Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SINA LOHRASB
APRIL 2012
1
1.0 Introduction
Every year, oil industry sustains billion dollars loss because of production of
unwanted water which is the result of water coning. Downhole Water Sink is one of
the techniques which have been used for removing this problem in oil industry. This
technology consist of production of water and oil separately and also simultaneously
from their own layer and this can be used for preventing water coning in vertical
2
wells and also preventing water cresting in horizontal wells. In fact, this technique
causes the vacuum of water in aquifer.
4- Finally, the main purpose is the simulation and investigation the other
conditions which can be useful in expansion of this technique.
1.4.2 To identify the causes and effects of water coning in oil wells.
3
1.5.2 What are the causes and effects of water coning in oil production?
1.5.3 What can be done to minimize the water production in oil wells?
These studies helps to re-production of old wells which have been located in
transition zone because of production and have the problem of water coning which
cause their production to be stopped.
These researches can help to prevent the entrance of two-phase fluid of water
and oil in a well.
4
These studies can lead to the expansion of this technique in horizontal wells
which today have more efficiency.
In these studies, it will be discussed the water coning phenomenon in old and
new wells as well and also the use of Downhole Water Sink technology in old wells
with sever water coning.
In the last few decades, many studies have been dedicated to the mechanism
of water coning in vertical wells and water cresting in horizontal wells. These
researches presented a formula for critical oil production rate to prevent water coning
and forecast the water break through time after happening of water coning. But as it
is known this production with critical oil rate is not economically profitable.
The aim of these studies is evaluating the operation of Downhole Water Sink
with the help of simulation and finally producing the oil without water in vertical and
horizontal wells.
Downhole Water Sink technology proved that we can produce more oil with
high oil production rate and water coning can be prevented and thus, this technology
prevents the oil to be bypassed to the reservoir.
1.7 Hypothesis
In most of the done researches, the types of fluid flow were supposed to be
stable and the type of two phase flow and reservoirs were supposed to be
homogeneous. However, as it is known, reservoirs are not so in fact. So for achieving
5
Reviewing these studies, shows that most of the researches are based on
experimental procedures and their simulations are based on numerical analysis and
their results are forecasting exact water break through time and critical oil production
rate.
Muskut, Wyckoff (1935) stated that the water coning phenomenon is the
result of unestablishing the balance between the surface of water and oil. They
believed that, for preventing this problem, these two surfaces should remain stable.
They presented a critical oil production rate formula to picking this problem.
Lee, Guo (1993) proved that water coning is related to vertical pressure
gradient under the well bore and presented a new formula for calculating of critical
oil rate.
But as it is know, the critical oil production rate is very low and its
production by this rate is not economically profitable. At the result, some ways were
expanded for preventing water coning in vertical wells and water cresting in
horizontal wells. In all these techniques, the aim is postponing the water break
through time.
1- Closing the well in the zone in that water coning was happened and
recompletion the well in upper layers.
2- Injection of chemical substances like vax, gel, and viscous materials to
aquifer for preventing the quick movement of water into the oil layers.
3- Use of the inner well separator by which oil and water will be separated in the
well.
4- Making a radius fluid flow around well bore by decreasing the oil production
rate.
1- The use of stinger for preventing turbulence of the flow and at the result
preventing water cresting.
2- Use of the variable perforation density procedure.
3- Use of high angle well with tip close to the water oil contact.
Chugbo et. al. (1989) observed that the euphoria of horizontal well
technology for the development of thin oil columns in an unconsolidated sand
8
Permadi et. al. (1997) investigated the horizontal well completion with a
stinger introduced into the perforated pipe to redistribute the crest profile along the
wellbore. They concluded that inserting a stinger about 0.25 times the length of the
horizontal well provides a better pressure drawdown distribution and therefore more
uniform flux along the wellbore.
Mehta, Pirson (1967) had presented a way in which the produced oil were re-
injected to the aquifer to prevent water coning. Theoretically their approaches were
practical for preventing water coning but were not justified economically.
simultaneously and will be separated by a packer in the well. The problem of this
procedure was that, by producing water, the oil production rate was reduced at the
same time. On the other hand in his procedure the problem of oil bypassing were
completely removed.
Ehlig, Economides et.al (1996) showed that Driscall procedure had high
efficiency in the reservoir with strong aquifer and also reservoirs in which oil is
produced by the water drive mechanism because these reservoirs are not affected
with pressure reduction by water production.
