Professional Documents
Culture Documents
50614
CONFIDENTIAL
by
Ed. de Saegher
Mark Brewer
Wai-Yin Wong
Siri Sivalingam
Karlheinz Arnecke
Paul van Oers
CONFIDENTIAL
This document is made available subject to the condition that the recipient will neither use nor disclose the contents except as agreed in
writing with the copyright owner. Copyright is vested in Shell Global Solutions International B.V., The Hague.
Neither the whole nor any part of this document may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical,
reprographic, recording or otherwise) without the prior written consent of the copyright owner.
Shell Global Solutions is a trading style used by a network of technology companies of the Shell Group.
GS.07.50614 1 CONFIDENTIAL
Document History
Summary
This document provides technical guidance for an implementation team on the key issues to
be considered when introducing Fatty Acid Methyl Esters (FAME) into automotive gas oil
(AGO) in a market. The report specifically considers FAME contents up to 5%v in AGO (B5)
and would apply to 10% v/v in most of the case and considers the full fuel supply chain
starting from the supply of FAME through to blending at refinery and depot storage, as well
as retail sites and use by the final customer.
The key issues relate to those aspects of FAME that differ from conventional AGO. These
are principally their cold properties, their poorer oxidation stability and their tendency to pick
up water and dirt in the supply chain to a greater extent than conventional AGO. This has
implications, in particular for the handling and blending of neat FAME. Blends with AGO can
be treated in a similar manner to conventional AGO. The need for the maintenance of a good
housekeeping regime becomes even more critical when FAME is introduced into the diesel
fuel.
The presence of FAME can alter the properties of AGO, in particular in terms of the low
temperature properties and increased water solubility and solvency. Because of this, specific
actions need to be taken to prepare storage tank farms for the introduction of FAME-
containing fuels. Storage tanks require checking, assessment and cleaning to remove water
and dirt. Furthermore material compatibility issues with materials used through the supply
chain should be looked at.
Refinery blending is the favoured way for FAME addition, although local circumstances might
favour terminal blending. For terminal blending “side stream gantry blending” is the
distribution standard, and deviation from this standard requires derogation via the distribution
biofuels team.
The table below summarises all the highlighted red () key points and recommendations
made in this report.
Chapter KEY POINTS & RECOMMENDATIONS
3.1 The properties and performances of FAME depend on the fatty acids
compositions, chain length and number of double bonds C=C in the molecules.
4 All requests and enquiries about FAME supply are handled through Shell
Trading contacts.
5 Compliance to FAME standards and quality specifications is important to ensure
good performance of the final AGO blend.
5.4 Local FAME specifications must be met by the FAME suppliers.
5.5 If a metal sample can is used for products containing FAME the sample can
shall be made from stainless steel. Only opaque bottles should be used for
storing samples as light can also affect the results.
7 Good housekeeping standards are of primary importance to minimize the
ingress of water into the neat FAME or AGO blends and ensure the products
remain within specification. Water and sediment contamination are the two main
housekeeping issues for FAME.
7.1 Good housekeeping to eliminate free water, proper material compatibility and
FAME that meets the quality specifications, are all measures to prevent
corrosion.
7.1 Copper, brass, bronze and galvanised materials should be avoided for fuel
systems where FAME is used.
GS.07.50614 3 CONFIDENTIAL
10.1 The addition of FAME to AGO can have a large impact on the cold properties
(CP and CFPP) of the fuel that can, in many cases, make meeting the
specifications difficult using current cold flow additives. FAME derived from
highly saturated, high melting point materials such as TME and POME can be
particularly problematical.
10.4 Neat FAME normally has a higher viscosity than standard AGO.
10.6 Existing blend rules apply to FAME blends up to 20%v.
12.1 In areas of cold climates refineries and depots receiving FAME should consider
whether heating of transfer lines and storage tanks are necessary.
12.4 The supplier must provide a Certificate of Analysis (CoA) for every batch of
FAME delivered. Prior to accepting a delivery of FAME product, it is important to
inspect the CoA to ensure that the properties reported lie within the allowable
range of the supply specification. Guidelines on ensuring and maintaining
product quality from FAME suppliers (GS.06.52356 V2) are to be followed.
12.5 In Europe the transportation of B5 (5%v/v FAME) in multi product pipelines that
is also used for Jet-A1 is acceptable by using a combination of minimum batch
size, modified interface cutting, product sequencing and buffers to ensure the
average level of FAME in a batch of jet fuel is below the maximum level of 5ppm
as defined in DEF STAN 91-91 for Jet-A1. This however is subject to the
approval of pipeline operators.
12.6 Colonial Pipeline has decided not to permit shipments of fuels containing bio-
components at this time. Any FAME blending into AGO will therefore have to be
carried out at terminals.
13.1.1 It is preferred that FAME does not contain any cold flow improvers, to minimize,
risk of interactions with other fuel additives and supply chain costs.
13.1.2 The recommended antioxidants for FAME are generally described as hindered
phenols, like BHT. These chemistries can be used up to 1000mg/L in a B100
FAME based on the acceptable levels in AGO and Jet fuel
13.2.1 Care should be taken to ensure B5 does not become overdosed with
Antioxidant.
13.2.2 Conventional AGO cold flow improvers are effective in B5 fuels produced from
FAME containing a low saturated fatty ester content, such as RME. Up treating
with current CFI cannot always prevent significant increases in CFPP for B5
fuels produced from FAME containing high-saturated fatty ester content.
13.2.3 There is no evidence from studies done to date that FAME has any detrimental
impact on either ester-based or acid-based lubricity additives. If the FAME
content is above 2%v in the final blend, optimisation of the dosing of a lubricity
additive should be considered.
13.2.3 If the FAME content is below 2%v in the final blend, dosing of a lubricity additive
should be considered.
13.2.4 FAME can cause a loss in static dissipater additive (SDA) activity.
13.2.5 B5 does not appear to affect the performance of cetane improvers in base fuels.
Normally, no additional boost is provided by high cetane FAME when added to
fuels containing 2-EHN (high cetane)
13.2.6 Use of FAME in V Power Diesel, is generally NOT recommended and should be
reviewed for individual cases and be subject to separate QAG assessments.
14.1 Reprocessing 5 to 10% slops containing 1-5% FAME on intake via CDU and
HDS is possible and will pose no significant risks on HDS catalyst performance.
If all product streams are fully hydro-treated at all time, there will be no risks on
product contamination. It is recommended that the refineries investigate the
origin of the slops and its process unit configurations before deciding on the
reprocessing route back to the refineries.
GS.07.50614 5 CONFIDENTIAL
Table of Contents
Summary 2
1 Introduction 9
2 Definitions/Glossary 10
3 Fatty Acid Methyl Ester FAME 11
3.1 Types 11
3.2 Common Sources of FAME 11
3.2.1 Rapeseed Methyl Ester, RME 11
3.2.2 Soybean Methyl Ester, SME 11
3.2.3 Palm Oil Methyl Ester, POME 11
3.2.4 Coconut Oil Methyl Ester, CME 11
3.2.5 Tallow Methyl Ester, TME 12
3.2.6 Used Vegetable Oil Methyl Ester, UVOME or Used Cooking Oil Methyl Ester,
UCOME 12
3.2.7 Jatropha 12
3.3 FAME (B100) properties 12
3.4 Non specification characteristics of FAME compared to AGO 12
4 Suppliers 14
5 Quality & Standards 15
5.1 Germany (representing EU) – Biodiesel Quality Management Association
AGQM 15
5.2 USA - National Biodiesel Accreditation Commission (NBAC) BQ-9000 15
5.3 Australia – Biodiesel Association of Australia (BAA) 16
5.4 Shell Quality Assurance Process 16
5.5 Sampling of FAME and biodiesel blends 17
6 FAME Specification Items 18
6.1 Density 18
6.2 Kinematic Viscosity 18
6.3 Flash Point 18
6.4 Sulphur Content 18
6.5 Carbon Residue 18
6.6 Distillation (T90) 18
6.7 Cetane Number 19
6.8 Ash Content 19
6.9 Water Content 19
6.10 Total Contamination 19
6.11 Copper Strip Corrosion 20
6.12 Ester Content 20
6.13 Free Glycerol 20
6.14 Mono-, Di- and Triglycerides and Total Glycerol 20
6.15 Methanol 20
6.16 Iodine Number 20
6.17 Linolenic Acid Methyl Ester 21
6.18 Polyunsaturated FAME 21
6.19 Acid Number 21
6.20 Phosphorus Content 21
6.21 Content of alkali and alkaline-earth metals 21
6.22 Oxidation Stability 21
6.23 Low Temperature Behaviour 21
GS.07.50614 7 CONFIDENTIAL
13 Additives 50
13.1 Additives for FAME B100 50
13.1.1 Cold flow improvers 50
13.1.2 Antioxidants 50
13.2 Effect of FAME on AGO Additives 51
13.2.1 Anti oxidant 51
13.2.2 Cold flow additives 51
13.2.3 Lubricity 51
13.2.4 SDA – Conductivity 51
13.2.5 2-EHN – Cetane Improvers 52
13.2.6 Impact on performance additives 52
14 Reprocessing Fuels containing FAME (including Slops) 53
14.1 Reprocessing slops via CDU and HDS 53
14.2 Blending into main grade fuels. 54
15 FAME in Industrial Gas oil and Domestic Heating Oil 55
16 B5 in Retail. 56
17 Risk Management in the introduction of FAME in Shell AGO products
– the Quality Assurance Group (QAG) 57
18 HSE Issues 58
18.1 Static risks, electrical conductivity: Neat FAME and AGO Blends 58
18.2 Spontaneous Combustion – Neat FAME 58
18.3 Regulatory Compliance 59
19 Higher FAME content blends (B7, B10/B20) 60
20 Fatty acid ethyl/alkyl esters FAEE 61
21 GTL blending component 62
22 Additional General References 64
Appendix A. Common Fatty Acids 65
Appendix B. Typical FAME properties 66
Appendix C. Fats and oil composition 77
Appendix D. Trans-esterification process 78
Appendix E. Iodine number 79
Appendix F. FAME structures 81
Appendix G. EN 14112 Oxidation stability – Rancimat test 82
Appendix H. Blend experiences from refineries 84
Appendix I. FAME CAS & EINECS list 87
Appendix J. Grouping and Mapping of FAME 88
Bibliographic Information 89
Report distribution 90
GS.07.50614 9 CONFIDENTIAL
1 Introduction
There is growing pressure around the world to increase the use of bio-components such as
FAME in automotive fuels as they offer governments opportunities to increase domestic
energy security, support their agriculture industry, develop renewable energy and reduce
carbon dioxide emissions. In this context many Shell Operating Companies are looking to
introduce FAME into AGO. Storage and handling issues at refineries and distribution sites,
are often not as straight forward as for conventional AGO alone. FAME is already present in
some countries in AGO blends of up to 5%v (designated as B5), although 7%v (B7), 10%v
(B10) and 20%v (B20) blends are also available.
