Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction • Concepts & Framework Thierry Chaumantin 3:00 p.m. – 3:15 p.m.
Session 1: Implementing a TP • Manage E2E Cycle Jeroen Lemmens 3:15 p.m. – 4:00 p.m.
Policy • Structure operations
Session 2: Addressing Common • Indirect Tax Liesbet Nevelsteen 4:00 p.m. – 4:40 p.m.
Challenges • Management Reporting Thierry Chaumantin
• System Data Gaps
Session 3: Case study: Applying • Scenario Thierry Chaumantin 5:00 p.m. – 5:50 p.m.
Technology to manage E2E • Tool Demo Delphine Maeckelberghe
Process for Transfer Pricing on
Goods
Reception
Arm’s
Length
Mark-up
True-up
VAT
Man
Business
model
Planning /
Defend Ex-ante
People & Organization Indirect Tax
documentation
Plan Process
Operate
Defend
Business TP policy
model TP benchmarks
TP tax audit
I/C agreement
Planning /
Defend Ex-ante
documentation
TP local file
(Ex-post) TP Life TP
TP master file Documentation Cycle procedures Guidelines
CbCR Operating procedure
Others
Plan
Black boxes
Defend
Business
model
Planning /
Defend Ex-ante
documentation
(Ex-post) TP Life TP
Documentation Cycle procedures
Defend
Implementing a TP Policy
Manage E2E TP Cycle &
structure Operations
Business
model
Planning /
Defend Ex-ante People & Organization Indirect Tax
documentation
Plan Process
Operate
Defend
(Ex-post) TP Life TP
Documentation Cycle procedures
Control Calculate
Process
Plan
Operate
Defend
Ex-post documentation
available Business
model
Alignment between ex-
post and ex-ante
Planning /
documentation Defend Ex-ante
Consistency between ex- documentation
post documentation of
different countries
(Ex-post) TP Life TP
Documentation Cycle procedures
Control Calculate
Process
Plan
Operate
Defend
© 2017 Deloitte Belgium 11
TP Life Cycle
“Operate” Phase – Check List
TP
Manager
Business
model
Planning /
Defend Ex-ante
documentation
(Ex-post) TP Life TP
Documentation Cycle procedures
Control Calculate
Effective tools to
calculate TP on goods
Process Effective tools to calculate
Plan TP on services
Adequate I/C invoice process
Operate
Approach to handle I/C price
correction
Defend
61%
Percentage of those who think that there
are no effective internal procedures in
place to rapidly detect any new
intercompany flow that occurs during the
fiscal year.
Ex-ante
documentation
78%
Percentage of those who think that it is
not easy to reference back the material
intercompany flow to an up-to-date and
valid TP Benchmark study (i.e. accepted
during a tax audit).
TP
procedures
Calculate
61%
Percentage of those who are not sure
whether that the transfer prices on
tangible goods for the next fiscal year are
based on the budget numbers.
Process
50%
Percentage of those who think that the
Indirect Tax impact of TP true-up invoices
has not been evaluated, nor that the
potential negative consequences (e.g.
custom fees & duties exposure, Intrastat
reporting) are being mitigated.
Control
(Ex-post)
Documentation
78%
Percentage of those who do not think
that the financial reports required for
local TP documentation can be easily
produced.
(Ex-post)
Documentation
56%
Percentage of those who are not sure that
there is an annual review process to check
whether the financial data included in the
local TP documentation is consistent with
the TP Benchmark studies and the TP
policy.