After that, the Downhole Water Sink technique was known as an ideal
technique for preventing water coning inn water drive reservoirs whose most
problems are also water coning.
The Downhole Water Sink technology was carried out for the first time in
1994 in Nebo Hemphill field in Louisiana of USA by the company of Hunt
Petroleum. The practical results showed that this technique not only prevent water
coning, but also increase the oil production rate and revise the old wells in which oil
production s are stopped because of water coning.
Downhole Water Sink technique also had been used later in horizontal wells
too. It consists of two techniques:
1- Tailpipe Water Sink: A well horizontally enters to the oil layer and other well
vertically enters to the aquifer and they will be produced oil and water
simultaneously and separately.
2- Bilateral Water Sink: Both wells will be drilled horizontally and in parallel
form. The lower well will be located in the aquifer and the upper one in the
oil layer and they will produced water and oil simultaneously and separately.
10
3.1.1 Collecting data from oil wells that have water coning.
3.2.1 Books
3.2.2 Journals
3.2.3 Articles
There are various softwares in the oil industry by which this sort of
simulation can be done and the results can be compared together, such as SCON,
CMG, etc.
11
The main applicable software for this research is ECLIPSE software and use
of Inflow Performance Window (IPW) technique also is a proper way for evaluating
the applicability of Downhole Water Sink in this study.
12
References
Archer, J.S. and Wall, C.G., 1988, “Petroleum Engineering – principles and
practice”, Graham and Trotman, London, pp. 92-119
Arirachakaran, S., Oglesby, K.D., Malinowsky, M. S., Shoham, O., and Brill, J. P.,
1989, “An Analysis of Oil/Water Flow Phenomena in Horizontal Pipes”, Paper SPE
18836, SPE Production Operations Symposium, Oklahoma City, OK, March 13- 14
Asheim, H., Kolnes, J., and Oudeman, P., 1992, “A flow resistance correlation for
completed wellbore”, Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 8, Elsevier
Science Publishers, Amsterdam, pp 97-104
Babu, D.K., and Odeh, A.S., 1988, “Productivity of Horizontal Well”, Paper SPE
18334, 63rd Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Houston, TX, October 2-5.
Bourgoyne, A.T. (Jr.), Millheim, K.K., Chenevert, M.E., and Young, F.S. (Jr.), 1991,
“Applied Drilling Engineering”, Society of Petroleum Engineers, Richardson, TX.,
pp144-147.
Bowlin, K.R., Chea, C.K., Wheeler, S.S., and Waldo, L.A., 1997, “Field Application
of In-situ Gravity Segregation to Remediate Prior Water Coning”, Paper SPE 38296,
SPE Western regional Meeting, Long Beach, CA, June 25-27.
Brekke, K, and Lien, S.C., 1992, “New and Simple Completion Methods for
Horizontal Wells Improve the Production Performance in High-Permeability, Thin
Oil Zones”, Paper SPE 24762, 67th Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition,
Washington DC, October 4-7.
Broughton, G., and Squires, L., 1937, “The Viscosity of Oil-Water Emulsion”,
Journal of Colloid Science 5, Academy Press, New York, NY, pp 253-263.
Chappelear, J.E., and Hirasaki, G.J., 1974, “A Model of Oil-Water Coning for Two-
Dimensional, Areal Reservoir Simulation”, Paper SPE 4980, 49th Annual Fall
Meeting, Houston, October 6-9.
Chen, H., 1993, “Performance of Horizontal Wells, Safah Field, Oman”, Paper SPE
25568, SPE Middle East Oil Technical Conference and Exhibition, Bahrain, April
3-6.
Chaperon, I., 1986, “Theoretical Study of Coning Toward Horizontal and Vertical
Well in Anisotropic Formations: Subcritical and Critical Rates”; paper SPE 15377,
61st Annual Technical Conference and exhibition, New Orleans, LA, October. 5-8
Chugbo, A.I., Roux, G.D., and Bosio, J.C., 1989, “ Thin Oil Columns: Most People
Think Horizontal Wells, Obagi Field Case Suggests the Contrary”, Paper SPE
19599, SPE 64th Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, San Antonio, TX,
October 8-11.
Craft, B.C. and Hawkins, M.F., Terry , R.E., 1991,“Applied Petroleum Reservoir
Engineering” Second Edition, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Cunningham, A.B., Jay, K.L., and Opstad, E.,1992, “Unconventional Prudhoe Bay
Wells Benefit From MWD Use”, World Oil, May, p43-52.
