You are on page 1of 7

Advances in KrampeHarex loose fibres, perfectly

straight aligned in a 20 kg box.

segmental
concrete lining
To meet the taxing needs of TBM-bored
tunnels, the segmental concrete lining
value chain has over the years continued
to advance its offerings. TJ looks at some
of the advances across three of the main
components that make up this discipline is one of the most promising application for this
material, with a large number of tunnels constructed
– fibre suppliers, concrete segment today using fibre reinforced concrete (FRC)
segments.
manufacturers and segment gaskets. In the paper, Twenty years of FRC tunnel final
lining: Lessons learnt, design proposal and new
By Munesu Shoko. development, De Rivaz notes that steel fibres have
been used to reinforce concrete since the early
The success of a tunnelling project relies on many 1970s. Employed initially for applications such
factors, one of the most important being the use as industrial flooring, the 1980s saw the start of
of a suitable segmental concrete lining. Given that deployment in underground applications, firstly in
tunnel construction projects are intricate by their very shotcrete and then in both precast tunnel lining
nature, with variations in soil conditions, different segments and cast in place final lining.
rock types and high water pressure, among others, However, a lack of regulation and standards
placing high demands on the materials and machines hampered the spread of FRC for final tunnel linings.
used, companies in the segmental concrete lining With the publication of international design guideline,
discipline – fibre suppliers, concrete segment the Fib Model Code for Concrete Structures 2010 (Ref
Projects using manufacturers and segment gasket suppliers – are 1), this obstacle has been overcome and designers are
FRC segments continuously advancing the development of their gaining confidence in working with fibres.
report excellent products accordingly. The use of FCR in precast tunnel segments, he
durability, The use of fibres has over the years been proved says, offers several advantages, and among them are:
while handling,
installing damage
to improve the structural performance of concrete cracking control during construction phases; higher
and repairs are segmental linings in tunnels. Benoit De Rivaz of impact resistance; durability advantages at final
minimised. Bekaert, says the use of fibre in reinforced concrete stage; reduction of costs; sustainability advantages;
and boosting of the production process. “However,
the advantages related to the adoption of FRC
use should be evaluated according to the project
characteristics,” says De Rivaz.
Wilhelm Nell, product & business development
manager at KrampeHarex, says, “We already have
many references worldwide, proving that FRC is
of great interest, working well and offering many
advantages.”
Nell believes that apart from the prominent
steel fibre reinforced concrete, the polypropylene
microfibers have also become important and today
are a proven and accepted material for passive
fire protection in tunnels. “With steel fibres we can
substitute the total amount of reinforcing steel bars
and with polypropylene microfibers we can add a
passive fire protection, fulfilling the requirements of
fire tests and different standards,” he says.

