Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Noninvasive blood glucose monitoring is a long pursued goal in clinical diagnostic. Among several other optical
methods, near infrared absorption spectroscopy is the most promising one for the noninvasive application to date.
However, realization has not been achieved. A major obstacle is the low signal-to-noise ratio pertinent to physiological
blood glucose measurement using the near infrared absorption technique. Sensitivity analysis of aqueous glucose
absorption signals was performed in the combination band region and in the first-overtone region. The analysis
involved quantification of both glucose absorption signal and the corresponding spectral noise within a particular
wavelength region. Glucose absorption band at 4430cm1 (2257nm) in the combination band region was found to give
an order of magnitude higher signal-to-noise ratio than the strongest band in the first-overtone region. A Fourier-
filtering algorithm was applied to the raw absorbance data to remove some of the unwanted spectral variations.
With simple peak-to-peak analysis to the Fourier-filtered absorbance data, repeatability of less than
was achieved. In addition, effects of temperature variations on the absorption spectra were studied. The effects of
sample temperature were compensated with the application of the Fourier filter.
Keywords: noninvasive, sensitivity, glucose, spectrocopy, infrared, absorption, fourier, blood, signal, noise
Optical Techniques and Instrumentation for the Measurement of Blood Composition, Structure,
and Dynamics, Alexander V. Priezzhev, P. Ake Oberg, Editors, Proceedings of SPIE Vol. 4163 (2000) 45
© 2000 SPIE · 1605-7422/00/$15.00
Sign
Most of the efforts in this research area have been focused on the software, which is mainly in the development
of mathematical algorithms in the form of " calibration" techniques to extract spectral information due to glucose
variations and suppress spectral noise and other unwanted variations3'4'5'6'7 . They involve taking a sufficiently
large amount of data from measurements of known glucose concentration values and building calibration algorithms
to fit the data. Although this is an important and necessary operation, the importance of understanding the origins
and characteristics of both the noise and the signal is often overlooked. Particularly, comprehension of hardware
limitations deserves more attention as it is known that the instrument often introduces noise much higher than the
glucose signal. Depending on the characteristics of the noise, the post-processing algorithms may not be able to
suppress it.
In this project, we take a somewhat different approach. We put significant effort on instrumental limitations
understanding as well instrumental optimization through the development of a custom near infrared Fourier transform
spectrometer.8 In this paper, the SNRs of two near-infrared glucose absorption bands in the first-overtone region
Tsampie(vi)
A(v) = —loge (1)
( T reference (ii) )
where A(v) is the absorption peak at wavenumber zi, Tsampie 5 the transmission spectrum of the sample and
Treference 5 the transmission spectrum of the reference. The reference could be an air background spectrum or the
spectrum of a pure buffer.
Therefore, in the single-beam absorption spectroscopy, measurement repeatability is of prime importance. In other
words, in-between-measurement errors have to be small compared with the absorption signal intensity. For example,
if the absorption intensity of the sample of interest is one absorption unit (AU) , the measurement uncertainties (or
the absorption spectral noise) has to be significantly less than one AU. Comparison between spectral noise and the
absorption intensity is usually apparent in qualitative measurements, where the presence and clarity of the absorption
peaks are all that need to be observed.
In quantitative studies, however, more careful analysis needs to be done to determine the ratio of the signal to
the noise. In these studies, signal intensity is related to the resolution of the sample concentration change to be
achieved. For a smaller step of concentration change to be observed, the signal intensity that needs to be recorded
will be lower. This is apparent from the Beer Lambert's law, which states that the absorption signal intensity is
linearly related to the path-length and the concentration, as indicated in eqn.(2),
N(ii) = -loge
(:) .
Ta and Tb are transmission spectra of the same buffer (for example, pure water) taken at two different times, usually
(3)
back-to-back, as shown in figure 2. Note that ideally, N is a flat line at zero across the wavenumbers. This is the
case where there is zero noise, or the measurement is perfectly repeatable. The root-mean-square (RMS) value of
the spectral noise NRMS in a particular wavelength region is computed as
where n is the number of spectral elements being observed. Note that the RMS value is usually three to five times
smaller than the peak-to-peak noise value. The SNR can then be computed as,
Figure 2. Left: transmission spectra of two same buffers. Right: illustration of absorption spectral noise and
signal-to-noise ratio evaluation in single-beam spectroscopy measurements.
Blocked by optical
Figure 3. Near infrared transmission spectrum of water in a 2mm path-length quartz cuvette
As seen in figure 3, there are two near infrared regions where water has relatively higher tranmittance. One is
between 5400cm1 and 6400cm' (1560nm and l85Onrn) and the other is between 4300cm' and 4800cm' (2080nm
x iø-
5860 5880 5900 5920 5940 5960 5980 6000 6020 6040
Wavenumber (cm-') Wavenumber (cm-')
Figure 4. Absorption spectra of aqueous glucose solutions in the first-overtone region. Left: raw absorption spectra.