The aim of this document is to provide guidance on the additional measures that are required
when introducing FAME into a refinery tank farm or distribution depot based upon the
experiences of the Shell companies and non-Shell parties. The intended audience for this
guide include personnel who are involved with the introduction and implementation of FAME.
It should be noted that this Technical Guide forms part of a group of documents from Global
Solutions related to FAME implementation into a market. Other Guides cover Quality
Assurance, and Specific property issues, while an overall Implementation Guide is available
to provide a summary of the key technical issues that should be considered by the business
implementation team responsible for FAME introduction.
This FAME Technical guide will be updated as new information or experiences become
available. Your views and learning’s are welcomed for this next issue. Please send your
comments to the author: Paul.vanOers@Shell.com
GS.07.50614 10 CONFIDENTIAL
2 Definitions/Glossary
The following nomenclature and definitions will be used in this document.
In this guide:
The convention used to denote FAME types or AGO blends is as follows:
RME, SME, POME, CME, UCOME, AOME or FAME is used to refer to neat methyl esters
Bxx refers to a specific blend of xx% of an ester in AGO.
B100 is also used to refer to 100% methyl esters
The convention used to denote specific FAME types are normally written as Cxx:n;
where xx = number of carbon atoms in the fatty acid
n = number of double bonds
when n = 0, it is saturated
when n > 0, it is unsaturated
FAME is produced via a chemical process called trans-esterification with methanol in the
presence of an alkaline or acidic catalyst to yield methyl esters. Glycerol is formed as a co-
product of the reaction. See Appendix D for a chart showing the trans-esterification process.
FAME can be produced from various oil-derived feedstock such as soybean, rapeseed,
sunflower seed, jatropha, coconut, palm and used vegetable oils, as well as tallow (animal
fats), although the most common types of FAME produced are:
3.2.6 Used Vegetable Oil Methyl Ester, UVOME or Used Cooking Oil Methyl Ester, UCOME
There is increasing interest in using recycle oils, which include UVOME - most commonly
derived from used frying oil. Recycled oils come from a variety of sources and the
composition may vary. They are chemically and physically degraded and often contaminated,
hence have to be treated to remove impurities. The recycled oils are already in used in
Europe and Japan.
3.2.7 Jatropha
Jatropha oil is extracted from Jatropha curcas (physic nut). This non-edible oil is particularly
attractive as a feedstock for FAME as it tends to be considerably cheaper than edible
vegetable oils. It is largely grown in India and has already been blended into diesel for
fuelling trains but is not widely available at present.
There are two main types of fatty acid esters, saturated or unsaturated: see Appendix F
• Saturated fatty acid esters do not contain any double bonds
• Unsaturated fatty acid esters do contain double bonds. They can contain 1 or more
double bonds. If they have 1 double bond, then they are called mono unsaturated,
and for more than 1 double bond, they are called poly unsaturated
In general, the properties of FAME can be linked to its fatty acid compositions.
A high content of Saturated fatty acids (e.g. CME, POME, TME) is associated with:
• Higher CFPP, cloud point & pour point
• Higher cetane number
• Better oxidation stability
A high content of unsaturated fatty acids (e.g. RME, SME) is associated with:
• Lower CFPP, cloud point & pour point
• Lower cetane number
• Poorer oxidation stability
• AGO fuel typically consists of about 30-35% aromatics and 65-70% paraffin’s and
traces of olefins and sulphur. Most of the paraffin’s in AGO fuel are in the range from
C10 to C16. FAME derived from rapeseed or soybean oil contains primarily C16 and C18
fatty acid methyl esters with one up to three C=C double bonds per molecule.
GS.07.50614 13 CONFIDENTIAL
• Oxygen: Higher oxygen content than AGO and this reduces black smoke. Typically,
oxygen content in FAME amounts to between 10 to 12 % m/m, as shown in Figure 1.
16
15
14
13
Oxygen content %
12
Typical Oxygen content of FAME ester types are between 10-12%
11
10
6
C12:0 C14:0 C16:0 C18:0 C20:0 C22:0 C24:0 C18:1 C18:2 C18:3
Fatty acid ester type
• Chlorine: Chlorine analysis showed typical levels of <20mg/kg. The UCOME results were
not significantly different from other FAME tested. High chlorine levels in UCOME have
been linked to increased dioxin exhaust emissions. These results suggest the UCOME
tested is likely to be no worse for this than other FAME types.
• Lubricity: Excellent lubricity improver and can eliminate the use of a separate lubricity
improver in low sulphur AGO. Bio-degradability: FAME is classified as “readily bio-
degradable”. .
• Eco-toxicity: Relative to conventional AGO, FAME can show significantly less eco-toxicity
to a range of micro-organism.
• Solvency: FAME is an effective solvent, hence tends to loosen and mobilise existing
deposits in pipes and tanks during distribution. If not carefully managed, this may lead to
problems with filter blockage further downstream.
• Conductivity: Whilst neat FAME components are expected to have higher conductivity
than AGO, the effect of introducing low concentrations of FAME into AGO on the overall
conductivity is small and not sufficient to ensure safe handling. On the contrary,
unexpected and large reductions in conductivity have been observed upon blending 5%
SME into base fuel containing static dissipater. Hence, the standard advice on the use of
conductivity additives is still applied, and to be verified on a case-by-case basis.
• Calorific value: FAME has lower calorific value compared to AGO, which increases fuel
consumption.
• Micro-organism: Neat FAME could be a potential source for micro-organism to enter the
supply chain. Advice is to monitor the microbial activity of FAME (see also chapter 7.2).
GS.07.50614 14 CONFIDENTIAL
4 Suppliers
All requests and enquiries about FAME supply are handled through Shell
Trading contacts.
FAME supply is handled through Shell Trading. The focal points are:
• STR Shell Trading Rotterdam (Europe and World),
• SIETCO Shell Trading Singapore (for East and World).
• STUSCO Shell Trading Houston (for US)
• SCAPSA Shell Trading Latin America
If suppliers approach sites directly, they should be forwarded to the Shell Trading contacts as
appropriate. This will enable maintenance of a consistent position with suppliers. It will also
ensure QA is maintained, avoid un-necessary risks and help to develop global opportunities.
GS.07.50614 15 CONFIDENTIAL
There are standards and quality accreditation schemes to provide quality control and
assurance in order to ensure that bio diesel in the marketplace meets the quality
specifications. Latest versions of local FAME and diesel blend specifications should be
obtained from the local Product Quality Focal Points.
EN 590 - describes the physical properties that all AGO fuel must meet if it is to be sold in the
EU, Iceland, Norway or Switzerland. It allows the blending of up to 5%v FAME with
conventional AGO. Only FAME meeting the EN 14214 specification can be used for blending
into AGO.
EN 14214 is currently the standard for neat biodiesel, developed by the European Standards
organisation CEN. The EN 14214 specification is broadly based on DIN 51606, a previous
German standard for Biodiesel. EN 14214 specifies properties and the test methods needed
to determine compliance. This standard allows any feedstock to be used, however its
specifications are most easily met by rapeseed methyl esters (RME). It only covers the use of
Fatty Acid Methyl esters (FAME).
Also in the US (like Europe) separate specifications for neat biodiesel and diesel blends
exist.
ASTM D 975 –08a: Standard Specification for Diesel Fuel Oils – this standard applies to
petroleum-derived AGO and allows the blending of max 5 % v/v bio diesel (not limited to
FAME) in No. 1 and No. 2 diesel fuels without the need for labelling at the pump. The
biodiesel blend stock used in these blends is required to meet ASTM D6751
GS.07.50614 16 CONFIDENTIAL
ASTM D7467-08a: Standard Specification for Diesel Fuel Oils – this standard applies to
petroleum derived AGO and allows the blending of biodiesel (not limited to FAME) in
concentrations between 5 and 20% v/v. B20 was a request from the US military through
DESC. The Defense Energy Support Center asked for the B6-B20 specification to make the
need for product quality data cascade to the supplier in a mandatory sense. Without the
ASTM specification, DESC and/or the local consuming arm of the military, state of federal
government was responsible for confirming product quality if the supplier was hesitant. Now
that the specification exists, suppliers can be pointed to it for contract compliance, and free
up the government from the responsibility to fund their own QA/QC programs. The biodiesel
blend stock used in these blends is required to meet ASTM D6751
ASTM D 6751-08a – is currently the standard specification for neat FAME (B100) intended
for blending with AGO fuel (15 to 500 ppm Sulphur).
The Fuel Standard (Biodiesel) Determination 2003 sets out the physical and chemical
parameters of neat FAME. It also sets out the associated test methods that the Australian
government will use to determine compliance. In general, industry members are in
agreement with the proposed standards, which will form the basis of the Australian Standard
for biodiesel.
One of the key issues in ensuring the trouble free use of AGO blends is the quality of the
neat FAME. It is essential that the neat FAME should comply with the local FAME
specification prior to blending with AGO. Additional specifications can be included if required
to ensure the FAME meets local operating unit requirements.
A set of Quality Control protocols has been developed (GS.06.52356 - Process for Ensuring
and Maintaining Product Quality from FAME (Fatty Acid Methyl Ester) Suppliers). The main
principles underpinning these protocols are:
• Responsibility for the quality of the FAME product lies with the supplier, and this will be
stated clearly in the supply contract.
• FAME should only be purchased from a reputable supplier. When assessing potential
FAME suppliers, Shell Operating Units should follow the guidance given by Contracts
and Procurement within Shell Trading or the local Supply organisation.
• The contract will include inter alia clauses to define the specification to which the product
must conform, (ii) how conformance will be demonstrated (scope and frequency of
testing, reporting of results), and (iii) the arrangements in the event that product does not
meet the specification.
• Laboratories providing data to demonstrate product conformity must be either (1)
accredited to a relevant internationally recognised standard, or (2) audited by a Shell
technical focal point prior to the establishment of a supply contract.
GS.07.50614 17 CONFIDENTIAL
• In addition to the quality assurance provided by the supplier, a rapid quality control test
must be run on every delivery to check for error or contamination. This includes check of
the CoQ and a rapid QC check on density, water content, flashpoint and appearance
before discharging the product. Oxidation stability of the product is managed by
monitoring the storage tank frequently (see 8.1.4).
