Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 - Stroke in The Middle-East and North Africa
2 - Stroke in The Middle-East and North Africa
Abstract
Background and methods: Intravenous thrombolysis for acute ischemic stroke in the Middle-East and North African
(MENA) countries is still confined to the main urban and university hospitals. This was a prospective observational study
to examine outcomes of intravenous thrombolysis-treated stroke patients in the MENA region compared to the non-
MENA stroke cohort in the SITS International Registry.
Results: Of 32,160 patients with ischemic stroke registered using the SITS intravenous thrombolysis protocol between
June 2014 and May 2016, 500 (1.6%) were recruited in MENA. Compared to non-MENA (all p < 0.001), median age in
MENA was 55 versus 73 years, NIH Stroke Scale score 12 versus 9, onset-to-treatment time 138 versus 155 min and
door-to-needle time 54 min versus 64 min. Hypertension was the most reported risk factor, but lower in MENA (51.7 vs.
69.7%). Diabetes was more frequent in MENA (28.5 vs. 20.8%) as well as smoking (20.8 vs. 15.9%). Hyperlipidemia was
less observed in MENA (17.6 vs. 29.3%). Functional independence (mRS 0–2) at seven days or discharge was similar (53%
vs. 52% in non-MENA), with mortality slightly lower in MENA (2.3% vs. 4.8%). SICH rates by SITS-MOST definition were
low (<1.4%) in both groups.
Conclusions: Intravenous thrombolysis patients in MENA were younger, had more severe strokes and more often
diabetes. Although stroke severity was higher in MENA, short-term functional independency and mortality were not
worse compared to non-MENA, which could partly be explained by younger age and shorter OTT in MENA. Decreasing
the burden of stroke in this young population should be prioritized.
Keywords
Ischemic stroke, hemorrhagic stroke, door-to-needle, door-to-imaging, burden of stroke
9
Department of Neurology, CHU de Blida – Hôpital Franz Fanon, Blida,
Algeria
10
1
Department of Neurology, Rashid Hospital – Dubai Health Authority, Department of Neurology, Mongi Ben Hamida National Institute of
Dubai, United Arab Emirates Neurology, Tunis, Tunisia
11
2
Department of Neurology, Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Faculty of Medical Sciences – Lebanese University, Neurology Division,
Sweden Hadath, Lebanon
12
3
Department of Clinical Neurosciences, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Department of Neurology, Cairo University, Cairo, Egypt
13
Sweden Department of Neurology, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi
4
Hamad General Hospital, Section of Neurology, Doha, Qatar Arabia
5
Department of Neurology, Imam Husain Hospital, Tehran, Iran Corresponding author:
6
Department of Neurology, Hassan II University Hospital, Fez, Morocco T Moreira, Tema Neuro/Dept of Neurovascular Diseases, Karolinska
7
Ain Shams University, Stroke Unit, Cairo, Egypt University Hospital, Eugeniavägen 6, Carolina Tower 3rd floor,
8
Department of Neurology, King Abdulaziz Medical City, Riyadh, Saudi Stockholm 17176, Sweden.
Arabia Email: tiago.more@gmail.com
Logistics (min)
Destination after discharge from hospital severity between the MENA cohort and the 10-year
earlier SITS-MOST, at NIHSS 12 in both studies.
(Figure 3) This comparison of cohorts a decade apart has rele-
Most MENA patients (73.6%) were discharged to their vance, as the novelty of IVT in clinical practice in
own homes compared to non-MENA patients (47.7%). MENA in 2014–2016 is comparable to that in
Thus, MENA patients were also less often discharged European centers in 2002–2006.8
to geriatric or rehabilitation units (7.9 vs. 22.8%), spe- The higher occurrence of more severe strokes in the
cial facilities (4.6 vs. 8.3%), and other acute clinics/ IVT MENA population is in contrast with the rela-
units (0 vs. 6%). Patients in MENA were also dis- tively lower burden of risk factors at baseline in these
charged dead less often than in non-MENA countries patients when compared to non-MENA patients,
(6.5 vs. 9.6%, all p < 0.001). The mortality rates above exception made to more frequent diabetes and ongoing
include the cumulative mortality rates at seven days smoking in MENA. The higher occurrence of diabetes
and beyond. in IVT-treated MENA patients (28.5% vs. 20.7% in
non-MENA) is in line with our previously reported
findings in the general stroke population in the SITS
Discussion
MENA Registry.7 Hypertension in IVT-treated MENA
In MENA hospitals participating in the SITS Registry, patients is less common compared to IVT-treated non-
IVT was predominantly given to relatively young, MENA patients (51.7 vs. 69.7%), possibly explained by
mostly male patients. During the study period of their younger age or underdiagnosed. In our previous
2014–2016, treatment was delivered in centers with SITS MENA study, atrial fibrillation was shown to be
logistic metrics similar (and somewhat better) to less frequent and probably underdiagnosed in an older
European centers participating in the original SITS- cohort of stroke patients. 7 However, IVT-treated
MOST study in 2002–2006. Specifically, in SITS- MENA patients in this study are younger and atrial
MENA, DNT was 54 min versus 64 in SITS-MOST, fibrillation is known to be more prevalent with older
OTT 138 min in MENA versus 140 min in SITS- age.12 Thus, a possible explanation for the more severe
MOST. This is coupled to identical median stroke strokes observed in the IVT-treated MENA patients
despite the lower risk factor burden is the higher preva- explanation is that most of MENA patients are in
lence of intracranial stenoses in the region, which may their 50s but have more severe strokes, whereas non-
increase stroke severity, occur at a younger age, and MENA patients are in their 70s but have milder
explain the higher frequency of dense vessel signs in strokes, thus balancing these groups regarding bleeding
the MENA patients.13,14 The general SITS-MENA risk. Indeed, older age and more severe strokes are
stroke population study also showed large-vessel sten- known risk factors associated with SICH.16,17
osis > 50% to be a common stroke etiology.7 There
were fewer women than men receiving IVT in both
Functional outcomes at seven days or discharge
MENA and non-MENA countries. This pattern was
seen in a previous SITS IVT study in predominantly The proportion of functionally independent patients
European patients in 2002–2011.15 Our previous SITS was comparable between MENA and non-MENA,
MENA study of general stroke patients also showed with slightly over half of the patients presenting with
fewer women than men in the cohort, with a wider mRS 0–2 at seven days or at discharge in both groups.
