Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ChanRobles On-Line
Bar Review
THIRD DIVISION
DECISION
GESMUNDO, J.:
The Antecedents
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 2/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
dangerous drug.4
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 3/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 4/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
shabu.5
A.C. No. 9676, they saw PO2 Burgos brought out from a
April 02, 2018 - IN black bag small plastic sachets and money.
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 6/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
Appellee, v. JERRY her possession was marked by PO3 Sarino who searched
BUGNA Y BRITANICO, her person after he spotted her leaving the house of
Accused-Appellants. Malou.
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 9/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
A.K.A. "LENG," or switched before they were delivered to the PNP Crime
Accused-Appellant. Laboratory for examination.
CYNTHIA LOZA, FR. Appellants further contend that such failure of the
EDGARDO ALAURIN, arresting officers to show that they followed the required
AND THE COLLEGE OF procedure in the chain of custody constitutes a deviation
FINE ARTS AND that destroys the presumption of regularity in the
DESIGN FACULTY performance of duty. And although the defense of denial
COUNCIL, is weak, appellants assert that they should nonetheless,
Respondents. be acquitted. They stress that the presumption of
innocence stands as a fundamental principle of both
G.R. Nos. 192595- constitutional and criminal law, imposing a rule on
96, April 11, 2018 - evidence, a degree of proof that demands no less than
NATIONAL total compliance.10
ELECTRIFICATION
On the other hand, the OSG, as Peoples' counsel,
ADMINISTRATION
maintains that appellants' guilt in the crimes they were
(NEA), Petitioner, v.
convicted was proven beyond reasonable doubt. All the
MAGUINDANAO
elements for both crimes of illegal sale and illegal
ELECTRIC
possession of shabu have been sufficiently proven by the
COOPERATIVE, INC.,
evidence presented. The drugs subject of the buy-bust
REPRESENTED BY
sale and those seized from the possession of Malou were
MAGUINDANAO
the same drugs presented and identified in the trial
ELECTRIC
court. Contrary to appellants' assertion, there was
COOPERATIVE-PALMA
substantial compliance with Section 21 (a) of R.A. No.
AREA (MAGELCO-
9165 and the chain of custody, as well as the
PALMA),
presentation of the corpus delicti in court, had likewise
REPRESENTED BY
been sufficiently established.
ATTY. LITTIE SARAH A.
AGDEPPA, ANTONIO As to the alleged absence of appellants when the
U. ACUB, EDGAR L. LA
inventory was being conducted by the arresting officers,
VEGA, RET. JUDGE
this issue was not raised before the trial court during the
TERESITA CARREON
stipulations made by the parties regarding Bgy. Kgd.
LLABAN, EMILY
Azarcon's testimony. As shown by the transcript of
LLABAN, ARMANDO C.
stenographic notes, appellants admitted that the
LLABAN, AUDIE D.
barangay kagawad was present during the inventory and
MACASARTE,
apart from stipulating on Azarcon's lack of personal
WILFREDO Q.
knowledge on the source of the specimen and the
LLABAN, EVANGELINE
circumstances surrounding the arrest of the appellants,
A. VARILLA, CORAZON
the latter did not stipulate nor make it of record that
TUMANG, AND when the barangay kagawad was there to witness the
PRESCILLA LANO,
inventory, appellants were not around at the time.
Respondents.; G.R.
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 12/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
Nos. 192676-77, April The OSG underscores the previous rulings of this Court
11, 2018 - COTABATO that non compliance by the apprehending/buy-bust team
ELECTRIC with Section 21 is not fatal for as long as there is
COOPERATIVE, INC. justifiable ground therefor, and as long as the integrity
(COTELCO), and the evidentiary value of the confiscated/seized
REPRESENTED BY items, are properly preserved. In particular, the absence
ALEJANDRO Q. of the representative from DOJ and media was already
COLLADOS AS explained by the arresting officers. Thus, if despite their
GENERAL MANAGER, efforts it was only Bgy. Kgd. Azarcon who arrived at the
Petitioner, v. scene to witness the photographing and inventory, this
MAGUINDANAO predicament is obviously beyond the control of the
ELECTRIC arresting team who had no choice but to proceed with
COOPERATIVE-PALMA the tasks at hand. What is essential was that the police
AREA (MAGELCO- officer had done all they could to safeguard the integrity
PALMA), and evidentiary value of the items involved.