When sampling neat FAME or diesel containing FAME the usage of traditional copper
sample cans should be avoided as this might affect the oxidation stability result. Stainless
steel or glass are preferred materials for the sample cans. The sample cans should be kept
clean and dry. For storing the samples only opaque bottles should be used as light can also
affect the results. If the sample is being taken for measuring the oxidation stability then the
sample should be analyzed promptly. (<3 days)
If a metal sample can is used for products containing FAME the sample
can shall be made from stainless steel. Only opaque bottles should be
used for storing samples as light can also affect the results.
GS.07.50614 18 CONFIDENTIAL
6.1 Density
FAME densities are generally higher than those of conventional AGO although changes in
density with temperature are very similar. The density of FAME depends not only on the fatty
acid composition but also on purity. Density increases with decreasing chain length and
increasing number of double bonds present in the fatty acid esters. Density can be
decreased by the presence of low-density contaminants, such as methanol and is therefore a
useful quick check for gross contamination in transit.
80
70
60
Cetane number
50
40
30
20
10
0
C12:0 C14:0 C16:0 C18:0 C18:1 C18:2 C18:3
Fatty acid type
concentration of insoluble impurities tends to cause blockage of fuel filters and may cause
damage of injection pumps. High concentrations of soaps and sediments are mainly
associated with these phenomena. Care should be taken with high cloud point FAME that
FAME residues do not remain on the filter, the use of warm solvent and filtering equipment is
recommended.
6.15 Methanol
High methanol contents pose safety risks in FAME transport and storage due to lowering of
flash points. Residual methanol in the ester product is removed by distillation or by repeated
aqueous washing steps. Flashpoint values higher than 100°C guarantee that the maximum
limit of 0.2% methanol is not exceeded.
Customer report GS08.54630 “AGO and biodiesel oxidation stability” gives a good overview
of the issues related to oxidation stability. See Appendix G for details on the Rancimat
method.
The same cold-temperature property measurements (cloud point, pour point and CFPP) are
used for FAME and AGO, however, FAME generally have poorer low temperature properties
than conventional AGO. This is covered in more detail in later chapter 8.1.6.
The “cold soak filterability” test is recently being introduced in the ASTM D 6751. This is an
attempt to identify high risk FAME where usage could potentially result in precipitation at
temperatures above the cloud point.
GS.07.50614 23 CONFIDENTIAL
The solubility of water in FAME (around 1500 ppmw) is higher than in AGO (50-80 ppmw).
As the specification for the water content of neat FAME is usually below this limit (e.g. 500
ppmw in EN14214) it is thus important to keep neat FAME dry.
As for diesel water bottoms should not be maintained in FAME storage tanks, since water
can cause internal corrosion of tank bottoms and lower shell plates and encourages microbial
growth.
It is recommended to drain the water bottoms of neat FAME storage tanks on a weekly basis,
prior to blending with AGO and before every new FAME delivery.
Water that has been introduced into tanks from ships, or if pipelines are cleaned by a water
plug, should be kept to a minimum, and drained as soon as possible.
During the first few months following FAME introduction, the water content of the neat FAME
should be assessed regularly to ensure that the housekeeping measures are working
effectively and the water content of the FAME is not significantly increased during storage. It
is recommended to record the water content in the FAME, estimated quantity of water
drained and any abnormal observation during water draining activities. This will help to
monitor the effectiveness of the housekeeping in place.
No FAME shall be used for blending purpose and no AGO blends shall be dispatched as
product from tanks where settled water may be drawn into the suction line. It is essential to
take every precaution to ensure a customer never receives any free or entrained water from
a refinery or terminal through any mode of transportation.
Tank vent pipes should be inspected periodically as they can allow rainwater to seep into the
system.
There are refineries where the haze point is reached in AGO despite the fact of on-
specification water content. Care should be taken in case of FAME blending containing
relatively high water concentrations (ref EN14214 spec) to ensure the AGO blend remains
within the water specification and clear and bright.
The time taken for water phase separation to occur is normally increased when FAME is
present. This can influence the daily operations in Oil Movement, thus the required settling
time of a tank should be considered.
If water contents become too high, check that the correct housekeeping procedures are
being followed.
GS.07.50614 24 CONFIDENTIAL
Corrosion originates from a combination of several factors, for example, the presence of free
water, incompatible material use and the presence of corrosive acids (together with the
presence of water) and free methanol in the FAME.
The presence of excess free methanol is likely to corrode materials like aluminium and zinc.
However, since the specification for methanol content in FAME is low (max 0.2% m/m, in EN
590) it is unlikely that methanol stress corrosion cracking of carbon steel piping will happen in
any FAME applications. Therefore, an additional stress relief heat treatment on the piping is
not necessary.
Material compatibility should be looked at when dealing with neat FAME (and the AGO
blends). Any installed or attached parts made of non-ferrous metals (for example copper,
brass, bronze) and galvanised materials must be replaced with equivalent parts made of
steel. This measure serves to prevent corrosion effects, which results in the formation of
metallic soaps and could impair the quality of FAME.
The limit specified for FAME is the same as that for petroleum AGO fuel. As the presence of
free fatty acids or residual acids will mask the true value of the copper strip corrosion, tests
like EN 14104 – Acid value is used to ensure that FAME does not contain those components.
Copper, brass, bronze and galvanised materials should be avoided for fuel
systems where FAME is used.
Microbial contamination occurs when micro-organisms grow and multiply in water, which
comes into contact with the fuel. Growth is most commonly found in water bottoms of fuel
storage tanks but can also occur in water droplets entrained into the fuel, e.g. mixed-in during
tank filling and emptying operations. Growth may also occur as bio-film on the internal
surfaces of tanks, which are exposed to water periodically, causing microbiological corrosion.
GS.07.50614 25 CONFIDENTIAL
The most common sources of water within fuel distribution and storage systems are:
• Settling from fuel on immediate cooling following manufacture
• Condensation within tanks associated with humidity and temperature changes
• Contamination with water during marine distribution operations
• Leaking tank roof seal, manhole covers, etc. allowing ingress of rainwater.
B100
• Twice per month water check (visible and total) and microbiological testing of rag
layer1.
• All free settled water and/or emulsion layer removed.
B5
• Monthly water check (visible and total) and microbiological testing of rag layer.
• All free-settled water and/or emulsion layer removed.
There are no standard agreed microbiological limits for acceptable contamination levels
in fuels. Low numbers can cause operational problems and high numbers do not
necessarily cause operational problems.
Studies have shown that when contaminated FAME is used as a blending component, it
can lead to microbial proliferation when blended into diesel fuel.
1
This is the fuel/water interface layer.
2
The MicrobMonitor method
GS.07.50614 26 CONFIDENTIAL
Biocides are chemical agents capable of killing micro-organisms in fuel. They can be
used in a low dosage as a preventative or in a high dosage as a disinfectant or shock
treatment. Two chemistries that are in widespread use are (Table 2 Storage tank
housekeeping)
8 Storage
8.1 Neat FAME
This section describes the storage and handling requirements of neat FAME.
In general many of the storage and handling aspects for neat FAME are
similar to standard (AGO).
8.1.1 General
There are a number of issues associated with neat FAME which mean that additional rules
and precautions are required for its storage and handling, over and above those that would
be normally be applied for handling conventional AGO. These issues are summarised below:
Poor oxidation stability can result in long-term storage problems and may accelerate fuel
oxidation, leading to gumming and deterioration of fuel injection systems. The use of anti-
oxidant additives is likely to be required in most cases, and should usually be added to the
bio-component by the FAME manufacturer rather than by the end-user. These additives are
most effective when added as soon as possible after FAME production. The type and
concentrations of additives are described in chapter 13.1.2.
Stability of FAME can be prolonged by limiting the fuel’s exposure to oxygen and, most
importantly, by use of antioxidant additives. The storage life and stability of FAME are
contingent on the FAME being stored properly but as a general guideline short-term storage
(<1month) of FAME should be possible without addition of antioxidant with little or no stability
GS.07.50614 28 CONFIDENTIAL
problems. Any fuel stored for longer than 1 month, however, may warrant the use of
antioxidants and should be tested regularly for oxidation stability, acid number, viscosity, and
sediments. The trend in these properties should be monitored. The recommended frequency
of testing is: monthly if Rancimat result is >8hrs and bi-weekly if result is <8hrs. Storage
periods, for FAME, longer than 1 month have been reported in the market.
FAME being stored for longer than 1 month should be checked regularly and
treated with antioxidant to avoid stability problems.
If long term storage is required FAME should also have a high oxidation stability (Rancimat)
value (>10 hr), contain a lower level of unsaturated fatty acid esters, and minimal levels of
poly unsaturated fatty acid esters. The FAME should also be checked regularly and stored
under controlled conditions.
Neat FAME has a higher viscosity than standard AGO as shown in Figure 3 Neat FAME
viscosity showing viscosity is normally higher than standard AGO (Viscosity of standard AGO
2-4.5cSt) The typical kinematic viscosity for standard AGO is between 2 to 4.5 cSt and this is
relatively lower than that of neat FAME (between 3 to 5.5 cSt as shown in Figure 4 Pure
Fatty acid ester viscosities, showing that viscosity is inversely proportional to the number of
double bonds and directly proportional to the chain length.. This behaviour is particularly
noticeable at lower temperatures. For instance, the effect of temperature on the viscosity of
RME and samples of UCOME are shown in Figure 5 shows the increase in viscosity at lower
temperatures. while the relationship between shear rate and dynamic viscosity of UCOME at
-10°C is illustrated in Figure 6 shows the increase in Viscosity at lower shear rates
The viscosity of FAME is related to the fatty acid composition. The viscosity of FAME is
inversely proportional to the number of double bonds and directly proportional to the chain
length. Figure 4 demonstrates how the viscosity varies with fatty acid and the impact this has
on the viscosity of the different FAME types.
Production impurities can also significantly affect the viscosity. The presence of
glycerol/glycerides and oxidation polymers, for example can increase the viscosity while
residual alcohol can reduce the viscosity.
7
6
Viscosity cSt
5
4
3
2
1
0
POME RME SME SUNME CME
FAME type
Figure 3 Neat FAME viscosity showing viscosity is normally higher than standard AGO
(Viscosity of standard AGO 2-4.5cSt)
6
5
Viscosity cSt
4
3
2
1
0
C14:0 C16:0 C18:0 C18:1 C18:2 C18:3
Fatty acid type
Figure 4 Pure Fatty acid ester viscosities, showing that viscosity is inversely proportional to
the number of double bonds and directly proportional to the chain length.