36 Tunnelling Journal
ADVANCES IN SEGMENTAL CONCRETE LINING

Explaining the significance of gaskets in the


segmental concrete lining value chain, Gilles
Mauchamp, product manager Tunnelling at Dätwyler
Sealing Technologies, says TBM-bored tunnel linings
comprise rings made of several segments, and
segmental linings thus have numerus longitudinal
and radial joints to be sealed against ground water
pressure with elastomer gaskets installed around the
prefabricated segment. During the ring assembly,
segments are pressed against each other and
opposite gaskets are compressed, sealing the joint.
“Tunnel gaskets are designed to perform water
tightness for a different combination of limited
segment misalignment (gap and offset) after the
ring is built. Performance and reliability of a tunnel
gasket depends on its dimension adjusted to the
groove geometry, its design shape and cross section,
together with material properties to be used,”
explains Mauchamp.
Craig Burkitt, marketing manager at VIP-
Polymers Ltd, agrees, saying that a tunnel segment
gasket’s main function is to provide a watertight
seal between each concrete segment to prevent
the ingress of groundwater or the egress of any
medium transported in the tunnel. Typically, they in segment production and to secure highest overall Beam test in
KrampeHarex’s
are manufactured from a synthetic polymer (EPDM) quality and performance,” he says.
lab.
rubber compound that is selected due to its sealing In comparison to conventional reinforcement, Nell
performance and resistance to general chemicals, says the advantages are diverse. For example, tough
temperatures and microbial attacks. and durable surfaces, reduction in maintenance and
repair cost, overall cost savings, resistance to impact,
Advances in fibres higher durability and sustainability, among others.
As far as new developments in fibres are concerned, “With these new developments, an array of
Nell says one important advancement over time is advantages can be realised. There is a trend to
the adapted tensile strength of the steel fibres for the higher concrete compressive strength in segments.
higher compressive strength of precast segments. Often we see that a planned C50/60 reaches
“The pull out behaviour of fibres in the concrete >80MPa after 28 days, sometimes we have had
matrix mainly depends on the bondage and also around 100MPa. So fibres should fit well to
anchorage. With higher concrete compressive higher compressive strength and developments
strengths, a higher tensile strength of the steel fibres in fibres will give higher tensile strength but also
will give much better performance of the steel FRC. higher elongation. Also further optimisation on
To pull out a fibre during crack opening, you simply anchorage (angle, geometry, details) can lead to
need more energy for the plastic deformation of better performance,” he says, adding that in general,
the steel. Together with the higher tensile strength the key advantage is a safer, more durable and more
there is usually also a higher elongation. This is still an economical solution.
ongoing process and all interrelations haven’t been The same view is shared by De Rivaz, who says
researched in detail yet,” says Nell. the main evolution in the fibre space is related
At the moment, KrampeHarex is undertaking wide- to the concrete mix design and fast demoulding
scale research with many different fibre types, various requirement. Bekaert currently provides fibre for the
steel qualities in different concrete compressive tunnel-bored segmental concrete linings with special
strengths and concrete mix designs to understand properties such as high l/D ratio of 80; low diameter
better the details and the interaction between steel of 0.75mm to provide network effect more than
fibres and concrete, as well as optimising existing 10,000 lm/m³ with 40kg; tensile strength greater
fibre types and to better adapt different fibres to the than 1,800Mpa and up to 2,200Mpa to avoid any
requirements of a certain project. The company has risk of snapping in high-strength concrete; optimal
about 40 years’ experience and Nell is confident that hook end to ensure better anchorage; and glued
there is still room to do more in this field. fibre to facilitate fibre introduction and guarantee
Another important factor, says Nell, is the overall homogeneity in the mix.
quality in the whole fibre production process. “We “Minimum Network is key for cracking control
see a lot of differences in fibre types if we compare but also to guarantee low dispersion in the result.
different products. For us, the optimisation of fibre Characteristic values are required for the structural
production in every single step is a matter of course, design to validate performance based on EN 14651
all the way from the quality of the raw material we testing method,” says De Rivaz.
are purchasing from European sources and the De Rivaz says tunnels could have different
machinery (accuracy, speed and cutting), through to geotechnical conditions along their development.
the packaging (smart boxes, safety big bags). Every Even if FRC is the only solution proposed, in some
single step is important to finally achieve best results parts of the tunnel the use of a hybrid solution can