REPRESENTED BY
On appellants' defense of denial, the OSG argues that
ATTY. LITTIE SARAH A.
such denial cannot overcome the positive assertions of
AGDEPPA, ANTONIO
the members of the buy-bust team. The well-entrenched
U. ACUB, EDGAR L. LA
principle is that, over and above the accused's denial,
VEGA, RET. JUDGE
greater weight is given to the positive testimonies of the
TERESITA CARREON
prosecution witnesses especially when these corroborate
LLABAN EVANGELINE
each other on material points, particularly the positive
A. VARILLA, AND
identification of the appellants as the ones who sold and
CORAZON TUMANG;
delivered the shabu to the poseur-buyer and that on the
AND MAGUINDANAO
occasion of their arrest, more plastic sachets of shabu
ELECTRIC
were recovered from one of them.11
COOPERATIVE, INC.,
REPRESENTED BY ITS
Issue
PRESIDENT, DATU
TUMAGANTANG Whether or not the CA erred in affirming appellants'
ZAINAL, Respondents. conviction for illegal sale and illegal possession of shabu.
INTERORIENT thing so] d and the payment for the thing. What is
MARITIME material in prosecutions for illegal sale of shabu is the
ENTERPRISE LIBERIA proof that the transaction or sale actually took place,
FOR DROMON E.N.E. coupled with the presentation in court of the corpus
AND JASMIN P. delicti as evidence.12
ARBOLEDA,
In this case, the prosecution narrated that PO2 Burgos,
Respondent.
the poseur buyer, accompanied by their informant, and
G.R. No. 208284, the rest of the buy-bust team, went to the area where
Malou and Betty (Beata) supposedly engaged in selling
April 23, 2018 - THE
shabu. It was Ramil who approached PO2 Burgos and
IGLESIA DE
offered him shabu, and when PO2 Burgos gave the
JESUCRISTO
payment (in marked money) for P500.00 worth of
JERUSALEM NUEVA OF
shabu, Ramil handed the money to Alvin. Malou then
MANILA, PHILIPPINES,
gave Ramil one plastic sachet containing suspected
INC., REPRESENTED
shabu, which Ramil handed to PO2 Burgos.
BY ITS PRESIDENT,
FRANCISCO GALVEZ,
With the sale consummated, PO2 Burgos threw his
Petitioner, v. LOIDA
cigarette as pre-arranged signal for the rest of the buy-
DELA CRUZ USING
bust team. He then introduced himself as a police officer
THE NAME CHURCH
and arrested appellants with the aid of his back-up, PO3
OF JESUS CHRIST,
Plopinio and PO3 Sarino. Four (4) more plastic sachets of
"NEW JERUSALEM"
shabu placed inside a plastic canister were recovered
AND ALL PERSONS
from Malou. Alvin tried to run towards their nearby
CLAIMING RIGHTS house but he was chased by PO3 Plopinio. On the same
UNDER HER,
day, the five plastic sachets containing white crystalline
Respondents.
substance seized from appellants were submitted for
chemical analysis to the PNP Crime Laboratory and the
G.R. No. 223321,
results confirmed the presence of methylamphetamine-
April 02, 2018 -
hydrochloride or shabu, a dangerous drug. The shabu
ROGELIO M. FLORETE,
contained in one plastic sachet weighing 0.01 gram,
SR., THE ESTATE OF
marked "RB" sold by appellants to PO2 Burgos was duly
THE LATE TERESITA F.
identified and presented as evidence in court. The other
MENCHAVEZ,
four (4) plastic sachets containing shabu, which were
REPRESENTED BY
seized from Malou on the same occasion marked as "RB-
MARY ANN THERESE F. 1", "RB-2", "RB-3"and "RB-4", were likewise presented
MENCHAVEZ, ROSIE
as evidence.
JILL F. MENCHAVEZ,
MA. ROSARIO F. For illegal possession of a dangerous drug, like shabu,
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 14/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-
b. "Chain of Custody" means the duly
Appellee, v. ROLAND
recorded authorized movements and custody
MIRAÑA Y ALCARAZ,
of seized drugs or controlled chemicals or
Accused-Appellant.
plant sources of dangerous drugs or
laboratory equipment of each stage, from the
G.R. No. 202217,
time of seizure/confiscation to receipt in the
April 25, 2018 -
forensic laboratory to safekeeping to
PABLO C. HIDALGO,
presentation in court for destruction. Such
Petitioner, v. SONIA
record of movements and custody of seized
VELASCO,
item shall include the identity and signature
Respondent.
of the person who held temporary custody of
the seized item, the date and time when such
G.R. No. 199161,
transfer of custody were made in the course
April 18, 2018 -
of safekeeping and used in court as evidence,
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL
and the final disposition[.]
BANK, Petitioner, v.
