You are on page 1of 96

Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH)


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering

ENERGY RESOURCES

Nuclear energy in the XXI century

Lluís Batet
Professor at BarcelonaTECH

BARCELONA, October 2018

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Preface

In Session 7, an overview of the present situation of


nuclear power generation worldwide has been offered,
along with a short explanation of the physical basis for the
harvesting and use of this type of energy.
The present session is devoted to
• address some concerns public opinion has on
nuclear energy
• present some features of new and future types of
nuclear power plants

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 2
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Concerns

• Risk of accidents

• Waste management

• Economics

• Limitation of uranium resources

• Proliferation

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 3
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear in the XXI century


Global average annual capacity additions and retirements by
technology in the New Policies Scenario of the IEA

Not quite good news

Source: IEA WEO 2017

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 4
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Concerns

• Risk of accidents

• Waste management

• Economics

• Limitation of uranium resources

• Proliferation

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 5
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear safety

• The IAEA Safety Standards Series establish the safety


requirements governed by the safety principles as well
as recommendations and guidance on how to comply
with the safety requirements. Usually this standards are
considered in National regulations adding specific
National Requirements.
• In countries with no specific nuclear regulations, it is
usual to require compliance with the regulations of the
Country of origin of the technology being acquired.

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 6
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear safety
Fundamental Safety Principle: Protecting People and the
Environment. It must be ensured that facilities are operated
and activities are conducted so as to achieve the highest
standards of safety that can reasonably be achieved, in
order to:
– Control the radiation exposure of people and the release of
radioactive material to the environment.
– Restrict the likelihood of events that might lead to a loss of control
over a nuclear reactor core, nuclear chain reaction, radioactive
source or any other source of radiation.
– Mitigate the consequences of these events if they were to occur.

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 7
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear accidents
11th March 2011
Earthquake magnitude 9 at 130 km from Japan east coast
Tsunami: waves of 14 meters in some places

National Police Agency


Reports (Sept 2012):
~15900 casualties
~6150 injured
~2650 missing
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

11th march 2011


The tsunami flooded the coast, already affected
by the earthquake
Fukushima Daiichi station is quite close to the
epicenter and suffers the effects of the
earthquake and subsequent tsunami.

Fukushima Daiichi

The plant is not designed for the


magnitude of the earthquake,
but suffers no damage.
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering
The tsunami is higher than the 9
plant’ s design wave
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Fukushima Daiichi station


FUKUSHIMA DAIICHI.
Unit 1: BWR 3 (439 MW). Operating
Status of the units at the Units 2 and 3: BWR 4 (760 MW). Operating
instant of the earthquake Units: 4 and 5: BWR 4 (760 MW). Shut down (unit 4 defueled)
Unit 6: BWR 5 (1007 MW). Shut down.

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 10
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

BWR

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 11
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

BWR

Spent Fuel Pool

Secondary Containment

Primary Containment

Reactor Vessel
Steel Containment Vessel

Source: GE

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 12
Suppression Pool (Torus)
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

ACCIDENT SEQUENCE
Normal Operation
Earthquake
Shutdown

Loss of External Power


Diesel Generators Start-up
Tsunami
Loss of Diesel Generators

Emergency cooling

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 13
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

REMINDER Need of cooling


Fission
products

Excess neutrons
Radioactive

85% of the energy is released in form


of kinetic energy pf fission fragments

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya7% is released later (decay heat)Energy Resources


(BarcelonaTECH)
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 135 135 135 135 135
Te → I→ Xe → Cs→ Ba (stable)
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Need of cooling
REMINDER MAIN SAFETY FUNCTIONS

Stop the reaction chain Extract the residual heat and


and maintain the maintain the fuel in a coolable
reactor in a shutdown geometry
state
DONE Confine the radioactive
substances and avoid their
release to the environment
NOT POSSIBLE AFTER THE
TSUNAMI

Residual (decay) heat


Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

BWR
1. Residual Heat Removal
2. Low Pressure Cooling
Injection
3. High Pressure Cooling
Injection
4. Reactor Core Isolation
Cooling (units 2,3 and 4)
5. Isolation Condenser
(unit 1)
6. Poison injection

