You are on page 1of 7

Journal of Counseling Psychology Copyright 1988 by the American Psychological Association, Inc.

1988, Vol- 35, No. 3, 472-478 0022-0167/8 8/$00.7 5

Perceived Social Support Among College Students: Factor Structure


of the Social Support Inventory
Steven D. Brown Dona Alpert
Department of Counseling and Department of Educational
Educational Psychology, and Psychological Studies,
Loyola University of Chicago University of Miami

Robert W. Lent George Hunt


Division of Counseling Psychology, Department of Counseling and
Michigan State University Educational Psychology,
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.

Loyola University of Chicago


This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.

Teresa Brady
Sister Kenny Institute,
Minneapolis, Minnesota

Brown, Brady, Lent, Wolfert, and Hall (1987) developed a measure of perceived social support
based on a person-environment fit model of satisfaction. This measure, the Social Support
Inventory (SSI), was scored according to a model of person-environment fit that assumed that
only an undersupply of resources for meeting social needs would result in dissatisfaction. We
tested this assumption empirically by comparing the original scoring model with three alternative
models. Our study also explored the factor structure of the SSI. Results supported the original
scoring model and suggested the presence of five social support factors on the SSI. We discuss
the limitations of the study and future research needs of the SSI and the person-environment fit
model.

A large and growing body of literature published over the and (2) a concomitant failure to define the construct ade-
past decade has demonstrated the importance of social sup- quately into its component processes (e.g., Cohen & Syme,
port in promoting mental health and preventing psychological 1985; Heller et al., 1986; Levy, 1983).
distress. Several recent reviewers (e.g., Cohen & Syme, 1985; In response to the first criticism, Brown et al. (1987) devel-
Heller, Swindle, & Dusenbury, 1986; Levy, 1983) have con- oped a measure of perceived social support from a person-
cluded unanimously that the absence of social support is environment (P-E) fit conception of interpersonal satisfac-
associated with increased psychological distress and that this tion. The fundamental tenet of the Brown et al. (1987) model
general finding holds across diverse subject samples, social- was that satisfaction with social support is a function of the
support and distress measures, and research designs. However, match between the strength of one's interpersonal needs (i.e.,
most reviewers have also noted that despite the convincing requirements for others that persons believe to be critical to
evidence of social support's value, we still have little basic their success, survival, or emotional welfare) and the amount
understanding of how social ties (or one's satisfaction with of social resources provided to fulfill those needs. It was
them) function to protect mental health and promote psycho- further hypothesized that dissatisfaction resulting from the
logical adjustment (e.g., Brown, Brady, Lent, Wolfert, & Hall, failure of the interpersonal environment to provide ade-
1987; Heller et al., 1986; Levy, 1983; Thoits, 1986). This quately for the individual's interpersonal needs would be
limited understanding of social support's underlying mecha- accompanied by behavioral, emotional, and physiological
nisms has, according to reviewers, resulted largely from two strain and by a motive to achieve greater fit with the interper-
interrelated weaknesses in the literature, (1) a failure to embed sonal environment.
the construct into a consistent body of theory that would The Social Support Inventory (SSI), developed by Brown
suggest its mechanisms of action and antecedent processes et al. (1987) from this model, contains 39 interpersonal need
(e.g., Brown et al., 1987; Heller et al., 1986; Thoits, 1986), statements (e.g., assistance in changing self-defeating behav-
ior) that respondents rate on two scales, (1) "How much of
this type of help or support have you needed in the past
We thank Dorothy Breen, Amy Culbertson, Karen Multon, Doris month?" (Need Strength, 1 = none to 7 = very much), and
Stormoen, Ellanora Ward, and Jenny Wolfert for their assistance
(2) "How much of this type of help or support have you
with this research; and Linda Heath for reading and commenting on
received in the past month?" (Perceived Supply, 1 = none to
an earlier draft of this manuscript.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to
7 = very much). A perceived fit (SSI-PF) score is derived by
Steven D. Brown, Department of Counseling and Educational Psy- subtracting Perceived Supply (S) from Need Strength (N)
chology, Loyola University of Chicago, 820 North Michigan Avenue, ratings and summing over all 39 items. The SSI also contains
Chicago, Illinois 60611. a direct measure of satisfaction in which respondents rate

