses, the resistors Rf and Rb can be controllable switching device to form the basic power elec-
inserted in series with the forward and backward current tronics switching unit. However, several alternatives are
flowing switches respectively, and a leakage resistor Rl can availablefor implementing this basic switchingunit in digital
simulations.
be connected crossingthe terminalsof the switch branches.
Considering only the terminal equivalent at the connection
V
..
point of the application, the simplest model that can be used
to presentone leg of the bridgerectifier or invertercan be con-
structed with one simplified bi-directional current flowing
Rf
switch with gate controls as shown in Fig. 5 (1). This model
Rb Gate X I -----.I
Vsb
Rl
Fig. 3. Power Diode Characteristic Realization (1) (2) (3 )
Lu
Real Device Simulated Device
Characteristic Characteristic
Igl IgO
DC AC
--::::=~-+-..-.:====.. ---=-+-=----- Battery Supply
Vbo
Cathode~ Anode
Fig. 6. Simplified InverterScheme in a UPS System
Fig. 4. An Actual and SimplifiedSwitching Characteristic of SCR When all the controlled switching devices are
Device blocked, the DC battery charges through the rectifier bridge
2-3
consisting of six reversal diodes. However, if the ideal bidi-
rectional switches are used, while the UPS is idling, the bat-
~~
tery will not be charged by the AC supply.
When the idling mode needs to be more realistically J---=3=- Voltage GTO
represented, the simple bidirectional device model can be Load
improved with a parallel reversal diode as shown in Fig. 5
(2) . When the terminal effects as well as the individual ~O"'"'---+-...l..-_------'
device current carrying conditions are of interest, a further
improvement on the model can be made by adding another To Firing Control
diode as shown in Fig. 5 (3).
It should be noted that for some programs, multiple Fig. 8. An Example Circuit to Show GTO Simulation.
switch connections on the same circuit node can lead to a sin-
gular system admittance matrix. When using a program with The GTO gating signal is illustrated in Fig. 9. When
such restriction, a small series resistor or inductor can be the gating signal is greater than zero , the GTO is turned on
used to create intermediate nodes and avoid the problem. and when the gating signal is equal to zero, the GTO is
turned off. The GTO is initially open . The current flowing
To illustrate a power electronic device realization, through the GTO and voltage across the load resistor after
an EMTP example of a GTO operation is given below. In this t=O are illustrated in Figs. 10 and 11 respectively. By control-
example , a GTO module is built with a controlled bi-direc- ling the GTO firing , the average output voltage at the load
tional current flowing switch (type-13 switch) in series with terminal can be regulated.
a built-in diode device (type-ll switch). Considering the
GTO is often utilized in applications with a reactive power
GTO Gating Sqncl
carrying capability, a reversal diode (free wheeling diode)
has been included. The schematic of the module connection
1
, 1
is shown in Fig. 7. A list of the module file is given in
Appendix A. Note that although it has not been shown in
Fig. 7, some small resistors are used to introduce intermedi-
--,--------,-----..-----1\ 1
]~J I
ate nodes between the EMTP switches and snubber elements
are used in this GTO module.
2-4
Snubber R ond C
6OO1t---+---I---t-+-+--++--
+
AC Output
DC Supply
o.>·f---+--r----l-t-+-+-+-H-t-+-+--'-I
0.00
Fig. 13. The GTO Firing Signal fortheSix Step Converter Operation
2-5
L; n e- : o - G r o i.J ~ C1 VOllcge
}
600
~
~- i-I
I
' 00 .... !
100
:
"
I
0
i
-100 i
,
: ~ I ii L-.
!
- '00
-600
j
JO '0
Time mS "
Fig. 18. The Resulting Line-to-Neutral Voltage
Fig. 14. Six Step OperationLine-to-Neutral Voltage
tine-t o- Line Voltage
~;
I
. . I~-··f~==q
' C10'&>"il'JS&-~I~ ej
"
Time (mS)
.
tL
. ----c------,;:----~---____;
- " JO
3.3.Representation ofPowerSystems
Fig. 17. The PWMFiringSignal: Reference VoltageFrequency =60 Similar to the situation in a power electronics sub-
Hz, Carrier Signal Frequency =600 Hz system, a power supply system can easily extend to a large
electrical and geographic radius and become too complicated
The simulated line-to-neutral and line-to-line output to model. Therefore, the power system needs to be simpli-
voltages are shown in Figs. 17 and 18, respectively. By fied . The proper level of system reduction depends on the
changing the magnitude and frequency of the reference sig- study objectives.
nal, the output voltage magnitude and frequency can be
changed. The carrier frequency determines the characteristic If the purpose is to characterize the harmonics gen-
harmonic components of the output voltage. erated by a particular type of power electronics application,
the power system model can be significantly reduced. When
a pre-existing voltage distortion level at a power electronics
interfacing bus is low, the rest of the power system can be
2-6
satisfactorily represented by one or a set of first orderequiva- sonable time delay to match with the limitations of the
lents connected to the bus at a higher system voltage level. control hardware and software.
For an example, if the power electronics application inter- Whenmodelinga control response, it is importantto
faces with the system at the low voltage bus of a step-down understand the programintroducedtime delay between
transformer, the equivalent of the system can be placed on the primarysystem and the control interface. For an
the high voltage bus of the transformer. When a pre-existing example, the controlmodel may introduceone or more
voltage distortionlevel is greater than 2%, one needs an ade- time step delaybecauseof structureand solutionmethod
quate harmonic source to properly represent the background of the program. This may not cause problemsin some
distortion. simulations. However, if the modeled control logic
makesthis time delay caused error to accumulate over a
If the objective is to evaluate effects of the power period of time, it can eventuallyresult in the solution
electronics on a connected utility system, the model shall be divergence. The problemcan be correctedin most cases
extended to cover all sensitive loads (i.e. rotating machines by reducing the size of the time step or avoidingthe pos-
and all other major power electronics) within a concerned sible accumulation mechanismin the controlmodel.
electrical radius. Special attention is needed if an unbal- Differentmethods may be used to synchronize power
ancedsystem conditionis involved. electronics gating signalswith required system refer-
ences. In many cases, a real phase-locked-loop (PLL)
Extensivepower systemmodel is requiredfor a har- can be greatlysimplifiedto reduce the modeling system
monic propagation and resonant study. The main system complexity. However, when the system contains signifi-
components and dominant topology need to be kept in the cant waveform distortions, either harmonicsor transient
power system model. Filter banks, nonlinear passive circuit disturbances, a practicalPLL with all signal filters
components, and all other harmonic injection sources should shouldbe carefully implemented in the control model in
be represented. Frequency dependent characteristics of the order to accurately predict controlresponse. This is par-
systemcomponents might need to be considered. ticularly important when the objectiveof the simulation
is to verifycontroldesignand to evaluatethe responseof
3.4. Representation ofSystem Controls a powerelectronic application to primarysystem dynam-
ics.
The system control is one of the most important All power electronic deviceshave their limit in switch-
aspectof a power electronics simulation. As illustrated in this ing frequency. When a load commutation or a standard
paper, a switching device is greatly simplified. The proper PWMtype scheme is simulated, the highest switching
switching performance of a device is realizedvia appropriate frequency in the simulationis controlledby the system
gate controls. Modelingof power electronic controls consists frequency or by a carrier frequency. Even considering a
of three steps: variable carrierfrequency, the number of switchingper
1. Monitoring and sampling fundamental frequency cycle is known and the highest
2. Signalprocessingand controlreference derivation switching frequency can be made under a physical limit
3. Device gating signal generation. of the simulateddevice. However, if the device firing is
determined by a simple comparison between the system
Most simulation tools provide some means to controlreference and the systemoutput,a device switch-
implement system controls. In some later developed pro- ing may takeplace in simulation whenevera comparison
grams, the control block diagram and flow-chart structures difference is detected. Therefore, the switchingfre-
are supported for modeling different levels of system con- quencybecomes highly dependenton the time step size,
trols. Using these tools, a user can define the specified con- and the average switching frequency becomes unpredict-
trols in a simulated system with great flexibility. Some key able. Whenusing this type of firing logic, user should
issues ensuring a correct control modeling is briefly men- alwaystake extra measures, such as introducing a hys-
tioned below. These issues are more thoroughly treatedin the teresis loop, to ensure that the modeled device is work-
guideline with illustration examples. ing under its physicalswitchingcapability.
For a time domainsimulation, the highestresolution for
a signal samplingis determined by a selectedtime step. The block diagram for a commonly used phase locked loop
In general, this presentsno problemfor analog control. [17,60] is shownin Fig. 20. The systemvoltageat the terminal
However, for digitalcontrolsimulation, if the selected of the load is sampled and used to generate the synchronous
time step is too large and if the simulated sampling reso- reference signal. From Fig. 21 through Fig. 26, the input, in-
lution is significantly differentfrom the real systemsam- termediate output quantities and output signal are plotted to
piing resolution, significant errorscan be introduced and showthe each step of this signal processing.
even lead to instability.
For a time domainsimulation, the computation time
does not reflect the simulatedcontrollogic response
time. User should always rememberto introduce a rea-
2-7
Uref DO-PLLC>lACS - DU ~009(Type g)
Va ""
Vb JOO
Vc 100
100
0
0 10 '0 60
lime (mS)
Fig. 20 The Block Diagramof a PLL
Fig. 24 DerivedFrequency Reference
DO - PLLO>TACS - IH['AR(Type 9)
i
+:t fI::: -+
i
I
I
/ / I / / !/ I
....-....__.... Ii. I
.- ._... _...........
i --f-
/ 7f / / ] /
J 1/ 17 I 1/ 1/ i /
10
Iime (mS)
10 4()
Iime(mS)
00
"'
Fig. 22 DQ Voltage Components Fig. 26 Comparison ofInput and Obtained Syn. Signals
0.1000
DO-PLLO>lACS -DUMD13(lype g) The response of this control circuitry to a system
disturbance is illustrated in Fig. 27. A balanced system fault
is placed on and removed from the system, resulting a three
0.0500
cycle voltage sag.
0.ססOO
-urseo ,
v , Three phase fault
Rf=0.01 ohms
Tin=0 .025s
Tcl=0.075s
: ,
-0.1000 Kpro= 100
o 100
Kint =8.3E-3
10 40 60 80
Time mS
2-8
oscillations in which case it is not a concern to the simulation
engineer. Otherwise, some of the measures listed later in this
section may have to be implemented to obtain correct results.
ATRMNL
140.0
GTRMNL
Fig. 28 The PLL Circuitry Responseto a SystemDisturbance SNUBBR
O----i
2-9
3.6.Simulation Errors and Control
Errors in a Power Electronics simulation can come AC Supply DC Link Induct ion
through the following sources: Motor
1. switching device approximation and system reduction
2. added circuit elements for numerical oscillation control
s~
3. control system simplification
4. time step related truncation
5. program structure and solution method introduced inter-
facing time delay Six Pulse PWM
Diode Rectifier Inverter
6. incorrect system initial conditions
Fig. 30. Electrical Circuit Configuration of an Adjustable Speed
For application simulations, some errors resulting Drive
from the system simplification and measures of numerical
oscillation control are acceptable. The fourth and fifth items The built-in diode models are used to construct the
in the list can be controlled by reducing the time step size. A front end rectifier. The same switching devices with added
recommended time step size should not be greater than 1/5 to open/close controls are used to represent output invert er
1/20 of the period of the highest concerned frequency IGBTs. The EMTP input data modules are use to build this
cycle. For an example, for an IGBT inverter simulation with example case . Both the output reference frequency and the
5000Hz PWM switching, a selected time step could be 10 PWM carrier frequency are made to be controllable. Model-
ms. However, if the objective of the simulation is to see the ing of a signal processing and firing pulse generation is illus-
detailed transient at the terminal of the induction motor trated in this example. The motor load of the drive is
which is fed by the inverter through a section of the cable represented by its R+jX equivalent branch. The simulated
with an 1.0 ms travel time, an adequate time step should be AC input current, carrier and reference signal for the PWM
0.2 ms or smaller. control , AC output voltage and current are presented in Fig.
31 through Fig. 33.
Errors caused by incorrect system initial conditions
can be reduced by just letting the simulation run for a period
<00
of time to reach a corrected initial condition. This may take I
more computing time , but time is saved in model construc-
tion , especially if the program allows to restart. There are
some methods developed which help to accelerate the system
into the correct initial condition quickly.
200
0
-f\ - J f~ h
'\ I-
•
J;
J
Ii
I
\0
~
.3
2-10
r
PWMVSI>INVRTA- INVRTB(Type 8)
II II II
8:xJ
i
600, ···· · · ·
~I
' 00
i :
slOO 144 kV snon circun ,"wi.
I i 74 MVA
rio 1
I I, l- 25 kV Bus
rYjY' 7.87% /
i' i
I I i i
-600 f----
-800
-0 60 80 100 2 km 266 MCM
Time mS
7.5 MVA VJ:A:) I
t5
Fig. 33. Simulated AC OutputLine-to-line Voltage of A PWM-VSI 5.75% : T T
other
Adjustable SpeedDrive 4.16 kV loads
10km
1/0
!!!
TTT
harmonic
, ASD
4.2.Simulation of Voltage Notching Causedby Operation of filters 6000 hp
Current Source Inverter (CSI) ASD 5,7,11
~:.•,_Iw, ~ -----.-
involved system is illustrated by the one line diagram in Fig.
34 . The 35 kV distribution system is supplied through a 10
MVA transformer from the 144 kV transmission system. The
customer causing the voltage notching problem has a 6000
hp induction motor supplied through a CSI adjustable speed rrrn u:IV
rrrn 1500 kVA
4 .7%
_",_y,,480 Volt bus
4.7%
of the six pulse drive . The actual adjustable speed drive and surge capacitors
800 hp
motor load were represented to reproduce the notching oscil-
lations observed in the measurements.
2-11
nous condenser (SC) and half-and-half mix of the two
Voltoge 01 4160 Volt Surge Copocitor - Bose Cose
(SVC+SC).
1.5
4.3. Simulation ofHVDC Terminal and Shunt TSCITCR
1.4
Compensation ,-..
;:3
5
eo 1.3
Q)
The third example is an illustration case for model- S
ing of an HYDC system with shunt TscrrCR compensation
at the inverter bus [54]. The simulation example is made
~ 1.2
(/)
2-12
detailed modeling for the electrical and the mechanical parts 4.5. VoltageSource Inverter Based FACTS Devices and their
is usually required, saturation effects should be included, and Modeling Techniques Using EMTP
capacitance effects can be neglected. Frequency dependent of
electrical parameters, mainly rotor parameters might also be This section describes the fundamentals and the
considered. If frequencies of the transient case to be simu- modeling techniques of Voltage Source Inverter-based Flexi-
lated are higher than 3 kHz, the simulation time is no longer ble Alternating Current Transmission Systems (FACTS)
than a few milliseconds and the machine is not close to any devices, namely, STATic synchronous COMpensator (STAT-
power electronic system (Le. a synchronous machine con- COM), Static Synchronous Series Compensator (SSSC), and
nected to a transmission system), the mechanical part can be Unified Power Flow Controller (UPFC) using an EMTP sim-
usually neglected and the machine can be represented by ulation package. The FACTS model includes all the neces-
means of an ideal source behind its subtransient reactance sary components - a voltage source inverter with a DC link
and a frequency-dependent resistor; capacitance effects capacitor, a magnetic circuit, and a realizable controller. The
become important, they can be represented by a parallel UPFC model consists of two solid-state voltage source
capacitance-to-ground [1]. inverters which are connected through a common DC link
capacitor. Each inverter is coupled with a transformer at its
Other representations should be considered for spe- output. The first voltage source inverter, known as STAT-
cific applications COM, injects an almost sinusoidal current, of variable mag-
A) An aggregated representation of several nitude, at the point of connection. The second voltage source
machines can be used to reduce complexity and simulation inverter, known as SSSC, injects an almost sinusoidal volt-
time. Ref. [2] resents an aggregated induction model to be age, of variable magnitude, in series with the transmission
used in power quality studies where short term interruptions line. When the STATCOM and the SSSC operate as stand-
(i.e. sags) are of concern. alone devices, they exchange almost exclusively reactive
B) A very simplified representation for synchronous power at their terminals. While operating both the inverters
and induction machines can be used in harmonic studies together as a UPFC, the injected voltage in series with the
when the machine is not directly connected to the harmonic transmission line can be at any angle with respect to the line
source [3]. current. The exchanged real power at the terminals of one
inverter with the line flows to the terminals of the other
An important aspect of the simulation of a rotating inverter through the common DC link capacitor. The func-
machine is the procedure to obtain machine parameters and tionalities of the models have been verified.
the information where these parameters are derived. Electri-
cal parameters of synchronous machines may usually be 4.5.1 VSI Based Facts Devices
obtained in one of the following forms: (1) data supplied
from manufacturer (conventional stability format data, stand- Flexible Alternating Current Transmission Systems
still frequency response), (2) data from field tests (on-line (FACTS) devices, namely STATic synchronous COMpensa-
frequency response, load rejection test, other tests) and (3) tor (STATCOM), Static Synchronous Series Compensator
computer calculation using the finite-element method [4]. A (SSSC) and Unified Power Flow Controller (UPFC), are
good discussion about methods to obtain electrical and also used to control the power flow through an electrical transmis-
mechanical parameters can be found in [5]. Data from steady sion line connecting various generators and loads at its send-
state and short circuit tests include reactances and time con- ing and receiving ends. Each of the STATCOM and the SSSC
stants, armature resistance as well as saturation effects. Sev- consists of a solid-state voltage source inverter with several
eral procedures have been proposed to pass from these data Gate Tum Off (GTO) thyristor switch-based valves and a DC
to electrical parameters which are used in the transient solu- link capacitor, a magnetic circuit, and a controller. The num-
tion of the machine [6-8]. Although these tests and the corre- ber of valves and the various configurations of the magnetic
sponding procedures can also be used to obtain electrical circuit depend on the desired quality of AC waveforms gen-
parameters of an induction machine, data conversion proce- erated by the FACTS devices. When the STATCOM and the
dures for this type of machines are performed from different SSSC operate as stand-alone devices, they exchange almost
specifications [9-10]. exclusively reactive power at their terminals. While operat-
ing both the inverters together as a UPFC, the exchanged
Frequency response tests have received much atten- power at the terminals of each inverter can be reactive as well
tion during the last 25 years. Several methods have been pro- as real. The exchanged line flows to the terminals of the other
posed to obtain parameters of d- and q-axis equivalent inverter through the common DC link capacitor. The objec-
circuits; they are based on standstill frequency response tive in this section is to describe each component, such as a
(SSFR) [11-14], and on-line frequency response [15-16]. voltage source inverter, a magnetic circuit, and a controller of
Some techniques have also been developed to account for FACTS devices and its modeling techniques using an EMTP
saturation effects [17]. simulation package. Since, the emphasis of modeling is
purely on FACTS devices, the power system in which the
FACTS devices are connected to has been modeled in a sim-
2-13
plistic way. A simple transmission line, shown in Fig. 39, has
an inductive reactance, X s' and a voltage source 'Vs' at the
sending end and an inductive reactance, X,., and a voltage sssc
source.P, at the receiving end, respectively. The STATCOM
is connected at BUS 1 of the transmission line as shown in
Fig. 39 . The STATCOM model in EMTP consists of a har- 12=
monic neutralized voltage source inverter, VSIl, a magnetic _v, ~~ii2
• ~ i;
circuit, MCI, a coupling transformer, TI, a mechanical
- ES22
switch, MSI , current and voltage sensors, and a controller. E", -
2-14
of the capacitor is a quasi square wave containing a positive VNO' consists of only a fundamental component and odd har-
sequence fundamental component and all the odd harmonic monic components (n) given by the equation (1) where n =6k
components, such as the zero sequence third, the negative ± 1 for k = 1,2,3, etc.
sequence fifth, and the positive sequence seventh, etc.
Fig. 44 shows two 6-pulse inverters (ABC and DEF)
which are operated from the same DC link capacitor. On the
At- c=a:cJ aT AC side, they are connected to a 3-phase load (XYZ) through
W
3-Levellnverter Pole I>r aT ~
a magnetic circuit. The poles D, E, and F are operated in such
A",cNJ aT rav aT COl
a way that the pole voltage fundamental phasors
O.5voc~ At-
o A",
o.5v<t:~
Vf!(j
-27t
1t-l'y '""'Y VE, 1, Ve,1 and VF,1 and are 120° apart and the funda -
O.5voc ~ I>r 1VIC Oy 1t-"( 1t .
mental voltage phasor set of the DEF inverter lags the funda-
..{).5v<t: -
mental voltage phasor set of the ABC inverter by 30°. The
displacement angle between two consecutive 6-pulse invert-
Fig. 42 A 3-Level Inverter "Pole" and its Output Voltage ers in a multipulse inverter arrangement is 21t/6m, where m is
the total number of 6-pulse inverters used. The configuration
The amplitude of any odd multiple of fundamental compo- of the magnetic circuit in Fig . 44 is such that if an inverter
nent is pole voltage is time shifted by an angle of -e,
the fundamen-
2 tal and all the harmonic components of the pole voltage get a
fA 0, n 7/DC ccsn ): (1) phase shift by an angle of +e in the positive direction, irre-
= n
spective of their sequence.
where y is the "dead" period during which the AC
valve operates in each quarter cycle and the pole output volt-
age is zero and n =2k + 1 for k =0, 1, 2, 3, etc. For y =0, the
fundamental as well as all the harmonic components have the
InverterOEF . -300
o ~ E ~~F VE,1
V0,1
Vx
x r---o:-
O.5Va::~
~
Vy
o MAGNETIC y f----c:>-- N
t- ORCUIT
O.5Va::~ r-
Vz
zf--c:>-
A l lJc B
VC,1
VA,1
2-15
ing output voltage exhibits a fundamental component and component and odd harmonic components (n) where n = 12k
odd harmonic components (n) given by the equation (1) =
± 1 for k 1, 2, 3, etc. The presence of 12-pulse harmonic
where n = 12k ± 1 for k = 1, 2, 3, etc. Note that the output components in the inverter output voltage may not be accept-
voltage of a 12-pulse inverter with 3-level poles is referred to able in many applications. Therefore, an inverter with a
as a 12-pulse waveform when the poles are operated with higher pulse output voltage should be considered [56-58].
dead angle y = o.