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

ACCIDENT SEQUENCE
Normal Operation
Earthquake
Shutdown

Loss of External Power


Diesel Generators Start-up
Tsunami
Loss of Diesel Generators

Emergency cooling

Loss of energency cooling

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 17
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Accident sequence
Dryout Core uncovery

Fuel
Overheating
Zr oxidation Release of FP
H2 production Cs, I, Xe, Kr
Overpressure Venting

Partial
retention
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) EnergyinResources
the SP
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

ACCIDENT SEQUENCE
Normal Operation
Earthquake
Shutdown

Loss of External Power


Diesel Generators Start-up
Tsunami
Loss of Diesel Generators

Emergency cooling

Loss of energency cooling

Severe accident

Sea water injection

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 19
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Hydrogen explosion
Explosion in Unit 1.
12th March 15:36

Source unknown

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 20
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Hydrogen explosion
Explosion in Unit 3. 14 March 11:01

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 21
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Hydrogen explosion
Two fires (H2 combustion) on 15-16 March Cooling tried by throwing
water from helicopters and then with fire engine pumps and water cannons

24th March

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 22
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Rating of the accident


INTERNATIONAL NUCLEAR EVENTS SCALE
Chernobyl
Fukushima Daiichi
TMI/Harrisburg
F-D Units 1, 2, 3
F-D Unit 4

Vandellòs I

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 23
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Radiological impact
Se-79 Sr-89 Nb-97 Sn-121 m Xe-135 m Ba-142 U-237 Am-241
0.327 My 50.50 d 1.23 h 43.9 y 15.30 m 10.70 m 6.75 d 433 y
Br-84 Sr-90 Mo-99 Sb-125 Xe-135 La-140 U-238 Am-242
31.80 m 29.10 y 2.79 d 2.76 y 9.10 h 40.27 h 4468 My 16.0 h
Kr-85 m Sr-91 Mo-101 Sb-126 Xe-137 La-141 U-239 Am-243
4.48 h 9.51 h 14.60 m 0.33 My 3.82 m 3.90 h 23.5 m 7370 y
Kr-85 Sr-92 Tc-98 m Te-132 Xe-138 La-142 Np-237 Cm-242
10.72 y 2.71 h 6.02 h 3.26 d 14.20 m 92.50 m 2.14 My 162.8 d
Kr-87 Sr-93 Tc-99 I-129 Xe-139 Ce-141 Np-238 Cm-243
1.37 h 7.4 m 0.211 My 15.7 My 39.70 s 32.50 d 2.117 d 29.1 y
Kr-88 Y-90 Tc-101 I-131 Xe-140 Ce-143 Np-239 Cm-244
2.84 h 2.67 d 14.20 m 8.04 d 13.70 s 33.0 h 2.36 d 18.0 y
Kr-89 Y-91 Tc-104 I-132 Cs-134 Ce-144 Np-240
3.15 m 58.50 d 18.0 m 2.28 h 2.07 y 284.6 d 1.032 h
Kr-90 Y-92 Ru-103 I-133 Cs-136 Nd-147 Pu-238
32.30 s 3.54 h 39.27 d 20.80 h 13.16 d 10.99 d 87.74 y
Rb-88 Y-93 Ru-105 I-134 Cs-137 Sm-151 Pu-239
17.70 m 10.20 h 4.44 h 42.60 m 30.17 y 90 y 24100 y
Rb-89 Zr-93 Ru-106 I-135 Cs-139 Eu-155 Pu-240
15.40 m 1.53 My 1.02 y 6.57 h 9.30 m 4.76 y 6570 y
Rb-90 Zr-95 Rh-105 I-136 Ba-139 U-234 Pu-241
2.60 m 64.00 d 35.40 h 1.39 m 83.70 m 0.245 My 14.4 y
Rb-90 m Zr-97 Pd-107 Xe-133 Ba-140 U-235 Pu-242
4.30 m 16.80 h 6.5 My 5.24 d 12.75 d 704 My 0.376 My
Rb-91 Nb-95 Cd-113 m Xe-133 m Ba-141 U-236 Pu-243
58.00 s 34.97 d 14.1 y 2.23 d 18.30 m 23.42 My 4.96 h