Dikken, B.J., 1990, “Pressure Drop in Horizontal Wells and Its Effect on Production
Performance”, Paper SPE 19824, Journal of Petroleum Technology, November.,
pp1426-1433.
Emerson, A. B., Jones, R. C., and Lim, S. B., 1998, “Multi-Lateral Case Histories in
the Thailand, Malaysia and Brunei Area”, Paper SPE 47810, IADC/SPE Asia Pacific
14
EPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency), 1995, “Crude Oil and
Natural Gas Exploration and Production Wastes: Exemption from RCRA Subtitle C
Regulation”, Solid Waste Emergency Response 5305, EPA530-K-95-003, May
Fisher, W.G, Letkeman, J.P., and Tetreau, E.M., 1970, “The Application of
Numerical Coning Model to Optimize Completion and Production Methods To
Increase Oil Productivity in Bellshill Lake Blairmore Pool” Journal of Canadian
Petroleum Technology, Oct. – Dec., p33-39.
Flores, J. G., Chen, X.T., Sarica, C., and Brill, J.P., 1999, “Characterization of Oil-
Water Flow Patterns in Vertical and Deviated Wells”, Paper SPE 56108, SPE
Journal of Production and Facilities, May, p102-109.
Giger, F.M., Reiss, L.H., and Jourdan, A.P., 1984, “The Reservoir Engineering
Aspects of Horizontal Drilling” Paper SPE 13024, SPE 59th Annual Technical
Conference and Exhibition, Houston, TX, September 16-19.
Guo, B., Molinard, J.E., Lee, R.L., 1992, “A General Solution of Gas/Water Coning
Problems for Horizontal Wells”, Paper SPE 25050, SPE European Petroleum
Conference, Cannes, France, November 16-18.
Hansen, K.L. and Verhyden, M., 1991, “Horizontal Well Solves Water Coning”,
Petroleum Engineer International, Houston, TX, September 16.
15
Henley, D.H., Owens, W.W., and Craig, F.F., Jnr, 1960, “A Scale-Model Study of
Bottom-Water Drives” Paper SPE , 35th Annual Meeting
Heysel, M., 1992, “Horizontal Well Performance in the Dina Sandstone in the
Provost Area of Alberta”, Paper CIM 92-93, Annual Technical Conference of
Petroleum Society of the CIM, Calgary, Alberta, Canada, June 7-10.
Ibrahim, A., Desbrandes, R., and Bassiouni, Z., 1994, “Derived Capillary Pressure
From Well Logs”, Petroleum Engineer International, New York, July, pp 38-41
Inikori, S.O., and Wojtanowicz, A.K., 2002, “Effect of 2-Phase Oil-Water Flow and
Friction Pressure Loss in The Wellbore on Water Cresting in Horizontal Wells”,
ETCE2002/Prod-29165, 25th ASME Annual Engineering Technology Conference on
Energy, Houston, TX, February 4-5.
Jiang, W., Sarica, C., Ozkan, E., and Kelkar, M., 2000, “Investigation of the Effects
of Completion Geometry on Single Phase Liquid Flow Behavior in Horizontal
Wells”, ETCE2000/Prod-10061, Energy Sources Technology Conference and
Exhibition, New Orleans, February 14-17.
Karcher, B.J., Giger, F.M., and Combe, J., 1986, “Some Practical Formulas To
Predict Horizontal Well Behavior”, Paper SPE 15430, 61st Annual Technical
Conference and Exhibition of the Society of Petroleum Engineers, New Orleans, LA,
October 5-8.
Koonsman, T.L., and Purpich, A.J., 1991, “Ness Horizontal Well Case Study”, Paper
SPE 23096, SPE Offshore Europe Conference, Aberdeen, Scotland, September 3- 6.
Lien, S.C., Seines, K., and Havig, S.O., 1990, 1991, “The First Long-Term
Horizontal- Well Test in the Troll Thin Oil Zone”, Paper 20715, SPE Annual
Technical Conference and Exhibition (JPT, August 1991, p914-974), New Orleans,
LA, September.
MacDonald, R.C., and Coats, K.H., 1970, “Methods for Numerical Simulation of
Water and Gas Coning”, Paper SPE 2796, Second Symposium on Numerical
Simulation of Reservoir Performance, Dallas, TX, February 5-6.
