Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI: 10.1002/pi.917
Abstract: Poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) has wide acceptance for use in direct contact with food,
can be recycled and can be depolymerized to its monomer constituents. Advances are continually being
made to reduce the environmental `footprint' that the polymer leaves. This paper discusses new
advances in three speci®c areas, ie process developments, catalysis and polymer degradation, that
address this issue.
# 2002 Society of Chemical Industry
* Correspondence to: WA MacDonald, DuPont Teijin Films, PO Box 2002, Wilton, Middlesbrough TS90 8JF, UK
†
Keynote lecture – Session A: Paper presented at the Polymers in the Third Millennium Conference, 2–6 September 2001, Montpellier,
France
(Received 27 July 2001; revised version received 21 November 2001; accepted 22 January 2002)
escape by vapour diffusion from the solid chip and are matter patents that are currently being ®led for the
rapidly removed from the surface of the chip instead of NG3 intermediate and ®nal products.
being limited by viscous diffusion through a bulk melt. The signi®cant process simpli®cation with NG3 and
SSP commonly raises the DP from about 100 to 140 resulting elimination of several unit operation steps,
repeat units.4 makes the NG3 process less capital-intensive, and as a
A new technology has recently been developed by result has lower maintenance and energy costs.
DuPont and is a signi®cant departure from conven- Compared to conventional technologies, NG3 offers
tional CP technology.5±9 This technology, designated signi®cant economy-of-scale advantages. In conven-
NG3 (from `Next Generation version 3') eliminates tional technologies, the size of the ®nisher or high
several vessels in the melt plant and instead uses a two- polymerizer restricts the ultimate capacity of a single
vessel continuous process (Fig 3). In addition to this, melt plant line. Because the NG3 process eliminates
the NG3 process eliminates the need for extensive the ®nisher, the size of an NG3 plant is not constrained
overhead condensing and vacuum systems, and like that of conventional technologies. In addition, the
inherent dif®culties linked with handling high-viscos- elimination of several steps required in the conven-
ity polymer. Instead the NG3 process produces a low tional process enables a signi®cant reduction in both
molecular weight intermediate in the melt phase with a the initial plant investment and the ongoing operating
DP of around 20±30. These pastilles are then cost. Not only does NG3 have capital cost advantages
conveyed to the solid-state polymerizer where the bulk over competitor technologies, it also offers savings in
of the polycondensation is carried out to reach the operating cost, eg less operating labour, reduced
required degree of polymerization. For this technology maintenance and insulation costs due to reduction in
to be viable the low molecular weight pastilles must be equipment, fewer motors and lower total electrical
robust enough to withstand the solid-state polymer- demand. In terms of the impact on the living
ization. DuPont scientists have developed a novel and environment the signi®cant bene®t of all this is that
proprietary technology whereby the particle formation the NG3 process technology leaves a smaller environ-
technology imparts a unique crystal structure to the mental `footprint'.
pellets providing the required strength for solid stating. In addition to its technical and investment advan-
The crystal structure is the basis for composition of tages, DuPont claim that the NG3 process technology
will bring product advantages to the market in terms of a balance of good activity and good colour. This results
productivity with respect to bottle blowing, product in polymers with excellent clarity and also improve-
quality (clarity and gloss) and properties (lower ments in reaction rates, so offering the potential of
residual acetaldehyde levels which lead to lower extra capacity on existing assets.
¯avour taint, and improved strength). One route taken to achieve this has been to form
titanium chelates with, for example, 2-hydroxy car-
boxylic acids such as citric, malic or lactic.15 Catalysts
3. ADVANCES IN PET CATALYSIS of this type are less active than the alkoxides, but can
A large number of main group and transition metals be more ef®cient as they are water-stable and less
have been shown to have catalytic activity for the titanium is knocked out as inactive oxoalkoxides.
