You are on page 1of 13

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/7462148

Living high-training low: Tolerance and acclimatization in elite endurance


athletes

Article  in  European Journal of Applied Physiology · February 2006


DOI: 10.1007/s00421-005-0065-9 · Source: PubMed

CITATIONS READS

66 675

9 authors, including:

Julien V Brugniaux Laurent Schmitt


Université Grenoble Alpes National Ski-Nordic Centre, Premanon, France
55 PUBLICATIONS   1,933 CITATIONS    62 PUBLICATIONS   1,780 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Jean-Paul Richalet
Université Paris 13 Nord,
313 PUBLICATIONS   7,208 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Point- Counterpoint J Appl Physiol: hypobaric vs. Normobaric hypoxia View project

Effectiveness of altitude/hypoxic training in elite athletes View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Julien V Brugniaux on 26 November 2014.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Eur J Appl Physiol (2006) 96: 66–77
DOI 10.1007/s00421-005-0065-9

O R I GI N A L A R T IC L E

Julien V. Brugniaux Æ Laurent Schmitt Æ Paul Robach


Hervé Jeanvoine Æ Hugues Zimmermann
Gérard Nicolet Æ Alain Duvallet
Jean-Pierre Fouillot Æ Jean-Paul Richalet

Living high-training low: tolerance and acclimatization


in elite endurance athletes
Accepted: 12 September 2005 / Published online: 26 October 2005
 Springer-Verlag 2005

Abstract The ‘‘living high-training low’’ (LHTL) model Signs of ventilatory acclimatization were present imme-
is frequently used to enhance aerobic performance. diately after training (increased HVRe and decreased
However, the clinical tolerance and acclimatization DSaO2e) and had disappeared 15 days later. In conclu-
process to this intermittent exposure needs to be exam- sion, LHTL was well tolerated and compatible with
ined. Forty one athletes from three federations (cross- aerobic training. Comparison of the three patterns of
country skiers, n=11; swimmers, n=18; runners, n=12) training suggests that a LHTL session should not exceed
separately performed a 13 to 18-day training at the 3,000 m, for at least 18 days, with a minimum of
altitude of 1,200 m, by sleeping either at 1,200 m (CON) 12 h day1 of exposure.
or in hypoxic rooms (HYP), with an O2 fraction corre-
sponding to 2,500 m (5 nights for swimmers and 6 for Keywords Intermittent hypoxia Æ Hypoxic ventilatory
skiers and runners), 3,000 m (6 nights for skiers, 8 for response Æ Cardiac function Æ Leukocyte count Æ
swimmers and 12 for runners) and 3,500 m (6 nights for Nocturnal arterial saturation
skiers). Measurements performed before, 1 or 15 days
after training were ventilatory response (HVRe) and
desaturation (DSaO2e) during hypoxic exercise, an Introduction
evaluation of cardiac function by echocardiography, and
leukocyte count. Lake Louise AMS score and arterial O2 Intermittent exposure to hypoxia has been proposed as a
saturation during sleep were measured daily for HYP. new technique for altitude training. This method namely
Subjects did not develop symptoms of AMS. Mean ‘‘living high-training low’’ (LHTL) consists of combin-
nocturnal SaO2 decreased with altitude down to 90% at ing acclimatization at moderate altitude with low alti-
3,500 m and increased with acclimatization (except at tude training (Levine et al. 1991). The aim of this
3,500 m). Leukocyte count was not affected except at technique is to enhance erythrocyte volume while keep-
3,500 m. The heart function was not affected by LHTL. ing similar training load than at sea level. LHTL has
been shown to enhance aerobic performance and red cell
mass (Levine and Stray-Gundersen 1992; Levine and
Julien V. Brugniaux (&) Æ L. Schmitt Æ A. Duvallet Stray-Gundersen 1997). However, there is no clear
J.-P. Fouillot Æ Jean-Paul Richalet
Laboratoire ‘‘Réponses cellulaires et fonctionnelles à l’hypoxie’’ consensus, since other studies did not find any
EA2363, ARPE, UFR SMBH, Université Paris 13, 74 rue Marcel improvement neither in performance (Hahn et al. 2001),
Cachin, 93017 Bobigny cedex, France nor in red cell mass (Ashenden et al. 1999). Despite the
E-mail: jbrugniaux@free.fr lack of evidence of a clear efficiency of LHTL, more and
Tel.: +33-1-48387757
Fax: +33-1-48387777 more endurance athletes use it by their own means, with
personal hypoxic tents or rooms. Moreover a miscon-
G. Nicolet Æ L. Schmitt ception wants that the higher the altitude, the more
Centre National de Ski Nordique, 39220 Premanon, France efficient it is, leading some athletes to sleep in severe
Paul Robach
hypoxia without any medical control.
Ecole National de Ski et d’Alpinisme, 74401 Chamonix, France Exposure to hypoxia from hours to days may lead to
several clinical conditions, which could impede the effi-
H. Jeanvoine cacy of a training session. Only few studies focused on
Hopital de St Claude, 39200 St Claude, France the effects of intermittent exposure to altitude on cardiac
Hugues Zimmermann function, while it is well established for years that
Hôpital de Champagnole, 39300 Champagnole, France chronic hypoxia may lead to cardiac morphological
67

