(/contact-

(/where-
(/gas- (/cart/)(/login-
(/) us/) to- detectors/product-
lobby/)
buy/) search/)
Solutions (/solutions/)

iNet Now Live Monitoring (/solutions/inet-now/)

iNet Control (/solutions/inet-control/)

iNet Exchange (/solutions/inet-exchange/)

By Application (/solutions/by-application/)

Hot Work (/solutions/by-application/hot-work/)

Hazmat (/solutions/by-application/hazmat/)

Fire - Emergency Response (/solutions/by-application/ re---emergency-response/)

Fence Line - Perimeter Monitoring (/solutions/by-application/fence-line---perimeter-monitoring/)

Con ned Spaces (/solutions/by-application/con ned-spaces/)

Turnarounds and Shutdowns (/solutions/by-application/Turnarounds-and-Shutdowns/)

Mobile Worker (/solutions/by-application/mobile-worker/)

In-Plant (/solutions/by-application/in-plant/)

Connected Safety (/solutions/connected-safety/)

iNet Documents (/solutions/inet-documents/)

Gas Detectors (/gas-detectors/)

By Model (/gas-detectors/model/)

Ventis Pro (/products/gas-detectors/ventis-pro/ventis-pro-series-monitor/)

MX6 iBrid (/products/gas-detectors/mx6/mx6-monitor/)

Ventis MX4 (/products/gas-detectors/ventis-mx4/ventis-mx4-monitor/)

Tango TX1 (/products/gas-detectors/tango-tx1/tango-tx1-monitor/)

GasBadge Pro (/products/gas-detectors/gasbadge-pro/gasbadge-pro-monitor/)

Radius BZ1 (/products/gas-detectors/radius-bz1/radius-bz1-monitor/)

Technology (/gas-detectors/technology/)

DualSense Technology (/gas-detectors/technology1/dualsense/)

iAssign Technology (/gas-detectors/technology1/iassign/)

Connectivity (/gas-detectors/connectivity/)

RGX Gateway (/products/gas-detectors/rgx-gateway/rgx-gateway/)

LENS Wireless (/gas-detectors/connectivity1/lens-wireless/)

Ventis® Pro5 Wi- Battery (/products/gas-detectors/ventis-pro/ventis-pro5-wi- -battery/)

By Gas (/gas-detectors/by-gas/)

Ammonia (/gas-detectors/by-gas/ammonia-nh3/)

Carbon Dioxide (/gas-detectors/by-gas/carbon-dioxide-co2/)

Carbon Monoxide (/gas-detectors/by-gas/carbon-monoxide-co/)

Chlorine (/gas-detectors/by-gas/chlorine-cl2/)

Chlorine Dioxide (/gas-detectors/by-gas/chlorine-dioxide-clo2/)

Hydrogen (/gas-detectors/by-gas/hydrogen-h2/)

Hydrogen Chloride (/gas-detectors/by-gas/hydrogen-chloride-hcl/)

Hydrogen Cyanide (/gas-detectors/by-gas/hydrogen-cyanide-hcn/)

Hydrogen Sul de (/gas-detectors/by-gas/hydrogen-sul de-h2s/)

Methane (/gas-detectors/by-gas/methane-detectors-ch4/)

Nitric Oxide (/gas-detectors/by-gas/nitric-oxide-no/)

Nitrogen Dioxide (/gas-detectors/by-gas/nitrogen-dioxide-no2/)

Oxygen (/gas-detectors/by-gas/oxygen-o2/)

Phosphine (/gas-detectors/by-gas/phosphine-ph3/)

Sulfur Dioxide (/gas-detectors/by-gas/sulfur-dioxide-so2/)

Product Search (/gas-detectors/product-search/)

Certi ed Pre-Owned (/gas-detectors/certi ed-pre-owned/)

Maintenance & Cal Gas (/gas-detectors/maintenance-page/)

DSX Docking Station (/products/gas-detectors/docking-stations/dsx-docking-station-prd/)

Calibration Gas (/gas-detectors/maintenance/calibration-gas/)

Calibration Gas Reference Tool (/gas-detectors/maintenance/calibration-gas-reference-tool/)

Cal Gas Accessories (/gas-detectors/maintenance/cal-gas-accessories/)

Calibration Gas Autoreplenishment Program (/gas-detectors/maintenance/calibration-gas-

autoreplenishment-program/)
 Bump-N-Go (/gas-detectors/maintenance/bump-n-go/)

Remote Sampling (/gas-detectors/remote-sampling/)

Warranty (/gas-detectors/warranty/)

Catalog Request (/gas-detectors/catalog-request/)

Training (/training/)

Gas Detection Made Easy Courses (/training/gas-detection-made-easy/)

Video Training (/training/video-training/)

Instructor Led Webinars (/training/instructor-led-webinars/)

General Gas Education (/training/general-gas-education/)

GDME Mobile App (/training/gdme-mobile-app/)

Register for a Class (/training/register-for-a-class/)

Rental (/gas-detector-rental/)

Repair (/repair/)

