You are on page 1of 1

I had a thought that complements the posted solution to Exercise 12.

10 –
namely what thinking of the dxdy as dx∧dy gets you. (This may be part of
what Penrose had in mind for this exercise.)

Let x = r cos ϕ, y = r sin ϕ, so

dx ∧ dy = (cos ϕdr − r sin ϕdϕ) ∧ (sin ϕdr + r cos ϕdϕ)


= r(cos ϕ)2 dr ∧ dϕ − r(sin ϕ)2 dϕ ∧ dr
= rdr ∧ dϕ

In short, the antisymmetry generates the Jacobean, which is a determinant,


ie, an antisymnmetric sum of products

You might also like