Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction
An effective method for filtering high frequency power supply The device used to demonstrate the effects of ferrite beads as
noise and cleanly sharing similar voltage supply rails (that is, an output filter is a 2 A/1.2 A dc-to-dc switching regulator
analog and digital rails for mixed-signal ICs) while preserving with independent positive and negative outputs (ADP5071).
high frequency isolation between the shared rails is the use The ferrite beads used in the article are mainly chip type
of ferrite beads. A ferrite bead is a passive device that filters surface-mount packages.
high frequency noise energy over a broad frequency range. It
becomes resistive over its intended frequency range and dis- Ferrite Bead Simplified Model and Simulation
sipates the noise energy in the form of heat. The ferrite bead A ferrite bead can be modeled as a simplified circuit consist-
is connected in series with the power supply rail and is often ing of resistors, an inductor, and a capacitor, as shown in
combined with capacitors to ground on either side of the bead. Figure 1a. RDC corresponds to the dc resistance of the bead.
This forms a low-pass filter network, further reducing the high CPAR, LBEAD, and RAC are (respectively) the parasitic capacitance,
frequency power supply noise. the bead inductance, and the ac resistance (ac core losses) asso-
ciated with the bead.
However, improper use of ferrite beads in system design can Ferrite beads are categorized by three response regions: induc-
lead to some detrimental issues. Some examples are unwanted tive, resistive, and capacitive. These regions can be determined
resonance due to combining the bead with a decoupling by looking at a ZRX plot (shown in Figure 1b), where Z is the
capacitor for low-pass filtering and the effect of dc bias current impedance, R is the resistance, and X is the reactance of the
dependency that degrades the EMI suppression capability of bead. To reduce high frequency noise, the bead must be in the
the bead. With proper understanding and consideration of the resistive region; this is especially desirable for electromagnetic
ferrite bead’s behavior, these issues can be avoided. interference (EMI) filtering applications. The component acts
like a resistor, which impedes the high frequency noise and
This article discusses the important considerations that system dissipates it as heat. The resistive region occurs after the bead
designers need to be aware of when using ferrite beads in crossover frequency (X = R) and up to the point where the
power supply systems such as impedance vs. frequency bead becomes capacitive. This capacitive point occurs at the
characteristics with varying dc bias current and unwanted frequency where the absolute value of capacitive reactance
LC resonance effects. Ultimately, to address the issue on the (–X) is equivalent to R.
unwanted resonance, damping techniques will be introduced In some cases, the simplified circuit model can be used to
and a comparison of the effectiveness of each damping method approximate the ferrite bead impedance characteristic up
will be presented. to the sub-GHz range.
1200
Z = R; RAC Resistive
1000
Inductive Capacitive
800
Impedance (Ω)
600
Z ≈ |XC|;
CPAR Z ≈ XL; LBEAD R CPAR
400
X
LBEAD
RDC 200
RAC
0
1 10 100 1000
(a) Frequency (MHz) (b)
Figure 1. (a) Simplified circuit model and (b) Tyco Electronics BMB2A1000LN2 measured ZRX plot.
1200
1000
800
IMPEDANCE (Ω)
600
Impedance 1.678 pF
C1
400
300 mΩ 1.208 µF
R2 L1 Simulation
AC 1 A 200
I1 1.082 kΩ
Actual Measurement
R1
0
1 10 100 1000
(a) Frequency (MHz)
(b)
Figure 2. (a) Circuit simulation model and (b) Actual measurement vs. simulation.
250
LC Resonance Effect
200
MPZ1608S101A Resonance peaking is possible when implementing a ferrite
(100 Ω, 3 A, 0603)
150 bead together with a decoupling capacitor. This commonly
742 792 510
overlooked effect can be detrimental because it may amplify
100 (70 Ω, 6 A, 1812) ripple and noise in a given system instead of attenuating it. In
50 many cases, this peaking occurs around the popular switching
frequencies of dc-to-dc converters.
0
0 1 2 3 4 5
DC Bias Current (A)
Peaking occurs when the resonant frequency of a low-pass
(a) filter network, formed by the ferrite bead inductance and
160 the high Q decoupling capacitance, is below the crossover
frequency of the bead. The resulting filter is underdamped.
140 Figure 4a shows the measured impedance vs. frequency
0 mA
120 100 mA plot of the TDK MPZ1608S101A. The resistive component,
250 mA
500 mA which is depended upon to dissipate unwanted energy, does
100 750 mA not become significant until reaching about the 20 MHz to
Impedance (Ω)
1000 mA
1500 mA 30 MHz range. Below this frequency, the ferrite bead still has
80 2000 mA
3000 mA a very high Q and acts like an ideal inductor. LC resonant fre-
60 quencies for typical bead filters are generally in the 0.1 MHz
to 10 MHz range. For typical switching frequencies in the
40 300 kHz to 5 MHz range, additional damping is required to
20
reduce the filter Q.