changes such as right ventricular hypertrophy associated The first study with cross-country skiers took place
with an increase in pulmonary arterial pressure (Hult- during the summer 2002. The second study with swim-
gren and Miller 1965). Hypoxia is known to suppress the mers was realized during the winter 2002–2003. The last
immune status (Pyne et al. 2000), which may predispose study, on runners, was performed during the autumn
the athletes to infections. Acute mountain sickness 2003. Modifications in procedures took into account the
(AMS), characterized by headache, sleep disturbances, results of the preceding study.
fatigue and nausea may also interfere in the first few This work is part of a multicenter study sponsored by
days of training during altitude exposure. the International Olympic Committee and the French
On the other hand, exposure to hypoxia induces Ministry of Sports. The Ethics Committee of Paris
acclimatization through an enhancement of the hypoxic Necker Hospital approved these studies, and all subjects
ventilatory response (HVR), as reported during chronic gave their voluntary written informed consent to par-
(Forster et al. 1971; Sato et al. 1994) or intermittent ticipate in the protocol.
(Katayama et al. 1998) hypoxia. An increase in venti-
lation at altitude counterbalances oxygen desaturation
and therefore improves oxygen transport and aerobic Subjects (Table 1)
performance (Richalet et al. 2002). This augmentation of
HVR due to acclimatization persists for a few days after For each study, subjects were divided in two groups, a
the return to normoxia, and then fades away (Sato et al. LHTL group (HYP) and a Control group (CON). After
1994). HVR has been shown to increase with intermit- the determination
 of maximal oxygen uptake
tent hypoxia (Katayama et al. 1998; Townsend et al. V_ O2 max at the altitude of 1,200 m, the subjects were
2002), but to our knowledge only Townsend et al. (2002) of equivalent V_ O2 max randomly assigned to the two
focused on de-acclimatization after LHTL and found a fitness-matched groups.
time-dependent increase in HVR for endurance athletes,
which persisted 2 days after the end of the session. Cross-country skiers
Several factors can influence the efficacy of a LHTL
training session. A debate is currently going on about Eleven athletes from the ‘‘Fédération Française de Ski
the optimal duration, the level of altitude, the duration Nordique’’ (seven biathletes, two nordic-combined ski-
of daily exposure and the optimal delay between the ers and two cross country skiers) were divided in two
training session and the programmed competitions. groups: control group (CONcs, n=5) and hypoxic
Furthermore, national and international sports institu- group (HYPcs, n=6). There were three female athletes
tions may address ethical aspects of LHTL training and in each group. Athletes participated either in the World
may be interested in evidence based presence or absence Cup or in the European Cup.
of detrimental or ergogenic effects of such training
procedures. Swimmers
The main objective of this study is to determine the
influence of factors such as the degree and duration of Eighteen national level from the ‘‘Fédération Française
hypoxia on the balance between beneficial effects of de Natation’’ divided in two groups of nine subjects with
LHTL and potentially detrimental effects of hypoxia. one female in each group: control group (CONs, n=9)
More specifically and hypoxic group (HYPs, n=9). Swimmers partici-
1. Is LHTL tolerated by athletes to allow an important pated either in International (World and European cup)
training load (i.e. up to 3h 30 per day)? or National trials.
2. How daily and/or total exposure to hypoxia do affect
ventilatory acclimatization and clinical status? Runners
3. Does the probable increase in HVRe persist 15 days
after the end of the session, and do the possible Twelve elite from the ‘‘Fédération Française d’Athlé-
harmful effects disappear 15 days after the end of tisme’’ were divided in two groups of six male subjects:
LHTL? control group (CONr, n=6) and hypoxic group (HYPr,
n=6). They participated either in International (World
and European cup) or National trials.
Methods
Cross-country skiers and swimmers had some expe-
This work is composed of three studies based on the rience of altitude training. They used to train for short
LHTL model described by Levine et al. (1991). Three sessions at moderate altitude but they had never used
different populations of elite athletes were studied: cross- this technique before. Runners had no experience with
country skiers, swimmers and runners. Subjects were altitude training. All athletes were unacclimatized to
classified as elite by their participation to national and high altitude before coming to Prémanon, they had not
international competition and were registered on a na- been exposed to altitudes higher than 1,500 m at least in
tional list including all French elite athletes. the month preceding the study.
68

Table 1 Anthropometric characteristics and V_ O2 max of the subjects

Group Cross-country skiers Swimmers Runners

CONcs (n=5) HYPcs (n=6) CONs (n=9) HYPs (n=9) CONr (n=6) HYPr (n=6)

Age (years) 20±1.8 23±3.9 17±0.6 20±3.2** 23±1.5 25±5.2


Weight (kg) 63.6±5.8 67.2±8.7 67.6±6.4 70.8±8.8 63.5±5.8 64.9±5.0
Height (cm) 173.8±5.1 174.5±6.1 180.3±6.8 178.9±4.7 178.2±4.6 176.1±5.2
V_ O2 max (ml min1 kg1) 58.6±8.7 59.7±6.3 58.5±1.9 57.9±1.9 63.3±4.2 63.3±2.5

Values are means ± SD


**P<0.05 HYP vs. CON. V_ O2 max : maximal oxygen uptake

Study design (Table 2) The training session for the cross-country skiers was
composed of three levels of altitude of six nights (and
All the studies were led in the ‘‘Centre National de Ski days) each. Altitudes were 2,500, 3,000 and 3,500 m.
Nordique’’ (CNSN) of Prémanon, Jura, FRANCE. It Athletes spent 11 h day1 in their hypoxic rooms (Ta-
consisted in three major phases: pre-training, training ble 2). For the swimmers, the session was composed of 5
and post-training. Evaluations were conducted at nights of pre-acclimatization at 2,500 m and 8 nights at
Prémanon (1,200 m), before (PRE), at the end (POST1) 3,000 m. Mean time spent in hypoxic rooms was
of the training session and/or 15 days after the training 16 h day1 (Table 2). Finally for the runners, we used
session (POST2). the same altitudes as for study 2 but pre-acclimatization
lasted 6 nights at 2,500 m followed by 12 nights at
3,000 m. Subjects spent 14 h day-1 in hypoxic rooms
Pre-training period (Table 2).
Athletes went to Prémanon (1,200 m) during the aerobic
preparation period of their competitive season, i.e. at the Post-training period
beginning of a new season. This period stands at least
2 months after the end of their respective national or After the training session at Prémanon, subjects con-
international cup and/or championship. The 3–4 days of tinued to have controlled training activities at home, i.e.
the Pre-training period were devoted to pre tests (PRE). near sea level. Athletes came back to Prémanon 15 days
Echocardiography, blood sampling and performance after the end of LHTL training for 3 days to perform the
tests were realized first. Then, the HVRe test was per- POST2 tests, identical to those realized at PRE and/or at
formed. POST1. Our tests were performed during the first two
days of POST2 (as in PRE and POST1). Athletes con-
tinued to have light training activities during the POST2
Training session measurements.
It was based on the LHTL model with incremental
altitude depending on the study groups and the duration Training quantification
of the session (13 days for swimmers or 18 days for
cross-country skiers and for runners). Altitudes ranged The quantification of the training stimulus, in term of
between 2,500 and 3,500 m. At POST1 some tests were volume and intensity, was determined in experiments
realized as at PRE. according to the method of Mujika et al. (1996). Briefly,

Table 2 Summary of procedures

Study PRE 2,500 m 3,000 m 3,500 m POST1 POST2


(before the session) (end of the session) (15 days after the end)