GS.07.50614 30 CONFIDENTIAL
90
80
70
Viscosity mPas
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
-20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Temperature C
Ref: Kerschbaum, S., Rinke, G. Measurement of the temperature dependent
UCOME A UCOME B RME B RME A viscosity of biodiesel fuels (2004) Fuel, 83 (3), pp. 287-291
700
600
500
Dyn Viscosity mPas
400
300
200
100
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
Shear rate 1/s Ref: Kerschbaum, S., Rinke, G. Measurement of the temperature
dependent viscosity of biodiesel fuels (2004) Fuel, 83 (3), pp. 287-
291
The cold properties of FAME depend on their degree of saturation, with more
saturated FAME, such as TME and POME having the worse properties.
Additives are only currently available that can lower the pour point and CFPP
of RME. The Shell recommendation is that these Additives should not be
used.
GS.07.50614 31 CONFIDENTIAL
Cold flow properties of FAME are one of the main operational issues to consider. More
saturated FAME, (such as TME and POME) have poor cold properties and will pose more
handling issues than less saturated FAME (such as RME or SME). This is shown in Figure 7,
which gives the Pour Point, Cloud point and CFPP of a number of FAME types.
20
10
0
Temperature ( C) TME POME RME (S) RME (W) SME
o
-10
-20
-30
Cloud Point
-40 CFPP
Pour Point
-50
Figure 7 shows the range of low temperature properties for a selection of FAME types.
Additives are currently available that can lower the Pour Point and CFPP of neat RME,
although they have minimal effect on Cloud Point. This is shown in Figure 7, where the RME
(W) contains such an additive. RME containing cold flow additives has been used in
Germany without reported incidents, however the current Shell recommendation is to prohibit
the use of such additives. The reason for this is to minimize the risk of interaction between
these cold flow additives with other types of fuel additives, for example performance
additives. It will also maintain supply flexibility and minimise supply chain costs.
Low temperature can cause FAME to solidify, but on warming it liquefies quickly. Pure FAME
can be stored underground in most cold climates, but above ground fuel systems should be
protected with insulation, agitation, heating systems, or other measures if ambient
temperatures regularly fall below the cloud point of the FAME l. This precaution includes
piping, tanks and pumping equipment. Heating can be by any of the common heating
mechanisms, but should be designed to minimise hotspots and prolonged storage at
temperatures above 50°C to minimise oxidation. Preferred system should be based on
tempered water, as steam will be to extreme and cause hotspots and accelerate product
degradation. The thermal degradation of FAME can occur even at relatively low
temperatures. The maximum allowable skin temperature of 80 –100 degC is the guideline
used to reflect the maximum design freedom.
GS.07.50614 32 CONFIDENTIAL
8.1.9 Impurities
Precipitation can also be affected by other impurities. Low temperature precipitation can be
increased by the presence of Sterol esters and increased water content. Other very low level
impurities (Fatty acid soaps and Fatty waxes) have also been associated with precipitation.
• Thermoplastic materials (linings, tanks, pump internals, filters, valve seats, etc);
• Elastomer materials (gaskets, seals, O-rings, hoses, etc);
Selection of non-metallic materials to be used in 100% FAME and/or mixtures of FAME and
diesel should be based on long-term compatibility of the material under fully immersed
conditions, from either laboratory testing (according to ASTM C 581 or equivalent), or from
field service experience.
The flash point property of the stored product determines the storage tank type according to
the rules as set by Energy institute (IP - Institute of Petroleum).
Neat FAME has a flashpoint above 100°C and therefore is categorized as "unclassified"
according to the IP flash point class definition (reference: IP guide - Area classification code
for handling flammable liquids, July 2005). Further details are also given in Shell Design
Engineering Practice (DEP) 34.51.01.31- VERTICAL CARBON STEEL STORAGE TANKS –
based on EN 14015).
The experience of FAME users (suppliers, refineries, etc) has shown that the most effective
way to prevent water ingress is to store neat FAME in a tank with a fixed roof, keeping the
tank as full as possible.
Conical-bottom designed tanks for FAME and AGO blend storage are recommended, as they
are easier to drain.
Floating- roof tanks can be effective provided good housekeeping practices are strictly
maintained and the turnover of FAME in the tank is high, since they are more prone to water
ingress via the roof rim seal.
It is recommended that FAME should be stored in dedicated tanks constructed from mild
steel. Alternative tank materials, suitable for FAME storage, are the following:
• Stainless steel
• Aluminium
• Polymer materials (see 8.1.10).
Copper and copper containing alloys lead such as tin and zinc should be
avoided as they can significantly increase sediment and deposit formation
from FAME.
It is not recommended to install desiccators on FAME tanks due to potential risk of having
vent blockage.
If heating should be applied for storage reasons heat transfer calculation shall be performed
in order to define the heating coil length and possible insulation requirements.
GS.07.50614 34 CONFIDENTIAL
The requirement of tank cleaning prior to introducing FAME into a tank is based on these
good housekeeping standards. Therefore it is important to identify the condition of the
storage tanks before introduction of FAME. See also chapter 8.1.5 on solvent properties of
FAME.
8.2.1 General
The standard storage and handling procedures used for conventional AGO
can be used for AGO-FAME blends.
AGO blends of up to 20% (B20) should be treated as conventional AGO. It is advised to store
AGO blends in fixed roof tanks.
It is stressed that B5 is “just diesel”, which meets all the requirements of the diesel
specification. The term biodiesel is used for the 100% FAME and is also referred to as B100.
This statement is considered key to minimising confusion and/or concerns in the
marketplace.
AGO blends have a flashpoint between 55 to 100°C and are stored at ambient temperature,
which meets a class III type of product.
Further details are also given in Shell Design Engineering Practice (DEP) 34.51.01.31
Use of Nitrile Butadiene Rubber (NBR) with 40% acrylonitrile, which are commonly found in
fuel systems, can also be sufficient for AGO blends up to 20%v (B20).
GS.07.50614 35 CONFIDENTIAL
9 Blending
9.1 Introduction
FAME blending depends on a variety of factors, including the volume of FAME required to
make the blend, the finished blend level, the volume of blended products being sold, tankage
and space availability, equipment and operational costs, and customer requirements for
blends, both now and in the future. It should be noted that
FAME is a fuel for AGO applications only and FAME is not to be blended with
gasoline.
FAME blending into AGO is not necessarily difficult. There are some ‘rules’ and ‘occurrences’
which should be considered to not run into operational or product quality difficulties. In the
following sections the options on how to blend FAME (B100) into base AGO are described
and recommendations are presented.
9.2 Location
As the market matures and volumes continue to increase, it is very likely that the actual point
of blending will occur further and further upstream in the distribution system where it is most
efficient and economical.
Blending FAME in a refinery allows for the correction of certain base fuel parameters (e.g.
density, T95 and cold flow parameters). It also enables the blender to take advantage of the
natural lubricity properties of FAME especially in low sulphur base fuels in which the lubricity
additive can be reduced or removed.
Quality assurance of feedstocks and finished products can be easily achieved in a refinery
rather than in a depot or terminal. Product blending is a daily business in a refinery where
knowledge and suitable equipment are in place. The volumes blended in a refinery give more
flexibility and is much more suited to establish a robust blend process.
Cold flow additives to adjust cold flow properties in finished AGO are not normally available
at terminals in EU. Additional investment for additive storage and injection has to be
accounted for or the base AGO for FAME blending has to have enough quality reserves to
compensate for possible adverse effect of the FAME blending on cold flow properties.
Cold flow additives are normally available at terminals in the US, but additional investment for
additional additive storage and injection may need to be accounted for.
9.3 Type
Regardless the types of blending the following sections are based on blending FAME into
AGO basefuel. The FAME used should meet the local specification required for blending.
Due to the chemical nature of FAME it can be used and handled in the
blending process like any other common HC blend component for AGO.
Existing equipment like tanks, pipes, mixers, sample points, measurements and process
control equipment of the blending system shall be used. If the existing equipment does not
allow the use of FAME, e.g. lack of tanks, then an upgrade of the system has to be done.
The tie-in to existing pipe work has to be realized in a way that the blending system retains
its basic character. An inline blending system should not be extended with a sequencing
batch blending process. In cases where the inline blending is done upfront of a HDS unit, the
tie-in of the FAME line has to be done down stream of the HDS unit. The blending remains a
continuous process and is not of batch character.
The control algorithms required for true continuous ratio blending of components into the tank
truck compartment is inherently more complex than a sequential load mode. Each blend
component must have a correctly tuned flow rate control valve in order to correctly adjust its
own injection rate in accordance with the overall blend recipe during the blending activities.
Maintaining the ratio of the low percentage component during low flow start-up can be
difficult. Therefore it is important to ensure that calibration of rack meters covering the lower
and higher range are carried out in order to have reliable and accurate blending
performance.
There is no homogeneity problem in a compartment with ratio blending mode. The actual
component ratio during the load is representative of the final ratio. The number of
occurrences of off spec blends tends to be less by ratio blending mode. The blending into the
compartment can be stopped at any point during the loading activities without affecting the
target blend recipe. The truck loading time is less for ratio blend mode compared to
sequential blending mode.
By ratio blending the AGO and FAME into the truck, there are two points of custody transfer,
AGO and FAME (Figure 8 AGO/FAME injection line up and metering – ratio blending (side
stream blending) It is noted that there are no volume gain or shrinkage effects taking place
while blending FAME into AGO. Hence metering position is less critical compared to e.g.
ethanol in gasoline gantry blending set-ups.
GS.07.50614 37 CONFIDENTIAL
M M
AGO FAM E
Figure 8 AGO/FAME injection line up and metering – ratio blending (side stream blending)
If big volumes have to be blended the slow process of batch blending should not be the first
choice.
The blend itself is closely monitored by QMIs and/or by lab analyses. The blend components
are blended in a fixed ratio given by a recipe (Blend Ratio Control - BRC). The recipe and
hereafter the blend ratios can be adjusted based on the feedback of measured product
qualities in the blend line.
GS.07.50614 38 CONFIDENTIAL
FAME as an AGO blend component should be and can be tied-in to an existing inline
blending system.
Inline Blending of B5
LGO-1 Pipeline
Refinery
T-202 B5
QMI T-301
LGO-2
T-203 B5
T-302
HGO
T-204 B5
T-303
B100
T-205
Inline Blending of B5 with Gasoil Blending up- and downstream of HDS Unit
T-201 Pipeline
B5
QMI T-301
LGO
T-202
B5
HDS
T-302
HGO
T-203
B5
T-303
B100
T-205
Figure 10 Inline blending system where base fuel is blended upstream of a HDS unit and Fame
blending is downstream. A similar system is operated at Harburg Refinery line blending is also
done at terminal level where at some locations the FAME in blended into the diesel during the
discharge of barge or delivery of the product through a pipeline.