Tunnelling Journal 37
The Combisegments® technology combines
high-precision precast segments with a smooth
but protective liner frame resistant to chemicals
for sewage, water and cable ducts. In one working
step, precisely overmoulded sealing frames achieve
immediate water tightness and concrete protection
subsequent to the ring building. A costly and time-
consuming second lining is thus no longer necessary
to protect the tunnel lining, for example, against
aggressive or abrasive substances.
These new developments, says Medel, are
contributing to the successful execution of
individual projects. For example, Herrenknecht
Formwork’s elaborate concrete distribution system
for a stationary production with different concrete
hoppers running on cranes could be assembled quite
quickly at the Albvorlandtunnel project in Germany
and offered an automated and reliable concrete
supply.
At the same project (Albvorlandtunnel), the
concrete curing system for a stationary production
with individually controlled heating for every mould,
combined with an overall heating for the complete
building, offered constantly perfect curing results
Herrenknecht be convenient, for example, cross passage and even in case of considerable fluctuations of the
Formwork’s shallow tunnels, to increase the FRC performance. outside temperature.
automated
concrete
“In general, it is convenient to define an FRC that can Elsewhere, the automated finishing line, which has
supply system cover the great part of the tunnel and adopt a hybrid been adapted to the customer’s building housing
in the segment solution in the remaining part,” he says. the segment production plant for the Fildertunnel,
factory for the The main advantage, says De Rivaz, is certainly Germany, increases safety in handling of the heavy
Albvorlandtunnel
durability and sustainability. After 25 years of positive concrete segments by reducing human involvement
project.
return of experience, the recent publication of key during the individual working steps such as
standard endorsed by Fib, ACI, ITA focus on precast demoulding, turning, piling, tilting and separating of
segment and based on MC2010 provides all detail the segments as well as gasket gluing.
design recommendations. “The concrete protection system,
Combisegments®, offers concrete protection for
Developments in lining segment production over 100 years. Another advantage, among others,
The manufacture of concrete lining segments is an increased production speed as the protective
for TBM driven tunnels, says Stefan Medel, MD of lining is installed with the concrete segments in
Herrenknecht Formwork, has achieved very high one step. No joints need to be welded,” explains
standards of quality and quantity in recent decades. Medel.
The most important developments, he says, is the
focus on improving quality of the segments on the Developments in gaskets
one hand, and on optimising segment production For decades, says Mauchamp, tunnel gaskets were
systems, on the other hand. glued in a dedicated groove on the segment. A major
“This means providing maximum safety and development in tunnelling gaskets, he says, was the
increasing production speed at the same time. anchored (or cast-in) gasket developed by Dätwyler
However, considering the individual conditions of and used for the first time in 2010 for the massive
every project, flexible and customised solutions have production of the segments for the Lee Tunnel
top priority,” says Medel. project in the UK. Main advantages are the better
Medel says the following developments are bonding to the segment, cost saving, health and
examples that have led to the improvements safety at work and environmentally friendliness due
mentioned above: to non-use of solvent glue.
n Design and layout of turnkey segment production Another recent development from Dätwyler is the
plants including moulds, carousel systems or adjusted or Performances Corner, which was first
concrete supply systems and automated finishing used in 2015. Mauchamp says customer requirements
lines for stationary production, segment handling for the corner design in machine-operated tunnel
equipment, concrete and reinforcement supply construction have increased significantly in recent
systems, concrete curing concepts as well as years, both in terms of material and components,
adequate software tools for monitoring and as well as the degree of individualisation and costs
steering of the production process. involved.
n Concrete protection: development of corrosion- The special properties of the Performance Corner
resistant and hydraulically optimised segments for are designed to ensure that the tunnel is leak-tight
utility tunnels, for example, wastewater tunnels. throughout the various geologies and to withstand
Herrenknecht Formwork’s Combisegments® the water pressure. “It is critical here that the right
technology is a true case in point in this regard. adjustment is made for the corner geometry from

38 Tunnelling Journal
48
Proven performance
in precast segmental
Synthetic Fibre Reinforcement for linings.

Precast Segmental Tunnel Linings


Once considered impossible, BarChip and our clients are proving
that macro synthetic fibre is a viable solution for precast segmental
tunnel linings. BarChip fibre reinforcement is: Santoña Laredo Water Tunnel, Spain

• The first synthetic fibre and steel hybrid reinforcement


solution for a segmental lining.

• The first 100% synthetic fibre reinforced segmental lining.

• The first synthetic fibre reinforced segmental lining in Europe.

• The first synthetic fibre reinforced segmental lining in North


America.

• The first synthetic fibre reinforced segmental lining in Japan.

• The first synthetic fibre reinforced segmental lining in a rail


Blacksnake Creek CSO Tunnel, USA
tunnel.

BarChip is the trusted fibre solution and the only choice for major
infrastructure projects.

Harefield to Southall Gas Pipeline, UK Malaga Airport Rail Tunnel, Spain


www.barchip.com

TUNNEL SEGMENT
GASKETS

YOUR TUNNEL SEALING PARTNER 100 % TIGHT


Our job doesn’t stop at supplying tunnel segment gaskets.
We are with you through every step of the project from
gasket design concept, to product training, to installation.
HAS TO BE …
No project is the same so whether we supply an off the shelf
ANY THING ELSE
gasket or engineer a bespoke design, VIP aren’t just a gasket
manufacturer, we’re your tunnel sealing partner. IS TOO RISKY