472
PERCEIVED SOCIAL SUPPORT 473

each individual need statement in terms of "How satisfied identical and when S ratings were larger than N ratings (which
have you been with what you have received in terms of this indicates an excess of resources to meet a particular interper-
type of help or support over the past month?" (1 = not at all sonal need).
to 7 = very much). A total Subjective Satisfaction (SSI-SS) However, at least two alternative models of the relation
score is obtained by summing ratings over all 39 items. between fit and satisfaction may be empirically reasonable, at
As predicted by the P-E fit theory from which the SSI was least for some types of interpersonal needs. All three models
derived, Brown et al. (1987) found in a sample of undergrad- are summarized schematically in Figure 1. (Positive numbers
uate college students, significant correlations between SSI-PF on the horizontal axis indicate conditions of oversupply of
and SSI-SS scores (r = -.77) and between SSI-PF scores and resources for needs; negative numbers represent conditions of
measures of anxiety (/• = .54), depression (r = .57), psycho- undersupply; and 0 indicates a condition of perfect lit between
somatic symptoms (r = .31), and health risk behaviors (r = needs and social resources.) The model on which the Brown
.20). SSI-PF scores also correlated more substantially with et al. (1987) scoring procedure was based is illustrated by
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.

direct satisfaction and strain measures than did measures of Curve B (a curvilinear function that plateaus at perfect P-E
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.

total network size, relationship quality, or frequency of receipt fit, i.e., when N = S). Curve A represents a linear relation
of socially supportive behaviors. Finally, results suggested that between P-E fit and satisfaction, suggesting that an excess of
the SSI is independent of respondent mood state and experi- supplies relative to needs (N < S) results in increasing levels
mental demand and that it may be useful as a diagnostic tool of satisfaction over perfect P-E fit. Finally, Curve C represents
in counseling interventions for college students who have a situation in which both an excess (N < S) and deficit (N >
difficulty adjusting to the university environment. S) of supplies in relation to need strength leads to reduced
Left unanswered by this first study, however, is the question satisfaction. In the present study we compared the adequacy
of the multidimensionality of perceived support as measured of the Brown et al. (1987) scoring model with these two
by the SSI. As noted previously, several writers (e.g., Cohen alternative models at both the item and total score levels. Our
& Syme, 1985) have advocated distinguishing among different specific questions were, (a) at the item level, which model best
types of social support (e.g., esteem maintenance and cogni- describes the relation between N — S difference scores and
tive guidance) to determine what kinds of aid are most subjective satisfaction ratings, and (b) at the total score level,
beneficial in different circumstances. For example, the types which model accounts for the greatest amount of variance in
of support one needs during the transition to college may be satisfaction (SSI-SS) scores?
different from those needed during the bereavement process.
Support needs may also change over time, with needs in the Method
early stages of college transition being different from needs
during later stages of the process. According to this line of Participants and Procedure
reasoning, it is, therefore, necessary to develop taxonomies of
The subjects for this study were 340 undergraduate students sam-
support and to derive multidimensional measures of them.
pled from three different sites, the University of Minnesota, the
(For reviews of and commentaries on current taxonomic
University of Wisconsin, and Madison, Wisconsin, area business and
schemes, see Cohen & Syme, 1985; Heller et al., 1986; Rook, junior colleges. The Minnesota sample was composed of 98 under-
1984; Shumaker & BrowneU, 1984.) graduates who took the SSI along with a battery of other question-
Our study had two primary purposes. First, given the im- naires as part of an undergraduate introduction to applied psychology
portance of determining the SSI's dimensionality, we explored course. The University of Wisconsin sample contained 60 students
the factor structure of the SSI-PF scale among undergraduate in an undergraduate counseling-skills course, and the other Wisconsin
college students. The specific questions addressed were (a) sample consisted of 182 students who volunteered during social
does a single social-support dimension underlie the data on studies classes to complete a battery of questionnaires that included
the SSI as part of a larger study. No differences among samples were
the SSI, (b) is there empirical support for a multidimensional
found for gender or marital status, though significant differences did
(i.e., multifactor) structure of the SSI, and (c) is sufficient
emerge for age, F(2, 337) = 8.14, p < .01, and racial/ethnic compo-
reliability and concurrent validity achieved by using a simple
sition, x 2 (l, A' = 280) = 12.09, p < .001. The Wisconsin junior
summated rating method to estimate factor and total scores? college sample was significantly older than the Minnesota sample
The second purpose of this study was to test empirically (Minnesota, M = 22.66, SD = 3.68; Wisconsin, M = 25.87, SD =
the adequacy of the scoring model used to estimate perceived 7.26) and contained a greater percentage of nonwhite participants
fit on the SSI. Brown et al.'s (1987) scoring model was based (Minnesota, 6% nonwhite; Wisconsin, 33% nonwhite). The Univer-
on a theory of needs (e.g., Murray, 1938) that posited that sity of Wisconsin sample's mean age (23.18, SD = 6.00) did not differ
dissatisfaction, strain, and motive arousal occur only when significantly from the other two samples. No data were available on
the interpersonal environment fails to provide sufficiently for the ethnic composition of this sample.
Despite these intersite differences on age and ethnic status, neither
the individual's interpersonal needs, that is, under conditions
variable related significantly to either SSI-PF (age, r = .04; ethnicity,
of deprivation in which Need Strength is greater than Per-
r = .11) or SSI-SS (age, r = .07; ethnicity, r = .06) scores. Further,
ceived Supply. An oversupply of resources to meet needs (i.e., SSI-PF and SSI-SS scores did not differ among the samples. Thus,
Need Strength is less than Perceived Supply) would not, data from the three samples were combined for all subsequent anal-
according to this model, lead to greater or lesser satisfaction, yses. The total sample was mostly female (62%), white (77%), and
strain, or motive arousal than would perfect P-E correspond- unmarried (84%); the mean age was 24.45 years (SD = 6.16); and
ence (i.e., Need Strength equals Perceived Supply). Thus, P- mean SSI-PF and SSI-SS scores were 35.05 (SD = 36.33) and 185.85
E fit item scores were set at 0 both when N and S ratings were (SD = 53.02), respectively.
474 BROWN, ALPERT, LENT, HUNT, BRADY