The FAME has to be loaded first for bottom loading truck followed by the lower density AGO
fuel. This loading method and sequence provides some mixing mechanism. The mixing
mechanism is further enhanced during transfer activities. This is generally enough mixing
except in cold weather.
It is not recommended to load FAME into a cold empty tank truck as this can cause the
FAME to solidify. In cold weather, it is better to load the tank truck with half AGO fuel
followed by FAME before final loading of AGO fuel. This will help to prevent the FAME from
freezing to the internal parts of the tank truck.
GS.07.50614 40 CONFIDENTIAL
FAME injection at the terminal can be arranged in a similar fashion as the Ethanol side
stream blending approach (chapter 9.3.1).
Estimate of required line length according to a rule of thumb at turbulent flow is:
The application of a static mixer should be considered, albeit this goes at an extra pressure
drop, which the system should be able to handle. The need for good hydraulics is a prime
factor to assure good and consistent blending under all flow conditions.
9.4 Pre-Blending
The chemical nature of FAME allows it to be blended with any kind of hydrocarbon distillates.
It is recommended not to use pre-blends (e.g. B90 or B80) to get a higher oxidation stability
blend component. Even B80 or B90 blends can be degraded quite quickly resulting in an off-
spec blend component. B20 or even lower pre-blends can be used to improve low
temperature storage and product handling characteristics.
The temperature during the blending process and thus in the finished product is determined
by the following conditions:
I) The dissolving of cold flow additives in AGO has to be assured using a specific
temperature range. This temperature range depends strongly on the cold flow
additives, which are injected. A typical range is between 25°C and 40°C. The
additive supplier should be contacted to get the specific temperatures.
II) The individual temperature of each blend component should be at least 6°C
above the highest cloud point of individual components. For refinery blending this
is not a constraint as FAME blending is usually done in the (relatively hot)
rundown. For terminal blending the temperature of the fuel should be at least 6
deg C above the cloud point of the FAME used. .
GS.07.50614 41 CONFIDENTIAL
III) The blender temperature has to be below the Flashpoint of the finished AGO.
Specification in EN 590 is above 55°C.
During the blending process the fuel temperature should be 6°C above the
Cloud point of the FAME and has to be in a range that assures that cold-flow
additives are dissolved completely.
The blending temperature has to comply with the standard safety requirements for AGO.
9.6 Additives
There is no difference in additive handling whether AGO blending is with or
without FAME.
Additives are usually stored in heated vessels. If the storage vessel is unheated a dilution of
the additive with a hydrocarbon distillate (e.g. Kerosene) may help to maintain ability of
additive dosing and responsiveness of the additive itself. The additive suppliers give advice
on how to handle specific products.
Most of the AGO blend properties do not show a different behaviour compared
to conventional AGO blending. Most issues can easily be addressed by
adjusting the additive levels and are therefore unlikely to be obstacles to
FAME introduction. Cold flow property is an exception and needs special
attention.
The addition of FAME to diesel fuel can have a considerable impact on the low temperature
properties (cloud point and CFPP) of the fuel (whether cold flow additives are used in the
base diesel fuel or not) and understanding this impact is one of the key aspects of ensuring
fuel fitness for purpose. This report aims to describe the various ways in which FAME can
affect fuel cold properties, discuss the reason why these occur and present advice for
minimising the effects. It is based on work carried out as part of the Fuels Product
Management programme underpinned by more fundamental understanding gained from a
Manufacturing and Supply R&D product quality project.
The low temperature properties of diesel fuel can be influenced by both the methyl ester type
and composition of the FAME and by the presence of impurities in the FAME. Methyl esters
are the main components of FAME and the low temperature properties of the blended fuel
are mainly influenced by the saturated methyl ester content of the FAME, which is directly
proportional to the cloud point, pour point and CFPP of the FAME. Of the common FAME
types, RME has a low saturated methyl ester content and thus has less influence on fuel cold
properties than FAME such as POME, which has a high-saturated methyl ester content.
Work has shown that, for EN590-type fuels with cloud points above –10 °C, the CFPP of the
fuel will be affected if the level of saturated FAME in the blend exceeds 1%. As a general
guideline, however, the original CFPP should be recoverable by up-treating the fuel with a
suitable cold flow additive. Once the saturated FAME level exceeds ca 2%, however, the
cloud point of the fuel will also be measurably affected and the original CFPP will be
unattainable without excessive addition of cold flow additive.
Threshold levels for use of common FAME types in diesel fuel can be set based on these
guidelines. Thus TME/POME use is limited to ca 4.5% levels before the cloud point is
influenced and CFPP becomes unrecoverable. By contrast RME can be used at
concentrations of up to 10% without changing the CFPP or cloud point while the level for
SME is somewhat below 7%.
The presence of impurities in FAME can also influence the cold properties of the blended
diesel fuel. In this case the issue is predominantly precipitation of the impurities at
temperatures above the cloud point of the fuel, which can lead to potential blockage of fuel
GS.07.50614 43 CONFIDENTIAL
filters. Saturated mono-glycerides have been identified as one of the main problem species
for blended fuels.
When B5 biodiesel blends were introduced to the Swedish market, during winter 2006/7
there was an industry-wide issue of precipitate appearing in fuel at temperatures well above
its cloud point. This caused operability problems for some commercial customers and
significant precipitated material was observed during inspection of depot storage tanks in the
spring of 2007. As an interim solution to the problem the industry has reverted to B2, which
had been successfully used in the Swedish market previously. The FAME used to produce
the B5 blend met the EN 14214 FAME specification and was an RME/SME mixture. An
investigation has identified the precipitates as saturated mono-glycerides. This is un-reacted
material from the FAME manufacturing process. Monoglyceride content is primarily a function
of the processing steps applied in manufacture and will vary by supply point. Perhaps
counter intuitively, perceived “heavy” or difficult FAME such as TME could often have low
mono-glyceride content because it will have undergone extra processing. Laboratory tests
have shown that precipitation of such partial glycerides can be expected from B5 blends at
typical Swedish winter temperatures due to their low solubility in diesel
These impurities have poor solubility in diesel fuel, which is temperature dependent. FAME
specifications only contain limits on total mono-glycerides and the proportion of these in a
particular FAME that are saturated will depend on the FAME type. However, for FAME types
ranging from RME to POME, a total mono-glyceride specification of 0.2% should prevent
saturated mono-glyceride precipitation in fuels with cloud points above –5 °C, while higher
levels (0.3 to 0.4%) could be tolerated in FAME such as RME that have low saturated methyl
ester contents. The effect of saturated mono-glyceride precipitation can be mitigated to some
degree by use of specific cold flow additives designed to keep the precipitate in suspension
as a finer suspended particle. These additives are still in the development phase, however it
is important to note that they will not prevent saturated mono-glyceride precipitation.
Other impurities that can impact cold properties of FAME include sterol glucosides (only
present in plant-derived FAME and most common in SME and POME). Sterol glucosides can
precipitate from the FAME itself (as opposed to the saturated mono-glycerides which
precipitate from the blended diesel fuel). Sterol glucosides have been a particular issue with
SME in the USA but correct FAME processing would be expected to prevent or minimise
their impact.
More details are given in GS.07.53836: Customer Report (S&D) - Precipitation above the
cloud point from Gas-oils containing FAME and in GS.08.54767: Customer Report (S&D) –
Understanding Biodiesel Low Temperature Issues.
10.2 Density
FAME have a relatively high density (about 880 kg/m3) compared to AGO and when blended
with AGO could lead to a product blend with a density higher than the maximum limit given
by the AGO specification (EN 590 is 845 kg/m3). This is of particular concern if the density of
the base AGO is already close to the upper limit even before blended with FAME. Especially
when the FAME is blended at the terminal the maximum density specification of the diesel
supplied should be defined in order to ensure density remains within specification after
blending the FAME into the diesel. The effect on density of blending FAME in AGO is linear,
i.e. the blend density is proportional to the concentration of FAME.
FAME and its blends demonstrate a temperature-dependent behaviour of the specific gravity
that is qualitatively similar to AGO fuels2.
2
Reference AOCS Press, Paper Number 9143 in JAOCS 77, 115-119, February 2000.
GS.07.50614 44 CONFIDENTIAL
10.3 Cetane
FAME has intrinsically higher or equivalent cetane compared to the AGO. FAME with higher
cetane (i.e. POME) can improve the cetane of base fuels. With only 5%v FAME, the
magnitude of improvement is close to the accuracy of the test method. It is recommended not
to rely upon FAME at low concentration to provide cetane quality to meet specifications.
Instead, they should preferably be blended into spec-compliant base fuel.
10.4 Viscosity
Neat FAME normally has a higher viscosity than standard AGO.
EN 14214 specifies a maximum viscosity of 5 mm2/s at 40 deg C, which is slightly more than
the maximum viscosity given by EN 590 for AGO i.e. max 4.5 mm2/s. If the base AGO and
the FAME are close to their maximum viscosity specification, this have to be taken into
account as this may lead to possible off-specification product. See also 8.1.6.
The properties and rules investigated are given in the table below. The full details are in
report OG0330932 - Investigation into existing blend rules for FAME.
Not all FAME are the same and have different properties. It is recommended that refinery will
test the available FAME in the local region and perform laboratory trial blends to gain
confidence.
GS.07.50614 45 CONFIDENTIAL
Application of “Cold Flow Property Blend Rules for FAME-to-FAME Blending” was assessed
by comparing predicted results with laboratory results. The comparison is based on POME-
RME blends with different ratios. (see report GS.08.53285)
The recommended blend rules for Cloud Point, CFPP and Pour Point are given in “Figure
12”. These blend rules had been originally developed for AGO and IGO blends and need a
small correction for bias if used for neat FAME blending.
These correction factors are within the repeatability of the reference test methods, but may
be different (likely to be larger) if using different FAME types (other than RME and POME)
and if FAME is already pre-additivated with cold flow improver additives.
12 Transportation
12.1 Introduction
FAME must be stored and handled using procedures that do not allow the temperature to
drop below 6 C above the cloud point of the FAME. . The cloud point of the FAME, the FAME
temperature, the ambient temperature, and the time the fuel is in transit are all factors that
must be taken into consideration. All handling procedures should be discussed and agreed to
by both the supplier and receiver.
FAME should be transported in a way that avoids contamination. The following guidelines are
recommended and are similar to those used by distributors and transporters of middle
distillate fuels. Therefore, in order to protect product integrity, the supplier and receiver
should agree to adhere to the guidelines.