Principal
Universitat radionuclides
Politècnica de Catalunyain(BarcelonaTECH)
the irradiated fuel, shortly after
EnergyaResources
shutdown
Master’s Degree in Non
Energy Engineering
Noble Short Small 24
Volatile gases lived quantity
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 25
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Radiological impact
Characteristic properties of I-131 and Cs-137

Isotope I-131 Isotope Cs-137


364 keV gamma radiation in 81% of the 662 keV gamma radiation in 85% of the
decay processes decay processes
Emitted radiation Emitted radiation
Beta particulates: 606 keV in 89% of the Beta particulates: 511 keV in 94.6% of the
decay processes decay processes

Half-life 8.04 day Half-life 30.22 year

Biologic half-life 120 - 138 day Biologic half-life 110 day

Specific dose rate 7,647x10


-5
mSv/h per MBq at 1 metre Specific dose rate
-4
1,03x10 mSv/h per MBq at 1 metre

Intake limits fixed by Japanese authorities shortly after the accident


Product I-131 Cs-137
Vegetables 2000 Bq/kg 500 Bq/kg
Milk 300 Bq/kg 200 Bq/kg
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya Adults 300
(BarcelonaTECH) Bq/kg 200 Bq/kg
Energy Resources
Water
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 26
Children 100 Bq/kg 100 Bq/kg
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Radiological impact

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 27
2011_09_22
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Radiological impact

Increased Risk of Solid Cancer with Dose for


A-bomb survivors.
Relationship with between increased risk and
radiation dose as reported by the "Health
Risks from Exposure to Low Levels of Ionizing
Radiation: Biological Effects of Ionizing
Radiation VII (BEIR VII) report with 90 %
confidence bars.
Source: wikipedia / Linear no-threshold model

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 28
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Effect on Energy Structure

54 units in operation in 2011

127.0 Million inhabitants in


2018

In operation in May 2018


(source: Wikipedia)

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 29
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Effect on Energy Structure


JAPAN Energy System 2010

TPED 496.8 Mtoe Electricity 1110.8 TWh

Source: IEA WEO 2012

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 30
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Effect on Energy Structure


JAPAN Energy System 2012

TPED 452.3 Mtoe Electricity 1026.1 TWh

Source: IEA WEO 2014

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 31
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Effect on Energy Structure


JAPAN Energy System Evolution
Source: IEA WEO 2012 2014 2016
Gas prices
$/mmBtu
JAPAN

Source: BP Statistical
Review of World Energy
2016

Source: BP Statistical Review


of World Energy 2016

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 32
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Impact of historical accidents


Have resulted in significant improvements in
Safety, Equipment and Organization:
– After TMI: Importance of Human Factors versus
Design on Safety.
– After Chernobyl: Safety Culture and Severe
Accidents Management.
– After Fukushima: External events, Improved
response to beyond design basis events.

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 33
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Concerns

• Risk of accidents

• Waste management

• Economics

• Limitation of uranium resources

• Proliferation

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 34
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

REMINDER Spent fuel management


Fission products Heavy nuclides
Generated by neutron capture in uranium and
transuranic nuclides: Alpha emitters
Long lived

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 35
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

REMINDER Spent fuel management


Time Evolution of high
level activity products
Example: 236Pu Decay Chain

236 α 232 α 228 α


94 Pu 
→ 92 U 
→ 90 Th 
→
224 α 220 α 216 α
88 Ra 
→ 86 Rn 
→ 94 Po 
→
212 β- 212 α 208 β-
82 Pb → 83 Bi 
→ 81Tl →
208
82 Pb (Estable)

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

REMINDER Spent fuel management


Nuclear Cycle Back End
From the plant to ...
temporary storage Interim storage
plant’s spent fuel pool dry centralized
pool on-site

reprocess
(recycling) ultimate storage
(repository)
DGR (or other)
CLOSED CYCLE OPEN CYCLE

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 37
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

REMINDER Spent fuel management


Temporary storage
in the plant. Spent
fuel pool.

