Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Available at www.sciencedirect.com
Article history: A hybrid nanofiltration (NF) and reverse osmosis (RO) pilot plant was used to remove the
Received 30 September 2005 color and contaminants of the distillery spent wash. The feasibility of the membranes for
Received in revised form treating wastewater from the distillery industry by varying the feed pressure (0–70 bar) and
24 February 2006 feed concentration was tested on the separation performance of thin-film composite NF
Accepted 12 April 2006 and RO membranes. Color removal by NF and a high rejection of 99.80% total dissolved
Available online 6 June 2006 solids (TDS), 99.90% of chemical oxygen demand (COD) and 99.99% of potassium was
Keywords: achieved from the RO runs, by retaining a significant flux as compared to pure water flux,
Membrane which shows that membranes were not affected by fouling during wastewater run. The
Reverse osmosis pollutant level in permeates were below the maximum contaminant level as per the
Nanofiltration guidelines of the World Health Organization and the Central Pollution Control Board
Distillery specifications for effluent discharge (less than 1000 ppm of TDS and 500 ppm of COD).
Wastewater & 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Effluents
$
This article is Center of Excellence in Polymer Science Communication number 92.
Corresponding author. Fax: +91 836 2771275.
E-mail addresses: dr_kmhosamani@yahoo.com (K.M. Hosamani), aminabhavi@yahoo.com (T.M. Aminabhavi).
0043-1354/$ - see front matter & 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.watres.2006.04.022
ARTICLE IN PRESS
2350 WAT E R R E S E A R C H 40 (2006) 2349– 2356
(Sostar-Turka et al., 2005; Amjad, 1993; Lee and Leuptow, 2001; concentrations on membrane modules was investigated. The
Rautenbach et al., 2000; Townstand et al., 1992; Hoffman et al., results are presented for the waste effluent samples collected
1997). Most of the effluents from different industrial source from the local distillery industries.
were used to be discharged directly in the soil or in ground
water. But due to the stringent environmental restrictions,
CPCB has become more strict and has imposed very stringent 2. Materials and methods
norms. Worldwide scarcity of water is also another incentive
for recovering pure water from such industrial effluents. 2.1. Wastewater generation pattern in a distillery
However, for the treatment of an effluent by conventional
methods like aerobic and non-aerobic digestion, the ratio of Surface water is the source of raw water supply for distillery
biological oxygen demand (BOD) to COD should be 40.6 industries. Each liter of alcohol produced in India generates
(Chain and Dewalle, 1977). An effluent from the distillery about 15 L of spent wash. Even though wastewater is
industry has high BOD/COD, which would cause the destruc- generated at various stages of alcohol production, wastewater
tion of microorganisms that are useful in biodegradation. In from the fermenter sludge, spent wash and spent lees are the
their effort to conform to discharge norms, Indian distilleries main contributors to pollution and the generation involves
employ various forms of primary, secondary and tertiary three main steps, viz., feed preparation, fermentation and
treatment. The typical treatment sequence is screening or distillation, as shown in Fig. 1. In feed preparation, molasses
equalization, followed by biomethanation. The biometha- is diluted with water to obtain a feed containing 15–16%
nated effluent is occasionally subjected to a single- or two- sugar. The pH is adjusted, if required, by the addition of
stage aerobic treatment through the activated sludge (Malina sulfuric acid. Then, the diluted molasses solution is trans-
and Pohaland, 1992), trickling filters or even a second stage of ferred to a fermentation tank where it is inoculated with
anaerobic treatment in anaerobic lagoons. Ferti-irrigation and yeast, typically 10% by volume. The mixture is then allowed to
biocomposting with sugarcane press mud are the most widely ferment anaerobically under controlled conditions of tem-
used options for effluent disposal. However, these methods perature and pH. The process involves:
are highly energy intensive and hence quite expensive. These
disadvantages emphasized the need for further research (a) Conversion of sucrose to glucose and fructose:
using novel separation methods. In this situation, mem- Invertase
C12 H22 O11 þ H2 O ! C6 H12 O6 þ C6 H12 O6 . (1)
brane-based separation techniques such as RO and NF would
yield excellent results when applied (Noble and Stern, 1995;
Rautenbach and Albrecht, 1989). The effectiveness of NF (b) Fermentation of glucose to alcohol, releasing carbon
membrane processes in water and wastewater treatment is dioxide and heat:
generally acknowledged and has now become the most Zymase
C12 H12 O6 þ H2 O ! 2C2 H5 OH þ 2CO2 þ 23:5 kcal: (2)
reliable standard technique. Hybrid techniques are also quite
popular. The main objective of this study was to purify the
distillery wastewater by removing the color and the con- Once the fermentation is complete, yeast is separated by
taminants by the combined use of NF and RO hybrid process. settling and the cell-free broth is taken for distillation.