The delivery of FAME to refinery or terminal happens either by trucks (e.g. Heide refinery) or
by barge (e.g. Harburg refinery). In case of truck delivery FAME may cool down to ambient
temperature and in case of barge delivery it may cool down to river water temperature.
Specification agreements about cold flow properties of FAME is a question of cold flow
performance in B5 or B10 but also of site-specific logistics, their capabilities for handling the
product and local climate conditions.
12.2 Tankers
Tankers dedicated to FAME should be used. If dedicated tankers are not available, non-
dedicated tankers can be considered taking into account the pre cargo. Depending on the
pre cargo adequate measures have to be taken before loading with FAME.
An example of using non-dedicated tankers in consideration of the pre cargo is shown in the
“pre cargo matrix” from ‘Rhine Supply’. The matrix is accessible on the home page of ‘Rhine
Supply’
http://sww.shell.com/downstream/supply_distribution/supply/rhine/qhse_ms/procedures/trans
port_operation.html
Example: If the pre cargo has been automotive diesel (10 ppm for Europe) the tanker has to
be “well drained” before loading with FAME. In cases the pre cargo has been Gasoil with a
high Sulphur content, e.g. IGO with 1000 ppm Sulphur, the tankers have to be “well drained”
and “stripped” before loading with FAME.
Dedicated hoses that are compatible with FAME should be used to avoid cross
contamination from residue left in the hoses. Hoses should be capped or shielded during
transportation. Tankers that have been used for heavy fuel oils or asphalt should never be
used to carry FAME fuel.
Trucks and rail cars should be made of aluminium, carbon steel, or stainless steel. Proper
inspection and washout certificates should arrive with the tank or rail car or be faxed to the
receiver prior to cargo arrival. Check composition of the last 3 previous loads for any residual
materials present.
The receiver, at their discretion, may determine that AGO fuel, kerosene or jet fuel is
acceptable as a residual. A closed cup flash point test (ASTM D93) should be performed if
light hydrocarbon material was in the transport as residual material. Certain residuals may
not be acceptable.
It should be assured that the used hoses and seals are clean and compatible with B100.
Viton or Teflon-lined hoses are recommended. Cold climate conditions may impose product
transfer difficulties. In this case it should be determined whether there is a need for insulation
or for methods to heat truck or rail car contents.
Neat FAME is generally shipped in one of the following ways during cold climate conditions:
Standard off loading procedures should be followed along with specific guidelines in
GS.06.52356 V2 - Process for Ensuring and Maintaining Product Quality from FAME (Fatty
Acid Methyl Ester) Suppliers.
The tests recommended in the above report are a minimum requirement, further tests can be
carried out if required.
When biodiesel containing FAME was first introduced into Multi Product Pipelines (MPPs) co-
transporting jet fuel in 1995, trials conducted using the best available analytical methods at
that time indicated no detectable trail back of the FAME component into following jet fuel
batches. Pipeline sequencing operations were not altered based on these data. However,
with significant advances in experimental analytical techniques, some evidence of very low-
level FAME was detected in interface samples in 2006 prompting both refinement of the
analytical methods and a further controlled pipeline trial in 2007. This controlled trial
demonstrated that low level trail back of the FAME component from biodiesel into a following
jet fuel batch can occur at detectable levels. In the absence of reliable data on historical trace
level FAME carryover in MPPs, the initial fuel supply industry advice required revision of the
sequencing of batches of biodiesel and jet fuel by employing a non-aviation buffer material
between the products.
The widespread mandatory introduction of bio-materials in automotive fuels during 2008 has
presented a significant challenge to the operators of fuel supply and distribution systems.
Whilst the use of non-aviation buffer materials between diesel fuel containing FAME and jet
fuel should still be followed whenever possible, it is acknowledged that this places a
significant operational constraint on the pipeline operator and may not be practical to
maintain the required supply integrity. Following discussions with the engine and airframe
OEM's in 2007, the approval of an effective “non-detection” limit of FAME using the latest
analytical technique was agreed. The Joint Inspection Group Ltd. (JIG) issued a detailed
GS.07.50614 49 CONFIDENTIAL
guidance bulletin (Number 15) (www.jointinspectiongroup.org) in November 2007 for the fuel
supply and distribution industry. Careful control of a combination of sequencing, batch size
and interface management can be used to ensure the level of FAME trail back into jet fuel is
below this detection limit Operators of multiproduct handling systems should also verify that
bulk contamination, even at very low levels (e.g. 0.01%), cannot occur.
Whilst pipeline operators and fuel distributors will need to go through a management of
change activity that will involve some testing for low level FAME using the new analytical
tests, it is not envisaged that routine testing of every batch will be required for two primary
reasons. Firstly, the general consistency of bulk fuel distribution operations provides surety
that once initial conditions have been tested and shown to provide the necessary control of
FAME, only periodic confirmatory testing should be needed. Secondly, management of
change systems shall be employed to ensure that any significant alteration to the distribution
operation is appropriately controlled and further FAME testing is triggered to verify the new
mode of operation. The sophisticated analytical techniques used to detect the low levels of
FAME are neither simple to run and interpret nor readily available. There are currently no
precision data for these methods.
Based on learning from an incident in the UK, it is important to note that testing activities
conducted to verify the effectiveness of QA procedures should focus on the final batch tanks
where jet fuel leaves a multi-product handling system. The handling system downstream of
the tested tank should be completely segregated from diesel containing FAME and there
must be no risk of any other contamination mechanism. If this is not the case and
downstream segregation cannot be guaranteed then FAME testing to verify downstream
operations should be performed. See JIG Bulletin 16 for further details and guidance.
The less than 5 mg/kg approval is granted on the basis that the aviation petroleum industry is
working towards an approval of 100 mg/kg FAME in jet fuel under the guidance of the engine
and airframe OEMs and that the ASTM protocol for additive and alternative fuel approval
shall be followed.
Colonial Pipeline has decided not to permit shipments of l fuels containing bio-
components at this time. Any FAME blending into AGO will therefore have to
be carried out at terminals.
The reasoning behind this decision is the fungible character of the system in combination
with the fear of liability. No technical evidence is available that there would be a problem.
GS.07.50614 50 CONFIDENTIAL
13 Additives
13.1 Additives for FAME B100
It is preferred that FAME does not contain any cold flow improvers, to
minimize, risk of interactions with other fuel additives.
Conventional AGO cold flow improvers can improve the Pour point and CFPP of B100 FAME
containing a low saturated fatty ester content. The low temperature properties of FAME with
a high-saturated fatty acid ester content cannot be significantly influenced by the introduction
of current additive technology.
Any unusual low temperature properties of FAME should be investigated further to ensure
fitness for purpose.
13.1.2 Antioxidants
The supplier needs to ensure the product will meet the specification on receipt at the Shell
location. The oxidation test in EN14214 is the EN 14112 Rancimat test, with a pass level of
>6 hours. Antioxidants can be used to achieve this result
The full list is shown below. Alternative antioxidants will need to be QAG assessed if the
market needs require further alternatives.
Alternative antioxidants are available and have been risk assessed for use in the supply
system. Contact GSMR or DSX for current assessments.
GS.07.50614 51 CONFIDENTIAL
As FAME may already contain antioxidant to ensure the Oxidation stability requirements are
met for EN14214.
Care should be taken to ensure B5 does not become overdosed with
Antioxidant.
Conventional AGO cold flow improvers are effective in B5 fuels produced from
FAME containing a low saturated fatty ester content, such as RME. Up
treating with current MDFI cannot always prevent significant increases in
CFPP for B5 fuels produced from FAME containing high-saturated fatty ester
content.
New additives, when available, will be needed to ensure high saturated FAME can be used
successfully. Until than we need to carefully consider the type of FAME that can be used in a
country, depending on the climate conditions (chapter 10.1).
Ideally before the introduction of FAME the additive supplier should be consulted to ensure
the system is robust enough to ensure low temperature operability is maintained.
13.2.3 Lubricity
There is no evidence from studies done to date that FAME has any
detrimental impact on either ester-based or acid-based lubricity additives.
FAME exhibit good lubricating properties when blended into AGO, both in the absence or
presence of lubricity additives. The extent of this effect is dependant on the FAME type.
Optimization of the level of FAME required to meet the lubricity specification needs to be
done on a case-by-case basis.
The extent of lubricity improvement varies across different FAME types (as it depends on
different raw materials and type of processing).
If the FAME content is below 2%v in the final blend, dosing of a lubricity
additive should be considered.
It is recommended that the operating unit carry out HFRR tests in the local base fuel, using
FAME from potential suppliers, to check that the particular FAME / AGO / lubricity additive
combination they intend to use will give sufficient lubricity performance in their market
( GSMR can provide advice if required).
Unexpected and large reductions in conductivity have been observed upon blending 5%
SME into base fuel containing static dissipater. Hence, the standard advice on the use of
conductivity additives is still applied, and to be verified on a case-by-case basis
FAME can cause a loss in static dissipater additive (SDA) activity.
GS.07.50614 52 CONFIDENTIAL
This should be checked for the FAME/SDA combination being used and the SDA dose rate
increased as necessary to ensure the finished fuel meets the required conductivity level to
satisfy local safety standards.
.
GS.07.50614 53 CONFIDENTIAL
The specific reprocessing route chosen will largely depend on how the slops containing non-
FAME are currently processed in the refinery. Potential routes from current practice include:
Hydrolysis, when in the presence of water in the desalter, will convert FAME into free fatty
acids and methanol. These components could remain in the organic phase representing a
potential corrosion risk in later refinery stages through the formation of methanoic acid.
Although these component are likely to be instantaneously hydrogenated and converted to
hydrocarbon and water in the HDS reactor (with increased partial hydrogen pressure), but
these corrosive mixtures could still be harmful to the upstream feed lines and vessels. For
example, free fatty acids in crude oil could lead to corrosion issues in the crude distiller but it
depends clearly on the concentration. Apart from corrosion, fatty acids can react with alkaline
salts in crude (saponification reaction) to form soaps and this increases the emulsion layer in
the desalter vessel.
• There should not be a corrosion issue if all organic acids in crude are below 0.3
mg KOH/100g.
Thermal decomposition of FAME breaks it down to shorter FAME molecules, and if distilled
into the kerosene stream may cause product contamination especially when kerosene is not
treated before sending to the Jet A1 pool.
It is recommended that the refineries investigate the origin of the slops and its process unit
configurations before deciding on the reprocessing route back to the refineries.