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 38
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

REMINDER Spent fuel management


Interim storage Example of a
dry storage
centralized
facility

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 39
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

REMINDER Spent fuel management


Interim storage Example of a dry
individualized storage.
Ascó NPP
Tarragona, Spain

The canisters have been manufactured by ENSA


(Spain) and contain 32 spent fuel assemblies

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 40
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

REMINDER Spent fuel management

Deep geological
repository

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 41
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Spent fuel management


These subterranean cities are places no human
will ever inhabit or see, places designed to
repel life and light. They are a mirror image to
our towering achievements above ground and,
like the pyramids, they are both monument
and tomb. Every nuclear nation is compelled to
build them, at great effort and expense, and to
continue building them until we find a better
way to deal with nuclear waste or a better
Scream Edvard Munch
alternative to nuclear power. Until then, we
must live with the thought that in some
unimaginable future aeons hence, this could be
all that remains to prove our species was ever
here.
The Guardian
Sunday 24 April 2011
Nuclear waste: Keep out – for 100,000 years
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 42
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Concerns

• Risk of accidents

• Waste management

• Economics

• Limitation of uranium resources

• Proliferation

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 43
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Economics of nuclear energy

Source: NEA /
IAEA: Uranium
2016:
Resources,
Production and
Demand

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 44
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Economics of nuclear energy

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 45
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Economics of nuclear energy


Typical structure of the cost of nuclear electricity

* Uranium cost is typically some 5%


Source: NEA and IEA

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 46
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Economics of nuclear energy


Effect of a 50% fuel cost increase on the cost of the
kWh electric

Source:
AIE WEO 2006
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 47
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Economics of nuclear energy


Levelized Cost of Electricity for Nuclear, Coal, Gas, PV and Wind,
at different discount rates

Source: IEA NEA Projected costs of


generating electricity 2015 edition

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 48
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Economics of nuclear energy

OECD/IEA © World Energy Outlook 2014

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 49
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Concerns

• Risk of accidents

• Waste management

• Economics

• Limitation of uranium resources

• Proliferation

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 50
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Uranium production and demand


Source:
NEA IAEA:
Uranium 2016:
Resources,
Production
and Demand

Committed
production centres
are those that are
either under
construction or are
firmly committed for
construction.

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 51
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Uranium production and demand


• Identified resources recoverable at costs of <USD 130/kgU were
estimated as 5.72 MtU in 2015.
• Meeting high case demand requirements would consume less than
30% of the total 2015 identified resource base by 2035 (resources
recoverable at a cost of <USD 130/kgU). (NEA IAEA: Uranium 2016:
Resources, Production and Demand)
• Nevertheless, new mines will be required as present production
declines.

Reasonably assured reserves


Reminder

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 52
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Uranium production and demand

OECD/IEA © World Energy Outlook 2014

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 53
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Demand of fuel cycle services


Forecast of conversion services demand and offer

Secondary supply

Source: E. Supko, T Meade “Conversion: Is renewal on the way?”


in Nuclear Eng. International, 7 Oct..2013 ERI: Energy Resources International

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 54
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Demand of fuel cycle services


Forecast of enrichment services demand and offer

Requirements per area Supply adequacy.


Redirection of
Source: T Meade, E Supko “Enrichment Rosatom to
excess is here to stay ” in NEI, 13 Oct..2015 uranium
ERI: Energy Resources International production

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 55
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Concerns

• Risk of accidents

• Waste management

• Economics

• Limitation of uranium resources

• Proliferation

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 56
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Proliferation
• Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty
– 5 states permitted to have nuclear weapons
– These states agree not to transfer weapons
technology to others
Bomb grade fissile material can be obtained
from the fuel cycle:

- Enriching uranium up to over 90% 235U

- Separating Pu from U while plutonium


composition is almost 239Pu
Incomplete fuel burn-up
+
Reprocessing technology

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 57
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Concerns