Cross-country Blood sampling 6 nights 6 nights 6 nights Blood sampling Blood sampling
skiers (n=11) Echocardiography 11 h day1 11 h day1 11 h day1 Echocardiography
V_ O2 max test HVRe test in hypoxia in hypoxia in hypoxia HVRe test
Swimmers (n=18) Blood sampling 5 nights 8 nights Blood sampling Blood sampling
Echocardiography 16 h day-1 16 h day-1 Echocardiography
V_ O2 max test HVRe test in hypoxia in hypoxia HVRe test
Runners (n=12) Blood sampling 6 nights 12 nights Blood sampling Blood sampling
Echocardiography 14 h day1 14 h day1 Echocardiography
V_ O2 max test HVRe test in hypoxia in hypoxia HVRe test

PRE: 3–4 days preceding the beginning of the session. POST1: 1–2 days following the end of the session. POST2: 3 days holding 15 days
after the end of the session
AMS (CON, HYP) and nocturnal SaO2 (HYP) were measured daily for each study. V_ O2 max : maximal oxygen uptake test; HVRe
hypoxic ventilatory response at exercise
69

before the experiments, during a routine incremental test Nocturnal arterial O2 saturation (SaO2)
to exhaustion, lactate concentrations were measured.
We determined five levels of lactate concentration (2, The nocturnal SaO2 was monitored in HYP subjects
4, 6, 10 and 16 mmol l1) corresponding to five levels during the last night in normoxia (basal values) and
training load (I, II, III, IV and V). Each level of lactate during all the nights of the training session using a finger
concentration corresponded to a level of heart rate pulse oximeter (NPB 290 Nellcor Puritan Bennett, Ire-
which was used to control workload in the field during land). Nocturnal SaO2 values presented were mean of
all the duration of our experiments. This model, which values recorded every minute while in bed after turning
originally determined the training load by multiplying the light off.
the intensity with the number of kilometers swam, can
also be applied while running. CON and HYP group Leukocyte count
always trained together; hence training load was quan-
titatively and qualitatively equivalent between CON and Leukocyte count of all subjects of the three studies was
HYP groups in each study. determined at PRE, POST1 and POST2 in a blood sample
obtained from an antecubital vein (Pentra 120 analyzer,
ABX, Montpellier, France). Blood sampling moments
Hypoxic rooms
were standardized, i.e. around 8:00 in the morning.
The normobaric hypoxia was obtained by extracting Echocardiography
oxygen from ambient air (OBS, Husøysund, Norway).
Altitudes of 2,500, 3,000 and 3,500 m were obtained A trained cardiologist used an ultrasound imager (So-
with an O2 fraction (FIO2) corresponding to 0.174, noheart, Sonosite, Bothell, WA, USA) to evaluate the
0.164 and 0.154 respectively. Calculation of the FIO2 resting cardiac morphological changes at PRE (for all
corresponding to the required altitudes took into studies), POST1 (for swimmers and runners) or POST2
account the altitude of Prémanon. Since the gas com- (for cross-country skiers). Complete two-dimensional,
position was continuously monitored, O2 fraction was TM-echography and Doppler parameters for left cardiac
permanently adjusted along the session and was kept function were recorded following classical procedures:
stable. Moreover it was verified that opening the door aorta, left atrium, left ventricle diastolic and systolic
of the room slowly for few seconds, even many times diameters, mitral flow velocities and cardiac output.
per day did not change FIO2. For safety reasons, O2 Tricuspid regurgitation (TR) was detected by color-flow
and CO2 compositions were monitored. Similarly Doppler on 4-chamber apical or modified parasternal
arterial O2 saturation of each subject, obtained by views. TR peak velocity was measured by continuous-
transcutaneous oximetry (see Measurements), was wave Doppler. A systolic (PAPs) pulmonary arterial
also monitored. Each room was connected to a central pressure was calculated by adding the right atrial pres-
monitoring room under the control of a medical sure (taken as 5 mm Hg) to the right atrium–right ven-
doctor. tricle gradient. Pressure gradients between the right
atrium and the right ventricle were then calculated by
the Bernoulli equation: DP=4V2. For technical reasons,
Measurements PAPs was not measured for swimmers and RV Sys was
not measured for cross-country skiers. This technique of
Complete results concerning performance and hemato- echocardiography has previously been used by our team
logical changes (red cell mass, hematocrit, hemoglobin) in field conditions (Richalet et al. 2005).
for these three studies will be presented elsewhere and
have been partly published in abstracts (Robach et al. Performance and hematology
2002, 2005; Brugniaux et al. 2005). A brief summary of
the results will be given here. We chose a trial corresponding to the speciality of ath-
letes, using a treadmill for cross-country skiers and
Acute mountain sickness (AMS) runners and a test in swimming pool for swimmers.
Hemoglobin and hematocrit were assessed by blood
Acute mountain sickness was evaluated daily in the early sampling and red cell volume was determined by a CO-
morning using the Lake Louise questionnaire (The Lake dilution method. The methods of measurements for
Louise consensus 1992). Questions are divided in two V_ O2 max and hematological parameters will be de-
parts: AMS self-assessment (headache, gastrointestinal scribed elsewhere.
symptoms, fatigue, dizziness and sleep disturbances) and
clinical assessment (ataxia and dyspnea). AMS self- Hypoxic ventilatory response at exercise (HVRe)
assessment symptoms were ranked from 0 to 3 for each
item. For example concerning sleep disturbances, 0 Hypoxic ventilatory response at exercise was determined
represents normal sleep while 3 corresponds to very poor at PRE (for all studies), POST1 (for swimmers and
sleep. runners) and POST2 (for cross-country skiers). This test
70