HIGH
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.

B,C

C/5

LOW

-6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 +1 +2 +3 +4 +5

P - EFIT

Figure 1. Three alternative person-environment fit models of satisfaction with social support. (From "Perceived Social Support Among
College Students: Three Studies of the Psychometric Characteristics and Counseling Uses of the Social Support Inventory" by S. D. Brown, T.
Brady, R. W. Lent, J. Wolfert, and S. Hall, 1987, Journal of Counseling Psychology, 34, p. 352. Copyright 1987 by the American Psychological
Association. Reprinted by permission.)

Data Analyses SSI-PF score was obtained by finding the difference between N and
S ratings, ranging from —6 to +6, and summing the item scores. The
Model testing. Two analytic methods were used to address the former method is representative of the inverted U model (Model C)
questions of scoring model adequacy (see Figure 1). First, Pearson in that higher total scores on the SSI-PF scale reflect greater dissat-
product-moment and eta correlation coefficients were calculated isfaction (i.e., less fit) and N - S differences representing overload (N
between fit and subjective satisfaction ratings for each item, by using < S) and underload (N > S) are allowed to contribute positively to
the full range of fit scores (-6 to +6), and then tested for linear and the total score. The latter method represents the linear model (Model
curvilinear trends. If the eta coefficient was found to be significantly A) in that negative N - S differences (N < S) contribute to the total
larger than the Pearson correlation (p < .05; Guilford & Fruchler, score by lowering it.
1973) and an analysis of variance (ANOVA) for trends (Hays, 1963) Additionally, a third alternative scoring model was developed from
revealed significant curvilinearity (p < .05), the true relation between the possibility that N ratings do not indicate how much of a particular
fit and satisfaction for that item was judged to be curvilinear and not item is needed but rather how important that type of need is to the
a chance deviation from linearity. Scatterplots were then inspected to respondent. This suggests a multiplicative rather than a difference
see if the curvilinear trends tended to match Model B (asymptotic) model in which the S ratings are weighted by the N ratings in a
or Model C (inverted U). If the eta coefficient was not significantly multiplicative fashion (N X S) and then summed.
larger than the Pearson correlation, the product-moment correlation After calculating total SSI-PF scores for each subject under all
was positive and significant (p < .05), and the ANOVA for trends models, the different scoring systems were compared in terms of the
revealed significant linearity (p < .05) but no significant deviations variance accounted for in SSI-SS scores to estimate which system
from linearity, the relation was judged to be linear and conforming (and, hence, which model) best describes the relation between P-E
to Model A (linear). fit and satisfaction with social support as measured by the SSI.
Second, to explore further the fit of the theoretical models to SSI Factor analyses. To explore the underlying factor structure of the
data, we developed two alternative scoring systems to represent the SSI, we used factor analyses (principal components factor extraction
different models displayed in Figure 1. In the first, the absolute value with varimax orthogonal and oblimin oblique rotations). The prin-
of N — S difference scores was calculated for each item and summed cipal components factor extraction solution was used to assess the
over all items to yield a total SSI-PF score. In the second, the total proportion of variance in the interitem correlation matrix that was
PERCEIVED SOCIAL SUPPORT 475

