Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ending Social Anxiety PDF
Ending Social Anxiety PDF
Ending
Social
Anxiety
A Free, Short Guide
socanxy@gmail.com
paypal.me/socanxy
1
Contents
Introduction 2
Section One 3
1A. Anticipatory Anxiety and Post-Event Evaluation 4
1B. Negative Automatic Thoughts 5
1C. Cognitive Distortions 6
1D. Misdirected Attention 8
1E. Safety Behaviours 10
Section Two 12
2A. Hierarchy of Fears 13
2B. Cognitive Restructuring Worksheet 14
2C. Likelihood and Consequence 18
2D. The Rationale for Exposure 19
2E. Metacognitive Therapy 21
2F. Attention Training Technique
And Situational Attention Refocusing 22
Section Three 23
3A. Meditation 24
3B. Supplements 25
3C. Exercise 27
Donate 28
Further Reading 29
2
Introduction
Until now, the severity of your social anxiety has been
dependent on a number of factors: strategies you’ve devised,
advice you’ve been given, seemingly random periods of respite or
of disimprovement. Now, however, that you’ve got your hands on
this document, one factor in particular has become the main
determinant of whether your social anxiety will improve or
maintain itself: that factor is self-discipline.
What I mean by that is that this document contains enough
sound and research-backed information that anyone who
diligently and repeatedly follows all of the steps will see some
improvement. Not everyone, however, will have the willpower
necessary to complete the exercises, including the complementary
techniques described in Section Three.
As you work on your social anxiety, it will be helpful to revisit this
document at times. At first read it weekly: after a while, read it
fortnightly. Whatever you do, you will need a Social Anxiety
Notebook (you may use a word document as a digital alternative)
to complete the exercises outlined here, as well as to take notes
on what follows.
3
Section One
In order to tackle your social anxiety, it is important to begin to
understand how it works. Social anxiety is caused by patterns of
thought and behaviour which maintain each other reciprocally. This
means that socially anxious thoughts strengthen our tendency to
behave in certain ways—and, conversely, that socially anxious
behaviour reinforces and seems to justify our anxious thoughts.
Social anxiety is, then, that hackneyed thing, ‘a vicious cycle’, and in
order to alleviate it, you must tackle your thoughts and behaviour in
tandem. Section One of this PDF will outline how social anxiety
operates.
4
1A A
nticipatory Anxiety and Post-Event Evaluation
Anticipatory Anxiety (or A nticipatory Processing) refers to worry
experienced in advance of a social event or interaction. It may
manifest in the form of picturing mistakes one expects to make,
worrying about what one will say, or devising strategies designed to
lessen one’s anxiety during the course of the interaction. Anticipatory
processing primes the mind to regard the upcoming social event (as
well as social interactions in general) as threatening, by focusing on
the ‘mistakes’ one might make, along with the ‘dangers’ to be
navigated. Anticipatory processing also tends to be self-focused, and
so prepares the mind to focus attention on oneself rather than on the
situation at hand.
Post-Event Evaluation (or Post-Event Processing) refers to the
process of remembering a past event or interaction, either in order to
identify where one ‘went wrong’ socially, or in order to establish
what kind of impression one has made. Rumination of this kind is
usually overwhelmingly negative, and has the effect of reinforcing
two problematic ideas: (a) that social interaction is threatening, and
(b) that one’s social resources are inadequate for coping with the
situations life presents. Rumination of this kind usually focuses on
one’s s ubjective negative experience of the event, and discounts or
overlooks contrary objective evidence.
It is important to become aware of the roles played by anticipatory
processing and post-event processing in your thinking. Next time you
find yourself engaged in either, adopt an attitude of curiosity: try to
observe what the processes involve and how such thinking makes
you feel. Record your findings in your SA notebook.
5
1B N
egative Automatic Thoughts
Negative Automatic Thoughts are habitual negative judgements
regarding one’s social abilities, the likelihood of social ‘failure’, and
the consequences of ‘failing’ socially. They are often so ingrained that
they have become reflexive, and they need not always be verbalised.