Glued-In Cast-In Hydrophilic Bespoke

Expert Technical Product Manufacturing


advice innovation training quality

' +44 (0)1480 4411333 * sales@vip-polymers.com 8 www.vip-polymers.com

40 Tunnelling Journal
ADVANCES IN SEGMENTAL CONCRETE LINING

which the relevant segment design is derived,” form. There the mixture is cured under high pressure
explains Mauchamp. and at a high temperature.
This guarantees the perfect fit of the gasket Thus the individual extruded profiles are connected
into the segment. The custom fit results from the to a completed, closed gasket frame. These
combination of the right cutting angle to the end individually adjusted corners provide the necessary
of the section and the right adjustments to the seal in the tunnel later on. In addition, only as much
opening and torsion angles, which are taken from material is used as is actually needed for the relevant
the ring design for the segments. The adjusted angle corner.
of torsion prevents the corner from tilting and the Dätwyler’s last major development in this field is
formation of an additional offset to the adjacent the Fibre Anchored gasket. Reinforcing its leading
gaskets which could result in possible leaks. position in innovation, Datwyler has in recent years
The Performance Corner comprises EPDM, enhanced glued and feet-anchored gaskets. In
which is also the basic material of the extruded contrast to the previous method of linear anchoring
profile section. EPDM has demonstrated excellent with feet, it is now possible to anchor surfaces
characteristics: it allows for a good connection to completely with fibres. The new fibre-anchored
the profile, which guarantees the necessary tear gaskets were first used for the South Hartford Water
resistance for the frame corner during the assembly Project in the US and are currently used for the REM
of the gasket frames and the installation of the Montreal LRT Airport Tunnel.
segments. Some of the key advantages include safe and easy
With regards to the long-term relaxation, EPDM installation; no air pockets in the concrete’s structure
ensures a structure is leak-tight throughout its underneath the gasket; better concrete compaction
entire service life and has very good ozone, aging in the anchoring area; avoiding shifting during ring
and weather resistance. For special requirements, installation; improved built-in corner configuration;
for example, soil contaminated with hydrocarbons, improved spalling behaviour; better resilience due
the gaskets Performance Corner can also be to a completely anchored surface; easier repair;
made of chloroprene rubber (CR). Materials with shortened process in the tubbing factory through the
an antibacterial effect can also be used in the reduction of the necessary groove preparation and
construction of tunnels for drinking water and waste aftercare; and removal of the assembly adhesive and
water drainage. the entire gluing procedure.
The injection molding process is used for
manufacturing the Performance Corner, which Major shift
generates significantly higher connection forces to According to Burkitt, rubber gaskets were traditionally
be generated in the corner area. These connection glued into the concrete segments after they were
forces within the sealing corner are absolutely manufactured. It is becoming more common
necessary so that the high compression force for gaskets to be cast into the segments during
between the concrete segments that occurs while manufacture by clipping them into the mould before
erecting them in does not result in tearing or moving pouring in concrete. This, he says, allows for a more
the corner during installation. secure fit (as the ‘legs’ in the profiles anchor it into
Mauchamp explains that during the corner molding the concrete), consistent gasket positioning and
process, the rubber mixture is first warmed on an brings with it manufacturing efficiencies.
injection molding machine in an extruder unit to 80- “The profile shape of a Cast-In gasket differs to
100°C and plasticised, and injected into the heated that of a Glued-In gasket, with the most obvious
difference being the flat bottom side of the gasket (as
Dätwyler’s
opposed to arches seen on Glued-In profiles) which adjusted or
is common across gasket manufacturers. This is done Performances
in order to ensure that concrete does not ingress into Corner was first
the gasket profile during pouring,” explains Burkitt. used in 2015.

This different profile, however, brings its own


challenges during manufacture. Tunnel segment
gaskets are manufactured to fit a concrete
segment’s profile by joining lengths of rubber profile
together to match the geometric shape of the
segment. Traditionally Glued-In gasket corners are
manufactured using a shot joining process.
This joins lengths of the extruded profile to create
angled corners. With Glued-In gaskets there are
no issues with this method, however, with Cast-In
gaskets this results in rubber filling the gasket voids at
these corners due to the flat bottom of the profile.
“When you have a solid corner profile, the stresses
created during the closing (compression) action
are greatly increased. Rubber is incompressible,
therefore, in a confined or determined space such
as in the segment groove, prevents the gasket
‘spreading’ under load,” explains Burkitt. “If the
volume of rubber in the gasket exceeds this space

