Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Pharmaceutical Development and Technology Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Leeds on 08/16/13
ABSTRACT
Over the last few years, oxygen scavengers have 4Fe þ 3O2 þ 6H2 O ! 4FeðOHÞ3
found an increasingly wide use in the food industry for
preservation of foods and beverages (1 –4). Mitsubishi ! 2ðFe2 O3 ·3H2 OÞ ð1Þ
Gas Corporation (Tokyo, Japan) introduced iron plus
various salt sachets as the first commercial oxygen 4FeðOHÞ2 þ O2 þ 2H2 O ! 4FeðOHÞ3
scavengers under the trade name Agelesse (5), while
similar products were introduced by Multisorb Tech- ! 2ðFe2 O3 ·3H2 OÞ ð2Þ
nologies, Inc. (formerly Multiform Desiccants, Inc.;
Buffalo, NY) under the trade name Fresh Paxe. The As can be seen, water must also be present for the
metal oxidation reaction with iron, the most commonly reaction to proceed. Water provides the activation
227
Copyright q 2002 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. www.dekker.com
228 Waterman and Roy
mechanism used in most applications. Scavengers are combination with secondary packaging was reported
generally stored dry where they can be handled without (15). In 1995, tonic solutions of vitamin C were
consuming oxygen. In the presence of moist foods, the stabilized using a bottle cap having an oxygen scavenger
scavengers are activated and begin removing oxygen. On covered with a polyolefin (16). The use of oxygen
the basis of the stoichiometry of the chemical reaction, scavengers with parenteral drug products has also been
300 cm3 of oxygen are consumed per gram of iron. This reported (17,18).
means that effectively 1500 cm 3 of air can be Oxygen induced drug degradation often limits shelf
deoxygenated by 1 gram of iron. Since the reaction is life (expiration date) or may render a drug unmarketable.
Pharmaceutical Development and Technology Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Leeds on 08/16/13
essentially irreversible, the air around these iron-based In fact, drug candidates that are highly oxygen sensitive
oxygen scavengers will eventually be virtually oxygen are often excluded from further development. In a
free. number of cases, oxygen sensitivity occurs only in the
Self-activated oxygen scavengers have been intro- presence of certain excipients. Since oxidation kinetics
duced to provide oxygen absorption with dry food are often non-Arrhenius in behavior, there are a number
products [see for example Refs. (6,7)]. These involve of drug candidates where the oxygen sensitivity of the
combining moisture-holding additives to the metals, drug is not recognized in accelerated aging studies and
usually iron, in sachets. Such additives include activated only becomes apparent in the later stages of drug
carbon, silica, zeolites, molecular sieves, hydrogels, and development. At that point, fixing the stability problem
diatomaceous earth. by reformulation and addition of antioxidants can require
Plastics containing oxygen scavengers have also considerable time and money, and may not be successful.
become increasingly prevalent in the new packaging In addition, more clinical data may be necessary with a
arena. The simplest of these “stealth scavengers” use the new formulation. Therefore, it can often be the case that
same metal oxidation process as above, but embed the use of a packaging option without reformulation for drug
For personal use only.
metal in an extrudable plastic [see for example Refs. stabilization is quite appealing.
(8,9)]. These are activated by moisture, generally by Even in early drug development, there is a need for
either being in direct contact with water or having a oxidation prevention with a new drug candidate to
permeable co-extruded layer adjacent to the water. provide adequate stability for initial studies without
Although these systems are relatively easy and investing significant resources prior to demonstrating a
inexpensive to make, they suffer from relatively low proof of concept. Once a candidate has been selected for
absorption capacity and high opacity. Another commer- further development, either use of oxygen scavengers or
cial option involves the use of ultraviolet photoinitiated more traditional stabilization methods can then be
oxygen-absorbing plastics (10,11). In these systems, incorporated. We have also found (as discussed below)
light in combination with a cobalt salt produces a radical that oxygen scavengers are useful in mechanistic
site, which has high reactivity with oxygen. Prior to investigations by verifying that the degradation pathway
photoinitiation, the system is quite stable in air and can is indeed oxidation.
be extruded to provide transparent, “active packaging.” We were interested in determining quantitatively the
The plastics are reported to be capable of consuming 45 – efficacy of oxygen scavengers in standard plastic
78 cm3 of oxygen per gram of plastic. packaging for solid dosage forms where the active
For pharmaceutical products, there have been only pharmaceutical ingredient (API) has a high sensitivity to
limited reports of using oxygen absorbers to stabilize oxygen. In prior, more qualitative publications, solid
drugs. For example, in 1984, tablets of an anti- dosage forms were stored in glass bottles rather than the
inflammatory drug were stabilized in large glass jars highly oxygen permeable plastic packaging common in
with oxygen absorbing sachets for six months at 508C pharmaceutical applications.