If one sees a colleague at the supermarket and thinks, ‘I’ll have
nothing to say to her, and I’ll regret it if I attempt to talk’, one has
experienced two related negative automatic thoughts. ‘She definitely
won’t like me,’ ‘I’ll say something stupid,’ and ‘I’ll seem boring,’ are
examples of other possible variants.
The general role of negative automatic thoughts in perpetuating
anxiety is quite clear: they create the problem they seem to describe.
When you experience such thoughts in the future, adopt a curious
attitude, and try to identify in words any thoughts which initially
seem non-verbal. Record your negative automatic thoughts in your
SA notebook.
6
1C C
ognitive Distortions
Cognitive Distortions a re inaccurate and unhelpful ways of thinking,
which perpetuate social anxiety in a number of ways: they may be
present in both negative automatic thoughts and in anticipatory and
post-event processing. For people with social anxiety, cognitive
distortions may have become so ubiquitous in their thought patterns
that it can at first prove difficult to identify them. Below are some
examples of cognitive distortions. (More can be found on this
document, created by Larry Cohen.) In your SA notebook, begin to
identify the cognitive distortions which colour your thinking.
Absolute Thinking: black-and-white thinking which ignores
ambiguity and grey areas in favour of a view which is unbalanced
(and usually wholly negative)
Mind-Reading: assuming one knows what others are thinking (and
usually concluding that their thoughts regarding us are negative).
Over-Generalising: concluding from particular negative experiences
that such things will always h appen, or that we are forever doomed
to repeat the social ‘mistakes’ of our past.
Fortune-Telling: assuming one knows what will happen in future
social situations (and usually concluding that the outcome will be
negative).
Magnifying and Minimising: emphasising one’s own ‘failings’ (and
others’ successes), and trivialising or ignoring one’s own successes
(and others’ failings). Connected to this is the habit of ‘upward
comparison’, a tendency to compare oneself unfavourably to those
who seem most socially adept, rather than to the majority of people
who possess indifferent social skills.
7
Personalising: attributing sub-par social interaction solely to one’s
own ‘deficiencies’ rather than to the myriad other reasons such
encounters can be tricky.
Having consulted Cohen’s document (linked above), see if you can
identify which distortions play the greatest role in your own thinking,
adopting once again an attitude of curiosity.
8
1D M
isdirected Attention
When suffering from social anxiety, one tends to focus one’s
attention in unhelpful ways. There are two primary unhelpful
directions of attention: towards oneself and towards ‘threats’. Each
serves to maintain feelings of discomfort and unease.
The mind of someone who suffers from social anxiety has learned to
become hypersensitive to apparent ‘threats’. In social situations, the
socially anxious person engages frequently in ‘threat monitoring’,
estimations of how ‘dangerous’ and potentially painful the current
situation is, as well as gauging the threats which may arise as the
situation progresses. These threats are responded to by means of
negative automatic thoughts and cognitive distortions, which leave
the socially anxious person feeling certain that s/he will fail to behave
in an appropriate manner.
The effect of this is two-fold: the socially anxious person begins to
direct attention ‘inward’, towards him- or herself, in an attempt to
navigate more carefully the ‘perilous’ situation. However, because
this inward-looking attention invariably encounters symptoms of
anxiety (an elevated heartbeat, feelings of agitation, sweating,
trembling, and so on), the initial sense of anxiety increases, as do
feelings of self-consciousness and self-awareness. Psychologists
refer to this as ‘processing oneself as a social object’. This tendency is
particularly pernicious because self-focused attention prevents the
socially anxious person from attending to the situation at hand, and
from noticing the non-threatening, positive, and comforting aspects
of the interaction.
Try to think of a recent interaction during which you felt socially
anxious. Try to identify and record in your SA notebook any unhelpful
ways you focused your attention, whether on ‘threats’ or on your
own ‘performance’ and discomfort. Also try to note down any
9
comforting, positive or non-threatening aspects of the interaction
which you were too agitated to attend to at the time.