Fig. 45 shows a possible configuration of the mag-
netic circuit which can be used to generate a 12-pulse har- 4.5.3 MODELING TECHNIQUE
monic neutralized voltage. The ABC 6-pulse inverter voltage
is fed to a Y-Y transformer and the DEF 6-pulse inverter ig. 46 shows the block diagram of the EMTP simu-
voltage is fed to a ~- Y transformer. The inverter side A lation program layout. Sample EMTP program files are
winding and DE winding will have per tum fundamental given in [56-58]. First, some general constants are defined.
component voltages which are of same magnitude and in Next, the control or the Transient Analysis of Control Sys-
phase and the fifth and the seventh harmonic components tems (TACS) section receives its input signals from the sen-
each of which are of same magnitude but in opposite phase. sors or measuring switches. This section generates the gating
Therefore, if the line side of the transformer windings are signals for the pole valves "on the fly." The ideal pole volt-
connected in series, the phase-X voltage will exhibit only a ages are mathematically combined to produce harmonic neu-
fundamental component and 12-pulse harmonic components. tralized inverter voltages, eI, which are fed to the source
Note that the inverter side ( winding has J3 times the turns section. In an actual simulation case, the gating signals are
as the inverter side Y winding has. This is needed in order to used to operate the pole valves of an inverter structure such
keep the same volts per turn in both windings. The line side as the one shown in Fig. 42.
inverter windings can have any turns ratio other than 0.5 to
increase or decrease the output voltage.
IGeneral Qlnsta1Is I
n time shift phase final time shift phase final
shift phase shift phase ConboI/TACS Inverter
pole A angle poleD angle Voltages
5 -5*(0) 0 0 -5*( -1tI6) +1t/6 1t
7 +7*(0) 0 0 +7*(-1tI6) +1t/6 1t
11 -11*(0) 0 0 -11*(-1tI6) +1t/6 0
13 +13*(0) 0 0 + I3*(-1tI6) +1tI6 0
17 -17*(0) 0 0 -17*( -1tI6) +1tI6 1t
Brmch
19 +19*(0) 0 0 +19*(-1t/6) +1t/6 1t • Transnission Li1e
23 -23*(0) 0 0 -23*(-1t/6) +1t/6 0 • Tn. ISformeI
25 +25*(0) 0 0 +25*(-1tI6) +1t/6 0
Solrnes
• TAC CooboIIed
Table 1 Phase Angles of a 12-Pulse Inverter Phasors • .1CIepeI1dert
2-16
line. Next, the controlled and the independent sources are calculated by adding the relative angle, 0., of the inverter
fed to the branch section which contains the transmission line voltage and the phase-lock-loop angle, e. The reference
and the coupling transformer. The line voltage set, vb at quadrature component, h q., of the inverter current is defined
BUS 1, the inverters' current sets, i l and i2, and the line cur- to be either positive if the STATCOM is emulating an induc-
rent, i, are measured by the measuring switches. Finally, the tive reactance or negative if it is emulating a capacitive reac-
output section is defmed. In reality, the magnetic circuit can tance. The DC link capacitor voltage, VDC, is dynamically
also serve as the coupling transformer. Therefore, there is no adjusted in relationship with the inverter voltage. The con-
need for an additional coupling transformer. trol scheme used in this section shows the implementation of
the inner current control loop which regulates the reactive
The modeling may be done at various levels. For current flow through the inverter regardless of the line volt-
example, to study the functionality of a FACTS device on an age. However, if one is interested in regulating the line volt-
elaborated power system network, a FACTS device with a age, an outer voltage control loop must be implemented. The
simplified model consisting of sinusoidal voltage sources and outer voltage control loop will automatically determine the
detailed control and protection schemes may be adequate. reference reactive current for the inner current control loop
For magnetic circuit and valve designers, the primary focus which, in turn, will regulate the line voltage.
should be on the modeling of the detailed power circuit. The
modeling techniques described in this section are useful tools Fig. 48 shows the digital simulation results from the
to the FACTS designers. reactive current control operation of a STATCOM. Between
oand 50 ms, the mechanical switch, MSJ, stays open, discon-
The various control techniques of FACTS devices necting the STATCOM from the transmission line . The DC
and simulation results are described in the next section. In link capacitor is precharged. The inverter output 12-pulse
each case, an instantaneous 3-phase set ofline voltages, vI> at voltage of phase a, el a, and the line voltage of phase a, Via,
BUS 1 is used to calculate the reference angle, which ise are in phase. At 50 ms, MSJ closes and the quadrature cur-
phase-locked to the phase a of the line voltage, Via' •
rent demand, h q , of the inverter is set to zero. Since the
inverter current is zero , the inverter voltage of phase a, el a ,
A. STATCOM
and the line voltage of phase a, Via, have equal amplitudes.
The controller of a STATCOM is used to operate the At 125 ms, the quadrature current demand, Ilq •, of the
inverter in such a way that the phase angle between the inverter is set to one per unit capacitive, which means the
inverter voltage and the line voltage is dynamically adjusted STATCOM should "see" the system as an inductive reac-
so that the STATCOM generates or absorbs desired VAR at tance and the inverter current of phase a, i la, lags the line
the point of connection [56]. Fig. 47 shows the control block 0
voltage of phase a, Via , by almost 90 .
diagram of the STATCOM. An instantaneous 3-phase
V,A
(PU)
I
I Gale
I
I PatIem
I 1...cJge
V1 I
I
IL I
~
-1-
Fig. 47 Control BlockDiagram ofa Static Synchronous Compensa- 1
tor
2-17
inverter in such a way that the injected alternating voltage in
The inverter voltage set, el, is greater than the line series with the transmission line is proportional to the line
voltage set, VI. At 175 ms, the quadrature current demand, current with the emulated reactance being the constant of
IIq *, of the inverter is set to one per unit inductive, which
proportionality [57]. When an SSSC injects an alternating
voltage leading the line current, it emulates an inductive
means the STATCOM should "see" the system as a capaci-
reactance in series with the transmission line causing the
tive reactance and the inverter current in phase a, i la, leads
power flow as well as the line current to decrease as the level
the line voltage at phase a, VIa, by almost 90°. The inverter of compensation increases and the SSSC is considered to be
voltage set, el, is less than the line voltage set, VI. At 250 operating in an inductive mode. When an SSSC injects an
alternating voltage lagging the line current, it emulates a
IDS, the quadrature current demand, IIq *, of the inverter is set
capacitive reactance in series with the transmission line caus-
to one per unit capacitive and the transition takes place in a ing the power flow as well as the line current to increase as
subcycle time. The phase angle, a, between the inverter the level of compensation increases and the SSSC is consid-
voltage and the line voltage is dynamically adjusted so that ered to be operating in a capacitive mode. An SSSC control-
the inverter maintains proper DC link capacitor voltage. ler can also be used for stable reversal of power flow in the
transmission line.
Fig. 49 shows the expanded view of two sections of
Fig. 48. The inverter voltage and current show the presence
of 12-pulse harmonic components.
V,A
(pu)
1-
I
I
I
I
I
V1
-1- I
I
IL I
~
1-
Fig. 50 ControlBlock Diagramof a Static SynchronousSeriesCom-
pensator
2-18
link capacitor voltage demand, VDC *, and the measured DC neous DC link capacitor voltage is proportional to the ampli-
tude of the inverter voltage.
voltage, VDC, are compared and the error is passed through an
error amplifier which produces an angle, p. The phase angle,
Therefore, when an SSSC emulates a reactance in
02, of the inverter voltage is calculated by adding the angle,
series with the transmission line, the power flow in the trans-
p, of the DC voltage regulator and the phase angle, 0\1> of the mission line always decreases if the emulated reactance is
insertion voltage demand. The compensating reactance inductive. Also, the power flow always increases if the emu-
demand, X q *, is either negative if the SSSC is emulating an lated reactance is capacitive.
inductive reactance or positive if it is emulating a capacitive
reactance. In another application, the insertion voltage Fig. 52 shows the expanded view of the two sections of Fig.
51. The inverter voltage show the presence of 24-pulse har-
amplitude demand, Vq * may directly be specified and the monic components.
SSSC will inject the desired voltage almost in quadrature
with the line current.
2- V,A,X,P 1-~~P ~
o~~~
(PU)
/i a
1
4- q
0 Pq
1-
-1
Qq X*q
tiTle
I (ms)
-2-
200 400 600
2-19
such as voltage injection, phase angle shifter emulation, line
impedance emulation, automatic power flow control, etc. In
each mode of operation, the final outcome is such that the
SSSC injects a voltage in series with the transmission line 1
[58]. In this section, the SSSC is operated in a voltage injec-
tion mode. The control block diagram for the SSSC is shown
in Fig. 53.
-1-
2-20
engineering community, the EMTP type of programs are
more commonly used. This results mainly from the great ca-
V,A pabilities and flexibility of these programs in handling con-
(PU) ventional power system dynamics and electromagnetic
transients beside their capabilities of handling power electron-
ics. With an adequate power electronics device and circuit
simplification, the EMTP type of programs are powerful for
modeling various types of power electronics applications .
Because these programs are based on the time domain solu-
tion method, the dynamic interaction between the power elec-
-1- tronics and the rest of the system can be easily incorporated in
simulation.
1- ia
The important considerations for simulating power electron-
ics applications have been summarized in this guidelines .
Several modeling examples including a comprehensive treat-
-
:D)
ment of voltage source inverter based FACTS device and its
time
(ms) modeling techniques using EMTP type of programs were pre-
-1- sented. The procedures used to implement power electronics
models in these examples are valuable for using other digital
Fig.55 Waveforms froma UnifiedPowerFlowController witha 24- simulation tools.
PulseQuasiHarmonic Neutralized Inverterwith 3-LevelPolesOp-
eratingin a Voltage Injection Mode 6. REFERENCES
1. CIGRE Working Group 02 (SC 33), "Guidelines for Rep-
4.5.4 SUMMARY resentation ofNetwork Elements when Calculating Tran-
sients", 1990.
FACTS devices - STATCOM, SSSC, and UPFC, 2. J. Blanes, A. Quijano, S. Catal n, "Simulation of induc-
have been modeled using an EMTP simulation package. The tion motors behaviour during voltage disturbances using
UPFC consists of two voltage source inverters - one injects an aggregated model", European EMTP/ATP Users
an almost sinusoidal voltage in series with the transmission Group Meeting, November 9-11,1997, Barcelona.
line and the other injects an almost sinusoidal current at the 3. P. F. Ribeiro, "Distribution system and other elements
point of connection . The injected voltage can be at any angle modeling", Chapter 3 of Tutorial on Harmon ics Model-
with the line current. The injected current has two parts. ing and Simulation, IEEE TP-125-0, 1998.
First, the real part , which is in phase with the line voltage, 4. "Symposium on Synchronous Machines Modelling for
Power System Studies", IEEE Power Engineering Soci-
delivers or absorbs real power to the line that is exchanged by
ety, Publication 83THOIOI-6-PWR, 1983.
the injected voltage source plus losses in the UPFC. Second, 5. P. M. Anderson, B. 1. Agrawal and J. E. Van Ness, Sub-
the reactive part, which is in quadrature with the line voltage, synchronous Resonance in Power Systems, IEEE Press,
emulates an inductive reactance or a capacitive reactance at 1990.
the point of connection . The SSSC model has been operated 6. "IEEE Guide: Test Procedures for Synchronous Ma-
injecting a voltage in series with the transmission line. The chines", IEEE Std. 115, 1983.
STATCOM model has been operated regulating the reactive 7. F.1. Alvarado and C. Canizares, "Synchronous machine
current flow through it and the transition from one mode of parameters from sudden-short tests by back-solving",
operation to the other mode takes place in a subcycle time . IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, Vol. 4, no. 2, pp.
The operation of the model is verified with the model con- 224-236, June 1989.
nected to a simple transmission line which can easily be 8. I. M. Canay, "Modelling of alternating-current machines
having multiple rotor circuits", IEEE Trans. on Energy
replaced by the utility's existing more complex power system
Conversion, vol.8, no. 2, pp. 280-296, June 1993.
network.
9. "IEEE Guide: Test procedure for polyphase induction
motors and generators", IEEE Std. 112-1978.
5. CONCLUSIONS 10. G. J. Rogers and D. Shirmohammadi, "Induction ma-
chine modelling for electromagnetic transient program",
The appropriate characterization of the power electronics is IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 622-
very important in power system simulations involving power 628, December 1987.
electronics operations. In most of these simulations, detailed 11. "IEEE Standard Procedures for Obtaining Synchronous
representations of the power electronics are not necessary. Machine Parameters by Standstill Frequency Response
Depending on the objective of a study, the involved power Testing", IEEE Std.l15A, 1987.
electronics subsystem can be always reduced to some extend 12. I. M. Canay, "Determination of the model parameters of
with minimal loss of accuracy. machines from the reactance operators xd(P), xq(P)
(Evaluation of standstill frequency response test)", IEEE
Numbers of the digital computation tools are capable of sim- Trans. on Energy Conversion, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 272-279,
ulating power electronics cases. However, in power systems June 1993.
2-21
13. A. Keyhani and H. Tsai, "Identification of high-order no. l,pp. 11-19, February 1992
synchronous generator models from SSFR test data", pre- 29. S. Y. Lee et aI., "Detailed modeling ofstatic Var compen-
sented at the 1994 IEEE/PES Winter Meeting, Paper no. sators using the Electromagnetic Transients Program
94 WM 022-4 EC, New York, January 30-February 3, (EMTP)", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, Vol. 7, no. 2,
1994. pp. 836-847, April 1992
14. J. R. Willis, G. J. Brook and J. S. Edmonds, "Derivation 30. S. Lefebvre and L. Gerin-Lajoie, "A static compensator
of induction motor models from standstill frequency re- model for the EMTP", IEEE PES Meeting, San Diego,
sponse", IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, vol. 4, no. July 28-August 1, 1991, Paper 91 SM 461-4 PWRS.
4, pp. 608-615, December 1989. 31. L. Dube and I. Bonfanti, "MODELS: A new simulation
15. P. L. Dandeno, P. Kundur, A. T. Poray and H. M. Zein tool in the EMTP", European Transactions on Electrical
El-din, "Adaptation and validation of turbogenerator Power Engineering, Vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 45-50, January/
model parameters through on-line frequency response February 1992.
measurements", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and 32. Leuven EMTP Center (ed.), ATP Rule BOQk, 1990.
Systems, vol. 100, no. 4, pp. 1656-1645, April 1981. 33. J. A. Martinez, "Simulation of a microprocessor-con-
16. P. L. Dandeno, P. Kundur, A. T. Poray andM. E. Coultes, trolled SVC", 21th European EMTP Meeting, June 5-7,
"Validation of turbogenerator stability models by com- 1992, Crete (Greece).
parison with power system tests", IEEE Trans. on Power 34. H.W. Dommel, EMTP Reference-Manual (EMIP Theo-
Apparatus and Systems, vol. 100, no. 4, pp. 1637-1645, ry Book), BPA, 1986.
April 1981. 35. J. A. Martinez, "Simulation of power electronics using
17. F. P. de Mello, L. N. Hannett, J. R. Willis, "Determina- the EMTP, Part I: Power converters, A survey", UP-
tion of synchronous machine stator and field leakage in- EC'94, September 14-16, 1994, Galway.
ductances standstill frequency response tests", IEEE 36. G. A. Capolino, H. Henao, "ATP simulation for power
Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 3, no. 4, pp. 1625-1632, electronics and AC drives", 15th European EMTP Users
November 1988. Group Meeting, Paper 88R-027, October 17-18, 1988,
18. L. Dube, H.W. Dommel, "Simulation of control system Leuven.
in an Electromagnetic Transient Program with TACS", 37. G. A. Capolino, H. Henao, "Simulation of electrical ma-
IEEE Trans. on Power Industry and Computer Applica- chine drives with EMTP", 18th European EMTP Users
tions, 1977 Group Meeting, Paper M7, May 28-29, 1990, Marseille
rs, EMTP Rule Book, EPRIIDCG Version 1.0. 38. J. A. Martinez, G. A. Capolino, "TACS and MODELS:
20. D. Goldsworthy, 1. J. Vithayathil, "EMTP model of an Drive simulation languages in a general purpose pro-
HVDC transmission system", Proceedings of the IEEE gram", Proc. MCED'91, Marseille, July 1-2, 1991, pp.
Montech '86 Conference on HVDC Power Transmission, RI-RI3.
September 26-0ctober 1, 1986, pp. 39-46 39. G. A. Capolino, H. Henao, "ATP advanced usage for
21. L. X. Bui, S. Casoria, G. Morin, "Modeling of digital electrical drives", EMTP Summer Course, July 5-8,
controls with EMTP" , CEA Meeting, March 25-29, 1993, Leuven.
1989, Montreal, Canada 40. H. Knudsen, "Extended Park's transformation for 2 by 3-
22. J. Reeve and S. P. Chen, "Versatile interactive digital phase synchronous machine and converter phasor model
simulator based on EMTP for AC/DC power system tran- with representation of harmonics", IEEE PES Summer
sient studies", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Sys- Meeting, Paper 94 SM 350-9 EC, July 24-28, 1994, San
tems, Vol. 103, No. 12, December 1984, pp. 3625-3633 Francisco.
23. K. G. Fehrle, R. H. Lasseter, "Simulation of control sys- 41. M. Mazzucchelli, G. Sciutto, "Digital simulation of AC
tems and application to HVDC converters", IEEE Tuto- electrical drives based on field-oriented control method
rial Course 81 EHOI73-PWR on Digital Simulation of using a general purpose program", Proceedings PCIM,
Electrical Transient Phenomena, 1981. pp.350-364, 1986, Munchen
24. L. X. Bui, G. Morin, J. Reeve, "EMTP TACS-FOR- 42. Z. Daboussi, N. Mohan, "Digital simulation of field-ori-
TRAN interface development for digital controls model- ented control of induction motor drives using EMTP" ,
ing", 91 SM 417-6 PWRS IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, Vol. 3, pp. 667-673,
25. G. Morin, L. X. Bui, S. Casoria, J. Reeve, "Modeling of September 1988.
the Hydro-Quebec - New England HVDC system and 43. L. Tang, M. McGranaghan, "Modeling an active power
digital controls with EMTP", IEEE Trans. on Power De- line conditioner for compensation of switching tran-
livery, Vol. 8, No.2, April 1993, pp. 559-566. sients", Proceedings of First International Conference on
26. R. H. Lasseter and S. Y. Lee, "Digital simulation ofstatic Power Systems Transients (IPST'95), Lisbon (Portugal),
var system transients", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus pp. 403-408.
and Systems, Vol. PAS-I0l, No. 10, pp. 4171-4177, Oc- 44. X. Z. Meng, J. G. J. Sloot, H. Rijanto, "Modelling of
tober 1982. semiconductor fuses in EMTP", Proceedings of First In-
27. A. M. Gole and V. K. Sood, "A static compensator model ternational Conference on Power Systems Transients (IP-
for use with electromagnetic transients simulation pro- ST'95), Lisbon (Portugal), pp. 481-486.
grams", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, Vol. PWRS-5, 45. J. A. Martinez-Velasco, R. Abdo, G.A. Capolino," Ad-
No.3, pp. 1398-1407, July 1990 vanced representation ofpower semiconductors using the
28. A. N. Vasconcelos et. al. "Detailed modeling of an actual EMTP", Proceedings of First International Conference
static Var compensator for electromagnetic transients on Power Systems Transients (IPST'95), Lisbon (Portu-
studies", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, Vol. PWRS-7, gal), pp. 505-510.
2-22
46. S. Lefebvre, R. D. Rangel, "Modeling of power electron- low short circuit capacities", IEEE PES 95 SM 388-9-
ics devices in EMTP-TACS", Proceedings of First Inter- PWRD.
national Conference on Power Systems Transients 54. O. B. Nayak, A. M. Gole, D. G. Chapman, and J.B.
(IPST'95), Lisbon (Portugal), pp. 511-516. Davies, "Dynamic performance of static and synchro-
47. G. A. Capolino, H. Henao, D. Leduc, V. T. Nguyen nous compensators at an HVDC inverter bus in a very
Phuoc, "CAD of field-oriented induction motor drives weak AC system", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, Vol.
using a general purpose program", Proceedings PC1M, 9, NO.3, August 1994, pp. 1350-1358.
1989, Munchen. 55. M. Szechtman, T. Wess, C. V. Thio, "First benchmark
48. E. Bassily, G. A. Capolino, H. Henao, "Simulation ofdis- model for HVDC control studies", Electra, No. 135,
crete DC drive using sliding mode control", 22nd Euro- April 1991.
pean EMTP Users Group Meeting, Paper 92R-018, 56. K. K. Sen, STATCOM - STATic synchronous COMpensa-
November 9-10, 1992, Leuven. tor: Theory, Modeling, and Applications, 99WM706,
49. E. Bassily, G. A. Capolino, H. Henao, "Simulation and IEEE PES Winter Meeting, New York, USA, 1999.
design of brushless motor drive control with fuzzy pi reg- 57. K. K. Sen, SSSC - Static Synchronous Series Compensa-
ulator", Proceedings of First European Conference on tor: Theory, Modeling, and Applications, IEEE Transac-
Power Systems Transients (EPST'93), Lisbon (portugal), tions on Power Delivery, vol. 13, No.1, January 1998.
pp 84-91, June 1993. 58. K. K. Sen and E. J. Stacey, UPFC - Unified Power Flow
50. A. K. Khan, R. Dwyer, M. Mcgranaghan, L. Tang, "Eval- Controller: Theory, Modeling, and Applications, IEEE
uation of Harmonic Impacts from Compact Fluorescent Transactions on Power Delivery, vol. 13, No.4, October
Lights on Distribution Systems", IEEE PES 95 WM 105- 1998.