polycondensation of PET.10±14 Antimony oxide (and Catalysts of this type are also soluble in ethylene glycol
derivatives thereof) historically emerged as the catalyst at room temperature, making them easy to handle on a
of choice because it demonstrates a good balance of manufacturing plant and meeting regulatory require-
catalytic activity in the presence of the phosphorus- ments for use in contact with food. With careful
based stabilizer, colour and cost. Germanium oxide is control of the balance of titanium to phosphorus and
also used; although it is a more active catalyst than with the incorporation of a blueing agent, such as
antimony, the high cost of the germanium precludes its cobalt acetate or red/blue dyes, good polymerization
common use in commercial production of PET. In rates can be achieved and the inherent yellow colour of
addition to increasing output through process design the titanium-catalysed polymers can be minimized or
as discussed above, increased rates through improve- masked. The optimum titanium content can be as low
ments in catalysts offer a further route to improving as 10±30 ppm compared with 250±300 ppm elemental
plant ef®ciencies. Furthermore, the use of antimony- antimony for an antimony-oxide-catalysed polycon-
based catalysts in the preparation of PET used in densations.3 A further development has been to
packaging applications have come under increasing incorporate an organophosphorus-based compound
scrutiny within Europe and Asia and this, together into the catalyst. This allows catalysts to be developed
with the desire to increase output, has led to PET that are optimized to have a balance of good reaction
manufacturers researching potential alternatives to rate and yet yield polymers of good colour.16
antimony which offer a balance of compliance with Despite the importance of catalysis to PET manu-
food contact regulations, activity, cost and colour. By facture, the mechanism of catalysis in the polycon-
far the front runner as an alternative to antimony that densation reaction is poorly understood; yet an
meets the above criteria is titanium. increased understanding of how the metal centre
Titanium-based catalysts are very active relative to interacts with the polymerizing PET chain is impor-
antimony, and the ®rst generation of titanium catalysts tant for facilitating further developments in catalyst
were either alkoxides or simple chelates. Although they design. Two different mechanisms have been pro-
were found to enhance reaction rates, they were prone posed: (i) coordination to the carboxyl group and (ii)
to hydrolysis to form oxoalkoxides which have reduced coordination to the hydroxyl group.
activity and give rise to haze in the polymer, yielded The mechanism proposed by Ravindranath28 in-
polymers of poor colour and were sensitive to volves a hexacoordinate metal catalyst molecule. It was
deactivation in the presence of phosphorus-based proposed that the primary step involved coordination
stabilizers. Several companies are now developing of the metal ion to the ester carbonyl bond. The
titanium-based catalyst systems: Synetix,15,16 Du- coordination of the ester carbonyl group lowers the
Pont17±23 Lurgi Zimmer and Sachtleben,24 Akzo electron density of the carbonyl carbon atom and
Nobel,25 Atochem26 and Hoechst27 are several who facilitates nucleophilic attack. It was proposed that the
have patented in this area. These latest catalysts are reaction then proceeded via the activation of the
designed to be stable and have been formulated to give hydroxyl end-group of a different incoming polymer
that under conditions of thermal degradation, PET degraded in air at 300 °C closely matched that of II.
undergoes a b scission reaction resulting in the Further oxidation of these degraded PET samples with
formation of a vinyl ester end-group and a carboxyl lead oxide led to further changes in the ¯uorescence
end-group (Fig 6). These vinyl ends can undergo and phosphorescence spectra that were proposed to be
further reactions, one of which leads to polymerization associated with further degradation of the hydroxy-
of the vinyl group ultimately to yield polyenes.24 lated species.
However, experimental evidence for this in the A possible pathway for colour formation in PET is
literature is minimal and studies were carried out shown in Fig 7. Peroxidation of the PET occurs at the
within our own laboratory by N Everall to look for ether link in DEG incorporated into PET. The
evidence of polyenes. Measurement of the conjugated peroxides break down to give hydroxy radicals which
Ð(C=C)nÐ stretching frequency using resonance attack the phenyl ring and ultimately lead to quinone-
Raman spectroscopy gives precise information on the type structures incorporated into the PET backbone.
value and polydispersity of the conjugation length `n', These compounds have only to be present in ppm
and allows detection of the polyenes at very low levels. amounts for the PET to be discoloured. The pathways
This is because polyene bands are very strong when are deliberately left as dotted lines as the intermediates
the laser wavelength falls within the electronic can only be guessed at.