10
1E Safety Behaviours
Safety Behaviours a re the strategies one engages in in social
situations in order to try to avert ‘threats’. These may work by
concealing symptoms of your anxiety (e.g., wearing makeup to
conceal blushing), by keeping the situation as familiar and
‘non-threatening’ as possible (e.g., speaking only to known, close
friends at a party, or sticking to ‘safe’ topics in conversation). Safety
behaviours are insidious, however: as Dr Gillian Butler notes, ‘trying
to stay safe makes you keep feeling the situation is risky. One thing
feeds into another to keep the problem going.’ Safety behaviours also
require increased self-focused attention, whose problematic aspects
have already been discussed.
Relying on alcohol to ‘loosen up’ is a particularly dangerous safety
behaviour for socially anxious people. In your SA notebook, write
down which of the following safety behaviours you employ (and try
to think of any which are not listed here):
● Asking questions of other people in order to distract
attention from oneself.
● Avoiding eye contact.
● Mentally preparing what one is about to say.
● Using one’s hair to conceal one’s face.
● Sitting or standing in a marginal position.
● Concealing one’s hands to hide trembling.
● Requesting that friends come along to social events.
● Drinking alcohol or taking drugs to alleviate anxiety.
● Speaking quickly to shorten the time spent talking.
● Sticking to safe topics.
● Trying to look at ease.
Avoidance i s the most blunt form of safety behaviour, by which one
simply does not participate in the feared social engagement or
11
interaction. Avoidance includes behaviours such as declining
invitations, pretending not to see acquaintances, and avoiding areas
where one is likely to encounter someone one knows. Like other
safety behaviours, avoidance reinforces the notion that the situation
in question is best avoided or is to be engaged in only very
cautiously.
12
Section Two
Now that you understand the way your social anxiety operates, and
perpetuates itself, you can begin to unpick the habits of thought and
behaviour that constitute your problem. The following section will
outline some of the techniques therapists use to do this, most of
which are drawn from the field of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy
(CBT). The essence of these practices is to expose oneself to a feared
situation (without using safety behaviors) and then to re-evaluate
one’s thought patterns and beliefs on the basis of that experience.
However, some methods, as you will see, take a different tack.
13
2A Hierarchy of Fears
For the purpose of ‘exposures’ (participation in anxiety-provoking
situations), it’s important to create a Hierarchy of Fears. While this
sounds rather menacing, in reality it only consists of an ordered list of
about 10 situations that make you feel socially anxious, in order of
greatest severity. The first and most difficult item might be going on a
date with a stranger, or speaking in front of a crowd: the last and
easiest might be saying ‘hello’ to colleagues at work. As you gain
social confidence, you will tackle progressively more ‘difficult’
situations, and ascend the hierarchy. As you do so, you might well be
encouraged by the progress you have already made in overcoming
social challenges.
A Hierarchy of Fears can also prove useful if one encounters a
set-back in one’s progress. In that case, the Hierarchy can help with
cementing and refreshing one’s achievements, by illustrating the
foundational steps that need to be re-traced. Use your SA notebook
to create your own Hierarchy of Fears.
14
2B Cognitive Restructuring Worksheet
A Cognitive Restructuring Worksheet is one of the most effective
methods of bringing about cognitive change. It consists of a table in
which one first outlines, in detail, one’s current attitude, before
proceeding to challenge and re-appraise that (harmful) attitude on a
number of grounds.
The following two schemes are modelled on Dr Gillian Butler’s (in
Overcoming Social Anxiety and Shyness). As the first table tackles
harmful thinking patterns, we will call it the Thought-Challenging
Table. T
he table below has been completed as an example, but
entries are abbreviated for the sake of formatting: you should copy
the table and its headings into your SA notebook, and try to expand
more than I have done below. Try to identify and challenge both
negative automatic thoughts and cognitive distortions in your own
thoughts.
Situation Upsetting Alternative Change in Plan of
Thoughts Ways of Feelings Action for
Thinking (-10 to Future
+10)
BEHAVIOURAL GOALS h
elpful alternatives to safety behaviours
Attend party for two hours. Greet 5+ new people, and start 2+
conversations. Try to direct my attention outwards during interactions.