7-PWRS. 59. A.M. Gole ,I.T. Fernando, G.D. Irwin , O.B. Nayak,
51. J. A. Martinez, "EMTP simulation of digitally-controlled "Modeling of Power Electronic Apparatus: Additional
static Var system for optimal load compensation", IEEE Interpolation Issues", International Conference on Power
PES Summer Meeting, Paper 94 SM 452-3 PWRD, July
System Transients, IPST'97, Seattle, June 22-26, 1997,
24-28, 1994, San Francisco.
Proceedings: pp 23-28.
52. J. A. Martinez and G. A. Capolino, "EMTP simulation of
60. A.M. Gole, L. Mootoosamy, \ZK. Sood, "Validation and
power electronics and drives using data modularization",
Analysis of a Grid Control System using d-q-z Transfor-
Proceedings First International Aegean Conference on
Electrical Machines and Power Electronics, Kucadasi mation for Static Compensator Systems", Canadian Con-
(Turkey), May 27-29, 1992. ference on Electrical & Computer Engineering,
53. L. Tang, M. F. McGranaghan, R. A. Ferraro, S. Morgan- Montreal, Sept. 17-20, 1989; Proceedings pp. 745-748.
son, b. Hunt, "Voltage notching interaction caused by
large adjustable speed drives on distribution systems with
2-23
Modeling Guidelines for Low Frequency Transients
Report Prepared by the Low-Frequency Transients Task Force
of the IEEE Modeling and Analysis of System Transients Working Group
Keywords: Low-Frequency Transients, Electromechanical For each of the above phenomenon this report provides (1) a
Transients, Modeling, Time-Domain Analysis, Torsional brief explanation of the physical phenomenon, (2) modeling
Dynamics, Turbine Vibrations, Bus-Transfer, Controller guidelines for time-domain simulation and analyses, and (3)
Interactions, Harmonic Interactions, Ferroresonance typical sample systems and simulation results.
1. INTRODUCTION
This report is intended for practicing power system engineers
An interconnected power system can experience undesirable who are involved in system analysis, system control, and sys-
oscillations and transients as a result of small-signal perturba- tem planning. To use the report efficiently, adequate under-
tions, large-signal disturbances, and nonlinear characteristics standing of the physical phenomenon of interest and
of the system components. The oscillations cover a wide fre- familiarity with the concepts and techniques of digital com-
quency range approximately from 0.01 Hz to 50 MHz. Oscil- puter simulation approaches are necessary.
lations in the frequency range of 0.01 to 1000 Hz are defmed
in this report as low-frequency (slow) transients. We inter-
changeably use the terms "slow transients", "low frequen- Section 2 of the report deals with low-frequency transients
cy(LF) dynamics", and "LF oscillations" throughout this which involve both electrical and mechanical dynamics, i.e.,
report. All the issues relevant to I ow-frequency inter-area torsional oscillations, transient torsional torques, turbine-
electromechanical oscillations (approximately 0.1 to 1 Hz) blade vibrations and fast bus-transfer. Section 3 discusses
and classical turbine-generator swing modes (approximately low-frequency electrical dynamics, as a result of control sys-
1 to 2.5 Hz) are discussed by other IEEE working groups, and tems interactions. Section 4 provides analysis guidelines for
are not discussed here. A general guideline for representation harmonic interactions and resonance phenomena. The phe-
of network elements for electromagnetic transient studies nomenon of ferroresonance is discussed in Section 5.
have been previously published [1.1]. The mandate of the
IEEE Low-Frequency Transients Task Force is to provide
modelling guidelines for time-domain analysis ofLF oscilla-
tions within the frequency range of 5 to 1000 Hz. Low fre- 2. LOW-FREQUENCY ELECTROMECHANICAL
quency dynamics are of concern with respect to power system DYNAMICS
stability issues and/or temporary overvoltages.
This section provides modeling and analysis guide-
phenomena of 60 Hz power systems in the LF range are di- lines for low-frequency dynamics which involve electrome-
vided into the following categories: chanical oscillations. The phenomena which are covered in
this section are torsional oscillations, transient torques, tur-
3-1
bine-blade vibrations, and bus-transfer. the natural frequencies of the shaft torsional oscillatory
modes. Usually, the oscillatory mode at the first torsional fre-
2.1 DEFINITIONS quency dominates the shaft transient oscillations. The major
incidents which result in severe shaft stresses are: line-to-line
2.1.1 Torsional Oscillations [2.1, 2.2, 2.3, 2.4, 2.5J faults, three-phase faults, fault clearing, automatic reclosures,
and out-of-phase synchronization. The amplitudes of the
Shaft system of a steam turbine-generator experiences tor- shaft transient stresses can be particularly large when the net-
sional oscillations when one or more of its natural oscillatory work is equipped with series capacitors.
modes, usually at subsynchronous frequencies, are excited.
Sustained or negatively damped torsional oscillations occur
when a turbine-generator shaft system exchanges energy with High amplitude shaft mechanical stress can induce significant
an electrical system at the shaft oscillatory modes. This ex- fatigue in the shaft segments and result in noticeable shaft
change of energy can exist if the electrical system is equipped life-time reduction during each oscillatory cycle. Such oscil-
with either series capacitors or HVDC converter stations. The lations may even result in catastrophic shaft failure. The pri-
phenomenon of torsional oscillations can also exist as a result mary purpose of time-domain investigation of turbine-
of interaction between the shaft system of a steam turbine- generator shaft mechanical stresses is to identify the peak
generator and torques imposed on the shaft segments, after system distur-
bances. Transient shaft mechanical stresses calculated based
on time-domain simulation methods also can be used to esti-
the generator excitation systems through either AVR or PSS mate shaft loss of life as a result of system disturbances.
control loops,
2.1.3 Turbine-Blade Vibrations [2.6]
electronically controlled governor system,
voltage control loop of an electrically close static VAR. compen- Frequencies of turbine-blade vibrational modes are
sator (SVC) usually within 90 to 250 Hz, and constitute supersynchro-
nous frequency modes. Identification of supersynchronous
large electric arc furnaces. frequency modes and their corresponding frequencies is best
carried out by solving elasticity equation of the shaft system
as a continuum, based on the use of finite element methods.
Although AVR, PSS and governor system can excite torsional This approach is beyond the scope of this report and usually
oscillations, the excitation is primarily due to inadequate con- carried out by turbine manufacturers.
trol design considerations and can be avoided by introducing
filters in the control circuitry. Thus, this report does not con-
sider the generator controls as the main contributors to the In this report, the objective is to investigate the impact of
phenomenon of torsional oscillations (Table 1). large-signal disturbances on those supersynchronous frequen-
cy natural modes which are the reason for turbine-blade vibra-
tions. Thus the required model is tailored to represent
The phenomenon of torsional oscillation is referred to as sub- particular supersynchronous modes and not all of them.
synchronous resonance (SSR) when it is a result of interaction
between a shaft system and a series capacitor compensated The concern with turbine-blade vibrations is fracture
transmission line. The problems associated with the phenom- and loss-of-life of the blades due to the fatigue induced in the
enon of small-signal torsional oscillations are: blades by repetitive or sustained oscillations. Vibrations of tur-
bine-blades can be excited by large-signal electrical distur-
bances, e.g. faults, fault clearing, line switching, reclosure, and
i) Sustained or even negatively damped oscillations which
out-of-phase synchronization.
are considered as small-signal instability problems, and
ii) (loss of life of turbine-generator shaft segment(s) due to the
2.1.4 Fast Bus Transfer [2. 7,2.8,2.9]
fatigue induced in the shaft segment(s) as a result of each
oscillatory cycle.
Motors and other loads in utility and heavy industrial applica-
tions are supplied during normal operation from a preferred
2.1.2 Transient Torsional Torques [2.1, 2.2, 2.3, 2.4, 2.5]
power source. An alternate power source is normally provid-
ed to supply such motors and other loads during planned shut-
The shaft segments of turbine-generator units are exposed to
downs and upon loss of normal power from the preferred
large-amplitude, oscillatory, mechanical stresses as a result of
power source. The process of disconnecting the motors and
electric network faults, and planned and unplanned switching
other loads from one source and reconnecting to an alternate
incidents. Frequencies of the shaft mechanical stresses are
source is commonly defmed as "bus transfer". Manual trans-
3-2
fer means are normally provided to allow transferring the mo- mode which propagates almost through the entire of an inter-
tors and other loads from one power source to the other. connected electric network, the phenomena described in Sec-
However, upon loss of the preferred power source, the motors tion 2.1 are experienced only within a limited part of the
and other loads are automatically transferred to the alternate network. The section of the network which experiences the
power source. This automatic transfer is necessary to allow phenomenon of interest, and must be represented in adequate
uninterrupted operation of the motors and other loads impor- detail for the study of the phenomenon, is referred to as the
tant to personnel safety and process operation. This report "Study Zone" The rest ofthe network is referred to as the "ex-
does not address the concept ofbus transfer by means of semi- ternal system" The external system is represented by an
conductor switches [2.23]. equivalent model. Identification of border nodes of the study
zone for a meshed network requires significant familiarity
with the network, as well as engineering judgment. As of
The normal and alternate power source connections are al- now, there is no straightforward and systematic approach to
ways selected such that they are in phase. Therefore, manual identify the border nodes. One approach involves multiple
transfers can be accomplished in a make-before-break, i.e., harmonic analyses of the system under investigation as
the motors and loads are connected to the second power boundaries are extended to identify if new resonant frequen-
source before the first power source is disconnected. In this cies (at the frequency range of interest) with low dampings ex-
overlapping transfer, the power supply is not interrupted and ist.
the motors are not subjected to transients. However, during
automatic transfers, the motors may be disconnected from
both power sources for a short duration depending on the type Proper determination of the study zone can exert a major im-
oftransfer and the associated circuit breakers operating times. pact on the investigations of torsional dynamics and transient
The time during which the motors are disconnected from both torques. Comparatively, the impact of the study zone on the
power sources is termed the "dead time". Dead time is usually vibrations of turbine blades is less significant. Identification
between two cycles to 12 cycles. If the relative angle between of the study zone for bus transfer studies is relatively straight-
the motor residual voltage and the power source voltage be- forward.
comes large enough at the time of reconnection with signifi-
cant residual voltage remaining, the resultant voltage 2.2.2 Component Model
between the power source and the motor will produce an in- Table 1 identifies the study zone components and their equiv-
rush current. The inrush current may be significantly largely alent models for investigations of slow transient phenomena.
than the normal full voltage staging current. Such high inrush Further explanation ofthe system components are given in the
currents cause high winding stresses and transient shaft following sections.
torques which can damage the motor and/or the driven equip-
ment.
3-3
Component Torsional Transient Turbine-Blade Fast Bus
Oscillations Torques Vibrations Transfer
Synchronous Second-Order Third-Order Third-Order Model Not
Generator's Model and Model (d-q-o (d-q-o Model) applicable
Electrical System Preferably Third- Model) Including
Order Model (d-q-o Including Saturation
Model) Saturation
Turbine-Generator Mass-Spring- Mass- Spring- Detail Not
Shaft System Dashpot Model Dashpot Model Mass-Spring- Applicable
Dashpot Model
Power Conventional Conventional Conventional Conventional
Transformer Low-Frequency Low-Frequency Low-Frequency Low-
Model including Model including Model including Frequency
Saturation Saturation Saturation Model
Characteristic Characteristic Characteristic including
Saturation
C harac terist ic
Transmiss ion Line Equivalent-a Equivalent-a Equivalent-a Not
Model Model Model Applicable
Series/Shunt Ideal Capacitor Ideal Capacitor Ideal Capacitor Ideal
Capacitor Capacitor
Series/Shunt Series R-L Series R-L Series R-L Series R-L
Reactor
Static Load Fixed Impedance Fixed Impedance Fixed Impedance Fixed
Load Load Load Impedance
Load
Large Motor Load d-q-o Model of Voltage Source Voltage Source d-q-o Model
Electrical System, Behind Fixed Behind Fixed of
Mass-Spring- Impedance Impedance Electrical
Dashpot Model of System,
Shaft System Mass- Spring-
Dashpot
Model of
Shaft System
HVDC Converter Detailed Model of Detailed Models of Detailed Models of Not
Station Converter and Converter and Converter and Applicable
Linearized Controls Controls
(Simplified)
Model of Controls
SVC Detailed Model of Detailed Model of Detailed Model of Not
Power Circuitry and Power Circuitry Power Circuitry Applicable
Linearized and Contro Is and Controls
(Simplified)
Model of Controls
Circuit Breaker Ideal Switch Ideal Switch Ideal Switch Ideal Switch
Generator Unimportant Unimportant Unimportant Not
Controls Applicable
Protection System' Unimportant Series Capacitor Ser ies Capac itor Not
Overvoltages Overvoltages Applicable
Protection System Protection System
3-4
nounced impact on transient torques andbladevibrations. erator unitmust be separately represented.
In most studies, the power plant under consideration is com-
posed of more than one turbine-generatorunit. If all the tur-
bine-generator units are nominallyidentical,and under almost
equal loading conditions, they can be representedby a single,
equivalent turbine-generator unit. Otherwise, each turbine-
generatorunit must be separately represented.
d-axis
Lt
~
STATOR ~
Rlq ~q ~
HP EXC
=
q-axis IP LPA LPB G
STAToJl:- HEW
d-axis Fig. 2.2. Turbine-generator shaftsystemand its mass-spring-dashpot mode
STATOR
FinalStageBlade Early Stage Blade
t ,
q-axis
3-5
2 2 2 4 Transmission Ijne Shaft dynamics of a turbine-generator can be excited as a re-
sult of interaction between the turbine-generator and either
The Equivalent-pi is an accurate model for representation of a rectifier current-control or the inverter extinction angle (volt-
long or medium length transmission line for the phenomena age) control of an HYDC link. Thus, ifboth the rectifier and
under investigation. In many reported studies, the shunt ca- the inverter stations are within the study zone, both converter
pacitive branches of the line model are also neglected. Shunt stations, de line, and the associated controls, with adequate
capacitive branches of the line model do not have any major level of sophistication, must be represented in the system
impact on the model.
3-6
station [2.16]. However SVCs have been recognized as ef- nomenon of torsional oscillations. Numerous study results,
fective countermeasures for shaft torsional dynamics. A con- using the benchmark model, have been published in the IEEE
ventional SVC is composed of thyristor-switched capacitors PES Transactions [2.1, 2.2, 2.3, 2.4, 2.5].
(TSCs) and thyristor-controlled reactors (TCRs) [2.17]. Dur-
ing small-signal dynamics, e.g. torsional oscillations, an SVC
can be approximated as fixed capacitors (FCs) and TCRs.thy- Time-domain simulation and frequency-domain eigen analy-
ristor valves in each arm of either the TCR or the TSC are sis are widely used as complementary approaches for recipro-
modelled as two equivalent ideal switches including the par- cal verification of torsional studies.
allel snubber branch. The three-phase transformer model of
Section 2.2.2.3 can adequately represent an SVC transformer 2.3.2 Transient Torques
for low frequency studies. Controlled reactor, switched ca-
pacitor and the SVC filter components are represented in the The first and the second IEEE benchmark models for Small-
time-domain simulation model by proper combinations of Signal torsional studies introduced in Section 2.3.1 also have
lumped RLC elements. Chapter 9 of [2.15] and reference been extensively used for transient torque studies. Due to the
[2.18] provide details of the controls of an SVC for time-do- nonlinear nature of large-signal torsional oscillations, digital
main simulation. Similar to an HVDC converter station, an time-domain simulation is the only approach to investigate
SVC may be equipped with auxiliary controls, e.g. supple- the phenomenon. There are no measurement results regarding
mental SSR damping control. Thus, all the closed-loop con- transient torques in the widely circulated technical literature.
trols must be represented in the simulation model to attain a Thus, simulation results cannot be readily compared with ac-
realistic time-response of an SVC. tual field tests. At this stage, a general verification rule is to
ensure that the simulation results satisfy the well understood
2 2 2 10 Generator Controls
behavioral patterns and immediately after switching inci-
dents.
Conventional generator controls, i.e. automatic voltage regu-
lator (AVR), power system stabilizer (PSS), and governor 2.3.3 Turbine-Blade Vibrations
system generally do not have major (positive or negative) ef-
fects on turbine-generator shaft dynamics. Although there are The radial power system of [2.6] is recommended as the test
reports oftorsional excitation as a result ofPSSs and electron- system. The system is composed of a multi-mass tubine-gen-
ically controlled governors, the adverse effect can be prevent- erator which is connected to an infinite bus through two par-
ed by introducing filters in the control circuitry. Thus, the allellines. The system can be used to study blade vibrations
dynamics of excitation and governor systems are neglected, of low-pressure turbine sections. It should be noted that in
and the input mechanical power and the generator field volt- contrast to the shaft torsional oscillations (either small-signal
age are considered as constant values for time-domain inves- or large-signal), the blade vibrations are not readily quantifi-
tigation of shaft dynamics. For those particular cases where able from time-domain responses. Thus, a frequency spec-
either AVR, PSS or governor may aggravate torsional oscil- trum analysis, e.g. FFT should be conducted on the time
lations [2.1,2.2,2.3,2.4,2.5], they can be represented by their response to obtain the relative amplitudes and frequencies of
linearized models in the system model. the blade dominant oscillatory modes.
2 2 2 11 Protection System
Overvoltage protection system of series capacitor can have a A qualitative verification of the simulation results can be ob-
significant impact on large-signal torsional torques and tur- tained based on the comparison ofthe frequencies of the blade
bine-blade vibrations following network transients. Thus, for vibrations, deduced from FFT of the simulation results, with
the simulation of these two phenomena, the series capacitor those provided by the turbine manufacturer.
overvoltage protection scheme including ZnO varistor and
the associated bypass logic and power circuitry must be rep- 2.3.4 Bus-Transfer
resented in the system model.
The simplified system introduced in [2.7], is recommended as
2.3 TESTSYSTEMS the test system for bus transfer studies. Typical motor load
data for simulation studies are available in [2.19].
2.3.1 Torsional Oscillations
The IEEE Working Group on Subsynchronous Resonance has Ideally, validating a model of a fast bus transfer operation
introduced two benchmark models for time-domain simula- should include validating the individual motor models and the
tion of turbogenerator torsional oscillations [2.12, 2.13]. The circuit breakers operating times. Individual motor models can
benchmark models have been extensively used for time-do- be validated by simulating motor starting and running condi-
main as well as frequency-domain investigation of the phe- tions and comparison of other simulation results to data re-
3-7
corded during an actual motor instantaneous current, power, enonis thatof multiple SVCs[3.1]. The problemof controller
apparent power (VA), and speed. However, since a typical interactions attracts more attention as the number of power
bus transfermodelmay include 15or moremotors, it maynot electronic baseddevices increases.
be practical to validate individual motormodels.
3.2 STUDYZONE
To establish the dead time and a range of the expected accu- When two or more interacting controls are identified, the
racy,it is recommended to performa fastbus transfertestwith study zone encompasses those system components which
a few motorsconnected and simulating the test conditions us- must be represented with adequate details to investigate the
ing motor models based on the manufacturer supplied data. interaction phenomenon. Sincethe frequencies of interestare
Since measuring the transient variations in the motor shaft in the subsynchronous frequency range,the studyzone is usu-
torque is a complextask, it is suggested to monitor, simulate ally identified based on the criteriaused for the study zone of
and compare the following parameters: torsional oscillations, Section2.2.1.
3.3 DEVICEMODELS
businstantaneous voltage 3.3.1 Generator ElectricalSystem
individual motors instantaneous currents
If a turbine-generator controls system, i.e. governor system,
total instantaneous currents through the alternate source circuit AVR, PSS, and its torsional mechanical modes do not partic-
breaker ipate in the interaction phenomenon, then the generatorelec-
trical system can be modelled as an ideal, fixed-frequency,
individual motors instantaneous power andapparent power three-phase, voltage sourcebehind a three-phase inductance.
motor speed Otherwise, the second-order model or the third-order model
for Section2.2.2.1 shouldbe used.
errors can then be determined by comparison of the test data
with simulation results. A statistical measure of the expected
modelaccuracy may be basedon the methodof the rootof the
sumof the squaresof the individual errors(RSS). The expect- 3.3.2 Turbine-Generator Mechanical System
ed error in the actual bus transferanalysis wouldbe less than
the RSS of the errors deriveddue to the largernumberof mo- Whenthe generator electrical systemis represented either by
tors included. References [2.7,2.8, 2.9]provide sometest re- the second-order model or the third-order model, the shaft
sults which can be used as general guidelines to verify the system should be represented by the mass-spring-dashpot
pattern of behaviour of the system variables due to the bus modelof Section2.2.2.2. Otherwise, the shaft dynamics and
transferphenomenon. consequently its oscillatory modes can be ignored.
3.3.3Power Transformer
Appendix A provides further information regarding fast bus- Whena generator is represented by a voltagesourcebehindan
transferand typical time-domain simulation results. inductance, the generator step-up transformer is represented
by a seriesRL branchin each phase. Otherwise, the low-fre-
3. CONTROL SYSTEM INTERACTIONS quency transformer model of Section 2.2.2.3 should be used
to represent the transformer in the overall system model. In
3.1 DEFINITION general, the low-frequency transformer model is an adequate
representation of a power transformer for investigation of
Closed-loop controls associated with various power system controller interaction phenomenon. The harmonics generated
apparatus, e.g. SVC controls, HYDC converter controls, con- as a result of transformer saturation have much higher fre-
trols of adjustable seriescapacitors, generator automatic volt- quencies than those of controller interactions. Thus the satu-
age regulators (AVRs), and generator power system ration does not have any major role in the controller
stabilizers (PSSs) have natural oscillatory modes at frequen- interaction phenomenon.Transmission Line
cies in the subsynchronous frequency range of 1 to 35 Hz.