• Risk of accidents

• Waste management

• Economics

• Limitation of uranium resources

• Proliferation

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 58
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

The nuclear fuel cycle


Source: WNA

5.54 MWd/kg Unatural

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 59
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

The nuclear fuel cycle


Source: WNA

7.0 MWd/kg Unatural

Assuming the annual operation of 1000 MWe of nuclear power reactor capacity
such as in the new EPR, with 5% enriched fuel and higher (65 GWd/t) burn-up:

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 60
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Advanced fuel cycles


• Aims of advanced nuclear fuel cycles:
– Improve the energy use of the fuel
– Reduce the radiological impact of waste in the long term
– Allow a simpler and more economical repository for spent fuel
– Reduce the proliferation risk
– Improve the perspectives for nuclear energy in the long term
• Necessary technological developments:
– treatment of irradiated fuel
– development of new fuels
– transmutation (partitioning and transmutation)

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 61
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Advanced fuel cycles


• In summary, thanks to technological advances, and
especially to transmutation, advanced nuclear fuel cycles
for fission reactors must allow:
– Recover the energy contained in the spent fuel
– Provide fuel for reactors of future generations
– Reduce the volume and toxicity of spent fuel
– Reduce the risk of proliferation that plutonium from spent fuel
represents
– Better use geological storage option (economically,
environmentally, proliferation-resistant)

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 62
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

New reactors

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 63
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

New reactors
Generation III
ABWR

EPR

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 64
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

New reactors
• Characteristics of 3rd generation reactors:
– Standardized designs: ease of licensing and reduction of costs and
construction time.
– Simpler and more robust designs: ease of operation, reduced
vulnerability to failures.
– Larger availability, longer operating times ~60 years.
– Smaller probability of accidents resulting in core melting (many designs
feature passive safety systems).
– Larger fuel burn-ups, to reduce the use of the uranium resource and the
amount of waste.
• European Utility Requirements (EUR document): reactors must
allow the use of mixed oxides (MOX) fuels (U-PuO2).

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 65
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Reminder Reprocessing
Materials suitable for fission
• Fissile nuclides: fission can
be triggered by neutrons of
whatever energy, including very
low energies, (uranium-235,
uranium-233, plutonium-239,
plutonium-241).
2.4 d
• Fissionable nuclides: need
neutrons with E > 1 MeV
(uranium-238).
• The latter are called Fertile
because these nuclei (232Th,
238U) can yield fissile nuclei on

neutron capture.
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 66
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Reminder Reprocessing
Comparison of the
composition of fuel before • Fuel reprocessing allows
the recuperation of U and
and after irradiation Pu from spent fuel
EXAMPLE

• Plutonium and other


actinides are obtained from
fuel reprocessing plants

• MOX = Mixed Oxides (UO2


+ PuO2, but other actinides
as well: NpO2)

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 67
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Reprocessing
Z

Nuclide chart

Zoom in the actinide zone

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 68
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

MOX Fuel
PUREX process
• Fuel chopping
• Dissolution in nitric acid
• Separation of U and Pu from
the fission products and minor
actinides by a countercurrent
solvent (tributyl phosphate)
extraction process
• U is separated from Pu (U
remains on the organic phase,
Pu is transferred to the
aqueous phase)
• Pu is concentrated by
evaporation and converted to
PuO2.
• U is concentrated by
evaporation and converted to
UO2.
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources
69
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 69
Source: WNA
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

MOX Fuel
• Recycled plutonium is mixed with depleted uranium, in
an adequate proportion to obtain the desired fissile
proportion.
– The mixture is grinded to form a solid solution of U-PuO2 which
will be used to produce fuel pellets by sintering
• In the future, reprocessing will evolve towards PUREX
variants that will provide the plutonium already mixed
with other actinides and uranium.
– The COEX process (France) leaves some U with the Pu and
possibly some Np.
– The UREX+ process (USA) leaves the Pu with other transuranic
elements to be used as fuel in fast spectrum reactors.
– Japanese reprocessing is linked to French developments.
These developments address proliferation risks
and waste treatment
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 70
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Generation IV