Try to keep each conversation going for 15+ minutes.
REVIEW after the event, identify t he benefits of attending
Decreased my anxiety regarding future parties. Met and had a good
chat with old friend from school. Realised I can enjoy a party without
sticking to known, safe friends. Got more comfortable making
small-talk. It was still a bit awkward but I know I can make
improvements. I also learned my anxious thoughts can be inaccurate.
18
2C Likelihood and Consequences of Social Mishaps
People suffering from social anxiety often exaggerate the likelihood
of committing social ‘mishaps’, as well as the consequences of doing
so. The result of this is to create the impression that social situations
are far more perilous than they really are, an impression which results
in anxiety and inhibition. Imagine how difficult it would be to enjoy a
walk if one thought the chances of tripping were very high, and that
tripping would certainly lead to debilitating injuries!
In advance of a feared social situation, complete a Likelihood and
Consequence Evaluation Sheet in your SA notebook. Briefly describe
the feared situation and the dangers you think it poses, and then
answer the following questions:
1. How likely is it that these mishaps will occur, from 1-10?
2. What would be the worst outcome of this situation?
3. Why would that be so catastrophic?
4. How would your life actually change as a result?
5. Could you deal with a little discomfort, as you have in the
past, if things go ‘wrong’?
In order to counteract distortions in likelihood and consequence
evaluation, you may wish to try S ocial Mishap Exposure. This a
technique which can seem daunting but which is highly effective: it
consists of committing a feared ‘error’ (e.g. dropping your pastry in a
café and asking for another for free) in order to reveal that the feared
social repercussions—in this instance, say, the server’s expression of
disapproval or anger—(a) do not materialise, or (b) are not
particularly grievous if they do.
19
2D The Rationale for Exposure
The point of exposure to feared situations is not to learn how to
avoid anxiety, and entering situations with such a goal will only
handicap your progress. The point is to accept one’s anxiety and to
do one’s best a longside one’s anxious feelings, in the knowledge that
repeated exposure will render such interactions less troubling.
Exposure also helps us to realise that our safety behaviours are in
fact doing us no favours (see the B ehaviour-Challenging Table in
section 2B, and S afety Behaviours, 1 E) and that our estimation of the
likelihood and consequences of subpar social performance is
unhelpfully skewed (2C).
Through performing exposures we learn that anxiety need not
prevent us from performing feared acts, and realise that the anxious
thoughts we feel are, in a sense, dishonest and therefore not to be
believed. Realising and proving to yourself that anxiety is tolerable
leads—in a seeming paradox—to an eventual decline in feelings of
social anxiety. The images below (drawn from Cognitive Behavioral
Therapy for Social Anxiety Disorder, S tefan G. Hofmann and Michael
W. Otto) illustrate this well.
20
21
2E Metacognitive Therapy
Metacognitive therapy (MCT), devised by Dr Adrian Wells, is a
method of treating anxiety and depression, which differs from
traditional CBT in a number of ways. Most of the methods outlined in
Section Two of this guide have been drawn from CBT, and frequently
involve the interrogation of anxiety-inducing thoughts (e.g. the
Thought-Challenging Table, section 2B). MCT, on the other hand,
emphasises non-engagement with individual thoughts (cognitions),
and stresses instead the modification of metacognitions, meaning
‘thoughts concerning thought’.
Maladaptive (or harmful) metacognitions can be classed as positive
or negative1. An example of a ‘positive’ metacognitive belief in a
socially phobic person might be, ‘Paying close attention to the way I
behave helps me to avoid doing something embarrassing.’ A negative
belief, on the other hand, might go, ‘Anxious thoughts always make
me so inhibited,’ or ‘I can’t control my anxious thoughts’. All three
metacognitions, both the ‘positive’ and the ‘negative’, perpetuate
social anxiety: the former by reinforcing self-focused attention, the
latter two by increasing one’s sense that anxiety is harmful and
uncontrollable.
Challenging such metacognitions is especially important for
disorders such as OCD, Generalised Anxiety Disorder and PTSD. Of
more immediate use in the treatment of social anxiety are two other
techniques drawn from Wells’ metacognitive model: the Attention
Training Technique and Situational Attentional Refocusing.
