Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TPT PDF
TPT PDF
To cite this article: Dr. D. A. Sargent (1921) The Physical Test of a Man, American Physical
Education Review, 26:4, 188-194
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information
(the “Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor
& Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties
whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the
Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and
views of the authors, and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The
accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and should be independently
verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable
for any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages,
and other liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in
connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any
substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,
systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.
Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/
page/terms-and-conditions
188 AMERICAN PHYSICAL EDUCATION REVIEW
One of the strongest of the natural gravity to pull us down from our top-
forces with which man is constantly lofty, vertical position to a horizontal
contending is gravity, or the tendency plane. Vie pay our respect to this natural
of his body to be attracted and held to force by availing ourselves of every op-
the surface of the earth. The infant first portunity to lean, sit, and recline at our
crawls, then creeps on its hands and work throughout the day, and we finally
knees, and finally by the aid of crib or yield to it completely by assuming a
chair or mother's assistance, gets onto his horizontal position for sleep at night.
feet. The raising of the head, the Many of these bodily weaknesses and
straightening of the spine, grasping with imperfections to which I have referred
the hands and feet, and striking out and have arisen largely from civilized man's
kicking with the arms and legs are only neglect to care for the form and strength
preliminary movements necessary to pre- of his bodily mechanism as an African
Downloaded by [New York University] at 20:58 13 February 2015
pare for the standing position. All the Zulu or Sandwich Islander would do.
twisting, rolling, wriggling, squirming, Instead of priding himself upon his abil-
crawling, creeping, and occasional stiffen- ity to sit straight without support for his
ing and straightening of the trunk and spine and legs, as shown by many of the
limbs an infant can be induced to do, the savage tribesmen, civilized man luxu-
better it will be for his future develop- riates in upholstered chairs and lounges
ment. moulded- to his physical defects,-and
A child must first get a footing in the then wonders why he has a weak back
world and be able to move in the erect and can not stand in a vertical position.
position before the adult may properly Yet the ability to stand erect, thereby
function as a human being. In other relieving the arms and hands from sup-
words, the child must pass in a few porting the body, and conserving their
months from the animal stage of its strength to be directed into self-chosen
existence where all its organic inher- activities constitutes man's supreme in-
itances for thousands of years had fitted heritance.
its body to resist the force of gravity in How is this ability attained? By
a . horizontal plane, to a verticalposi- gradually 'strengthening and developing
tion where gravity acts iri a perpendicular. the muscles all up and down the front
plane. Is· it any wonder that over 75 and back of the trunk and legs. These
per cent of our youth of both sexes have muscles hold the body balanced in perfect
a bad posture, and that so few ever equilibrium over the .two feet, which, in
attain the ability to meet this compar- length and breadth taken together, av-
atively new strain-the ability to sit and erage about one-sixth the perpendicular
stand erect?
If there is any doubt as to the serious- height. When the body is thus accurately
ness of failing to measure up to this test balanced on the bones of the legs and
of young manhood, ask your physician as spine, gravity is acting parallel with these
to the fundamental causes of the follow- bones, and consequently the strain is
ing list of physical imperfections: spinal taken largely from the' muscles and
curvature, knock knees, bow legs, flat thrown onto the bones and ligaments.
feet, drooping head, round shoulders, If one relaxes from this vertical posi-
weak backs, varicose veins, hernia, sag- tion, and stands with the body flexed or
ging of the abdominal organs, misplace- ,bent forward at the knees, hips, back, and
ment of the' pelvic organs; and many neck, the strain is then brought upon the
other physical weaknesses and defects muscles and after a little while the effort
which afflict mankind. of standing becomes intolerable. But
These prevailing weaknesses are mainly strain or pain means loss of power and
due to the failure of the body to make energy. This is the reasoi. why a perfect
provision to resist this constant force of poise in standing or sitting is the most
THE PHYSICAL TEST OF A MAN 189
So, in theory at least, it may be well enough, goes through three stages in his
said in support of the relationship of career. The first one is where his prop-
bodily measurements and vital functions ositions are unfounded and absurd; the
"that the greater advance we may make second stage is where if proven true, they
in inquiries of this nature, the more per- are not original; and the third stage is
fectly is the law of proportion that gov- where they are so self-evident that any
erns the typical man demonstrated; ren- fool ought to have thought of them. I
dering it equally apparent how undue or have now arrived at the third stage in my
imperfect development of anyone organ career, and want to share what seems to
or function throws the remaining or- me the simplest and most effective of all
ganismout of gear, and constitutes a tests of physical ability with the other
greater or less tendency to disease." fools who have been looking for one.