is a submaximal exercise test performed at a power both studies for CON groups. Red cell volume was
output corresponding to 30% of the normoxic V_ O2 max globally not modified among HYP groups, except for
measured before the training session. We used a slightly swimmers in which it increased by 8.5% at POST1 vs.
modified test previously described by Richalet et al. PRE. Red cell volume tended to decrease at POST2 for
(1988) which is composed of four phases of 5 min each: CONcs. In the same time plasma volume was not
rest in normoxia, rest in hypoxia (corresponding to modified between groups or along with each study.
11.5% of oxygen in gas mixture, i.e. 4,800 m), exercise in Hemoglobin and hematocrit were globally not modified
hypoxia (11.5% of oxygen in gas mixture), exercise in along with the sessions in all studies.
normoxia. In our studies, oxygen fraction in gas mixture
was determined taking into account the altitude of
Training
Prémanon (1,200 m). Three parameters were monitored:
heart
 rate  (HR, bpm), pulmonary ventilation
In each study, training volume as well as intensity were
V_E ; l min1 and arterial O2 saturation (SaO2, %). HR
kept equivalent in both groups (results not shown).
was continuously recorded with a numeric S810 Polar
Training stimulus was decreased over the 15-day period
Recorder (Polar, Kempele, Finland). Data were trans-
between the end of the LHTL session and the POST2
ferred by telemetry to a computer, via a RS 232 Polar
measurements. Around two-thirds of the training con-
interface, for further analysis with the Polar precision
sisted in endurance training at relatively low heart rate
performanceTM SW4 software. SaO2 was measured by
(below 75% of maximal heart rate) and without accu-
an ear lobe pulse oximeter (Ohmeda Biox 3740, Louis-
mulation of lactate (i.e. intensity I and II). The last third
ville, USA). Pulmonary ventilation was recorded breath
of the training program was performed above the onset
by breath and averaged every 30 seconds (CPX/D car-
of blood lactate accumulation (development of anaero-
diopulmonary exercise system; Medical Graphics, Min-
bic endurance and speed/weight lifting exercises).
neapolis, MN, USA). Calculated parameters were:
Hypoxic Ventilatory Response at exercise (HVRe),
Hypoxic Cardiac Response at exercise (HCRe) and de- Acute mountain sickness (Lake Louise Score)
saturation at exercise (DSaO2e) (Richalet et al. 1988) (see
below for the calculation formulas of DSaO2e, HVRe Whatever the study and/or the group of subjects con-
and HCRe). sidered, nobody developed acute mountain sickness.
Analysis of the responses to the AMS questionnaire
demonstrates that the subjects did not complain of
Statistical analysis headache, gastrointestinal symptoms, dizziness or ataxia
and dyspnea. However fatigue and sleep disturbances
All data are expressed as mean ± SD. Given the small were frequently mentioned but without any significant
number of subjects in each group we used non-para- difference between hypoxic and control groups. The
metric tests. To compare results before and 15 days after maximal individual scores during the three sessions were
the altitude training camp, we used the Wilcoxon test of 1.0, 2.4 and 0.8 respectively for HYPcs, HYPs and
rank. To compare the two groups we used the U-Mann HYPr.
Whitney test. The Statview version 5.0 statistical pack-
age was used for these analyses. The level of significance
Nocturnal arterial O2 saturation (SaO2) (Fig. 1)
was set at P £ 0.05.
Cross-country skiers
Results
Nocturnal SaO2 was lower at altitude. At 1,200 m, it was
Summary of performance and hematological parameters 96.8±0.8% and it decreased during the first night in hy-
poxia compared with the basal value. Mean SaO2 for a
V_ O2 max at POST1 tended to increase for HYP swim- given altitude decreased from 93.6±0.5% at 2,500 m to
mers (+8.1%, P=0.09) and was significantly enhanced 91.7±1.1% at 3,000 m (P<0.05) and to 89.8±0.5% at
for HYP runners (+7.1%, n=5). Concerning skiers 3,500 m (P<0.05). SaO2 increased progressively during
V_ O2 max was not modified along the study. At POST2 the 2,500 m step from 92.7±0.5% during the first night to
V_ O2 max values were similar to basal level for swimmers 94.2±0.8% during the last night of the step (6th night of
but remained higher for HYP runners compared with the session) (P<0.05). There was only a tendency during
PRE (+3.4%, n=5). V_ O2 max was not modified in the 3,000 m step (from 89.8±2.8 to 92.7±0.5%,

 hDSaO2 e ð%Þ ¼ normoxic SaO2 e  hypoxic SaO


  2e i
HVRe 1 min kg 1 1 _
_ _
_
¼ hypoxic exercise V E  normoxic exercise V E =DSaO2 e=body weight  100
HCRe ðbpmÞ ¼ ðhypoxic exercise HR  normoxic exercise HRÞ=DSaO2 e:
71

Fig. 1 Mean nocturnal


saturation per night in hypoxia
for subjects of the three groups.
Values are means ± SD.
1,200 m Basal measure realized
at the altitude of Prémanon
(1,200 m), prior to the hypoxic
exposure. *P<0.05 vs. 3,000 m.
#P<0.05 vs. the first night at
this altitude

P=0.07) and there was no significant change during the SaO2 increased between the first and the last night of
last step of altitude (3,500 m). While the lowest individual each step of altitude (from 91.2±0.8 to 92.4±1.5%
SaO2 was 92% during the first night at 2,500 m, this value during the 2,500 m step, from 90.4±1.4 to 92.7±1.7%
fell at 87% for the first night at 3,000 m (3 subjects under during the 3,000 m step, P<0.05). The lowest individual
90%) ant at 86% at 3,500 m (3 subjects under 90%). value was 90% during the first night at 2,500 m and
During the last night at 3,500 m there was still one subject 89% during the first night at 3,000 m (only one subject
who presented a value of 89%. (Fig. 1a) under 90%). (Fig. 1b)

Swimmers Runners

Basal value at 1,200 m (96.1±0.8%) was significantly SaO2 at 1,200 m was 95.5±0.8% during the last night
higher than during the first night at 2,500 m. There was before the beginning of the LHTL session and was sig-
a significant decrease of mean SaO2 between the last nificantly higher than during the first night in hypoxia.
night at 2,500 m and the first night at 3,000 m (P<0.05). SaO2 did not significantly increase along with the 6-day
72

period at 2,500 m. SaO2 decreased from 93±1.3 to increase in mean PAPs between PRE and POST2 was
91.7±1.2% between the last night at 2,500 m and the first not significant. However four out of six skiers presented
at 3,000 m (P<0.05). SaO2 increased from 91.7±1.2 to an increase in PAPs.
92.7±1.4% between the first and the last night at 3,000 m
(P<0.05). The lowest value was 90% during the first
night at 2,500 m (for one subject) and 91% during the first Swimmers
at 3,000 m (for four subjects). (Fig. 1c)
Right ventricle/left ventricle ratio slightly increased for
Subjects of all studies presented some episodic de- HYPs between PRE and POST1, so that the difference
saturations during the night (result not shown). The between the two groups became significant at POST1
lowest recorded desaturation was 83% at 2,500 m and compared with PRE (P<0.05). RV Dia was not altered
81% at 3,000 and 3,500 m. Surprisingly, the greatest by LHTL. Because RV Dia was 9% higher in POST1
individual desaturations did not occur only during the than in PRE for HYPs, the difference between groups
first night but all along the study at a given step of was significant at POST1 (P<0.05). RV Sys was sig-
altitude. Episode of desaturation was short (less than nificantly higher in HYPs than CONs at PRE and this
30 s), with a total duration below 2 min for the whole difference remained significant at POST1 (P<0.05). EF
night. Since we did not measure ventilation during sleep, significantly decreased (14%) between PRE and
we cannot say if these episodes of desaturation occurred POST1 in CONs (P<0.05), whereas it stayed similar for
during sleep apneas. HYP.