1
‘Positive’ metacognitions are not ‘good’: they simply express approval of a
certain style of thinking. Similarly, ‘negative’ metacognitions simply express
disapproval of thinking patterns or thoughts.
22
2F The Attention Training Technique and Situational Attentional
Refocusing
The Attention Training Technique (ATT) is an auditory task which
has been designed to strengthen one’s control over the focus of one’s
attention. Originally manually administered by a therapist, it is now
available online as an a udio file. It consists of clashing simultaneous
sounds, and instructions to focus one's attention on individual noises
alternately. It is to be practised twice daily (though Wells
acknowledges once daily is more likely).2 Keep a log of every time
you practise in your SA notebook.
In the case of social anxiety, increased attentional control means an
improved ability to direct attention outwards, onto others and the
interaction at hand, rather than focusing on oneself and one's
inhibition or apparent 'vulnerability' (see M isdirected Attention, 1D).
This dovetails nicely with another metacognitive technique,
Situational Attentional Refocusing ( SAR). SAR helps to reduce
self-focus and allow attention to be directed in a more helpful
manner. It consists merely of making an effort to focus one’s
attention externally in social situations, on the people to whom you’re
talking and on the social encounter at hand—that way you will learn
that the feared social situation in reality contains no threats. In
addition to this, it is important to cease anticipatory and post-event
processing (Section 1A): if you notice yourself beginning to ruminate
about a past or upcoming social situation, try to focus on neutral
aspects of the past or imagined environment. What was the weather
like? What top will your friend wear? Once you have done this,
disengage with the remembered or imagined scenario3.
2
It is important, when practising ATT, that one does not use it as an acute
coping strategy, either in order to avoid unwanted thoughts or to ‘prepare’
for a social situation.
3
In the case of anticipatory anxiety, consider completing one of the
worksheets provided in Section 2B.
23
Section Three
The techniques described in Section Two constitute the core
methods involved in overcoming social anxiety. In Section Three,
however, we will turn to examine complementary ways of dealing
with SA, which will not solve the problem on their own but which
may help you in your efforts to treat the problem: namely, meditation,
supplements and exercise.
24
3A Meditation
Meditation has been shown to be effective in reducing anxiety
generally, and has proved effective in alleviating social anxiety.
Clinical studies tend to follow the Mindfulness-Based Stress
Reduction (MBSR) paradigm developed by Dr Jon Kabat-Zinn, which
is outlined in layman’s terms in his book F ull Catastrophe Living. It is
not necessary to read this book before beginning to reap the benefits
of meditation, however: Headspace and similar apps can help you
start to establish a routine, as can the FAQ at /r/meditation.
A 2012 study found that ‘post-MBSR patients had decreased social
anxiety, depression, rumination, and state anxiety, as well as
increased self-esteem’. It went on to state that ‘mindfulness training
might attenuate avoidance’, a fact which ‘may be an important
mechanism that contributes to the success of exposure therapy for
SAD’. Meanwhile a nother study found that ‘MBSR completers
showed (a) increased self-esteem and decreased anxiety, (b)
increased positive and decreased negative self-endorsement, (c)
increased activity in a brain network related to attention regulation,
and (d) reduced activity in brain systems implicated in
conceptual-linguistic self-view.’
Another wrote that MBSR was ‘associated with reductions in social
anxiety and depression and increases in subjective well‐being, both
immediately post‐intervention and at 3 months post‐intervention’.
And finally a 2007 study recorded that MBSR ‘produced clinically
meaningful changes on measures of social anxiety, mood, disability
and quality of life’.
25
3B Supplements: Ashwagandha and L-Theanine
Please consult a medical professional to ensure that supplements will
not interact with medication you are currently taking, or adversely
affect you in any other way.
The following is based on information available at examine.com.
Ashwagandha is a herb that has been used for centuries in
Ayurvedic medicine, the traditional medicine of India. It has been
shown to provide a range of health benefits, some particular to men.
