Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Association Between Loss of Work Ability and Depression. A Focus On Employment Status PDF
The Association Between Loss of Work Ability and Depression. A Focus On Employment Status PDF
DOI 10.1007/s00420-016-1178-7
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
13
Int Arch Occup Environ Health
Depression may come from various factors, includ- households. In the present study, data from 2013 were con-
ing loss of a spouse, life stress, social isolation, loneli- sidered baseline (n = 17,984), and data from 2012 were
ness, and health factors such as disease or loss of physical included as lagged data in the baseline. We excluded partic-
function (Salzman and Shader 1979). Specifically, work- ipants under 20 years old (n = 3694), as well as those who
related factors could also contribute to depressive moods did not have both a job (n = 6544) and the ability to work
(Tennant 2001). Among work-related factors, the ability to (n = 2739) and those who have depression as chronic dis-
work is considered an important aspect of well-being and ease (n = 126). We also excluded those who have depres-
health status (Tavakoli-Fard et al. 2016). The work ability sive moods in 2012 measuring by CES-D scale (n = 1927).
of employees is defined as the degree of a worker’s physi- We also excluded participants who did not follow up from
cal and mental status that enables them to meet the expec- 2012 or who were missing from the 2013 data. Cases with
tations of their occupation or job (Escorpizo 2008), and is missing values were then excluded, and our final study
considered a useful indicator for measuring social health population was 5241 individuals.
of the economy and economic growth (Escorpizo et al.
2007). Loss of work ability is primarily affected by disease Variables
or aging. Due to the increase in chronic health conditions
among employees and the accompanying economic burden The dependent variable of the present study was depres-
on not only the employees themselves, but also the organi- sion, which is measured by the Center for Epidemiologic
zations where they work and the society at large, the impact Studies Depression (CES-D) Scale. The CES-D Scale is
of health on an employed person’s ability to work is consid- useful for measurement of the current level of depres-
ered an important matter (Freid et al. 2012). The work abil- sive symptoms, focusing on an affective component,
ity of employees is associated with their work productivity; and depressive mood (Radloff 1977). The original ver-
therefore, work ability loss due to health-related factors sion of CES-D Scale has 20-item questionnaire of cogni-
leads to reduced work productivity in an organization. Evi- tion of depressive moods. Instead of this original version,
dence from the USA suggests that approximately $260 bil- KOWEPS used CES-D 11 which is a reliable abbreviated
lion is lost each year due to work ability loss associated with form of CES-D 20 Scale (Kohout et al. 1993; Pun et al.
health-related problems (Mitchell and Bates 2011). In addi- 2016; Asamsama et al. 2015). CES-D 11 has 11-item ques-
tion, the effect of aging on work ability is also important, tionnaire of cognition of depressive moods evaluating a
particularly in South Korea, which is aging faster than any past week on a four-point scale (0: less than one time per
other developed country (Statistics Korea 2013). However, week, 1: two to three times per week, 2: four to five times
many studies focus on determining the risk factors associ- per week, 3: more than six times per week): (a) ‘No appe-
ated with loss of work ability or its economic consequences, tite,’ (b) ‘I felt that I was living well,’ (c) ‘I felt depressed
whereas few studies consider the effect of loss of work abil- considerably,’ (d) ‘I felt difficulty in doing everything,’ (e)
ity on the elderly or as related to industrial accidents. There- ‘I could not sleep well,’ (f) ‘I felt lonely,’ (g) ‘I thought that
fore, in-depth study regarding the impact of work ability I was living without complaint,’ (h) ‘I felt that people did
loss on an individual’s psychological status is needed, given not treat me warmly,’ (i) ‘I felt sad,’ (j) ‘I felt people didn’t
the seriousness of depression as a public health issue. like me,’ and (k) ‘I did not have courage to do something.’
The purpose of this study was to examine the associa- We used the total score of the 11 items, with a higher score
tion between work ability loss and depression. Workers with indicating more depressive moods (The Korean Institute for
reduced work ability could be related to long-term or perma- Health and Social Affairs 2013).
