Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ild
nt B
ehavio
Selamat, et al., J Child Adolesc Behav 2018, 6:1
Behavior DOI: 10.4172/2375-4494.1000369
Jo
r
ISSN: 2375-4494
Abstract
This review focusing on studies on autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and attention disorder hyperactivity disorder
(ADHD), which consists of assessment and intervention on three main domains; neuropsychological (cognitive),
social interaction and behavioral problems. Majority of the studies reviewed used non-randomized control studies
which involves mostly children, some adolescence and few adults, who are diagnosed as either ASD, ADHD or ASD
+ADHD. The outcome of these studies mostly shows positive results in improving autism symptom such as cognitive
skills impairment, social interaction dysfunctions between child and parents and behavioral problem. Children with
ASD that undergone occupational therapy using sensory integration needed less caregiver assistance during self-
care and social activities. Pivotal Response Treatment (PRT) challenges the child to improve communication and
increased parental self-efficacy. Social skills training (SST) promote social competence and friendship and
decreasing feelings of loneliness. Animal companionship increases alertness and attention in human, which might
promote enhance concentration and task persistence and promote calming effect in children suffering from ADHD.
Mind-Body Therapies showed positive results in mental and emotional health and decreased in behavioral problems
in children with ASD. In parent -mediated early intervention for children with ASD, children’s language, adaptive
skills and parents stress showed no significance change. Despite of small to medium improvement, there were little
scientific evidence of effectiveness of each type of intervention that could be suggested as best suited therapy for
children with ASD and ADHD. Therefore, it was suggested to have standardized training technique as a promising
area for future research along with continuous monitoring is needed in the long term to see the results in these
children.
Keywords: Autism spectrum disorder (ASD); Attention deficit and problems [6]. Majority of children with autism spectrum disorder
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD); Neuropsychological (cognitive); showed deficit in social cognition [5] whereby they have fewer
Social interaction; Behavioral problems reciprocal friendships and lower friendship quality, more isolated and
have a less central position in social networks [7]. This social
Introduction impairment causes difficulty for parents to communicate with them
which later leads to frustrations [1]. According to Busch et al. [8], there
Individual with Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is defined as a is an also significant difficulty in social interaction and peer’s
neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by persistent deficits in impulsivity and hyperactivity seen in children with ADHD.
reciprocal social communication and interaction as well as restrictive,
repetitive stereotyped patterns of behaviour and interests [1-3]. While, Methods
Attention Deficiency Hyperactive Disorder (ADHD) have symptoms of
inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity [3].
Search strategies and selection of criteria
Children with ASD have difficulty in understanding metaphorical
or non-literal language, slower information processing, intellectual The PubMed and Science Direct database were search using the
disability, as well as repetition of nonsense words [3,4]. These keywords “autism” and “attention deficit hyperactivity disorder”
impairments undoubtedly influence their linguistic competence on combined with intervention on cognitive, behavioural and social.
object recognition and perception, and understanding of visuospatial When the first keyword autism and attention deficit hyperactivity
relationship [3]. Children with ADHD, experience consistently deficit disorder was searched 5000 hits were obtained. When the word
in their working memory, verbal comprehension difficulties and to intervention was added, the results were decreased to 1700. All related
sustained attention and response inhibition [3,5]. issues mainly from ASD and ADHD (Journal of Child Psychology and
Psychiatry), intervention study (Journal of Autism Developmental
Irritability is the most primary presentation of children with autism Disorders).
spectrum [1], other behaviour and medical problems that requires
clinical assessment social withdrawal, anxiety, rigid-compulsive
disorder, depression, and high rates of sleep and gastrointestinal
J Child Adolesc Behav, an open access journal Autism Spectrum Disorder; the past, the present, and the future- ISSN:2375-4494
Vol II
Citation: Selamat NW, Renganathan Y, Karim SA (2018) Intervention Approaches for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and
Attention Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD): Review of Research between 2013 and 2017. J Child Adolesc Behav 6: 369. doi:
10.4172/2375-4494.1000369
Page 2 of 6
Parent-mediated early
intervention for young
children with autism spectrum
1 United Kingdom 2013 disorders (ASD) NA NA NA
Neuropsychological
Performance of Egyptian
Children with Autism
Spectrum Disorder and 6-12 years ASD=7.35(2.09)
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity ADHD=9.19(1.68) TD=9.14 Male=79.6%
2 Egypt 2017 Disorder (1.9) Female=20.4% Egyptian=100%
A Meta-Analytic Review of
the Efficacy of Physical
Exercise Intervention on
Cognition in Individuals
Autism Spectrum Disorder
7 Australia 2016 and ADHD 3-25 years Mean(SD)=NA NA NA
Animal-Assisted Interventions
for infants at high risk for
Children with Attention
Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder:
A Theoretical Review and
Consideration of Future
8 Netherlands 2016 Research Direction 2-11 years Mean(SD)=NA NA NA
Medical comorbidities in
10 Europe 2017 children and adolescents with 4-18 years Mean(SD)=NA NA NA
J Child Adolesc Behav, an open access journal Autism Spectrum Disorder; the past, the present, and the future- ISSN:2375-4494
Vol II
Citation: Selamat NW, Renganathan Y, Karim SA (2018) Intervention Approaches for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and
Attention Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD): Review of Research between 2013 and 2017. J Child Adolesc Behav 6: 369. doi:
10.4172/2375-4494.1000369
Page 3 of 6
Neuropsychological
Characteristics of Children Years=NA ASD=10.9(3.6)
14 America 2017 with Mixed Autism and ADHD ASD+ADHD=9.8(2.2) NA NA
Age Location
The publications included several age ranges, from children as Mostly, non-randomized research study on ASD and ADHD were
young as 10-16 years (n=277), young adults from 18 to 25 years conducted in developed countries in which 13 articles had originated
(n=1955), general adults from 29 to 49 years (n=40) and elderly from from America (n=6), United Kingdom (n=3), Netherlands (n=3) and
50 to 65 years (n=13). The most-researched group involved children, in Egypt (n=1).
whom ASD and ADHD is common.
