Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Articulo 17 Marco Antonio Hungaro Duarte
Articulo 17 Marco Antonio Hungaro Duarte
Abstract
Introduction: This study evaluated in vitro the radio-
pacity, setting time, flow, film thickness, solubility,
and dimensional changes of AH Plus sealer pure (Dents-
T here has been an ongoing search for an endodontic sealer that meets the ideal phys-
icochemical properties of sealing, radiopacity, setting time, and flow as well as bio-
logical properties over the last few years. One concern has been to develop materials
ply De Trey Gmbh, Konstanz, Germany) and containing that stimulate the repair process (1).
5% and 10% of calcium hydroxide. Methods: The study Calcium hydroxide, because of its biological effects, is now accepted along with
was performed according to the requirements of the ISO endodontic sealers and gutta-percha points. It acts at the tissue level by favoring alkaline
6876:2001 standard and the American National Stan- pH and calcium release, producing biochemical effects culminating in speedy repair
dards Institute/American Dental Association (ANSI/ process (2–4). Furthermore, the calcium ion exerts essential paper in the
ADA)’s Specification No. 57. The following tests were mineralization, stimulating the fibronectin gene expression (4). The high pH values
performed: setting time, flow, film thickness, dimen- of calcium hydroxide promote antibacterial activity through an irreversible enzymatic
sional stability, radiopacity, and solubility. Data were reaction (3, 5), and calcium release clears up the carbon dioxide that bacteria use
analyzed statistically by analysis of variance and the Tu- for anaerobic respiration (6). Calcium hydroxide also inhibits irritant lipopolysaccha-
key tests with a significance level of 5%. Results: The rides present in the external membrane of gram-negative bacteria (7–9).
addition of 5% or 10% calcium hydroxide to AH Plus Sealapex was one of the first commercially available endodontic sealers containing
sealer did not alter significantly the radiopacity or calcium hydroxide (Sybron Kerr Co, Romulus, MI). Some authors (1, 10) reported
setting time values (p > 0.05). Adding 10% calcium excellent biological results, showing the positive effect of adding calcium hydroxide
hydroxide reduced the flow compared with pure AH to root canal sealers, and this material favors a high pH and calcium release (11).
Plus and AH Plus/5% calcium hydroxide. The addition The epoxy resin-based sealer AH Plus (Dentsply De Trey Gmbh, Konstanz,
of 5% and 10% calcium hydroxide increased the solu- Germany) is an improved modification of its precursor AH26 and shows a high flow
bility and expansion of AH Plus. All materials presented (12). An adequate flow ability of the endodontic sealers is a very desirable property
expansion valued above those recommended by the that allows filling irregularities. However, an excessive flow can favor apical extrusion.
ADA. The addition of calcium hydroxide to the sealer re- The sealer extrusion could injure the periapical tissues because of sealer cytotoxicity
sulted in greater film thickness. Conclusions: The addi- (13) by the low biocompatibility, mainly at the initial stage (14).
tion of 5% calcium hydroxide did not affect most Duarte et al (15) incorporated calcium hydroxide to AH Plus and verified an alka-
physical properties of AH Plus sealer. (J Endod line pH of the sealer and subsequent release of calcium ions. Any new dental product to
2010;36:1048–1051) be launched to the market must be previously evaluated for its physical, chemical, bio-
logical, and microbial properties. Regarding the physical properties, the American
Key Words National Standards Institute/American Dental Association (ANSI/ADA)’s Specification
AH Plus, calcium hydroxide, flow, radiopacity, setting No. 57 (16) established guidelines for the evaluation of sealers, such as flow, film thick-
time ness, setting time, radiopacity, solubility, and dimensional changes.