Mattax, C.C and Dalton, R. (ed.), 1989, “Reservoir Simulation”, Monograph Vol. 13,
SPE Textbook Series, Richardson, TX, p135.
McMullan, J.H., and Larson, T.A., 2000, “Impact of Skin Damage on Horizontal
Well Flow Distribution”, Paper SPE/Petroleum Society of CIM 65507,
SPE/Petroleum Society of CIM International Conference on Horizontal Well
Technology, Calgary, Canada, November 6-8.
Marett, B.P., and Landman, M.J., 1993, “Optimal Perforation Design for Horizontal
Wells in Reservoirs With Boundaries”, Paper SPE 25366, Asia Pacific Oil and
Gas Conference and Exhibition, Singapore, February 8-10.
Martinez, A.E., Arirachakaran, S., Shoham, O., and Brill, J.P., 1988, “Prediction of
Dispersed Viscosity of Oil/Water Mixture Flow in Horizontal Pipes”, Paper SPE
18221, SPE 63rd Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Houston, TX,
October 2-5.
Miller, R.T. and Rogers, W.L., 1973, “Performance of Oil Wells in Bottom Water
Drive Reservoirs” Paper SPE 4633, 48th Annual Meeting, Las Vegas, NV,
September. 30-October. 3
Muskat, M., 1949, “Physical Principles of Oil Production”, McGraw-Hill Book Co.
Inc., New York City, p. 226-236.
Mungan, N., 1975, “A Theoretical and Experimental Coning Study”, Paper SPE
4982, SPE-AIME 49th Annual Fall Meeting, Houston, TX, October 6-9.
17
Murphy, P.J., 1988, “Performance of Horizontal Wells in the Helder Field”, Paper
SPE 18340, SPE European Petroleum Conference, London, U.K., October 16-19.
Ozkan, E, Sarica, C., and Haci, M., 1993, 1999, “Influence of Pressure Drop Along
the Wellbore on Horizontal Well Productivity”, Paper SPE 25502 and 57687, SPE
Journal 4 (3), September.
Papatzacos, P., Herring, T.R., Martinsen, R., and Skjaeveland, S.M., 1989, 1991,
“Cone Breakthrough Time for Horizontal Wells”, Paper SPE 19822, SPE Annual
Technical Conference and Exhibition (Reservoir Engineering Journal, August
1991), San Antonio,TX., October 8-11.
Peng, C.P., and Yeh, N, 1995, “Reservoir Engineering Aspects of Horizontal Wells -
Application to Oil Reservoirs with Gas or Water Coning Problems”, Paper SPE
29958, International Meeting on Petroleum Engineering, Beijing, PR China,
November 14-17.
Permadi, P., Lee, R.L., and Kartoatmodjo, R.S.T., 1995, “Behavior of Water
Cresting Under Horizontal Wells”, Paper SPE 30743, Annual Technical Conference
and Exhibition, Dalls, TX, October 22-25.
Permadi, P., 1996, “Water Cresting Behavior Under High Angle Wells: An
Experimental Investigation”, Paper SPE 35715, Western Regional Meeting,
Anchorage, Alaska, May 22-24.
Permadi, P., Wibowo, W., Alamsyah, Y., and Pratomo, S.W., 1997, “Horizontal
Well Completion With Stinger for Reducing Water Coning Problems”, SPE
Production Operations Symposium, Oklahoma City, OK, March 9-11.
Pirson, S.J., and Mehta, M.M., 1967, “A Study of Remedial Measures for Water-
Coning By Means of a Two-Dimensional Simulator”, Paper SPE 1808, 42nd Annual
Fall Meeting of the Society of Petroleum Engineers of AIME, Houston, TX, October
1- 4.
Reed, R.N., and Wheatley, M.J., 1984, “Oil and Water Production in a Reservoir
With Significant Capillary Transition Zone”, Paper SPE 12066, Journal of
Petroleum Technology, September, p1559-1566
Renard, G., Gadelle, C., Dupuy, J.M., and Alfonso, H., 1997, “Potential of
Multilateral Wells in Water Coning Situations”, Paper SPE 39071, Fifth Latin
American and Caribbean Petroleum Engineering Conference and Exhibition, Rio De
Janeiro, Brazil, August 30 – September 3.
18
Richardson, E.G., 1959, “The Formation and Flow of Emulsion”, Journal of Colloid
Science 5, Academy Press, New York, NY, pp 404-413.