Depending uponthe "electricaldistance" betweenthe appara- Per-phase equivalent- modelis an adequate representation of
tus, the associated closed-loop controls can interact and result a line for investigation of the phenomenon of controlinterac-
in either unsatisfactory operation of the device(s), sustained tions.
oscillations, or even small-signal instability. Another type of
controller interactions is the interaction between a closed- 3.3.4Series and Shunt Capacitor Banks
loop control system and a natural oscillatory mode of an ap-
paratus. One practicalcase of controller interaction phenom-
3-8
Presence of series capacitors in a transmission line can alter not within the Study Zone.
the level of controller interactions or even excite the interac-
tion mode(s) [3.2]. Impacts of parallel (shunt) capacitors on 3.3.8 Static VAR Compensator (SVC)
the controllerinteractionsis significantly less than that of a se-
ries capacitor. Both series and shunt capacitors can be ade- A conventional SVC, which is composed of thyristor-con-
quately represented by three-phase lumped capacitor banks trolled reactor (TCR) and fixed capacitor (FC), can interact
for investigationof controller interactions. with an HYDC converterstation or other SVCs through their
closed-loop controls and excite the phenomenonof controller
3.3.5 Shunt Reactor interaction. An SVC model for control interaction studies
should accurately representthe SVC and its control system in
Similarto shunt capacitors, fixed, shunt inductors do not have the frequency range of 5 to about 45 Hz. The steady-state
a major impact on controllerinteractions. Nevertheless, shunt continuous controlsincludingall the auxiliaryloops, e.g. SVC
reactorsare adequatelyrepresentedby three-phase lumpedin- voltage controland SSR damping control, must be represent-
ductancesfor investigationof controllerinteractions. ed in the simulationmodel. Further details of an SVC small-
signal model are availablein Section 4.3.9.
3.3.6 Loads
3.3.9 GeneratorControls
"Fixed Impedance" modelof loads withinthe studyzonepro-
vides accurate representation of the loads for investigation of Conventional synchronous generator controls, i.e. governor
controllerinteractionphenomenon. Very large load areas can system, AVR, and PSS are designed to perform correspond-
also be representedby an "infinite bus" with proper phase an- ing tasks at very low frequencies (0.1 to 2.5 Hz), and are not
gle to draw the requiredpower at the fundamental frequency. the prime cause of controllerinteractions. Thus the dynamics
The impacts of various load models on the phenomenon of of the generatorcontrols often can be neglected for the inves-
controller interactions have been neither adequately investi- tigation of controller interaction phenomenon. However, if
gated nor reported in the literature. their presence in the overall system model is required, their
conventional low-frequency, linearized models would suf-
3.3.7 HVDC ConverterStation fice.
3-9
4.2 STUDYZONE
230kV 68kV
250km 220km 180km
'I Thosesystemapparatus whicheithergenerateor interactwith
the frequencies of interestmustbe representedin adequatede-
tails,andthey identifythe studyzone. Also transmission lines
which connect the apparatus within the study zone must be
represented with adequate accuracyin the frequency range of
interest in the system model. The remainder of the system
which neither generates nor interacts with the harmonics can
(b) be simplified and represented by its frequency dependent
equivalent model [4.3].
Fig. 3.1. Testsystemsfor investigation of controller interaction phenomena 4.3.1 Generator Electrical Model
Small-signal controller interactions also can be investigated 4.3.2 Turbine-Generator Mechanical System
based on the linearizedmodel of the systemunder investiga-
tion, using eigen analysis approaches [3.6, 3.7. 3.8]. Both dynamics do not play any noticeable role in the harmonic in-
time-domain simulation and the eigen analysis of controller teraction phenomenon. Thus, the shaft model can be readily
interactions are conducted for qualitative comparison of the discarded from the overallsystem model.
results and their mutual verifications.
4.3.3 Power Transformer
3-10
4.3.6 Shunt Reactor capacitors, Fig. 4.1.
Magnetic saturation characteristics of convertertrans-
Similarto series and shunt capacitors, shunt reactors also in- formers must be includedin the model [4.4].
fluence the system natural resonant frequencies and must be
represented in the systemmodel. A shuntreactoris adequate- 4.3.9 Static VAR Compensator (SVC)
ly represented by a three-phase lumpedreactorbank.
StaticVAR compensators have not been reported as a source
4.3.7 Loads of interference phenomenon and harmonic interactions.
However, in the vicinity of HVDC converter stations and
"Fixed Impedance" model is a valid representation for loads FACTS devices, a static VAR compensator can aggravate
withinthe studyzone,unlessthe load is knownto havepartic- harmonic related issues [4.4]. The required SVC model for
ular resonant frequency or generates particular hannonic(s) time-domain investigation of harmonic problems is the same
whichcan affect the harmonic phenomenon of interest. as the modeldescribed in Section3.3.9,exceptfor the follow-
ing differences:
4.3.8 HVDC Converter Station Snubber circuits of each valve chain must be includedin
the simulation model.
The HVDe converter station is one of the major The model of valve firing circuitry must be capable of gen-
sources for generation of harmonics which cause interference erating exact firing instants.
and/or instability of electrical power networks [4.1]. The
required model of an HVDe converter station for studying inter- Operating point and parametervalues of a SVC can readily
ference and harmonic interaction phenomena is the same as the influence series/parallel resonant frequencies of a network
model described in Section 3.3.8. andconsequently tunethe systemfor resonantconditions, e.g.
secondharmonic resonance [4.4]. The above model can also
be used for this class of resonant conditions which normally
occur at noncharacteristic harmonics generated by power
electronic circuits.
cs
4.3.10 Generator Control
Fig.4.1. Lumped equivalent of the stray capacitances ofa 12-pulse HVDe The HVDC-AC system of Fig. 4.2 is proposedas the test sys-
converter and the convertertransformers tem for the investigation of harmonic interactions phenomena
and the secondharmonic instability issues.
Exactparameters of the snubbercircuitsof each valve
chainshouldbe included in the model[4.2]. It shouldbe
noted that in some transients programs, the exactparam-
eters of snubbercircuits cannotbe used. Unrealistic
snubbercircuits are required by theseprograms to avoid
numerical problems.
The model used for the valve firing circuitry should gener-
ate actual firing instants. Otherwise, the amplitudes and
orders of noncharacteristic harmonics will be noticeably
distorted as a result of improper firing instants [4.4].
Stray capacitances of the converter transformers, valve
structure, and smoothing reactormust be adequately rep-
resentedin the systemmodel [4.2]. The impactof stray Fig. 4.2. HVDC-AC test systems for time-domain simulation of harmonic
interaction phenomena, and the second harmonic instability
capacitances can be represented by a set of lumped
3-11
The HVDC link is a ±450-kV, 936-km, 2000-MW, 12-pulse, modelling approach of [4.15] are reported in [4.14]. Refer-
bipole configuration. Each pole is equippedwith ac side and ences [4.16,4.17,4.18] provide a comprehensive and funda-
de side filters. The inverterneutralis equippedwith a neutral mental description of the harmonic interactionphenomenon.
filter. The rectifierneutralis solidlygrounded closeto the sta- However, there are not that many measurements and investi-
tion. Parameters and controlsystemof the ManitobaHydrois gationof the harmonic interaction phenomenon to establisha
Bipole-2 HVDCsystem[4.5,4.6] are adoptedfor the test sys- method for verification of time-domain simulation studies.
tem of Fig. 4.2. Reference [4.19] introduces an alternative approachbased on
frequency scanning methodfor identification of harmonic in-
stabilities in HVDCsystems. This approachmay be used for
Therectifierac system, Fig. 4.2, is composed of an equivalent qualitative verification of digital time-domain simulationap-
26-kV source which is connected to the rectifier ac bus proach.
through a 26/235-kV transformer and a short 230-kV line.
The effective short circuitratio (ESCR) of the rectifierac sys-
tem is 3.6.
5. FERRORESONANCE
The inverterac system consists of a 230-kV ac source which
is connectedto the inverterstationthrougha 500-kV, 832-km
transmission system. The transmission line is equipped with In this section, ferroresonance is introduced and a general
240/525-kV y - Y connectedtransformer at the source side. modeling approach is given. An overview of available litera-
The ac line is divided in three sections, Fig. 4.2. Each inter- ture and contributors to this area is provided. A simple case
mediate station is equipped with a 400 MVA capacitorbank of ferroresonance in a single phase transformer is used to il-
for voltageprofileimprovement. Loads#1, #2, and #3 arerat- lustrate this "phenomenon". Three phase transformer core
ed at 920-MVA, 400-MVA and 360-MVA respectively. The structures are discussed. Ferroresonance in three phase
inverter station is also equipped with an SVC which can ad- grounded-wye distribution systemsis describedand illustrat-
just its reactive power from 180-MVAR inductive to 510- ed with waveform data obtainedfrom laboratorysimulations.
MVAR capacitive. Electrical parameters of the inverter ac Representation of the study zone is discussed, modelingtech-
systemare givenin [4.7]. The ESCR of the inverterac side is niques are presented, and implementation suggestions are
2.2. made. Three case studied are presented. Transformerrepre-
sentation is criticalto performing a valid simulation. The di-
rection of ongoing research is discussed, and the reader is
References [4.8] and [4.9] provide various HVDC/ac bench- advisedto monitor the literature for ongoing rapid improve-
markmodelsthat also can be used for the analyses of harmon- ments in transformer modelingtechniques.
ic interactions and resonance phenomena. The first HVDC
benchmark model [4.8] proposed by CIGREWG 14-02 also
exhibits second harmonic resonance and can be adopted for
investigation of harmonic instabilityphenomenon. This sys- 5.1 INTRODUCTION TO FERRORESONANCE
tem is less complicated as compared with that of Fig. 4.2.
Reference [4.10]providesa very simple circuitconfiguration
which exhibits instability due to switching characteristic of Research involving ferroresonance in transformers has been
thyristor-controlled reactor (TCR). A set of time-domain conducted over the last 80 years. The word ferroresonance
simulations results of the test systems of Fig. 4.2 is given in first appears in the literaturein 1920[5.7],althoughpapers on
[4.4]. resonance in transformers appeared as early as 1907 [5.4].
Practical interest was generated in the 1930s when it was
4.5 VERIFICATION OF SIMULATION RESULTS shown that use of series capacitors for voltage regulation
caused ferroresonance in distribution systems [5.9], resulting
There are several technical papers which deal with analysis in damaging overvoltages.
and measurement of noncharacteristic harmonics of HVDC
converter stations [4.2,4.11,4.12,4.13]. The primary con- The firstanalytical workwas doneby Rudenberg in the 1940s
cern in these papers is the de side triplen harmonics which [5.36]. More exacting and detailed work was done later by
cause interference and not the second harmonic instability Hayashi in the 1950s [5.17]. Subsequent research has been
problem. Reference[4.15]providesa modelling approachfor divided into two main areas: improving the models used to
representation of a six-pulseconverterwithrespectto the sec- predict the behavior of the transformers, and studying fer-
ond harmonic for eigen analysis. Such eigen analysis ap- roresonance involving transformers installed in power sys-
proach can be used as an alternative technique for validation tems.
of simulation results. Eigen analysis studies based on the
3-12
An understanding of the nonlinear parameters describing a
transformer core is prerequisite to dealing with ferroreso-
nance. Swift [5.47] and Jiles [5.20] have provided insight into
transformer core behavior and the separation ofhysteresis and
~
eddy current losses. Frame [5.15] and others have developed R~2 R",. LU l~l
+ lEX
piecewise-linear methods of modeling the nonlinearities in
saturable inductances. V,_", ~ll
Hopkinson [5.19] performed system tests and simulations on xc IDEAL HO
the effect of different switching strategies on the initiation of TRANSFOIUlER
ferroresonance in three phase systems. Smith [5.38] catego-
rized the modes of ferroresonance in one type of three phase
distribution transformer based on the magnitude and appear- 1.0
ance of the voltage waveforms. Arturi [5.2] and Mork [5.29] 0 .75
~
have demonstrated the use of duality transformations to ob- 0 .5
W
rt.
rt.
tain transformer equivalent circuits . Mork [5.27] and Kieny 0 .25
III
~ 0 .0
Q.
::;
:l
0
[5.21] have shown that the theories and experimental tech- 0
> « 0
Z
-0 .2 5
niques of nonlinear dynamics and chaotic systems can be ap- t=
~
-0.5
plied to better understand ferroresonance and limitations -0.7 5
inherent in modeling a nonlinear system. Developments in
the near future are expected to be in the areas of developing
TIME
improved transformer models and applying nonlinear dynam-
ics to the simulation of ferroresonance. Fig. 5.1. Unloaded singlephasetransformer withratedvoltage applied.Solid
waveform is appliedvoltage; dashedwaveform is exciting current
3-13
are possible, depending on the magnitudes of source voltage Ferroresonance can leadto heatingof transformer, due to high
and series capacitance. In this case, all modes are seen to pro- peak currentsand high core fluxes. High temperatures inside
duce periodic voltage waveforms on the transformersecond- the transformermay weakenthe insulationand cause a failure
ary [5.26,5.29]. In general, gradualchanges in source voltage under electrical stresses. In EHV systems, ferroresonance
or capacitance will cause state transitions. A reversalto con- may result in high overvoltages during the first few cycles, re-
ditions that caused a transitionwill not reverse the transition, sulting in an insulation coordination problem involving fre-
due to nonlinearity ofLM [5.36]. Transientscan also trigger quencieshigher than the operating frequency of the system.
transition from mode to mode.
Because of nonlinearities, analytical solution of the ferrores-
In modem terms, these jumps are referred to as bifurcations onant circuit must be done using time domain methods. Typ-
[16,27,29,45], and may be better understood by applying the ically, a computer-based numerical integration method is
theory of nonlinear dynamics and chaos. A long-used intui- applied using time domain simulation programs such as the
tive explanationof thesejumps, basedon a graphical method, EMTP.
is given by Rudenberg [5.36]. However, this method is not a
good analyticaltool since it is based only on the fundamental
frequency and neglects harmonics.
Damping added to the circuit will attenuate the fer- 5.3 MAGNETIC BEHAVIOR OF THREE PHASE TRANS-
roresonant voltage and current. Some damping is always FORMERS
present in the form of resistive source impedance, transformer
losses, and also corona losses in high voltage systems, but most It is incorrect to assume that a three phasetransformer
damping is due to the loadapplied to the secondary of the trans- core is magnetically equivalent to three singlephasetransform-
former. ers, i.e. that the three phases haveno direct magnetic coupling.
Such an assumption can leadto serious errors, especially if one
is investigating a transformer's behavior under transient or
unbalanced conditions.
- 11:.t
-se.e
"HELL P'OR¥ ~ACK!lD)
Fig. 5.2. Same transformeras in Fig. 5.1, fed througha 7511F capaci-
tance,operatingin ferroresonance. Solid waveformis terminal voltageof
transformer; dashed waveform is the current.
5-IBdOED WOUND CORE
I~
Damping added to the circuit will attenuate the ferroresonant
voltage and current. Some damping is always present in the Fig. 5.3. Core configurations commonly used in three phase transform-
form of resistive source impedance, transformer losses, and ers.Only one set of windings is shown.
also corona losses in high voltage systems, but most damping
The only type of core that displays magnetic characteristics
is due to the load applied to the secondary of the transformer.
similar to three single phase transformers is the triplex core.
Therefore, a lightly-loaded or unloaded transformer fed
Althoughthe cores share the same tank, they are magnetically
through a capacitive source impedance is a prime candidate
isolated(except for leakage fluxes). Core laminations can be
for ferroresonance.
stacked or wound. Zero sequence fluxes will circulate indi-
This elementary type of ferroresonance is similar to that vidually in each core, and tank heating is not a problem. Un-
which occurred in the series capacitor compensated distribu- der normal balanced operation, exciting currents in each
tion systems of the 1930s. It can also occur, from different phase are identical, except for their 120 shift in phase angle.
sources of capacitance, in today's single phase distribution
All of the other core conftgurations provide direct flux linkag-
transformers and voltage instrument transformers [5.1,5.18].
es between phases via the magnetic core. Simply stated, ap-
It can also occur in series-compensated transmission lines.
plying a voltage to anyone phase will result in voltages being
3-14
induced in the other phases (only in the adjacent phase(s) in lines, capacitor banks, coupling capacitances between double
the case of the five-legged wound core). Further, the degree circuit lines or in a temporarily-ungrounded system, and volt-
of saturation in each limb of the core affects the way flux age grading capacitors in HV circuit breakers. Other possibil-
flows divide. The apparent reluctance seen by each of the ities are generator surge capacitors and SVCs in long
windings changes depending on the degree of saturation in transmission lines. Due to the multitude of transformer wind-
each of the limbs of the transformer core. Therefore, exciting ing and core configurations, system connections, various
currents vary from phase to phase, even under balanced oper- sources of capacitance, and the nonlinearities involved, the
ation. A brief discussion of each of these core types follows: scenarios under which ferroresonance can occur are seeming-
ly endless [5.5].
Core-form transformers require the least amount of core ma-
terial to manufacture. Laminations are stacked. Their worst System events that may initiate ferroresonance include single
problem is that unbalanced operation results in zero sequence phase switching or fusing, or loss of system grounding. The
fluxes which cannot circulate in the core. These zero se- ferroresonant circuit in all cases is an applied (or induced)
quence fluxes are forced through the insulation surrounding voltage connected to a capacitance in series with a transform-
the core and through the transformer tank. Tank steel is not er's magnetizing reactance.
laminated like the core is, so eddy currents can heat the tank
and cause damage. Therefore, this type of core should only be Fig. 5.4 gives three examples offerroresonance occurring in a
used where load currents are balanced. network where single phase switching is used. A wye-con-
nected capacitance is paralleled with an unloaded wye-con-
The shell-form core provides a magnetic path for zero se- nected transformer, The capacitance could be a capacitor
quence flux, and is much better-suited for unbalanced opera- bank or the shunt capacitance ofthe lines or cables connecting
tion. Laminations are stacked. There is a large base of the transformer to the source. Each phase of the transformer
transformers with this type of core (about half of the installed is represented by jXm, since ferroresonance involves only the
three phase power transformers in the US). magnetizing reactance.
like behavior. a}
....,
J
J
_
3-15
tance(s) exists and ferroresonance is possible. Ifboth neutrals Whether ferroresonance occurs depends on the type of
are grounded or both are ungrounded, then no series path ex- switching and interrupting devices, type of transformer, the
ists and there is no clear possibility of ferroresonance. In all load on the secondary of the transformer, and the length and
of these cases, the voltage source is the applied system volt- type of distribution line. A long underground line is much
age. Ferroresonance is possible for any ofthe core configura- more capacitive than a short overhead line. However, due to
tions of Fig. 5.3 (even for triplexed or a bank of single phase nonlinearities, increased capacitance does not necessarily
transformers). mean an increased likelihood of ferroresonance. Operating
guidelines based on linear extrapolations of capacitance may
not be valid. Also, as mentioned previously, the smaller the
Depending on the type of transformer core, ferroresonance load on the transformer's secondary, the less the system damp-
may be possible even when there is no obvious series path ing is and the more likely ferroresonance will be. Therefore,
from the applied voltage through a capacitance and a magne- a highly capacitive line and little or no load on the transformer
tizing reactance. This is possible with three phase core types are prerequisites for ferroresonance. Binary loads (either full
which provide direct magnetic coupling between phases, load or no load) such as irrigation, are essentially zero most of
where voltages can be induced in the open phase(s) of the the time and cannot be relied upon to damp ferroresonance.
transformer. To illustrate, a grounded-wye to grounded-wye Ferroresonance is rarely seen provided all three source phases
transformer typical of modem distribution systems is consid- are energized, but may occur when one or two of the source
ered. A recent survey in the US showed that 79% of under- phases are lost while the transformer is unloaded or lightly
ground rural distribution systems use this configuration, so loaded. The loss of one or two phases can easily happen due
ferroresonance problems in this type of installation are of spe- to clearing of single phase fusing, operation of single phase
cial interest [5.23,5.25,5.40,5.41]. A simplified schematic of reclosers or sectionalizers, or when energizing or deenergiz-
such a system is shown in Fig. 5.5. The distribution line is ing using single phase switching procedures.
represented by its RLC pi equivalent, with no interphase cou-
pling. Three phase circuit breakers and gang-operated If one of the three switches of Fig. 5.4 were open, only two
switches are used at the substation where distribution lines phases of the transformer would be energized. If the trans-
originate, but single phase switching and interrupting devices former is of the triplex design or is a bank of single phase
are used outside of the substation. transformers, the open phase is simply deenergized and the
energized phases draw normal exciting current. (Existence of
capacitor banks or significant phase to phase capacitive cou-
pling could still result in ferroresonance, but that possibility is
not addressed here).
3-16
will continue to be supplied, although with dangerously high The "higher energy modes" [5.1] offerroresonance involving
or low voltage levels and with poor power quality. relatively large capacitances and little damping can produce a
nonperiodic voltage on the open phase(s). These voltage
Therefore, use of single phase interruption and switching waveforms can be quite similar to those ofDuffmg's equation
practices in systems containing the five-legged core trans- [5.45] , which describes a nonlinear forced oscillator common-
formers is the main operating tactic responsible for initiating ly used to illustrate the behaviors of a nonlinear dynamical
ferroresonance . Replacement of all single phase switching system. Transitions between periodic and nonperiodic modes
and interrupting devices with three phase devices would elim- occur due to gradual changes in circuit parameters or to tran-
inate this problem, although economics discourages such sients. And as with Duffing's equation, initial conditions de-
large scale upgrades. An alternate solution would be to re- termine the mode that operation stabilizes in after the
place all five-legged core transformers with single phase transients die down.
banks or triplex designs wherever there is a small load factor.
System wide operation and design implications of this prob- The recognition that ferroresonance is a nonlinear and some-
lem have been more fully addressed in prior work [5.25] . times chaotic process opens up many possibilities. The new-
ly-developed techniques for analysis of nonlinear dynamical
5.5 NONLINEAR DYNAMICS AND CHAOS APPLIED systems and chaos are being evaluated for use with ferroreso-
nance [5.27,5.21]. Use of geometric graphical methods like
TOFERRORESONANCE phase plane projections and PoincarE sections can be applied
to obtain a better understanding of ferroresonance .
