Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 3
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In this section, we summarize our key findings about the
impact of talent diversity on TV demand.
4 5
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
INTRODUCTION &
METHODOLOGY
In this section, we share our reasoning, definitions,
and procedures for conducting this study.
Show Trivia!
U.S. demand for Euphoria
is 27x greater than the
average U.S. title as of
October 2020, landing the
title in the 99.7th percen-
tile of all U.S. dramas.
6 7
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
Additionally, social movements are continuing to gain access to television content. Because of the rapid in-
INTRO TO DIVERSITY IN TV attention both within and outside the industry. Initiatives
like #OscarsSoWhite and organizations like Black Lives
crease in the number of shows available to audiences, it
is important for producers, studios and networks to iden-
Matter are calling for systemic change to advance racial tify the creative metrics that directly impact a show’s
and ethnic equity across business and society. They are success.
recognizing the essential role that entertainment, spe-
cifically television, plays in creating a more empathetic We understand that the intersection of various issues can
society. impact the success of a television series because:
In addition to measuring the racial and ethnic makeups of the series regular
casts, this study examines the relative success of these shows by utilizing
post-premiere U.S. domestic audience demand as the primary metric.
8 9
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
• TALENT
METHODOLOGY On-screen as well as voice actor series regular cast members as defined by
Variety Insight.
• NON-DIVERSE DEBUT
Key Definitions Other Pacific Islander, as well as Scripted Series U.S. first-run television scripted series premiere in which less than 40% of the
Hispanic and Latino individuals. series regular cast is nonwhite.
We acknowledge that the impact
Race and Ethnicity Therefore, “non-diverse” refers spe-
of talent diversity in live-action
cifically to white, non-Hispanic or
As dialogue around racial and eth- Latino individuals.
scripted series differ from animation • MODERATELY DIVERSE DEBUT
nic representation in entertainment and children’s programming. In
U.S. first-run television scripted series premiere in which at least 40% but less
and media continues to evolve, so In categorizing a television series live-action content it is difficult to
than 60% of the series regular cast is nonwhite.
does the terminology around de- debut as “diverse” or “non-diverse,” differentiate between the race and
scribing groupings and sub-group- we reference the current percentage ethnicity of a character and the ac-
ings of individuals in American so- of nonwhite individuals in the United tor playing that character. In ani- • HIGHLY DIVERSE DEBUT
ciety, including language such as States, which is approximately 40% mation and children’s series, these U.S. first-run television scripted series premiere in which at least 60% of the
“people of color” and “BIPOC” of the population. We recognize that do not always align. However, audi- series regular cast is nonwhite.
(Black, Indigenous and People of in characterizing a series as “diverse,” ences today can easily research who
Color). more than half of the series regular voices their favorite animated char-
cast may still be white. Recent re- acters and as a result, may feel a • DEMAND
For the purposes of this report, and ports project nonwhite individuals lack of authenticity when non-di- The cross-platform popularity of content measured by audiences across var-
in line with recent studies from rel- will become the majority in the U.S. verse actors voice diverse charac- ious digital forms of interaction including video consumption (streaming and
evant organizations, we have chosen population by 2045. Therefore we ters. In response, two high-profile downloads), social media engagement (hashtags, liking, sharing) and research
to use the term “diverse” to identify further segmented diverse debuts animated series recently recast ac- actions (reading about shows and writing about shows) via the global stan-
individuals from nonwhite racial and two subcategories: “moderately di- tors in series regular voiceover roles dardized metric of demand (see here for more information).
ethnic backgrounds. In accordance verse” and “highly diverse.” We de- to better align with the characters
they portray. While diversity among Average post-premiere U.S. audience demand was used as a standardized
with racial and ethnic categories on fined diverse debuts with at least a
voice actors may impact audiences popularity metric for the shows in this report.
the U.S. census, “diverse” includes 40% but less than 60% nonwhite cast
Black or African American, Native as “moderately diverse” and diverse indirectly, they are included in this
American and Alaska Native, Asian debuts with at least a 60% nonwhite study of scripted series. • DIVERSE TENTPOLES
American, Native Hawaiian and cast as “highly diverse.” Refers to the annual top 25 most in-demand U.S. first-run television scripted
series premieres, typically at least 8x more in-demand than the average title.