Root canal sealers need to have sufficient radiopacity to be distinguished from the
surrounding anatomic structures such as dental tissues and bone. Also, radiopacity is
necessary to verify the correct obturation of the cavity and to facilitate follow-up of the
From the *Department of Operative Dentistry, Dental Mate- case (17, 18). Therefore, because radiopacity is an important physical property, the ISO
rials and Endodontics, Dental School of Bauru, University of São
Paulo, Bauru, SP, Brazil; and †Department of Endodontics, Bra- 6876:2001 standard (19) and the ANSI/ADA’s Specification No. 57 (16) have stated 3
siliense Dental School, Brası́lia, DF, Brazil. mm of aluminum (Al) as the minimum radiopacity value for endodontic material.
Address requests for reprints to Dr Marco Antonio Hungaro The aim of the present study was to determine whether the addition of 5% and 10%
Duarte, Rua Anna Pietro Forte, 3-18 (lote A12), Residencial Vil- calcium hydroxide to the AH Plus endodontic sealer alters the physical properties of
lagio 1, CEP: 17018-820 Bauru, SP, Brazil. E-mail address:
mhungaro@travelnet.com.br.
this material.
0099-2399/$0 - see front matter
Copyright ª 2010 American Association of Endodontists.
doi:10.1016/j.joen.2010.02.007 Material and Methods
The AH Plus sealer used in the present study has the following composition: epoxy
paste: diepoxy, calcium tungstate, zirconium oxide, aerosol, and dye; amine paste: 1-
adamantane amine, N.N’dibenzyl-5-oxanonandiamine-1,9, TCD-diamine, calcium
tungstate, zirconium oxide, aerosol, and silicon oil. The modified AH Plus sealers
JOE — Volume 36, Number 6, June 2010 Physical Properties of AH Plus with and without Ca(OH)2. 1049
Basic Research—Technology
TABLE 1. Mean (and Standard Deviation) of the Setting Time (minutes) for the that the addition of 5% and 10% calcium hydroxide favored a higher
Tested Materials According to the Environmental Conditions alkaline pH and a greater calcium ion release compared with pure
Environment AH Plus sealer (15). The high pH of calcium hydroxide normally
promotes antibacterial activity and inhibits the effect of lipopolysaccha-
Material Dry Humid rides present in gram-negative bacteria (3, 7–9).
AH Plus + 10% Ca(OH)2 810 (10) 845 (15) The flow test results revealed that the values found in this study
AH Plus + 5% Ca(OH)2 810 (12) 870 (13) (40.25 mm) were higher than the minimum required by the ANSI/
AH Plus 815 (15) 955 (11) ADA (20 mm) (16). The reported values were also higher than the
values reported by Versani et al (20) and lower than the values reported
by Almeida et al (12). During the root canal–filling procedures per-
and imported into Digora 1.51 for Windows software (Orion Corpora- formed with this sealer, sealer extrusion has been clinically evident
tion Soredex, Helsinki, Finland). The radiopacity value was determined (21); however, the addition of 5% and 10% of calcium hydroxide to
according to the radiographic density and converted into millimeters of the material composition has been proposed to decrease the AH Plus
Al following the method as described by Duarte et al (18) using the flow.
following equation: Sealer extrusion could injure the periapical tissues because of
A2 sealer cytotoxicity (13) and low biocompatibility, mainly at the initial
þ mm Al immediately below RDM stage (14). The flow values in the present study were 37 mm when
B 5% was added to the sealer and 27.25 mm when 10% was used,
where A = radiographic density of the material (RDM) – radiographic revealing the possibility of verifying a decrease in the flow ability
density of the Al stepwedge increment immediately below RDM and B = when using 10% calcium hydroxide ( p < 0.05). However, these values
radiographic density of the Al stepwedge increment immediately above are still above the minimum value recommended by the ISO (18) and
RDM: radiographic density of the Al stepwedge increment immediately the ANSI/ADA (16). It is evident that in large root canals with wider
below RDM, and 2 = 2-mm increments of the Al stepwedge. foramen adding a proportion of 10% could help prevent extrusion.