3-17
combination of initialconditionandtransientmakeprediction cannotbe correctlyincorporated with this representation (the
less than certain. only place it can be connected is on one of the external trans-
formerterminals).
5.6.2 The Study Zone
Model performance depends mainly on the representation of
Parts of the system that must be simulatedare the source im- the nonlinearelements RC and LM. RC has traditionally been
pedance, the transmission or distribution line(s), the trans- modeledas a linear resistance. Such a core loss representa-
former, and any capacitance not already included. Source tion, if it represents the average losses at the level of excita-
representation is not generally critical. Unlessthe sourcecon- tion being simulated, may in fact yield reasonable results.
tainsnonlinearities, it is sufficientto use the steady-state thev- Due to eddy currentlosses and hysteresis lossesbeing nonlin-
enin impedance and open-circuit voltage. The distribution ear, calculation of a linear core loss resistance RC gives dif-
line or transmission line can be assumed to be an RLC cou- ferent values for each level of excitation. Using the value of
pled pi-equivalent, cascadedfor longer lines. Shunt or series RC closest to rated voltage may be a good enough estimate.
capacitors may be represented as a standardcapacitance, par- Past research has shown low sensitivities to fairly large
alleled with the appropriate dissipation resistance. Stray ca- changes in RC [5.29] for singlephase transformers, but a high
pacitance may also be incorporated eitherat the comers of an sensitivity for three-phase cores.
open-circuited delta transformer winding or midway along LM is typically represented as a piecewiselinear -i character-
each winding. Other sources of capacitance are transformer istic [5.22], or perhaps as a hysteretic inductance
bushings and interwinding capacitances, and possiblybusbar [5.15,5.20,5.33]. The linear value ofLM (below the knee of
capacitances. the curve) does not much affect the simulation results [5.8],
One of the most critical parts of any ferroresoriance study is although great sensitivities are seen for the shape of the knee
the transformermodel. The transformer containsthe nonlin- and the fmal slope in saturation.
earities, and modeling results are most sensitive to correct Factorytest data providedby the transformermanufactureris
representation of magnetic saturationand core loss. The rest often insufficient to obtainthe core parameters. Open circuit
of this discussion focuses mainly on how the transformer tests shouldbe madefor 0.2 to 1.3pu (or higher)insteadof the
shouldbe modeled. Manyare dissatisfied with the transform- typical 0.8 to 1.14pu range. It is importantthat open circuit
er modeling capabilities in today'smodeling packages. There testsbe performed for voltagesas high as the conditionsbeing
has been much discussionrecently as to what improvements simulated, or the fmal -i slopeof LM must be guessed. Some
can be made in modeling techniques [5.6,5.13,5.46]. thought should be given to the requirements of test reports
when specifying new transformers.
5.6.3 More on Single Phase Transformer Models And
Parameters A method proposedby Dommel [5.11,5.22] is often used to
convertthe RMSV-I opencircuitcharacteristic to the -i char-
Singlephase transformers are typicallymodeledas shown in acteristic of LM. To successfully use this method, the first
Fig. 5.2. This model is topologically correctonly for the case (lowest) level of excitationmust result in sinusoidal current,
wherethe primaryand secondarywindings are not concentri- or errorswill result in the form of an S-shaped -i curve. Also,
callywound. LL2 is essentially zero for concentric coils. Er- the V-I characteristic must extend as high as the highest volt-
rors in leakage representation are not significant, however, age that will be encountered in the simulation. An extension
unless the core saturates. Obtaining the linear parameters for on this method has been proposed to obtain a nonlinear v-i
this 2-winding transformer may be difficult. Short circuit representation ofRC [5.31], but the resulting flux-linked vs.
tests give total impedance (Rl + R2) + j(XI + X2). A judge- lEX loopdoesnot seemto correctlyrepresentthe core losses.
ment must be made as to how it is dividedbetweenthe prima-
ry and secondarywindings. Modem low-loss transformers have comparatively large in-
ter-winding capacitances whichcan affectthe shapeof the ex-
If the transformerhas three or more windings, the Rs and Xs citationcurve [5.47]. This can cause significant errors when
for the individual windings of each phase may be separated. the abovemethodis being used to obtain core parameters. In
Sometimes one of Xs is negative, but this will not usually thesecases,factory testsmustbe performedto get the -i curve
causea problemin the time domaintransientsimulation. This beforethe coils are placed on the core. A means of removing
approach satisfactorily separates the windingresistances, but the capacitive component of the excitingcurrenthas also been
may not correctlyaccount for mutual inductive coupling. To developed [5.29].
solve this problem, a coupled L representation for the short
circuit inductances is recommended [5.11]. Binary short cir- 5.6.4 Three Phase Transformer Models And Model Parame-
cuit (shortingtwo windingsat a time while leavingall others ters
open)tests for all possiblecombinations of windings must be
performedto obtain the inductance matrix. Additional devel- For three phase transformers, it is possible to make a simpli-
opments are still needed, however, since the core equivalent fied model by connecting together three of the above single
3-18
phase models. If this is done, a triplex core configuration is transformers. Binary short circuit tests involving all windings
assumed (see Fig . 5.3). A delta-wye transformer of this type of all phases must be performed. Problems can arise for RMS
is shown in Fig. 5.7. It is postulated that zero sequence (ho- short circuit data involving windings on different phases,
mopolar) effects are included almost entirely by the leakage since the current may be nonsinusoidal. A problem also exists
inductance of the delta windings [5.11,5.22]. with connecting the core equivalent. Three single phase core
equivalents are often attached to the windings closest to the
core, and may provide acceptable results in some cases , espe-
cially in the case of the three-legged stacked core. Questions
pr imory : Delto secondary : grounded Wye
exist as to this method's validity, especially depending on the
PA
type of core being analyzed. The most important question is,
however, what is the topology of the core equivalent? A
method of obtaining topologically correct models is presented
R2 L2 SA in the next section .
3-19
the core and leakages. Winding resistance and interconnec- The capacitance in this case comes from whatever "stray"
tion of the windings appears external to the coupling trans- coupling capacitance exists between the delta windings and
formers . The advantage to this is that the derived core earth. Adding a resistive burden to the VT can elim inate the
equivalent can be used independently of winding configura- problem .
tion (delta, wye, zig-zag, etc.). Winding resistance, core loss-
es, and capacitive coupling effects are not obtained directly ,
but can be added to this topologically-correct equivalent elec-
trical circuit.
LUKAGE X1- X! H1 X1
L£AKAcz: Xl-la LEAICACf: la-X!
Rx
X2
-
I/J L[AIC 'Ill"
H3 X3
I I~ ~I ;
~ ~II~ ~x N
x ~III x
N
CDI[ I
HO xc
...L
Fig. 5.9. Duality derived equivalent circuit with current sources replaced by
ideal coup ling transformers. Winding resistances have also been added
1/2 LlM X1X1
Fig. 5.8. Development of magnetic circuit for grounded-wye togrounded - A recent problem occurring in a 50-kV network in the Hafs-
wye five-legged wound core transformer. At top, transformer core sectional lund area near Moss, Norway, serves as an excellent example
view used as a basis for duality derivation . Leakageflux paths are labeled.
Bold dividing lines mark division in corereluctances. Equivalent magnetic
[5.18]. The clearing of a short circuit removed the only re-
circuit is shown at bottom. maining source of grounding on the system. After the fault
was cleared, the only remaining zero sequence impedance
Tests have been developed to determine the parameters for was due to capacitive coupling to earth. After operating in
this model [5.28]. this way for only 3 minutes , ferroresonance had destroyed 72
of the VTs used for measurement and protective relaying. All
5.7 CASE STUDIES 72 of the damaged VTs were from the same manufacturer.
The VTs of two other manufacturers that were also in service
5.7.1 Case Study #1: VT Ferroresonance on Floating Sys- during this time were not damaged.
tems
Fig. 5.10 shows the typical VT arrangement used in this sys-
It is possible that parts of a power system can be oper- tem. The VTs have two low voltage windings. The secondary
ated for short times without system grounding . One common is used for measurement and protective relaying purposes.
example is the no-load energization of the wye side of a wye to The burden on that winding has a very high impedance and its
delta power transformer. effects can be ignored when considering ferroresonance. It is
the tertiary windings which are shown in Fig. 5.10. These
The delta side will "float" with respect to earth, until some windings are connected in open delta and loaded with a damp-
load or other source of grounding is connected. If there is a ing resistance RO. The purpose of this damping resistance is
voltage transformer (VT) connected to the delta side of the to damp out ferroresonance, and this design has been com-
power transformer, ferroresonance can occur (see figure) .
3-20
monly used for many years. ances were found to be very small compared to the primary
impedances of the VTs, and could be neglected. The zero
sequence impedance ZO consists almost entirely of the stray
capacitance of the floating system, and is therefore very impor-
tant. Values ofZO varied from 0.6 - j219 to 0.2 - j221 ,depend-
ing where in the system. ZO therefore becomes the only system
impedance needed in the model, and the positive sequence volt-
age sources can be modeled as stiff sources. The core losses of
the VTs were also neglected, their values being much higher
than the damping resistance RO.
- ---t--.-.-.-.. -t------.-..- I
B.O
I I
I----'---~__'__--'----+---'----'-___'_------I-~~.l..---~__'__--'----'
Since some of the VTs were damaged and the others weren't, Fig. 5.11.Comparison of the saturationcharacteristics of the three VTs.
Notethe much lowersaturationlevel of VT # 1, the ones that were damaged.
the VTs of different manufacturers obviously must have dif-
ferent characteristics. The problem at Hafslund therefore
VA
forced a re-evaluation of the specification and application of I ( +--a~--..-----------
....
A
voltage transformers. EMTP was used to simulate the system
conditions that caused the VT failures. VT model parameters
were obtained from the manufacturers. Parameters are shown VB
in Table 2. Saturation characteristics were calculated based I (t-+-<J~--+-----..------
B
on core material B-H data, core dimensions, and number of
primary turns. Data for the damaged VTs are listed as VT #1.
Vc
The designed flux densities BM at rated voltage vary. As a I ( +--a~--+------+-----..--
....
more uniform basis of comparison, the flux densities were C
converted to flux-linked values (Fig. 5.11). Note that VT #1
will saturate out at lower levels than the other VTs, and one
might guess this to be one of the reasons these failed and the
others didn't. But this can only be confrrmed from simulation
results.
Fig. 5.12.Reducedsystemequivalent, neglecting line impedances and lump-
ing all VTsin each phase into an aggregatejXM.
I Rp
I Xp
I XT I Nl:N3 I BMAX
I Many simulations were run, with various combinations of
VTs and values of RO. It was found that ferroresonance oc-
VT#1 32500 25000 0.010 20k:23 l.05T curred in most cases where RO was set to the 60 value typi-
cally used in system design. It was also seen that the high
VT#2 32180 30940 0.010 -36k:42 0.77T
magnetizing currents drawn by VT #1 while in ferroresonance
VT#3 75880 48330 0.010 25k:29 0.83T caused high loR losses in the windings, which thermally de-
stroyed those VTs. If all of the VTs from manufacturer #1
were replaced with different VTs and ifRO was reduced to 10
, ferroresonance would not occur. It was therefore recom-
Table 2: Linear parameters used to model the VTs at Hafslund
mended that the failed VTs be replaced with those of either
Fig. 5.12 shows the reduced equivalent used in the
EMTP model. System positive and negative sequence imped- VT #2 or VT #3. A decrease in the value of RO standardly
being used was also recommended.
3-21
latedare very close for the periods one, two, and three. Period
five is generally correct, with slightly lower than actual peak
5.7.2 CaseStudy #2: Ferroresonance in Distribution Systems amplitudes predicted. The chaotic response predicted is slightly
higher than actual. Themodel useda simplistic linearresistance
This case involvesthe verificationof the 75-kVAfive-legged to represent the core losses of each core. The model's accuracy
wound-core distribution transformermodeldeveloped earlier. couldbe improved by implementing a more correct (complex)
Ferroresonance was staged on the secondary windings in the corelossrepresentation.
laboratory. Balanced 3-phase voltage was applied to the sec-
ondary windings, and then one or two phases of the supply 5.7.3 CaseStudy #3: Ferroresonance ofAutotransformer
were removed and replaced with various values of shunt ca-
pacitance. Scenarios investigated were loss of one source This case is taken from the Ontario Hydro system
phase to the centeror an outer winding, and loss of two source where the Cataraqui 230/115-kV autotransformer T2, fedby line
phases to either the two outer windingsor to the center wind- X3H, was experiencing ferroresonance upon deenergization of
ing and one outer winding [5.27]. lineX3H and the 115-kV bus(Fig. 5.15). The deenergizing cir-
cuit breaker was also experiencing a high recovery voltage. It
Measured waveforms were then compared to EMTP simula- wasdeduced that capacitive coupling between line X3H and the
tions. The transformerequivalentcircuitused was essentially still-energized lines X4H and X522A was driving the autotrans-
that of Fig. 5.9. Details of model development and parameter former into ferroresonance. Damping resistors were added to
values are given in [5.29]. the tertiary of T2, but it was not certain whetherthe resulting
damping was sufficient to limit the duration of ferroresonance
Since many ferroresonant modes are possible, bifurcation andtherelated recovery voltage.
simulations were first run. A bifurcationis essentially a jump
from one mode of ferroresonance to another. A simulation
technique was developedto very slowlyrampthe capacitance 600 If>....i.j~erroresonance: I Laboratory
Simulated ._-_.: ~
\ 22.5uF Connected Xl-XO I
[5.12,5.28] and recordjumps from one mode to another. Fig. zr400 ..... ..
['h,
.~
~":
5.13 gives one bifurcation diagram for the case where a ! r-, L••.
RJ.: \
("' i..•
200 ....
-...,..
ramped capacitance is connectedto unenergized winding Xl
r-;
l ! ..
I'-
!
/ t· \··
and rated positive sequencevoltage is applied to X2 and X3. x~ a ···· ..· · · 1·· ..·..........1··....·
! \\~
. ~J
Due to nonlinearities, it is importantto ramp the capacitance f
II)
X2H
CATARA Q UI I S
KINGSTON y .
GAROINER TS
e
::>
i :
·········:························i···· . . ~
Fig. 5.15. OntarioHydro230-kVsystem. Ferroresonance involvingline
. ~~:~~..
, "'
X3Hand connectedtransformerat Cataraqui TransformerStation.
5.8 1B .8 15.8 28 .8
CAPACITANCE X I- H (uF)
SeveralEMTP simulations were run, with Y-connectedresis-
Fig. 5.14. Samplebifurcationdiagram. Shunt capacitanceon XI is ramped tive loads of zero, 133kW/phase, and 266 kW/phase attached
from 0 to 30 IlF. Blurredareas correspondto chaos.
to the tertiary ofT2. In each case, the 115-kVbreaker ofT2
Fig. 5.14 shows the result of one of the EMTP simula- was assumed to open last. Two double-circuit 230-kV lines,
tions and compares it to the actual measurements. The model an existing500-kVline, and a future 500-kVline were includ-
correctly predicts the existence of all modes of ferroresonance at ed in the corridor, resulting in an 18-phase coupled-circuit
the correct values of capacitance. The actual waveforms simu- transmission equivalent (Fig. 5.16).
3-22
Fig. 5.17 shows the circuit breaker recovery voltage
for one of the cases.
It is interesting to note that a I33-kW/phase load did an ! ! .
effective job of damping ferroresonance in T2, but resulted in a 2.oE+S :.. .. ...... '
~
:
.1 CATARAQJI12 FERRORESONANCE I,
EXTERNAL DAMPING = 133 k!N I phas eJ
...:
.
when the load was doubled to 267 kW/phase . Simulations were MIV\~ --j -
also performed for deenergization ofTl, with similar but less
severe behaviors noted. Recommendations were made to add
-ine-s
.
v.y...... ..r~ ·······~···~·~·~····~
..
267 kW/phase loads to both transformers, and add surge arrest- -2.oE+S ...~ ~ '1' .:
ers to the high and low voltage terminals of both transformers . -3.oE+S _ . ...: : : ...;
~ 402kV peak : :
-4.oE+S 1- ......... ~·I······ ··········i················i········ ·· · · · ·..;
O.os 100.oms zoonms 300.oms 400.om,
liME
5.8 RECOMMENDATIONS
6. SUMMARY
3-23
The report is intended for practicing engineers who are in- Transfer Studies", IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, Vol.
volved in analysis, control and system planning issues related EC-5, No.3, pp. 470-476, 1990.
to electronic power systems. It is assumed that the reader has
(1) a fair understanding of the physical phenomena and (2) an [2.9]P.L. Young, W.L. Snider, T.A. Higgins, H.I. Holley,
adequate knowledge of digital simulation techniques. The "Report on Bus Transfer: Part III, Full Scale Testing and
guidelines are provided for seven transient torsional torques, Evaluation", IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, Vol. EC-5,
(3) turbine-blade vibrations, (4) fast bus transfer, (5) control- No.3, pp. 477-484, 1990.
ler interactions, (6) harmonic interactions and resonance, and [2.10]P.L. Dandeno, M.R. Iravani, "Development and Appli-
(7) ferroresonance. For those phenomena which have exten- cation of Third-Order Turbogenerator Electrical Stability
sively discussed in the literature, i.e. (1) to (4), general guide- Models With Particular Reference To Subsynchronous Reso-
lines are provided and the reader is frequently referred to the nance Studies", IEEE Trans., Vol. EC-I0, No.1, pp. 78-86,
technical literature for further in-depth modeling and simula- March 1995.
tion issues. The emphasis of this document is on phenomena
(5), (6) and particularly (7). [2.11]G. Gross, M.C. Hall, "Synchronouos Machine and Tor-
sional Dynamic Simulation in Computation of Electromag-
netic Transients", IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and
7. REFERENCES Systems, Vol. PAS-97, No.4, pp. 1074-1086, 1978.
[2.3]IEEE SSR Working Group, "First Supplement to a Bib- [2.16]N. Rostamkolai, et al, "Subsynchronous Torsional In-
liography for the Study of Subsynchronous Resonance Be- teractions with Static VAR Compensators - Influence of
tween Rotating Machines and Power Systems", IEEE Trans., HYDC", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, Vol. PWRS-6, No.
Vol. PAS-98, No.6, pp. 1872-1875, Nov. - Dec. 1979. 1, pp. 255-261, Feb. 1991.
[2.4]IEEE SSR Working Group, "The Second Supplement to [2.17]L. Gyugyi, "Fundamentals of Thyristor-Controlled
a Bibliography for the Study of Subsynchronous Resonance Static VAr Compensators in Electric Power System Applica-
Between Rotating Machines and Power Systems", IEEE tions", IEEE Publication 87TH0187-5 PWRS, pp. 8-27,1987.
Trans., Vol. PAS-I04, No.2, pp. 321-327, Feb. 1985. [2.18]A.N. Vasconcelos, et aI, "Detailed Modeling of an Ac-
[2.5]IEEE SSR Working Group, "Third Supplement to a Bib- tual Static VAR Compensator for Electromagnetic Transient
liography for the Study of Subsynchronous Resonance Be- Studies", IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, Vol. PWRS-7, No.
tween Rotating Machines and Power Systems", IEEE Trans., 1, pp. 11-19, 1992.
Vol. PWRS-6, No.2, pp. 830-834, May 1991. [2.19]H.J. Holley, T.A. Higgins, P.L. Young, W.L. Snider,
[2.6]T.P. Tsao, C. Chgn, "Restriction ofTurbine Blade Vibra- "A Comparison of Induction Motor Models for Bus Transfer
tions in Turbogenerators", lEE Proceedings, Vol. 137, Part C, Studies", IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, Vol. EC-5, No.
No.5, pp. 339-342, 1990. 2, pp. 310-319, 1990.
[2.7]J.D. Gill, "Transfer of Motor Loads, Between Out-of- [2.20]EPRI Report, "Bus Transfer Studies for Utility Mo-
Phase Sources", IEEE Trans. on Industrial Applications, Vol. tors", EERI EL-4286, Vol. 2, Project 1763-2, October 1986.
1A-15, No.4, pp. 376-381,1979. [2.21]G.J. Rogers, D. Shirmohammadi, "Induction Machine
[2.8]T.A. Higgins, P.L. Young, W.L. Snider, H.I. Holley, Modelling For Electromagnetic Transients Program", IEEE
"Report on Bus Transfer: Part II, Computer Modelling for Trans., Vol. EC-2, No.4, pp. 622-628, December 1987.
3-24
[2.22]R.H. Doherty, "Analysis of Transient Electrical No.1, pp. 335-344, January 1996.
Torques and Shaft Torques in Induction Motors as a Result of
Power Supply Disturbances", IEEE Trans., Vol. PAS-I0l, [4.5]Manitoba HVDC Research Center, "EMTDC User Man-
No.8, pp. 2826-2834, August 1982. ual", pp. 12.44-12.50, 1988.
[2.23]Y. Pavlyuk, "Application of Static Transfer Switch For [4.6]D.A. Woodford, "Validation ofDigital Simulation ofDC
Induction Motor Load Transfer", M.A.Sc. Thesis, University Links", IEEE Trans., Vol. PAS-I04, No.9, pp. 2588-2595,
of Toronto, 1997. September 1985.
[3.1]A.J.P. Ramos, H. Tyll, "Dynamic Performance of a Ra- [4.7]M. El-Marsafaway, "Use of Frequency Scan Techniques
dial Weak Power System with Multiple Static VAr Compen- for Subsynchronous Resonance Analysis of a Practical Series
sators", IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRS-4, pp. 1316-1325, Compensated AC Network", lEE Proceedings, Vol. 135, No.
November 1989. 1, pp. 28-40, 1983.