10 11
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
FINDINGS
In this section, we share the primary
insights from our study.
Show Trivia!
As of October 2020,
Grown-ish is 6x more
in-demand among U.S.
audiences than the av-
erage U.S. title. The show
is an even bigger hit
among South African
audiences, where it is 11x
more in-demand than
the average title.
12 13
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
SUPPLY In 2019, the number (supply) of diverse debuts has surpassed DEMAND Diverse debuts outperform non-diverse
non-diverse debuts. debuts as of 2019.
How has the Diversity Supply Gap Changed Between 2017 and 2019? How has the Diversity Demand Gap Changed Between 2017 and 2019?
Annual Count of All US Scripted Debuts Average Demand of Annual Top 100 In-Demand US Scripted Debuts
17x • S
ince 2017, demand for diverse
71 • Since
2017, the supply of-
debuts has more than doubled,
66 debuts with diverse talent
increasing 112.5%, and outpac-
has increased by 42%.
Demand (x times)
11x ber of (supply) diverse debuts.
• T
he supply of non-diverse
debuts has only increased
50 10x • T
he demand for non-diverse
16% between 2017 and
8x debuts has only increased 36%
2019.
since 2017.
How has the Diversity Demand Gap Changed Average Demand of Annual Top 100 In-Demand US Live-Action Debuts How has the Diversity Demand Gap Changed Average US Demand of Annual Top 25 In-Demand US Scripted Debuts
Among Live-Action Debuts? Between 2017 and 2019 Among Tentpoles?
When examining the demand of diverse debuts Our findings reveal that as of 2019, diverse
17x 41x
in the annual top 100 live-action debuts we find: tentpoles (hit debuts) are more popular than
Indexed Demand to Annual
15x
Demand (x times)
more in-demand than live-action diverse debuts. • In 2019, for the first time, diverse tentpoles 28x
10x 10x 10x 26x
were 46% more in-demand than non-di-
• S
ince 2017, demand for diverse live-action debuts verse tentpoles. 22x 21x
8x 19x
had grown 112.5%, while demand for non-diverse
live action debuts only grew 50% in the same • D
iverse tentpoles have almost doubled their
period. demand in three years, increasing 86%.
• In 2019, demand for diverse live-action debuts’ • The demand for non-diverse tentpoles’ has
surpassed that of non-diverse live-action debuts. 2017 2018 2019 only increased by 8%, since 2017. 2017 2018 2019
Non-Diverse Diverse Non-Diverse Diverse
14 15
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
TALENT DIVERSITY TRENDS TALENT DIVERSITY TRENDS
How Do the Ethnicities and Races of Series Regular Talent in Debuts Between 2017 and 2019 Compare to That of the
Talent diversity has increased since 2017, primarily growing U.S. Population?
on streaming platforms.
While diverse representation is on the rise, examining equity in representation requires evaluating the casting of various
ethnic and racial groups as compared to their proportion of the U.S. population.
How Has Talent Diversity Changed Between 2017 and 2019?
Racial and Ethnic Composition of US Population vs. US Debut Series Regular Talent in 2017-2019
How Has the Casting of Diverse Talent Shifted Between 2017 and 2019 by Distribution Type?
Black
Number of Diverse Talent Cast as Series Regular in a US Debut When evaluating the annual number of diverse
talent cast in U.S. scripted debuts by broadcast,
White
cable, and streaming platforms, we found:
US Census 2019 Talent
203
• S
treaming platforms (streamers) have shown
the greatest increase and the overall highest
number of diverse talent in 2019, nearly dou- • H
ispanics & Latinos are severely underrepresented. Compared to their proportion of the U.S. population, Hispanics
138
120
bling the number of diverse talent on cable and and Latinos have been represented by debuts series regular talent less than one-third as often.
114
133 broadcast series.
116
• A
merican Indian & Alaskan Natives are also severely underrepresented; they are 10 times more common in the U.S.
104
85 • I n 2017, broadcast had cast more diverse talent population than in the debuts series’ regular talent.
80
than streamers. Broadcast tied with streamers
in 2018, then fell behind by 2019. • N
ative Hawaiians & Pacific Islanders are underrepresented as well; they make up 0.2% of the U.S. population but only
only 0.08% of the debut series’ regular talent.
