You are on page 1of 2

the condensation of oxygen in cold traps).

I would like to imental observations that led to the formulation of quantum


add that substances hazardous to health, such as Na/Pb mechanics. This is followed by 140 pages on vector space and
alloys (p. 8) or chromic acid (p. 75) should no longer be used function space, matrix algebra, operator algebra, etc. After
in a modern research laboratory, and should be replaced by this come several chapters in which the postulates of quan-
more suitable drying and cleaning agents. Chapter 2 (The tum mechanics are introduced and the usual model problems
main vacuum line) can be considered the heart of the book. are treated (particle in a box, harmonic oscillator, the hydro-
It contains detailed descriptions of the building and running gen atom, etc.). The Hamiltonian operator for molecular
of a high-vacuum line. After a short overview, the individual systems is discussed in considerable detail, including the ef-
components of this equipment (pumps, cold-traps, taps, fects of external magnetic fields as well as relativistic effects.
valves, manometers) are described and compared. The read- The final chapter of the book contains an equally detailed
er thereby obtains important advice on which device best treatment of the approximate methods that are commonly
suits each situation. Here too, Plesch succeeds in giving the used in quantum chemistry, such as the closed- and open-
reader the experience he has gained from many years of shell Hartree-Fock SCF approximations, perturbation theo-
working with high-vacuum techniques. Even apparently ry and configuration interaction.
minor particulars, like the correct greasing of ground glass The overall impression is of a sound and competently
connections, are not to be underestimated in practice. Practi- written book. Explanations are given of many points that are
cal advice of this kind makes the book useful reading mate- not often covered in comparable textbooks; for example,
rial for every diploma or PhD research student who needs to there are discussions of the Rayleigh-Schrodinger and Bril-
use some form of vacuum technique. After the construction louin-Wigner perturbation theories, of methods of calculat-
of the vacuum line the sometimes laborious task of detecting ing lower limits for the energy, and of such details as the
leaks is discussed. In Chapter 3 (Applications and proce- origin of the s,p,d. . . nomenclature for atomic orbitals. Nev-
dure) countless specialized apparatus and additional pos- ertheless, there is some doubt as to whether the book entirely
sible applications for high-vacuum techniques are described. succeeds in the ambitious aim of presenting the complex
Plesch gives particular attention to the filling and melting of mathematical background in a form which is both detailed
glass phials. Much of this equipment (burettes, dilatometers, and comprehensible to the student. Too often one finds that
viscometers, calorimeters, etc.) is useful, but some, in my proofs and theorems are glossed over, and the reader is re-
view, is a little too exotic (e.g., on page 93, the device for ferred, in one of the many footnotes, to the original litera-
simultaneous filling of several dilatometers). On the other ture. Also the mathematics is presented without directly re-
hand the section on NMR measurements (p. 96) is a little too lating it to applications, and one suspects that many students
short. Sealing NMR tubes under vacuum should be a routine will consequently feel that this part of the book is an unap-
operation for any advanced graduate student. However, I pealing and barren slog.
consider the making of NMR tubes (p. 97) a waste of time. It is also regrettable that the discussion of quantum-me-
Chapter 4 (Purification, including drying) contains countless chanical computational methods is not always completely
useful tips for practical work. Every synthetic chemist will up-to-date. New developments such as the use of direct SCF
daily encounter problems with cleaning and drying reagents methods for calculations on large molecules or of natural
and solvents. A book about potential applications of vacu- atomic orbital basis sets are not described. In the discussion
um techniques would therefore be incomplete without advice of the multiconfigurational SCF approach one searches in
on drying glass apparatus (p. 119) as well as degassing and vain for a mention of the CASSCF method that is now most
drying the solvent to be used. Thus, Section 4.6 (What is so commonly used; also the direct CI methods that have now
special about drying?) particularly is worth reading atten- become so important are treated rather too briefly. A further
tively. Chapter 5 concludes the book with a few syntheses example of the sometimes rather outdated treatment is the
and measurements, chosen to show the advantages of the comment by Christoffersen that the diagonalization of a
high-vacuum technique. 1000 x 1000 matrix takes several seconds of computation,
In the introduction P . H . Plesch defines the aim of the whereas fast modern computers can in fact perform
book: ”. . .to enable a chemist to assess the possible utility of such tasks in fractions of a second. This tendency towards
high-vacuum techniques for his purposes, to design and outdatedness is also reflected in the choice of literature
build a high-vacuum system, and to do good chemistry with references, which mostly come from the 1970s and early
it”. The author has succeeded in doing this. 1980s.
Frank T Edelmann [NB 1178 IE] It is also unfortunate that many printing errors have
Institut fur Anorganische Chemie found their way into the text, including some that are rather
der Universitat Gottingen (FRG) confusing. For example, “yield” has become “field”, a factor
of 1/2 has been omitted from one formula, and one suddenly
finds that instead of an external force one is dealing with an
“external face”. With monotonous regularity a trial wave-
function becomes a “trail” wave-function, and even the
Basic Principles and Techniques of Molecular Quantum Me- names of authors in the literature citations do not escape
chanics. By R. E. Christoffersen. Springer, Berlin 1990. xiv, distortion. A particularly annoying error is a reference to a
686 pp., hardcover DM 178.00.--ISBN 3-540-96759-1 figure at the end of Chapter 7, where one looks in vain for it;
it is not until four chapters later that one suddenly comes
This book is a comprehensive student text and work of across an identical paragraph, this time with the figure.
reference on the theoretical fundamentals of quantum chem- Blunders such as these could certainly have been avoided
istry and their practical applications. It differs from other with a little care.
books on this theme in several respects, including the amount However, if one leaves aside these deficiencies in the prep-
of space devoted to describing the mathematical basis of aration, the tendency towards outdatedness in some parts,
quantum-mechanical methods. and the fact that the planning of the mathematical part is
A brief introductory section reminds the reader of some of perhaps not entirely successful, Christoffersen’s book is an
the concepts of classical mechanics, and describes the exper- interesting addition to the range of textbooks on theoretical