[3.2]E.V. Larsen, et al, "Basic Aspects of Applying SVCs to [4.8]M. Szechtman, T. Wess, C.V. Thio, H. Ring, L. Pilotto,
Series Compensated AC Transmission Lines", IEEE Trans., P. Kuffel, "First Benchmark Model for HVDC Control Stud-
Vol. PWRD-5, No.3, pp. 1466-1473, July 1990. ies", Electra, No. 135, pp. 54-73, April 1991.
[3.3]IEEE TF Report, "Modelling and Analysis Guidelines [4.9]CIGRE Working Group 14.02 of Study Committee 14,
For Slow Transients", IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRD-l1, No.3, "The CIGRE HVDC Benchmark Model - A New Proposal
pp. 1672-1677, July 1996. with Revised Parameters:, Electra, No. 157, pp. 60-66, De-
cember 1994.
[3.4]M. Parniani, "Small-Signal Stability Analysis And Ro-
bust Control Design of Static VAR Compensators", Ph.D [4.10]L.A.S. Pilotto, J.E.R. Alves, E.H. Watanabe, A.E. Ham-
Thesis, University of Toronto, 1995. mad, "A Non-Linear Switching Function Model for Static
VAR Compensators", Proceedings of International Power
...[3.5]M. Parniani, M.R. Iravani, "Voltage Control Stability Electronics Conference (IPEC), pp. 627-631, Yokohama,
and Dynamic Interaction Phenomena of Static VAR Compen- April, 1995.
sators", IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRS-I0, No.3, pp. 1592-1597,
August 1995. [4.11]N.L. Shore, G. Andersson, A.P. Canelhas and G. As-
plund, "A Three-Pulse Model of DC Side Harmonic Flow in
[3.6]G. Gross, C.F. Imparato, P.M. Look, "A Tool for Com- HVDC Systems", IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRD-4, No.3, pp.
prehensive Analysis of Power System Dynamic Stability", 1945-1954, July 1989.
IEEE Trans., Vol. PAS-I0l, No.1, pp. 226-234, January
1982. [4.12]D.L. Dickmander, K.J. Peterson, "Analysis of DC Har-
monics Using the Three-Pulse Model for the Intermountain
[3.7]R.M. Hamouda, M.R. !ravani, R. Hackam, "Coordinated Power Project HVDC Transmission", IEEE Trans., Vol.
Static VAR Compensators and Power System Stabilizers for PWRD-4, No.2, pp. 1195-1204, April 1989.
Damping Power System Oscillations", IEEE Trans., Vol.
PWRS-2,pp. 1059-1067, 1987. [4.13]T.F. Garrity, 1.0. Hassan, K.A. Adamson, J.A.
Donahue, "Measurement of Harmonic Currents and Evalua-
[3.8]M. Parniani, M.R. Iravani , "Computer Analysis of tion of DC Filter Performance of the New England - Hydro
Small-Signal Stability of Power System Including Network Quebec Phase I HVDC Project", IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRD-4,
Dynamics", Proceeding lEE, Gen-Trans-Distrib, Vol. 142, No.1, pp. 779-786, January 1989.
No.6, pp. 613-617, November 1995.
[4.14]D.L. Dickmander, S.Y. Lee" G.L. Desilets, M. Grang-
[4.1]A.E. Hammad, "Analysis of Second Harmonic Instabili- er, "AC/DC Harmonic Interaction in the Presence of GIC for
ty for the Chateauguay HVDC/SVC Scheme", IEEE Trans., the Hydro Quebec - New England Phase II HVDC Transmis-
Vol. PWRD-7, No.1, pp. 410-415, January 1992. sion", IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRD-9, No.1, pp. 68-78, January
1994.
[4.2]E.V. Larsen, M. Lublich, S.C. Kapoor, "Impact of Stray
Capacitance on HVDC Harmonics", IEEE Trans., Vol. [4.15]H. Stemmler, "HVDC Back-to-back Interties on Weak
PWRD-4, No.1, pp. 637-645, 1989. AC Systems - Second Harmonic Problems Analysis and So-
lution", CIGRE Symposium, Paper 300-08, Boston, 1987.
[4.3]A.S. Morched, J.H. Ottevangers, L. Marti, "Multi-Port
Frequency Dependent Network Equivalents for the EMTP", [4.16]R.H. Lasseter, L.J. Bohmann, "Harmonic Interactions
IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRD-8, No.3, pp. 1402-1412, July 1993. in Thyristor Controlled Reactor Circuits", IEEE Trans., Vol.
PWRD-4, No.3, pp. 1919-1925, July 1989.
[4.4]A. Sarshar, M.R. Iravani, J. Li, "Calculation ofNonchar-
acteristic Harmonics of HVDC Station Using Digital Time- [4.17]L.J. Bohmann, R.H. Lasseter, "Stability and Harmonics
Domain Simulation Method", IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRD-l1, in Thyristor Controlled Reactors", IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRD-
3-25
5, No.2, pp. 1175-1181, April 1991. 28-30, 1989.
[4.18]S.G. Jalali, R.H. Lasseter, "A Study of Nonlinear Har- [5.14]D.G. Fink and H.W. Beatty, Standard Handbook for
monic Interaction Between a Single Phase Line-Commutated Electrical Engineers, 11th Ed., McGraw-Hill Book Compa-
Converter and a Power System", IEEE Trans., Vol. PWRD-9, ny, New York, NY, copyright 1978.
No.3, pp. 1616-1624, July 1994.
[5.15]J.G. Frame, N. Mohan and T. Liu, "Hysteresis Model-
[4.19]X. Jiang, A.M. Gole, "A Frequency Scanning Method ing in an Electro-Magnetic Transients Program", IEEE Trans.
for the Identification of Harmonic Instabilities in HYDC Sys- PAS, vol. PAS-I0l, no. 9, pp. 3403-3411, September, 1982.
tems", IEEE PES paper 95WM222-0 PWRD.
[5.16]J. Gleick, Chaos: Making a New Science, Viking, New
[5.1]R.G. Andrei and B.R. Halley, "Voltage Transformer Fer- York, NY, copyright 1987.
roresonance from an Energy Standpoint", IEEE Trans. Power
Delivery, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 1773-1778, July, 1989. [5.17]C. Hayashi, Nonlinear Oscillations in Physical Sys-
tems, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, NY, copy-
[5.2]C.M. Arturi, "Transient Simulation and Analysis of a right 1964.
Five-Limb Generator Step-Up Transformer Following an
Out-of-Phase Synchronization", IEEE Trans. Power Deliv- [5.18]T. Henriksen and O. Rervik, "Ferroresonans i 50-kV
ery, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 196-207, January 1991. Nett til Hafslund", Energiforsyningens Forskningsinstitutt AI
S, Trondheim, Norway, ISBN 82-594-0229-7, EFI TR 3779,
[5.3]F.R. Bergseth and S.S. Venkata, Introduction to Electric December 19, 1990 (in Norwegian),
Energy Devices, Prentice Hall, Inc., Inglewood Cliffs, NJ,
copyright 1987. [5.19]R.H. Hopkinson, "Ferroresonance During Single-Phase
Switching of3-Phase Distribution Transformer Banks", IEEE
[5.4]J. Bethenod, "Sur le Transformateur et Resonance", Trans. PAS, vol. PAS-84, no. 4, pp. 289-293, April 1965.
L'Eclairae Electrique, pp. 289-296, November 30, 1907.
[5.20]D.C. Jiles and D.L. Atherton, "Theory ofFerromagnetic
[5.5]J.L. Blackburn, Protective Relaying Principles and Ap- Hysteresis," Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Journal of
plications, Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, NY, pp. 231-237, Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, vol. 61. pp. 48-60, Janu-
9th printing, copyright 1987. ary 21, 1986.
[5.6]M.H.J. Bollen, "The Search for a General Transformer [5.21]Kieny, "Application of Bifurcation Theory in Studying
Model", 16th European EMTP Users Group Meeting, paper and Understanding the Global Behavior of a Resonant Elec-
89-07, pp. 1-20, May 28- 30, 1989. tric Power Circuit," IEEE PES Summer Meeting, SM 265-9
PWRD, July 1990.
[5.7]P. Boucherot, "Existence de Deux Regimes en Ferro-re-
sonance", R.G.E., pp. 827-828, December 10, 1920. [5.22]K.U. Leuven EMTP Center, Alternate Transients Pro-
gram Rule Book, Leuven EMTP Center, Heverlee, Belgium,
[5.8]V. Brenner, "Subharmonic Response of the Ferroreso- Revised July, 1987, copyright 1987.
nant Circuit with Coil Hysteresis", AlEE Transactions, vol.
75 I, pp. 450-456, September 1956. [5.23]D.D. Mairs, D.L. Stuehm and B.A. Mork, "Overvoltag-
es on Five-Legged Core Transformers on Rural Electric Sys-
[5.9]J.W. Butler and C. Concordia, "Analysis of Series Ca- tems", IEEE Trans. on Industrial Applications, vol. 25, no. 2,
pacitor Application Problems", AlEE Trans., vol. 56, pp. pp. 366-370, March, 1989.
975-988, August, 1937.
[5.24]L.W. Match and J.D. Morgan, Electromagnetic and
[5.10]E.C. Cherry, "The Duality Between Interlinked Electric Electromechanical Machines, Third Edition, Harper & Row
and Magnetic Circuits and the Formation of Transformer Publishers, Inc., New York, copyright 1986.
Equivalent Circuits," Proceedings of the Physical Society,
Part B, vol. 62, pp. 101-111, 1949. [5.25]R.D. Millet, D.D. Mairs and D.L. Stuehm, "The Assess-
ment and Mitigation Study of Ferroresonance on Grounded-
[5.11]H.W. Dommel with S. Bhattacharya, V. Brandwajn, Wye to Grounded-Wye 3-Phase Padmounted Transformers",
H.K. Lauw and L. Marti, EMTP Theory Book, 2nd Ed., Mi- Summary Report, NRECA Project 86-7, July, 1987.
crotran Power System Analysis Corporation, Vancouver, BC,
May 1992. [5.26]B.A. Mork, Ferroresonant Modeling Using EMTP, MS
Thesis, North Dakota State University, September 1981.
[5.12]L. Dube and B.A. Mork, "Variable Capacitances and
Inductance in ATP," EMTP News, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 33-36, [5.27]B.A. Mork and D.L. Stuehm, "Application ofNonlinear
March 1992. Dynamics and Chaos to Ferroresonance in Distribution Sys-
tems," IEEE Trans. Power Systems, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 1009-
[5.13]G. Empereur, "Miscellaneous - Transformers", 16th 1017, April 1994.
European EMTP Users Group Meeting, Paper 89-09, May
3-26
[5.28]B.A. Mork, "Five-Legged Wound-Core Transformer Delivery, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 1786-1793, July, 1989.
Model: Derivation, Parameters, Implementation, and Evalua-
tion," Submitted for IEEE PES Winter Meeting, 98WM414, [5.42]D.L. Stuehm., "Final Report - Three Phase Transformer
January 1998. Core Modeling," Bonneville Power Administration Award
No. DE-BI79-92BP26700, February 28, 1993. Copies avail-
[5.29]B.A. Mork, Ferroresonance and Chaos - Observation able from BPA, Dept. EOHC, (503) 230-4404.
and Simulation of Ferroresonance in a Five-Legged Core
Distribution Transformer, Ph.D. Dissertation, North Dakota [5.43]G.W. Swift, "Power Transformer Core Behavior Under
State University, May 1992. Publication No. 9227588, UMI Transient Conditions," IEEE Trans. PAS, vol. PAS-90, no. 5,
Publishing Services, Ann Arbor, MI, 48106, (800) 521-0600. pp. 2206-2209, Sep/Oct 1971.
[5.30]A. Narang and R.H. Brierley, "Topology Based Mag- [5.44]E.J. Tarasiewicz, A.S. Morched, A. Narang, E.P. Dick,
netic Model for Steady-State and Transient Studies for Three "Frequency Dependent Eddy Current Models for Nonlinear
Phase Core Type Transformers," IEEE Trans. PWRS, vol. 9, Iron Cores," IEEE Trans. PWRS, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 588-597,
no. 3, pp. 1337-1349, August 1994. May 1993.
[5.31]W.L.A. Neves and H.W. Dommel, "On Modelling Iron [5.45]J.M.T. Thompson and H.B. Stewart, Nonlinear Dynam-
Core Nonlinearities," IEEE Trans. Power Systems, vol. 8, no. ics and Chaos - Geometrical Methods for Engineers and Sci-
2, pp. 417-425, May 1993. entists, John Wiley and Sons, New York, NY, (Reprinted
October 1987), copyright 1986.
[5.32]NRECA, Underground Distribution System Design and
Installation Guide, Section 6, National Rural Electric Cooper- [5.46]J. Usaola and G. Empereur, "Comparison Between Dif-
atives Association, 1994. ferent Transformer Models in EMTP," EMTP News, vol. 2,
no. 2, pp. 25-34, June 1989.
[5.33]0.E. Radulescu, "EMTP Transformer Model with
Type-96 Element - Computation of the Inrush Current", [5.47]R.A. Walling, K.D. Barker, T.M. Compton, and L.E.
EMTP Newsletter, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 25-33, June, 1986. Zimmerman, "Ferroresonant Overvoltages in Grounded Wye-
Wye Padmount Transformers with Low-Loss Silicon-Steel
[5.34]J. Rougin and V. Ranjamina, "Modeling of Magnetic Cores", IEEE Trans. Power Delivery, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 1647-
Circuits with EMTP", EMTP Newsletter, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 1660, July, 199.
8-28, March 1987.
3-27
are always selected such that they are in phase. Therefore, equivalent motor with typical characteristics. The distinction
manual transfers can be accomplished in a make-before- between large and small motors should be made on a case by
break, i.e., the motors and loads are connected to the second case basis.
power source before the first power source is disconnected.
In this overlapping transfer, the power supply is not inter- A.2.i Motor Electrical System
rupted and the motors are not subjected to transients. How-
ever, during automatic transfers, the motors may be The motor electrical system may be modeled by the
disconnected from both power sources for a short duration differential equations describing the stator and rotor quanti-
depending on the type of transfer and the associated circuit ties and flux linkages [2.20] or by the two-axis model [2.21].
breakers operating times. The time during which the motors A single rotor motor model may be adequate since the motor
are disconnected from both power sources is termed the speed usually does not drop significantly during the time a
"dead time". It is commonly longer than two cycles and can fast transfer is accomplished. The model should account for
be as long as 12 cycles. While motors are disconnected from saturation in the magnetizing, stator and rotor leakage reac-
both power sources they decelerate. The deceleration rate tances.
depends on the motor-load inertia and the synchronizing
power flowing between motors due to their differing charac- A.2.2Loads
teristics. As the motor decelerates, the relative angle
between the motor internal voltage and the power source The mechanical load should be modeled by its
voltage changes. Also, the motor residual voltage decays at a torque-speed characteristics and moment of inertia. Com-
rate which depends on the motor magnetic characteristics, mon centrifugal and axial pumps and fans may be modeled
speed and initial loading. If the relative angle between the by a quadratic torque-speed characteristic.
motor residual voltage and the power source voltage
becomes large enough at the time of reconnection with sig- Non-motor loads may be lumped together and mod-
nificant residual voltage remaining, the resultant voltage eled by an equivalent resistance-inductance circuit. Non-
between the power source and the motor will produce an motor loads would be included in the model to account for
inrush current. The inrush current may be significantly their damping effects on the motors during the dead time.
larger than the normal full voltage starting current. Such
high inrush currents cause high winding stresses and tran- A.2.3Motor-Load Shaft Torsional Model
sient shaft torques which can damage the motor and/or the
driven equipment. The shaft system should be modeled by the motor
rotor mass connected to the load rotor mass by a flexible
The most common bus transfer scheme is the fast spring representing the shaft [2.22]. The motor air gap
bus transfer scheme. In this scheme, opening of the normal torque excites the mass representing the motor rotor while
power source breaker initiates closing of the alternate power the load torque excites the mass representing the load rotor.
source breaker without intentional time delay. The fast bus The shaft torsional model should include the effect of damp-
transfer operations result in the motors being disconnected ing and shaft flexibility. The effect of shaft flexibility is par-
from both power sources for a duration of as short as 2 cycles ticularly important in applications where loads have a large
to as long as 12 or more cycles. inertia relative to that of the motor. An example of this appli-
cation is torsional study of a large boiler fan. Under such
Presently, there are no generic criteria to ensure conditions, the shaft flexibility may cause the shaft torque to
acceptable fast bus transfer operations. Therefore, it is nec- be higher than the motor air gap torque [2.22].
essary to analyze the transient behavior of motors during fast
bus transfer operations. The analysis should be on a case by A.2.4Circuit Breakers
case basis to ensure that the motors will not be subjected to
excessive inrush currents and!or shaft transient torques. The circuit breakers should be modeled as a three
pole switch which can be opened or closed at a preset time.
A.2Modeling and Analysis The three poles of the circuit breaker connecting the alternate
source must be modeled to close simultaneously. the individ-
A three-phase model of the motors and the power ual poles of the circuit breaker disconnecting the normal
distribution system is required. This is to permit simulating source must be modeled to open only at the respective cur-
the breaker individual pole interruption at separate current rent zero. In analysis involving transfers caused by high
zeros and analyzing the effect of unbalanced faults on the level electrical faults, the individual poles may be modeled to
motor behavior. The model must simulate the motor stator open at the respective first current zero following the end of
and rotor dynamics, the load dynamics, and the power source the breaker arcing time. This is a conservative approach
dynamics when available. The larger motors should be indi- which, in effect, models a zero resistance arc.
vidually modeled; smaller motors unless for the motor being
studied, if any, may be lumped together and modeled by one A.2.5Power Sources
3-28
torques should be investigated.
Generally, events which initiate bus transfers such The motor air gap torque at the instant of closing the
as the loss of the generator in a generating station also initiate alternate source breaker is determined by the motor residual
disturbances to the connected power system. The dynamic voltage magnitude and phase angle. The magnitude of the
variations of the power system voltage magnitude and phase motor residual voltage decreases with time while the phase
angle are normally determined as part of system stability angle increased with time. This causes the magnitude of the
studies. air gap torque to be cyclic. It has a minimum value at some
Ideally, the normal and alternate power source mod- short bus dead time, peaks as the dead time increases and
els should reflect the dynamic variations in the voltage mag- then decreases as the dead time increases further. The dura-
nitude and phase angle following the initiating event. This tion of the dead time at which the air gap torque attains mini-
can be accomplished by a point to point representation of the mum and maximum values are system specific and depends
system voltage magnitude and phase angle profiles. Alter- on the connected motors characteristics and load levels.
nately, the system voltage magnitude and phase angle may be
modeled by polynomials fitting their profiles for the short The account for the above considerations, the fol-
duration of interest. However, in the event that data on the lowing fast bus transfer operations should be simulated and
dynamic behavior of the power system is not available, the analyzed.
normal and alternate power sources may be modeled as ideal
sources in phase. Transfers caused without high level electrical faults
with motors operating at their highest loadings when the
A.2.6TransforDlers alternate source voltage is at its maximum level.
Transfers caused without high level electrical faults
Transformer dynamics have a little or no effect on as in 1) above except without the largest high inertia motor
bus transfer operations. Therefore, a transformer may be running.
modeled as an ideal transformer in series with a lumped Transfers caused by high level electrical faults (line
resistance in series with a lumped inductance representing to ground and three line to ground faults).
the transformer equivalent impedance.
The following parameters should be monitored dur-
A.2.7 Cables/Lines ing the simulations:
Cable and Lines may be modelled by their -equiva- bus instantaneous voltages
lents. bus voltage phase angle
individual motors instantaneous currents
A.2.8Simulation and Analysis individual motor air gap torques
individual motors shaft torques (when modeled)
In selecting conditions to be analyzed, the following individual motors speed
should be taken into consideration:
A.3 Model Validation
The motor initial loading (prior to the transfer) has a
significant effect on the rate of change of the motor internal Ideally, validating a model of a fast bus transfer
voltage phase angle. Higher loads cause faster drop in rotor operation should include validating the individual motor
speed and faster rates of change in the phase angle. There- models and the circuit breakers operating times. Individual
fore, the worst case transfer results when the motors are oper- motor models can be validated by simulating motor starting
ating at their highest loading. and running conditions and comparison of the simulation
The motor-load inertia also has a significant effect results to data recorded during an actual motor starting test.
on the internal voltage phase angle rate of change. Motors Parameters be compared include motor instantaneous cur-
with a high inertia have a slower rate of change than motors rent, power, apparent power (VA), and speed. However,
with low inertia. Therefore, the effect of fast bus transfer since a typical bus transfer model may include 15 or more
operation with and without such high inertia motors should motors, it may not be practical to validate individual motor
be evaluated. models. As an alternative, the bus transfer model can be
Bus transfers are initiated by low and high level based on modeling motors using unadjusted manufacturers
electrical faults. The motor residual voltage decays at a high supplied data and establishing a range of the expected accu-
rate until the fault is cleared by opening the source breaker. racy.