• I n 2017, cable rivaled broadcast, but in 2018
2017 2018 2019 and 2019, cable cast the lowest number of di- • T
he multiracial demographic is overrepresented. Multiracial talent has three times the representation among debuts’
Streamers Broadcast Cable verse talent. series regulars as this demographic’s proportion of the U.S. population.
16 17
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
HIGHLY DIVERSE DEBUTS HIGHLY DIVERSE DEBUTS
How Does the Supply of Highly Diverse Debuts Between 2017 and 2019 Compare Across Distribution Types?
Highly diverse debuts (60%+ cast diversity) are growing
Highly diverse debuts have increased their demand, but supply has not kept up with audiences desires. In this section,
more in-demand every year.
we examine the supply of highly diverse debuts across the three years for broadcast, cable, and streaming platforms.
How has the Demand for Highly Diverse Debuts Changed Between 2017 and 2019?
Diversity in Annual Top 100 US Debuts Between 2017-2019 by Distribution Type
Number of Titles
buts are more in-demand 10 4
than non-diverse debuts 3
12
2017 2018 2019 and perform as well as 7
moderately diverse debuts 3 7 6
17 4
Non-Diverse Moderately Diverse Highly Diverse (40-60% cast diversity).
3 4
15
13
How Has the Supply of Highly Diverse Debuts Changed Between 2017 and 2019?
20 17 16 21 21 28
Annual Top 100 US Scripted Debuts
13 9 9
When evaluating the supply of highly diverse
15 23 17 debuts in the top 100 U.S. scripted debuts across
broadcast, cable, and streaming platforms, we 2017 2018 2019 2017 2018 2019 2017 2018 2019
found:
31 30 30
Non-Diverse Moderately Diverse Highly Diverse
• T
he number of moderately diverse debuts has
remained consistent in the last three years.
• S
treamers’ increasing number of highly diverse debuts corresponds with a greater share of streaming titles in the top
54 47 53 • I n 2018, the number of highly diverse debuts 100 debuts. Streamers released 2.5x more highly diverse debuts in 2019 than 2017.
peaked. While there was a decline in 2019, the
number of highly diverse debuts still increased • B
roadcast, on the other hand, has dropped its share of debuts in the annual top 100 by 32%, while decreasing the
13% since 2017. share of highly diverse debuts by 62%.
2017 2018 2019
• I n 2018 and 2019, the overall number of cable debuts in the annual top 100 decreased by 20%, and the number of
Non-Diverse Moderately Diverse Highly Diverse
highly diverse debuts decreased by 33%.
18 19
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
PLATFORM SNAPSHOT
In this section, we provide a deep dive into diversity on
broadcast, cable, and streaming platforms.
Show Trivia!
Pose is categorically an
“outstanding” show. As
of October 2020, Pose’s
U.S. audience demand
is 10x greater than the
average U.S. title. The
show also travels well
to Brazilian audience,
with which it is 14x more
in-demand than the
average title.
20 21
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
BROADCAST Broadcast’s diverse debuts have steadily grown more in-demand BROADCAST
and more popular than its non-diverse debuts.
What are the 25 Most In-Demand Diverse Broadcast Debuts Between 2017 and 2019?
Broadcast’s Diversity Demand vs Supply Gap
How has Broadcast’s Diversity Demand Gap Changed Between 2017 and 2019?
Genre Breakdown of Top 25 In-Demand Diverse US Broadcast Scripted Debuts 2017-2019
Examining the 25 most in-demand debuts on broadcast yearly, we found: Genre
Batwoman Action and Adventure
Manifest Drama
tently outperformed
11x
Demand (x times)
Emergence Drama
• I n 2019, diverse debuts are
20% more in-demand than Whiskey Cavalier Drama
2017 2018 2019 non-debuts. Marvel’s Inhumans Action and Adventure
Non-Diverse Diverse New Amsterdam Drama
FBI Drama
Annual Percentage of Diverse Talent in US Broadcast’s Scripted Debuts Series Regulars God Friended Me Drama
Charmed Drama
• T
he share of broad- All American Drama
cast debuts’ diverse
Bluff City Law Drama
series regular talent
56% 50% 55% 24: Legacy Action and Adventure
has steadily remained
above 40%, the high- Magnum, P.I. Drama
est of any platform The Neighborhood Comedy
type.