(12). The source of the oxygen being removed was There are three major sources of oxygen in the
primarily from the headspace and not from ingress since permeable bottles typically used in the pharmaceutical
the glass is essentially impermeable. Similarly, cold industry: (1) oxygen in the headspace, (2) oxygen that
remedy powders were stabilized in impermeable bottles permeates through the walls, and (3) leakage through the
by either nitrogen purging or with oxygen scavengers in bottle caps. The amount of oxygen contributed by the
the bottle (13). In a 1990 publication, L -cysteine in an three sources will vary with the size and shape of the
ophthalmic ointment was stored with an oxygen bottle, the type of cap and seal, the permeability of the
scavenger (14). In 1993, stabilization of dopamine bottle material, and the number of tablets in the bottle. To
formulations with oxygen scavengers (nonstandard) in eliminate oxygen ingress through the bottle cap, we
Stabilization by Oxygen Scavengers 229
chose to use heat-induction seal (HIS) closures (19). We drug was selected having a known oxidative degradation
have found that these provide essentially airtight seals in pathway. The oxidative degradation pathway for the anti-
an easy and practical manner. For these studies, round emetic drug candidate 1, as previously reported (22), is
bottles made of high-density polyethylene (HDPE) with shown in Sch. 1. Although the primary oxidative product
a labeled capacity of 60 cm3 and a wall thickness of of 1 is the imine 2, this material hydrolyzes readily,
0.9 mm (37 mils) were used. Oxygen permeability partly in the dosage form and partly during work-up to
through HDPE is reported to be 102 cm3 mm/(m2 d atm) give the two products 3 and 4, as shown. A second
in one publication (20) and 26.3 cm3 mm/(m2 d atm) in oxidative pathway involves the formation of the peroxide
Pharmaceutical Development and Technology Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Leeds on 08/16/13
another (21). To assure we have adequate oxygen 5, which decomposes slowly to the alcohol 6. There also
scavenging capacity, we will assume the higher value. appears to be an oxidation process converting 1 to the
The bottles used in this study were 4 cm in diameter and alcohol 6, which does not go through the intermediate 5.
7.3 cm in height giving an approximate surface area of We speculate that this latter process may be a metal-
100 cm2. With a maximum driving force for oxygen catalyzed oxidation with trace oxygen. Metal-catalyzed
ingress (i.e., zero oxygen inside, 0.21 atm oxygen outside oxidations of cumenes to alcohols have been reported in
the bottle), the amount of oxygen permeating into the the literature (23). In conducting these studies, excipients
bottle over a one-year period can be calculated as and processing conditions were chosen such that the drug
follows: was very prone to oxygen-based degradation. In addition,
storage conditions were used to accelerate the degra-
102 cm3 mm=ðm2 d atmÞ £ 0:21 atm £ 365 d dation, thereby accentuating the beneficial effects of
oxygen removal in a relatively short time. This study was
£ 0:01 m2 =0:9 mm therefore carried out to determine if indeed oxygen
scavengers could match the oxygen ingress rate and
For personal use only.
230
Scheme 1.
Oxidative degradation pathways for drug candidate 1.
Waterman and Roy
Stabilization by Oxygen Scavengers 231
Samples were prepared by placing the indicated In packaging tablets of an API with an oxygen
materials in round, white HDPE bottles (60-cc capacity) scavenger in common HDPE bottles with HIS closures,
and sealing with HIS closures (33/400) using a Enercon we hoped to determine whether oxygen scavengers
Industries Corp. (Tulsa, OK) demonstration unit could be a practical method for stabilizing pharmaceu-
induction sealer with a 1-sec dwell time at 80% output. tical formulations. Toward this end, we used three
Sample-1 (Control): 45 placebo tablets plus one tablet representative oxygen scavengers, all of the self-
Pharmaceutical Development and Technology Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Leeds on 08/16/13
containing 1 (no oxygen scavenger added) activating type. Each of these scavengers is designed
Sample 2: 45 placebo tablets plus one tablet for optimal performance at room temperature and above.