Tunnelling Journal 41
With 150 reference projects worldwide, Bekaert has
seen great successes at all of the projects realised in
Middle East since 2010 around durability requirement.
“In the past 10 years, there has been a number of
major deep gravity sewerage and drainage tunnels
constructed. The projects provide a sustainable
solution to increase the capacity of large sewer/
drainage systems and include the DTSS in Singapore,
the STEP in Abu Dhabi, the IDRIS in Doha, the
Thames Tideway in UK and the Dubai Storm water
project. They are large tunnels, mostly in excess of
5m in diameter, constructed with a segmental lining
and in most cases a secondary in-situ lining,” explains
De Rivaz.
These tunnels, he adds, need to have a long
service life, thus the durability design of the concrete
segmental or in-situ lining to resist the deterioration
mechanisms associated with the ground conditions
and sewerage is of primary importance. “It can be
concluded that SFRC presents an overall improved
durability to corrosion compared with conventional
reinforcement,” says De Rivaz.
For Herrenknecht Formwork, a recent flagship
project, which includes three individual projects, is
Combisegments® then the closure force is greatly increased. If you the Neubaustrecke Stuttgart- Ulm (Stuttgart-Ulm
for the project cannot close the segment and you are still applying Rail Project) in the south of Germany. It includes
West Trunk Sewer
P2 Mississauga
closure pressure, the load will then follow the three tunnel projects with segmental lining, the
– Canada. The weakest path which can result in crack through the Albvorlandtunnel, the Boßlertunnel and Fildertunnel.
protective liner segments and localised spalling art corners.” Here, Herrenknecht Formwork developed different
and the gasket In 2015, VIP developed a patented manufacturing customised segment production plants according to
frame are directly
process which eliminates the formation of solid the project requirements.
integrated into the
segment during corners and ensures the force needed to collapse After its completion, with a length of 8,176m, the
concreting. the gasket corners into the groove is equal to that Albvorlandtunnel, near Kirchheim unter Teck, will be
needed along the length of the profile. one of the 10 longest railway tunnels in Germany.
It is a section of the new line between Stuttgart and
Case studies Ulm, expanding a trans-European east-west main
One flagship project where KrampeHarex has line for high-speed traffic. The tunnel consists of two
deployed its new fibre innovations is the Stormwater single-track tunnel tubes, which are being lined with
Tunnel in Dubai, UAE. “We have just finished the a total of around 60,000 segments (outer diameter
delivery of around 5,000 t of our DE 60/0.9 H in 10.5m, width 2m). Mechanised tunnelling has been
February 2020. This fibre with 60mm length, 0.9mm underway since November 2017 and completed
diameter and a tensile strength of >1900MPa in in October 2019 with two EPB Shields from
average fits very well to the requirements of this Herrenknecht AG.
demanding mega project,” explains Nell. A project of note where the Combisegments®
Here KrampeHarex has shown the overall system has proved its worth is the Mississauga
performance of the fibre with continuously good in Canada. Here, Herrenknecht Formwork’s
results on concrete performance tests from the Combisegments® Type II with a 5mm thick HDPE
beginning to the end of the project. After first trials Sure Grip Liner were successfully installed over a
and understanding the details of the concrete length of 110m in the inlet and outlet area of a shaft
mix design, performance requirements and high structure.
requirements on durability of 120y, the company’s As a result the increased corrosion loads can be
choice of fibre was done. permanently withstood while reducing maintenance
“We demonstrated that we can offer the highest costs. This section was realised as part of the 3.8km
workability, performance and efficiency, taking long sewer tunnel “Mississauga West Trunk Sewer
into consideration the layout of production plant, Phase 2” (ID 3m), Mississauga. As with standard
concrete additives, consistency, deadlines, up to segments, handling and installation in the tunnel are
packaging with our safety big bag,” says Nell. carried out by means of a vacuum or mechanical
“The fibre itself has very good workability with erector. The segment gasket designed specifically
best performance. The anchorage, the hook of for the project is positively integrated into the
KrampeHarex DE fibres is slightly more marked Combisegments® protective lining, which has saved
compared to other products on the market. We are working steps in segment production.
using a certain steel quality for the production to As far as the application of gaskets is concerned,
secure highest quality, the high tensile strength and VIP’s Cast-In profile is currently being used on
production speed. All together the development over London’s Thames Tideway project along different
years is leading into a high-end product which offers sections, including the main tunnel and supporting
best results for a specific demand/project,” he adds. tunnels which feed into it.