Angrw. Cliem. In[. Ed. Engl. 30 (1991) No. I t 0 V C H Verlagqeselischufr mbH, W-6940 Wrinheim. 1991 OS70-0833/9I/111t-l523S S.SO+.ZS/O I523
chemistry, and is to be welcomed especially for its many- of redox reactions of N-0 compounds and the biological
faceted treatment of the subject. activity shown by many individual compounds. In the case
Wolfam Koch [NB 1116 IE] of the hydrazines the reason for the length is that the alkyl-
IBM Deutschland GmbH hydrazines have made a welcome appearance in the last
Heidelberg Scientific Center few decades; previously these could only be prepared with
Institute for Supercomputing and Applied Mathematics great difficulty by laborious alkylation of hydrazine or by
Heidelberg (FRG) reduction of nitrosamines, whereas they are now accessible
by a variety of interesting reactions, mainly by forming
N-N bonds. The lengths of these two chapters are therefore
justified. However, the lengths of some of the subsections are
Houben-Weyl. Methoden der Organischen Chemie. 4th Edi- not commensurate with the importance of the topics. Addi-
tion, supplementary volumes. Volume E 16a, Parts 1 and tion reactions of nitrones and olefins occupy 20 pages with
2: Nitrogen Compounds I. Edited by D.Klamann. Thieme, an enormous table, and the (admittedly interesting) criss-
Stuttgart 1990. Part 1: xxxvi, pp. 1-855; Part 2: xiv, cross cycloaddition of alkenes to hexafluoroacetone is given
pp. 856- 1516; hardcover DM 2100.00 (subscription a six-page table. Such comprehensive treatments of examples
price: DM 1890.00).-ISBN 3-1 3-218-604-X that are analogous should be left to specialized monographs.
The same also applies to the 16 pages with analogous exam-
The publishing house Thieme continues to press on with ples of Meerwein’s reaction of diazonium salts with alkenes
the work of updating the Houben-Weyl volumes written in in Part 2 of the work. On the other hand the work does not
the period from the 1950s to the 1980s, by publishing a give an up-to-date procedure for preparing solutions of
supplementary work which takes into account the latest state chloramine; the conventional procedure giving a yield of
of development on methods and the most recent literature. 30-40% (reproduced here on p. 250) can be improved to
In these two part volumes on organonitrogen compounds give reproducibly more than 90 ‘YOsimply by adding ammo-
they have again succeeded in an impressive way. nium chloride ( Z . Anorg. Allg. Chem. 396 (1973) 178).
This work again meets the aim (which has never been In the chapter on hydrazines it would have been useful in
explicitly stated) of not only giving an appropriate experi- a number of cases to indicate how precursors that are not
mental procedure for each special case, but also providing altogether commonplace can be prepared, for example, when
the reader who has not yet become a specialist in a particular describing the reduction of alkoxy(alky1)diazene-N-oxides
field with an introductory, but nevertheless thoroughly (p. 463). The usefulness of the method for preparing 1,2-di-
sound, overview of the possibilities. The reader may look up ethylhydrazine by reduction of the azo compound (p. 523)
a specific method and gain some additional information as a could be better appreciated if one knew whether it was pos-
result, or browse around the special problem of interest, or sible to make the azo compound by some route other than
again may read a few dozen pages almost in the manner of the reverse of the reaction described, i.e. by oxidation of di-
a textbook. Each of these types of readers will get good value ethylhydrazine. The interesting synthesis of arylhydrazines
from the work, helped by the information-packed and main- by acid hydrolysis of arylsydnones cannot give acetic acid as