containing 1 and one 100 cm 3 Agelesse sachet Although oxygen scavengers that work optimally at
(Mitsubishi Gas Chemical Company, Tokyo). lower temperatures are available, for this and most
Sample 3: 45 placebo tablets plus one tablet drugs, low temperature stability is adequate even
containing 1 and two sachets of 50D Fresh Paxe (total without oxygen scavenging. Samples were stored
of 100 cm3 oxygen absorbing capacity; Multisorb under conditions designed to accentuate the oxidation
Technologies, Inc., Buffalo, NY). reaction as well as under control conditions (58C). It
Sample 4: 45 placebo tablets plus one tablet should be noted that the use of the 58C samples as
containing 1 and four ZPTJe sachets (total of 120 cm3 controls appears justified both because of similar
of oxygen absorbing capacity; Mitsubishi Gas Chemical impurity levels to the initial API and because of the
Company, Tokyo). observed 58C stability. Tablets were removed from the
packaging and analyzed at either 7 or 18 weeks. The
Stability Testing and Analysis results of this analysis are summarized in Table 1.
For personal use only.
Table 1
3
Stability of Compound 1 Packaged in 60 cm High-Density Polyethylene Bottles with Heat-Induction Seal Closures. Weight Percents
Refer to the Percent of the Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient (API) (1). Area Percents are the Percent of the Total Area
Product
Test Condition Weeks Wt% 3 Wt% 4 Area% 5 Wt% 6 Area%a Total Area%
API Initial 0 0.000 0.300 0.03 0.027 0.01 0.20
Pharmaceutical Development and Technology Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Leeds on 08/16/13
Table 2
Oxygen Levels in 60 cm3 High-Density Polyethylene Bottles with Heat-Induction Seal Closures After Storage
the majority of pharmaceutical products, oxidation be utilized such that single doses can be maintained
kinetics is also slowed at lower temperatures. In under anaerobic conditions.
packaging with the Fresh Paxe oxygen absorber, The use of oxygen scavengers is appealing for solving
oxygen levels in a bottle were measured after 24 hr stability issues with commercial products. Additionally,
at room temperature. The oxygen level was found this technology can readily be implemented with early
to be 80 ppm, indicative of the rapid rate that the drug development where a proof of concept for a drug
oxygen scavenger was able to consume the headspace can be established without having to modify a
oxygen. formulation as a solution to a stability problem. In the
Pharmaceutical Development and Technology Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Leeds on 08/16/13
In mechanistic investigations, it is often useful to event the drug progresses, it may be that a formulation
know whether oxygen is involved in the rate-limiting solution is still more desirable; however, the timesavings
step for degradation processes. Commonly, tests are involved in generating the proof of concept data may
conducted by degassing samples in bottles fitted with justify the use of scavengers in early development stages.
rubber septa. We have carried out a number of such
degassing experiments and have found that the level of
oxygen in bottles remains at 2 –3% after even several ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
hours of purging. Only with a vacuum step does the
level of oxygen drop much below 2 – 3%. In contrast, The authors would like to acknowledge the sugges-
oxygen scavengers achieve and maintain much lower tions and initial contacts for oxygen scavenger producers
oxygen levels in a facile packaging scheme, thereby from Dr. Karen Alsante and Mr. Robert Bergeson (at
providing an easy method for evaluating oxygen Pfizer). The assistance of Mr. Nimish Shah, a summer
sensitivity for drug substance, powder blends, com- intern who helped with this project, was essential in
pacts, and final dosage forms. By knowing the oxygen getting this work off the ground. Dr. Scott Smith and Mr.
For personal use only.
sensitivity at an early stage of development, it may be Hai Wang (at Pfizer) provided help in identifying a drug
possible to choose appropriate salt forms, excipients, formulation with the requisite instability issues. Dr. Joel
and processing conditions to minimize instability Hawkins (at Pfizer) helped with rationalizing some of the
issues. This information can also be useful in stability results. We would also like to acknowledge
determining which antioxidants are appropriate for Mitsubishi Gas Corp. and Multisorb Corp. for samples of
stabilization (26). their oxygen scavengers.