The effect of process variables such as feed pressure and feed Distillation proceeds with heating the cell-free fermented
Distilled Yeasts
Molassese
CO2
Rectifying
Column Alcohol
55%
Free Analyser Column
Fermenter Fermenter
Spent Wash
Spent less
broth to about 90 1C, and is sent to the de-gasifying section of using sodium hydroxide. The neutralized solution has a lot of
the analyzer column. The bubble cap fractionating column suspended solids, so the filtration was carried out to remove
removes any trapped gases (CO2, etc.) from the liquor, which the suspended particles with a fine-pore thin cloth. This pre-
is then steam heated and fractionated to give 40% alcohol. filtrate was used as feed.
The bottom discharge from the analyzer column is the main
effluent, spent wash. Water consumption in process applica- 2.4. Pilot plant description
tions like yeast propagation, molasses preparation, steaming,
etc., is in the range of 14.5–21.4 L/L of alcohol production. A pilot-scale skid-mounted system as shown schematically in
Water consumption in non-process applications such as Fig. 2 was built by incorporating a commercial TFC polyamide
cooling water, steam generation, making potable liquor etc., RO membrane with an inlet operating pressure of 400 psi and
is much higher, i.e., ranging between 102.65 and 240 L/L of TFC NF with an inlet pressure of 300 psi inside an FRP
alcohol production. cylindrical pressure vessel; 2.5 inches diameter 21 inches
length was the size of each module. A feed tank of 30 L
2.2. Materials capacity made of stainless steel-316 was provided for storage
and supply of effluent to the system as well as collection of
The commercial NF and thin-film composite (TFC) polyamide the recycled concentrate. A cooling coil was installed inside
RO membrane in spiral wound configuration was purchased the feed tank for circulating cold water to maintain constant
from Permionics, Vadodara, India. The membrane was feed temperature within the range of 27–29 1C. A high-
specified for seawater desalination with catalogue designa- pressure pump capable of maintaining a pressure of 100 bar
tion Perma PPT-9908, effective area 2.5 m2, module length was installed for transporting the feed liquid throughout the
40 inches and diameter 2.4 inches. The pure water flux was system. A 2 HP single-phase motor ran the pump. A restrict-
specified to be 90 L/(h m2) at 55.2 bar feed pressure and 25 1C. ing needle valve was provided on the concentrate outlet of the
The standard NaCl salt rejection under these conditions was membrane pressure vessel to pressurize the feed liquid to a
99.4% for 32,000 ppm feed concentration for the pH range of desired value, as indicated by a pressure gauge installed at the
2–11 for the operation. upstream of the valve.