gender gap in the MENA versus the non-MENA popu- There was slightly lower mortality in the MENA region
lation.7 Similarly, a study from Qatar showed that 79% which may relate to the younger population; however,
of all stroke patients were male and that almost half of follow-up data are lacking in a substantial proportion
them were 50 years or less, which is in line with the of non-MENA patients warranting caution in inter-
present study population.4 Despite comparable age pretation. Given the high average stroke severity in
and gender profiles in previous studies, it is important the MENA IVT cohort, we saw a notably low propor-
to mention that pre-or in-hospital patient selection tion of patients discharged to rehabilitation clinics.
could have resulted in younger male patients being trea- More often, patients were discharged to their own
ted with IVT, in the past and in the present study. homes, which is a traditional standard of care in this
region. This was in line with our previous MENA study
and a separate study from Lebanon.3,7 The short-term
SICH
follow-up in our study does not yet reflect any long-
SICH rates as per ECASS II and SITS-MOST were low term effects of discharge to home versus rehabilitation
(ranging from 1% to 3.9%) and comparable between units on outcomes. Additional resources and improved
MENA and non-MENA patients. A reasonable logistics are necessary to achieve high stable rates of
long-term follow-up. Mobile phone follow-up at three was Chairman (1996-2018) and now senior advisor of SITS
months could be a feasible alternative. A previous pilot- International, which received an unrestricted grant from
study from our research group showed 83% agreement Boehringer Ingelheim for the SITS-ISTR. T Moreira has
between mobile phone and clinical-based mRS assess- received travel and speaker grants from Boehringer-
Ingelheim. M Almekhlafi received travel and speaker grants
ment in separating functional independence mRS 0–2
from Boehringer-Ingelheim.
from functional dependence (mRS 3–5).18 Planned
endovascular treatment studies using the SITS
Thrombectomy protocol (SITS-TBY) in the MENA Funding
region may incentivize performance and data collection The author(s) received no financial support for the research,
from structured three-month follow-up at comprehen- authorship, and/or publication of this article.
sive stroke centers.
Finally, factors influencing general accessibility to ORCID iD
IVT treatment in MENA countries need to be con-
T Moreira https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7613-5169
sidered. For instance, in Iran, the major obstacles to
timely treatment of acute ischemic stroke were identi-
fied to be low public awareness, low priority for acute References
stroke care and insufficient amount of stroke ready hos- 1. Zakaria MF, Aref H, Abd ElNasser A, et al. Egyptian
pitals, including lack of 24/7 access to endovascular experience in increasing utilization of reperfusion thera-
therapy.5 Inadequate knowledge in emergency service pies in acute ischemic stroke. Int J Stroke 2018; 13:
workers about stroke types, symptoms and mimics was 525–529.
also found in Dubai, which led to an effective educa- 2. Chtaou N, Rachdi L, Midaoui AE, et al. Intravenous
tional initiative.19 However, a success story of IVT dis- thrombolysis with rt-PA in stroke: experience of the mor-
semination can be told for Egypt, which uses SITS for occan stroke unit. Pan Afr Med J 2016; 24: 207.
3. Lahoud N, Salameh P, Hosseini H, et al. Care and dis-
the Egyptian Stroke National Registry with the support
charge outcome of acute stroke in lebanon: a hospital-
of the ESO Angels Initiative. IVT rates across 52
based study. J Nerv Ment Dis 2018; 206: 637–643.