Leukocytes count (Fig. 2) Runners

All values remained with normal limits whatever the There was no significant difference between PRE and
group and the condition. Leukocytes count for cross- POST1 measurements or between the two groups.
country skiers was not modified between PRE and However, similarly to cross-country skiers in POST2,
POST1 for CONcs, but was not statistically decreased PAPs in HYPr was not modified at POST1, but mean
for HYPcs. This decrease was maintained and became PAPs was higher by 18.7% compared with PRE.
significant at POST2 (9% vs. PRE, P<0.05) (Fig. 2a).
Leukocytes for swimmers presented a 10% decrease
between PRE and POST1 for CONs (P<0.05), but va- Hypoxic ventilatory response at exercise (Table 4)
lues returned to the basal level at POST2. On the other
hand leukocyte count for HYPs was not modified along No change was found in HVRe, HCRe or DSaO2e be-
the session (Fig. 2b). Similarly leukocyte count for tween PRE and POST2 or between groups of cross-
runners was not modified during the session whatever country skiers. Swimmers presented a 24% decrease in
the group of subjects (Fig. 2c). DSaO2e between PRE and POST1 for CONs (P<0.05).
In the HYPs group, HVRe increased (+30%, P<0.05)
Echocardiography (Table 3) and DSaO2e decreased (31%, P<0.05) at POST1 com-
pared with PRE. In CON runners, HCRe decreased
Cross-country skiers between PRE and POST1 (P<0.05) while there was no
alteration in HYPr. At the same time HVRe decreased
Between PRE and POST2, there was no change in the between PRE and POST1 for CONr (24%, P<0.05).
echocardiographic parameters in both groups. The 19% In the HYPr group, HVRe increased by 74% (P<0.05)
Fig. 2 Leukocyte count of
athletes of the three groups
before (PRE), at the end
(POST1) and 15 days after
the end (POST2) of the
LHTL sessions. Values
are means ± SD.
*P<0.05 vs. PRE
Table 3 Echocardiographic parameters at rest

Group Cross-country skiers Swimmers Runners

CONcs (n=5) HYPcs (n=6) CONs (n=9) HYPs (n=9) CONr (n=6) HYPr (n=6)

PRE POST2 PRE POST2 PRE POST1 PRE POST1 PRE POST1 PRE POST1

PAPs (mm Hg) 21.00±4.18 20.00±3.54 17.50±4.18 20.83±3.76 27.20±4.55 24.00±3.39 22.33±2.94 26.50±2.65
RV/LV 0.43±0.10 0.42±0.08 0.41±0.02 0.43±0.04 0.46±0.11 0.44±0.08 0.52±0.07 0.56±0.05** 0.42±0.13 0.41±0.07 0.40±0.06 0.41±0.07
RV Dia (mm) 22.20±4.20 21.60±4.72 20.50±1.00 21.33±3.33 23.33±5.05 22.89±3.98 26.11±3.76 28.56±2.65** 21.83±6.85 21.00±3.85 22.00±2.74 22.40±3.44
RV Sys (mm) 19.22±4.60 20.22±3.31 23.22±3.03** 24.33±2.40** 18.67±6.22 18.50±4.14 18.00±2.00 18.80±3.03
EF (%) 0.62±0.02 0.63±0.02 0.68±0.08 0.69±0.08 0.70±0.06 0.60±0.05* 0.64±0.08 0.64±0.08 0.72±0.09 0.69±0.07 0.68±0.02 0.68±0.03

Values are mean ± SD; PAPs systolic pulmonary arterial pressure (mm Hg); RV/LV right ventricle/left ventricle ratio during diastole; RV Dia right ventricle diameter in end diastole
(mm); RV Sys right ventricle diameter in end systole (mm); EF left ventricular ejection fraction (%)
*P<0.05 vs. PRE, **P<0.05 HYP vs. CON

Table 4 Hypoxic cardiac and ventilatory response at exercise

Group Cross-country skiers Swimmers Runners

CONcs (n=5) HYPcs (n=6) CONs (n=9) HYPs (n=9) CONr (n=6) HYPr (n=6)

PRE POST2 PRE POST2 PRE POST1 PRE POST1 PRE POST1 PRE POST1

HCRe (bpm1.%) 0.99±0.39 1.15±0.36 1.14±0.19 1.14±0.31 0.85±0.28 0.87±0.21 0.89±0.22 0.90±0.26 0.82±0.15 0.69±0.14* 0.64±0.21 0.86±0.31
HVRe (l.min1.kg1) 1.04±0.72 0.84±0.60 0.76±0.15 0.90±0.47 0.79±0.31 1.02±0.48 0.74±0.40 0.96±0.49* 0.79±0.18 0.60±0.14* 0.62±0.27 1.08±0.33*
DSaO2e (%) 22.4±6.8 23.2±6.14 22.5±4.7 23.3±6.9 25.2±4.5 19.1±4.4* 27.1±6.9 18.8±3.5* 30.7±6.2 31.3±11.2 29.7±3.8 24.2±7.7*

Values are mean ± SD; HCRe: hypoxic cardiac response at exercise; HVRe: hypoxic ventilatory response at exercise; DSaO2e: difference of arterial saturation between normoxic and
hypoxic exercise. *P<0.05 vs. PRE
73
74

and DSaO2e decreased by 19% (P<0.05) from PRE to disturbances, but without any significant difference be-
POST1. tween groups, so that they cannot be related to inter-
mittent altitude exposure, but rather to training and
other environmental factors.
Discussion