JAMES T. CUA, The apprehending team is required to "document the
Respondent. chain of custody each time a specimen is handled,
transferred or presented in court until its disposal, and
G.R. No. 197645, every individual in the chain of custody shall be identified
April 18, 2018 - following the laboratory control and chain of custody
CARLOS JAY form."20
ADLAWAN, Petitioner,
Section 21, paragraph 1 of R.A. No. 9165 provides for
v. PEOPLE OF THE
the custody and disposition of confiscated, seized,
PHILIPPINES,
and/or surrendered drugs and/or drug paraphernalia.
Respondent.
Said provision has been amended by R.A. No. 10640.21
G.R. No. 231053, Since the alleged offense was committed on January 26,
April 04, 2018 - 2011, the old law and its corresponding implementing
DESIDERIO DALISAY rules and regulations shall be applied, being more
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 16/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 17/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
HIS CAPACITY AS
The OSG suggests that the absence of the DOJ and
ASSISTANT
media representative may be overlooked, explaining that
OMBUDSMAN, PAMO
"this predicament is obviously beyond the control of the
I, AND CONCHITA
arresting team who had no choice but to proceed with
CARPIO MORALES IN
the tasks at hand."
HER CAPACITY AS
OMBUDSMAN OF THE The Court cannot agree to such proposition.
REPUBLIC OF THE
In the recent case of People v. Macud,27 we stressed the
PHILIPPINES, PETER
importance of this requirement, thus:
L. CALIMAG,
ASSISTANT We cannot even declare that there was
SECRETARY, REVENUE substantial compliance with the law in this
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 19/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
IN HIS CAPACITY AS
A: Yes, sir.
MUNICIPAL BLDG.
OFFICIAL OF MAKATI,
METRO MANILA, AND
Q: And in this case, Kgd. Noel Azarcon
HON. JOSE P. DE
was present?
JESUS, IN HIS
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 22/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
MARRIED TO
A: It was our team leader who
MAURICE GEORGE
coordinated with the barangay
FUERTE, Petitioner, v.
and only Kgd. Azarcon together
SPOUSES SILVINO
with the two barangay tanods
S.ESTOMO AND
arrived.
CONCEPCION C.
ESTOMO,
Respondents.
Q: You would admit that your team
leader contacted the barangay
G.R. No. 213617,
kagawad together with the barangay
April 18, 2018 -
tanods during the actual inventory?
ARCH. EUSEBIO B.
BERNAL, DOING A: Yes, sir.
BUSINESS UNDER
THE NAME AND STYLE
CONTEMPORARY
Q: But he did not contact
BUILDERS, Petitioner,
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 23/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
corpus delicti.34
G.R. No. 211232,
April 11, 2018 - The CA clearly disregarded the operative phrase—that
COCA-COLA the prosecution must provide "justifiable grounds" for
BOTTLERS PHILS., non-compliance, in addition to showing that the
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 25/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
Petitioners, v. PEOPLE
OF THE PHILIPPINES,
Respondent. A.1.10. Any justification or explanation in
cases of noncompliance with the
G.R. No. 206529, requirements of Section 21 (1) of
April 23, 2018 - RA No. 9165, as amended, shall
RENANTE B. be clearly stated in the sworn
REMOTICADO, statements/affidavits of the
Petitioner, v. TYPICAL apprehending/seizing
CONSTRUCTION officers, as well as the steps
TRADING CORP. AND taken to preserve the
ROMMEL M. ALIGNAY, integrity and evidentiary
Respondents. value of the
seized/confiscated items.
G.R. No. 229047, Certification or record of
April 16, 2018 - coordination for operating units
PEOPLE OF THE other than the PDEA pursuant to
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff- Section 86 (a) and (b), Article IX
Appellee, v. of the IRR of RA No. 9165 shall
RAMONCITO CORNEL be presented. (emphasis
supplied)
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 26/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
Y ASUNCION,
Accused-Appellants. The Implementing Rules and Regulations on the chain of
custody thus require that the apprehending officers not
G.R. No. 211187, simply mention a justifiable ground, but also clearly
April 16, 2018 - state this ground in their sworn affidavit, coupled with a
SERVICES, INC. AND integrity of the seized item.37 In this case, there was no
CROWN justifiable ground given by the arresting officers for the
SHIPMANAGEMENT, absence of DOJ and media representatives in their
INC., Petitioners, v. Pinagsamang Salaysay.38 PO2 Burgos' testimony in court
CELESTINO M. further highlighted the lack of justifiable ground for the
HERNANDEZ, JR., buy-bust team's failure to strictly comply with the
Respondent. requirements of Section 21.