Business
model
Planning /
Defend Ex-ante
documentation People & Organization Indirect Tax
Plan
Process
Operate
Defend
Ex-ante TP Ex-post
Calculate Process Control
documentation procedures documentation
TP Manager
FP&A Finance
IT
SSC
Indirect Tax
FP&A
Finance Cycle
Forecasts
Ex-ante TP Ex-post
Calculate Process Control
documentation procedures documentation
Strong
Weak
Business
model
Planning /
Defend Ex-ante
documentation People & Organization Indirect Tax
Plan
Process
Operate
Defend
Data Gaps
Routine
margin
Upward
adjustment
Obtaining the ”right profit” based Applying the “right tax” based on
on functions, assets and risk transaction type
Routine
margin }
Upward
adjustment
Take no action Issue credit note Take no action Issue credit note
CIT exposure for LRD Import fees & duties
leakage
Intrastat reporting
Reference to original
© 2017 Deloitte Belgium invoices 25
Typical Indirect Tax Challenge – Case 2
TP True-Up Downward Adjustment and Debit Note
Entrepreneur Distributor (LRD)
Routine
}
margin Downward
adjustment
Take no action Issue debit note Take no action Issue debit note
CIT exposure for (Except in some countries Import fees & duties
Entrepreneur where downward exposure
adjustments are not CIT
Intrastat reporting
deductible leading to
double taxation) Reference to original
© 2017 Deloitte Belgium invoices 26
Typical Indirect Tax Challenge -3
TP True-Ups as Marketing/Sales Support Service Allocation
Routine
} Seller Buyer
Downward
margin adjustment
Sales support
Routine
Routine
margin
TP1 1 margin }
3
}
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
4 Calculate upward/downward
adjustment on extrapolated year-end
Main Supply margins
5
Routine
margin
TP1 TP2 } 4
6
TP2
}
}
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
Data Gaps
Costs Revenues
Routine
margin E2E margin
Residual
profit
Manufacturer Distributor
Transfer price
{
• Standard • Standard
• Material
Standard (actual) (actual)
• Labor cost cost
(actual)
cost • Machine • TP margin • E2E margin
3 Re-Classify PPV to inventory for unsold stock at year-end for statutory reporting
Statutory OP
Data Gaps
01 04
Budgets are prepared using If EBIT Budget & Forecast can
Management Reporting be linked to a legal entity, there
dimensions but not legal entity is no automatic segmentation
dimensions: by function
• Business Units
• Product Group
• Market /Customer Group
02 05
Forecasts do not usually Budget, Forecast and Quarterly
contain volume information Actuals are usually in
(only monetary equivalent) management GAAP (IFRS, US
GAAP) vs. local GAAP
03
Budget & Forecast are
externally focused and do
usually not contain
• I/C margin on tangible
goods
• I/C recharge of services
01 03
Challenges in getting adequate Challenges in updating ERP
reports for calculation purposes back
• BI reports: gross margin by • Pricing procedures/tables
product and EBIT reports update
• GL account analysis: manual • I/C invoice processing (TP
GL journals/postings – PPV, true-up)
inventory valuation
02
Complex calculations in Excel
spreadsheets to manage
• Mapping
• Reconciliation
• Segmentation
• Simulation
• Output reports
Long Term
Data
Part of ERP/EPM upgrade (S/4 HANA)
Short & Medium Term • Entity dimension
• I/C service recharge
Data Technology
• Fully loaded entity P&L
Rules & formulas Pricing & modelling tool
• Extrapolation IFRS to Stat adj. • Benefit of Excel in terms of
flexibility and user-friendliness
• Extrapolating volume forecast
• Additional functionality
• EBIT segmentation by product
SKU − Audit trail - update
− Server storage
− Workflow
Case Study
Applying Technology to manage
E2E Process for Transfer Pricing
on Goods
NL10
Sales Organization
CZ30
Sales Organization & Plant BE10
Principal
FR10
CH10
Clients
Goods flow
Goods flow Sells at C
Invoice flow
OM% Sales
margin
Principal Principal
margin Margin
Manuf. Manuf. Manuf. C
NCP%
margin margin B margin
Budget A Budget Budget
Standard Standard Standard
cost cost cost
TP benchmarking methods
TNMM method is used with the following
PLIs: NCP for manufacturers and OM for
distributors.
Perform
Actuals FY16 load top-down Sales Actuals load first three
budgeting months FY17
Step 2 Step 7
Review
top-down budget and Bottom-up Sales
perform bottom-up forecast
Sales budgeting
Step 3 Step 8
User legend
Budget production costs Copy OPEX and COGS
Sales Manager budget to forecast
and calculate COGS
Supply Chain Manager
Tax Manager
Budget
Transfer price
OPEX, IC service
calculation for budget &
recharge & Allocation of
review of financial
OPEX
statements
Step 5
Transfer price
calculation for budget & Maintenance
review of financial of user roles, access
statements rights and master data
changes
Apply technology
Use tools to integrate transfer pricing with the FP&A
finance cycle. Tailored tools can be easily built (e.g.
Anaplan)
1
Complete a detailed “Maturity
Level Assessment”
Where are the gaps?
2
Make a business case for an
operational transfer pricing tool
E2E TP process cannot be effectively
managed without technology
Business
model
Planning /
Defend Ex-ante
documentation
Operate
Process
Drafting an action plan
Defend