Parameters
Gender
The psychological and behavioural studies of ASD and ADHD have
The percentage of female respondents was between 9-20% (n=222) been focused on measuring behavioural, followed by cognitive skills
and for males was between 50-90% (n=1277) in 15 research studies in and social skills. Mostly, these studies were conducted in the recent
America, United Kingdom, Netherlands, Australia and Egypt. years to investigate the effectiveness of the type of intervention applied
on three main parameters; cognitive, social and behavioural in
Ethnicity, religion and locality children and adolescence with ASD and ADHD. The main findings for
each study are summarized in Table 2.
The respondents represented ethnic groups within the country were
Egyptian, Hispanic/Latino and Caucasians, White and Non-whites.
The sample recruited included young children (n=277), adolescent
(n=1955) and adults (n=53) (Table 1).
Study design Study
No Author setting Year Respondents Sample (n=) Parameters Main findings
● Reviewed article
● United Kingdom
Improved in understanding language
1 Oono et al. [9] ● 2013 Children 371 Social comprehension and severity of autism
J Child Adolesc Behav, an open access journal Autism Spectrum Disorder; the past, the present, and the future- ISSN:2375-4494
Vol II
Citation: Selamat NW, Renganathan Y, Karim SA (2018) Intervention Approaches for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and
Attention Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD): Review of Research between 2013 and 2017. J Child Adolesc Behav 6: 369. doi:
10.4172/2375-4494.1000369
Page 4 of 6
●Longitudinal
● Egypt
Impaired of cognitive skills in variant in ASD and
2 Elsheikh et al. [3] ● 2017 Children 69 Cognitive ADHD
●Longitudinal
● United Kingdom
Children with ASD and ADHD presented atypical
3 Groom et al. [2] ● 2017 Children 35 Cognitive gaze cue and face processing
● Non- randomized
study
● Netherlands
4 Duifhuis et al. [12] ● 2017 Children 24 Behaviour Improvement in Autism symptoms
●Longitudinal
● United Kingdom
Increased in parental non -directiveness’ with
5 Green et al. [10] ● 2017 Infants 54 Social dyiad interaction
●Randomized - trial
study
● America
6 Schaaf et al. [11] ● 2014 Children 32 Behaviour Social Improved in self-care and social skills
● Meta- analysis
Improved small to medium effect of exercise on
7 Beron et al. [13] ● Australia ● 2016 Children and adults 579 Cognitive cognition
● Review article
● Netherlands
8 Busch et al. [8] ● 2016 Infants 43 Social Improved effect on several core symptoms
● Review article
● America
PCP can be used to generate individualized
9 McGuire et al. [1] ● 2016 Children NA Behaviour treatment in children with ASD
● Review article
Children with ASD and ADHD commonly have
● Europe
neurology, immunology and gastroenterology
10 Jet et al. ● 2017 Children and adults 104 Behaviour disorder
●Longitudinal
● America
Non-referred siblings Cognitive Autism Trait has higher levels of morbidity and
11 Biederman et al. ● 2016 of proband with ADHD 491 Behaviour Social dysfunction
● Cross - sectional
analysis
● America
Children and Depression were common in high functioning
12 Greenlee et al. [6] ● 2016 adolescence 1272 Behaviour older children
●Longitudinal
●Netherlands
13 Deckers et al. [7] ● 2016 Children 52 Social Greater improvement of social skills
● Cross - sectional
analysis
Children with ASD + ADHD showed higher
● America
Colombi and Cognitive symptoms of anxiety, worse working memory
14 Ghaziuddin [5] ● 2017 Children 47 Behaviour and less empathy
●Systematic review
Improved in emotional health (anxiety and
● America
Hourston and depression). Reduced physical aggression and
15 Atchley [4] ● 2017 Children and adults 193 Behaviour disruptive behaviour
Table 2: An Overview of study design setting, year and sample that have assessed intervention approach on children with ASD and ADHD.
J Child Adolesc Behav, an open access journal Autism Spectrum Disorder; the past, the present, and the future- ISSN:2375-4494
Vol II
Citation: Selamat NW, Renganathan Y, Karim SA (2018) Intervention Approaches for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and
Attention Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD): Review of Research between 2013 and 2017. J Child Adolesc Behav 6: 369. doi:
10.4172/2375-4494.1000369
Page 5 of 6
J Child Adolesc Behav, an open access journal Autism Spectrum Disorder; the past, the present, and the future- ISSN:2375-4494
Vol II
Citation: Selamat NW, Renganathan Y, Karim SA (2018) Intervention Approaches for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and
Attention Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD): Review of Research between 2013 and 2017. J Child Adolesc Behav 6: 369. doi:
10.4172/2375-4494.1000369
Page 6 of 6
J Child Adolesc Behav, an open access journal Autism Spectrum Disorder; the past, the present, and the future- ISSN:2375-4494
Vol II