The Canal Water Dispute
Indian/Pakistan Disputes of 1947 and onwards
What was the dispute about?
Reasons for the dispute.
Reconciling approaches.
Aftermaths of the dispute.WHAT WAS IT? THE S & CLAIMS:
SG SUR RUN Oe Cee Rem)
What PRU COS MCSE ec OC
experienced a hot, arid climate. Rainfall was scanty and thus relied upon irrigation from a series
ESE M MCN ee eel OE
OM SCIRUS IE ECCLES CURE SES TT UCU REC m rCUR UTD eS
Why India, in cities such as Ferozepur.
OECD CMOS TU RTC R Ua Tbe Se UEC ne EL
Indians demanded Pakistan to pay for the water.
ae 8 e India claimed that they wished to do anything as they had the right to the land
India Ss Claim ETRE CU eee USEC OSC UEC
1 7 1 e Pakistan claimed the right to the water under International-Lawias»their
Pakistan S$ Claim economy was dependent on it.Fee aaa LUUL SRO AU LST
Kashmir Relation:
Joint Commissions:
India proposed a joint
commission to solve the
dispute. There was no
agreed decision in the
end.
The Kashmir issue was
also related to the Canal
Water dispute, as three of
the rivers (Indus, Jhelum,
Chenab) came _ into
Pakistan from the Indian
Occupied Kashmir.
INT Court of Justice:
Pakistan asked the International Court of Justice to help
settle the dispute legally but India refused to participate.STANDSTILL/TEMPORARY AGREEMENTS
May
1948
In this year, Temporary
Agreement was reached in
to allow water from East
Punjab (Indian side) to
flow into West Punjab
(Pakistani Side) until
Pakistan looks for an
alternative water supplies.
In 1952, The World
Bank _ intervened
and offered to help
with financial and
technical support
to settle the
dispute.
Pakistan accused India
of cutting the flow of
water which — was
contrary to — the
agreement, charge
which India repeatedly
denied.
After numerous World
Bank recommendations,
a temporary agreement
was reached to which
India agreed ~—but
Pakistan did not.THE INDUS WATER TREATY, 1959
The final permanent agreement between the two nations with the World Bank
witnessing was reached on 19 September 1959, called the Indus Water Treaty. The
terms of the treaty are as follows:
- India was given the control of Ravi, Beas and
Sutlej Rivers
- Pakistan had the control of Indus, Jhelum and
Chenab rivers.
+ World Bank promised to help build dams,
hydroelectric production and soil reclamation
in both countries.
« Main advantage for Pakistan was that India
could not interfere legally with the water that
was now in their control (Indus, Jhelum and
Chenab)SSE UNS sas
e Following the Indus Treaty water wars had decreased significantly between
Pakistan and India. However, India has built the Kishangaha dam in Indian
occupied Kashmir and is working on a hydro electric project in Chenab.
e India had threatened to stop water reaching Pakistan from rivers that flow
from and even broke the rules of the treaty by building the Baglihar dam on
the Chenab river.