accounted for by the first extracted factor. The proportion ought to percentage of variance = 42.0) and Component 2 (eigenvalue
be substantial and the magnitude of loadings high across all items to = 2.50, percentage of variance = 6.4). Further, all items
support the hypothesis of a single underlying social-support factor
showed uniformly large loadings on the first unrelated com-
and to justify calculating a total SSI-PF score by using all items.
ponent (.34 to .76). Taken together, these results suggest a
Varimax orthogonal and oblimin oblique rotations were then used
to estimate whether a multifactor solution could be used to describe
general underlying Perceived Fit (support) factor on the SSI
SSI-PF data and to identify items to be included on each factor- and support the use of a total SSI-PF score that is a sum of
based scale. Conclusions about the item content of each factor-based the N - S difference scores across all items.
scale were based on both convergent- and discriminant-validity cri- Nevertheless, because of the potential theoretical and prac-
teria (Veil & Ware, 1983). Convergent validity was judged to be tical utility of a multidimensional conception of perceived
satisfactory when an item's loading with a factor equaled or exceeded support, we decided to examine the nature of the principal
.40. Discriminant validity was judged to be satisfactory when the components. The scree test (Cattell, 1966) suggested that five
difference in magnitude between an item's highest and second highest of the six components with eigenvalues greater than 1 be
factor loading was greater than .10. Thus, items included on each
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.

retained for rotation. However, because of the subjectivity


This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.