Schols, R.S., 1972, “An Empirical Formula for the Critical Oil Production Rate”,
Erdoel Erdgas,Z, Vol. 88, No.1 , January, p6-11
Seines, K., Aavatsmark, I., Lien, S.C., and Rushworth,P., 1993, “Considering
Wellbore Friction Effects in Planning Horizontal Wells”, Journal of Petroleum
Technology (JPT), October pp 994 – 1000
Shirman, E.I., and Wojtanowicz, A.K., 1998, “More Oil with Less Water Using
Downhole Water Sink Technology: A Feasibility Study”, Paper SPE 49052,
Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, New Orleans, LA, October 27-30.
Sobocinski, D.P., and Cornelius, A.J., 1965, “A Correlation for Predicting Water
Coning Time”, Journal of Petroleum Technology, May, p594-600.
Soleimani, A., Lawrence, C.J., and Hewitt, G.F., 1999, “Spatial Distribution of Oil
and Water in Horizontal Pipe Flow”, Paper SPE 56524, SPE Annual Technical
Conference and Exhibition, Houston, TX, October 3-6.
Swisher, M.D., and Wojtanowicz, A.K., 1995, “New Dual Completion Eliminates
Bottom Water Coning”, Paper SPE 30697, SPE Annual Technical Conference &
Exhibition, Dallas, TX, October 22-25.
19
Swisher, M.D., and Wojtanowicz, A.K., 1995, “In-situ Segregated Production of Oil
and water – A Production Method With Environmental Merit: Field Application”,
Paper SPE 29693, SPE/EPA Exploration and Production Environmental Conference,
Houston, TX, March 27-29.
Tang, Y., Ozkan, E., Kelkar, M., Sarica, C., and Yildiz, T., 2000, “Performance of
Horizontal Wells Completed with Slotted Liners and Perforations”, Paper SPE/PS
- CIM 65516, SPE/Petroleum Society of Cim International Conference on
Horizontal Well Technology, Calgary,Alberta,Canada, November 6-8.
Tehrani, A.D.H., 1992, “An Overview of Horizontal Well Targets Recently Drilled
in Europe”, Paper SPE 22390, SPE International Meeting on Petroleum
Engineering, Beijing, China, March 24-27.
Trallero, J.L., Sarica, C., and Brill, J.P., 1996, “ A Study of Oil-Water Flow Patterns
in Horizontal Pipes”, Paper SPE 36609, SPE Annual Technical Conference and
Exhibition, Denver, CO., October 6-9
Wanty, R. B., 1997, “USGS Research on Saline Waters Co-Produced With Energy
Resources”, Fact Sheet FS-003-97,
Weinstein, H.G., Chappelear, J.E., and Nolen, J.S., 1986, “Second Comparative
Solution Project: A Three Phase Coning Study”, SPE paper. Journal of Petroleum
Technology, March.
Wheatley, M.J., 1985, “An Approximate Theory of Oil/Water Coning”, Paper SPE
14210, 60th Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Las Vegas, NV,
September 22-25.
Wojtanowicz, A.K., and Shirman, E.I., 1994, “An In-situ Method for Downhole
Drainage – injection of Formation Brine in a Single Oil-Producing Well,” Proc. Int.
Symposium on Scientific and Engineering Aspects of Deep Injection Disposal of
Hazardous and Industrial Wastes, Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, Berkeley, CA,
May 10 –13.
Wojtanowicz, A.K., Hui Xu, and Bassiouni, Z., 1991, “Oilwell Coning Control
Using Dual Completion With Tailpipe Water Sink”, Paper SPE 21654, SPE
Production Operation Symposium, Oklahoma City, OK, April 7-9.
Yang, W. and Wattenbarger, R.A., “Water Coning Calculations for Vertical and
Horizontal Wells”; Paper SPE 22931, 66th Annual Technical Conference and
exhibition, Dallas, TX, October. 6-9
Yokoyama, Y, and Lake, Larry W., 1981, “The Effect of Capillary Pressure on
Immiscible Displacements in Stratified Porous Media”, Paper SPE 10109, 56thc
Annual Fall Technical Conference and Exhibition of Society of Petroleum engineers
of AIME, San Antonio, TX, October 5-7.
Yuan, H. J., Sarica, C., and Brill, J.P., 1999, “Effect of Perforation density on Single-
Phase Liquid Flow Behavior in Horizontal Wells”, Paper SPE 57395, SPE Journal of
Production and Facilities, Richardson, TX., August, pp 203-209.