FAME, for e.g. 10% slops containing 5% FAME gives only 0.5% FAME on the total HDS
feed. This will require only a small increase in HDS operating temperature, i.e. Weighted
Average Bed temperature, WABT (<2 degC) and continuous monitoring. The deactivation of
catalyst (if any) is reversible. It can be assumed that the esters are fully converted into water.
For instance, Petit Couroune reprocessed about 4% of slops on CDU feed containing
approximately 0.2% of esters, based on their best estimates. No issues on CDU operation
and product quality have been reported.
• Hence, from the HDS point of view, reprocessing of slops containing FAME
should not cause big issues for 5 to 10% of slops containing <5%v FAME.
These issues have been seen at levels of 100ppm and higher in gasoline.
Introduction of FAME into a market can potentially lead to its introduction into the Industrial
gas oil or heating oil pool. This may be as contamination (at ppm levels) by the downgrading
of AGO fuel to industrial gas oil or by the deliberate introduction of FAME (at percentage
levels).
There are a number of issues (such as water contamination, oxidation stability and solvent
properties) associated with handling and storage of neat FAME, which could affect heating oil
properties if blended with FAME. Such issues have the potential to lead to problems such as
filter and pump blockage. However, use of RME in both France and Germany has revealed
no significant increase in problems or complaints in the heating oil market, despite the
potential for FAME contamination in both markets. A European-wide joint industry field trial
(EHI and Eurofuel) has been started in 2007 to investigate in fitness for purpose of heating
fuels containing 5 % FAME. No severe problems have been reported until today.
• The risks associated with FAME contamination of heating oil due to shared logistics will
be accepted by the Commercial Fuels Business and further precautions are not needed.
The relevant customer service centre, however, should be fully informed to identify as
soon as possible any potential increase in customer complaints. Today, in Germany, a
contamination of heating fuel is allowed up to a level of 0,5 % FAME according to several
industry standards
• An individual case-by-case evaluation should be performed before the downgrading of
FAME-containing diesel for use as heating oil. This should identify market specific
potential risk and assure that local requirements are met. The decision to downgrade
AGO to heating oil should be supported by a positive business case. The Commercial
Fuels business should be consulted if a risk evaluation has to be carried out.
GS.07.50614 56 CONFIDENTIAL
16 B5 in Retail.
Introduction of B5 should not require any special cleaning or flushing of retail
tanks. It is recommended that it is handled in a similar manner to AGO
containing a mid or top tier performance additive package.
Introduction of B5 into a retail network should not require any special cleaning or flushing of
retail tanks, and it is recommended that it be handled in a similar manner to AGO containing
a mid or top tier performance additive package (such as VPower Diesel). In particular, as far
as water & dirt pickup are concerned, B5 should not present any additional problems
compared to differentiated fuels.
As a precaution, however, water levels in retail tanks should be checked (either by automatic
gauge or manually) and any water removed before introducing FAME blends into the. During
normal operations, retail site staff should not be required to carry out any additional actions
beyond those that would normally be applied for the handling of AGO.
GS.07.50614 57 CONFIDENTIAL
The Quality Assurance Group (QAG) Process provides a risk-based assessment of the
fitness for purpose of new or significantly changed fuel products prior to introduction into the
market. The output is a risk assessment for the business to enable informed decision making
on acceptance/mitigation/avoidance of fuels Product Quality (PQ) risk. The process is owned
by the Fuels Product Management Group in Supply (DSX/3) and documented in a detailed
process description on the Fuels Product Management website.
A key output of the QAG Process is a Quality Assessment Record (QAR) that documents the
risk assessment outcome together with any recommended operating or use constraints. .
Generic QARs have been developed to cover use of FAME conforming to
standard specifications in main grade fuels in both Europe and the US.
Use of FAME in premium grades (V-Power Diesel) requires a case-by-case assessment and
any Operating Unit intending to introduce differentiated fuels containing FAME into their
market should contact the QAG coordinator (DSX/36) to discuss QAG requirements as early
as possible.
GS.07.50614 58 CONFIDENTIAL
18 HSE Issues
For AGO blends (up to 20%v), the fuel should be treated as conventional AGO
in all HSE aspects. FAME is generally classified as non-hazardous.
Full HSE details are provided in the Material Safety Data Sheet, contact suppliers for the
current version.
18.1 Static risks, electrical conductivity: Neat FAME and AGO Blends
Whilst neat RME shows a higher electrical conductivity than conventional AGO (250 pS/m at
20˚C as measured by the ASTM D2624-95), the effect of introducing up to 5%v RME (or
other FAME) in AGO on the overall conductivity of the blended fuel is small and not sufficient
to ensure safe handling.
Unexpected and large reductions in conductivity have been observed upon blending 5%
SME into base fuel containing static dissipater. Hence, the standard advice on the use of
conductivity additives is still applied, and to be verified on a case-by-case basis.
Neat FAME can self-ignite when soaked into porous material, e.g. rags,
textiles, insulations and inorganic materials, therefore materials saturated
with FAME should be disposed of correctly.
High Iodine value FAME when under high surface to air ratios, can oxidise rapidly and
generate excessive heat. When the temperature rises above its ignition point, combustion
then begins in the presence of sufficient oxygen. Therefore neat FAME soaked into porous
material, e.g. rags of a critical mass in an open container or drum can self-ignite and cause
spontaneous combustion. Recently two incidents were reported by US Independent Liquid
Terminals Association (ILTA) on the spontaneous combustion of saturated rags soaked with
biodiesel. To prevent such incidents from happening at terminals when handling neat FAME,
the following practices are recommended:
1. Conduct a facility audit for FAME exposure, locations of loading/unloading and the
proper location for the FAME disposal drums.
2. Proper signage at all loading and unloading points indicating FAME rags need to be
placed in the proper containers.
3. Containers are properly labelled FAME Rags Only and filled with enough water to
cover the saturated rags.
4. Before disposal, wash rags with soap and water, and dry in well-ventilated area.
5. Discuss the hazards of FAME with all staff and visitors to the facility that might be
working with this material.
Improve housekeeping at all facilities especially those areas where FAME might be present
to limit the exposure to fire and/or damage in the event of a fire.
GS.07.50614 59 CONFIDENTIAL
Many FAMEs are sold as the “source oil or fat”-methyl ester, and many of these are identified
by their CAS and EINECS numbers (Appendix I) There are, however, no specific substance
identities for used cooking oils or some of the newer oil sources, such as Jatropha.
There are, however, at least four (A-D below) generic descriptors for FAMEs, covering
slightly different ranges of fatty acid composition, which could be useful.
Descriptor CAS No EINECS No
Fatty acids, C16-18 and C18-unsatd., Me esters 67762-38-3 267-015-4 A
Fatty acids, C16-18 and C16-18-unsatd., Me 102047-28-9 310-005-2 B
esters
Fatty acids, C14-18 and C16-18-unsatd. Me 67762-26-9 267-007-0 C
esters
Fatty acids, vegetable oil, Me esters 68990-52-3 273-606-8 D
The first (A) is the most specific, and covers around 90% of the composition of most FAMEs
derived from both vegetable oils and animal fats. In consequence, we have used this
substance identity to pre-register most FAME imports into Europe for Shell Trading, under
the new REACH Legislation. Certain (high erucic acid) forms of Rape Methyl Ester (RME)
would only be covered by descriptions D & R, and we have also pre-registered using “R”.
In making the FAME pre-registrations, we have linked them to some of the individual fatty
acid methyl esters, such as methyl oleate, as they have been known for years and extensive
HSE information is available in the public domain. (Enter the CAS or EINECS No in the ESIS
database (http://ecb.jrc.ec.europa.eu/esis/) and click on “IUCLID Chemical Data Sheet”). The
mapping of CAS Numbers and typical fatty acid compositions and oil/fat sources is given in
Appendix J.
Shorter fatty acid chain length FAMEs form another family that are currently not imported into
Europe, although “Fatty acids, coco, Me esters” are used in fuels in the East. It is exempt
from Registration under REACH. The FAME from Palm Kernel oil is a similar substance but
not currently imported or exempt from REACH.
The chemical composition of FAMEs derived from other sources (fish, algae, etc) would need
to be checked to see if any of the generic descriptors was suitable, or it had already been
given a separate substance identity, otherwise the material needs to be registered as a new
substance.
Inclusion on the local Chemical Inventory, where it exists, is generally a requirement for
manufacture and sale in that country. This can be checked via the ARIEL database at
https://webinsight.arielresearch.com/ . Contact a business Product Steward or the Product
Regulatory Support Group to run a search or if you require access.
GS.07.50614 60 CONFIDENTIAL
In Europe, the current EN590 standard covers FAME contents of up to 5%v (B5). CEN have
been requested by the European Commission to recommend necessary changes to EN590
to cover B10 blends. Activities to investigate potential issues associated with B10 are also
ongoing in some national inter-industry organisations (such as the German DGMK).
Objections to the use of B10 are currently being voiced by some OEMs (particularly in
Germany). These revolve around issues of:
• Increased fouling of injectors from the higher FAME content and how this is related to the
oxidation stability of the B10. Some OEMs are pushing for changes in the EN590
oxidation stability test to account for this. Initial results suggest that B10 blends can lead
to loss of engine power with time compared to conventional AGO. This is associated with
increased injector fouling
• Non-compatibility of current elastomer seals with B10 blends
• Incompatibility with current methods of regeneration of particulate traps
• Accelerated dilution and degradation of the lube oil
Based on discussion within CEN between the oil companies, OEMs, and biodiesel producers
the acceptance level of biodiesel in EN 590 is expected to increased to max 7% v/v. However
in order to make sure that the final blend still is “fit for purpose” an additional oxidation
stability specification (EN 15751) of min 20 hr will be introduced for blends containing more
than 2% v/v FAME (voting in CEN Jan 2009).
In the US, a new specification (ASTM D7467) for B6-B20 blends was approved at the ASTM
meeting.
In Europe France has introduced B7 in 2008 with some adjustments in the national diesel
specification (oxidation stability, mandated BHT level of 1000 ppm, limited increase TAN).
Higher concentrations of FAME are used by captive fleets with a high variety in specifications
often developed in close cooperation with the OEMs.
GS.07.50614 61 CONFIDENTIAL
However, similar issues are expected as with FAME, although physical properties of the base
esters will be different, notably in viscosity, density and low temperature properties.
GS.07.50614 62 CONFIDENTIAL
GTL blending in diesel up to a level of 5% will not cause interaction with FAME
(change in solvency characteristics). Higher concentrations up to a level of
30% have shown to be compatible but local testing is recommended before
blending of GTL is started.
One of the possible issues when blending high levels of GTL into diesel is the change in
solvency characteristics (no aromatics in GTL). This can change the solubility behaviour of
FAME contaminants like mono saturated glycerides and steroglucocides and result in
precipitation.