scale were only those with a factor loading greater or equal to .40 on
involved in the use of the scree test, we retained and separately
that scale and a difference of at least .10 between its primary and
secondary factor loading.
rotated five and six components orthogonally and obliquely.
The five-factor orthogonal and oblique solutions yielded the
most interpretable factors, and the use of oblique or orthog-
Results onal rotations did not seem to change the interpretability of
the five-factor solution.
Model Testing Finally, because of the substantial loadings of all items on
the first unrotated component, we inspected the number of
Analyses of the relation between SSI-PF and SSI-SS item noteworthy residual correlations for the one-, five-, and six-
scores revealed significant curvilinear trends for 33 of the 39 factor orthogonal models for further evidence on the useful-
items. The remaining six items, representing needs for infor- ness of a multidimensional solution for the SSI. These anal-
mation and services, showed strong and significant linear yses revealed that the number of large residual correlations
relations between fit and satisfaction. Inspections of the re- was substantially greater for the single-factor solution (103
sulting scatterplots suggested that all 33 items showing signif- residuals > .10; largest residual = .43) than for the five-factor
icant deviations from linearity most nearly matched Model B solution (17 residuals >. 10; largest residual = . 14). There was
(see Figure 1) by becoming asymptotic near perfect P-E fit no further reduction in the number of large residuals for the
(N — S = 0). No support was found for the model predicting six-factor solution (17 residuals > .10; largest residual = .14).
that both over- and undersupply for needs is associated with Thus, the five-factor orthogonal solution was chosen to rep-
decreasing feelings of satisfaction (Model C). resent the factor structure of the SSI-PF scale (accounting
The results obtained when total SSI-PF scores, calculated together for 59.7% of the variance in the original correlation
by the four alternative scoring models, were correlated with matrix).
total SSI-SS scores were largely consistent with those obtained Items and their factor loadings for our final five-factor
in the item analyses. First-order partial correlations (control- orthogonal model are presented in Table 1. The components
ling for gender) were used in these analyses because gender (hereafter called scales) are interpretable and may be described
correlated significantly (p < .05) with fit scores obtained from as follows: (1) Acceptance and Belonging, (2) Appraisal and
Models A and C. Although all four scoring methods yielded Coping Assistance, (3) Behavioral and Cognitive Guidance,
nearly identical internal consistency estimates (.94 to .96), (4) Tangible Assistance and Material Aid, and (5) Modeling.
there were differences among them in their correlations with
total SSI-SS scores (linear, Model A = -.56; asymptotic Reliability, Validity, and Scale Intercorrelations
curvilinear, Model B = -.69; inverted U curvilinear, Model
C = -.38; multiplicative importance model = .18). The The upper panel of Table 2 presents summary statistics and
correlation between SSI-PF and SSI-SS using the asymptotic internal consistency estimates of each scale as well as the
model (B) was significantly larger than the correlations ob- intercorrelations of the five scales. Scale scores were calculated
tained using the linear model (A), z(337) = 2.07, p < .05; the by a simple summated ratings method (i.e., by summing over
inverted U model (C), ((337) = 5.27, p < .001; and the N — S difference scores of items included on each scale). The
multiplicative model, ((337) = 9.39, p < .001. Thus, the reliability (internal consistency) estimates for all scales appear
Brown et al. (1987) scoring model (B) accounted for more to be satisfactory for research purposes, ranging from .79 to
variance in total satisfaction (SSI-SS) scores than the other .91.
three models and was used in all subsequent analyses. Scale intercorrelations ranged in absolute magnitiude from
.35 to .76. Although several of the intercorrelations are high,
all are lower than their respective internal consistency esti-
Factor Analyses
mates, which suggests that the scales contain a noteworthy
The principal components analysis of the 39 SSI-PF item amount of unique reliable variance.
scores yielded six components with eigenvalues greater than We also conducted a principal components analysis with a
1. The only large differences between eigenvalues for the varimax rotation to five factors on the SSI-SS scale. The
components was between Component 1 (eigenvalue = 16.39, resultant factor solution was similar enough to the five-factor
476 BROWN, ALPERT, LENT, HUNT, BRADY

Table 1
Factor Loading Estimates on the Five-Factor Orthogonal Model

Factor scale/Hem summary I II III IV V


I. Acceptance and Belonging
Assurance that loved .76 .28 .20 .03 .15
Know others willing to talk about anything .68 .24 .16 .20 .12
Assurance that needed .67 .41 .18 .03 .19
Know others willing to talk about good aspects of life .65 .25 .31 .15 .12
Assurance that accepted .64 .35 .20 .03 .16
Know others willing to talk about good feelings .63 .02 .41 .17 .15
Assurance that respected .62 .51 .15 .06 .10
Assurance that belong to a caring group .61 .20 .07 .29 .15
Know others willing to talk about hopes .53 .18 .41 .26 .05
Know others willing to talk when you're down and blue" .48 .31 .41 .24 .16
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.

Know others willing to talk about your insecurities" .48 .17 .44 .18 .15
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.

II. Appraisal and Coping Assistance


Reassurance that it is normal to feel down about life .20 .70 .19 .04 .24
Help to see optimism in the future .30 .64 .19 .17 .12
Encouragement to talk of good aspects of life .33 .63 .34 .16 .08
Help to set realistic goals .24 .58 .16 .17 .21
Reassurance that fears are normal .26 .58 .29 .19 .17
Reassurance that it is normal to feel hopeful .38 .57 .19 .25 .11
Reassurance that it is normal to feel down now .27 .52 .31 .00 .21
Information on how to cope .15 .52 .32 .08 .39
Information on services" .14 .50 .02 .30 .29
Help in seeing positives' .27 .50 .47 .21 .15
Encouragement to talk of future positively" .45 .48 .34 .21 .02