OF THE PHILIPPINES,
For greater specificity, "marking" means the
Respondent.
placing by the apprehending officer or the
poseur-buyer of his/her initials and signature
G.R. No. 230249,
on the item/s seized. If the physical inventory
April 24, 2018 - ATTY.
and photograph are made at the nearest
PABLO B. FRANCISCO,
police station or office as allowed by the
Petitioner, v.
rules, the inventory and photography of the
COMMISSION ON
seized items must be made in accordance
ELECTIONS AND ATTY.
with Sec. 2 of Board Resolution No. 1, Series
JOHNIELLE KEITH P.
of 2002 but in every case, the apprehended
NIETO, Respondents.
violator or counsel must be present. Again,
this is in keeping with the desired level of
G.R. No. 196020,
integrity that the handling process requires.
April 18, 2018 -
Thereafter, the seized items shall be
MANILA ELECTRIC
placed in an envelope or an evidence bag
COMPANY, VICENTE
unless the type and quantity of the
MONTERO, MR.
seized items require a different type of
BONDOC, AND MR.
handling and/or container. The evidence
BAYONA, Petitioners,
bag or container shall accordingly be
v. NORDEC
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 27/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
IFURUNG, Petitioner, plastic sachets of the drug specimen were not sealed and
v. HON. CONCHITA C. placed inside the transparent plastic canister when it was
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 28/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
ENGUERRA RAMOS IN police station and until their submission to the crime
CALATES Y DELA
As a final word, the Court reiterates its ruling in People
CRUZ, Accused-
v. Holgado, et al.:49
Appellants.
CASTILLO, COURT OF Alvin L. Alvarez and Ramil M. Dal. They are accordingly
ACQUITTED of the crime(s) charged against them and
APPEALS, MANILA.
ordered immediately RELEASED from custody, unless
G.R. No. 210518, they are being held for some other lawful cause.
Respondents.
Velasco, Jr., (Chairperson), Bersamin, Leonen, and
Martires, JJ., concur.
G.R. No. 210580,
April 18, 2018 -
REPUBLIC OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Petitioner, v. LUDYSON May 23, 2018
C. CATUBAG,
Respondent.
NOTICE OF JUDGMENT
(FORMERLY MIRANT
SUAL CORPORATION),
Respondent.; G.R. No.
TO: Director General Ronald Dela Rosa
201133 (From CTA-EB
BUREAU OF CORRECTIONS
No. 649), April 18,
1770 Muntinlupa City
2018;
COMMISSIONER OF
INTERNAL REVENUE, GREETINGS:
Petitioner, v. TEAM
SUAL CORPORATION WHEREAS, the Supreme Court on April 23, 2018
Respondent.
"WHEREFORE, the appeal is GRANTED. The
Decision dated May 19, 2017 of the Court of
G.R. No. 197930,
Appeals in CA-G.R. CR No. 07568 is hereby
April 17, 2018 -
REVERSED and SET ASIDE for failure of the
EFRAIM C. GENUINO,
prosecution to prove beyond reasonable
ERWIN F. GENUINO
doubt the guilt of accused-appellants Malou F.
AND SHERYL G. SEE,
Alvarado, Alvin L. Alvarez and Ramil M. Dal.
Petitioners, v. HON.
They are accordingly ACQUITTED of the
LEILA M. DE LIMA, IN
crime(s) charged against them and ordered
HER CAPACITY AS
immediately RELEASED from custody, unless
SECRETARY OF
they are being held for some other lawful
JUSTICE, AND
cause.
RICARDO V. PARAS
III, IN HIS CAPACITY The Director of the Bureau of Corrections is
AS CHIEF STATE ORDERED to implement this decision and to
COUNSEL, CRISTINO inform this Court of the date of the actual
L. NAGUIAT, JR. AND release from confinement of the accused-
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 32/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
THE BUREAU OF
IMMIGRATION,
Very truly yours,
Respondents.; G.R.
No. 199046, April 17, (SGD.) WILFREDO V. LAPITAN
2018 - JOSE MIGUEL Division Clerk of Court
T. ARROYO, Petitioner,
v. HON. LEILA M. DE
LIMA, AS SECRETARY
Endnotes:
OF THE DEPARTMENT
OF JUSTICE AND
1Rollo, pp. 2-15; penned by Associate Justice
RICARDO V. PARAS
III, AS CHIEF STATE Leoncia Real-Dimagiba and concurred in by
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 34/40
11/18/2020 G.R. No. 234048, April 23, 2018 - PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. MALOU ALVARADO Y FLORES, ALVIN ALVA…
Accused-Appellant.
23People v. Saragena, supra note 15.
VALENZUELA CITY,
BRANCH 171,
Respondent.
NORTHERN CEMENT
CORPORATION,
Respondent.
PHILIPPINES, Plaintiff-
Appellee, v. BASHER
TOMAWIS Y ALI,
Accused-Appellant.
https://www.chanrobles.com/cralaw/2018aprildecisions.php?id=321 40/40