Another test was performed to evaluate the setting time. The value
obtained for AH Plus was 14 hours in a dry environment and 15 hours in
Statistical Analysis
a wet environment. The manufacturer reported a setting time value of 8
Statistically significant differences among the sealers regarding ra- hours at 37 C. The setting time found in this study was higher than the
diopacity, setting time, flow, film thickness, solubility, and dimensional
manufacturer’s reported setting time and higher than the setting time
changes were analyzed statistically by analysis of variance and the Tukey observed by other authors, which was 8 hours (22). This could be
tests with a significance level of 5%.
caused by the differences in the weight of the needles used in the tests
in the studies, which varied from 100 g to 453.6 g. Moisture did not
Results seem to significantly alter AH Plus setting time, perhaps because of
The means (and standard deviations) for the setting time values the presence of silicon oil in the AH Plus composition. Increasing the
(minutes) in the presence or absence of moisture are shown in calcium hydroxide showed no significant interferences in the setting
Table 1. There was no statistically significant differences ( p > 0.05) time according to Table 1.
between AH Plus and AH Plus modified with 5% or 10% calcium AH Plus showed a high radiopacity value equivalent to 6.94 mm of
hydroxide in both environments. Al. This value is higher than the gutta-percha value, which is in accor-
Table 2 shows the means (and standard deviations) of the flow dance with the findings of Resende et al (22). However, the results in
(mm), film thickness (mm), solubility (%), and dimensional changes this study were lower than the values presented by other authors
(%). There was no statistically significant differences ( p > 0.05) in the (23–25). The AH Plus radiopacity values vary in different published
flow of AH Plus and AH Plus modified with 5% calcium hydroxide. AH works, probably because of the variations of the methodology
Plus modified with 10% calcium hydroxide showed the lowest flow applied or the manipulation of the sealer during the mixing process.
values and differed significantly from the other materials ( p < 0.05). Because AH Plus is a paste-catalytic sealer, its components can get
Table 3 lists the radiopacity results in mm of Al. All sealers showed deposited at the lower end of the tube, whereas the upper portions
significantly ( p < 0.05) higher radiopacity values than dentin and gutta- can present lower quantity of the radiopacifying agent.
percha ( p < 0.05). There was no statistically significant difference AH Plus and AH26 have different radiopacifying agents. AH Plus
between AH Plus and the modified AH Plus sealers (with 5% and presents zirconium oxide and calcium tungstate, which are both white
10% calcium hydroxide). in color. Zirconium oxide occurs naturally in the mineral baddeleyite
and finds wide application in dermatology (26). AH26 has bismuth
Discussion oxide, which is yellow in color, occurs naturally within the bismite
The addition of calcium hydroxide to endodontic sealers has been mineral, and is mainly used as an astringent (26). The addition of
proposed to improve the biological and antimicrobial activity (11, 15). 5% or 10% calcium hydroxide does not significantly influence the ra-
A previous study of calcium ion release and pH determination showed diopacity according to the data in Table 3. Pure AH Plus, AH Plus +
TABLE 2. Mean (and Standard Deviation) of the Flow (mm), Film Thickness (mm), Solubility (%), and Dimensional Changes (%)
Material Mean (flow) Film thickness Solubility Dimensional changes*
b a b
AH Plus + 10% Ca(OH)2 27.25 (0.65) 76.60 (5.70) 0.70 (0.18) +1.14 (0.26)a
AH Plus + 5% Ca(OH)2 37.00 (0.83)a 70.00 (10.00)a 0.60 (0.22)ab +0.93 (0.14)a
AH Plus 40.25 (0.65)a 43.30 (11.54)b 0.30 (0.03)a +0.57 (0.10)a
a,b
Different letters indicate statistically significant difference among the properties.
*Positive values indicate expansion of the material.
JOE — Volume 36, Number 6, June 2010 Physical Properties of AH Plus with and without Ca(OH)2. 1051