42 Tunnelling Journal
For the Thames Tideway East (Main) and
Greenwich Connection Tunnel, VIP supplied its
35mm and 28mm Cast-In profiles. The company
also provided its 28mm profile for the Frogmore
connection tunnel and the Beckton Siphon which
was manufactured from NBR due to the chemical
resistance required.
Located in Somerset, UK and owned by EDF
Energy, Hinckley Point C is the first new nuclear
power station to be built in the UK in over 20 years.
Here, VIP’s Cast-In profile is being used in both the
Intake and Outfall tunnels.
“Nuclear power stations require large volumes
of water for cooling and both tunnels make up the
cooling system that will be an integral part of the
nuclear power station, transporting sea water from
Bridgwater Bay to and from the power station. Here
we supplied our 35mm Cast-in profile for both
tunnels,” explains Burkitt.
Dätwyler’s Performance Corner gaskets are
currently being used on a number of worldwide
projects, including the St. Petersburg Collector, a
5km tunnel with 3.5m ID - 26mm anchored gasket;
Buenos Aires’ Rio Subterraneo a Loma, a 13.5km
tunnel with 3.9m ID - 26mm anchored gasket company’s recent and future business. “We are A VIP Polymer
designed for the specific project; and the Melbourne increasing the re-use of refurbished components by gasket which
is cast into
Metro, a 16km tunnel with 6.3m ID - 26mm anchored offering the same high-quality standards compared a complete
gasket. to new equipment,” he says. segment.
Other projects where the Performance Corner Moving to segment gaskets, Burkitt says VIP is
gaskets are in use include the Grand Paris Express working on some new profiles based on feedback
Metro Line – 14, 15, 16 and 17 of the Paris Metro from precasters who have used the company’s and
network with more than 80km tunnel currently other gasket manufacturer’s profiles. “It is important
running with 8.7m ID - 33mm anchored gasket; the to listen to the voice of the customer to provide
Virginia (US) CBBT Thimble Shoals, a 2km tunnel with solutions that are of benefit to the design and
11.9m ID - 44mm glued gasket; as well as the New construction of tunnels and their components,” he
York Rondout Water bypass (US), a 4km tunnel with says.
5.54m ID - 44mm special new design (40 bar) glued Elsewhere, Mauchamp says improvements in
gasket. concrete mix as well as segment reinforcement
means that segments are becoming thinner. In fact,
To the future the current trend in tunnelling is a move towards
Looking to the future, as far as developments in thinner segments to reduce the total costs and to
this discipline are concerned, De Rivaz believes that increase the TBM speed.
developments in FRC for underground application “Consequently, gaskets are moving towards
will continue apace. “We can see a momentum the extrados side, having influence on the risks or
around Permanent Spray Concrete and high spalling and cracks. In the meantime, tightness
performance steel fibre as 4D 65/35BG will be one of performances required remain the same or higher.
the key drivers of this development,” he says. The next generation of gaskets should consider
According to Medel, besides the range of such factors for durable sealing of tunnels with
automation systems and tools mentioned earlier smaller width of profile, thinner internal shape
for optimising the whole production process and geometry, higher performance of the rubber used
at the same time tailored to the requirements of and new or different bonding on segments method,”
each project, Herrenknecht Formwork’s current says Mauchamp.
developments focus on further, more general More and more studies, says Mauchamp, are
automation. considering segment lining for very deep or high
“We recently developed a robot supported cover tunnel projects. “That will be, for sure, another
moulding system together with Swiss construction challenging development for gaskets as well as
company, Marti. The system includes a robot hanging testing methods due to very high water-tightness
on a crane bridge which is able to do relevant requirements and higher ground temperatures
working steps before concreting, such as opening having an influence on the ageing of gasket
and closing the moulds, cleaning, oiling and placing materials,” says Mauchamp.
inserts. Additionally, there are developments ongoing Last but not least, Mauchamp notes that new
with regards to the moulds themselves in order to tunnel lining development itself or ring assembly
reach an even higher level of safety and precision,” methods are having a direct impact on the gasket
says Medel. and the company is closely working together
Besides innovation and automation, Medel with designers in order to offer the most efficient
says, sustainability plays an important role in the products.

Tunnelling Journal 43

You might also like