The main findings of this study were: (1) fatigue and Nocturnal arterial O2 saturation (SaO2)
sleep disturbance were sometimes observed but no AMS
symptoms developed along with the sessions. (2) Noc- The values of nocturnal saturation were in agreement
turnal saturation decreased with altitude and thereafter with those commonly found at these altitudes (lowest
athletes progressively developed acclimatization leading mean SaO2 for HYPs during the first night at 3,500 m:
to increase in SaO2 (except at 3,500 m for cross-country 89±1.8%). A marked desaturation is known to repre-
skiers). (3) Immune status was not affected except at sent hypoventilation during sleep, which leads to hyp-
3,500 m for cross-country skiers. (4) Cardiac function oxemia and may trigger pathological manifestations. In
was globally not modified by LHTL except a slight in- patients with heart failure, the presence of sleep apneas
crease in PAPs but within normal limits. (5) HVRe was is related to left ventricular systolic dysfunction (Java-
enhanced at POST1 but signs of ventilatory acclimati- heri 2000). In the present study, no change in ventricular
zation had faded away at POST2. ejection fraction was observed in the HYP group sug-
Procedures of our studies were adapted from the gesting that the limited degree of desaturation observed
conclusions of the preceding one. For the first study we had no consequence on the contractility of the left
chose a relatively short session when compared with ventricle
those classically recommended in the literature (4 weeks, As expected, nocturnal SaO2 decreased with increas-
Levine 2002) but with a higher altitude, to allow athletes ing altitude. We also observed that nocturnal SaO2 in-
to perform many sessions during different mesocycles of creased with time, at a given level of altitude. This result
training over the year. The lack of improvement in can be related to the lower hypoxic exercise-induced
performance and the relatively poor acclimatization at desaturation observed at POST1. An increase in SaO2 or
3,500 m, lead us to use a lower level of altitude. How- lesser desaturation is a well-known sign of acclimatiza-
ever in the same time we kept a similar total time spent tion (Richalet et al. 2005). Thus, at least 6 nights at
in hypoxia (208 h for swimmers vs. 198 h for cross- 2,500 m followed by six nights at 3,000 m are sufficient
country skiers). Because of the limited modifications in to induce a progressive acclimatization. However at
performance observed with swimmers we decided to 3,500 m, this duration seems to be too short to obtain a
change the procedure for runners. We kept the same complete acclimatization, since SaO2 did not increase
altitude design, since it was well tolerated, but we in- significantly with time.
creased the time spent in altitude essentially by length-
ening the duration of the LHTL session (252 h, i.e.
14 h day1 during 18 days). Leukocytes count
Two main reasons may explain the relatively low
V_ O2 max measured among our elite endurance athletes. Immune status is known to be impaired after an expo-
First of all V_ O2 max test were performed at an altitude sure to continuous hypoxia. Actually Pyne et al. (2000)
of 1,200 m which is known to induce a decrease in showed a decrease in immune status for elite swimmers
V_ O2 max of 5–6% (Robergs et al. 1998) or more (Gore after a 21-day training camp at 2,102 m. To our
et al. 1996). Secondly, values of cross-country skiers can knowledge no other team previously studied immune
be partly explained by the fact that 5 women were part status during a LHTL session. Our results showed a
of our study. Finally it can also be due to the period of trend to decrease in leukocytes for HYPcs whereas val-
the experiments in the season: we can reasonably ues stayed similar for CONcs. Contrary to cross-country
imagine that our subjects were not at their peak of skiers, HYPs and HYPr did not present any significant
performance. modification of leukocytes count. The decrease observed
only for the study in which the altitude reached 3,500 m
supports the idea that this altitude was excessive. This
Acute mountain sickness (Lake Louise Score) observation is in agreement with others from our team
(Tiollier et al. 2005) who found a depletion of secretory
Symptoms of AMS can appear from altitudes exceeding immunoglobulin A (sIgA) consecutively to the same
2,000 m (Richalet and Herry 2003) and progressively session. However contrary to Pyne et al. (2000), who
disappear with acclimatization after a few days of resi- concluded that training-induced changes may be sec-
dence at the same altitude. On the other hand, AMS ondary to those induced by altitude, we were not able to
score increases with altitude (Richalet et al. 1999). In our determine if altitude or training was the main determi-
study we observed no modification of the AMS score nant of observed changes in leukocytes. Hence, these
whatever the study or the altitude considered. The only results suggest that LHTL is well tolerated by athletes
symptoms mentioned were fatigue and sleep up to a maximal altitude of 3,000 m. Although a slight
75

decrease in leukocyte count was shown in the control method developed by Weil et al. (1970), which is an iso-
group of swimmers, values remained within normal capnic test at rest. We preferred to use a method simu-
limits. As already mentioned, values for all groups re- lating exercise conditions closer to real altitude exposure,
mained within normal limits and, moreover, these rela- i.e. hypoxia and hypocapnia (poikilocapnic), derived
tive alterations were not coupled with major added from Richalet et al. (1988). Therefore, CO2 was not
infections. controlled and ventilatory response to CO2 was not as-
sessed. However, HVR has been shown to be similar be-
tween isocapnic and poikilocapnic at rest for an exposure
Echocardiography
up to 48 h (Tansley et al. 1998). In our study, we focused
on the response at exercise (HVRe), more appropriate to
We did not observe any LHTL-induced change in the
evaluate athletes. Townsend et al. (2002) found an in-
left systolic function at rest. Hence, contrarly to Liu
crease in resting HVR two days after a 20-day LHTL
et al. (1998), we did not find an improvement in the
session (8–10 h day-1 at 2,650 m) in well-trained runners
systolic cardiac function with LHTL. Left diastolic
despite previous findings that sea level endurance training
function (assessed by the E wave/A wave ratio, results
depressed HVR (Katayama et al. 1999). In our case,
not shown) was not modified, as found by Liu et al.
training was controlled and equivalent for CON and
(1998), suggesting the absence of change in the pre- or
HYP in each study. Thus a possible lower volume or
afterload. At exercise, some cardiac modifications could
intensity of training cannot explain the increase in HVRe
occur with chronic hypoxia. Sawka et al. (2000) evi-
for the HYPs and HYPr groups at the end of the session.
denced that cardiac work at exercise, quantified as the
On the other side the depression of HVR due to endur-
product of heart rate by mean arterial pressure, can be
ance training (Katayama et al. 1999) can explain that
enhanced after acclimatization. Similarly the authors
HVRe for HYPcs at POST2 was not significantly differ-
suggested a decrease in cardiac output during sub-
ent from basal measurement. Townsend et al. (2002) also
maximal exercise consecutively to acclimatization.
found that the magnitude of HVR was less important two
Exposure to chronic hypoxia is well known to induce
days after the end of the session than after fifteen days of
pulmonary hypertension and right ventricular hyper-
LHTL, even if it was still higher than before the session,
trophy (Hultgren and Miller 1965). Right ventricular
while in our study, HVRe returned to basal values
hypertrophy is proportional to the severity of pulmo-
15 days after the end of the session.
nary hypertension (Hultgren and Miller 1965). PAPs for
Evidence of diminished resting HVR at the fourth
cross-country skiers and runners presented a slight but
day after the return to sea level consecutive to 12 days of
insignificant increase of around 19%. However a type-II
continuous hypoxia at 3,810 m had already been ob-
error cannot be discarded. Furthermore it was not
served (Sato et al. 1994). However Forster et al (1971)
coupled with modifications in RV Dia or RV/LV ratio,
observed that HVR remained elevated 45 days after the
for which an increase is classically admitted as an indi-
return to normoxia from a 45-day sojourn at 3,100 m. In
rect indicator of pulmonary hypertension.
our study 15 days after the altitude sojourn, we did not
To the best of our knowledge, the only studies that
find any difference in HVRe or DSaO2e compared with
dealt with pulmonary hemodynamics by using an
PRE. During this period of 15 days, skiers were no more
intermittent model of hypoxia concerned miners that
subjected to hypoxia and continued their endurance
stayed for a few days or weeks at altitude and the same
training, which would have blunted their chemoreceptor
time at lowland, this shift pattern being repeated for
sensitivity (Katayama et al. 1999).
months (Sarybaev et al. 2003; Richalet et al. 2002). This
CONs presented a decrease in DSaO2e at POST1,
model of exposure, defined as ‘‘chronic intermittent
which could be surprising when we look at the two other
hypoxia’’, is different from our model where the inter-
control groups who did not show any change in DSaO2e.
mittence was performed during the same 24-h period.
In fact, two control subjects presented an increase in
However even in that chronic model, intermittent hy-
total hemoglobin mass (Robach et al. 2005), which could
poxia did not increase PAPs measured in normoxia after
have contributed to a better O2 transport during exercise
a maximum of 31 months (Richalet et al. 2002) or
and thus a smaller exercise-induced decrease in SaO2 in
3 years (Sarybaev et al. 2003) of intermittent exposure.
hypoxia.