It is of significant use in the treatment of social anxiety. ‘In stressed
humans given 300mg of ashwagandha daily for 60 days, there have
been reported improvements in social functioning … which reached a
68.1% reduction in “social dysfunction”’ (examine.com).
Furthermore, ‘In chronically stressed persons, symptoms of
depression … have been noted to be reduced with 300mg of
ashwagandha daily over the course of 60 days by 77-79.2%. [10]‘
Examine.com concludes, ‘In regards to social interaction (a
mechanism related to serotonin neurotransmission and anxiety),
Ashwagandha appears to both inherently promote social interaction
as well as attenuate the negative effects that prolonged isolation has
on social function.’ Not all supplements are equal, however, and some
are entirely ineffective: look for KSM-66 Ashwagandha, which is the
gold standard. The wiki at / r/nootropics, and the whole sub, in fact,
are your friends4.
L-Theanine is one of the active ingredients found in green tea, and it
helps to promote relaxation. In order to consume the amount of
L-Theanine found in a 250mg supplement, however, one would need
to drink dozens of cups of tea. A research summary on examine.com
writes that people ‘with high baseline anxiety note benefits
4
They give a handy overview of reliable suppliers.
26
associated with relaxation’—but others do not. It concludes that
‘reductions of perceived stress have been reported in human subjects
given oral theanine at the standard dosages’.
27
3C Exercise
In addition to the widely-known benefits of exercise, regular
workouts have been shown to reduce anxiety in general, and social
anxiety specifically. A 2 012 study concluded that aerobic exercise
‘was associated with reductions in social anxiety and depression and
increases in subjective well‐being, both immediately post‐
intervention and at 3 months post‐intervention’. A meta-analysis
determined that exercise programmes need to last 10 weeks in order
to be effective in the reduction of anxiety, and that individual sessions
need to last over 21 minutes.
However, in the reduction of ‘anxiety sensitivity’ (fears of
anxiety‐related sensations), one study found that a ‘2-week protocol
consisting of six brief sessions that involved 20 min of exercise at
70% of HRmax [maximum heart rate] yielded large reductions in
anxiety sensitivity.’ Another concluded that ‘exercise has been shown
to be an effective and cost-efficient treatment alternative for a variety
of anxiety disorders.’ Although any exercise is better than none,
‘cardio’ work (exercise that gets you out of breath and increases your
heart-rate significantly) is best.
28
Donate
As someone who has struggled with anxiety myself, I knew I didn’t
want a nybody to be unable to access this document. Even though I
knew 95% of people could afford to pay a small price of a few dollars
or pounds or euro, I couldn’t bear to think that some people might not
be able to: and as a result, I’m sharing this freely online.
The thing is, I’m a really very broke college student and I’ve put a
huge amount of time into this: I’d be a grand or two richer if I’d spent
my time working a minimum-wage job instead of writing this for you.
So if you can spare anything—if you found this helpful or just
appreciate the effort I’ve made—please, please send some money my
way, at p aypal.me/socanxy. Think of how much a single session at a
psychotherapist’s office—not to mind a whole session of
treatment—would have set you back. So thank you all, and best of
luck!
d
onate at
paypal.me/socanxy
29
Further Reading
Self-Help
● Gillian Butler, Overcoming Social Anxiety and Shyness.
● Larry Cohen, Social Anxiety resources.
Overview of Treatment for Social Anxiety
● Stefan G. Hofmann and Michael W. Otto, Cognitive
Behavioral Therapy for Social Anxiety Disorder.
● Aaron T. Beck and David A Clark, Cognitive Therapy of
Anxiety Disorders: Science and Practice.
Metacognitive Therapy
● Peter Fisher and Adrian Wells, M etacognitive Therapy:
Distinctive Features.
● Adrian Wells, Metacognitive Therapy for Anxiety and
Depression.
Meditation
● reddit.com/r/meditation
● Jon Kabat-Zinn, Full Catastrophe Living.
● Bhante Gunaratana, M indfulness in Plain English.
Supplements
● examine.com
● reddit.com/r/nootropics