nent absence due to illness, early retirement, or unemployment Work ability status was investigated by self-reported
status (Lagerveld et al. 2010). Hence, we further examined the questionnaire in the KOWEPS, and we created the work
association between loss of work ability and depression strati- ability transition variable, which is the primary independent
fied by employment status after loss of work ability. variable, by comparing work ability status compared to the
previous year. Work ability transition was measured using
three categories: maintained, loss, and completely loss, as
Methods determined by self-reported work ability status compared
to the previous year. The maintained group was defined as
Study population those who maintained their work ability and did not have
any difficulty performing at the worksite. The loss work
We used data from the Korea Welfare Panel Study ability group was defined as those who lost their work abil-
(KOWEPS) collected from 2012 to 2013. KOWEPS ity slightly and had some difficulty performing at the work-
is a nationwide longitudinal study published annually, site (able to telecommute). The completely loss group was
which began in 2006 with 18,856 participants from 7072 defined as those who lost their work ability considerably
13
Int Arch Occup Environ Health
13
Int Arch Occup Environ Health
13
Int Arch Occup Environ Health
13
Int Arch Occup Environ Health
Table 3 Subgroup analyses of the effect of work ability transition or productivity due to the loss of work ability. Therefore,
stratified by working status transition and gender according to a linear this situation could cause low self-esteem or depression.
mixed-effects model
Third, chronic disease, which could cause work ability
Variables CES-D 11 loss, may have affected depressive moods. Among many
β SE 95% CI p value factors affecting work ability, health problems, including
musculoskeletal disease, diabetes, disability, or at least one
Lower Upper
chronic disease, may interfere with work ability (Mitchell
Working status transitiona and Bates 2011; Radloff 1977; Schultz and Edington 2007;
Maintain Pendo 2009; Rodbard et al. 2009). Also, physical function
Maintain Ref. loss due to chronic disease is recognized as one of the con-
Loss 1.361 0.498 0.386 2.337 0.006 tributors to depression (Salzman and Shader 1979) due to
Complete loss 2.804 1.283 0.290 5.317 0.029 the stress from coping with the chronic disease or dimin-
Loss ished self-efficacy (Moussavi et al. 2007). This psychologi-
Maintain Ref. cal status further contributes to withdrawal from rehabilita-
Loss 4.123 1.561 1.064 7.182 0.008 tion or social activities (Lee 2006), leading to isolation of
Complete loss 2.944 1.522 −0.039 5.927 0.053 the individual, which makes it more difficult to overcome
Genderb work ability loss.
Male Apart from the contribution of work ability itself to
Maintain Ref. depression, we found that those who lost their ability to
Loss 1.750 0.797 0.189 3.311 0.028 work had significantly higher depression scores when they
Complete loss 4.487 2.009 0.550 8.423 0.026 also lost their employment. Even though someone may lose
Female the ability to work due to health problems, there are some
Maintain Ref. cases in which these individuals can sustain work even
Loss 2.396 0.773 0.881 3.911 0.002 after becoming unhealthy or losing their job, whether com-
Complete loss 1.513 1.176 −0.791 3.817 0.198
pulsory or not. The case of maintaining working status after
a reduction in work ability could be divided into presen-
a
Adjusted for age, gender, educational level, income, marital status, teeism (on-the-job productivity) and absenteeism (Schultz
chronic diseases, current smoker, alcohol consumption, and industrial and Edington 2007). Both of presenteeism and absenteeism
accident compensation insurance
b
could have negative influence on mental health. In the case
Adjusted for age, educational level, income, marital status, chronic
diseases, current smoker, alcohol consumption, employment status of presenteeism, people could feel discouragement due to
transition, and industrial accident compensation insurance reduced performance (Conway et al. 2014). In the case of
absenteeism, absence due to illness is connected to not only
impaired career opportunities and self-image, but also other
comprised 1.4% (n = 72), and those who completely lost negative consequences such as inactivity, social isolation,
their work ability accounted for 0.5% (n = 27). Our find- and decreased well-being (Ockander and Timpka 2001,
ings revealed that those in the work ability loss group had 2003; Judiesch and Lyness 1999). These previous data
higher depression scores than those in the maintained work could explain our result that those with loss of work abil-
ability group, and the depression score was much higher ity that also maintained their working status had a higher
when someone completely lost their ability to work, such depression score.