Oxidation
Density Viscosity Flash Water Cloud
Acid Value CFPP stability
15C KV40 point Content point
Rancimat
kg/m3 cSt mgKOH/g °C mg/kg °C °C Hrs
Average 883.3 4.434 0.28 151 235 -4.9 -15.5 7.1
Std Dev 0.25 0.067 0.08 14.9 55 1.2 3.6 0.7
Max 884.0 4.505 0.46 174 396 -3 -9 8.4
Min 870.3 3.966 0.13 80 128 -7 -22 4
Distillation profile °C
360.0
350.0
340.0
Temperature C
330.0
320.0
310.0
300.0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
- - - Error bars 3xStd Dev % distilled
GS.07.50614 68 CONFIDENTIAL
30 100.%
Frequency
25 80.%
20 60.%
15
10 40.%
5 20.%
0 .%
e
4
8
2
or
2.
2.
3.
3.
4.
4.
88
88
88
88
88
88
88
88
M
Frequency Cumulative % Density 15C kg/m3
14 100.%
12 80.%
Frequency
10
8 60.%
6 40.%
4
2 20.%
0 .%
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
10
14
18
22
26
30
34
38
42
46
50
-9
-7
-5
5
3
1
9
7
5
3
1
-2
-2
-2
-1
-1
-1
-1
-1
Frequency Cumulative % CFPP C
20 80.%
15 60.%
10 40.%
5 20.%
0 .%
0
e
M 0
-9
-8
-7
-6
-5
-4
-3
-2
-1
or
-1
30 80.%
60.%
20
40.%
10 20.%
0 .%
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 More
Oxidation Stability (Rancimat Hrs)
Frequency Cumulative %
GS.07.50614 70 CONFIDENTIAL
or
M
Frequency Cumulative % Acid value mgKOH/g
15
60.%
10
40.%
5 20.%
0 .%
4
M 5
e
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
4.
4.
or
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
30 100.%
25
Frequency
80.%
20 60.%
15
10 40.%
5 20.%
0 .%
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
M 0
e
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
or
Frequency Cumulative % Flashpoint C
Fr 4 80.%
eq 3 60.%
ue
nc 2 40.%
y 1 20.%
0 .%
5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
More
Frequency Cumulative CFPP
% deg C
GS.07.50614 72 CONFIDENTIAL
5 60.%
4
3 40.%
2 20.%
1
0 .%
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
M 0
e
87
87
87
87
87
87
87
87
87
87
88
or
Frequency Cumulative % Density
8
60.%
6
40.%
4
2 20.%
0 .%
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
4
M 5
e
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
4.
or
2.5
2 60.%
1.5 40.%
1
20.%
0.5
0 .%
50
52
54
56
58
60
62
64
66
68
70
72
Frequency Cumulative % Iodine value
4.5 100.%
4
3.5 80.%
Frequency
3
60.%
2.5
2
40.%
1.5
1 20.%
0.5
0 .%
e
2
4
6
8
2
4
6
8
1
3
1.
1.
1.
1.
2.
2.
2.
2.
or
M
8 80.%
6 60.%
4 40.%
2 20.%
0 .%
e
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
or
87
87
87
87
87
88
88
88
M
Density
Frequency Cumulative %
12 100.%
10 80.%
Frequency
8
60.%
6
40.%
4
2 20.%
0 .%
4 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 4.9 5 More
Viscosity
Frequency Cumulative %
GS.07.50614 75 CONFIDENTIAL
6 100.%
Frequency
80.%
4 60.%
2 40.%
20.%
0 .%
e
-4
-2
or
M
CFPP C
Frequency Cumulative %
5 100.%
Frequency
4 80.%
3 60.%
2 40.%
1 20.%
0 .%
70
72
74
76
78
80
82
84
86
88
90
Iodine Value
Frequency Cumulative %
GS.07.50614 76 CONFIDENTIAL
e
2
4
6
8
2
4
6
8
3
4
or
2.
2.
2.
2.
3.
3.
3.
3.
M
C18:3 Content %
Frequency Cumulative %
GS.07.50614 77 CONFIDENTIAL
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Coconut
Soybean
Corn
Cottonseed
Sunflower
Lard
Rapeseed
Olive
Safflower
Palm
Peanut
Tallow
Butterfat
Beef
Saturated fatty acids Mono-unsaturated fatty acids Poly-unsaturated fatty acids
GS.07.50614 78 CONFIDENTIAL
Two procedures for the determination of iodine value are provided by EN 14214.
EN14111 a titrimetric method using Wijs reagent is suggested. It can be calculated from the
relative methyl ester contents as determined by capillary gas chromatography according to
EN 14103. Here iodine values are obtained by adding up the respective contributions of each
unsaturated ester contained in the sample, multiplying the methyl ester mass per cents with
conversion factors characteristic of each compound. See below.
B.1 Scope
This method describes a procedure for calculating the iodine value of neat biodiesel or
biodiesel extracted from blends with diesel fuel. In case of dispute on the iodine value this
method shall not be used as a substitute for EN 14111.
B.2 Definition
This method is used to calculate the iodine value expressed in g I2 /100 g sample from the
percentage by mass of methyl esters as determined by either EN 14103 (neat biodiesel) or
EN 14331 [1] (biodiesel extracted from blends with diesel fuel).
B.3 Procedure
The methyl ester composition of the sample is checked using the appropriate method as
described in paragraph 2. NOTE: The total methyl esters thus revealed should equal 100
after the deduction of the methyl ester C17 used for internal standard in EN 14103.
The percentage by mass thus obtained is then used to calculate the sample’s iodine value,
being the sum of the individual contributions of each methyl ester, obtained by multiplying the
methyl ester percentage by its respective factor (Table B.1), as indicated in the example in
Table B.2.The factor for each constituent of biodiesel is given in Table B.1.
Table B.1
METHYL ESTER FACTORS
Methyl ester Factor
Methyl ester of saturated fatty acids 0
Methyl hexadecenoate (Methyl palmitoleate) C16:1 0,950
Methyl octadecenoate (Methyl oleate) C18:1 0,860
Methyl octadecadienoate (Methyl lineolate) C18:2 1,732
Methyl octadecatrienoate (Methyl linolenate) C18:3 2,616
Methyl eicosenoate C20:1 0,785
Methyl docasenoate (Methyl erucate) C22:1 0,723
GS.07.50614 80 CONFIDENTIAL
An example of the calculation of iodine value from the percentage by mass of methyl esters
is given in Table B.2
Table B.2
CALCULATION EXAMPLE
Methyl ester of the Percentage % Factor Contribution
following acids m/m
Myristic C14:0 0,3 0 0
Palmitic C16:0 4,0 0 0
Palmitoleic C16:1 1,1 0,950 1,0
Stearic C18:0 2,0 0 0
Oleic C18:1 60,5 0,860 52,0
Linoleic C18:2 19,8 1,732 34,3
Linolenic C18:3 9,4 2,616 24,6
Eicosanoic C20:0 0,4 0 0
Eicosenoic C20:1 0,7 0,785 0,6
Docosanoic C22:0 0,7 0 0
Docosenoic C22:1 1,1 0,723 0,8
Calculated Iodine 113,3
Value
tallow
soybean
FAME type
rapeseed
palm
coco
The Rancimat test Figure 12 measures the induction period prior to the onset of rapid
oxidation.
Air is passed through the sample, at a specific temperature (110 ºC). The gases released,
are absorbed in water and the conductivity is measured. Figure 13 Determination of
Oxidation Stability Principle.
The time at which the conductivity begins to increase rapidly is defined as the induction time.
Figure 14 Typical Rancimat Trace
Acids produced during the oxidation process and are absorbed in the water causing the
conductivity to increase.
Figure 15 is a schematic of the neat FAME floating roof storage tank as being used at Petit
Couronne by Shell France
FAME that is used is a mixture of RME, TME, UCOME, SME that is blended up to the EN
14214 specification at a third party location. From the third party location the FAME is
shipped to Pernis refinery where a separate line is used to fill the two storage tanks (content
10.000 m3) usage is 8kt.month. Stock level is kept below 6kt
The FAME doesn’t/t contain any flow improver, but in order to assure good pumpablity the
CFPP in winter is specified at max –10 C.
Oxidation stability of the FAME is tested every two weeks, no problems meeting the
specification have been reported up till now.
FAME storage at the third party supplier and at Pernis is checked for microbial contamination
every month. (sample from lowest sample point). No issues have been reported up till now.
Blending of the FAME at the refinery is done in line and blended into the final tank together
with the other diesel components (LGO, Kero and HCU-gasoil)
Conductivity additive is added to the mixture (Stadis 450) in a concentration of 2 ppm in order
to have a minimum conductivity of 100 pS/m.
Lubricity additive is not used anymore except for the blends that are moved via RMR
(pipeline to Germany) Infineum R655 at 120 ppm
For RMR blends dedicated blend tanks are used as the product should not contain FAME.
Type of cold flow additive that is used is Infineum R720 (wasa) and R591 (MDFI) and is
dosed at a concentration of 150 ppm, 300 ppm regardless whether the product contains
FAME. Responds up till was sufficient to meet the spec.
Tanks (fixed roof) at Pernis are drained for water after every discharge and minimum once
very week. Before blending Up till now the amount of water removed from the tank is
minimum. Typical water content of the FAME is 300-400 ppm.
GS.07.50614 87 CONFIDENTIAL
Bibliographic Information
This report has been classified as Confidential and is not subject to US Export Control
regulations.
Report distribution
Outside Shell Global Solutions
Company name and address E or P No. of
paper
copies
Joanna Pedley, SIPC-DSX/3 E
John Hargis, SUKOP-DSX/33 E
Christian Hoppe, DSO-DSX/33 E
Kersten Ross, SEPL-DAS/53 E
Greg Kamla, SOPUS-DSX/32 E
Silvia Lugea, SCAPSA-DSX/38 E
Jan Maarten Teuben, SPSHELL-DSX/36 E
Eva Bednarik, SAT-DSX/39 E
Mike Battie, SIPC-DSX/392 E
David Williams, SDSI-DME/43 E
Vincent Tertois, SPSHELL-DIC/65 E
Bernadette Schlenter, SDSI-DSD/111 E
John Unsworth, GSUK-GSMR/2 E
Mike Farmery, SIPC-DIA/12 E
Karen Crawley, STASCO-STO/3 E
Tony Clarke-Sturman, SIPC-DSX/31 E
Patsy Clegg, SDIUS-DSX/314 E
This report can be freely shared with all Shell Global Solutions employees.