In popular estimation it takes so many I have dwelt at some length upon gravity
inches and so many pounds and a certain as a constant force to be overcome and
size chest girth to make a man, and this its relation to the height and weight and
estimation is borne out largely by expe- other measurements of the body. The
rience. Hence, the universal interest in new test that I offer consists of using
the physical measurements of the human the constant factors of height and weight
body. However, those of us who are which one always has with him, in a little
engaged in making physical measure- different way than is commonly thought
ments of men by the thousand soon learn of. It is so simple and yet so effective
the limitations of the information which for testing the strongest man or weakest
comes to us from this source alone. woman or child that one feels almost like
While it is true that the strength and apologizing to the general public for
functional capacity of a part generally mentioning it.
increases with the size of that part, other
things being equal, the number of cases THE NEW TEST.
where other things are not equal is so
numerous that the generalization should The individual to be tested stands un-
be greatly modified. der a cardboard disk, or paper box cover,
The measurements alone do not tell us heavy and stiff enough to hold its form,
anything of the texture and quality of the about twelve inches in diameter, held or
parts covered, i.e., how much is fat or suspended from ten to twenty or more
bone, and how much muscle, nor do the inches above his head. He is then re-
measurements alone give us any informa- quested to bend forward, flexing the
tion of innervation of the parts, upon trunk, knees, and ankles, and then bv a
which power and efficiency so frequently powerful jump upward, straightening -the
depend. Even if we accept the physical legs and spine, to try to touch the card-
measurements of a man as an indication board disk with the top of the head.
of his potential power, as so many of us Swinging the bent arms forward and up-
THE PHYSICAL TEST OF A MAN 191
ward at the time the legs, back, and neck a good deal upon the length of the legs
are extended, will be found to add to and trunk that make up the total stature,
the height of the jump. When the disk the tall man being favored-therefore
has been placed at the highest point above an exact ratio of the height jumped to
the head that can be just touched in the stature would seem to make the test
jumping, this height is measured. The more equitable. Thus, if the man weigh-
difference between this height and that ing 150 pounds was 70 inches tall and
of the total stature is of course the height jumped 20 inches above his head, the
actually jumped. ratio of 20 to 70 would account for this
Now, if this height is multiplied into advantage in height. This ratio may be
the total weight of the body at the time obtained by the following formula:
of making the jump, it will give one some
idea of the amount of work done in foot Formula C=
pounds as usually calculated. But it will Height Jumped X 100 - 285
be observed, no credit is given for lifting Total Height - .
the full weight of the body from the deep
Although the formulse A, B, and C
knee or squatting position to the per-
Downloaded by [New York University] at 20:58 13 February 2015
TABLE. 1.
FIRST TEN OUT OF FOUR HUNDRED TESTED AT THE SARGENT SCHOOL OF PHYSICAL
EDUCATION, CAMBRIDGE, MASS.
Ratio
Jump Height Jump to Weight F. P. of
Class Age Inches Inches Height Ibs. Work Index
1. L.V.M. Jun. 20 20 67.5 .300 152 253 45.0
2. M.N.G. Sen. 20 20 61 .328 132 220 43.2
3. M.E.W. Sen. 20 20.5 65.5 .312 132 226 41.3
4. M.J.a. Jun. 20 18.8 60.2 .312 132 217 41.0
5. H.W. Sen. 22 15.3 64.2 .238 176 224 40.5
6. M.E.F. Fresh. 19 16.9 60.6 .260 145 204 40.5
7. J.1.]. Fresh. 23 14 68 '.206 196 240 40.3
8. E.M.B. Sen. 23 20.5 61.5 .333 117.5 200 39.1
9. H.A.B. Fresh. 23 16 68 .236 163 217 38.2
10. B. S. Fresh. 18 17.5 64.5 .271 146 213 38.0
Downloaded by [New York University] at 20:58 13 February 2015
product by 12) and has an energy index in height. As might be expected she
of 45. jumps the least height of any in the
No. 2 has an energy index of 43.2. group, and the least percentage of her
Although she is shorter and lighter than own height. But she projects 196 pounds
some of her 'mates and does less foot fourteen inches above her head and
pounds of work than four others in the thereby does 240 foot pounds of work,
group, she lifts her weight higher in pro- which makes her the second strongest
portion to her height, and therefore gets one on the list.