HI. Behavioral and Cognitive Guidance


Information to change self-defeating behavior .12 .45 .67 .00 .15
Information to change negative feelings .24 .31 .64 .06 .13
Reassurance that normal to feel good .36 .12 .60 .16 .18
Assistance when act in self-defeating ways .21 .42 .60 .06 .14
Encouragement to face reality .26 .43 .57 .06 .09
Help to change self-defeating behavior .32 .20 .52 .09 .29
Encouragement to talk when down" .42 .37 .46 .00 .15
Encouragement to talk of insecurities" .44 .33 .46 .13 .12

IV. Tangible Assistance and Material Aid


Financial assistance for maintenance .16 .13 .00 .80 .09
Nonfinancial aid for maintenance' .13 .11 .10 .74 .15
Financial assistance for emergencies .04 .03 .15 .72 .09
Information on sources of financial assistance" .08 .22 .01 .69 .09
Nonfinancial aid for emergencies" .13 .06 .41 .53 .17

V. Modeling
Information on how others feel" .19 .10 .14 .10 .83
Information on how others handle situations" .11 .21 .19 .16 .80
Information on how others think .23 .24 .11 .25 .70
A model or example to follow .14 .27 .33 .26 .51
* These items failed to meet the discriminant validity criterion. They are, therefore, not used to calculate scale scores, but are used to calculate
total SSI-PF (and SSI-SS) scores. " These items showed a linear relation between perceived fit and satisfaction.

orthogonal SSI-PF solution (median Salient Variable Simi- and conceptual indicators of satisfaction with corresponding
larity Index = .94; Cattell, Balcar, Horn, & Nesselroade, 1969) types of support.
to allow us to construct five SSI-SS factor-based scales iden-
tical in content to the five SSI-PF scales. Correlations calcu- Discussion
lated among these SSI-PF and SSI-SS scales are displayed in
the lower panel of Table 2. Convergent validity correlations The purposes of this study were to explore the factor
between corresponding SSI-PF and SSI-SS scales were signif- structure of the SSI-PF scale and to test the comparative
icantly larger than discriminant-validity correlations of each utility of different scoring models for deriving SSI-PF scores.
SSI-PF scale with the other four SSI-SS scales, all dependent Two different tests, one at the item level and one at the total
sample rs(337) > 2.11, all ps < .05. It, thus, appears that fit score level, of alternative scoring systems suggested that the
scores obtained from the SSI-PF scales are valid operational model predicting satisfaction to plateau at perfect P-E corre-
PERCEIVED SOCIAL SUPPORT 477

Table 2 The second factor (Appraisal and Coping Assistance) seems


Summary Data on Social Support Inventory-Perceived Fit to combine the emotional regulatory functions of support
(SSI-PF) and Social Support Inventory-Subjective suggested in other taxonomies (cf, Cohen & Syme, 1985)
Satisfaction (SSI-SS) Scales with appraisal functions suggested by Lazarus and his associ-
Reli- SS1-PF Scale ates (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984) in their model of stress,
abil- coping, and adaptation. Specifically, the second factor appears
Scale Ka M SD ityb I II III IV V to assess the degree to which the social environment provides
SSI-PF the individual during times of stress with emotional support,
I. 9 7.60 9.59 .91 — hope, and coping assistance through (a) assurances that feel-
II. 9 8.24 9.42 .89 .74 — ings are normal, (b) positive reinterpretations of the situation
III. 6 5.57 7.04 .88 .73 .76 —
and future, and (c) information on coping skills.
IV. 5 3.55 5.44 .79 .40 .44 .35 —
V. 4 4.44 5.29 .83 .52 .61 .54 .44 — The third (Behavioral and Cognitive Guidance) and fifth
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.

ssi~ss (Modeling) factors appear to measure the degree to which the


This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.