CONCLUSIONS REFERENCES
Self-activated, iron-based oxygen scavengers used 1. Schroeder, G. M. Oxygen Absorber Industry Overview:
Snapshot of Players and Markets, Conference Proceed-
widely in the food and beverage industries are quite
ings of Oxygen Absorbers 2001 and Beyond (Future-Pak
effective in stabilizing pharmaceutical formulations
Conferences), Chicago, June 9– 26, 2000.
through adaptations to common packaging systems, 2. Pruskin, L.R. Oxygen Absorbers Take Active Role in
provided the dosage form can tolerate relatively high Quality Packaging. Packaging Tech. Eng. 1996, July,
humidity. For a model drug compound, rapid oxidative 38 –43.
degradation is eliminated effectively by the addition of 3. Ahvenainen, R. Trends and Applications of Modified
the oxygen scavengers. These scavengers do not Atmosphere and Active Packaging Systems; Safety and
involve direct contact with the dosage form, and are Acceptability. VTT Biotechnology and Food Research.
expected to meet regulatory requirements for safety. VTT Symp. 1995, 148, 85 – 102.
Even with the permeable HDPE packaging commonly 4. Abe, Y. Active Packaging with Oxygen Absorbers. VTT
used in the pharmaceutical industry, the amount of Symp. 1994, 142, 209– 223.
5. Yoshikawa, Y.; Amemiya, A.; Komatsu, T.; Inoue, Y.;
scavenger needed for multi-year shelf life is manage-
Yuyama, M. Oxygen Absorbent for Food Packaging. Jpn.
able and will generally not add significantly to the cost
Kokai Tokkyo Koho Showa 56-33980, 1978.
of goods. 6. Yoshikawa, Y.; Nawata, T.; Komatsu, T.; Inoue, Y.;
Once a package is opened, the scavenger can be Kondo, Y.; Yuyama, M. Oxygen Absorbent. Jpn. Kokai
quickly consumed. Thus, a separate expiry period may be Tokkyo Koho, Showa 57-31449, 1980.
required for opened and closed bottles. Alternatively, 7. Kashiba, T. Oxygen Absorber and Method for Producing
blister packaging with oxygen absorption capacity could Same. US Patent 5,725,795, 1998.
234 Waterman and Roy
8. Oda, Y.; Maruhashi, Y. Co-extrusion Technology for 17. Gustafsson, B.; Lundmark, S.; Berglund, K.; Brooling, C.;
Oxygen Scavenging Packages. Polym., Laminations Skolling, O. Containers for Parenteral Fluids. US Patent
Coat. Conf. 1996, 1, 233– 240. 6,007,529, 1999.
9. Schmidt, S. L.; Lynch, B.; Barker, K.; Adams, R.; 18. Suzuki, T.; Isono, K. Medical Fluid-Filled Plastic
Agrawal, A.S. Enhanced Oxygen-Scavenging Polymers, Container and Methods for Making the Same. US Patent
and Packaging Made Therefrom. PCT Int. Appl. WO 4,998,400, 1991; 4,872,553, 1989.
38914, 1999. 19. Chookazian, M. Bonding Plastics by Induction Heating.
10. Ching, T. Y.; Cai, G.; Depree, C.; Galland, M. S.;
Soc. Plast. Eng. J. 1970, 26 (10), 49 – 53.
Goodrich, J. L.; Leonard, J. P.; Matthews, A.; Russell,
Pharmaceutical Development and Technology Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Leeds on 08/16/13
(1-Methylethyl)phenyl]methyl]-2-(Diphenylmethyl)-1-
14. Futagami, K.; Nakashima, K.; Kawashige, M.; Otubo, K.;
Azabicyclo[2.2.2]octan-3-amine with (1R)-(2)-10-Cam-
Nakao, Y.; Higuchi, S.; Aoyama, T. Study on the Stability
phorsulfonic Acid. US Patent 6,008,357, 1997.
of L -Cysteine Ophthalmic Solution. Kyushu Yakgakkai
25. Castello, R.A.; Mattocks, A.M. Discoloration of Tablets
Kaiho 1990, 44, 37 –41.
15. Mayers, C.L.; Jenke, D.R. Stabilization of Oxygen- Containing Amines and Lactose. J. Pharm. Sci. 1962, 51,
Sensitive Formulations via a Secondary Oxygen Scaven- 106– 108.
ger. Pharm. Res. 1993, 10 (3), 445– 448. 26. Waterman, K.C.; Adami, R.C.; Alsante, K.M.; Hong, J.;
16. Arai, M.; Kochi, S.; Kukita, T.; Urushizaki, Landis, M.S.; Lombardo, F.; Roberts, C.J. Stabilization of
F. Stabilization of Vitamin C in Tonic Solutions. Pharmaceuticals to Oxidative Degradation. Pharm. Dev.
Japanese Patent 0,722,3946, 1995. Technol. 2002, 7, 1 – 32.