a high score. She is an earnest student No.8, although she lacks the mechan-
and a good all-round athlete, but not a ical advantage in height that a girl of 67
star. or 68 inches would possess, and has the
No. 3 is the star athlete of her class, least advantage in weight of any in the
excelling especially in running and jump- group, still manages to project her 117.5
ing. In this test she jumps 20.5 inches pounds 20.5 inches above her head, which
above her height, but she is 4.5 inches is the highest ratio of her own height
taller than No.2 and does not lift her of any in the group (.333). This girl is
weight as high in proportion to her quite strong for her height and weight and
height. very energetic-she also has the distinc-
No. 4 although of the same weight as tion of being the highest ranking scholar
Nos. 2 and 3, and jumping the same pro- in her class. The records of Nos. 9 and
portion of her height as the girl above
10 are self-explanatory. They are girls
her, does not jump as high and therefore
gets a little lower index. of fine natural physiques, good athletes,
No.5 jumps nearly five inches less superior to the average in height and
than those who have preceded her, but weight, and will show a much higher in-
she is a strong husky girl weighing 176 dex after a little more training.
pounds and to raise this weight a less I have commented upon the variations
height requires a high index. in physique as shown by the height and
No.6 has the same index as No.5, al- weight in these seven individuals, be-
though she is 3.13 inches shorter and cause these variations illustrate the com-
weighs 31 pounds less. She makes up pensating nature of the test. With a
for this difference in weight and height variation of 7.4 inches in height and 78.5
by jumping an inch and a half higher, and pounds in weight, there is little difference
jumping a greater per cent of her height. in their physical ability as shown by the
No.7 is the heaviest girl in the school, test, as all w-ere able to make the first
weighing 196 pounds, and is 68 inches ten in the school. What one lacks in
THE PHYSICAL TEST OF A MAN 193
T H IS series of seven large plates contains seventeen separate life-size and larger illustrations
of the human anatomy. The colors are as true to life as it is possible to obtain by modern
scientific lithography. All figures are anatomically accurate in form and detail; they were care-
fully edited, revised and augmented by the foremost of American medical illustrators,
MAX BRODEL, Professor of Medical Drawlng---Johns Hopkins Medical School
"I find them extremely interesting to the students and very helpful in instruction." says Mr. E. Berry of the
International Y. M. C. A. College. Springfield, Mass. Your experience would be the same if you had a set of
these charts.
WRITE TO-DAY for a fr•• C:OPJ' of d•• c:riptiv. bookl.t No. R3
A. s. NYSTROM & CO., Publishers 2249·35 Calumet An., CHICAGO, ILL.
height and length of limb, she makes up this deficiency by greater determination.
in strength, speed, and energy; what an- will power, nerve force, or some other
other lacks in weight she makes up in unknown quality, that makes for physical
height and energy; what still another one efficiency. If anyone of the factors
lacks in energy and speed she makes up chosen for the formula had been adopted
in superior height, strength, and weight; as a standard, it would have brought a
while still another who lacks both in little different type of girl to the front.
height and weight has to make up for This is shown by the following table:
TABLE II.
RELATIVE STANDING OF FIRST TEN ACCORDING TO OTHLR FACTORS AS, JUMP, HEIGHT,
WEIGHT, ETC.