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
• D
iversity in broadcast
44% 50% 45% Indexed to Annual Average US Demand (x times)
debuts’ series regular
talent peaked in 2018 Drama Comedy Action and Adventure
at 50%, decreasing to
45% in 2019. • 7 2% of the 25 most in-demand diverse broadcast debuts were dramas.
2017 2018 2019
Non-Diverse Diverse • 20% of the 25 most in-demand diverse broadcast debuts were action and adventure series.
22 23
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
CABLE Cable’s debuts talent diversity has stagnated. In 2019, cable’s CABLE
diverse debuts still perform as well as its non-diverse debuts.
What are the 25 Most In-Demand Diverse Cable Debuts Between 2017 and 2019?
Cable’s Diversity Demand vs Supply Gap
How has Cable’s Diversity Demand Gap Changed Between 2017 and 2019? Genre Breakdown of Top 25 In-Demand Diverse US Cable Scripted Debuts 2017-2019
Genre
Examining the 25 most in-demand debuts on cable yearly, we found:
Euphoria Drama
Six Drama
Non- Diverse Diverse
SMILF Drama
Feud Drama
How has Talent Diversity in Cable’s Debut Series Regulars Changed Between 2017 and 2019? The Last O.G. Comedy
• W
hile demand for diverse Here And Now Drama
debuts has doubled, ca- Famous In Love Drama
63% 64% 64%
ble’s talent diversity in its
Dietland Action and Adventure
debuts’ series regular cast
Miracle Workers Comedy
has stagnated.
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
• In 2019, cable has the
Indexed to Annual Average US Demand (x times)
smallest percentage of
talent diversity among its 37% 36% 36%
Drama Comedy Action and Adventure
debuts’ series regular cast
of any platform type.
2017 2018 2019 • 72% of the most in-demand diverse cable debuts were dramas.
Non- Diverse Diverse • 16% of the 25 most in-demand diverse cable debuts were comedies.
24 25
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
Streamers have made consistent progress in talent
STREAMING PLATFORMS diversity. In 2019, their diverse debuts outperform STREAMING PLATFORMS
their non-diverse debuts.
What are Streamers’ 25 Most In-Demand Diverse Debuts Between 2017 and 2019?
Streamers’ Diversity Demand vs Supply Gap
Genre Breakdown of Top 25 In-Demand Diverse US Streamers’ Scripted Debuts 2017-2019
How has Streamers’ Diversity Demand Gap Changed Between 2017 and 2019?
Genre
Examining the 25 most in-demand debuts on streamers yearly, we found: The Witcher Action and Adventure
Annual Percentage of Diverse Talent in US Streamer’s Scripted Debuts Series Regular Wu Assassins Drama
Non-Diverse Diverse • 33% of the most in-demand diverse streamers’ debuts were dramas, diverging from broadcast’s and cable’s debut trends.
26 27
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
“We know that our success is dependent on nurturing and maintaining a prin-
ciple of inclusion. This led to defining one of Quibi’s core values as ‘Be The
Audience’ -- which inherently puts diversity and inclusion as a central tenet
in all of our operations -- from the team members we hire to the creators we
work with and the stories they tell.”
INDUSTRY VOICES
“As a multi-media company dedicated to the power of art, we strive to raise
Executives from the industry reflect on the report’s findings awareness and celebrate all forms of arts and culture. To be a true reflection
of our community, all voices should have a platform regardless of race, gen-
and the future of diversity in TV. der, sexual orientation or religion. This study underscores the value proposition
of diverse programming, and highlights the fact it’s also a good business
strategy.”
“At Gaumont, inclusion and diversity is at the core of our culture and we strive
to reflect this within our internal organization, in the stories we choose to tell
and the talent we work with to bring those stories to life. Through our highly
acclaimed films and with 18 series across 8 languages, we have made great “It’s incredibly important for us as a company to use data to help inform clients’
strides toward contributing to an industry standard which offers representation decisions across film, TV, music, sports, and more. We have had a longtime
for all. Through our partnership with Parrot Analytics, we have the ability to focus on diversity backed with real data, which is why we are excited that this
access real time data and insights across global audiences allowing us to re- first-of-its-kind study led by CAA and Parrot Analytics will help guide the agen-
main agile in our continued efforts to serve the needs of our global partners cy and industry as a whole as we continue to push for greater diversity onscreen.”
and their audiences.”