Repair Centers (/repair/repair-centers/)

Return Repair Form (/repair/return-repair-form/)

Company (/company/)

About Us (/company/about-us/)

Our Leaders (/company/our-leaders/)

Work With Us (/company/work-with-us/)

Newsroom (/company/news/)

eBooks (/company/news/ebooks/)

Case Studies (/company/news/case-studies/)

White Papers (/company/news/white-papers/)

Press Releases (/company/news/press-releases/)

Product Bulletins (/company/news/product-bulletin/)

Published Articles (/company/news/published-articles/)

Corporate Certi cations (/company/corporate-certi cations/)

Policies (/company/policies/)
Blog (/the-monitor-blog/)

Home (/) > Blog Search (/blog-search/) > Combustible Gas Detection – Infrared or Catalytic Bead?

COMBUSTIBLE GAS DETECTION –

INFRARED OR CATALYTIC BEAD?
DAVE WAGNER | FRIDAY, JULY 29, 2011
One of the latest and fastest growing trends in gas detection today is the use of infrared
sensors for detecting LEL levels of combustible gas. I was engaged in a lengthy debate
with a customer this week on whether or not the infrared technology was the right t for
the job he was doing. The question is, is it right for your application?

Many people have joined the movement toward infrared combustible gas detectors
based on the belief that this technology provides greater stability in readings, longer
sensor life, and less need for calibration, or even no need for calibration at all. There may
be some degree of truth to these points, but we will come back and discuss them later.
There are other points to consider about infrared sensors and their catalytic bead
sensor counterparts rst.

Infrared sensors do provide two clear advantages for detecting combustible gases.
They do not lose sensitivity due to chemical poisoning and do not require oxygen to be
present in order to function appropriately like the traditional catalytic bead sensors.

But this is where the clear advantages stop. The output of infrared sensors can be
greatly affected by high humidity and changes in ambient temperature and pressure.
The effects of these factors on catalytic bead sensors are generally considered to be
negligible.

The output from infrared sensors is inherently non-linear and response curves vary for
different species of gas. This means that the sensor must be characterized and
calibrated to a particular gas in order to produce a linear result. The linear response of
the catalytic bead sensor makes it very easy to predict its response to various gases
and provide a correlation factor based on virtually any gas used for calibration.

But most importantly, infrared sensors are not capable of detecting hydrogen. If you are
using an infrared sensor in a safety monitoring application where there is any possibility
that hydrogen may present an explosion hazard, STOP! Immediately! You may be in
serious jeopardy!

Back to those original beliefs about the infrared sensors. Generally speaking, the
infrared-based sensors do have better long term stability and should provide longer
sensor life based on the long-life IR light sources that are used. However, these sensors
are still exposed to the environment and hazards of everyday use on the job and
therefore are susceptible to having the gas pathway to the sensor blocked by dirt and
debris. If gas cannot enter the sensor, it cannot be detected. The characteristics of the
light source and the IR detector may also be changed due to damage from physical
shock. For these reasons, it is still very important that infrared combustible gas sensors
are bump tested and calibrated regularly.

Infrared sensors for detecting combustible gases may be the latest wave. And they
may be the perfect choice in applications where detection of a known gas in a low
oxygen environment is necessary. But before you have IR sensors installed in your
instruments, make sure that they truly will work for you.

Dave

(/the-monitor-blog/subscribe-to-the-monitor-newsletter/)

<< Previous Post (/blog-search/why-do-i-see-negative-readings-on-my-gas-monitor/)Home (/the-monitor-blog/)

Next Post (/blog-search/so2-sensor-and-acetylene/) >>

Share Share Tweet Email Print

Solutions (/solutions/)
By Application (/solutions/by-application/)
 Gas Detectors (/gas-detectors/)
Product Search (/gas-detectors/product-search/)
By Model (/gas-detectors/model/)
By Gas (/gas-detectors/by-gas/)
ASC Parts Warranty Request (/warranty-part-input-form/)

Rental (/gas-detector-rental/)
Training (/training/)
Repair (/repair/)

Company (/company/)
About Us (/company/about-us/)
Work With Us (/company/work-with-us/)
Newsroom (/company/news/)

The Monitor Blog (/the-monitor-blog/)

(http://www.linkedin.com/company/industri
(http://www.facebook.com/IndSci)
(http://www.youtube.com/indsci)
scienti
(https://www.instagram.com/industrial_
c)
(https://twitter.com/#!/IndSci_Corp)

Languages (/link/cdfb651ba486454ca60f8de33fa8922d.aspx)

Website Feedback (/website-feedback/)

Did you nd a bug, error

or a feature you like?
Let us know!

Home (/) | Contact Us (/contact-us/) | Where to Buy (/where-to-buy/) | Product Search (/gas-
detectors/product-search/) | Quote Cart (/cart/) | Terms of Use (/terms-of-use/) | Privacy
Statement (/privacy-statement/) | Login (/login/)

© Industrial Scienti c | One Life Way Pittsburgh, PA 15205-7500 USA | +1 412-788-

4353 | info@indsci.com