Egyptian centers increased from 2% to 4.5% just two 4. Ibrahim F, Deleu D, Akhtar N, et al. Burden of stroke in
years after the conclusion of data collection for the pre- Qatar. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis 2015; 24: 2875–2879.
sent study.1,20 5. Shahjouei S, Bavarsad-Shahripour R, Assarzadegan F,
et al. Acute management of stroke in Iran: obstacles
and solutions. Iran J Neurol 2017; 16: 62–71.
Conclusions 6. Tran J, Mirzaei M, Anderson L, et al. The epidemiology
Experience with IVT treatment is increasing in MENA of stroke in the Middle East and North Africa. J Neurol
countries. Our observational study reveals the treated Sci 2010; 295: 38–40.
population to be a relatively young, predominantly 7. Rukn SA, Mazya MV, Hentati F, et al. Stroke in the
male, presenting commonly with diabetes and ongoing Middle-East and North Africa: a 2-year prospective
observational study of stroke characteristics in the
smoking. Wider implementation of IVT treatment,
region – results from the safe implementation of treat-
improved risk factor control, access to rehabilitation
ments in stroke (SITS)-Middle-East and North African
and long-term follow-up need to be incentivized and (MENA). Int J Stroke. Epub ahead of print 12 March
supported by health authorities. Without this, the pre- 2019. DOI: 10.1177/1747493019830331.
dicted rise in the burden of stroke is unlikely to be 8. Wahlgren N, Ahmed N, Davalos A, et al. Thrombolysis
halted in the MENA countries. with alteplase for acute ischaemic stroke in the Safe
Implementation of Thrombolysis in Stroke-Monitoring
Acknowledgements Study (SITS-MOST): an observational study. Lancet
The authors thank Carla Zeid, Dubai, for excellent develop- 2007; 369: 275–282.
ment and support to the MENA network. Dr Shekhar 9. Mazya MV, Lees KR, Markus R, et al. Safety of intra-
Ghotoskar for valuable input for the MENA network collab- venous thrombolysis for ischemic stroke in patients trea-
oration. A list of national and local coordinators of the SITS ted with warfarin. Ann Neurol 2013; 74: 266–274.
MENA network is provided in our previous publication.7 10. Anani N, Mazya MV, Bill O, et al. Changes in European
label and guideline adherence after updated recommen-
dations for stroke thrombolysis: results from the safe
Declaration of conflicting interests implementation of treatments in stroke registry. Circul
The author(s) declared the following potential conflicts of Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes 2015; 8: S155–162.
interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or pub- 11. Mazya MV, Ahmed N, Azevedo E, et al. Impact of tran-
lication of this article: MV Mazya holds the position of scranial doppler ultrasound on logistics and outcomes in
Researcher at SITS International, N Ahmed is the stroke thrombolysis: results from the SITS-ISTR. Stroke
Chairman (2019) of SITS International and N Wahlgren 2018; 49: 1695–1700.
12. Feinberg WM, Blackshear JL, Laupacis A, et al. 17. Mazya M, Egido JA, Ford GA, et al. Predicting the risk
Prevalence, age distribution, and gender of patients of symptomatic intracerebral hemorrhage in ischemic
with atrial fibrillation. Analysis and implications. Arch stroke treated with intravenous alteplase: safe implemen-
Intern Med 1995; 155: 469–473. tation of treatments in stroke (SITS) symptomatic intra-
13. Moustafa RR, Moneim AA, Salem HH, et al. cerebral hemorrhage risk score. Stroke 2012; 43:
Intracranial steno-occlusive arterial disease and its asso- 1524–1531.
ciations in Egyptian ischemic stroke patients. Stroke 18. Cooray C, Matusevicius M, Wahlgren N, et al. Mobile
2013; 44: 538–541. phone-based questionnaire for assessing 3 months mod-
14. Abd-Allah F, Ibrahim EM, Zidan O, et al. Screening of ified Rankin score after acute stroke: a pilot study. Circul
asymptomatic intracranial arterial stenosis among high Cardiovas Qual Outcomes 2015; 8: S125–130.
risk subjects: a pilot study from Egypt. J Vasc Interv 19. Shire F, Kasim Z, Alrukn S, et al. Stroke awareness
Neurol 2018; 10: 68–72. among Dubai emergency medical service staff and
15. Lorenzano S, Ahmed N, Falcou A, et al. Does sex influ- impact of an educational intervention. BMC Res Notes
ence the response to intravenous thrombolysis in ischemic 2017; 10: 255.
stroke? Answers from safe implementation of treatments 20. Zakaria MF. Increasing the number of stroke units: suc-
in Stroke-International Stroke Thrombolysis Register. cess stories in hospitals in Egypt. Oral communication,
Stroke 2013; 44: 3401–3406. Oct 19, 2018; Session: Improving stroke care across the
16. Ford GA, Ahmed N, Azevedo E, et al. Intravenous alte- world: the Angels initiative at the 11th World Stroke
plase for stroke in those older than 80 years old. Stroke Congress, ESO Angels Symposium, Montreal, Canada.
2010; 41: 2568–2574.