160
0
1 10 100 1000
140
Frequency (MHz)
Z
(b)
120
120
100
Impedance (Ω)
0 mA Crossover Frequency
100 R
100 mA 80
250 mA
500 mA
80 1000 mA 60
X
Impedance (Ω)
1500 mA
2000 mA 40 Inductive
60 3000 mA Region
4000 mA
20
5000 mA
40
0
1 10 100 1000
Frequency (MHz)
(a)
20
20
0 10
1 10 100 1000
Frequency (MHz) 0
(c)
–10
Figure 3. (a) The effect of dc bias current on bead inductance and
Gain (dB)
–20
impedance curves with respect to dc bias current for: (b) a TDK
MPZ1608S101A bead, and (c) a Würth Elektronik 742 792 510 bead. –30 Ferrite Bead:
TDK MPZ1608S101A
(100 Ω, 3 A, 0603)
For effective power supply noise filtering, a design guideline –40
40 Method B
Amplitude (dBµV)
30
Ferrite Bead:
TDK MPZ1608S101A
(100 Ω, 3 A, 0603)
20
In Out
ADP5071 Output Spectrum
with Bead and C Low-Pass Capacitor:
10 Murata
Filter (Undamped) CDAMP
GRM188R71H103KA01
ADP5071 Output Spectrum (10 nF, X7R, 0603)
0 Without Bead and C
Low-Pass Filter RDAMP
Using an Additional
–10 RC Decoupling Filter
0.01 0.1 1 10 100 Method C
Frequency (MHz)
Figure 6. ADP5071 spectral output at 5 mA load. Figure 7. Actual frequency response for various damping methods.
DC Bias 0 mA 60
R
X
80 Z
50 Ripple Spur at 2.4 MHz
60 Is Reduced by 5 dB
40
40
Amplitude (dBµV)
20 30
0 20
1M 10M 100M 1G
Frequency (Hz)
(a)
12 10
ADP5071 Output Spectrum
with Bead and C Low-Pass
Filter (Method C Damping)
0
10 ADP5071 Output Spectrum
Without Bead and C
Low-Pass Filter
–10
8 Bead Only, 0.01 0.1 1 10 100
DC Bias 0 mA
Impedance (Ω)
R Frequency (MHz)
X
6 Z
Figure 9. ADP5071’s spectral output plus a bead and capacitor low-
Bead with
10 Ω Resistor, pass filter with Method C damping.
DC Bias 0 mA
4
R
X
Z Generally, Method C is the most elegant and is implemented
2 by adding a resistor in series with a ceramic capacitor rather
than buying an expensive dedicated damping capacitor. The
0
1M 10M 100M 1G
safest designs always include a resistor that can be tweaked
Frequency (Hz) (b) during prototyping and that can be eliminated if not necessary.
Figure 8. (a) MPZ1608S101A ZRX plot and (b) MPZ1608S101A ZRX The only drawbacks are the additional component cost and
plot, zoom view. greater required board space.
Because the ferrite bead is inductive, do not use it with high Q Kundert, Ken. “Power Supply Noise Reduction.” Designer’s
decoupling capacitors without careful attention. Doing so can Guide Consulting, Inc.
do more harm than good by producing unwanted resonance
Weir, Steve. “PDN Application of Ferrite Beads.” IPBLOX, LLC.
in a circuit. However, the damping methods proposed in
this article offer an easy solution by using a large decoupling
capacitor in series with a damping resistor across the load, Acknowledgements
thus avoiding unwanted resonance. Applying ferrite beads The authors would like to acknowledge Jeff Weaver, Donal
correctly can be an effective and inexpensive way to reduce O’Sullivan, Luca Vassalli, and Pat Meehan (University of
high frequency noise and switching transients. Limerick, Ireland) for sharing their technical expertise and inputs.
References
AN-583 Application Note, Designing Power Isolation Filters with
Ferrite Beads for Altera FPGAs. Altera Corporation.
Jefferson A. Eco
Jefferson A. Eco [jefferson.eco@analog.com] joined Analog Devices
Philippines in May 2011 and currently works as an application development
engineer. He graduated from Camarines Sur Polytechnic College Naga City,
Philippines, with a bachelor’s degree in electronics engineering.
Aldrick S. Limjoco
Aldrick S. Limjoco [aldrick.limjoco@analog.com] joined Analog Devices
Philippines in August 2006 and currently works as an applications development Also by this Author:
engineer. He graduated from the De La Salle University Manila, Philippines, with Understanding Switching
a bachelor’s degree in electronics engineering. Aldrick currently holds a U.S. Regulator Output Artifacts
patent on switching regulator ripple filtering. Expedites Power Supply Design
Volume 48, Number 3