The effluent sample was collected from the S.L.N Dis- Permeate and concentrate flow rates were measured by two
tilleries, Garag, Dharwad, India. Tetrasodium EDTA, hydro- glass rotameters containing metal floats. An adjustable safety
chloric acid and sodium bisulfate for membrane cleaning and valve was fixed on the pump discharge line to prevent the
storage were purchased from S.D. Fine Chemicals, Mumbai, system pressure from exceeding the maximum desired value
India. KCl and NaCl for the atomic absorption spectrometer (70 bar). All the accessories were connected by the 0.5 inches
(AAS) standard preparation were obtained from Himedia, outer-diameter stainless steel-316 piping in the high-pressure
Mumbai, India, and all were of analytical grade. Deionized region, whereas the low-pressure outlets from concentrate
water for cleaning and analytical standards preparation was and permeate sections were made of PVC braided tubing.
generated from the same RO system.
2.5. Experimental procedure and sampling
2.3. Pre-treatment
Thirty liters of the pretreated feed was poured in the feed
The effluent collected from the distillery industry is highly tank after thoroughly cleaning the membrane systems and
acidic with a pH range of around 3. Hence, it was neutralized wetting with deionized water. The high-pressure pump was
2 3 3
Retentate
Pump
NF Permeate
6
2 3 4
3 RO Permeate
Pump
1 2
1. Feed 4. NF module
2. Control valve 5. RO module
3. Pressure guage 6. Thermocouple
employed to transport the feed to the spiral wound mem- the membrane. Fouling layers are removed by using appro-
brane module and the system pressure was adjusted at a priate cleaning procedures. The most common procedures
value greater than the osmotic pressure, by means of a are by using caustic detergent for the removal of dirt, oils and
restricting needle valve. With a control valve, the retentate colloidal material, acids for metal hydroxides, and oxidizing
flow rate was maintained constant (10 L/min) throughout the agents for adsorbed organics. A dosage of 10 ppm of sodium
experiments, to ensure the steady hydrodynamic conditions hexametaphosphate antiscalant to the RO feed helped in
inside the membrane module. The feed pressure was varied preventing CaSO4 scaling.
from 0 to 70 bar and keeping the feed TDS concentration (for The CaCO3 scaling was controlled by treating the mem-
NF 206,000 ppm and for RO 10,000 ppm) constant, permeate brane at the end of the day’s study with an acid solution (HCl,
samples were collected after 10 min with every 6.9 bar pH ¼ 2), which converts the carbonate to CO2 and also
increase in the feed pressure. Flux was noted by collecting removes other metal precipitates and mineral scales. Wash-
the permeate in a measuring jar for a period of 2–3 min. ing with a 1% aqueous solution of tetrasodium EDTA, a
Around 300–400 mL of permeate was collected in each chelating agent useful in removing organics and silt, was
pressure increase for a thorough analysis. The experiment done on alternate days. To prevent biological fouling, the
was repeated twice with every feed sample for reproducibility membrane was washed thoroughly with deionized water and
of the permeate characteristics. stored in a 0.5% solution of sodium bisulfate (NaHSO3) at the
end of the experimental runs. The above methods were
2.6. Analytical methods efficient in restoring the water flux.
V
J¼ . (4)
At Table 1 – Characteristic contaminants of distillery spent
wash
pH 3.0
Fouling of the membrane surface is the bane of membrane
Color Dark brown
operations. The concentration of calcium in the form of Conductivity (mS/cm) 346
carbonate and sulfate and hardness in the distillery effluent TDS (mg/L) 51,500
was reasonably high, which would cause scale formation on COD (mg/L) 100,000
the membrane surface, thereby causing subsequent fouling. Potassium (mg/L) 2050
There are two types, colloidal flocculation or inorganic scaling Chloride (mg/L) 4900
Parameter
pH 6.5–7.5
Color Colorless
Conductivity (mS/cm) 15.06
TDS (mg/L) 9050
COD (mg/L) 2900
Potassium (mg/L) 1750
Chloride (mg/L) 2650
in the colloidal size range. As the distillery wastewater has a 3.2. RO experiments
very dark brown color, the pre-treated effluent samples free
from suspended particles were used as feed for the NF RO is suitable for the remaining ions and larger species from
experiment with the characteristics as shown in Table 1. Fig. 3 dye bath effluents. Several parameters have been studied
displays the screening of six samples with numbers starting here.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
2354 WAT E R R E S E A R C H 40 (2006) 2349– 2356
Fig. 8 – Variation in TDS concentration as a function of Fig. 10 – Variation in potassium concentration as a function
pressure for RO process. of pressure for RO process.