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 71
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Generation IV

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 72
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Generation IV
Objectives (1)
• Sustainability:
– provide sustainable energy generation that meets clean air
objectives and promotes long-term availability of systems and
effective fuel utilization
– minimize waste generation and reduce its effect in the long term
• Economy:
– clear life-cycle cost advantage over other energy sources
– level of financial risk comparable to other energy projects

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 73
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Generation IV
Objectives (and 2)
• Safety and Reliability
– very low likelihood and degree of reactor core damage
– elimination of the need for offsite emergency response
• Proliferation Resistance and Physical Protection :
– assure that the reactors are a very unattractive and the least
desirable route for diversion or theft of weapons-usable materials
– provide increased physical protection against acts of terrorism

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 74
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Reminder Fast reactors


Microscopic cross section of the two principal
uranium isotopes 4
Probability of a fission reaction

Fission microscopic cross section σf (barn) 1x10


Larger probability
3
1x10 235U

2
1x10

1x101
Smaller
probability
1x100
En=0.025 eV

1x10-1
238U
-2
1x10

1x10-3 1x103

1x104

1x105

1x107
1x10-3

1x100

1x106
1x10-2

1x10-1

1x101

1x10

Neutron energy (eV) 1 barn = 10-24 cm2

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 75
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Fast reactors
• Almost all the operating reactors are “thermal”, i.e. fissions are
induced by low energy neutrons (thermal spectrum).
• The reason is that the best way to sustain a fission chain needs the
slowing down (moderation) of the neutrons produced in the fissions
(that have a fast energy spectrum).
• In fast reactors the presence of moderating material (substances
with light atoms such as water or graphite) is avoided in order to
have a neutron spectrum as fast as possible.
• Usually, fast reactors are cooled by liquid metal (sodium, lead or
lead-bismuth), with high conductivity and high boiling point and
without moderating effect. They operate at 500-550°C and at near
atmospheric pressures.

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 76
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Fast reactors
• In a typical fast reactor, the fuel in the core is Pu-239 (or U-238 with
Pu-239)
• The core is designed so that large number of neutrons escape from
it and produce Pu-239 in the fertile U-238 breding blanket.
• Part of the U-238 can undergo fission (basically in the core, since
the neutrons that reach the blanket have lost part of its energy and,
therefore, the only possible reaction with U-238 is capture, which
generates Pu-239)
• This type of reactor is more efficient in breeding than the current
thermal reactors.
• Fissile nuclei emit more neutrons when fission is induced by fast
neutrons than when by thermal neutrons
• Pu-239 emits more neutrons per fission than U-235

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 77
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Fast reactors

fission Fission propagation


neutrons
Fission fragment

Incident 200 MeV


neutron Radiative
capture

Breeding
Uranium-238 --- Plutonium-239

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 78
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Fast reactors

BLANKET CORE BLANKET


238U 238U 238U
+239Pu

Fission
Breeding Breeding

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 79
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Fast reactors
235U

From using less than 1% of the uranium to using 100%


238U

Source: GIF Source: GIF

940 MWd/kg Unatural

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 80
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Fast reactors
The role of fast reactors:
• Fast reactors can be designed as
breeder reactors to produce more
fissile material than they consume
• Also (without the breeding blanket)
they can be used as plutonium
“burners”
• A fast reactor could as well be used to
transmute (“burn”) part of the other
actinides
Transmutation probabilities %

Source: Chang, Y.I. 2014,


Plentiful Energy, the Story
of the Integral Fast
Reactor, Argonne, May
2014 (in WNA web site)

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


81
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering
Source: GIF
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Fast reactors
Fast nuclear Some 400 reactor-years experience has been gained in operation of FNR
reactors in
Generation IV reactor designs are largely of this type (FNR are a priority in
the World international cooperation)
Source: WNA
BN-800 Beloyarsk 4
(Rosatom)

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 82
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Advanced fuel cycles