This causes the transient shaft torque produced upon closing
the alternate source breaker to be relatively low. However,
faults such as line to ground faults cause the motor to experi-
ence a high oscillatory torque before the fault is cleared. The
effect of the torsional stress caused by such high oscillatory
3-29
Modeling Guidelines for Switching Transients
Report Prepared by the Switching Transients Task Force
of the IEEE Modeling and Analysis of System Transients Working Group
4-1
tion of frequency independence can usually be made; for
cables the matrices are often frequency dependent. In addi- Voltage 230kV 345kV 500 kV 765kV
tion, for pipe-type cables, the cable impedance can be a func- Level
tion of the cable current, if pipe saturation occurs. The Com- No. of ccts=2 No. of ccts= 1 No. of ccts= 1 No. of ccts=1
saturation is difficult to model. ments: Cond/phase= 1 Cond/phase=2 Cond/phase=3 Cond/phase=4
The distributed parameter model consists of a Gnd. wires= 1 Gnd. wires=2 Gnd. wires=2 Gnd. wires=2
description of each mode, and the transformation matrices to p-l00 n-m p=100 n-m p=100 Q-m p=100 Q-m
return to the phase domain. The description of each mode Xl,Q!km 0.50 0.38 0.38 0.34
will probably consist of the surge impedance, resistance, RI,Q!km 0.05 0.032 0.018 0.017
velocity and length. More sophisticated frequency depen-
XO,Q!km 2.5 1.3 1.2 1.00
dent models will include information on the variation of the
parameters with frequency. This may be an important consid- RO,Q!km 0.49 0.34 0.33 0.33
eration when the ground return mode (zero sequence) is Cl, ~F/km 0.0088 0.012 0.013 0.013
involved (e.g., during a line to ground fault). In these cases, a CO, ~F/km 0.0041 0.0083 0.0075 0.0093
frequency dependent distributed parameter line model gives
Table 1: Typical Transmission Line Parameters at 60 Hz
a very accurate representation for a wide range of frequen-
cies in the transients phenomenon.The parameters for the dis-
In many cable studies, such as disconnect switch
tributed parameter model (either frequency-dependent or operation, the constant parameter assumption can be too lim-
constant) are obtained from geometrical and physical infor-
iting. Here a frequency dependent parameter model must be
mation (line/cable dimensions, height above ground, conduc- used, because the frequencies span a large bandwidth and the
tor and soil resistivity) by using a line/cable constants cable parameters significantly vary within this range. How-
program usually included with the EMTP-type programs ever for solid dielectric cables, the constant parameter model
is often adequate. The calculations shown below are useful in
For secondary lines (not directly feeding the phe- determining the maximum allowable pi-section length and in
nomenon under study), and for those studies where mostly estimating errors.
positive sequence conditions are involved (e.g., three-phase Consider as an example a single phase cable with an
energization), a simple distributed constant parameters mod- impedance of Z per unit length and an admittance Y per unit
els can gives satisfactory results. length. Then the propagation constant is given by
1
x, = 3(XO + 2X t ) (5)
1
Xm = 3(XO-Xt ) From this expression it is easy to see how small x
(2) has to be for any desired matching of the surge impedance.
1
c, = 3(CO + 2C t )
Next consider the phase error across the length of the cable
for any frequency f. If Yn is the phase shift at any frequency
1
c; = 3(CO-C t )
across one pi-section, then YnN is the phase shift across all
N sections. It can be shown that
4-2
break circuits. In switching surge studies, the switch is often
modeled as an ideal conductor (zero impedance) when
closed, and an open circuit (infinite impedance) when open.
(6)
Transient programs allow various options to vary the closing
Since the correct phase shift is yL , the error in the time ranging from one-shot deterministic closings to multi-
shot statistical or systematic closings.
phase shift can be easily found.
Statistical Switching: Transient voltage and current magni-
2.2 TRANSFORMERS tudes depend upon the instant on the voltage waveform at
which the circuit breaker contacts close electrically [12]. A
For switching surge transient studies, the trans- statistical switching case typically consists of 100 or more
former model used is a reduced order representation with less separate simulations, each using a different set of circuit
detail (i.e., as in the example in Fig. 21) in comparison with a breaker closing times. Statistical methods can be used to pro-
model used for insulation studies. Usually a lumped parame- cess the peak overvoltages from each simulation. Fig. 1 is a
ter coupled-winding model with a sufficient number ofR-L- plot derived from 100 peak overvoltage magnitudes from the
C elements gives the appropriate impedance characteristics at line energization case study presented in section III A. This
the terminal within the frequency range of interest. The non- plot shows a 10% probability (Y axis) of exceeding 2 pu volt-
linear characteristic of the core should usually be included, age (X axis).
although the frequency characteristic of the core is often
ignored. This may be an oversimplification as the eddy cur- Circuit breakers can close at any time (angle) on the
rent effect prevents the flux from entering the core steel at power frequency wave. For a single phase circuit, the set of
high frequencies thereby making the transformer appear to be circuit breaker closing times can be represented as a uniform
air-cored. This effect begins to be significant even at frequen- distribution from 0 to 360 degrees with reference to the
cies in the order of 3-5 kHz. power frequency. The standard deviation for a uniform distri-
bution over 1 cycle is 1/(2)31) ,where fis the frequency of
For switching surge studies, the following
the waveform.
approaches may be used:
i ) The model may directly be developed from the trans-
A three phase (pole) circuit breaker can be modeled
former characteristic e.g., nameplate information or
as three single phase circuit breakers, each with independent
Doble measurements. The standard EMTP models fall
uniform distributions covering 360 degrees. However, an
into this category. Examples are described in [6,7]
alternative (dependent) model can be used if the three poles
ii) A model synthesized from measured impedance vis fre-
are mechanically linked and adjusted so that each pole
quency response of the transformer as described in [8,9].
attempts to close at the same instant. In reality, there will be a
This approach is used in the Case Study of section 3.3.5
finite time or pole span between the closing instants of the
iii) A very detailed model obtained from the transformer
three poles. The pole span can be modeled with an additional
geometry and material characteristics may be developed.
statistical parameter, typically from a Gaussian (normal) dis-
The model is then reduced to one that is usable in the
tribution. For a mechanically linked three pole circuit
time domain solution. Examples of this method are
breaker, the closing times use both uniform distribution
described in [7,10,11].
parameters and Gaussian distribution parameters. All three
dependent poles use the same parameter from the uniform
When possible, the following techniques can be
distribution, which varies from 0 to 360 degrees. Each pole
used to validate the model. A frequency response obtained by
uses a unique parameter from the Gaussian distribution. The
simulation can be compared within the desired bandwidth
standard deviation of the maximum pole span is typically 17
with the actual characteristic if available. This should be
~o 25 ~ercent of the maximum pole span. For the case study
done for all possible open and short circuit conditions on the
in section III A, a maximum pole span of 5 ms was assumed.
~indings. Determining the fundamental frequency response
m the form of open and short circuit impedances is a standard
Statistical cases with pre-insertion resistors or reac-
check. The turns ratio or induced winding voltages at funda-
tors require a second set of three phase switches. The first set
ment~l fre~uency are of interest. Comparison with factory
is modeled as described above. The closing times of the sec-
tests If available also validates the model. If terminal capaci-
ond set (which shorts the resistors or reactors) are dependent
tance measurements are available a comparison between
upon the first set plus a fixed time delay, typically one-half to
measured and computed responses is useful.
one cycle for pre-insertion resistors used with circuit break-
ers, and 7 to 12 cycles (depending on application voltage
2.3 SWITCHGEAR
class) for pre-insertion reactors used with circuit-switchers
closing in air through high-speed disconnect blades.
Switchgear includes circuit breakers circuit-
switchers, vacuum switches and other devices which make or
4-3
closed during the steady state solution or closed at a specific
100 time or voltage. Several runs with variations in the closing
instant should be carried out as the point on wave of switch-
90
ing can affect the transient.
80
Sometimes faults are modeled with flashover con-
70
trolled switches to represent a gap. The switch is operated
~ 60 typically, when the gap voltage exceeds a fixed value. More
~ sophisticated models include a volt-time characteristic.
~. 50
4-4
acteristic can only change at the end of every time-step. The
preferred model is a true non-linear element which iterates at
Load bus
each time-step to a convergent solution and is thus numeri-
cally robust. The V-I characteristic, usually determined from
the 36 x 90 fJ.S surge should be modeled with 5-10 (preferably
IL 1r -I
I
exponential as opposed to linear) segments. I
(ZS
Waveshape dependent characteristics are usually not
required for most switching transient simulations. Likewise, _I
the surge arrester lead lengths and separation effects can also -I
be ignored for such studies. Modeling of the older series
---L
gapped SiC arresters is not discussed in this paper. ....,.....Xc
2.6 LOADS _-.J
4-5
magnitude to the source impedance. In such a case it may not 3.1.2 Model
be possible to lump the source and lines into one equivalent
impedance. The source, transformer, overhead lines, circuit breaker and
More complex equivalentswhich properly represent the trapped charges (if any) on the line are to be modeled in
the frequency response characteristic(as opposed to the ones order to study the line energizationtransients. In this study a
above that are most accurate near fundamental frequency) are simple power system is used to demonstrate the simulation
also possible [20,21]. Mutually-coupled sources are often results.
typical for line-fed substations. The network configuration of a 345 kV circuit is
shown in Fig. 4. The 345 kV source (1 pu) is connected
2.8 TIME-STEP AND SIMULATION LENGTHS through a transformer to the 203 Ian overhead line. The line
was modeled with several pi-sections in the manner
The time step to be chosen should be small enough described in section 2.2.1.The parameters are given at 60 Hz
to properly represent the smallest time constant in the mod- as:
eled system. It should also be significantlysmaller (typically
1/20 th) than the period of the highest frequency oscillatory Source and transformer impedance,
component. Additional factors that affect the time-step are Zl = Zo = (6.75 + j127)Q
the presence of non-linear characteristics such as arrester Line impedance,Zl = (0.04+jO.318) Q/km
characteristics, and the minimum travel time of travelling Line impedance,Zo = (0.26+jl.015) Q/km
wave cable and transmission line models. Time-steps in the
Charging capacitance, C 1 = 11.86 nF/km
range of 5 J..1S to 50 J..1S (typically 20 J..1s) are used. The simula-
Chargingcapacitance,Co =7.66 nF/km
tion time in typical switching surge studies ranges from 20
ms to 200 ms (typically 50 ms). Slightlylarger time-steps(20
J..1s-50 J..1s) can be used with programs that use interpola-
tion[22], because the linear interpolation method calls for
less iteration of surge arrester characteristics and also does Source (1 pU,60Hz)
203 km transmission line
not introduce spurious current chopping.
~---
One simple method for checking the suitable time- TR CB TR - Transformer
CB- Circuit breaker
step is to check if no further gains in accuracy accrue from
any further time-step reduction.
Fig. 4. One Line Diagramof System Used for Energization Study
3. CASE STUDIES
3.1.3 Simulation Results
Typical case studies are now presented for a practi-
First a statistical overvoltage study is conducted in order to
cal demonstrationof the modeling guidelines. Several differ-
evaluatethe switching time at which maximum transients are
ent examples are considered: Line energization, transient
produced. The results of the statistical energization study
recovery voltage determination for line and transformer
were presented in Fig. 1. Then the effect of various parame-
faults and the switching of shunt as well as series capacitor
ters and related issues on the energization transients are stud-
banks.
ied.
Four, eight or sixteen pi-sections gave similar
3.1 LINE ENERGIZATION
results although the maximum overvoltage was slightly
higher with eight pi-sections. No significant improvement
Aim: The aim of such a study is to determine the overvoltage
was obtained by reducing the time-step below 50 us,
stresses and choose the insulation strength in order to achieve
an outage rate criterion [23].
The overvoltages produced in the presence of
trapped charge on the line depend on the polarity and the
3.1.1 Phenomena:
magnitude of the trapped charges. Therefore additional stud-
ies were carried out to see the effect of trapped charge on the
The energization of overhead transmission lines by closing
line. For reclosure operations, it is assumed that trapped
the circuit breaker produces significant transients. It is
charges on phases A, B, and Care -0.9, -0.8, and 0.8 per unit
important to distinguish between two closely related phe-
respectively.
nomena: energizationand reclosing. In the former case, there
is no trapped charge. In the latter case of reclosing, the line
may have been left with a trapped charge after the initial
breaker opening. In this case, the transient overvoltages can
reach higher values (up to 4.0 pu).
4-6
the switching instant. The peak overvoltages are then deter-
Location Phase A Phase B Phase C mined using statistical switching.
pu pu pu
3.2.2 Model
Source end 1.272 2.164 2.413
Open end 1.442 2.839 2.784 The first example that was done was a 345 kV pipe-type
(HPFF or high pressure fluid filled) cable. A drawing of the
Table 2: Overvoltages in the Presence of Trapped Charge cable is shown in Fig. 6. The 345 kV cable has 2500 kcmil
segmented conductors with a 1.824 inch diameter, 1.035 inch
From Table 2 it can be seen that the highest over- of paper insulation with a dielectric constant c = 3.5. The
voltage magnitude due to the presence of trapped charges is sheath is 0.01 inch.
2.839 pu. The corresponding overvoltage magnitude in the
absence of trapped charges are 2.2 pu (Fig. 1). Typical ener-
Corr osive Protective
gization waveforms are shown in Fig. 5. Coatl"9 . .07 Inch Th;cJ(
,, ~~~ ......
Additional studies (not shown) that can be con -
ducted on this model include the comparison of simultaneous
Impregna t ed Paper
and non-simultaneous closing of breaker contacts, the effect Insulation 1.035 inch
Thickness
of including a closing resistance and including the effect on c - 3.5
2.0
~ 1.0
2.0
i thick, and the sheath resistivity was set to p = 1.0xlO·5 Om to
::i 1.0 account for the wrapping pitch. A 10.5 inch pipe with a 0.25
..:
• 0.0 •..•._..._ .._ . .....
inch wall thickness was used; for the pipe a p = 14xlO·8 Om
~ was used. It was assumed that all shields and the pipe were
.1.01------1
continuously grounded.
-2.0
The cable was energized using the simple power
system, shown in Fig. 7. The energizing was done with a
2.0
variety of cable models, including traveling wave and pi-cir-
::i 1.0 1 -_ _---, cuit models. A decision must be made about the number of
..: pi-sections to be used in the model, and the equations from
• 0.0 --.----.
j the preceding section can assist in making the choice. For
·1.0 the pipe-type cable, the positive sequence propagation con-
stant is Y1- 3.75xlO·3/km, and the zero sequence propagation
o 10 20 30
constant is Yo -7.28xlO-3/km . Based on these values, for the
Timc, l'hS
surge impedance of the pi-circuit to be within 10% of the cor-
Fig. 5. Voltage At OpenEndOf Line on Energization withTrapped Charge rect value, the pi-circuit section lengths must be less than 239
km based on positive sequence parameters and less than 123
3.2 ENERGIZATION OF PIPE-TYPE CABLE km based on zero sequence. Therefore, the surge impedance
requirements have little impact on the pi-section length for
Aim.:. To determine the maximum overvoltages in the cable. this short cable . Next, suppose it was desired that the one
way phase shift error be less than one radian at a frequency of
3.2.1 Phenomena 900 Hz. Then, based on the positive sequence parameters 14
pi-sections would be required for the 20 km cable . For the
As in the case of overhead transmission line energization, the zero sequence parameters, 38 pi-sections would be required
overvoltage in the cable is a function of the point on wave of for this same phase error! A 15 section model was actually
4-7
used. In addition, a 3 section model was used to see the
effect of using only a small number of sections. tr'8.vellins we-ve
83454 83451
3.
HIN 1
20 km Hour 1
Cable
Q2
~
c- o.
-3.
4-8
3.3.1 Phenomena
8 1384 8 1381
3.3.2 Model
Cable Model HIN HOUT
A 138 kV solid dielectric cable with the geometry
shown in Fig. 10 was modelled.The three cables were Traveling wave model with 60 2.05 2.20
installed 1.2 m underground with a 25 cm horizontal spacing Hz parameters
between the conductors. The lead sheath was grounded at 15 section pi-circuit model with 2.00 2.15
only one end, and the sheaths were crossbonded at 1000 m 60 Hz parameters
intervals.
3 section pi-circuit model with 2.00 2.15
60 Hz parameters
Ground Surface
Traveling wave model with 1.95 2.10
1000 Hz parameters
G
0 .85 inch
insulati on 15 section pi-circuit model with 2.00 2.15
~ = 2 .3
500 mm 2 conductor
1000 Hz parameters
1.031 inc h diameter 1.2 m
Table 4: Overvoltages when 138 kV cross bonded cable is energized.
0palyethe
. 11 inch
lene
Jacket 0 0 0
The breaker pole closing times were recorded that
-i
0 .11 inch lead resulted in the largest overvoltages at the open end of the
cable when the 60 Hz traveling wave model was used. Then,
~
h eath
25 em
138SD.GCD deterministic simulations were run with several cable models
using these closing times . The resulting waveforms for the
Fig. 10. 138kV SO cable. 60 Hz models is shown in Fig . 12. As can be seen, all the
waveforms are very similar, probably because there is little
The circuit for energizing the 138 kV cable was high frequency content in the switching surge waveform.
approximately the same as used for the 345 kV HPFF cable,
t r av el l i n g wave
except of course the voltage levels had to be changed, and 2.
some changes had to be made in the equipment. A typical
138 kV compact design overhead line was used, and the ~ 0 .
autotransformer was turned around, with 230 kV used for the
high side transformer voltage . The transformer size was also
reduced to 100 MVA A sketch of the energizing circuit is -2 .
shown in Fig. 11. In the several cases simulated, various dif- 2 .
15 p i - s e c t i ons
ferent models, pi-section as well as distributed parameter
models were used for the cable.
~ o.
3.3.3 Simulation Results
-2.
A series of statistical energizing simulations were
:3 p i - se c t i o n s
done, and the maximum overvoltages are shown in Table 4. 2 .
As can be seen, the values obtained with the 60 Hz models
are very close to each other. The 1000 Hz values are also o.
consistent, and, unlike the HPFF cable, the 1000 Hz values
are very close to those obtained at 60 Hz. Therefore, the fre-
quency dependent model may not be necessary for the SD so.
cable. mi l l i sec o n ds
Fig. 12. Overvoltages whenenergizing 138kV SO cable with various60 Hz
models.
4-9
The deterministic simulations were then rerun using
the 1000 Hz cable models. The results are shown in Fig. 13. HIN 1 HOUT 1
As can be seen, for the SD cable there is not as much differ- o-e-e-------'-.;....;;;.,)-c
ence between the 60 Hz and 1000 Hz results as there was for J
HIN 2 HOUT 2
the pipe-type cable. Again, this would seem to indicate that o-e-e---------)-c
the frequency dependent model is not as important for the SD J
cable as it is for the pipe-type.
2.
:::::::I
c- o. Fig. 14. Circuit used to apply pulse to one cable phase.
-2.
travelling wave
15 pi-sections 3.
2.
:::::::I 1 •
0..
:::::::I
c- o.
- 1 •
-2.
100 pi-sections
3 pI-sectIons 3.
2.
:::::::I 1 •
0..
:::::::I
c- o.
- 1 •
-2 0 . 50. 15 pi-sections
milliseconds 3.
Fig. 13. Results of energizing 138 SD cable with various 1000 Hz models.
:::::"
0.. 1.
3.3.4 Simulations for a High Frequency UnitStep
4-10
receiving end circuit breaker after clearing a fault.
travelling wave
3.
3.4.1 Phenomena
:=1
c.. 1 • Consider the circuit in Fig. 17 which shows a fault
fed from a single line "L", which in turn is fed by a bus with
substantial capacity and seven connected long transmission
- 1 •
lines.When a fault at the remote end of a transmission line is
100 pi-sections cleared, the receiving end voltage at the remote end oscillates
3.
with a half period equal to the travel time of the line. The
peak magnitude in the lossless case, can be up to twice the
::::s 1 •
c.. sending end voltage at the instant of fault clearing. This volt-
age now appears as the TRV across the open breaker. In the
- 1 • actual case, the slope and magnitude of the TRV is dependent
pi-sections
on the damping present in the system.
15
3 .
3.4.2 Model
:=1
c.. 1 •
The network equivalent (Fig. 18) is of type c) pre-
sented in section 2 2.7. The inductance value is obtained
- 1 • from the short circuit current (30 kA) at the bus. The parallel
3.
3 pi-sections resistance is the combined surge impedance (parallel combi-
nation) of the 7 unfaulted lines. This representation is appro-
priate because the lines are long and no reflections affect the
::::s 1 • protective device during the transient period under consider-
c..
ation. Note that as the fundamental frequency impedance of
the source (7.04 mH x 377 rad/s) is much smaller than the
-1 0. 2. equivalent parallel impedance of the transmission lines
milliseconds
(51.57 Q), the warning in section 2 2.7 does not apply. How-
Fig. 16. Results from pulse energizing for 138 kV SO cable with various
ever, when considering unbalanced faults, a full model may
1000 Hz models.
be necessary.
The following general conclusions can be drawn
from the switching studies presented in subsections 3.2 Line"L"
F
(HPFF cable) and 3.3 (SD cable):
For both the HPFF and SD cable, when statistical
energizings are done, it appears that either a constant parame-
ter traveling wave or a pi-circuit model can be used. The
overvoltage results are similar with either model. In addi- Multiple Lines
tion, the overvoltage waveform does not appear to have
much frequency content at 1000 Hz or above, so the number
of pi-sections used for modeling can be evaluated at 1000 Hz
or below. Fig. 17. System for Simulating Single-line Fed Bus Fault
model for switching surge simulations Fig. 18. Equivalent Circuit for System in Fig. 17
3.4 SINGLELINE BUS FED TRANSIENT RECOVERY The line "L" is represented as a low-frequency loss-
VOLTAGE (TRV) less line with lumped resistance at the midpoint and at the
end of the line. For a 138 kV substation, the available fault
Aim.:. To fmd the Transient Recovery Voltage (TRY) across a current at the main bus is 30 kA and 3.7 kA at the fault loca-
4-11
tion. Circuit parameters were selected for a 795 MCM line of mined by the leakage inductance of the transformer and the
length 40 km to the fault location with a surge impedance of effective source impedance as shown in Fig. 20. At the same
360 ohms. time, the transformer secondary-side voltage collapses to
zero, dropping the bus voltage (reduced from its pre-fault
Lumped bus capacitance of 10000 pF is represented value due to the fault) across the leakage inductance of the
at the supply station while 600 pF, which is typical for a transformer. When the fault is cleared, the source-side bus
small substation, is represented at the station at the end of the voltage recovers in an oscillatory fashion with a frequency
line determined by the source inductance and its equivalent
capacitance. If the transformer is located at the end of a line,
3.4.3 Simulation Results the source-side bus voltage will attempt to recover to the pre-
fault voltage level through a ramp, and overshoot. This sets
Fig. 19 shows the resultant bus voltage, fault cur- up a damped "oscillation" on the source side of the protective
rent, and protective device transient recovery voltage. The device with a period determined by the positive- and zero-
protective device recovery voltage is a ramp whose magni- sequence travel times of the line. For short lines the source
tude, neglecting damping, would be 2 times 0.88 per unit inductance dominates, reducing the magnitude of oscillations
(since about 12% of the voltage is dropped across the source that occur at a higher frequency. The voltage on the trans-
impedance during the fault), or 1.76 per unit; circuit damping former side of the switch collapses to zero in an oscillatory
would reduce this by about 5 to 10%. The time-to-peak of the fashion with a frequency determined by the leakage reac-
recovery voltage is the round-trip travel time of a voltage tance of the transformer and its equivalent terminal capaci-
wave on a single line supplying the fault. The rate-of-rise of tance. The resulting switch transient recovery voltage rate-
the voltage ramp is determined by the product of the surge of-rise is very steep with a substantial peak value (see Fig.
impedance of the line and the rate-of-change of the fault cur- 22).
rent. Since the first peak is typically reached in only a few
hundred microseconds, the rate-of-change of a symmetrical
fault current can be considered constant and equal to
Jilt» .It should be noted that the TRV for a three phase to 138 kV/13.8 kV
80MVA
ground fault would vary significantly from that for a three 10.7°k Z
Faultcurrent
20
:;-
l:!!-
Ie
eD -20
~~ -60
~§
¥ (J -100
11:=
~::s
l~ -140 Fault
-gal
Switchtransientrecoveryvoltage
: -180
::s Fig. 21. The Equivalent Circuit for the Case in Fig. 20
£D
-220
3.5.2 Model
Fig. 19. Bus Voltage, Switch Recovery Voltage and Fault Cur-
rent for a Single-line Fed Bus Fault.