Right: Fourier-filtered absorption spectra
To quantify the correlation of the filtered spectrum and its corresponding glucose concentration, simple peak-to-
peak assessment was performed. For the first-overtone band, the filtered absorbance magnitude was calculated to be
the maximum peak height at around 5940cm' minus the midpoint of the two minimum values of the valley around
5885cm' and around 6000cm' . Similarly for the combination band region, the filtered absorbance magnitude was
calculated to be the maximum peak height at around 4430cm' minus the midpoint of the two minimum values of
the valley around 4380em' and around 4480cm'. Simple algorithms were used to perform this evaluation, and
are illustrated in eqn. (6) and eqn. (7) for the first-overtone and the combination band region respectively.
165mM
-1.5
=
-2 - -- --- 84mM
-2.5
-3 125m?4-
-as
-4 -- -
-4_s ----
4350 4400 4450 4500 4550 4380 4400 4420 4440 4460 4-480 4500
Wavenumber (cm') Wavenumber (cm-')
Figure 5. Absorption spectra of aqueous glucose solutions in the combination band region. Left: raw absorption
spectra. Right: Fourier-filtered absorption spectra
Figure 6 shows how these values change as a function of glucose concentration for both the first-overtone band
and the combination band. For both cases, the magnitude of the absorbance seem to vary linearly with glucose
concentration. The rate of change is approximately 2.3 x 1O_6 per mmol/L for the first-overtone region, and 3. 1 x iO
per mmol/L for the combination band region. Thus, the Fourier filtered glucose absorption signal intensity in the
4430cm1 band is 13.5 higher than in the 5940cm' band. Note however that these are not the true absorbance
values due to the application of the digital Fourier filter. With carefull analysis, the true absorbance value was
estimated to be twice the filtered value for the first-overtone band and 2.6 times as high for the combination band.
Another thing to infer from figure 6 is that the repeatability in the combination band is much better than what is
achievable in the first-overtone band. This can be seen from how close the two absorbance values from the same
concentrations are with each other.
,,
8 tO
= 8
=
= 0
'.5
0 00
8
0
0 0
0.5 0 8°
00 8 8
8
_o 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 880 0 5 tO 5 20 25 30 35
Figure 6. Fourier-filtered peak absorbance as a function of glucose concentration. Left: first-overtone region. Right:
combination band region
Glucose
0.015 - - - _40pc 6
40C
0.01
0
0.005 Glucose
25CC
0 -4
4300 4350 4400 4450 4500 4550 4600 4360 4380 4400 4420 4440 4460 4480 4500
Figure 7. Left: spectral variations due to sample temperature changes. Right: removal of temperature effects
through Fourier filtering. Note: glucose concentration: 32mmol/L
In the case of noninvasive applications, the radiation would most likely need to penetrate through a tissue.
Tissue property variations may create spectral variations, which may be larger than the signal from glucose changes.
Therefore, measurements may not be repeatable. Careful studies need to be done to understand the characteristics
of the spectral noise due to each tissue variation. As demonstrated in the case of temperature effects, some may be
eliminated or compensated through the post-processing algorithms.
In addition to the irreproducibility due to tissue variations, the radiation that can be collected would be much
lower in intensity due to the additional scattering and absorption that take place in the tissue. It is likely that the
signal would be low enough such that detector noise becomes the dominant source of noise. When this is the case,
spectral signal-to-noise ratio or the achievable sensitivity would decrease in proportion to the decrease in signal.
More efforts need to be put in careful investigations of the effects of tissue to the spectral noise, and finally to the
achievable signal-to-noise ratio, before realization of a reliable noninvasive glucose sensor is possible.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors greatly appreciate the financial support provided by the Home Automation & Health Care Consortium.
In addition, the authors are indebted to Professor Ian Hunter and Dr.Colin Brenan of MIT for the invaluable
discussions and suggestions.
REFERENCES
1. The Diabetes Control and Complications Trial Research Group, "The effect of intensive treatment of diabetes
on the development and progression of long-term complications in isulin-dependent diabetes melitus," N. Engi.
J. Med. 329, pp.977-986, 1993
2. OS. Khalil, "Spectroscopic and clinical aspects of noninvasive glucose measurements," Gun. Chem. 45(2), pp.165-
177, 1999
3. F.M. Ham, G.M. Cohen, I. Kostanic, BR. Gooch, "Multivariate determination of glucose concentrations from
optimally filtered frequency-warped NIR spectra of human blood serum," Physiol. Meas. 17, pp.1-20, 1996
4. M.J. Mattu, G.W. Small, M.A. Arnold, "Determination of glucose in a biological matrix by multivariate analysis
of multiple band-pass-filtered Fourier transform near-infrared interferograms," Anal. Chem. 69(22), pp.4695-4072,
1997
5. D.M. Haaland, M.R. Robinson, G.W. Koepp, E.V. Thomas, R.P. Eaton, "Reagentless near-infrared determination
of glucose in whole-blood using multivariate calibration," Appl. Spect. 46(10), pp.1575-1578, 1992