Hypoxic ventilatory response at exercise


Methodological considerations
In the present study HVRe increased at the end of the
session, which supports the general consensus that hyp- This study had suffered from some methodological
oxic exposure increases the hypoxic ventilatory response, limitations. First, some interpretations may be specula-
as reported during continuous (Forster et al. 1971; Sato tive because of the small number of subjects (possible
et al. 1994) or intermittent (Katayama et al. 1998; type-II error). Actually studies with elite athletes are
Townsend et al. 2002) exposure, whatever the technique hard to lead mainly because of there tight schedules.
of HVR measurement (Richalet et al. 1999; Sato et al. Moreover, the choice of the time of experiments in the
1994). In fact, most studies use a modification of the season may not have been optimal, since the fitness level
76

of all athletes was not fully stabilized at the beginning of Brugniaux JV, Schmitt L, Robach P, Nicolet G, Fouillot JP,
the session. It could explain some modifications ob- Moutereau S, Lasne F, Pialoux V, Saas P, Chorvot MC, Olsen
NV, Richalet JP (2005) Eighteen days of ‘‘Living High—
served in CON groups (especially during the HVR test). Training Low’’ stimulate erythropoiesis and enhance aerobic
The differences in the profile of exposure of each performance in elite middle-distance runners. J Appl Physiol (in
group made comparison relatively difficult to do. First press)
the protocols were determined in order to test various Forster HV, Dempsey JA, Birnbaum ML, Reddan WG, Thoden J,
Grover RF, Rankin J (1971) Effect of chronic exposure to hy-
profiles of LHTL sessions (regarding acclimatization poxia on ventilatory response to CO2 and hypoxia. J Appl
and tolerance on one hand, and performance and Physiol 31:586–592
hematology on the other hand), as asked by the Inter- Gore CJ, Hahn AG, Scroop GC, Watson DB, Norton KI, Wood
national Olympic Committee (IOC). Secondly, as men- RJ, Campbell DP, Emonson DL (1996) Increased arterial de-
tioned above, we tried to optimize each study from the saturation in trained cyclists during maximal exercise at 580 m
altitude. J Appl Physiol 80:2204–2210
results of the preceding one. The wish of the IOC was to Hahn AG, Gore CJ, Martin DT, Ashenden MJ, Roberts AD,
have an overview of the LHTL method in order to Logan PA (2001) An evaluation of the concept of living at
implement regulations of the use of LHTL with simu- moderate altitude and training at sea level. Comp Biochem
lated altitude. Physiol A Mol Integr Physiol 128:777–789
Hultgren HN, Miller H (1965) Right ventricular hypertrophy at
Finally we could not exclude a possible placebo ef- high altitude. Ann N Y Acad Sci 127:627–631
fect. However studies were not performed in a double Javaheri S (2000) Effects of continuous positive airway pressure on
blind manner, which limited the placebo effect. sleep apnea and ventricular irritability in patients with heart
failure. Circulation 101:392–397
Katayama K, Sato Y, Ishida K, Mori S, Miyamura M (1998) The
Conclusion effects of intermittent exposure to hypoxia during endurance
exercise training on the ventilatory responses to hypoxia and
hypercapnia in humans. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol
We can conclude from the present study, that the 78:189–194
training protocol used did not induce any significant Katayama K, Sato Y, Morotome Y, Shima N, Ishida K, Mori S,
clinical disorder. A minimum of six nights at a maximal Miyamura M (1999) Ventilatory chemosensitive adaptations to
altitude of 3,000 m, preceded by a few days at a lower intermittent hypoxic exposure with endurance training and
detraining. J Appl Physiol 86:1805–1811
altitude seems to be necessary and sufficient to trigger Levine B, Stray-Gundersen J, Duhaime G, Snell P, Friedman D
the acclimatization process. On the other hand, six (1991) ‘‘Living high-training low’’: the effect of altitude accli-
nights at 3,500 m seem to be too short to develop matization/normoxic training in trained runners (Abstract).
acclimatization. Limited cardiac changes may occur, but Med Sci Sports Exerc 23:S25
all parameters stayed within the normal physiological Levine BD, Stray-Gundersen J (1992) A practical approach to
altitude training: Where to live and train for optimal per-
range. Similarly a slight alteration of the leukocyte count formance enhancement. Int J Sports Med 13(Suppl 1):S209–
may occur consecutively to an exposure to 3,500 m. S212
Athletes can thus use this type of training without major Levine BD, Stray-Gundersen J (1997) ‘‘Living high-training low’’:
risks for health. However because of possible nocturnal effect of moderate-altitude acclimatization with low-altitude
training on performance. J Appl Physiol 83:102–112
SaO2 desaturation, a medical survey could be required, Levine BD (2002) Intermittent hypoxic training: fact and fancy.
or at least athletes have to be instructed to the use of High Alt Med Biol 3:177–193
oximeters (how to adjust alarms for example). Liu Y, Steinacker JM, Dehnert C, Menold E, Baur S, Lormes
Although the number of subjects was limited and not W, Lehmann M (1998) Effect of ‘‘living high-training low’’
on the cardiac functions at sea level. Int J Sports Med
all the possible combinations of characteristics of LHTL 19:380–384
sessions were explored, this study allows to suggest opti- Mujika I, Busso T, Lacoste L, Barale F, Geyssant A, Chatard JC
mal conditions for this type of training session. A maximal (1996) Modeled responses to training and taper in competitive
altitude of 3,000 m (with few days of pre-acclimatization swimmers. Med Sci Sports Exerc 28:251–258
at a lower altitude), during at least 18 days and with a Pyne DB, McDonald WA, Morton DS, Swigget JP, Foster M,
Sonnenfeld G, Smith JA (2000) Inhibition of interferon, cyto-
minimum of 12 h day1 in hypoxia seem to be required. A kine, and lymphocyte proliferative response in elite swimmers
time period of 15 days after the end of the session is too with altitude exposure. J Interferon Cytokine Res 20:411–418
long to maintain the signs of acclimatization. Richalet JP, Kéromès A, Dersch B, Corizzi F, Mehdioui H,
Pophillat B, Chardonnet H, Tassery F, Herry JP, Rathat C,
Acknowledgements This study was supported by grants from the Chaduteau C, Darnaud B (1988) Caractéristiques physiologi-
International Olympic Committee and the French Ministry of ques des alpinistes de haute altitude. Sci Sports 3:89–108
Sports. The skillful assistance of Patrick Bouchet for software Richalet JP, Robach P, Jarrot S, Schneider JC, Mason NP,
development is gratefully acknowledged. Cauchy E, Herry JP, Bienvenu A, Gardette B, Gortan C
(1999) Operation Everest III: effects of prolonged and pro-
gressive hypoxia on humans during a simulated ascent to
8,848 m in a hypobaric chamber (COMEX’97). Adv Exp Med
Biol 474:297–317
References Richalet JP, Vargas Donoso M, Jiménez D, Antezana AM, Hud-
son C, Cortès G, Osorio J, Leòn A (2002) Chilean miners
Ashenden MJ, Gore CJ, Dobson GP, Hahn AG (1999) ‘‘Live high, commuting from sea level to 4500 m: a prospective study. High
train low’’ does not change the total haemoglobin mass of male Alt Med Biol 3:159–166
endurance athletes sleeping at a simulated altitude of 3000 m Richalet JP, Herry JP (2003) Médecine de l’alpinisme, 3ème édn.
for 23 nights. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol 80:479–484 Masson, Paris, pp 110–111
77