• Different concepts of the fuel
cycle:
– One-through (open cycle
without any reprocessing
uranium)
– reprocessing of spent fuel, use
of U and Pu in thermal reactors,
– spent fuel reprocessing, use of
U and Pu in a mix of thermal
and fast reactors (fast breeder
reactors)
– Inclusion of thorium (thorium-
232) in the fuel cycle

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 83
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Thorium cycle
Cycle U+Pu Cycle U+Pu+Th

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 84
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Thorium cycle
• Thorium is much more abundant in nature than uranium
– It is found in small amounts in most rocks and soils, where it is 3 times
more abundant than uranium.
– Thorium is found in various minerals (the most common monazite,
which contains up to 12% thorium oxide, but the average is 6-7%).
– Thorium-232 is slightly radioactive but there are other isotopes in the
chain of uranium-238 which (although present in tiny amounts) are more
radioactive: thorium-234 and thorium-230.
• Thorium-232 can be used as nuclear fuel because it can generate
(breeding) uranium-233.
• The thorium fuel cycle produces much smaller amounts of plutonium
and other transuranic nuclides, comparing with the cycles of
uranium.

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 85
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Thorium cycle
Reasonably assured and
Reasonably assured Uranium resources plus
inferred Thorium resources
inferred resources, to US$ 130/kg U
recoverable at a cost of $80/kg
Th or less
Source: WNA
Data taken from IAEA NEA
Uranium 2014: Resources,
Production and Demand

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 86
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Small Modular Reactors


Diverse technologies

High interest:
• Safety
• passive safety features
• Could be placed underground or
underwater
• Reduced radioactivity inventory
• Costs
• Modularized
• Constructed in a factory (versus
being erected in-situ)
• Remote areas, countries with weak
grids
• Removable as a whole after operation
(versus decommissioning in-situ)
• etc.

More info: http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-cycle/nuclear-power-reactors/small-nuclear-power-


reactors.aspx

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 87
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Fueling the future

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 88
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear Fusion

Nuclear Fusion process

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 89
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear Fusion
2H + 3H  4He + n

Comparison between fusion energy and


fission energy
Efusion= 17.6 MeV (4 nucleons involved)
Efission= 200 MeV (235 nucleons involved)

17.6 Mev 200 Mev


4
= 4.4 MeV/nucl. > 235
= 0.85 MeV/nucl.

Fusion Fission

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 90
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear Fusion

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 91
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear Fusion

Evolution
of n T τ

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 92
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear Fusion
Central Blanket
Solenoid Module

Vacuum Vessel
Outer Intercoil
Structure
Cryostat
Toroidal Field Coil
Port Plug (IC Heating)

Poloidal Field Coil


Divertor

Machine Gravity Supports


Torus Cryopump

ITER

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IP7Vuqz-MAE

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 93
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear Fusion
• Safe by physical principle
• Radioactive waste: production orders of
magnitude below that of fission
• The first generation of fusion reactors must relay
on the D-T reaction 2H + 3H  4He + n
• Deuterium is “abundant” in sea water:
• 33 g m-3
• 46 1012 tonnes
• Tritium:
• do not exist in nature (T1/2 = 12.3 year)
• must be produced from lithium (6Li)
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources
Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 94
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Nuclear Fusion
• Lithium is abundant in earth crust, in pegmatites and salt formations:
– North Carolina: 3Mt
– DR of Congo: 2.3 Mt
– Urals: 0.4 Mt
– Chile and Bolivia : ~ 7 Mt
Reserves: 2 Mt. Resources: 14 Mt.
• 2 g D + 6 g 6Li = 40 toe
• Two natural isotopes: 6Li (7.42%) and 7Li (92.58%).
• Having into consideration consumptions in conventional and
expanding applications (among them batteries and breeding
blankets), existing lithium can provide energy during 200-300 years.
• Lithium is present in earth crust (some 60 ppm) and in sea water (0.17 ppm)
which is equivalent to 240 109 tonnes

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 95
Nuclear Energy in the XXI century

Thanks for your attention

Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (BarcelonaTECH) Energy Resources


Master’s Degree in Energy Engineering 96
96

You might also like