I. 9 35.71 10.08 .93 -.76 -.56 -.57 -.32 -.42 social environment meets the individual's needs for direct
II. 9 42.36 13.14 .88 -.53 -.66 -.56 -.33 -.44 and modeled feedback about appropriate behaviors and
III. 6 27.68 9.79 .81 -.50 -.54 -.63 -.27 -.38
IV. 5 24.30 8.52 .78 -.33 -.33 -.27 -.56 -.29 thoughts. These factors appears to differ from the Appraisal
V. 4 17.06 6.89 .83 -.40 -.44 -.45 -.29 -.63 and Coping Assistance factor in that they do not include
Note. SSI-SS scales were constructed to be identical to their corre- needs for emotional support and appraisal and do not appear
sponding SSI-PF scales in item content. I = Acceptance and Belong- to be tied to a specific stressful circumstance. Rather, they
ing; II = Appraisal and Coping Assistance; III = Behavioral and appear to reflect what Shumaker and Brownell (1984) have
Cognitive Guidance; IV = Tangible Assistance and Material Aid; V termed self-identity needs (i.e., needs for feedback regarding
= Modeling. Correlations in italics in the lower panel represent
aspects of self and appropriate behavior in ambiguous situa-
convergent validity coefficients between corresponding SSI-PF and
SSI-SS scales. tions). The fourth factor (Tangible Assistance and Material
• Number of items in scale. " Internal consistency estimates by Cron- Aid) clearly measures the degree to which instrumental needs
bach's alpha. (cf., Cohen & Syme, 1985) for money, goods, and services are
met by the social environment.
Although this study yielded useful data on the SSI, the P-
spondence fit the data best. In item analyses 33 of the 39 SSI E fit model from which it was derived, and the SSI's compo-
items matched the asymptotic model, whereas at the total nent social-support functions, we need to acknowledge the
score level, this scoring model accounted for a greater per- study's limitations and the need for continued research on
centage of variance in total satisfaction (SSI-SS) scores than the instrument and theory. First, an inspection of Table 2
did the alternative scoring models. These results suggest that reveals that all SSI-PF scale scores were positively skewed,
college students' satisfaction with social support is linearly with means near the low ends of the N - S distributions
related to perceived P-E fit up to the point where social (indicating substantial P-E fit). Whether these score distribu-
resources match need strength levels; excesses of social re- tions are representative of those of the undergraduate college
sources beyond need strength levels generally neither decrease student population as a whole or are simply a function of
nor increase subjects' reported satisfaction. These findings sample size and sampling error needs to be addressed in future
offer tentative support for Brown et al.'s (1987) scoring model research.
for the SSI. Second, although the asymptotic model accounted for sig-
The factor analytic investigation revealed that using the nificantly more variance in satisfaction scores than did the
total SSI-PF score derived from the asymptotic model as a alternative models, all models correlated significantly with
global measure of fit and therefore satisfaction is appropriate. satisfaction scores and the linear model seemed to describe
The first principal component was considerably larger than the relation of fit and satisfaction best for 6 of the 39 SSI
any others in both SSI-PF and SSI-SS scales, and the total items. Thus, future research should continue to explore the
scores derived from these scales seemed to correlate substan- relations of the various models to satisfaction ratings before
tially with each other, suggesting that an asymptotic model of the reliability of these results can be firmly established. Espe-
P-E fit is a good (but not perfect) operational index of cially needed are studies that use samples of sufficient size
satisfaction with support among undergraduate college stu- and heterogeneity to achieve a balanced distribution across
dents. all levels of perceived fit. The number of subjects expressing
Retaining and rotating five components, however, yielded fit scores in the high levels of overload (i.e., where social
a solution that appears to be empirically justified, theoretically resources far exceed needs) in this study was smaller than the
meaningful, and consistent with past taxonomic schemes. The number of subjects expressing other levels of fit. Thus,
first factor (Acceptance and Belonging), similar to esteem and whether satisfaction turns downward (as suggested by the
social integration functions of support included in other tax- inverted U model), continues upward (as suggested by the
onomies (cf., Cohen & Syme, 1985), appears to measure the linear model), or stabilizes (as suggested by the asymptotic
degree to which the individual's needs for affiliation and model) after perfect P-E fit is reached needs to be studied
esteem are met through the provision of love, acceptance, further with samples containing substantial numbers of sub-
respect, belonging, and shared communication. jects in the high range of overload (N < S) scores on SSI-PF.
478 BROWN, ALPERT, LENT, HUNT, BRADY