Richalet JP, Gratadour P, Robach P, Pham I, Déchaux M, Jonc- Sawka MN, Convertino VA, Eichner ER, Schnieder SM, Young
quiert-Latarjet A, Mollard P, Brugniaux J, Cornolo J (2005) AJ (2000) Blood volume: importance and adaptations to exer-
Sildenafil inhibits altitude-induced hypoxemia and hyperten- cise training, environmental stresses, and trauma/sickness. Med
sion. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 171(3):275–281 Sci Sports Exerc 32(2):332–348
Robach P, Scmitt L, Brugniaux J, Nicolet G, Duvallet A, Fouillot JP, Tansley JG, Fatemian M, Howard LSGE, Poulin M, Robbins P
Pialoux V, Poutéreau S, Lasne F (2002) Living High-Training (1998) Changes in respiratory control during and after 48 h of
Low: effect on erythropoiesis and aerobic performance in highly isocapnic and poikilocapnic hypoxia in humans. J Appl Physiol
trained cross-country skiers (Abstract). High Alt Med Biol 85(6):2125–2134
3(4):430 The Lake Louise Consensus on the definition, quantification of
Robach P, Schmitt L, Brugniaux JV, Roels B, Millet G, Hellard P, altitude illness (1992). In: Sutton JR, Coates G, Houston CS
Nicolet G, Duvallet A, Fouillot J-P, Moutereau S, Lasne F, (eds) Hypoxia and mountain medicine. Queen City Printers
Pialoux V, Olsen NV, Richalet J-P (2005) Living high – training Inc., Burlington, pp 327–330
low: effect on erythropoiesis and aerobic performance in highly- Tiollier E, Schmitt L, Burnat P, Fouillot JP, Robach P, Filaire E,
trained swimmers. Eur J Appl Physiol (submission number: Guezennec C, Richalet JP (2005) Living high-training low
EJAP-00251-2005) altitude training: effects on mucosal immunity. Eur J Appl
Robergs RA, Quintana R, Parker DL, Frankel CC (1998) Multiple Physiol 94(3):298–304
variables explain the variability in the decrement in V_ O2 max Townsend NE, Gore CJ, Hahn AG, Mckenna MJ, Aughey RJ,
during acute hypobaric hypoxia. Med Sci Sports Exerc 30:869– Clark SA, Kinsman T, Hawley JA, Chow CM (2002) Living
879 high-training low increases hypoxic ventilatory response of
Sarybaev AS, Palasiewicz G, Usupbaeva DA, Plywaczewski R, well-trained endurance athletes. J Appl Physiol 93:1498–1505
Maripov AM, Sydykov AS, Mirrakhimov MM, Le Roux H, Weil JV, Byrne-Quinn E, Sodal IE, Friesen WO, Underhill B,
Kadyrov T, Zielinski J (2003) Effects of intermittent exposure Filley GF, Grover RF (1970) Hypoxic ventilatory drive in
to high altitude on pulmonary hemodynamics: a prospective normal man. J Clin Invest 49:1061–1072
study. High Alt Med Biol 4:455–463
Sato M, Severinghaus JW, Bickler P (1994) Time course of aug-
mentation and depression of hypoxic ventilatory responses at
altitude. J Appl Physiol 77:313–316

View publication stats

You might also like