that they could not do housework. These effects were much However, there are those who lose their ability to work
more severe in the job loss group compared to the job as well as their employment status, finally becoming unem-
maintained group. ployed. According to the results of this study, unemploy-
In the present study, those who lost the ability to work ment status with loss of work ability had significantly
showed higher depressive moods. The first explanation of higher depression scores compared to those who main-
this result may be related to a sudden loss of the ability to tained their employment status even after loss of work
work. Herein, we recorded the ability to work in reflection ability. Loss of work ability could result in loss of work-
upon the previous year. Therefore, the loss of work abil- ing status (Belgrave et al. 1987; Lindbohm et al. 2014),
ity may have occurred suddenly. According to a previous and according to previous meta-analysis studies, job loss
study, this sudden loss of work ability leads to a chronic itself has negative effects on mental health (McKee-Ryan
stress, lower self-esteem, and depression, because those et al. 2005; Paul and Moser 2009). A previous study that
who lose work ability suddenly face difficulties in accept- investigated a work-injury population found that those who
ing the sudden change (Park and Park 2012). Second, we were unemployed after an accident had significantly higher
suspect that our results reflect reduced work performance depressive moods compared to those who were employed
13
Int Arch Occup Environ Health
(Kim 2010). Similarly, a study of breast cancer survivors In conclusion, we found that those who lost their ability
found that non-employed survivors had higher anxiety lev- to work could be at risk of depression, particularly those
els compared to employed survivors (Comino et al. 2003). who also lost their employment. Current support for those
These results could be explained by the following conse- who lose their work ability or employment usually focuses
quences: societal, financial, and psychological (Zijlstra on economic aspects and does not offer support focused
and Nijhuis 2014); work is the vital factor in meeting eco- on mental health. Rehabilitation for return to work is
nomic and social needs (Bethge et al. 2009). Financially, a needed; however, according to our results, those who lose
job assures income (Witte 1999), enabling people to earn their ability to work could be experiencing depression,
money, while job loss means loss of income, and could which may make returning to work more difficult (Lind-
be the beginning of a stressful situation with individual bohm et al. 2014). Therefore, psychological support also
or societal factors. With respect to societal aspects, full needs to be considered when providing support to these
retirement from working status has a negative influence on individuals.
health status both physically and mentally (Sugisawa et al.
1997), and job loss means a loss of opportunity to form Acknowledgements A number of colleagues from the Department of
Public Health and the Graduate School of Yonsei University provided
social relations (Witte 1999), which is strongly associated advice for this manuscript.
with mental health (Cohen 2004; Melchior et al. 2003).
This loss of social interactions makes people feel that they Compliance with ethical standards
are not part of society, which may result in low self-esteem,
depressive moods, and eventually preoccupation with feel- Conflict of interest The authors declare no conflict of interest.
ings of being isolated from society (Black 2008; Hulshof
2009). Moreover, job loss is also a lost opportunity for
structured time, as well as the opportunity to spend time References
on personal endeavors (Witte 1999). Therefore, it could be
suggested that these financial and societal consequences Asamsama OH et al (2015) Bidirectional longitudinal study of type
due to loss of employment status may aggravate depressive 2 diabetes and depression symptoms in black and white church
moods of those who lose their ability to work. going adults. J Diabetes Metab Disord 14(1):1
Belgrave LL, Haug MR, Gómez-Bellengé F-X (1987) Gender and
Our study has several limitations. First, we exam- race differences in effects of health and pension on retirement
ined work ability through a self-reported answer to a sin- before 65. Compr Gerontol B Behav Soc Appl Sci 1(3):109–117
gle question, which could be inexact and not examine the Bethge M, Radoschewski FM, Müller-Fahrnow W (2009) Work
boundaries of each category. Second, it is possible that we stress and work ability: cross-sectional findings from the
German sociomedical panel of employees. Disabil Rehabil
did not include all covariates that may affect depression. 31(20):1692–1699
Third, employment status cannot be distributed into presen- Black DC (2008) Working for a healthier tomorrow. The Stationery
teeism or absenteeism because we used only one question Office, London
to determine whether or not an individual maintained their Cohen S (2004) Social relationships and health. Am Psychol
59(8):676
job status compared to the previous year. Fourth, depres- Comino EJ et al (2003) Relationship between mental health disorders
sion could not be specified as mild, moderate, or severe. In and unemployment status in Australian adults. Aust NZ J Psy-
addition, even though we excluded individuals with depres- chiatry 37(2):230–235
sion as a chronic disease and those with depressive moods Conway PM et al (2014) Is sickness presenteeism a risk factor for
depression? A Danish 2-year follow-up study. J Occup Environ
at the baseline year, there remains the possibility of hid- Med 56(6):595–603
ing depressed symptoms due to the self-reported method. Escorpizo R (2008) Understanding work productivity and its appli-
Accordingly, there is the possibility for social desirability. cation to work-related musculoskeletal disorders. Int J Ind
Also, there is the possibility of reverse time order due to Ergonom 38(3):291–297
Escorpizo R et al (2007) Worker productivity outcome measures in
the same reason. Nevertheless, our study’s strength is in the arthritis. J Rheumatol 34(6):1372–1380
use of nationally collected data, which can be considered Freid VM, Bernstein AB, Bush MA (2012) Multiple chronic condi-
representative. Moreover, we excluded participants who tions among adults aged 45 and over: trends over the past 10
had already lost their ability to work or who were unem- years. Women 45:64
Hulshof CT (2009) Working for a healthier tomorrow. Occup Environ
ployed by using longitudinal data, and we determined their Med 66(1):1–2
change of work ability and working status compared to the Judiesch MK, Lyness KS (1999) Left behind? The impact of
previous year. Therefore, we could examine the short-term leaves of absence on managers’ career success. Acad Manag J
effect of loss of work ability and working status. To the 42(6):641–651
Kim MY (2010) The causes of depression workers with lumbago due
best of our knowledge, this is the first attempt to examine to industrial accident. Sogang University, Seoul
the impact of work ability loss on depression, focusing on Kohout FJ et al (1993) Two shorter forms of the CES-D depression
change in employment status. symptoms index. J Aging Health 5(2):179–193
13
Int Arch Occup Environ Health
Lagerveld S et al (2010) Factors associated with work participation Pun VC, Manjourides J, Suh H (2016) Association of ambient
and work functioning in depressed workers: a systematic review. air pollution with depressive and anxiety symptoms in older
J Occup Rehabil 20(3):275–292 adults: results from the NSHAP study. Environ Health Perspect.