3.2.1. Effect of feed pressure on permeate characteristics to 70 bar. Even though small decline in flux rate of pure water
Effect of pressure on the removal efficiency of different ions was obtained, the comparison shows that the performance of
through RO module is shown in Table 3. A comparison of pure the membrane was not affected by the fouling phenomenon.
water flux with feed flux shown in Fig. 7 clearly demonstrates Figs. 8 and 9, respectively, show that the amount of TDS in the
the effect of osmotic pressure in RO transport. The flux for permeate reduced drastically, while COD decreased about 20-
distillery spent wash feed increased almost linearly from 20 fold. The percent rejection of TDS increased from 83 to 99.06,
ARTICLE IN PRESS
WAT E R R E S E A R C H 4 0 (200 6) 234 9 – 235 6 2355
4. Conclusions
Hosamani thanks the Department of Science and Technology, Malina, F.J., Pohaland, F.G., 1992. Design of anaerobic process for
New Delhi, India (Grant no. SR/S1/OC-08/2005), for financial the treatment of industrial and municipal wastes. Water Qual.
support. Manage. 7, 1–10.
Narkis, N., Rebhun, M., 1975. The mechanism of flocculation
processes in the presence of humic substances. J. Am. Water
R E F E R E N C E S
Works Assoc. 67, 101.
Noble, R.D., Stern, S.A., 1995. Membrane Separation Technology:
Principles and Applications. Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Amjad, Z. (Ed.), 1993. Reverse Osmosis: Membrane Technology, Rautenbach, R., Albrecht, R., 1989. Membrane Processes. Wiley,
Water Chemistry and Industrial Applications. Van Nostrand Chichester.
Reinhold, New York. Rautenbach, R., Linn, T., Eilers, L., 2000. Treatment of severely
Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB). Annual Report. New contaminated waste water by a combination of RO, high
Delhi, India, 2002–03. pressure reverse osmosis and nanofiltration potential and
Chain, E.S.K., Dewalle, F.B., 1977. Treatment of high strength limits of the process. J. Memb. Sci. 174, 231.
acidic wastewater with completely mixed anaerobic filter. Sekar, D., Murthy, D.V.S., 1998. Colour removal of distillery
Water Res. 11, 295. spentwash by adsorption technique. Ind. Chem. Eng. A 40, 367.
Hall, E.S., Packham, R.F., 1965. Coagulation of organic color with Sostar-Turka, S., Simonic, M., Petrinic, I., 2005. Wastewater
hydrolyzing coagulants. J. Am. Water Works Assoc. 57, treatment after reactive printing. Dyes Pigments 64, 147–152.
1149. Townstand, R.B., Neytzelle-de welde, F.G., Buckley, C.A., Turpie,
Hoffman, J.A.M.H., Beerendonk, E.F., Folmer, H.C., Kruithof, J.C., D.W.F., Steenkamp, C., 1992. The use of dynamic membranes
1997. Removal of pesticides and other micropollutants with for treatment of wool scouring and textile dyeing effluents.
severe fouling and sealing potential. Desalination 113, Water SA 18 (2), 81.
209–214. Uppal, J., 2004. Water utilization and effluent treatment in the
Lee, S., Leuptow, R.M., 2001. Reverse osmosis filtration for space Indian alcohol industry—an overview. In: Proceedings of the
mission wastewater: membrane properties and operating Indo–EU workshop on Promoting Efficient Water Use in Agro-
conditions. J. Memb. Sci. 182, 77. Based Industries, New Delhi, India, 15–16 January 2004.