Alternatively, it may be that the distribution of overload scores Cattell, R. B., Balcar, K. R., Horn, J. L., & Nesselroade, J. R. (1969).
obtained in this study accurately represents the reality of Factor matching procedures: An improvement of the s index; with
college student life (i.e., comparatively few perceive that their tables. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 29, 781-792.
social resources far exceed their needs). Such a possibility may Cohen, S., & Syme, S. L. (1985). Issues in the study and application
of social support. In S. Cohen & S. L. Syme (Eds.), Social support
also be examined in replications and extensions of this study.
and health (pp. 3-22). New York: Academic Press.
Finally, the factor structure of the SSI-PF scale was derived
Guilford, J. P., & Fruchter, B. (1973). Fundamental statistics in
from a single exploratory factor analysis with a single sample psychology and education (5th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
of college students. The robustness of the results and the Hays, W. L. (1963). Statistics. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
reliability of the factor solution reported here need cross- Heller, K., Swindle, R. W., Jr., & Dusenbury, L. (1986). Component
validation with other samples. social support processes: Comments and integration. Journal of
Nonetheless, the results of this investigation and the Brown Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 54, 466-470.
et al. (1987) study suggest that the SSI may have both theo- Lazarus, R. S., & Falkman, S. (1984). Stress, appraisal, and coping.
New York: Springer Publishing.
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.

retical and practical usefulness. Theoretically, it appears to be


Levy, R. L. (1983). Social support and psychological disorder: A
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.

a valid operationalization of the P-E fit model of perceived


review. Journal of Community Psychology, 11, 3-21.
support. Thus, its use in research on social support may add
Murray, H. (1938). Explorations in personality. New York: Oxford
greater theoretical and conceptual clarity concerning the
University Press.
structure and functions of social support. Practically, the SSI Rook, K. S. (1984). Research on social support, loneliness, and social
may serve a useful diagnostic function by enabling counselors isolation: Toward an integration. In P. Shaver (Ed.), Review of
to identify more accurately clients' major unmet support- personality and social psychology (Vol. 5, pp. 239-264). Beverly
related needs. The usefulness of the SSI for this and other Hills, CA: Sage.
applied purposes also deserves further research attention. Shumaker, S. A., & Brownell, A. (1984). Toward a theory of social
support: Closing conceptual gaps. Journal of Social Issues, 40(4),
11-36.
References Thoits, P. A. (1986). Social support as coping assistance. Journal of
Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 54, 416-423.
Brown, S. D., Brady, T., Lent, R. W., Wolfert, J., & Hall, S. (1987). Veil, C. T., & Ware, J. E., Jr. (1983). The structure of psychological
Perceived social support among college students: Three studies of distress and well-being in general populations. Journal of Consult-
the psychometric characteristics and counseling uses of the Social ing and Clinical Psychology, 51, 730-742.
Support Inventory [Monograph]. Journal of Counseling Psychol-
ogy, 34, 337-354. Received October 15, 1987
Cattell, R. B. (1966). The scree test for the number of factors. Revision received December 31, 1987
Muhivariate Behavioral Research, 1, 140-161. Accepted January 7, 1988 •

Editor Named for APA's Clinician's Research Digest

The Publications and Communications Board has named George Strieker of Adelphi Uni-
versity's Gordon F. Derner Institute of Advanced Psychological Studies Editor of Clinician's
Research Digest (CRD), which is being published by the American Psychological Associa-
tion as of July 1988.

The six-page newsletter reports on research related to approaches to treatment modalities,


including any systematic empirical study, as well as some coverage of child and gerontologi-
cal issues. Although therapy is the main focus, key assessment and diagnostic questions as
well as forensic issues are covered. CRD is an easy-to-read, fact-based, findings-oriented
digest of research that summarizes for practitioners relevant material from the science base
of practice. Complete citations are included so that clinicians interested in more information
can request the full article from the author.

Although all published material will originate with the Editor, readers of CRD are invited to
refer to Strieker any references or reprints of articles they find valuable.

You might also like