Ratio of
Index Jump Height Jump to Height Weight Foot Pounds
I. L. V.M. I. M.E.W. I. J. 1. J. I. E. M. B. I. J. 1. J. I. L. V. M.
2. M.M.G. 2. E.M.B. 2. H.A. B. 2. M.M.G. 2. H.W. 2. J. 1. J.
3. M.E.W. 3. L.V.M. 3. L. V. M. 3. M.E.W. 3. H.A. B. 3. M.E.W.
4. M. J. O. 4. M.M.G. 4. M.E.W. 4. M. J. O. 4. L.V.M. 4. H.W.
5. H.W. 5. M. J. O. 5. B. S. 5. L.V.M. 5. B. S. 5. M.M.G.
6. M. E. F. 6. B. S. 6. H.W. 6. B. S. 6. M. E. F. 6. M. J. O.
7. J. 1. J. 7. M. E. F. 7. E. M. B. 7. M. E. F. 7. M. M. G. 7. H.A. B.
8. E. M. B. 8. H.A. B. 8. M.M.G. 8. H.W. 8. M.E.W. 8. B. S.
9. H.A. B. 9. H.W. 9. M. E. F. 9. H.A.B. 9. M. J. O. 9. M. E. F.
10. B. S. 10. J. 1. J. 10. M. J. O. 10. J. 1. J. 10. E. M. B. 10. E. M. B.
194 Al'v[ERICAN PHYSICAL EDUCATION REVIEW
It will be observed by referring to ever it may be termed which drives our
Table II, that, if the height of the jump internal machinery. Overlapping all, of
had been the only factor considered course, is the skill or dexterity with which
M. E. W. and E. M. B. would have come -the jump is executed.
to the front as 1 and ,2 ; or if height and I think, therefore, that the test as a
weight had been the prime factors, J. 1. J., whole may be considered as a momentary
who was 10 in the jump, would have been try-out of one's strength, speed, energy
put in the first place. I f the height and dexterity combined, which, in my
jumped in proportion to her own height opinion, furnishes a fair physical test
had been accepted as the final test, E. M. of a man, and solves in a simple way his
B. would have reached first place, though unknown equation as determined poten-
she ranked 10 in weight and strength. tially by his height and weight. It will
Then again, if foot pounds of work done, be observed that the parts tested, namely,
as usually calculated had been adopted as the muscles of the feet, calves, thighs,
the standard, J. 1. J. would have come buttocks, back, neck, anterior deltoid,
up from tenth place in height really chest, and biceps are the muscles most
Downloaded by [New York University] at 20:58 13 February 2015
jumped and ratio of height jumped to used in all forms of athletics, sports,
second place. The foot-pound formula track and field games, setting up ex-
is perhaps the best test for real strength ercises, posture drills, etc., and are of
and gives the taller and heavier girls a fundamental importance in all the active
decided advantage. industries. For this reason, I think it
It must be admitted, however, that the should precede any other all-round phys-
three girls who come the nearest to the ical test in basic value.
front in all the factors that make up the In presenting this paper for discussion,
test are those that stand I, 2, and 3, ac- I have intentionally narrowed myself
cording to the index adopted. What this down to a consideration of the factors in-
index as thus obtained really indicates is volved in making the test, omitting the
a question that may well engage our at- experience that has led up to it, and the
tention. application that may be made of it, and
First, no one would deny that the abil- the method of conducting it.
ity to project one's weight 20 or 30 To those who wish to try the exper-
inches into the air, against the force of iment, I would suggest that the jump be
gravity requires strength on the part of made in gymnasium slippers or at least
the muscles engaged in the effort. No in shoes with low heels, and as the fac-
one would deny that the effort would tors, weight, height, and height jumped
have to be made with a certain degree are to be multiplied and divided in the
of velocity or speed in order to create calculation, that all the measurements be
impetus enough to carry the body twenty made with the greatest accuracy.
inches above its own level in the standing If the test is of any value, then the
position. Further, no one would deny standardization of it, and the collection
that back of the requisite strength of of different data concerning it will, of
muscle fibers and rapidity with which course, be of the greatest importance,
they are made to contract there must be and follow naturally for the benefit of
energy, "pep," "vim," vitality. or what- those who want to make use of it.