- André Vargas, Head of Data, CAA
- Christophe Riandee, Vice-CEO, Gaumont
“Growing up, I was drawn to content that reflected the faces of my family and
“Richard Pryor, Eddie Murphy, and Will Smith were topping the charts decades
community, whenever it was available. For so long audiences have craved true
before a Black actor was entrusted a starring role in a blockbuster-budgeted
representation on their television screens. More recently, the opportunity has
film. The demand for more diversity is not just large, it has existed for decades
emerged to showcase what so many have known to be true, with data. Unsur-
and will continue to grow for decades more. The ability to better assess this
prisingly, the numbers prove that investing in authentically diverse content isn’t
demand is good for audiences, for talent, for Hollywood, Bollywood, Nollywood
just the right thing to do, but actually a solid business investment.”
and more.”
- Matthew Ball, Managing Partner, Epyllion Industries - Karina Dixon, Global Insights Director, Parrot Analytics
28 29
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020
Nicole
Zamanzadeh,
RECOMMENDATIONS
PhD
4. Integrate culturally specific themes or storylines
throughout the show. Insights Analyst
Parrot Analytics
Explore opportunities to build in themes or sto-
rylines that authentically reflect the character’s
experience. Even subtle cultural representations
can have a tremendous impact on viewers and
deepen their engagement with the show. Be cau-
POSTFACE
Based on our findings, we propose the following tious of playing into negative or harmful stereo- Our study demonstrates that audiences’
types with new storylines that may arise as a result demand for shows with diverse casts has
guidelines for cultivating diversity:
of your casting choices. grown faster than the industry’s supply of
shows with diverse casts. Our study reflects
the industry’s progress thus far, and grow-
ing opportunity in the future.
1. Evaluate casting breakdowns and avoid language that encourages implicit bias.
When specifying a role as diverse, be sure to check for language that could feed into Yet, diversity extends far beyond the quan-
harmful stereotypes. Consider removing negative identity markers and avoid using
prototypes that might affect how people imagine the character on the page. Focus
on highlighting traits and qualities that support the narrative and character devel-
5. Proactively source, acquire and greenlight ma-
terial where diverse talent can be central to the
tity of diverse actors or of diverse people.
Diverse representation includes the type
and variety of roles that marginalized peo-
narrative.
opment in an authentic way. ple play in the creative process of TV.
Exercise your influence to identify material that
elevates underrepresented communities and voic-
Talent diversity is foundational, yet it is far
es. Be careful to maintain the cultural integrity of
from an all-encompassing measure of in-
these projects and to bring in the right creatives
clusive storytelling in TV. I hypothesize the
and consultants that can ensure that you represent
impact of diverse representation evidenced
specific communities and cultures with care.
2. Set casting goals that reflect the world we live in.
According to recent data for the U.S. Census Bureau, 40% of the population identifies
here becomes magnified by the participa-
tion of diverse voices in content creation.
as racially or ethnically diverse. Set strategic casting targets that are reflective of
When diverse voices make meaningful con-
the audiences watching and think about how casting decisions can be complimentary
tributions to the creative process of con-
to the show.
tent, they expand the reach, power, and
It’s important that executives look beyond hard viewership data. Analyzing audienc-
ions are being used to direct decisions on the fu-
ture of a show or on specific creative choices.
fabric that builds and sustains our industry.
Storytelling is and has been cherished by
es demand more holistically, including social conversations, can be critical to illus- Whenever possible, bring in appropriate “comps” people across time, culture, and geography
trating a show’s value and should be considered in decisions around future seasons that strengthen the case for racial and ethnic di- for much needed relief from and informa-
or other projects that are being developed. versity in your project. tion about our world. As we evidence the
value of representing the diversity in our
experiences, we see the new possibilities
ahead for TV creatives and audiences alike.
30 31
Diversity in T V MIPCOM 2020