ly well chosen subject matter, although not necessarily by the the secondary cleavage product, as is shown in the formula
arrangement of the contents, which follows an ever more on page 793. Also, the preparation of methylhydrazine from
rigid pattern. The strict adherence to the ten hierarchical methylamine (p. 426) should not be described as an oxida-
levels of classification sometimes results in an undue empha- tion.
sis on unimportant features, and often separates closely re- In Part 2 the long chapter on N-halogenated amines possi-
lated topics. For example, the closely similar procedures of bly puts too much emphasis on the preparation of pure com-
the N-alkylation of hydroxylamine and that of N-alkyl- pounds; it is more important to have straightforward meth-
hydroxylamines appear in different sections, as also do the ods for preparing well-defined solutions for use in further
entirely analogous methods used to synthesize mono- and reactions. This chapter is followed by the subject of C-nitro-
dihalogenated amines. so compounds, which obviously has a great many subdivi-
The limitation to work published during the last twenty to sions and requires no less than 129 headings in 47 pages of
thirty years, which is usually applied very consistently, some- text. In the description of the nitrosation of arenes it would
times results in an emphasis on procedures that have been have been desirable to show a clear division between those
overrated. Without actually copying “Beilstein” it would nitrosation reactions that are useful for synthetic purposes
have been useful to keep in mind the system used there, in (e.g. those of phenols) and the nitrosations of simple arenes
which the variety of routes to a class of compounds is shown such as benzene that have also been investigated. The chap-
under the heading “Bildungsweisen”, whereas under ter by J. Goerdeler on ammonium compounds is excellent;
“Darstellung” the more generally useful and perhaps less this describes the quaternization of amines of increasing in-
elegant method is chosen. The recommended procedures ertness on reaction with alkylating agents of increasing reac-
should always be rather more generally applicable than the tivity. A separate chapter is devoted to the hydrazinium
reactions described in between these. A welcome feature is compounds, which have only attained importance in recent
the caution that has been applied with regard to mecha- years. This is followed by the classical diazonium com-
nisms, avoiding unnecessary embellishments on this theme; pounds; as these have had a career of more than a hundred
in view of the need for “Houben-Weyl” to remain up-to-date years their preparation occupies less space (35 pp.) than their
for decades, speculations of that nature would be likely to reactions (49 pp.). Next come chapters on a few special
become obsolete more rapidly than the established facts. classes of compounds such as nitrosamines, triazenes and
The first of the two part volumes contains two very long tetrazenes; the work ends with a chapter on azides.
chapters on organic hydroxylamine compounds (395 pp.) Finally a few errors and incorrect usages need to be men-
and organic hydrazine compounds (435 pp.), together with tioned. On page 462 the statement that the pressure falls from
much shorter chapters on nitroxyl radicals, nitroxides and 73 694 torr to 60 765 torr is hardly in accord with the preci-
amino-oxides. The considerable length of the chapter on the sion of typical pressure measurements in the preparative lab-
hydroxylamines is no doubt due to the many different types oratory. Quoted values such as 101.87 kPa (p. 878) probably

1524 0 VCH Verlagsgesellschafi mbH, W-4940 Weinheim. 1991 0570-0833~9iIllil-~524$3.50+.2S/0Angew. Chem. Inr. Ed. Engl. 30 (1991) No. i l

You might also like