To illustrate the transient recovery voltage that
occurs across the primary-side protective device when a
3.5 TRANSFORMER SECONDARY-FAULT TRV (WITH
transformer secondary fault is cleared, consider the system in
PRIMARY-SIDE PROTECTIVE DEVICE)
Fig. 27 (Case D). Assume that a fault occurs on the second-
ary side of the 80 MVA 138 kV/13.8 kV radially fed trans-
Aim.:. To fmd the TRV on the circuit breaker on the primary
former. Based on the 10.7% transformer impedance, the
side of a transformer after it clears a secondary side fault.
inherent 3-phase fault current of the transformer is approxi-
mately 3.1 kA. Because of the source and line impedances,
3.5.1 Phenomena
the 3-phase secondary-fault current magnitude is further lim-
ited to about 1.0 kA. To simulate the protective device tran-
When a fault occurs on the secondary-side of a
sient recovery voltage, the transformer can be represented as
transformer, the relatively large leakage inductance of the
shown in Fig. 21. Transformer terminal capacitances are cal-
transformer will limit the magnitude of the fault current
culated from the transformer oscillation frequency when a
through the primary-side protective device. When the fault
fault on the one side of the transformer is cleared from the
occurs, the source-side bus voltage drops to a level deter-
4-12
other side. Representative frequencies for power transform- 3.5.3 Simulation Results
ers are reported by Hamer and Rodriguez [24]. For the 138-
kV winding, the frequency of oscillation is approximately 9.6 Fig. 22 shows the transient recovery voltage for the
kHz, while that of the 13.8-kV winding is approximately switching device, the source-side and transformer-side volt-
72 .3 kHz. The high-frequency capacitive coupling ratio ages, and the 138 kV substation bus voltage for interrupting a
(i.e., Ch t / ( Chi + CI) ) is generally lower than 0.4 and was fault on the secondary side of the transformer.
4-13
the capacitor bus with a magnitude that can approach twice The highest transient voltages, on a per unit basis, occur at the
the peak bus voltage prior to energization. The characteristic lower voltage capacitance (C2) during capacitor C1 energiza-
frequency of the energization transient is: tion when (1) the capacitive Mvar rating of C 1 is significantly
j= 1 greater than that of C2 and (2) the natural frequencies fi and h
2rcJLsC (as defined below) are nearly equal.
4-14
tant, as they have the potential for exciting transformer inter- Because both the chart and hand calculation methods do not
nal resonances. include the effects of system losses, loads, or transmission
As with other capacitor switching related transients, lines, the arrester energy requirements determined by them
these transients can be reduced by the use of synchronous will be conservatively, but not excessively, high. The most ac-
closing control, pre-insertion resistors, or pre-insertion curate method of determining arrester energy requirements
inductors. during capacitor breaker restrike is to simulate the restrike
event using a detailed transient model. The transient simula-
3.6.5 Capacitor Breaker Restrike Arrester Energy Duty tion should model the system in detail at least two busses in
each direction from the capacitor.
Arresters applied at large shunt capacitors should be evaluat- It has been reported that the energy handling capa-
ed for their energy duty during capacitor breaker restrike. This bility of an arrester during capacitor restrike is significantly
is true even when the capacitor breakers are designed to be less than the published arrester energy handling capability.
"restrike free." Some derating of arrester energy ratings may be required
There are several methods of determining arrester because of the high magnitude currents which may be associ-
energy requirements during the first capacitor breaker ated with capacitor restrike transients. The arrester manufac-
restrike. The energy during subsequent restrikes can be much turer should be consulted to determine the level of arrester
higher, but is usually not considered when sizing arresters. energy derating, if any, is necessary.
The chart shown in Fig. 24 [25] can be used to determine
arrester energy duty based on arrester protective level and
capacitor size. Hand calculations which include the effects of 3.6.6 Inrushfrom Another Capacitor During Energization
capacitor size, can be used to more accurately determine
arrester energy requirements. The equations for hand calcu- The inrush currents associated with back-to-back
lating arrester energy during restrike of a grounded capacitor capacitor switching must be evaluated with respect to the
is shown below. The details of the hand calculation for both capacitor switch capabilities and overvoltages on CT second-
grounded and ungrounded capacitor can be found in [25]. aries. A circuit illustrating back-to-back switching is shown
in Fig. 25.
The equations for calculating current magnitude and
frequency are shown below.
(joules)
I = Vel f = I x f =~
where: C = Capacitor Capacitance (farads) z ' 2n~Leq x Ceq' 2nL eq
Vp = Arrester Protective Level (volts)
Vs = Peak Line-to-Ground Voltage (volts) where: VCl=Voltage across Cl as switch closes
Ll, L2 = Self Inductances of Capacitor Banks
L3 = Inductance between Capacitor Banks
10.0
Z =Surge Impedance = J~eq, L eq =L1 + L2 + L3,
DUTY eq
1.5
[
Mvar
p~r ]
Cap
5.0
4-15
the equation for Ixfabove as shown below and using peak
pre-switch current and voltage values:
S~stem Breaker
L = Vel
eq 2JZ(Ixf)
CiT JC2
VCl 1 VCl
1= Z ,f= 21t rrc-' Ixf= -
Aj~eq'-'eq 21tL
-
eq
Z= SurgeImpedance = ~,
~~ S~5tem
Leq = L1 + L3, Ceq = C1
L = Vel
eq 2 JZ(Ix f)
faul t
3.6.8 Additional Concerns
L3
In addition to the capacitor switching phenomena
listed above, which will be illustrated in the example later in
this paper, there are two other capacitor switching phenom-
ena that should be considered. The fITst is dynamic overvolt- Ll
I~
age. Dynamic overvoltage may occur when energizing a
capacitor and transformer simultaneously during fault clear-
ing and line re-energization. During line faults, even if the
capacitors are normally switched separately, the bus trans- Cl
former and capacitor bank may be de-energized and subse-
quently reenergized together with the line. The resulting long
term, low magnitude, but high energy, overvoltage cannot be
effectively limited by surge arresters. It must be controlled
Fig. 26. CircuitIllustratingOutrush Switching
by using an acceptable switching scheme.
4-16
Another concern when switching shunt capacitor 13.8 kV transformer located at the 138 kV equivalent bus.
banks is internal overvoltages at remote transformers. These All three capacitors are grounded.
overvoltages are a function of the switching transient and
Loads: Two loads are modeled, each half the peak system
transformer internal resonance characteristics. Transformer
load. Both are modeled as parallel resistance and inductance
terminal arresters may not adequately protect for this condi-
elements. The first load (90 +j40 MYA) is modeled at the 138
tion. Possible solutions include (1) capacitor switch pre-
kV equivalent source bus. This load contains series as well as
insertion resistors or reactors and (2) capacitor bank reactors.
parallel components to represent the impedances of trans-
formers not explicitly modeled. The load fed from this bus is
3.6.9 The Model
assumed to have a uncorrected power factor of about 90% and
a corrected power factor of 100% when both 40 Mvar capac-
A one line diagram of a three-phase transient model
itors are in service. This full load condition is represented by
assembled to illustrate capacitor switching phenomena is
parallel resistive and reactive loads of 180 Mvars (105.8
shown in Fig. 27. The individual components of the model
ohms) and 80 Mvars (238.05 ohms) respectively. Full load is
are discussed below.
represented by half this load when one 40 Mvar capacitor is in
Source: The system source is modeled as an ideal voltage service or to be switched into service.
source behind a system equivalent impedance. The equivalent The second load (1.8 + jl.8 MYA) is modeled on the
impedance consists of both positive and zero sequence induc- low side of the 138/13.8 kV transformer located at the same
tance and resistance. The ideal voltage source magnitude is equivalent source bus. This load has an uncorrected power
set so that the 138 kV bus voltage prior to capacitor energiza- factor of 70.7% and a corrected power factor of unity. With a
tion will be 1.025 pu. The actual magnitude can vary depend- 3.6 Mvar capacitor placed at this bus, this means that the
ing upon system loading and capacitor operating procedures. resistive and reactive components of the load at this bus are
In this case the positive sequence equivalent impedance is 5.8 both equal to 3.6 Mvars (52.9 ohms).
ohms reactive and 0.58 ohms resistive and the zero sequence Load modeling is very important because loads help
system equivalent impedance is 5.0 ohms reactive and 0.50 attenuate and damp out capacitor switching transients. Simu-
ohms resistive. This results in a 138 kV bus three phase fault lations with no loads modeled will produce transients that are
current of approximately 13.7 kA and a single line-to-ground much higher than those found on the actual system. Simi-
fault current of approximately 14.3 kA. larly, models with the entire load modeled at higher voltage
busses rather than dispersed at lower voltage busses will sim-
ulate transients lower than those on the actual system.
Because of the limited size of the model used to illustrate
_-+-_SOURC
capacitor switching phenomena, accurate load modeling is
not possible. The model would have to be expanded about
EQ138 two busses out in all directions to model loads with reason-
able accuracy. To help compensate for this, loads half the size
ofthose described above are placed at the appropriate busses.
In a real study the effect of load modeling and
model size must be analyzed. The best way to optimize the
size and detail of a model is to keep adding to the modeled
area until the transients are no longer affected by additional
components. Because this can be time consuming, rules of
thumb, such as modeling the system one or two busses from
all locations of interest, are often used when assembling tran-
LOAD sient model.
TRTER
TransfQnners: Two transformers are modeled. They both in-
~ ~ TR138 clude 138/13.8 kV transformations, but their locations and
40 MVar 40 MVar
13.8 kV winding configurations are different. The transformer at the
Fig. 27. One Line Diagram of Transient Model equivalent source bus is an 18 MYA rated three winding
transformer with primary (138 kV) and secondary (13.8 kV)
Capacitors: Three capacitors are modeled. There are two 40 grounded wye windings and a delta tertiary (4.8 kV). The
Mvar (5.571 microfarad) capacitors located at the 138 kV high, low, and tertiary impedances are represented as 39.44%,
equivalent source bus. These capacitors are each equipped 0.01%, and 17.78% on a 100 MYA base. The transformer XI
with 0.15 mH reactors to limit back-to-back switching cur- R ratio was assumed to be 20. Saturation was modeled with a
rents and a common 1 mH reactor to limit outrush currents. knee point of approximately 1.15 pu. The remote transformer
How these reactor sizes were determined is presented in sub- is an 80 MYA rated two winding transformer with grounded
section 3.6.10. The third capacitor (3.6 Mvars or 50.10 wye primary (138 kV) and delta secondary (13.8 kV) wind-
microfarads) is located on the low voltage side of the 138/ ings. The transformer impedances is 10.7% on its 80 MYA
4-17
base. Half this impedance is modeled on each winding . The
transformer X/R ratio was assumed to be 20. Saturation was
200 kV
modeled with an approximately 1.2 pu knee.
Fault Model ' The fault model used in the outrush simula-
tions is a 0.1 milliohm resistance in series with an ideal 20 kV
switch. When the fault is initiated, the switch is closed and
when the fault is cleared the switch is opened.
Capacitor Energization: Capacitor energization was simu - As discussed before, for voltage magnification to
lated to demonstrate three different phenomena. The first is occur, there must be two circuits resonant at about the same
the transient overvoltage at the switched capacitor location. resonant frequency. The first circuit is usually the source
The second is voltage magnification at a lower voltage impedance and switched capacitor and the second is usually
capacitor. The third is phase-to-phase overvoltage at a trans- a low voltage capacitor and a transformer. The resonant fre-
former terminated line. quency of the first circuit in this example is 544 .1 Hz as
The capacitor energizing simulation used 100 statis- shown below . The 138 kV 40 Mvar capacitor has a capaci-
tical switching events to determine the worst case overvolt- tance of 5.571 j.l.F and the system equivalent positive
age . With the half load model, the worst overvoltage sequence impedance has a inductance of 15.39 mH (5.800
simulated at the 138 kV capacitor location was 1.805 pu (Fig. Q) .
28). This transient's peak value was 2.032 pu in the no load
case and 1.695 pu in the full load case.
f, - 1 _ 1 = 544.IHz
1 - 2fffLC - 2~15.36mHx5 .571,tF
4-18
1 1 Juu kV
f = = = 5416Hz
2 2tNLC 2;r,j1.71lmH x50.l,tF
200 leV
400 kV
200 kV
o kV-f---'<---+f-t-
-300 leV
4-19
Figure 5. In this case the reactor size was calculated to be
0.942 mH, as shown below.
300 kJ
okJ .J...-..-t-----+--+-~-_t_-_+__-+_____t-__+_-.....; An outrush reactor value of 1.0 mH was used to simulate this
.885 .81 .815 .82 .8Z5
Seconds event. This simulation gave a peak current (first current peak)
Fig. 33. ArresterEnergyDuringBreakerRestrike of 1,966 amps at a frequency of9,454 Hz. This results in an I
xfproduct of 1.86 x 107, which is below the 2.0 x 107 limit.
Capacitor InDlsh During Back-to-Back Switching· The con-
cern during back-to-back switching is that capacitor inrush 3.7 SERIES CAPACITOR SWITCHING
currents will exceed breaker ratings. The magnitude and fre-
quency of the inrush current can exceed breaker capabilities Series capacitors may be installed on transmission
if the impedance between the two capacitors is too low. lines to increase power transfer capability. Electromagnetic
Breakers applied between two capacitor banks at a single bus transient studies are required to determine the impact of the
are usually definite purpose breakers. According to Table 3A series compensation on the existing system to ensure safe
of ANSI/IEEE C37.06, the product of the breaker current and reliable operation.
magnitude and frequency must be less than 6.8 x 107 (16 kA ~To evaluate several aspects of system performance,
times 4250 Hz) for definite purpose breakers. including the following:
An equation for calculating the inductance neces- Surge Arrester Sjzjng· Establish surge arrester duty and
sary to limit the I x f product to an acceptable level was given related protection settings for the capacitor bank.
in subsection 3.6.6. With Vmax equal to the peak line-to- Line Protection· Investigate relay requirements.
ground voltage, times a conservative 1.05 pu voltage, the Line Breaker Transient Recoyery Voltage (TRY)· Deter-
mine the transient recovery voltage for the transmission
inductance necessary to meet the 6.8 x 107 breaker rating can
line breakers of the compensated line.
be calculated to be 0.277 mH or 0.139 mH per capacitor as
Line Energization· Investigate system behavior when the
shown below. Some of this inductance may be supplied by
compensated line is energized.
the buswork between the two capacitors. Buswork rated for
Bank Insertion and Bypass· Investigate system behavior
use on 138 kV systems is usually considered to have an
when the series capacitor is bypassed or inserted.
inductance of 0.9 JlH per meter.
Single-phase Reclosing· Determine line end arrester
duty for single-phase reclosing operation.
L= Vmax = 118.3lkV = 0.277mH Simulated events include varying size and location
21Z{I x f) 21Z{6.8x 10 7 ) of the series capacitor. However, these are generally deter-
mined by steady-state, transient stability and subsynchronous
Back-to-back capacitor switching inrush currents are inde- resonance studies and by relaying requirements which are
pendent of load or nearby system components. Inrush currents not applicable to this document. Additionally, minimum and
were simulated with a with a 0.15 mH reactor in series with maximum generator conditions may also be considered.
each 40 Mvar 138 kV capacitor. This resulted in a peak cur-
rent of 12 kA at a frequency of5.5 kHz, giving an Ix/product 3.7.1 Model
of 6.6 x 107, below the 6.8 x 107 limit.
Fig. 34 shows a representative system to be studied.
The system model typically includes lines and transformers
Capacitor Outmsh into a Fault The concern during capaci- at least one bus back from the switching locations of interest.
tor outrush into a fault is again breaker I x / ratings, but Transmission lines are modeled as distributed parameter
because the fault current may go through a general purpose lines considering their positive and zero sequence character-
breaker rather than a defmite purpose breaker, the breaker I x istics. Transformers are modeled using the saturable trans-
frating will probably be a much lower 2.0 x 107 rather than former component model which represents each winding of
the transformer as well as its saturation characteristics. One
6.8 x 107. The equation derived in subsection 3.6.7 can be
bus away are equivalent sources modeled as mutually-cou-
used, but the I x f product will be different and the reactor
pled elements considering their positive and zero sequence
must placed so that the fault current discharged from both
characteristics. Series capacitors and other system compo-
capacitors will have to flow through the reactor to get to the
nents are modeled as lumped circuit elements with typical
main bus, as shown between busses CAP40 and CPOUT in
quality factors represented. Also pertaining to series capaci-
4-20
tor modeling are its associated components such as the should be simulated under varying power flow and other
bypass breaker with its series reactor and the surge arrester operating conditions. The bypass switch TRV is evaluated
connected across the series capacitor. The surge arrester from the simulation of capacitor bank insertion. The simula-
model uses the 36x90 us voltage-current characteristic, tion of capacitor bypass determines the inrush currents.
Results are compared to the withstand ratings at the breaker
3.7.2 Phenomena and Simulation Results and its series reactor.
The worst case fault conditions that keep the capac- Waveforms of sample results are shown 5 for these
itor bank inserted determine the maximum surge arrester switching transients cases:
energy requirements. The case list includes three-phase, dou-
ble-phase and single-phase faults. Also considered are sin- i ) Single-Phase Fault, Clearing, and Reclosing (Fig. 35)
gle-phase reclosing events under fault conditions: the line ii) Three-Phase Fault at Middle of Line and Clearing (Fig.
end breakers open on the faulted phase only to clear the fault, 36 and Fig. 37)
and then one end recloses. iii) Series Capacitor Bank Insertion (Fig. 38)
BUS 1 BUS2
115KV 115KV
69KV
69KV
4-21
:~ :~I
'~ ~~~!A~ 1:] . . : .. ; .. : :
:'1iFiIr-
'~ J :::::.:::.
0Jl0~ o..oor.. . . ·.", "' . . ·.·.. . . . . . . · O.llOJ
~
. : : :~
: .: : : : : ~1 : : : : : : : : : : t:
0..00
.1llO •.••
Bus 2 115 kV [pu]
• • •• ••
ILQDJINII ..,".',\\y.tNItYo ~ ,
-a.IlO • • • ••
Capacitor Current ll'u -Irated]
• • • • • ~
0.00
j~----------
• •• • . • •• .•
: ~ :jW/N'~' , :j~
:~ :] ·······... =]1.--_
:~~]
4.00 I •
0..00
~j i • i i
a2S
• , , '.
OJll 0Jl0
j iii iii
a2S
iii
lI.5O
I~;::=;r=;::=;r=;=r=r=r=;=::;
0..00
I
Q.2S
j f\ ~ ~ ~ : PdtANIJ./ . .
Bus 1 115 kV [pu] Capacitor Voltage [pu-Vrated]
:}fA~~~~~AAI\
:
~t-J1MM ~L1llJi ·
V\TV~VV \{\[v
~~
~Jf\fJ"lVVoJIMP
. Ii'
0.0
I • I
0.1
' , iii
lU
I
0.0
I , i i j
0.1
, • , i I
lU
Ii
0.0
. i ii
0.1
. .• I
0.2
Time in Seconds Time in Seconds Tim e in Seconds
Fig. 36. Simulation Results: Three-Phase Fault at Middle of Line and Clearing
4-22
!J~er ~ [pu].
. . . .
.
"
. . . .
o
,.
·2 . .
B~!=r ~ghtlpu] .
0+---------------- -,-;.
·2
.. ,,--i--T-,;-;,-r---;-';-;'--+--;-i---r-r--r-;;-T--;-"';'-;-;--T-';-;'--i--+-';-;'--+---;-;--;'--+-";-;--;---+-";-i---r-i
i i i I i
a.ooo O.CW O.ll5O cum 0.100 0.12'
Time In Seconds
:JNvVNrNVV. ::]
1~1 '
f\f\f\/\f\f\f\f\f\/\
::: ] .A~WM~A o.33::'J
'1.00 ] . V. . . . . . . .o.~
i\~i\~A~AA/»:J
]
.
A 1\/\ 1\ /\ 1\ 1\ /\ 1\
\fIrV\TVVV . V
AI\I\I\I\/\/\/\/
.: VlJ VVV V\TV ~ J VV V V V vVvlJ ] \JVV\J\) V \TV\)
'$p
.\ .00
A
o.»~
: j"A"AA""AAj
.:J lfVVITVVVV\",,: J ~
VV VVlJ \[\{\TVlJ
0.730 ] . f\ . f\ ' f\ ' ] . .
:YII
] V ~
=====
~1~ 0.00
4-23