absorption pro®le, even dominating the spectrum at
levels as low as 0.5 ppm. The classical examples of this 4.3 Heterogeneity of degradation
occur in elimination reactions of vinyl polymers, such Pellets of PET were dried and then annealed at 235 °C
as dehydrochlorination of PVC, or dehydration of for 1 and 3 h in air. The samples were then cooled and
poly(vinyl alcohol).33 If polyenes were present in a 30±35 mm section microtomed along as close as
degraded PET then they should be readily apparent possible the long axis of the chip. End-group measure-
in the Raman spectrum. However, no evidence was ments were undertaken within our own laboratory
found for the presence of polyenes in any of the using transmission IR microscopy (N Everall, PJ Mills
degraded PET samples studied, even when the
samples were highly coloured. This strongly suggests
that classical polyenes are not responsible for the Table 2. Change in DEG level after repeated passes through an extruder
colour formation in PET. In further studies carried out Number of Mol% DEG Mol% DEG
by Edge et al 34,35 at The Manchester Metropolitan passes (extrusion rate 10 kg/h) (extrusion rate 20 kg/h)
University, changes in the ¯uorescence and phosphor-
0 2.8 2.8
escence spectra of PET degraded in the absence and 4 2.2 2.1
presence of oxygen at melt temperatures were com-
pared relative to model compounds such as 2,5-
dihydroxydiethylterephthalate (II) and 2,2,6,6'-tetra
(test-butyl)stilbenequinone (III).
and J Chalmers). The microscope apertures were set to polymer can be inhomogeneous. Confocal Raman
give a sampling area of about 200 mm by 25 mm. The microscopy can also been used on these materials to
intensity of the vibrations due to COOH (3255 cm 1) measure crystallinity pro®les over the same region of
and OH (3542 cm 1) were internally referenced to the the chips; one normally ®nds correlations between
1950 cm 1 band to normalize for thickness variations. crystallinity and end-group balance. This has been
Values plotted were normalized to a control sample. useful in understanding solid-phase polymerization
The depth over which degradation was measured was processes and the in¯uence on chip `sintering'.
small compared to the chip dimensions. As the Chemiluminescence (CL) has gained recognition as
polyester degraded the concentration of COOH a technique for studying the degradative processes in a
increased relative to OH. It can seen from Fig 8 that variety of polymers.36 In the presence of air, when
the proportion of COOH was highest at the surface polymers oxidize they emit small quantites of light and
and decreased into the bulk. With further time this this CL can be used to track the rate of oxidation.
became more pronounced. This indicates that oxygen Recently, Fredrikssen37 has investigated the degrada-
diffusion is controlling the thermo-oxidative degrada- tion of PET using CL: this is the ®rst time this
tion, but also demonstrates that the degradation of technique has been used to study the thermo-oxidative
degradation process in PET.37 The CL detecting
29 Parshall GW and Ittel S, in Homogeneous Catalysis, 2nd edn, 33 Gerrald DL and Maddams WF, Appl Spectrosc Rev 22:251
Wiley, (1992) (1986).
30 Kelly R, Synthesis and characterisation of intermediates in metal 34 Edge M, Allen NS, Wiles R, MacDonald WA and Mortlock SV,
alkoxide catalysed PET polymerisation, PhD thesis, University Polymer 36:227 (1995).
35 Edge M, Allen NS, Wiles R, MacDonald WA and Mortlock SV,
of Newcastle (2000).
Polym Degrad Stab 53:141 (1996).
31 Pilati F, Comp Polym Sci 17:275 (1989).
36 Goerge GA, in Developments in Polymer Degradation, Vol 3,
32 Zimmerman H, in The Degradation and Stabilisation of Polyesters, Applied Science Publishing, London. Chapter 6 (1981).
Vol 5, Ed by Grassie N, Applied Science Publishers, London, 37 Fredrikssen EA, Chemiluminescence from the thermal oxidation
UK (1984). of PET, PhD thesis, University of Sussex (1999).