Lee HJ (2006) A study on the quality of life of the workers compen- doi:10.1289/EHP494
sation insurance beneficiary in Korea. Korean Soc Secur Stud Radloff LS (1977) The CES-D scale a self-report depression scale
22(1):153–177 for research in the general population. Appl Psychol Meas
Lindbohm ML et al (2014) Early retirement and non-employment 1(3):385–401
after breast cancer. Psychooncology 23(6):634–641 Rodbard HW, Fox KM, Grandy S (2009) Impact of obesity on work
Marcus M et al (2012) Depression: a global public health concern, productivity and role disability in individuals with and at risk for
vol 1. WHO Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse, diabetes mellitus. Am J Health Promot 23(5):353–360
Geneva, pp 6–8 Salzman C, Shader R (1979) Clinical evaluation of depression in the
McKee-Ryan F et al (2005) Psychological and physical well-being elderly. In: Raskin A, Jarvik L (eds) Psychiatric symptoms and
during unemployment: a meta-analytic study. J Appl Psychol cognitive loss in the elderly. Hemisphere, Washington, DC, pp
90(1):53 39–72
Melchior M et al (2003) Social relations and self-reported health: a Schultz AB, Edington DW (2007) Employee health and presenteeism:
prospective analysis of the French Gazel cohort. Soc Sci Med a systematic review. J Occup Rehabil 17(3):547–579
56(8):1817–1830 Statistics Korea (2013) Population projections for Korea. Statistics
Mitchell RJ, Bates P (2011) Measuring health-related productivity Korea, Daejeon
loss. Popul Health Manag 14(2):93–98 Sugisawa A et al (1997) Effect of retirement on mental health and
Moussavi S et al (2007) Depression, chronic diseases, and decrements social well-being among elderly Japanese. Jpn J Publ Health
in health: results from the World Health Surveys. The Lancet 44(2):123–130
370(9590):851–858 Tavakoli-Fard N et al (2016) Quality of life, work ability and other
Ockander M, Timpka T (2001) A female lay perspective on the important indicators of women’s occupational health. Int J
establishment of long-term sickness absence. Int J Soc Welf Occup Med Environ Health 29(1):77–84
10(1):74–79 Tennant C (2001) Work-related stress and depressive disorders. J Psy-
Ockander MK, Timpka T (2003) Women’s experiences of long term chosom Res 51(5):697–704
sickness absence: implications for rehabilitation practice and The Korean Institute for Health and Social Affairs (2013) User’s
theory. Scand J Public Health 31(2):143–148 guide the 8th Wave of the Korean Welfare Panel Study. The
OECD (2015) Health at a Glance 2015: OECD indicators. OECD, Korean Institute for Health and Social Affairs, Seoul
Paris Witte HD (1999) Job insecurity and psychological well-being: Review
Organisation for Economic Co-operation Development (2014) Soci- of the literature and exploration of some unresolved issues. Eur J
ety at a Glance 2014: OECD social indicators. Organisation for Work Organ Psy 8(2):155–177
Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris World Health Organization (2015) Health in 2015 from MDGs to
Park YM, Park K (2012) A study of body psychotherapeutic interven- SDGs. World Health Organization, Geneva
tion on depression and chronic pain of industry accident patients. Zijlstra F, Nijhuis F (2014) Return to work for long-term absentees:
Korean J Psychother 4(1):79–90 An undervalued topic in (psychological) research. Europäische
Paul KI, Moser K (2009) Unemployment impairs mental health: Arbeitsmarktstrategien auf dem Prüfstand, 28
meta-analyses. J Vocat Behav 74(3):264–282
Pendo E (2009) Working sick: lessons of chronic illness for health
care reform. Yale J Health Policy Law Ethics 9:453
13